Sent My V10 To LG For Repair; Receive Phone With Ridiculous Amount Of Scratches - LG V10 General

To make a long story short my LCD panel started to bleed at the top of my screen. There was no apparent cracks and no signs of impact but my mobile carrier refused to call it a defect and quoted me a repair price of $175, even with the insurance I pay $10 a month for. I filled out a LG repair form, they send me my prepaid label, get an email saying it is a defect and they will repair for free and I'll have my phone back in 4 days. Excellent, until I get my phone in the mail. I will post pictures once my girlfriend gets home and I can use her camera, but holy hell my screen looks like Freddy Krueger tried using it. My screen was flawless when I sent it in, I bought a tempered glass protector minutes after getting the phone so there was no damage prior to sending it in. I could live with a small scuff or something but this is absolutely ridiculous, I'm talking deep, DEEP scratches. I contacted LG and spoke with 2 different representatives just to see if I could get a different answer out of somebody else, but both have told me the only option is to send it back in for repair and they will offer no other compensation. I'm also having doubts that this is my original phone. My girlfriend and I both have a V10 so I put a small white dot behind the battery and that's no longer there, and my left rail had a small scratch on it at the very top and that is no longer there.
Has anybody else had a similar situation with LG? I've already went a week without my phone and I'm not really up for going another week without it, especially not knowing what condition I'll get it back in. I need to access my emails for work. My mobile carrier won't issue me a loaner phone since I'm not getting the repair done through them.

ThisIsCheez said:
To make a long story short my LCD panel started to bleed at the top of my screen. There was no apparent cracks and no signs of impact but my mobile carrier refused to call it a defect and quoted me a repair price of $175, even with the insurance I pay $10 a month for. I filled out a LG repair form, they send me my prepaid label, get an email saying it is a defect and they will repair for free and I'll have my phone back in 4 days. Excellent, until I get my phone in the mail. I will post pictures once my girlfriend gets home and I can use her camera, but holy hell my screen looks like Freddy Krueger tried using it. My screen was flawless when I sent it in, I bought a tempered glass protector minutes after getting the phone so there was no damage prior to sending it in. I could live with a small scuff or something but this is absolutely ridiculous, I'm talking deep, DEEP scratches. I contacted LG and spoke with 2 different representatives just to see if I could get a different answer out of somebody else, but both have told me the only option is to send it back in for repair and they will offer no other compensation. I'm also having doubts that this is my original phone. My girlfriend and I both have a V10 so I put a small white dot behind the battery and that's no longer there, and my left rail had a small scratch on it at the very top and that is no longer there.
Has anybody else had a similar situation with LG? I've already went a week without my phone and I'm not really up for going another week without it, especially not knowing what condition I'll get it back in. I need to access my emails for work. My mobile carrier won't issue me a loaner phone since I'm not getting the repair done through them.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
well...my V10 have the bleeding issue in the second screen too, its legible when in a dark envroiment and i dont like that but...guess what?! i dont care about that bleeding issue so much because i know 60% (or more) V10's have the same issue...is LG issue but i dont bother about this!
is a waste of time send it to repair and then they dont take care of your phone and get scratches everywhere and you get a worst phone than you have after sending to repair! belive me, screen issues like this dont deserve that treatment.
I hope you go to repair shop (if you can) and write a coment on the book of the store explaining the things happened to you...it dont do much but LG will know they have to treat better theyr customers phones!

sun_is_shinning said:
well...my V10 have the bleeding issue in the second screen too, its legible when in a dark envroiment and i dont like that but...guess what?! i dont care about that bleeding issue so much because i know 60% (or more) V10's have the same issue...is LG issue but i dont bother about this!
is a waste of time send it to repair and then they dont take care of your phone and get scratches everywhere and you get a worst phone than you have after sending to repair! belive me, screen issues like this dont deserve that treatment.
I hope you go to repair shop (if you can) and write a coment on the book of the store explaining the things happened to you...it dont do much but LG will know they have to treat better theyr customers phones!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry to confuse, but I'm not referring to the 2nd screen bleeding light, my LCD below the front facing cameras actually starting bleeding liquid.

If you still have original box you can compare imei and serial numbers, this will tell you if it's your phone or not
Sent from my LG-H901 using XDA-Developers mobile app

This does suck indeed. I suggest you try getting hold of one of the higher ups of your carrier there, else if nothing works perhaps you can send a complaint e-mail to LG Korea to hopefully get your matter sorted out.

