Database Info

[Q] Which ICS Rom is Leading?

Heya guys, developers, readers!!!
just want a vote from you all on the best ICS rom around for the Desire S

Muru11 said:
Heya guys, developers, readers!!!
just want a vote from you all on the best ICS rom around for the Desire S
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
In your opinion, exactly how many ICS roms are out there for the Desire S currently, which made you want to start a poll?
Let's also start a poll about "which is the worst, most useless thread on xda for the Desire S ?"
Sure winner, this one!

Just in case you didn't understand, there's only one...
Sent from my Desire S using xda premium

dan-fish said:
Just invade you didn't understand, there's only one...
Sent from my Desire S using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Exactly. Mystery solved!
Poll closed.

dude..i was just trying to find how many ICS roms are out there..to b frank..jst took another way of finding the answer..

For the Desire s is only one out there, the others are just ics themed gingerbread roms. Or did you mean device independent?

Muru11 said:
dude..i was just trying to find how many ICS roms are out there..to b frank..jst took another way of finding the answer..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Muru, i'm not trying to be rude or anything... just that it doesn't take much searching to understand that there is currently only one ROM in beta stage for the desire s and that is by superkid and mdeejay. Even that has not received an update in a week now... So a poll is definitely not warranted.
A simple question would have sufficed. But i, or far that matter any of the members here do not own xda so you are essentially free to ask what you want, and it's not my place to be moral police here... but it helps to keep the forum clean. That's why i had posted my comment. Please take it in the right spirit.
The forum is anyway cluttered with ICS question threads and the relevant ones get lost in all the cacophony. If you visit the ROM development thread, i'm sure it'll answer all your questions. Sorry for sounding unfriendly.
Peace.

your a ****, why do people do that, someone asks a question and you have to come back with a stupid answer and try to make them look small.

Because, as with just about every other forum on the Internet, there is free speech for all.
If somebody you had never met walked in to your place of work and asked "Let's take a poll - which is Rasher67's best wife" then you would react the same way (unless you are a Mormon or one of a select few Muslim groups who allow polygamy).
It was a stupid question and unnecessary - anybody who actually bothers reading the forums knows there is only one ICS ROM. Like so many people who drop by here they just ask a question without bothering to do any research first. I hung around here for over a year following advice I read before even signing up as there is so much advice available. As everyone who contributes here does it for free, they are bound to get annoyed at stupid questions from time to time - and annoyed at people like you who react the same way with only 4 posts to your name against people who have been here for a long time helping out and guiding those of us who don't know what we are doing.

rasher67 said:
your a ****, why do people do that, someone asks a question and you have to come back with a stupid answer and try to make them look small.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
More like moron asks moronic question, moron receives an answer that points out that the moron asking the question is an absolute moron. Moron proceeds to get butthert and replies with yet another moronic post.
Good work enig, +1 to you good sir.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda premium

More like moron asks moronic question, moron receives an answer that points out that the moron asking the question is an absolute moron. Moron proceeds to get butthert and replies with yet another moronic post
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So much more to the point than my reply

Simon.TS.HTC said:
So much more to the point than my reply
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just read your post and I've got to admit I did the same thing, nights of just reading reading reaaaaadddding. But also yeah my post is a vague summary of yours.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda premium

lol
kids!

so there isnt any Sensation port by proxuser????

lavier said:
so there isnt any Sensation port by proxuser????
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not yet, give him time to port it
Swyped from my desire s running damn sweet ice cream

rasher67 said:
lol
kids!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Troll
Sent from my HTC Desire S using xda premium

CM7/AOSP/ICS Discussion Thread.

Hey there everyone.
I'm from the Vibrant section, and I have some questions for you Galaxy S 4G users, please do know I searched around, but I thought it'd be best to have all the information anyone had on this particular topic all in one thread, so if anyone feels this is useless, feel free to delete it, I'm just trying to gain some knowledge. My girlfriend has a GS4G, and although the devs have done a great job modding Samsung's ROMs.. they don't compare to AOSP ROMs in my opinion.
Now, for the questions.
1. Why is it we can't get a working kernel to boot for the GS4G? (Someone please do explain in detail.)
2. How far has someone gone/gotten? (I know krylon handed the work to someone, but I don't think they've reported back?)
And please, no stupid answers. This is pure discussion. If a kernel dev is what we need, I could try to find one that's willing to work with me, but we'd need testers and such.

