Close Thread: Alternate Replacements: Received Note 2 - Verizon Samsung Galaxy S III

Getting out of hand. Please close this thread

So much info
Sent from my SCH-I535 using xda premium

ihavenewnike said:
I was told no more alternate replacementents will be given due to people "abusing" the system.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
FYI: I can confirm this too. Probably due to the crapple i****, but its worth noting they are also going to try and deny a swap to a different Android device as well.
A month ago I was told I would be able to swap out my device for any other I wanted; if the new device is more expensive I would pay more, if it was less I would get money back. Last week however I called Verizon just to check on things and they changed their story. I figure I am in for an argument when I try and do the swap out. The grounds for the swap are poor reception which has been confined as a "bug" by Samsung. They say they are working on a fix, but the G Nexus had **** reception which still has not been fixed eight months later, and the GS3 uses the cell same receiver, at least thats what I am told. A Verizon field rep came to the house and reported back service in this area was fine but this device (he had a test one) was a total POS when it came to reception. I have been with verizon for 10+ years and never had so many dropped calls and dead zones. My Data speeds are bi-polar, going from ~39 MBPS next to a VZW tower, down to a few KBPS when I go about 1000 ft away from the tower. Verizon tech support said they can see the increase of dropped calls and poor data speeds on my account, which is why they offered the swap. I am waiting for the Droid Inc X because nothing else out now has 2bg ram.
When you add poor reception to the long list of other issues, I can see why people are jumping off this sinking ship.
I used to keep my Droid X & X2 in a car dock mounted on the windshield and audio out through the earphone jack to the car speakers. No ext mic or BT headset was needed for people to hear me and no once did anyone ever complain they could hear themselves through the phone echoing. I can no longer do this now that I have the GS3.
The audio processor for the US versions is total ****. The international version has a different audio processing chip which is MUCH better and you can HEAR the difference not only with headphones, but with car speakers through headphone jack, and even the phones built in crap speaker. Volume levels suck, and while it is ok when just using headphones, if you use the device in a Car Dock plugged into your car speakers, you will find you have to turn up the volume on your car stereo much higher then other phones. Noise cancelation is horrid; people on the other end of my calls can hear themselves echo if I use the device in the car with audio through the speakers. The mic sensitivity is no where near good as Motorola phones. I can no longer use my phone for voice calls hands free when its mounted on the dash because the mic's do not pick up my voice more then 2 feet away from the device. When using video conferencing apps like Tango or GChat, I have to hold the phone close to my face or the other party can't hear what I am saying. While my other Android devices did not have forward facing cameras, I did test out these apps using just the rear camera and I did not have the same issue. Samsung phone hardware just blows. They are cheep, the whole device is cheep garbage quality with garbage internal components. They wanted an inexpensive phone and they got it by putting in garbage components to save money.
Its ironic that a company that makes such amazing TV's could totally screw up the screen on the GS3. The phones display PPI are awful compared to other premium devices and pentile is such garbage old technology. There alr also widespread manufacturing defects in the screen. I have checked out seven different GS3's, not just Verizon but on different carriers too. All of them have visible screen manufacturing defects where when the screen is set to medium or higher brightness, and you are looking at a black backdrop, you can see these black waterspots. Its the glue they used under the **** pentile display. Thats what happens when you rush out 10+ million devices using cheep labor. I love Samsung TV's but I will NEVER buy another Samsung smartphone.
Combine all of this with Verizon's encrypted bootloader, annoying Wi-Fi popup, S-Voice interface forced instead of Googles Voice Command interface, and Verizons spyware Backup Assistant / Mobile Hotspot emended into the system menu and you have a subpar POS device.
Yes, you can Root and Rom to fix the software issues, but the hardware ones will not be fixed by a 3rd party Rom or software update. Verizon knows this device is a POS and they know they have completely messed up the software side, in fact while they say the Wi-Fi popup is a "bug" we all know Verizon is a bunch of scumbag liars.
This is why people are returning the device; the abuse is by Verizon on its customers.
EDIT: I made it very clear with Verizon that I will NEVER use an Apple product due to the fact they are criminals who violate the US construction and civil rights. They said they are no longer swapping devices for any manufacture, not just Apple. This has nothing to do with the 15 day return policy, just the policy where Verizon will swap your phone if you have known issues they can't fix. It used to be the 3 strikes swap, where if you had to swap the same device three times you could pick a different one.

Thalinor said:
FYI: I can confirm this too. Probably due to the crapple i****, but its worth noting they are also going to try and deny a swap to a different Android device as well.
A month ago I was told I would be able to swap out my device for any other I wanted; if the new device is more expensive I would pay more, if it was less I would get money back. Last week however I called Verizon just to check on things and they changed their story. I figure I am in for an argument when I try and do the swap out. The grounds for the swap are poor reception which has been confined as a "bug" by Samsung. They say they are working on a fix, but the G Nexus had **** reception which still has not been fixed eight months later, and the GS3 uses the cell same receiver, at least thats what I am told. A Verizon field rep came to the house and reported back service in this area was fine but this device (he had a test one) was a total POS when it came to reception. I have been with verizon for 10+ years and never had so many dropped calls and dead zones. My Data speeds are bi-polar, going from ~39 MBPS next to a VZW tower, down to a few KBPS when I go about 1000 ft away from the tower. Verizon tech support said they can see the increase of dropped calls and poor data speeds on my account, which is why they offered the swap. I am waiting for the Droid Inc X because nothing else out now has 2bg ram.
When you add poor reception to the long list of other issues, I can see why people are jumping off this sinking ship.
I used to keep my Droid X & X2 in a car dock mounted on the windshield and audio out through the earphone jack to the car speakers. No ext mic or BT headset was needed for people to hear me and no once did anyone ever complain they could hear themselves through the phone echoing. I can no longer do this now that I have the GS3.
The audio processor for the US versions is total ****. The international version has a different audio processing chip which is MUCH better and you can HEAR the difference not only with headphones, but with car speakers through headphone jack, and even the phones built in crap speaker. Volume levels suck, and while it is ok when just using headphones, if you use the device in a Car Dock plugged into your car speakers, you will find you have to turn up the volume on your car stereo much higher then other phones. Noise cancelation is horrid; people on the other end of my calls can hear themselves echo if I use the device in the car with audio through the speakers. The mic sensitivity is no where near good as Motorola phones. I can no longer use my phone for voice calls hands free when its mounted on the dash because the mic's do not pick up my voice more then 2 feet away from the device. When using video conferencing apps like Tango or GChat, I have to hold the phone close to my face or the other party can't hear what I am saying. While my other Android devices did not have forward facing cameras, I did test out these apps using just the rear camera and I did not have the same issue. Samsung phone hardware just blows. They are cheep, the whole device is cheep garbage quality with garbage internal components. They wanted an inexpensive phone and they got it by putting in garbage components to save money.
Its ironic that a company that makes such amazing TV's could totally screw up the screen on the GS3. Its PPI is awful compared to other premium devices and pentile is such fking old technology. Then there is the manufacturing defects in the screen. I have checked out seven different GS3's, not just Verizon but on different carriers too. All of them have visible screen manufacturing defects where when the screen is set to medium or higher brightness, and you are looking at a black backdrop, you can see these black waterspots. Its the glue they used under the **** pentile display. Thats what happens when you rush out 10+ million devices using cheep labor. I love Samsung TV's but I will NEVER buy another Samsung smartphone.
Combine all of this with Verizon's encrypted bootloader, annoying Wi-Fi popup, S-Voice interface forced instead of Googles Voice Command interface, and spyware backup assistant / Mobile Motspot emended into the system menu and you have a subpar POS device.
Yes, you can Root and Rom to fix the software issues, but the hardware ones will not be fixed by a 3rd party Rom or software update. Verizon knows this device is a POS and they know they have completely messed up the software side, in fact while they say the Wi-Fi popup is a "bug" we all know Verizon is a bunch of scumbag liars.
This is why people are returning the device; the abuse is by Verizon on its customers.
EDIT: I made it very clear with Verizon that I will NEVER use an Apple product due to the fact they are criminals who violate the US construction and civil rights. They said they are no longer swapping devices for any manufacture, not just Apple. This has nothing to do with the 15 day return policy, just the policy where Verizon will swap your phone if you have known issues they can't fix. It used to be the 3 strikes swap, where if you had to swap the same device three times you could pick a different one.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
They swapped me last week, without the blink of an eye, tier two made me get one more cln before they swapped. It went crazy and they sent me a gs3
Sent from my SCH-I535 using xda app-developers app

Started with a galaxy nexus... the usb melted got it replaced... horrible quality control.. poor radio... sent me one more nexus and this razr ( at the same time)
Razr has dead pixels and the home button light is dead...
Other galaxy nexus wont turn on...
Verizon is sending me a white 16gb s3
If it has any problems i was promised and noted on my account no ETF for both of my lines
Been with verizon for 2 and a half years
You guys just need to learn how to talk to them
Sent from my DROID RAZR using xda app-developers app

@hchristy2013
It seems missed the point, and more then likely the point of the OP. I can't say for sure as there is not enough info in the post, but because this is in the GS3 section, I am assuming he is talking about the same thing I am talking about... GETTING RID OF THE GS3 and swapping it for another device.
You are GETTING a GS3 from Verizon, I am (and assume the OP) talking about getting RID of GS3's and getting a different phone model. Verizon has been giving G Nexus people free swap outs to GS3's for several months now, mainly over G Nexus poor reception issues. Thats the joke of it too; the GS3 has the SAME issue, but people are getting a faster device so they are happy with the swap and keep quiet. I came over from a Droid X and a X2 via Ins replacement [of the DX]; both had BS encrypted bootloaders which made me hate the devices and Motoroal itself, but at least the "phone" part of the "smartphone" actually worked correctly.
If I wanted a smartphone that could not properly make and receive calls I would have bought an iPhone.
EDIT: Because this forum is filled with people from all over the world, I would like to point out once again the GS3 de international' is not even close to the GS3 from North America. I am not just talking about the piss poor benchmarks of the duel CUP vs quad CPU, which were oddly under talked about by most of the main stream android media, I am trying to point out that the two devices are completely different down to the Audio Processing chip they stuck on the circuit boards. They are not the same device.