Related

Broken LCD Screen - some info wanted please :(

Hello All,
today I used my phone for a regular phone call, went back to my desk, put it down, a couple of hours later, I hear the sms ringtone, pressed the 'wake up' button on the top, (the screen had gone blank as usual), and.... disaster, I see a long crack on the screen...
I suppose the phone is still under warranty (1.5years), but I do not know if it covers the LCD screen... It's quite insane, it was not in my pocket, it was not dropped, no liquids were spilled on it... Literally, used for a phonecall, put it down and then next time I use it has a crack is on it!!!
Did anyone have any similar experience in the past? Do you think it is covered by warranty? If not, does anyone have any idea what it costs to get it fixed? (I had bought it from devicewire, uk)....
Thanks,
MM
What's the options?!
You need the screen replaced as soon, as (with my experience) the crack will outgrow the whole screen and soon you won't be able to use it.
Take it to the dealer as soon and as small the crack is, and suggest it was a manufacturer stress in the factory assembly that has started a hidden crack that grew up.
If you have the UK model (same as me) (Orbit 2 Xda branded) they are very very hard to find parts as they are mostly made for the HTC branded phone (silver original one).
So if you find a replacement online pls let me know, i need the touchscreen, not lcd but same diff!
P.S your warranty should only be for 12mths, well atleast mine are, and everything is covered usually, so just ask your outlt... if not, find a part online and repair, i would be happy 2 help with guiding through repairs if needed.
good luck, keep us informed.
I had the same problem. The phone was in my jacket´s pocket and when I was putting the jacket on the back of a chair it slightly hit the wall, for which I didn´t even worry. When later I picked up the phone the lcd was cracked. I have had the phone falling to floor without any problem a long time ago, and ironically it broke with a little hit.
I am sending it to fix, but I know I cant avoid paying for the repair.
Hello All,
thanks for your replies. My HTC is now at the HTC Service... I was told that the warranty does not cover the screen, so we will see how much it costs. The person at the HTC support line told me that the screen would cost around £60 and if it was the case that the mainboard has a problem, it will be more. Additionally, running the diagnostics on the first place will cost £15. It kind of makes me wonder what on earth that warranty covers for. I was under the impression that the phone is still under warranty and their attitude in claiming that this is not covered under by warranty shows the same thing.
Their quality of the service is probably average. I only received an email with the ticket number from them when I phoned them for a second time telling them that tehy had not send me any emails yet. I know they received the phone on the 7th of July, since I received an automated email from them, however, I have not heard anything from them since then, and I will need to phone them again. I have also input the ticket number and my email in their web page, but have not received any updates...
I decided to fix the phone, unless they come up with a stupid cost; the phone is lees than 2 years old and has served me well: I have used messenger while in airports and watched many movies while travelling. On a side note, I kind of have mixed feelings about HTC now. On one hand, HTC is very innovative, on the other hand the fact they release new phones so quickly kind of upsets me. I also think that nokia for example puts a lot more research and QC into their phones. The final thing I am not very fond of on this phone is that it's finger-unfriendly (no, I am not buying an iPhone...).
Even so, I have decided to fix it (subject to the repair quote), and keep it a couple of years more...
I will keep you posted about the final price....
I just replaced my Screen myself tonight, I also fixed a few things inside the device which were getting loose, just as the keys. I put some foam in the case where the keys are and now they are nice and tight.
The device is built better now than it was when i purchased it, plus it has a brand new screen now too. Cost: $1.00 Shipping to AU + $8.87 (USD$)
Tools are mine, they costed me $7 and got some free with screen.
HTC Repair... hell nah!
Hello All,
I know this is an old thread, but believe it or not, I only managed to get my phone back yesterday...
The phone as predicted costed around £60 pounds to fix (including postage). UPS then tried to deliver it to the address I gave to them. Unfortunately, it happened I was not there, so they left me a card. Using the number on the card, I arranged the delivery address to be changed. This happened on the 22n of July.
Unfortunately, the phone went missing and then my long adventure started... UPS asked me to phone HTC, HTC's reply was (I quote): 'Why did you change the delivery address, you would not have a problem now'. Their attitude was mostly unhelpful and they insisted that now (I quote again): 'It's now between you and UPS, why should we contact UPS?'
My understanding is that UPS in these cases asks the SENDER to raise a trace request and that they charge the SENDER for this, which is why a lot of merchandisers are unwilling to put a 'trace request' . Finally, after lots of phonecalls, UPS raised a trace request by itself.
It would take lots of pages to describe here the conversations I had with both UPS and HTC, each one blaming each other, until around mid-September where UPS said that they sent a claim to the SENDER, and it is now upon the sender to act.... Needless to say HTC continued arguing they have not received anything...
Finally, someone found that claim and sent me a replacement phone. The replacement seems new, though I guess, it might as well have been a refurbished phone. I also got a stylus with it and a battery cover, but no battery of course, (I had removed all these prior to sending the phone back).
Now here comes the amazing bit:
This time they used CityLink to send the package and HTC had forgotten to put my name on the package; they only put the delivery address. Amazingly, the package ended up in the company I work for, but in a different building near the one that was supposed to be delivered. Someone from my company called me and asked me if I am expecting a package from HTC, and that I can pop down the street to collect it from them....
Anyway, I have my phone now, it's ok... But I would avoid any interaction with HTC UK in the future.... I think I will also avoid HTC altogether in the guture, but that's a different issue altogether
Thanks everyone who posted in this thread (knowing that this would cost a few bucks to fix does not make it any better, but anyway )
just for next time
in my clumsiness i closed a car door on my cell which broke the LCD
after a short search over the net i found the tools needed (small screwdrivers and some plastic screwdrivers) and the LCD.
found the LCD at Ebay and the screwdrivers at dealExtreame
in really cheap all together cost me something like 140 US dollars
the change was quite simple as there are many youtube videos on how to open our cell.
so after like ah hour all was done and good to go.
hope it will help someone
if anyone need the ebay dealer just ping me (not related someone from china )