From what I heard and read around, you guys don't have any devs thats capable of doing that.

Surfacet said:
From what I heard and read around, you guys don't have any devs thats capable of doing that.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Lol
Sent from my SGH-T959V using xda premium

Surfacet said:
From what I heard and read around, you guys don't have any devs thats capable of doing that.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Capable of doing what, exactly?

Surfacet said:
From what I heard and read around, you guys don't have any devs thats capable of doing that.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
sgs2 fourm that way bra <<<

He said sgs4G
Sent from my SGH-T959V using XDA App

theexel said:
Hey there everyone.
I'm from the Vibrant section, and I have some questions for you Galaxy S 4G users, please do know I searched around, but I thought it'd be best to have all the information anyone had on this particular topic all in one thread, so if anyone feels this is useless, feel free to delete it, I'm just trying to gain some knowledge. My girlfriend has a GS4G, and although the devs have done a great job modding Samsung's ROMs.. they don't compare to AOSP ROMs in my opinion.
Now, for the questions.
1. Why is it we can't get a working kernel to boot for the GS4G? (Someone please do explain in detail.)
2. How far has someone gone/gotten? (I know krylon handed the work to someone, but I don't think they've reported back?)
And please, no stupid answers. This is pure discussion. If a kernel dev is what we need, I could try to find one that's willing to work with me, but we'd need testers and such.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
We are already working on this now. Read through my kernel thread. I have specific milestones to getting cm7 on our phone. I will not skip steps to get to cm7 sooner, compromising stability and functionality. If you want to help, please pm me.
Sent from my SGH-T959V using xda premium

bhundven said:
We are already working on this now. Read through my kernel thread. I have specific milestones to getting cm7 on our phone. I will not skip steps to get to cm7 sooner, compromising stability and functionality. If you want to help, please pm me.
Sent from my SGH-T959V using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yep, just checked your replies on Rootz Wiki, sorry, I didn't notice that earlier.
But like I said, this thread isn't meant to rush anyone or say someone can't do something, simply for discussion and information. Thanks for taking the time to reply.

For real this thread again!? I'm going to kill myself. Can't bear it.
Wait... better idea! Lets flame the OP!

Surfacet said:
From what I heard and read around, you guys don't have any devs thats capable of doing that.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
haha bh will make you eat your words

chris31jct said:
For real this thread again!? I'm going to kill myself. Can't bear it.
Wait... better idea! Lets flame the OP!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Alright, flame me.. because I'm definitely doing something wrong. I'm in no way demanding an ETA or even demanding anyone to start working on this, I simply wanted to group the information anyone knows so we could help each other.. you know.. kind of what a community does?

Guys, being cynical and trolling won't get us anywhere, and tell you the truth, it's childish and starting to bore.
The guy said he wanted a technical status summary and specifically said he wants to help.
In this case, i think we do need to maintain a thread of work chords and specify the barriers.
I thank every new dev with a will to help.
I think he deserves a different attitude than a noob, especially if we don't want to scare all devs from here.
That's my opinion anyway.
Sent from me

Surfacet said:
From what I heard and read around, you guys don't have any devs thats capable of doing that.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
hahah XXDDD

Sorry I didn't respond sooner. I had life happen
I see the usual knee scuffs and bruises hit this thread too. I really wish people wouldn't post if doesn't help move the thread forward.
--
Anyways... back on topic... :clears throat:
theexel said:
Yep, just checked your replies on Rootz Wiki, sorry, I didn't notice that earlier.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's ok. I've responded to a few of these threads. It's surprising how many people don't click 'search' and search for 'cm7' or 'cyanogenmod'. I also don't expect people to read both rootz and xda. So if you read my op on the kernel thread, I have a "Plans" section (on both forums!).
theexel said:
But like I said, this thread isn't meant to rush anyone or say someone can't do something, simply for discussion and information. Thanks for taking the time to reply.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you want to help, pm me.
Starting threads like these without searching only causes trolling and thread thrash (a lot of useless threads in the forum that blur the current state).
When you read what I'm saying, imagine a skinny geek with a deep helpful-relaxed voice... and a smile
A lot of people take me the wrong way. I'm a geek. I read and write code. I don't like wasting my time making you feel all warm and fuzzy.