I got vow to swap my nexus for the 32GBP gs3 love the battery life on it also 2 gig ram is nice you just have to know how to talk to them I've had no screen problems also phone is a lot faster
Sent from my SCH-I535 using xda premium

Thalinor said:
FYI: I can confirm this too. Probably due to the crapple i****, but its worth noting they are also going to try and deny a swap to a different Android device as well.
A month ago I was told I would be able to swap out my device for any other I wanted; if the new device is more expensive I would pay more, if it was less I would get money back. Last week however I called Verizon just to check on things and they changed their story. I figure I am in for an argument when I try and do the swap out. The grounds for the swap are poor reception which has been confined as a "bug" by Samsung. They say they are working on a fix, but the G Nexus had **** reception which still has not been fixed eight months later, and the GS3 uses the cell same receiver, at least thats what I am told. A Verizon field rep came to the house and reported back service in this area was fine but this device (he had a test one) was a total POS when it came to reception. I have been with verizon for 10+ years and never had so many dropped calls and dead zones. My Data speeds are bi-polar, going from ~39 MBPS next to a VZW tower, down to a few KBPS when I go about 1000 ft away from the tower. Verizon tech support said they can see the increase of dropped calls and poor data speeds on my account, which is why they offered the swap. I am waiting for the Droid Inc X because nothing else out now has 2bg ram.
When you add poor reception to the long list of other issues, I can see why people are jumping off this sinking ship.
I used to keep my Droid X & X2 in a car dock mounted on the windshield and audio out through the earphone jack to the car speakers. No ext mic or BT headset was needed for people to hear me and no once did anyone ever complain they could hear themselves through the phone echoing. I can no longer do this now that I have the GS3.
The audio processor for the US versions is total ****. The international version has a different audio processing chip which is MUCH better and you can HEAR the difference not only with headphones, but with car speakers through headphone jack, and even the phones built in crap speaker. Volume levels suck, and while it is ok when just using headphones, if you use the device in a Car Dock plugged into your car speakers, you will find you have to turn up the volume on your car stereo much higher then other phones. Noise cancelation is horrid; people on the other end of my calls can hear themselves echo if I use the device in the car with audio through the speakers. The mic sensitivity is no where near good as Motorola phones. I can no longer use my phone for voice calls hands free when its mounted on the dash because the mic's do not pick up my voice more then 2 feet away from the device. When using video conferencing apps like Tango or GChat, I have to hold the phone close to my face or the other party can't hear what I am saying. While my other Android devices did not have forward facing cameras, I did test out these apps using just the rear camera and I did not have the same issue. Samsung phone hardware just blows. They are cheep, the whole device is cheep garbage quality with garbage internal components. They wanted an inexpensive phone and they got it by putting in garbage components to save money.
Its ironic that a company that makes such amazing TV's could totally screw up the screen on the GS3. The phones display PPI are awful compared to other premium devices and pentile is such garbage old technology. There alr also widespread manufacturing defects in the screen. I have checked out seven different GS3's, not just Verizon but on different carriers too. All of them have visible screen manufacturing defects where when the screen is set to medium or higher brightness, and you are looking at a black backdrop, you can see these black waterspots. Its the glue they used under the **** pentile display. Thats what happens when you rush out 10+ million devices using cheep labor. I love Samsung TV's but I will NEVER buy another Samsung smartphone.
Combine all of this with Verizon's encrypted bootloader, annoying Wi-Fi popup, S-Voice interface forced instead of Googles Voice Command interface, and Verizons spyware Backup Assistant / Mobile Hotspot emended into the system menu and you have a subpar POS device.
Yes, you can Root and Rom to fix the software issues, but the hardware ones will not be fixed by a 3rd party Rom or software update. Verizon knows this device is a POS and they know they have completely messed up the software side, in fact while they say the Wi-Fi popup is a "bug" we all know Verizon is a bunch of scumbag liars.
This is why people are returning the device; the abuse is by Verizon on its customers.
EDIT: I made it very clear with Verizon that I will NEVER use an Apple product due to the fact they are criminals who violate the US construction and civil rights. They said they are no longer swapping devices for any manufacture, not just Apple. This has nothing to do with the 15 day return policy, just the policy where Verizon will swap your phone if you have known issues they can't fix. It used to be the 3 strikes swap, where if you had to swap the same device three times you could pick a different one.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I would be more than happy to trade you my RAZR MAXX for your GS3 if there was an easy way of doing it. I feel the same about my MAXX, ever since the ICS update my phone is crap. I'd love to have a GS3. I've messed with them and I like everything about them EXCEPT the battery, but I would give up battery life for that phone. LOL. Sorry for highjacking this thread, but i couldn't help it. I've heard a lot worse about Motorolas.

Thalinor said:
@hchristy2013
It seems missed the point, and more then likely the point of the OP. I can't say for sure as there is not enough info in the post, but because this is in the GS3 section, I am assuming he is talking about the same thing I am talking about... GETTING RID OF THE GS3 and swapping it for another device.
You are GETTING a GS3 from Verizon, I am (and assume the OP) talking about getting RID of GS3's and getting a different phone model. Verizon has been giving G Nexus people free swap outs to GS3's for several months now, mainly over G Nexus poor reception issues. Thats the joke of it too; the GS3 has the SAME issue, but people are getting a faster device so they are happy with the swap and keep quiet. I came over from a Droid X and a X2 via Ins replacement [of the DX]; both had BS encrypted bootloaders which made me hate the devices and Motoroal itself, but at least the "phone" part of the "smartphone" actually worked correctly.
If I wanted a smartphone that could not properly make and receive calls I would have bought an iPhone.
EDIT: Because this forum is filled with people from all over the world, I would like to point out once again the GS3 de international' is not even close to the GS3 from North America. I am not just talking about the piss poor benchmarks of the duel CUP vs quad CPU, which were oddly under talked about by most of the main stream android media, I am trying to point out that the two devices are completely different down to the Audio Processing chip they stuck on the circuit boards. They are not the same device.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You make it sound like Verizon is giving people a GS3 from a gnex like its free candy and that is definitely not the case. I had 5 gnex replacements and had to deal with serveral bad reps and 2 supervisors before they budged on giving me one. There are also plenty of people going on their 6+ gnex replacement.
Sent from my Galaxy SIII
---------- Post added at 09:28 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:26 PM ----------
xterra91 said:
I got vow to swap my nexus for the 32GBP gs3 love the battery life on it also 2 gig ram is nice you just have to know how to talk to them I've had no screen problems also phone is a lot faster
Sent from my SCH-I535 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How on earth did u get them to give you a 32gb GS3 I went through hell and back just to even get a 16gb gs3.
Sent from my Galaxy SIII

From day of OP, it the decision to stop alternate replacements had been made with in the "last 72 hours". It came from corporate. Due to people abusing the system and getting multiple alternate replacements. QUESTION: does this apply to me when VZW sent me a Nexus accidentally instead of the S3 I had origianally. I cc called and told them I received the Nexus and they apologized and agent me the S3
Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2

I continuously get the no SIM error. On replacement device 4 today and replacement SIM 11, yes 11. Really tired of this B.S. I might leave VZW. NOTE THIS: If you have opened a trouble ticket and it comes back saying you live in a known trouble area, you can cancel your contract with paying an early termination fee.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2

I have never had to re-read so many posts to understand the point.
Back to the topic, I am repeatedly offered alternative replacements to my S3, due to the NO SIM issue. I keep refusing them, hoping for a software update to fix the bug, or the Note 2 release...
Like the other person said, I think you gotta learn to talk nice to them.