Dust under screen request..

Can someone post a picture of "dust under the screen" I'm a bit confuses on what people mean when they post this problem.
Sent from my MT4G running Gingerbread
Well far as I know as the dust is behind/underneath the touch screen glass. Which does happen trust me sometimes it gets in as in my HD2 I saw dust in rare camera and behind the screen which was not present when I got it but as time went on. DWAI it as its not that serious unless you have OCD or something as it bothers you lol then its another issue.
I had it on my first device, very obnoxious. I take good care of my phone and am constantly wiping the smudges off the screen. It looks like dust ON the screen that just never budges no matter how hard you rub it with a microfiber.
If you take excellent care of your phones it will piss you off to no end. If you always have smudges on your screen and you don't notice then don't worry about it.
I have dust right above my front facing camera
Sent from my HTC Glacier using XDA App
SOB just found dust on the display on the top right side, IDK WTF that got in as its only 2days old and I didn't even use much.
HyperNode said:
SOB just found dust on the display on the top right side, IDK WTF that got in as its only 2days old and I didn't even use much.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That sucks, my first one had that. Not cool.
Time to return it.
Phateless said:
That sucks, my first one had that. Not cool.
Time to return it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hmm, you know - I think I just found a dust speck under my screen too...on the lower center of the screen, there's this little dot that I can't clean away with a cloth. Pretty small, and wouldn't have found it unless I scrutinized the screen. I think I'm going to mention this as well as my inferior screen when I go in for an exchange so it'll hopefully go smoother.
sunsean said:
Hmm, you know - I think I just found a dust speck under my screen too...on the lower center of the screen, there's this little dot that I can't clean away with a cloth. Pretty small, and wouldn't have found it unless I scrutinized the screen. I think I'm going to mention this as well as my inferior screen when I go in for an exchange so it'll hopefully go smoother.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Couldn't hurt. I even flat out told the rep, "I know I'm being a little nitpicky, but this is your FLAGSHIP DEVICE and I've been with you guys for 6 years. I want it to be right."
They really can't argue with that.
sunsean said:
Hmm, you know - I think I just found a dust speck under my screen too...on the lower center of the screen, there's this little dot that I can't clean away with a cloth. Pretty small, and wouldn't have found it unless I scrutinized the screen. I think I'm going to mention this as well as my inferior screen when I go in for an exchange so it'll hopefully go smoother.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I just got my replacement because of 10 dust specs under my touchscreen. I referred them to the t-mobile forum and they believed me. My new one has the good screen and the built quality seems to be better. Good Luck with exchanging your phone.
10 dust :O well I can't say about you but this device is 2days old so IDK wtf it got in as I barely even used it.
HyperNode said:
10 dust :O well I can't say about you but this device is 2days old so IDK wtf it got in as I barely even used it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I had my MT4G for nearly 2 months....it was the second one. I am almost sure it will happen again. As long as I don't see it it's fine;-)
As I was reading this thread I removed my screen protector and sure enough I have little black spots under my screen and this completely pisses me off. I baby my phones to the point that my girlfriend and I get into heated arguments and to have dust under the screen is unexceptionable. I'd call T-Mobile right this f###ing second if I didn't want to be on hold for over an hour which is something that is down right ridiculous!!!!!!!!!!!
I just called in for an exchange. They asked me to pay $9.99 for shipping, and I said that I felt it was unfair for them to charge me if it was not my fault that the phone came like this.
When I asked them to just cancel everything, since I am still under the 30 day remorse period (in CA, that is), they transferred me to the supervisor of the customer loyalty department. I explained the story to her and she waived the shipping fee for standard 3 day shipping.
I then asked her if this will be a new phone, or if it will be refurbished. She told me that it will either "be new, or be like-new," but the package will only have the phone and nothing else; no battery, instruction manual, accessories, etc. Do all T-MO exchanges come like that, or do they just send out refurbished ones?
Sfkn2 said:
I just called in for an exchange. They asked me to pay $9.99 for shipping, and I said that I felt it was unfair for them to charge me if it was not my fault that the phone came like this.
When I asked them to just cancel everything, since I am still under the 30 day remorse period (in CA, that is), they transferred me to the supervisor of the customer loyalty department. I explained the story to her and she waived the shipping fee for standard 3 day shipping.
I then asked her if this will be a new phone, or if it will be refurbished. She told me that it will either "be new, or be like-new," but the package will only have the phone and nothing else; no battery, instruction manual, accessories, etc. Do all T-MO exchanges come like that, or do they just send out refurbished ones?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
In all the time I've been with them (since Voicestream was still around), I've only ever received one phone new in the box. It was the Behold 2 (what a joke of a phone...) and only because it was only 1 week after the release of the phone and as such they didn't have any refurbished phones available yet.
Otherwise, every single phone I've received as a replacement has been in the standard return box with only the phone in a plastic bag with the foam cushioning in the box.
porter66062 said:
In all the time I've been with them (since Voicestream was still around), I've only ever received one phone new in the box. It was the Behold 2 (what a joke of a phone...) and only because it was only 1 week after the release of the phone and as such they didn't have any refurbished phones available yet.
Otherwise, every single phone I've received as a replacement has been in the standard return box with only the phone in a plastic bag with the foam cushioning in the box.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did you receive new or refurbished phones? Is there any way to tell the difference?
Honestly, I couldn't tell between refurbished and new. They don't really tell you, and as far as I know, there isn't a way to tell.
I'm sure that I got refurbished on a few of them, but in a lot of cases the refurbished phones are in better shape and go through more testing than the new phones.
Thank you for the information, Porter.