itzik2sh said:
Guys, being cynical and trolling won't get us anywhere, and tell you the truth, it's childish and starting to bore.
The guy said he wanted a technical status summary and specifically said he wants to help.
In this case, i think we do need to maintain a thread of work chords and specify the barriers.
I thank every new dev with a will to help.
I think he deserves a different attitude than a noob, especially if we don't want to scare all devs from here.
That's my opinion anyway.
Sent from me
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This.
10 Char.

Lets keep this thread going I am also wondering how come there is so little development here but what developers we have are dedicated!

We have great developers that work hard on cm. The sgs 4g is the problem of not having it, freaking sammy with their experiments. i really enjoy their masterpieces(devs). Op you just have to have some patience, cm will come to us i believe in our devs.

theexel said:
I simply wanted to group the information anyone knows so we could help each other.. you know.. kind of what a community does?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Then why didn't you group all the information that is already available in the 50 other threads about CM7 into this one?
if you really wanted to do that, you could have made your OP a summary with bullet points of the details of everything that was already discussed, and then updated it with new information that comes along.
did you even search at all??

mike-y said:
Then why didn't you group all the information that is already available in the 50 other threads about CM7 into this one?
if you really wanted to do that, you could have made your OP a summary with bullet points of the details of everything that was already discussed, and then updated it with new information that comes along.
did you even search at all??
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Before flaming and insulting did you notice the date on the first post?
Personally I think the person that cast the raise dead spell should be getting beat with the flame bat.
I swear sometimes people are too eager to flame somebody. Its like they had a bad day come to xda to post behind a anonymous screen name and then walk away feeling better. But that is just me, Im sure my observation is wrong.

mike-y said:
Then why didn't you group all the information that is already available in the 50 other threads about CM7 into this one?
if you really wanted to do that, you could have made your OP a summary with bullet points of the details of everything that was already discussed, and then updated it with new information that comes along.
did you even search at all??
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
First of all, this has never been my primary device. I have never owned this device. I used to own the Samsung Vibrant, now I own a Nexus S. My girlfriend owned a Galaxy S 4G, and was using her phone to try to bring something new to you guys. (First ICS theme for this device ring a bell?) It's not my job to group 50 other threads about CM7 into this one. That's not what a community is. I am in no way a recognized developer, I know my stuff, but I have a long way to go. But it's people like you that make devs want to leave and stop posting their stuff. You swear people have time to do everything. And indeed that was my intention, but I wasn't going to pull useless information from other threads that members have posted, that are often inaccurate. This thread was mostly meant for devs, that could actually help out, and working together.
In other news, I finally have some time to mess around with stuff, might look into more themes or something, but I lack a device to work on, so I guess if some people would like to help (testing, etc.) I'd be glad to push things out from time to time.

[Q] Is there a OC Kernel yet based on the new ICS Leaks ?

As the thread title asks....
Sent from my ICS Skyrocket using Tapatalk 2

LordGeek said:
As the thread title asks....
Sent from my ICS Skyrocket using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No sir

sigh**

Not until the kernel source in released or leaked.

scott14719 said:
Not until the kernel source in released or leaked.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's what I thought .. bummer
Has anyone reached out to DesignGears to see if its possible to get .. since he is the main GOD here for our upcoming ICS release leaks.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I727 using Tapatalk 2

LordGeek said:
That's what I thought .. bummer
Has anyone reached out to DesignGears to see if its possible to get .. since he is the main GOD here for our upcoming ICS release leaks.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I727 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm pretty sure he posts them as he gets them. I'm just thankful him and his leak source are working hard to get the leaks to us.

scott14719 said:
I'm pretty sure he posts them as he gets them. I'm just thankful him and his leak source are working hard to get the leaks to us.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah, I'm sure if he had kernel source he would have posted it

I gotta be honest though, if a noob had posted this question he would have for roasted... I believe u got away with it because you've been around longer than all of us. Did u search before hand my friend?