I sweat talk my butt off. nothing changes at all.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2

ihavenewnike said:
I sweat talk my butt off. nothing changes at all.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well there's the problem ... less "sweat" (ewww ...) and more sweet.
Sent from my SCH-I535 using xda premium

Bear gri11z said:
Started with a galaxy nexus... the usb melted got it replaced... horrible quality control.. poor radio... sent me one more nexus and this razr ( at the same time)
Razr has dead pixels and the home button light is dead...
Other galaxy nexus wont turn on...
Verizon is sending me a white 16gb s3
If it has any problems i was promised and noted on my account no ETF for both of my lines
Been with verizon for 2 and a half years
You guys just need to learn how to talk to them
Sent from my DROID RAZR using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nothing to do with how you talk to them. It is called luck of the draw. Some reps can be pushed to give you what you want and others can't. End of story.

[email protected] said:
Nothing to do with how you talk to them.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Of course it does, the techs are human & it absolutely DOES matter how you talk to them.
I am the head of our cell dept at work (187 phones). When I call VZ I get phenomenal service (& have for over 10 years). I have never had a single problem with them.
I have a coworker that absolutely HATES VZ but it's because he is a loudmouth hothead & manages to piss off just about everybody he talks to rather quickly. LOL, he never gets any help from anybody..........

jmorton10 said:
Of course it does, the techs are human & it absolutely DOES matter how you talk to them.
I am the head of our cell dept at work (187 phones). When I call VZ I get phenomenal service (& have for over 10 years). I have never had a single problem with them.
I have a coworker that absolutely HATES VZ but it's because he is a loudmouth hothead & manages to piss off just about everybody he talks to rather quickly. LOL, he never gets any help from anybody..........
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can be the nicest person in the world to a rep, it does not mean they will swap your GNEX for an S3.
I have seen many times a nasty frustrated person get what he wants and the nice guy gets Jack ****.
I am not saying that you should not be nice I am just saying it does not mean it will get you what you want.
Also, you being a head of cell phones for a company puts you in another class.

Update: Seems that the rep was lying, and her supervisor. I am guessing she told her supervisor what to say and he played along with her. I called in last night and spoke to another rep. She does some troubleshooting and sees it isn't working. She then offers me a replcement in a nexus. I told her I already had one but sold it to get the S3. She then proceeds to say and I quote " Well I am not supposed to make these statements but there are rumors of a Galaxy Note 2 coming out within the next month and you might like that. I can call you back then and see if you are interested in that as a replacement device." So looks like if things go well, I could have a note in my hands soon.
Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2

ihavenewnike said:
Update: Seems that the rep was lying, and her supervisor. I am guessing she told her supervisor what to say and he played along with her. I called in last night and spoke to another rep. She does some troubleshooting and sees it isn't working. She then offers me a replcement in a nexus. I told her I already had one but sold it to get the S3. She then proceeds to say and I quote " Well I am not supposed to make these statements but there are rumors of a Galaxy Note 2 coming out within the next month and you might like that. I can call you back then and see if you are interested in that as a replacement device." So looks like if things go well, I could have a note in my hands soon.
Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
hmmmm I would like a note as well!! Only issue I have is super crappy 3g reception at my house (1 bar that drops constantly) and I can drive less than 5 minutes into town and have 4 full bars of 4g so I don't think its a service issue more so than a radio issue. Never had the issue with any of my moto devices.

I must be one of the lucky people. My phone has never had a problem... yeah I had bad reception until lately when they must have extended 4G out here... now I'm usually always 2-3 bars 4g! Also I did flash the new modem also. I don't know if that was the fix or just the 4g extension
Sent from VZW Galaxy SIII

Related

Getting flack from friends for switching

They all are saying AT&T is evil, I'm crazy blah blah vampire emergency blah...
OMG WHAT HAVE I DONE????
Seriously. All Cellular carriers in the US are evil. Just in different ways. Why all the AT&T hate? Where's the gotchas?
Are they paying for your phone or wireless bill?
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I897 using XDA App
mesasone said:
Are they paying for your phone or wireless bill?
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I897 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ditto. Plenty of people have legitimate reasons to complain about AT&T (dropped calls, lack of coverage, etc) but plenty of people have never had a single issue with them. Personally I just switched to AT&T for the Captivate (formerly with T-Mobile) and I've been happy so far. I get at least the same if not better coverage and my bill is actually cheaper thanks to a 21% discount from my employer.
it's fashionable to hate at&t. If you listened to these people, at&t would have worse coverage than tmobile. Anyone who's ever owned both outside of a major metro area knows that's a joke.
AT&T issues are market-based and are not universal. If any of your "friends" are iPhone 4 users, their problems are universal.
i dont have any real complaints with service anymore (one perk of the iphone)
but i dont think ive had one single interaction with att that they didnt mess up (ex. adding a line and putting a messaging block on the whole account. wtf?)
I was one of those that had trouble with at&t. I had each iPhone generation, and all 3g versions would drop calls. Now I will say I worked for apple retail at the genius bar for this time period, and it was all to frequent in terms of customers complaining. I bought the hype that it was at&T's sucky network causing all the issues.
Then the iPhone 4 hit. I had one. Returned it due to lack of satisfaction with he fix for the search grip as well as the proximity sensor issue. I immediately went and got the captivate.
I haven't dropped a single call since. Not one. Even in areas that were guaranteed to drop on 3 successive generations of iPhone. I have yet to have any issue.
That tells me something.
That I will not go back. No matter what.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I897 using XDA App
id10terrordfw said:
I haven't dropped a single call since. Not one. Even in areas that were guaranteed to drop on 3 successive generations of iPhone. I have yet to have any issue.
That tells me something.
That I will not go back. No matter what.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Same, my wife and I were disgusted with our iPhone 3Gs, both dropped calls and limited customization, and poor performance with the iOS 4 update. It was so bad we thought it was AT&T's network and were contemplating on switching carriers. I decided to try out the Captivate, and it's been awesome.
And your buddies are jealous, that's all
id10terrordfw said:
I was one of those that had trouble with at&t. I had each iPhone generation, and all 3g versions would drop calls. Now I will say I worked for apple retail at the genius bar for this time period, and it was all to frequent in terms of customers complaining. I bought the hype that it was at&T's sucky network causing all the issues.
Then the iPhone 4 hit. I had one. Returned it due to lack of satisfaction with he fix for the search grip as well as the proximity sensor issue. I immediately went and got the captivate.
I haven't dropped a single call since. Not one. Even in areas that were guaranteed to drop on 3 successive generations of iPhone. I have yet to have any issue.
That tells me something.
That I will not go back. No matter what.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I897 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My experience is similar. I have had at&t for years.i never had a problem with them until I had an iphone. The three I had dropped calls constantly. Now I have the captivate and at&t is great again.
thanks all. You'll never get a die hard apple fanboi to admit the iphone problems are problems with the phone. Thanks for the positive stories
Yeah, when I had my first gen iPhone, I occasionally dropped calls and just generally had bad quality. I figured it was AT&T's infamous network. I almost switched carriers, but I was prepaid at that time and had built up nearly a 500 dollar balance on my account, so I didn't want to lose that. So, I gave the Blackberry Bold (9000) a try - turns out it was the iPhone all along. I got great reception and fantastic call quality on my Bold.
I haven't made many calls with my Captivate - frankly, the voice/phone portion of my cellphone is fairly low on my priorities - but while it doesn't really seem to quite be up to the level of my Bold, it's still far ahead of my iPhone.
Same story here.
Had a WinMo phone for years (HTC Hermes) then switched to iPhone, started dropping calls, and losing data. It wasn't too big, and at about the same time I moved into a basement apt. I chalked it up to all the concrete that I could not talk on the phone when home. We moved again, and on my commute to and from work there were 3 spots that would lose signal EVERY time. Calls would drop, Pandora would stop playing, etc. Then I got my HTC Aria, same commute, far fewer dropped calls, then my Captivate (day 30 of my Aria return window) and haven't dropped a call since on the commute. AT&T having network issues? I think not.
I am giddy at the chance of a Verizon iPhone, so all the people complaining about AT&T will see that the iPhone on any network sucks.
I've had at&t for years, because until recently it was all we had I'm my area that was any count at all. Recently Verizon has moved in, and I did consider switching because of hardware choices. But I waited it out, and decided to go ahead with my Captivate, and I'm loving it. My friends all have iPhones and so did I. I never had the problems that they seem to have, but I'm happier now anyway being away from the tyranny of Steve Jobs.
Sent from my GT-I9000-Captivate using XDA App
i had to switch to at&t because of work. i do a lot of international travel and at&t's list of countries is about 5x bigger than any other carrier for reduced roaming rates. and GSM is more universal and i didn't want verizon's blackberry offerings.
i had minor issues with call drops, but that's because i'm usually in large metal/concrete airplane hangers.
so far though, no issues with captive. even with one bar, no call quality issues either in the states...or as of so far hong kong.
oh and my entire office but 2 others have iphones and i got nothing but flack for not getting one. glad i didn't
I have been with ATT since 1998 and the only issues I have ever had with dropped calls was with the following phones since the Cingular/ATT Merger: Nokia N-Gage QD, Motorola V551 *just close to my house*, Motorola V3 *close to my house and when the phone was at the end of its life*, Samsung Sync *bought it used of fleabay worst cell ever*, Nokia N55 *would drop in typical black hole areas*, Motorola Razr2 *POS never could get a good voice call on it no matter what area I was in*, Blackberry Curve 8300 *dropped calls in blackhole areas*, BB 8310 *same as 8300*, BB Bold 9000 Same as the previous BBs, and now the Captivate *same as the BB in terms of dropped calls which equals about 2 dropped calls in the past 5 weeks or so*...
Now funny thing when I talk to a couple of my friends who actually have the iPhone, they drop randomly and it is pretty funny where I dont have the issue with my Captivate. Even my friend who is also a snake breeder *boas, pythons and other snakes*, told me today he likes his iPhone 3G besides the dropping call issue and asked me how Android is treating me, I said I love it and not going back to BB...
HTH,
Charlie
Gunny, wtf Re you doing here in the ATT phone section? Shouldn't you be in the Hero section? >¦(
LOL
Sent from my iPhone with the bigger Gee Bees.
LOL notasimpleway. Got tired of having an out of date phone and super slow EVDO.