HELP ME!!!!! Petition against Motorola!!!!! Fix My Phone Motorola!

I have a Motorola Triumph that i bought new from pre-order. Of course we all know most of the problems it had! Well i have one of those and it had the charging problem were you had to wiggle the cable around till it charged or have to not touch it or pick it up while charging, or if you did it would stop charging.
I sent the phone in for repair under my 2 year Motorola warranty.
When they received the phone (9/28/2011 @ 10:05AM) i called and asked how the repair was doing later that day and whoever i talked to said that everything was ok and it will be covered under warranty and that is already being repaired and it would take 5-7 business days to repair. so i waited patiently for it to return which is today (10/5/2011) i opened it up and saw 2 cards one saying pretty much that they are not going to repair it under warranty due to severe physical abuse and misuse, and the other card saying they will give me a 15% discount towards a new Motorola product at there store, but guess what they don't sell the Triumph in the Motorola store on-line, how convenient for them! and to top all of this off they took my PCB out of my old phone and the sticker with all the MEID's and put it in another phone and sent it to me! The one i sent to them had 2 scratches on the screen with no screen protector and no damage to the back of the phone. The one i get back has a huge scratch on the back, the paint around the camera is almost gone and scratched, the MEID sticker is damaged from trying to remove it when they switched it, and the screen has a screen protector with no scratches.
All im wanting from you guys and girls is to help me out and sign a petition (say agree or whatever stating that Motorola should A: Repair my phone for free or B: Replace my phone for free) to get my phone fixed/replaced.
I know there are alot of you out there with the same problem or different ones that Motorola needs to fix, so this is your time to help!!
So after all of that said, please agree or whatever stating that you feel like Motorola should repair or replace my phone for free!!! and I'm not trying to get one over on them you can clearly see by your own personal experiences with the phone that it is not from personal misuse or damage! I thank everyone here on XDA-Developers i've been here for a while and i'm never leaving!!
I didn't know Motorola took back phones like that... you probably should have contacted Virgin Mobile instead.
That much said... get Moto to send your phone back. Your original phone. This has a great amount of wtfness around it, but hopefully if it's the wrong MEID you'll be able to prove it by pointing to the MEID linked to your Virgin Mobile account.
primetechv2 said:
I didn't know Motorola took back phones like that... you probably should have contacted Virgin Mobile instead.
That much said... get Moto to send your phone back. Your original phone. This has a great amount of wtfness around it, but hopefully if it's the wrong MEID you'll be able to prove it by pointing to the MEID linked to your Virgin Mobile account.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thank you for your response but they already sent it back if you read all the way i recieved a phone that was not mine they took the sticker with the MEID off of mine and put it on another and i am about to update this post so please read what else happend!
***Update***
After writing this i powered on my phone and it skipped the Moto symbol and went directly to the Moto symbol were it has the little swirl around it then goes to the virgin mobile screen and then on to lock screen. but that's not the kicker my screen has black lines through it as if it had water damage and the digitizer doesn't work (meaning when i goto unlock the phone or press the home or back button it doesn't read my touch!! so i called back and talked to a "manager" and they pretty much told me they never opened it and sent it back which is a lie because when i called the day the received it the person said they already started repairing the phone and it was covered under warranty...and she said that i sent the phone in like that! then tried to blame FedEx for swapping it out! You can see where they took my old sticker that has the MEID and put it on the phone i received! please sign this to help me out so this doesn't happen to anyone else!!!!!!!!
That sucks. I don't think it was Fedex at all. I'd like to help you but can you provide the link for the petition or are you still making one? I'll sign it.. I would have been pissed of...
nickmcnamara said:
***Update***
You can see where they took my old sticker that has the MEID and put it on the phone i received! please sign this to help me out so this doesn't happen to anyone else!!!!!!!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I meant, can you read the device's MEID via the Settings menu? I'm rather ADHD about long paragraphs on the computer but I think I caught that part
If the MEID under the battery doesn't match the MEID stored in the phone, you have a clear case of a mislabeled device. If not, well... bullcrap.
In the mean time, please do post pictures with as much detail as possible, taking care to blur out any personal information.
I had a charging issue too and i had virgin mobile send me a replacement under their one year warranty. they lagged but they did finally send me one. i also them check it to assure me they werent sending me another dud. hope this helps.
dont i have to pay that stupid $5 a month to have the 1 year warranty???
primetechv2 said:
I meant, can you read the device's MEID via the Settings menu? I'm rather ADHD about long paragraphs on the computer but I think I caught that part
If the MEID under the battery doesn't match the MEID stored in the phone, you have a clear case of a mislabeled device. If not, well... bullcrap.
In the mean time, please do post pictures with as much detail as possible, taking care to blur out any personal information.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i would but the digitizer they put on doesn't work so i can't check....i can't unlock the phone!!!!
nickmcnamara said:
dont i have to pay that stupid $5 a month to have the 1 year warranty???
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, you automatically get a 1 year through VMU
really? ok thanks im going to try that!!!!
Going via VM would have been the first thing I would have recommended.
WTF is a digitizer?
It's what goes over the actual LCD screen and picks up your finger presses. It's what allows phones to still pick up your finger presses even when the glass or plastic is cracked.
hmm actually I'm one of the first people who broke the Triumph (You can even see my post) and from first hand experience, I can say that the digitizer will not work at all when the glass screen breaks...
This pisses me off.
I mean hell, if I sent my phone in for repairs, got a whole different heavily f**ked up phone back, and they tried saying that was the phone I sent them, I'd contact a lawyer and ask "What settlement could I get and is it worth the lawyer fees?".
The only proof you need is that the MSID on the VirginMobile account is different then the one on the phone.
i wish they took the MEID sticker off the old phone and stuck it to the piece of crap they sent me as well as changing out the PCB to make everything match!! but no matter VM is sending me a new phone and i will receive it Monday!!! thank you crxmax and idbl_fanatic for sharing this info!!!!
nickmcnamara said:
i wish they took the MEID sticker off the old phone and stuck it to the piece of crap they sent me as well as changing out the PCB to make everything match!! but no matter VM is sending me a new phone and i will receive it Monday!!! thank you crxmax and idbl_fanatic for sharing this info!!!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Glad to hear it!!!