icenight89 said:
I gotta be honest though, if a noob had posted this question he would have for roasted... I believe u got away with it because you've been around longer than all of us. Did u search before hand my friend?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
And you wanted me to search for what ? "ICS" "kernel" "OC" .. yeah .. good luck with that.
And.. yes, no one has asked here in our threads being General or Q&A about OC'ing an ICS kernel .. what I did not know though, was the fact that you need a full kernel source in order to accomplish this. So, my question was answered .. thank you.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I727 using Tapatalk 2

I dont blame u. This forum is so polluted with almost identical threads in every section
Lol search may be overwhelming

I disagree. We can't have senior members telling all the new users to search, and then because one can't be bothered to search Google for "skyrocket overclock kernel ics" we provide direct answers. Can't be using a double standard, its not fair.

icenight89 said:
I disagree. We can't have senior members telling all the new users to search, and then because one can't be bothered to search Google for "skyrocket overclock kernel ics" we provide direct answers. Can't be using a double standard, its not fair.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
IceNight89 .. took your advise .. searched Google for "skyrocket overclock kernel ics" .. as you stated .. YEAH // like I said before, good luck with that !!!

that would indicate to me that there is no such thing at present

icenight89 said:
that would indicate to me that there is no such thing at present
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
1.3m results = nothing?
Also, when asking something like this, Google is great for finding a positive, but a negative (I.e. there is no OC kernal) is exceptionally hard to figure out without checking every search result.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I727 using Tapatalk 2

I answered the OPs question (the best I could) because:
A. The question actually appears in the Q&A section where such generalized questions belong. And...
B. The "header" of the thread clearly stated what the OP wanted to know. This will help in the future when others need to search for the information. This thread will most definately appear in a thread search for ICS Kernel OC, when other threads that this has been discussed in may not readily appear to.
So, Yes, it has been discussed, but by answering the question in this thread it (hopefully) will help keep it from being asked again and again and again... At least now there isn't an excuse about the info not coming up in a search.

First of all relax and clear your minds.
There has been a lot of flaming lately, which is definetively a bigger issue than nonsense threads opened up in our forums. So please, I beg you, if you have nothing productive to say, just dont say it and stay out of trouble.
It is a fair question, ok, but this thread (like many I have seen before) could easily become a sticky about "ICS Kernels for the Skyrocket" or something like that. Sadly, it will never reach that status, because, instead of the user having his question asked, and other members contribute with positive and constructive comments (<-----forum), it turned out a thread where it serves to critize each other.
Please think about the above before opening a new thread (your question has been probably asked and besides the search button there is reading, and reading, and even more reading) and replying to that new thread (replies insulting other users are even more useless than a thread with an already answered question).
Have a nice day.

[Q] Galaxy s 4G ICS

Do you think we will ever have ICS on the galaxy s 4g? I mean we saw it on G1, and lots of unsupported phones, and on the galaxy s 1 which doesn't support ICS officially. What is the problem stopping the development ?

ismailham said:
Do you think we will ever have ICS on the galaxy s 4g? I mean we saw it on G1, and lots of unsupported phones, and on the galaxy s 1 which doesn't support ICS officially. What is the problem stopping the development ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Threads like this.
Also, the other phones have like a billion and one kernel devs. Not to mention our phone is Sammy's black sheep, by that I mean this phone is way different from other sgs.
Lastly, we have at least 3 other ICS threads why not ask there?
sent from my batcave

ismailham said:
Do you think we will ever have ICS on the galaxy s 4g? I mean we saw it on G1, and lots of unsupported phones, and on the galaxy s 1 which doesn't support ICS officially. What is the problem stopping the development ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You haven't downloaded the source code and tried to help us port it. We need your help.