Any former X2/Charge owners switch to TB?

I went from the Charge to the X2, and now I'm starting to dislike the lack of development for the phone and I miss 4G.
Anyone here previously own a Charge and/or X2? Thoughts? I would have gotten the TB instead but the comments I've seen about the poor voice quality and some bad screens had turned me away.
triton302 said:
I went from the Charge to the X2, and now I'm starting to dislike the lack of development for the phone and I miss 4G.
Anyone here previously own a Charge and/or X2? Thoughts? I would have gotten the TB instead but the comments I've seen about the poor voice quality and some bad screens had turned me away.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think there's 2 kinds of people out there.... There's the guys that think everything kicks ass, and there's the guys that think everything sucks ass. I really think people should investigate more for themselves and rely less on here-say to form an opinion about something. There's still people that think the Tbolt has problems rebooting all the time.
I haven't had one problem with my Tbolt. Can't say the same about anything from Motorola. A friend has an X2 and is feeling some real regret on account of speed, lack of 4G, and... It's a motorola. I think that pretty much says it all.
The Charge isn't bad, but it's not as technically capable as the Tbolt; a fact that carries weight with me. To me, the Tbolt is still the only option for me.
I came from the Droid X and I was disappointed in the t bolt. I'm on my 4th now, all of them rebooted constantly while on the old radio, but this is the only one that still reboots even after the new radio was flashed. the build quality is very poor on the t bolt compared to the X, horrible sound quality, call quality (on both ends) cheap feeling, poor finish. The only things I like on the t bolt over the X is the captive buttons, 4g and the RAM. Motorola has the best build quality, best reception, best call quality. As long as the bionic is rootable that's what I'll be getting next (verizon will replace it with a different phone next time)
eraursls1984 said:
I came from the Droid X and I was disappointed in the t bolt. I'm on my 4th now, all of them rebooted constantly while on the old radio, but this is the only one that still reboots even after the new radio was flashed. the build quality is very poor on the t bolt compared to the X, horrible sound quality, call quality (on both ends) cheap feeling, poor finish. The only things I like on the t bolt over the X is the captive buttons, 4g and the RAM. Motorola has the best build quality, best reception, best call quality. As long as the bionic is rootable that's what I'll be getting next (verizon will replace it with a different phone next time)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Motorola cellular radios have always sucked ass. I stopped using them because it didn't seem to matter what model it was, NONE of them could keep a signal on the coast or the island I lived at. One had a buzz so loud you couldn't hear anyone talking over it. One wouldn't let you use switchboards. They ALL restarted all the time. Before I went smart phone, all I used was Samsung and Kyocera. For smart phones all I'd use are HTC, Samsung, and MAYBE BlackBerry. Every review I read of a Motorola notes it's cheap, flimsy feeling and build quality. If the Bionic ends up like that Moto Sprint is selling, I wouldn't be impressed by it.
loonatik78 said:
Motorola cellular radios have always sucked ass. I stopped using them because it didn't seem to matter what model it was, NONE of them could keep a signal on the coast or the island I lived at. One had a buzz so loud you couldn't hear anyone talking over it. One wouldn't let you use switchboards. They ALL restarted all the time. Before I went smart phone, all I used was Samsung and Kyocera. For smart phones all I'd use are HTC, Samsung, and MAYBE BlackBerry. Every review I read of a Motorola notes it's cheap, flimsy feeling and build quality. If the Bionic ends up like that Moto Sprint is selling, I wouldn't be impressed by it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well I had a 2 Razr's and a Droid X and no Samsung, LG or HTC can match the reception of any of those, and they all had great build quality (personal experience, not reviews) I also had a blackberry storm which was a joke, but it did have great reception and call quality when it wasn't frozen. I have also had a few Samsung and LG phones (as well as my wife) and all of them had poor reception and call quality, and the trend continues from what I've seen with the galaxy phones. I've only had one HTC phone and it hasn't impressed me but from what I've seen in the inc, and what many others have told me about HTC Windows phones they seem to be good phones, that's why I think the t bolt was rushed because it isn't a very good phone.
I agree with both of you on certain points.
I have owned a few Motorola devices and my DX was by far the best when it came to call quality, I could be in my basement with -99 dbm signal strength on a call and it just wouldn't drop. Only a few times in the year I had that phone did I ever just randomly drop out of 3G in an area where Verizon had excellent coverage. Probably the most dependable phone I ever had. My old v325 held signal very well too, never had a dropped call with it.
However... the lack of updates and the outdated hardware makes it difficult for Motorola to keep up with the competition, that's why Samsung and HTC are ahead in the Android game. Those two companies are always coming out with something better in one way or another... but what has Motorola release lately that is a knockout? Nothing, and pretty soon the Bionic will be in the same boat. Motorola is too late in the game with the Bionic and it'll probably have the same crappy Pentile qHD display. I'd almost rather have a standard LCD screen.
I owned the Incredible when it first came out, but I sold it for the DX because I wanted a bigger screen and I wasn't a fan of that generation of AMOLED screens, looked just like the Pentile on the X2 except with more vivid colors. Otherwise it was a speedy phone, just didn't have the call quality the DX did.
triton302 said:
I agree with both of you on certain points.
I have owned a few Motorola devices and my DX was by far the best when it came to call quality, I could be in my basement with -99 dbm signal strength on a call and it just wouldn't drop. Only a few times in the year I had that phone did I ever just randomly drop out of 3G in an area where Verizon had excellent coverage. Probably the most dependable phone I ever had. My old v325 held signal very well too, never had a dropped call with it.
However... the lack of updates and the outdated hardware makes it difficult for Motorola to keep up with the competition, that's why Samsung and HTC are ahead in the Android game. Those two companies are always coming out with something better in one way or another... but what has Motorola release lately that is a knockout? Nothing, and pretty soon the Bionic will be in the same boat. Motorola is too late in the game with the Bionic and it'll probably have the same crappy Pentile qHD display. I'd almost rather have a standard LCD screen.
I owned the Incredible when it first came out, but I sold it for the DX because I wanted a bigger screen and I wasn't a fan of that generation of AMOLED screens, looked just like the Pentile on the X2 except with more vivid colors. Otherwise it was a speedy phone, just didn't have the call quality the DX did.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My devices usually see a minimum of 30 or so states, if not all 48, so I definitely get to try out devices under just about every condition and terrain there is. Motorola's devices have consistently sucked ass. I was forced to stop using them all together when my wife and I lived on an island in FL. Forget making a phone call... you couldn't even text with them. I'm not too concerned about call quality if I can't make the call. The only company to make radios that are as bad is LG.
loonatik78 said:
The only company to make radios that are as bad is LG.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I will agree with that.
Are you on your original TB? What do you think of the screen and the call quality? Those are the two biggest factors in my decision on getting this phone. I read that the TB gets much better 4G reception than the Charge does.
Screen and call quality have been great with mine. But like loonatik, I've never had reboot problems either. That said until I bought the extended battery I was ready to give up on it.
courtesy of my bolt and tapatalk
I have had problems with both the Droid X and the HTC Thunderbolt. I also travel all across the country and seen how each each work in those areas. I don't know why but one of the many Thunderbolts I had would have terrible static at times. I could hear the person but all they heard was a bunch of static. I heard static on my end a couple times. That device was replaced and I never had that issue again. Out of the LTE devices available NOW, I would still pick the Thunderbolt out of any of the others. I would actually pick it over any of Verizon's smartphones as of NOW. The Thunderbolts pros outweigh the cons for me. I love the 35+Mbps download speeds at times.
Sent from my ADR6400L using xda premium
I have been lucky and have not had any reboot issues or any of the other ones some have mentioned. I get great reception unless I'm buried in the basment of the building I work in. I also think the screen is damn good. It's bright, great color reproduction, deep blacks, and very crisp. It doesn't do good in direct sunlight but thats pretty much the case with most any phone screen. Overall it has been a great phone for me but I would recommend rooting and a custom ROM for the best experience.
Sent from my HTC Thunderbolt
The TBolt is a cool phone. I had a really tough time deciding whether to get it or the Charge. At the end of the day, the Charge was cheaper at Costco and I liked the screen more. Development definitely seems better on the TBolt, though I don't really mind as much since I don't use 3rd party ROMs. I'm a huge fan of the SAMOLED+, the proper subpixel pattern makes all the difference. I hate the pentile format that older AMOLEDs used, as well as what Moto is using on all of their new phones...
Regardless, I'd honestly say wait a few more days and see what the Bionic does.