Cracked screen

Due to unresolved billing issues with T-Mobile and now to add injury to insult, the dang phone fell 2.5ft while i was getting out of the car...and guess what?
Gorilla glass is not all it's cracked up to be (pun intended)
Im thinking this is a final sign that i need to bail ship and move onwards.
What is an otherwise perfectly working stock G2X running GB worth?
Do you have the insurance on the phone? It covers drops.
Sent from my LG-P999 using XDA App
Nope, no ins. Never broke a phone before...normally pretty careful dude so didnt think it was necessary. I was really really surprised, especially how bad it shattered from a short fall.
Isnt there like a $50 deductable for that anyway? the Screen's + Digi go for less on ebay.
How about this one?
It doesn not say it has the digitizer is what's stopping me from pulling the trigger right now.
any opinion on this??
http://www.ebay.com/itm/LCD-Display...042?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item27c05e642a
I was under the impression that the two terms; touchscreen and digitizer could be used interchangably. I may be wrong though. That item would work in my mind but I would see what other members had to say.
Well nevermind the idea of a sale or value for the phone. It is worth nothing according to LG.
I sent the phone in for repair and it was returned today. I asked why nobody contacted me and was told becuase they had received the phone physically damaged and it was unrepairable. I asked for a photo but the one they sent was pretty small and shows really nothing plus i am not sure what im supposed to be looking for anyway.
So are they sending you a new one or just keeping yours?
Sent from my HTC Glacier using xda premium
I posted here today prior to receiving my phone back from repair. I was posting trying to figure out what my options were going to be in advance of things.
I was not expecting to receive the phone back as i had not been notified, no calls or anything from stellar/LG...
Surprised to see teh fedex man with a package for me...it was my phone...broke.
So no, They are not sending me a new one. I am bummed. I have a nice fancy broken g2x that stellar/LG deems unrepairable!
Hendge said:
I posted here today prior to receiving my phone back from repair. I was posting trying to figure out what my options were going to be in advance of things.
I was not expecting to receive the phone back as i had not been notified, no calls or anything from stellar/LG...
Surprised to see teh fedex man with a package for me...it was my phone...broke.
So no, They are not sending me a new one. I am bummed. I have a nice fancy broken g2x that stellar/LG deems unrepairable!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Your G2X is not unrepairable.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/archive/index.php/t-1207651.html
There is plenty of information on the internet about repairing it including videos on You Tube http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wDUPPzbQKTI
Here's where to purchase parts http://www.repairsuniverse.com/lg-g2x-p999-screen-replacement-repair-parts.html
http://www.cell-phoneparts.com/lg-tmobile-g2x-touch-screen-digitizer-replacement-p999-p-623.html
http://www.globaldirectparts.com/SearchResults.asp?Search=p999
There are other sources of parts too.
People make this mistake all the time. Hardness and strength are not interchangable. Gorilla glass is hard, great for scratch resistance but terrible for shatter resistance.
Basic metallurgy. Applies to metals too.
Hendge said:
Gorilla glass is not all it's cracked up to be (pun intended)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sent from my LG-P999 using XDA App
Corememory - I just received the phone back from it's authorized repair center and they say the phone was sent back to me "as is" because they do not replace phones, only repair...and mine in non repairable.
I will post the pic they sent if you still dispute it's fixable and undertstand circuit board repair or whatever the issue is.
TerryM - yes.My mistake as well as many others too. Also surprsing is in the reference thread posted it was also noted by another poster the extremely short fall it took to break.
Possibly the 'Gorilla Glass' is a worse alternative after all...more susceptble to shattering than Non gorilla or standard display glass.
Hendge said:
Well nevermind the idea of a sale or value for the phone. It is worth nothing according to LG.
I sent the phone in for repair and it was returned today. I asked why nobody contacted me and was told becuase they had received the phone physically damaged and it was unrepairable. I asked for a photo but the one they sent was pretty small and shows really nothing plus i am not sure what im supposed to be looking for anyway.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
LG (and pretty much every other manufacturer) covers repairs for manufacturing defects. They have no responsibility to repair a phone that was broken otherwise, and there is absolutely no reason whatsoever to expect LG to do so.
Being as you didn't purchase insurance, that means you get to find someone to fix it for you, or fix it yourself. It isn't that difficult or expensive.