I'm trying really hard to remain "civil".....really I am

FBis251 said:
You haven't downloaded the source code and tried to help us port it. We need your help.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I like that answer lol
Sent from my SGH-T959V using XDA

Why does everybody get annoyed when a regular person just wants to know whats wrong out of curiosity? I don't want any ROM or anything I just wanted a technical answer. is the problem the source code being unreleased? will the company ever release it?
I wish I could help, I would really love to. Its like a dream or long term goal to be a dev, study programming languages etc... but that requires lots of time and I'm just waiting a bit as i'm not sure where to start.
I am sorry for any misunderstanding as I know Devs already have rough days and nights with developing and improving. I wasn't "Demanding" or "pushing" as i'm not that person. I am just seeking knowledge, and if the Q&A section isn't the right place to search for Knowledge then I don't know where is.

The problem isn't with you so much as it is with the million dollar question that's been asked and answered a million times....its the question all devs cringe over when they see it repeated time n time again.
Put yourself in their shoes for a minute.....they put out as much as they can with what they can and people keep popping up this same question like they just aren't happy with what they are getting

To answer your question, and anybody else that wants to ask,
It is being worked on. We cannot get ICS to boot due to coding and kernel issues. I semi successfully ported an ICS ROM, but due to all the mods and changes, it felt empty. So we went back to the drawing board and started over. Since we don't have source code, it makes things much more difficult. Be patient. And for the record, the first place to search for knowledge is Google. Fb is right though. We do need more help. The more people we have working on this, the better our chances are. Learn how to compile kernel and ROM from source. Learn scripting. And learn how to Google...
Sent from my SGH-T959V using XDA

Shortbus-Driver said:
The problem isn't with you so much as it is with the million dollar question that's been asked and answered a million times....its the question all devs cringe over when they see it repeated time n time again.
Put yourself in their shoes for a minute.....they put out as much as they can with what they can and people keep popping up this same question like they just aren't happy with what they are getting
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I do understand what you mean, and I already put myself in the dev's shoes and I really admire their work, all of it. But I went through all the threads regarding ICS, and sadly their aim is to push , demand and request stuff from devs as if devs don't have enough on their minds already, and that is really annoying and disrespectful. But not all people are like that. I don't have any requests( I have a Nexus S with ICS, SGS 4g CM7.2) I am just seeking knowledge.
I am really grateful for what each and every DEV offers as it is from their personal and free time. Sorry for any misunderstanding

thomas.raines said:
To answer your question, and anybody else that wants to ask,
It is being worked on. We cannot get ICS to boot due to coding and kernel issues. I semi successfully ported an ICS ROM, but due to all the mods and changes, it felt empty. So we went back to the drawing board and started over. Since we don't have source code, it makes things much more difficult. Be patient. And for the record, the first place to search for knowledge is Google. Fb is right though. We do need more help. The more people we have working on this, the better our chances are. Learn how to compile kernel and ROM from source. Learn scripting. And learn how to Google...
Sent from my SGH-T959V using XDA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I really thank you for your answer sir. You have helped me a lot, I hope I can lend a hand in any way possible. I will read about kernel/rom compiling. I googled many stuff about a month ago but its so vast and big I sort of got lost and stopped.
Thank you...
Sorry for double posting...

http://forum.xda-developers.com/wiki/Samsung_Galaxy_S/SGH-T959V

erikmm said:
Also, the other phones have like a billion and one kernel devs. Not to mention our phone is Sammy's black sheep, by that I mean this phone is way different from other sgs.
)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What Thomas posted is true but the main reason we dont have a working ICS port is this statement above.
The op makes a good point, this is the Q&A section. Even tho there are many threads asking this same question most of them have ended up in bashing with nerf bats or a mod locking because of insults. Ive read the other threads, but most people will stop reading when the conversation turns sour. You might actually read the other posts but your mind shuts it down. So a informative post will slip in and you wont catch it.
The biggest problem with threads that ask this question is assumptions. When people stop assuming and start to understand the person asking the question things get resolved.

thomas.raines said:
To answer your question, and anybody else that wants to ask,
It is being worked on. We cannot get ICS to boot due to coding and kernel issues. I semi successfully ported an ICS ROM, but due to all the mods and changes, it felt empty. So we went back to the drawing board and started over. Since we don't have source code, it makes things much more difficult. Be patient. And for the record, the first place to search for knowledge is Google. Fb is right though. We do need more help. The more people we have working on this, the better our chances are. Learn how to compile kernel and ROM from source. Learn scripting. And learn how to Google...
Sent from my SGH-T959V using XDA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'd like to help, how would I go about doing that?