Microphone Issues?

I ordered 4 galaxy S3's for my family plan from amazonwireless for the $99 deal 2 weeks ago. Right away we noticed all of them have extremely poor call quality compared to our previous phones. I live in a major city with good reception so it doesn't make sense. It literally sounds like we are standing next to a jet engine while driving and people that we are calling are constantly complaining. I turned off the noise cancellation and made sure the microphones weren't covered by the cases but no improvments. Anyone else experiencing louder than usual background noise and raspy/choppy voice quality? Any suggestions on fixes? I'm beginning to suspect that amazon/samsung dumped a bunch of defective units for the $99 deal they had.
"Poor" may be relative, but what kind of phones did you have previously?
Call quality on our two Galaxy S III phones have been very good, I feel. At least, it sounds better than comparable iPhone 4s and other Androids we've owned, but we've had a few minor incidents of borked signal (or something) with Verizon or the phone(s) that required a redial to correct since receiving them from pre-order.
Perhaps consider use of a Voice Recorder or memo function on the new and old phones, generating sound files you can compare on a single piece of equipment to sort of test the microphone. This assumes each voice recording app use similar specifications for sampling, etc. but might help pinpoint the mic vs other causes of what you hear.
- ooofest
We all had the epic 4g touch (galaxy II) on sprint before. The problem is so bad that practically everyone I've called is reporting it to me and my family members are having the same experience. I can hear it first hand when we call each other. My wife sounds like a raspy 90 year old grandmother. If we are in any location other than a completely silent room the call is unbearable. It's like the microphone sensitivity is way to high. Definitely not an isolated incident. It's every call.
chase7545 said:
We all had the epic 4g touch (galaxy II) on sprint before. The problem is so bad that practically everyone I've called is reporting it to me and my family members are having the same experience. I can hear it first hand when we call each other. My wife sounds like a raspy 90 year old grandmother. If we are in any location other than a completely silent room the call is unbearable. It's like the microphone sensitivity is way to high. Definitely not an isolated incident. It's every call.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't have this issue at all either. My friend has a S3 and we talk all the time when we are driving with the windows part down and not 1 complaint.
x714x said:
I don't have this issue at all either. My friend has a S3 and we talk all the time when we are driving with the windows part down and not 1 complaint.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yep looks like were going to have to return the phones for new ones. Ours are obviously defective units. Problem is amazonwireless makes you go 4-6 days without a phone to exchange and I have no phone to temporarily switch to. Never buying from them again.
chase7545 said:
Yep looks like were going to have to return the phones for new ones. Ours are obviously defective units. Problem is amazonwireless makes you go 4-6 days without a phone to exchange and I have no phone to temporarily switch to. Never buying from them again.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry to hear, though it seems so odd that all four phones would have this same problem if it was a phone hardware defect. One might expect that one or two phones have a serious issue, but all four having the exact same defect seems very strange.
Something must be common to them all, I guess: each was categorized as having the same problems for reconditioning and sat in a "fixed" pile to send out, they were all made during the same (bad) run in original manufacturing, they are all roaming due to a common activation issue, the local network is not healthy for them for some reason or perhaps some unique software is running that interferes with the voice.
I attached two screenshots from my Settings -> About submenu for Verizon . . . do yours look similar?
If you made a local voice recording, playback sounds just as bad as over the phone?
Are you now on Verizon? I guess that's why you're posting here, but just checking my assumption. If so, do you have a local Verizon store in which you can test yours vs one of their store models to ensure this isn't something inherent to the way this model phone works with their local network? It sounds like you came from Sprint, so I wonder if there's a fundamental problem with that Verizon location, for some strange reason.
- ooofest