TL;DR: You broke your phone. You don't have insurance. Fix it.
Ummm...thanks i know it's tough luck and am aware of SOP's for getting my situation str8. What i am NOT getting is prior to sending it in i read on here as well as other sites the costs and procedures involved. So why then are two members directing me to repair on my own or find someone, if the actual USA LG auth repair facility is saying it's non??
I do not want to spend anymore time or money. I would just assume move on to the next phone and carrier. Screw t-mobile. The phone was great aside from the fragility.
Hendge said:
Ummm...thanks i know it's tough luck and am aware of SOP's for getting my situation str8. What i am NOT getting is prior to sending it in i read on here as well as other sites the costs and procedures involved. So why then are two members directing me to repair on my own or find someone, if the actual USA LG auth repair facility is saying it's non??
I do not want to spend anymore time or money. I would just assume move on to the next phone and carrier. Screw t-mobile. The phone was great aside from the fragility.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If all that was broken is the screen, it isn't by any means unrepairable (no matter what LG's authorized repair facility says), but you would need to check it out for yourself in order to find out the extent of the damage, unless you already know. Without pictures or details of what is damaged, we can't exactly tell you if it is fixable or not. The way it was worded sounded a bit like you attempted to get a warranty repair rather than something you would have had to pay for.
The thing is throughout the thread your attitude towards T-Mobile and LG already shows more than a little animosity and it colors how we read your posts as a whole, or at least how I read it. I don't know what your issue with them is exactly, and I don't want to. You flat out say you don't want to spend any more time or money on this problem, so...Hope you know that moving to another phone and carrier is going to cost you (either you pay for the phone up front or you pay for it in your contract, dearly, and in the US there aren't any better deals than Sprint or T-Mobile). Either way, without more details there isn't much we can tell you.
Also, this phone isn't any more 'fragile' than any other thin slab of glass attached to metal and plastic that is less than an inch thick.
Hendge said:
Screw t-mobile. The phone was great aside from the fragility.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ummmm. This phone is no more fragile than the next. I actually stood on my phone and ground it into limestone rocks. I ended up with just a couple of scratches. It isn't unbreakable, but there is no issue that makes it more fragile than any other phone. It isn't T-Mobile's fault that 1) you didn't buy insurance and 2) glass can be broken.
Sent from my LG-P999 using Tapatalk
JaiaV said:
If all that was broken is the screen, it isn't by any means unrepairable (no matter what LG's authorized repair facility says), but you would need to check it out for yourself in order to find out the extent of the damage, unless you already know. Without pictures or details of what is damaged, we can't exactly tell you if it is fixable or not. The way it was worded sounded a bit like you attempted to get a warranty repair rather than something you would have had to pay for.
The thing is throughout the thread your attitude towards T-Mobile and LG already shows more than a little animosity and it colors how we read your posts as a whole, or at least how I read it. I don't know what your issue with them is exactly, and I don't want to. You flat out say you don't want to spend any more time or money on this problem, so...Hope you know that moving to another phone and carrier is going to cost you (either you pay for the phone up front or you pay for it in your contract, dearly, and in the US there aren't any better deals than Sprint or T-Mobile). Either way, without more details there isn't much we can tell you.
Also, this phone isn't any more 'fragile' than any other thin slab of glass attached to metal and plastic that is less than an inch thick.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not sure what exactly you are reading into...ive stated that the phone was dropped and was surprised the repair facility intimated their inability to repair.
Maybe i exagerrated when i mentioned i am normally careful. I am, but sheet happens and i have dropped other phones w/out damage. My first smartphone was the mytouch3g, it was dropped a few times from greater distances with only a few nicks and a crack in the casing. All i have is my own experience to draw from, and in this case the other thread posted where another member also complained about a short fall and the resulting damage. In my experience the phone is fragile due to completely shattering from a small fall!
I understand your lack of interest in my issues with T-Mobile. So all i can do is say: BEWARE
What i would REALLY like is info/help on determining if this phone is fixable. I assume i can go to simple mobile and buy a SIM or would anyone possibly l know if i quit on a contract with T-Mobile and could care less what they do to my credit, can i get on one of their pre-paid plans via wal-mart or something?
So, should i post the photo they sent me, take the phone apart and look for something?? how to save myself from ordering a display/digitizer and coming to the same conclusion as stellar?
lotherius said:
Ummmm. This phone is no more fragile than the next. I actually stood on my phone and ground it into limestone rocks. I ended up with just a couple of scratches. It isn't unbreakable, but there is no issue that makes it more fragile than any other phone. It isn't T-Mobile's fault that 1) you didn't buy insurance and 2) glass can be broken.
Sent from my LG-P999 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
In this case, and my experience dropping other phones, you are proven incorrect - hopefully you'll never have to deal firsthand.
I know and said nothing about this being T-Mobiles fault. I have posted on here in the past some detail so no need to go into it. All i can say is WATCHOUT FOR THEM. Be very careful and cautious if ever doing any business with them. TRUST ME please and save yourself the frustration.
as for insurance, just a risk i take. I would prefer no auto/home any kind whatsoever. That's just me, foolish or not i'd rather not pay monthly. Most insurances will look for any way not to pay. I only purchase required insurance.
Hendge said:
In this case, and my experience dropping other phones, you are proven incorrect - hopefully you'll never have to deal firsthand.
I know and said nothing about this being T-Mobiles fault. I have posted on here in the past some detail so no need to go into it. All i can say is WATCHOUT FOR THEM. Be very careful and cautious if ever doing any business with them. TRUST ME please and save yourself the frustration.
as for insurance, just a risk i take. I would prefer no auto/home any kind whatsoever. That's just me, foolish or not i'd rather not pay monthly. Most insurances will look for any way not to pay. I only purchase required insurance.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
After reading your other threads and going over the things you ask about (like getting a Simple Mobile SIM and putting it in the phone to 'fix' the screen, wanting to know how to get out of your contract, complaining that LG and T-Mobile won't just magically replace your $15-20 battery at your whim) it sounds like all you want is out of a contract you signed with no repercussions, or ETF. You give absolutely no details, pictures, proof of correspondence with LG's repair facility, or any necessary information required to help you figure out just how damaged your phone is. You state you have read about and even checked prices on how to fix your screen.
I want to help you, but you don't seem to want help. All you seem to want is a way out of your contract and an easy way to chum up with another carrier without spending any money. Sorry, but you won't find help for that here.
JaiaV said:
After reading your other threads and going over the things you ask about (like getting a Simple Mobile SIM and putting it in the phone to 'fix' the screen, wanting to know how to get out of your contract, complaining that LG and T-Mobile won't just magically replace your $15-20 battery at your whim) it sounds like all you want is out of a contract you signed with no repercussions, or ETF. You give absolutely no details, pictures, proof of correspondence with LG's repair facility, or any necessary information required to help you figure out just how damaged your phone is. You state you have read about and even checked prices on how to fix your screen.
I want to help you, but you don't seem to want help. All you seem to want is a way out of your contract and an easy way to chum up with another carrier without spending any money. Sorry, but you won't find help for that here.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hey, you seem to want to draw your own conclusions, nitpick and challenge whne i have no interest in any of that. Tell ya what, i was under impression you were trying to help. If so, check the pic stellar sent me today that i have attached and comment if you have any expertise on the subject.
If not, have a great night and myob next time
Hendge said:
In this case, and my experience dropping other phones, you are proven incorrect - hopefully you'll never have to deal firsthand.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Actually. If you read what I wrote, I mentioned that I dropped my phone onto onto limestone gravel and then proceeded to STAND ON IT. And I weigh 260 lb. Screen scratched but unbroken. Does that prove it is unbreakable? Nope. In any single incident all kinds of things are possible. I used to work for tmo, I know this firsthand. You'd be surprised, even with those old "indestructible" Nokias, how many people dropped their phones a "couple of feet" onto the carpet and ended up with something broke. It happens. Shut up and deal with it like a man.
Sent from my LG-P999 using Tapatalk