Considering Galaxy S3 - Looking for owner input

I need a new phone. My Galaxy Nexus is shot... It was my first Samsung phone though so I'm a little gunshy due to the problems I have had. I am trying to decide if I should go with the Galaxy S3 or wait for the Motorola Razr Maxx or HD that is supposedly coming soon.
Problems I had with GNEX
Data Drops - known problem, I put up with it, but it was annoying. Data would drop and then take min to reconnect, sometimes few times a day
Screen cracked two places - First phone I ever cracked the screen, but much larger screen then I had before (Dinc). Phone still usable but annoying. Both phones I'm considering have the Gorilla Glass so I assume this wont be an issue
USB Charging port - the final straw, the port went bad. GNex sometimes thinks it is charging when not plugged in and switches every few seconds causing the display to come on constantly and kill my battery within two hours from a full charge. Other times I have to plug in and out just to get it to charge overnight. I know the USB board can be replaced but seriously, not putting money into this phone. I'm worried the GS3 has the same USB charging problem board???
Google Wallet - Verizon blocked it on GNex and GS3... I assume they will block on Razr??? I am rooted so I was able to install the APK but it was always hit or miss as far as using wallet... only worked about 50% of the time. It would connect but then say the transaction did not go thru. I really want to use NFC.
How does the rooted ROM community view each phone? Will the Razr have as many custom ROMs? I will Root whatever phone I get.
The Razr Maxx's aren't out yet so can't tell how they hold up... The GS3 worries me most with the USB charging port and the above issues I had with the Samsung line...
Any comments appreciated. I have an upgrade avaible now so I don't have to wait, but I can limp thru the day with the Gnex plugged in at work a lot so if the Razrs are worth waiting for I can... unless they're not expected till January, but they claim BEFORE the holidays so I assume November?
Also, are there any phones I'm missing? I liked the Dinc and HTC Sense (I know... I know... ) but no HTC phones seem to have NFC and the flagship is not avail on Verizon. I need to stay on Verizon. I will root.
Thanks,
Jim
First i must say the GS3 is MUCH better than the GNex and i haven't had any data drops so far, the screen seems fine but as always be careful with it. I can't say much about the port because i've never heard of that going bad on anything before. Now about rooting and custom roms. From what i can see the GS3 will have a wide arrange of custom roms and support for awhile. The Razr Hd and Razr Maxx Hd will get support but i doubt it will come near as much as the Gs3 as the Gs3 is much more popular than any other android phone. Google Wallet is also blocked on all Verizon phones. Also i personally think the Razr Maxx Hd looks awesome but i already got a gs3 so thats that. Hope this helped your decision.
calaski8123 said:
I need a new phone. My Galaxy Nexus is shot... It was my first Samsung phone though so I'm a little gunshy due to the problems I have had. I am trying to decide if I should go with the Galaxy S3 or wait for the Motorola Razr Maxx or HD that is supposedly coming soon.
Problems I had with GNEX
Data Drops - known problem, I put up with it, but it was annoying. Data would drop and then take min to reconnect, sometimes few times a day
Screen cracked two places - First phone I ever cracked the screen, but much larger screen then I had before (Dinc). Phone still usable but annoying. Both phones I'm considering have the Gorilla Glass so I assume this wont be an issue
USB Charging port - the final straw, the port went bad. GNex sometimes thinks it is charging when not plugged in and switches every few seconds causing the display to come on constantly and kill my battery within two hours from a full charge. Other times I have to plug in and out just to get it to charge overnight. I know the USB board can be replaced but seriously, not putting money into this phone. I'm worried the GS3 has the same USB charging problem board???
Google Wallet - Verizon blocked it on GNex and GS3... I assume they will block on Razr??? I am rooted so I was able to install the APK but it was always hit or miss as far as using wallet... only worked about 50% of the time. It would connect but then say the transaction did not go thru. I really want to use NFC.
How does the rooted ROM community view each phone? Will the Razr have as many custom ROMs? I will Root whatever phone I get.
The Razr Maxx's aren't out yet so can't tell how they hold up... The GS3 worries me most with the USB charging port and the above issues I had with the Samsung line...
Any comments appreciated. I have an upgrade avaible now so I don't have to wait, but I can limp thru the day with the Gnex plugged in at work a lot so if the Razrs are worth waiting for I can... unless they're not expected till January, but they claim BEFORE the holidays so I assume November?
Also, are there any phones I'm missing? I liked the Dinc and HTC Sense (I know... I know... ) but no HTC phones seem to have NFC and the flagship is not avail on Verizon. I need to stay on Verizon. I will root.
Thanks,
Jim
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Spotty data and drops all over the place here... coming from all htc devices it's horrible... that being said.. the phone is very nice n fast but if u can't live with the crappy Samsung radios anymore I'd say wait.
Google wallet can be fixed via rooting.
Sent from my unlocked VZW Galaxy SIII
I live in an area where I have 4g LTE everywhere so I can't say anything bad about the radio cause I have no issues with mine nor did I have issues with My Gnex (as far as the radio)... I would say that Samsung makes THE most cheapest phones out there as far as parts and build quality but I still LOVE my phone for some reason.... Maybe cause it's just fast as hell and some of the downfalls don't affect me but I will tell you that you had better make sure that you get a solid S3 NEW cause if and when it does fail their refurbs are a JOKE and I think I am on my fourth Verizon refurb cause they keep sending me garbage but I finally have one that I "think" is going to be good minus the power button being loose as hell but I think every S3 I have had has a loose power button... Just know that the bootloader is unlocked and if you go to another phone it's gonna be locked until these kickass devs over here figure it out... And as far as development goes, I am in LOVE!! Sooo many options with my S3's and I don't see it stopping anytime soon... Read the forums and make a wise decision but I don't regret getting this phone I think I have just been cursed by Verizon.... Just please don't buy an iPhone.... LOL Have a great day!
Coming from a Droid X (rooted) to a GS3 (not rooted yet) can't really complain. In Phoenix coverage is very good, even along desolate hwy's and out in the desert far from anything. Just recently drove across country and used Sirius/XM 90% of the way and made a ton of calls. XM app only dropped out 3 times, in some very remote areas of hwy. Didn't drop a single call and sound quality was good, even traveling at 75 mph. Sent a lot of SMS with Pictures taken along the way, all w/o problem.
Will say that inside of buildings here in PHX, I do see slightly lower signal strength than my Droid X. It's not a deal breaker as the structures I'm talking about are old and mainly steel and concrete. Took a short period of time to adjust to the TouchWiz, but it's no more difficult than any other manufacture tweaked OS. The phone definitely does not have the "built US strong" feel, kinda flimsy. I could drop the DX and not worry too much. This phone I spent a few extra $'s for a stronger case.
Overall, I'd say it's a good phone for now until something better comes along. Could be worse, gotta co-worker with an LG that drives him nuts. He's gonna need therapy one day.
Haha no iphone for me. Wife has one but I wont go over to the cult. Thanks for the replies so far... Seems people like the Samsung but it still has problems that make me worry. I'm tempted to wait for the Razr just too see them both but I think the GS3 has some better specs... I live in northern NJ outside nyc so very good coverage but my nexus still just periodically losses all connections and has to reconnect... Four replacements makes me nervous....
Jim
Xmeoff said:
Coming from a Droid X (rooted) to a GS3 (not rooted yet) can't really complain. In Phoenix coverage is very good, even along desolate hwy's and out in the desert far from anything. Just recently drove across country and used Sirius/XM 90% of the way and made a ton of calls. XM app only dropped out 3 times, in some very remote areas of hwy. Didn't drop a single call and sound quality was good, even traveling at 75 mph. Sent a lot of SMS with Pictures taken along the way, all w/o problem.
Will say that inside of buildings here in PHX, I do see slightly lower signal strength than my Droid X. It's not a deal breaker as the structures I'm talking about are old and mainly steel and concrete. Took a short period of time to adjust to the TouchWiz, but it's no more difficult than any other manufacture tweaked OS. The phone definitely does not have the "built US strong" feel, kinda flimsy. I could drop the DX and not worry too much. This phone I spent a few extra $'s for a stronger case.
Overall, I'd say it's a good phone for now until something better comes along. Could be worse, gotta co-worker with an LG that drives him nuts. He's gonna need therapy one day.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Haha... I'm a cop so I prob need an otterbox, but I didn't get one with the nexus it would make the phone huge. I'm used top the size now so am otterbox prob wouldn't bother me. Just thought maybe with gorilla glass a thinner case might be OK.
Jim
If you are really worried about wear and tear on the usb port this mod should be right up your alley: http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1877191
All in all, it takes no more than 20-30 minutes to install, worst case.
It depends how much you care and flashing roms, I'd wait for the razr maxx HD. It's suppose to have a locked boot loader, but they're unlocking all there new phones. Some new phones are suppose to be coming out in the next couple months, so you might wanna wait to see what's coming.
Sent from my Cocaine White S3.
If you can, I'd at least advise waiting a few months for the next Nexus, Maxx HD etc. Phones with the next gen chipset (S4 Pro etc) are coming out soon.
My S3 is a great phone, but I have to agree the radios are worse than my previous HTC phone. If you are in an area with poor signal, the S3 will frequently drop data and gps locks.
Wow that's a really cool mod... I like. As for flashing ROMs I am pretty crazy until I find one I like then I back off and usually just do the updates. Sometimes it takes a while to find something that has all the features I want.
I'm still undecided...going to go look at the store today and hold it.
One more question... I read the reviews talk about the screen on gs3 being a little darker... Is this a problem or is it fixed with the custom ROMs?
Jim
Being in New Hampshire, with no other 4g coverage here on any other carrier, the service is awesome. The screen seems a tad darker than my epic 4g was on Sprint, but it is far from a problem. Rooting is extremely easy. Like it takes 2 minutes literally. Tons of stable ROMs. I definitely made a really good choice with the GS3, you won't be disappointed.
calaski8123 said:
I need a new phone. My Galaxy Nexus is shot... It was my first Samsung phone though so I'm a little gunshy due to the problems I have had. I am trying to decide if I should go with the Galaxy S3 or wait for the Motorola Razr Maxx or HD that is supposedly coming soon.
Problems I had with GNEX
Data Drops - known problem, I put up with it, but it was annoying. Data would drop and then take min to reconnect, sometimes few times a day
Screen cracked two places - First phone I ever cracked the screen, but much larger screen then I had before (Dinc). Phone still usable but annoying. Both phones I'm considering have the Gorilla Glass so I assume this wont be an issue
USB Charging port - the final straw, the port went bad. GNex sometimes thinks it is charging when not plugged in and switches every few seconds causing the display to come on constantly and kill my battery within two hours from a full charge. Other times I have to plug in and out just to get it to charge overnight. I know the USB board can be replaced but seriously, not putting money into this phone. I'm worried the GS3 has the same USB charging problem board???
Google Wallet - Verizon blocked it on GNex and GS3... I assume they will block on Razr??? I am rooted so I was able to install the APK but it was always hit or miss as far as using wallet... only worked about 50% of the time. It would connect but then say the transaction did not go thru. I really want to use NFC.
How does the rooted ROM community view each phone? Will the Razr have as many custom ROMs? I will Root whatever phone I get.
The Razr Maxx's aren't out yet so can't tell how they hold up... The GS3 worries me most with the USB charging port and the above issues I had with the Samsung line...
Any comments appreciated. I have an upgrade avaible now so I don't have to wait, but I can limp thru the day with the Gnex plugged in at work a lot so if the Razrs are worth waiting for I can... unless they're not expected till January, but they claim BEFORE the holidays so I assume November?
Also, are there any phones I'm missing? I liked the Dinc and HTC Sense (I know... I know... ) but no HTC phones seem to have NFC and the flagship is not avail on Verizon. I need to stay on Verizon. I will root.
Thanks,
Jim
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Doesn't Verizon offer a 14 day return/exchange policy? Worst case is try it, if you don't like it return it for another phone. Just don't root it during that time frame if you want to play it safe. Otherwise, ROMS provided for the GS3 are awesome in this community. I've had both the Sprint variant and now on Verizon for it's 4G LTE service.
Personally I'd wait a few months. Reception sucks but it's not too bad.
Sent from my SCH-I535 using xda premium
I would go with it and a JB ROM... I almost bought the iPhone 5 and backed out to keep my GS3 and unlimited Data..thank god I went over 2 GB today lol
Sent from VZW Galaxy SIII
I am also in the upgrade search. Thanks to all that contributed it may have helped me a bit with my choice as well coming from my Dinc.
Yes thank you for everyone's input. The opinions seem to be a little split, but that is to be expected. I'm leaning towards the GS3. I went to my local Verizon guy I've been dealing with for years. He said hands down he would go with the GS3. He said the Razr is still a bit behind in specs. I also see that the GS3 is 2GB RAM and the Razrs are only 1GB... The GS3 felt nice in hand.. sleek and smooth. The Motorola is still too clunky feeling to me.. angular and just not sleek. Personal opinion.
He also said there is no set release date for the Razrs... and I can get the GS3 cheaper. I also liked the reviews of the TouchWiz gestures...Interested to see how they are. Do any of the custom ROMs maintain the Touch Wiz gestures or features?
I think with the better specs right now I'd go with the GS3. The biggest problems, screen and reception, seem to be issues I can deal with. I rarely use my Nexus at full brightness and I the reception seems to be better than NExus in my area.
Jim
Also the battery on the GS3 seems to be pretty good considering its not promoted as such like the Maxx HD will be...
intelinside83 said:
I would go with it and a JB ROM... I almost bought the iPhone 5 and backed out to keep my GS3 and unlimited Data..thank god I went over 2 GB today lol
Sent from VZW Galaxy SIII
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I almost got it too. Went to apple store and compared it hands on. I had 30 day return policy. Compared to the iphone, the colors are so much more vibrant! And the screen size is icing on the cake.
Sent from my SCH-I535 using xda app-developers app
---------- Post added at 04:51 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:47 PM ----------
I'll also add that I own a macbook pro, and syncing--unless you run bootcamp--can be a PITA. Even with Android file transfer, it's often hit or miss.
Sent from my SCH-I535 using xda app-developers app
skater95 said:
It depends how much you care and flashing roms, I'd wait for the razr maxx HD. It's suppose to have a locked boot loader, but they're unlocking all there new phones. Some new phones are suppose to be coming out in the next couple months, so you might wanna wait to see what's coming.
Sent from my Cocaine White S3.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
there is no way a Verizon phone will come with a unlocked bootloader unless its that dreaded iPhone.

V10 >>>Banter BONANZA<<< and Tagline Thread _______________

So the Root thread was starting to get out of hand.
If you want to "talk shop" or "shoot teh $hit", let's do that here and keep the Root thread clean for development headway.
Got a few thoughts on the V10 myself.
1) Battery life is not the best, leaves me desiring more.
2) When wearing a case, the Volumptuous10 has a very "specific" spot it likes to be touched. (we are talking about the fingerprint reader here... get your mind outta the gutter)
3) General performance is pretty good, but graphic prowess is severely lacking. Wished LG had used something other than the 808
4) Speaker is a bit weak for my uses. I often work in loud environments where using speakerphone on calls is necessary just to hear the other party
5) I miss having dual cellular radios. Means no simultaneous data and voice calls unless using your Carriers "advanced calling" app/feature. Not an ideal solution
6) Second screen is useful, but too restricted. I hope LG opens this up more to 3rd party apps that can expand its usability 100 fold
7) Picture quality for me is softer on the V10 when compared to the G4 in side by side shots. I have tested this under many different conditions
8) WOULD CARRIERS STOP LOCKING DOWN OUR DEVICES AND LOADING THEM UP WITH CRAPWARE ALREADY ???? damn.....
9) Love the design. Looking at it reminds me of Star Wars imperial designs. I have officially named my V10 " TIE-Fighter X " . And I guess the relation to the Dark Side is fitting seeing that Verizon just had to brand the back plate.
That brings me to TAG LINES. If you have one bouncing around in that noggin of yours, let it loose here...
1st point on my list above spawned this thought.
Tag line reads: " V10 battery life got you down? Could've had a V8 "
Needs to have an image to go along with this. Someone make me one??
And my feelings about the battery life and design of this spectacular device come with a development request.
SOMEONE PLEASE MAKE A STAR WARS ROM FOR THIS BEAST!!! I beg of you.
Call it something like "Star Destroyer", or "Vader's Vain". Maybe even "DeathStar". Get creative.
As you can see by the title of this thread and the content within... ANYTHING GOES.
Have at it !!!
Why in the bloody hell does the default camera app have to sharpen every image. I think LG wants to compensate on everything *wink wink*
Battery life is ... Meh... ok though.. two batteries / fast charging is a nice option...
also, and probably the bigger topic. I can talk and use data (either on the device itself or tethering via Foxfi) at the same time. I'm not doing anything special but it works for me.
Development for this phone it's pretty much non existent. I should have kept my nexus 6 or bought the newest note.
The second screen is a total waste at this point and a awful gimmick that managed to suck me in to buy the phone. ( that was one of the reasons I bought it).
This is my first and probably last LGv phone.
Battery life is less than desirable but so are most Android phones.
TheRealKingSen said:
Development for this phone it's pretty much non existent. I should have kept my nexus 6 or bought the newest note.
The second screen is a total waste at this point and a awful gimmick that managed to suck me in to buy the phone. ( that was one of the reasons I bought it).
This is my first and probably last LGv phone.
Battery life is less than desirable but so are most Android phones.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is your name Nancy by chance?
I like the second screen. use it to control pandora (or music app) while in another app or while screen is off, quick apps to launch (from anywhere), answer or ignore phone calls without it taking over your screen. I extended the text notification to ten seconds so if i see one come in I have time to click on it to bring it up or swipe it away. anyhow. just my opinion. Hope it grows on you and if not that you are able to trade someone for a phone you like better.
ke5pcv said:
Why in the bloody hell does the default camera app have to sharpen every image. I think LG wants to compensate on everything *wink wink*
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I tested my V10 side by side with my mothers G4. Her G4 takes a sharper shot on almost every attempt. This is testing them literally side x side taking shots in various conditions.
So either the software on the V10 need tweaking, or I bought my Mom a killer G4. LOL Just my $.02
kaluna00 said:
I can talk and use data (either on the device itself or tethering via Foxfi) at the same time. I'm not doing anything special but it works for me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Log into your Verizon account online and look on the right side of the page. You should see "Plan Management" in red letters. Right under that are 2 red buttons. Click on the [My Products and Apps].
On the next page under the Get Products tab, click on "Free Products". You should see HD Voice. If that is enabled already, that might be why you can do that.
Now the feature that originally allowed you to use data and voice simultaneously used to be listed here under the name Advanced Calling 1.0. It does not appear there any more, but it was there just a month ago. I am not sure if it has been rolled up into the HD Voice or not, but it's probably baked into all current Verizon phone Roms (official). And probably enabled by default.
What it does is call over your data connection (basically like VOIP) thus you are not really using voice and data simultaneously. You are making calls over LTE while still using LTE.
Try going out to an area where there is no LTE and you will find that you cannot use the Advanced Calling while on 3G. AC can also drop calls if you are in an area where LTE signal is weak, or you are moving around a large distance at a time (driving, etc.)
Its a compromise, but it certainly does not make up for the true capabilities of separate radios.
TheRealKingSen said:
Development for this phone it's pretty much non existent. I should have kept my nexus 6 or bought the newest note.
The second screen is a total waste at this point and a awful gimmick that managed to suck me in to buy the phone. ( that was one of the reasons I bought it).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Gimmick.... eh, maybe somewhat. "Eye of the beholder" I suppose. I think it would have made more sense on the bottom, but then it just would have been a longer screen.
The way I see it being useful is having it on the bottom where your nav bar would be, and allowing it to swipe and change to something else beside the nav buttons. And this would give you back the screen space that you are loosing to the nav bar. But like I said, then you just have a longer screen overall.
Custom Roms already have features like this, so it wont be anything revolutionary except to those that didn't know such a thing existed.
I think it will gain more traction when LG decides to let devs expand on the 2nd screens functions and 3rd party support.
But the phone is beautiful right? The Note used to be my favorite phone line, but now it is in the dumpster along with the whole Galaxy line-up. It lays right there next to the iFone slopped in decaying banana guts, just beneath the rotting apple.
I've had Samsung phones back to the Captivate, and I REALLY like what LG has put out with the V10. For me it isnt so much a drastic change in the GUI/Software, that's all really just a change in the "theme". GUI wise, it's a bit refreshing to get away from Sammy. Hardware wise, I LOVE what LG did with this device, it's far more solid feeling than my Note III. It has a great weight. It did take a little getting use to the button placement, but after a month or 2 it's really MUCH more intuitive than the placement on the side rails. I suppose the bump to a higher rated processor would've been really nice, but for my usage I see zero lag/performance issues.
So to carry over from the Root bounty thread, and I KNOW this will cause a fury of discussions on device lock down/Root/locked bootloaders
I've mentioned this before in other areas, and unfortunately, I believe this is the way things are going to continue to move.
One of the things I think we (here at XDA) fail to realize is the full scope of a devices impact in the market versus the size and scope of XDA's "footprint". Take the S6 and S6 edge as an example. Estimated combined device sales figures are somewhere around 45 million (as of June 2015). XDA's current membership is close to 7 million in total, for ALL devices. If you (generously imo) estimate that 10% of all XDA members own a S6 or S6 edge, that would account for around 1.6% of the devices total sales.
As someone said in the other thread, that "we" should boycott the carries that are locking devices down...... under 2% of total sales(again for the S6/S6 Edge as the example)? I think they would barely even notice
It just makes really good business sense to cater sales to large scale corporations who require a secure device. Which is why I think Big Red and Big Blue are locking the devices down. This model, is really just securing all of the business that they ripped away from Blackberry.
T-Mo, seems to be moving in a different direction by catering to the "younger generation"/family's, etc. Which doesn't really "require" a locked system.
I think that we are still very lucky to have some really talented folks who are still able to dig in and get things done. Unfortunately, I fear this is going to become more and more difficult to do
This is all "what I think", not "what I know" so take it with a grain of salt
@fire3element
Log into your Verizon account online and look on the right side of the page. You should see "Plan Management" in red letters. Right under that are 2 red buttons. Click on the [My Products and Apps].
On the next page under the Get Products tab, click on "Free Products". You should see HD Voice. If that is enabled already, that might be why you can do that.
You were right... It was enabled on my line. I have been able to do this since I had my Rezound though (also on my G2). I still have an UDP and could talk while tethering or surfing... don't know why (rooted, custom ROM???) anyway. glad it is still working and I'll try it if I get into a place without 4G and report back. anyway..
kaluna00 said:
You were right... It was enabled on my line. I have been able to do this since I had my Rezound though (also on my G2.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am pretty sure that the Rezound had separate data and voice radios. Let me clarify that. LTE radio is separate from the 3g/1x radio. The Note 3 and I believe up to the S5 have separated raidos. Think that changed with the Note 4 and other phone that came out around that time.