[Q] Verizon Warranty Exchange

I have a Warranty dilemma that I thought maybe someone else has experienced.
I had a legitimate warranty issue, called Verizon and they sent out the new phone next day overnight shipping. Currently no exterior damage to the old phone. Literally the day that the new phone is supposed to be coming I dropped my old phone and even though I have never cracked a screen before fate would have it that I crack one the day I am supposed to be exchanging it.
First of all it is a very fine crack in one of the corners of the screen and you almost can’t even see it unless you really look closely or feel it with a fingernail. There is also a small scratch on the corner of the aluminum case now.
Option 1: Should I just send the old phone back anyways and hope that they don’t notice the crack in the screen and scratch on the case? I’ve read on this forum that all they do is see if the phone turns on and then they move on to the next one? Could result in paying the $229 fine for the phone being damaged.
Option 2: Call Verizon tell them what happened send back the phone they sent me and instead do a cracked phone replacement through HTC's website which supposedly does a onetime replacement phone for things like breaking your screen.
Option 3: Keep the new phone without sending back the old phone and hope they dont notice. I actually did this in the past once and they never charged or contacted me about it. Ive heard that they dont really track to see if you turn in the old phone but that was some time ago and I dont know if that is still the case.
Sure would be nice if they had a way to still do a warranty exchange for the legitimate issue while also paying them a lesser amount to pay for the cracked screen but I guess they dont have that option.
Any advice would be much appreciated.
Wulf01 said:
I have a Warranty dilemma that I thought maybe someone else has experienced.
I had a legitimate warranty issue, called Verizon and they sent out the new phone next day overnight shipping. Currently no exterior damage to the old phone. Literally the day that the new phone is supposed to be coming I dropped my old phone and even though I have never cracked a screen before fate would have it that I crack one the day I am supposed to be exchanging it.
First of all it is a very fine crack in one of the corners of the screen and you almost can’t even see it unless you really look closely or feel it with a fingernail. There is also a small scratch on the corner of the aluminum case now.
Option 1: Should I just send the old phone back anyways and hope that they don’t notice the crack in the screen and scratch on the case? I’ve read on this forum that all they do is see if the phone turns on and then they move on to the next one? Could result in paying the $229 fine for the phone being damaged.
Option 2: Call Verizon tell them what happened send back the phone they sent me and instead do a cracked phone replacement through HTC's website which supposedly does a onetime replacement phone for things like breaking your screen.
Option 3: Keep the new phone without sending back the old phone and hope they dont notice. I actually did this in the past once and they never charged or contacted me about it. Ive heard that they dont really track to see if you turn in the old phone but that was some time ago and I dont know if that is still the case.
Sure would be nice if they had a way to still do a warranty exchange for the legitimate issue while also paying them a lesser amount to pay for the cracked screen but I guess they dont have that option.
Any advice would be much appreciated.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've done plenty of warranty exchanges with Verizon. Best bet is to call Verizon and tell them what happened. Send the old one back. This way you don't feel guilty or have to lie about certain things. VZW won't care. Or another option is to just send it back without calling them. I'd advise you to call them though so they can note it in your account. They don't play as fast and loose as they used to. They sent me 2 HTC Thunderbolts and when I called they said I could sell one if I wanted to. It costs them a good amount of money per warranty exchange. That's why there is a $100 deductible now with the $10/mo warranty.
Sent from my Big Red M8

Categories

Resources