Note 3 had the 801 chipset, so most phones around that time had the same radio setup.
Snapdragon and other manufactures started merging to single radio setups to conserve power. The result is hindered operation, which is trying to be solved with software. Seems ok till you don't have a strong LTE signal or no LTE at all. The call dropping is also very aggravating. Specially those that use their devices for business... _________________yeah
Hate to admit it.. But guess that was just dumb luck. I normally have week LTE @my brothers house. I'll try it out next time I'm there.
kangi26 said:
I've mentioned this before in other areas, and unfortunately, I believe this is the way things are going to continue to move.
One of the things I think we (here at XDA) fail to realize is the full scope of a devices impact in the market versus the size and scope of XDA's "footprint".
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, you are absolutely right. We are of little to no significance to the phone makers, but there IS a large market to influence with Unlockable devices. As has been proven with Nexus, One+, and Motorola sales.
On the subject of T-mobile, I think the majority of their decision to allow Unlockable devices is purely grasping at straws for more customers. That and the fact they realize the % of users that are even interested in this is just a small portion of the customer base, thus fairly irrelevant vs. being something that impacts their bottom line.
BUT WHY WON'T GOOGLE FORCE ALL MANUFACTURES TO ALLOW BOOTLOADER UNLOCKS FOR USERS THAT CHOOSE TO DO SO?? I mean it is GOOGLE's OS. They could make this mandatory.
And implement it the same way the Nexus line does. You can unlock your Bootloader, but you are forced to wipe the device in the process. Yes there could be ways around this, but so exist exploits to gain Root on devices without wiping.
I think Motorola has a good policy on this. You are allowed to officially unlock your Bootloader upon agreement that Moto is not responsible for your security thereafter, and your warranty is now VOID.
I see little risk allowing this with all devices. And this is what Android SHOULD BE.
Users need to have the choice to do with their devices what they want. I have a feeling that there is a bigger player in this that is keeping the Gubermint from forcing manufactures to abide by this like they did to Verizon with the Carrier unlocking.
fire3element said:
Yes, you are absolutely right. We are of little to no significance to the phone makers, but there IS a large market to influence with Unlockable devices. As has been proven with Nexus, One+, and Motorola sales.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think that if we look a little at the device sales for last year,
Samsung sold 392 million
Lenovo, Motorola sold 84 million
LG sold 76 million (this would include Nexus)
and so on and so on(sales numbers get smaller). I think what were looking at is complete dominance in the handset market. Even Apple only sold 191 million, not even close to Sammy!
So to me, it's a "Do what you can to stay a viable device manufacturer", and to do that you have to get as many sales as you can. Being in IT in the Healthcare industry, I know what the company I work for requires. The more secure the manufacturer can make the device, the more likely they'll be in the running to get a sale/contract
fire3element said:
On the subject of T-mobile, I think the majority of their decision to allow Unlockable devices is purely grasping at straws for more customers. That and the fact they realize the % of users that are even interested in this is just a small portion of the customer base, thus fairly irrelevant vs. being something that impacts their bottom line.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think you're spot on here! I've thought that for a while too
fire3element said:
BUT WHY WON'T GOOGLE FORCE ALL MANUFACTURES TO ALLOW BOOTLOADER UNLOCKS FOR USERS THAT CHOOSE TO DO SO?? I mean it is GOOGLE's OS. They could make this mandatory.
And implement it the same way the Nexus line does.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think that it's because Google is in the market to sell it's OS, and if they can provide a product that will sell and ship on well over 500 million devices in 2014. That's what I call makin' money!
To be honest, I've always thought that the reason Google came out with the Nexus line was to maintain a platform that was "Pure Google" knowing full well that the rest of the industry was going to be changed. And keep it the way the first rolled out and hoped it would be. I think that's really cool
I enjoyed the dialog you two posted and agree with it all and the parts in the middle.
Thanks Kangi26 and Fire3Element, good stuff.
This is my first LG device and in happy that I purchased it. I've read all through the forum people are complaining about things that could've been avoided before you left the carrier store or where ever the device was purchased. When I went in I had three devices in mind, this device the note 5 and Samsung Galaxy S6. I tested all three over an hour and half time frame and ended up choosing the LG V10. I've even dropped it or its been knocked off my counter to tile flooring about 4 or 5 times with no issues. The only thing that I've found that I don't like is the LG keyboard so I switched to the Google keyboard... Problem solved. I have good battery life, so I'm happy
Overall, I am happy with this phone. Yes there are some nitpicks, but ALL devices have them.
The fact that I still get a removable battery and microSD card slot more than make up for the rest of the V10's issues.
But I will say I am still a Note fan. If the Note 5 had kept the removable battery and SD card, I'd most likely have bought the Note 5. My Note 3 has been an absolute beast, and still is to this day.
Unfortunately, the LTE reception issues have been getting so bad that I was forced to upgrade to a new phone. Otherwise, I would still be using my Note 3 until SamSmug got their $tuff together. If the V10 gets Root, I will be more than happy. Hope for a Bootloader unlock as well.
this thread is what we needed to vent and just bs. thanks bud.
fire3element said:
Overall, I am happy with this phone. Yes there are some nitpicks, but ALL devices have them.
The fact that I still get a removable battery and microSD card slot more than make up for the rest of the V10's issues.
But I will say I am still a Note fan. If the Note 5 had kept the removable battery and SD card, I'd most likely have bought the Note 5. My Note 3 has been an absolute beast, and still is to this day.
Unfortunately, the LTE reception issues have been getting so bad that I was forced to upgrade to a new phone. Otherwise, I would still be using my Note 3 until SamSmug got their $tuff together. If the V10 gets Root, I will be more than happy. Hope for a Bootloader unlock as well.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I really loved my Note 3 as well, and was really on the fence with the Note 5. I loved the size and how small the screen bezels are, but there were a couple things that I really didn't like at all. The removable battery/no SD slot wasn't the straw that broke the camels back, it was oddly the glass back. I had that thing in my hand at the AT&T store, and it was WAY too slick for me
And really when I got the V10 in my hands, it just felt so much better than even my Note 3, I bought it on the spot (I had been looking at the specs for a while too)
kangi26 said:
The removable battery/no SD slot wasn't the straw that broke the camels back, it was oddly the glass back. I had that thing in my hand at the AT&T store, and it was WAY too slick for me
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is where we differ the most then. I absolutely have to have a case on my phones due to working conditions. After having the Zero Lemon extended battery + case on several phones, there is no way I would ever sacrifice having a removable batt on my main device again. That is unless there are no longer any phones with removable batt.
I had contemplated building a design just like what Zero Lemon sells back when I had my LG VX8700 flip phone. A triple cell battery that covered the entire length of the phone just made sense to me. I pondered on it for a while, but did not see how I could get a manufacture to build them.
Then when I got my Droid X, I bought 3 batteries and attempted to build one. It seemed to work ok, but again my working conditions are harsh. I had to stop using it in fear that I would lose/drop them while working.
Now that there is a manufacture making these tri-cell batteries, I don't think I could ever live without one. Just so close to what I had envisioned years ago so I guess it means more to me than most.
Not everyone's idea of portable I suppose. But when you can tether for 48hrs straight and never have to worry that your battery is going to go dead... now THATS POWAR!!!
Prob could jump start your car off one of these. LoL
fire3element said:
But when you can tether for 48hrs straight and never have to worry that your battery is going to go dead... now THATS POWAR!!!
Prob could jump start your car off one of these. LoL
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
HAA!! That's a riot!!
You know, that gives me an idea! You could take a spare back for the V10, epoxy it to one of these, run a cable to the USB ports.
You could run FOREVER, and jump a car all at the same time!!
---------- Post added at 12:57 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:51 PM ----------
fire3element said:
This is where we differ the most then. I absolutely have to have a case on my phones due to working conditions. After having the Zero Lemon extended battery + case on several phones, there is no way I would ever sacrifice having a removable batt on my main device again.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
In the past few years, I've not been quite the power user I use to be, and also saw that the N5 had an option for larger memory (Not the BEST options, but I could've lived with it). And even my career changed too, so even a case isnt NEARLY as important as it use to be for me (I was in construction, so Otterbox was a MUST)
This very type of thread was created back when the device was launched here.
No need to start another.
Please carry on in the Lounge:good:
This thread has been closed
Thank you.

Categories

Resources