brandonc0526 said:
I'd like to help, how would I go about doing that?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
jump on irc and go to the teamacid channel this evening...
Sent from my SGH-T959V using XDA

thomas.raines said:
jump on irc and go to the teamacid channel this evening...
Sent from my SGH-T959V using XDA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Joined too late man. Tried to take a break at work but I couldnt
---------- Post added at 02:01 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:20 AM ----------
brandonc0526 said:
Joined too late man. Tried to take a break at work but I couldnt
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Send me a PM when you guys get on

This would be sweet! ***NVM

I think that it would be cool if we had a poll thread with every rom listed so we can have an idea of the most popular Roms. I know when I am new to a phone I want to know the top rated roms to save time flashing. What do you guys think? Just a poll with every Rom and just let people vote on their favorites.
EDIT**** this is NOT for me I am extremely satisfied with Viper and JellyBam and I don't need this, It was just to help other but it looks like no one wants to and wants everyone to find it out on their own so i retract this idea

Re: This would be sweet!
joshuadjohnson22 said:
I think that it would be cool if we had a poll thread with every rom listed so we can have an idea of the most popular Roms. I know when I am new to a phone I want to know the top rated roms to save time flashing. What do you guys think? Just a poll with every Rom and just let people vote on their favorites.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No.

RollTribe said:
No.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
why wouldn't you like it?

Re: This would be sweet!
We sort of all ready got it, the thread read count. If it's popular people are reading about it.
Screwed by Google. Canceled ICS upgrade on my Moto Photon. No Wow for us.

RollTribe said:
No.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
rbeavers said:
We sort of all ready got it, the thread read count. If it's popular people are reading about it.
Screwed by Google. Canceled ICS upgrade on my Moto Photon. No Wow for us.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
not always, just means that the thread got people's attention. I view a lot of Rom's thread a lot but I haven't downloaded it just read what people were saying

Re: This would be sweet!
Just because there's a thing on XDA about not having best ROM threads and this would be like the ultimate best ROM thread. It would be against the rules, that's why I said what I did.

been done before anyways and the thread got buried.
*Poll* 4.0.4 Sense Roms

Re: This would be sweet!
So you want a poll to show you what ROMs people are running so you can run the ROM everyone is? Wanna be with all the cool kids I guess?
You know how everyone else did it? They tried them all, and I suggest you do the same
Sent from my One X using Tapatalk 2

RollTribe said:
Just because there's a thing on XDA about not having best ROM threads and this would be like the ultimate best ROM thread. It would be against the rules, that's why I said what I did.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
lol ok if you only said that to begin with it would have been resolved. Its ok, guess noobs have to find out the hard way

superchilpil said:
So you want a poll to show you what ROMs people are running so you can run the ROM everyone is? Wanna be with all the cool kids I guess?
You know how everyone else did it? They tried them all, and I suggest you do the same
Sent from my One X using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
it is not for me... I have tried all the main ones, its for new people. I don't care either way I just thought it would be nice if you just got your phone. But if you didn't read my post I guess you didn't see that
I love my Viper, or for a change up I got Jellybam and I couldn't be happier

you Need to find the best ROM for you self.
when the ROM makes you happy, then it's the best for you.

Ghostrider said:
you Need to find the best ROM for you self.
when the ROM makes you happy, then it's the best for you.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
man... does anyone read my post before commenting I already have found the best, its for others. I love Viper and I am very satisfied.

adding a poll of all active roms would help bring light to some under rated roms as long as it wasn't perceived as a best rom poll which would be very difficult as it most likely would turn into one.

It's against the rules, and there are good reasons why that is the case.
Such threads often lead to debates about "best roms," which creates unnecessary drama.
They also annoy the devs, and can lead to hurt feelings.
The devs almost unanimously do not like them, and if you haven't gathered from the name of this site, this is a developer forum.
This thread will be locked like the 500 others like it before this.

Ghostrider said:
you Need to find the best ROM for you self.
when the ROM makes you happy, then it's the best for you.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
iElvis said:
It's against the rules, and there are good reasons why that is the case.
Such threads often lead to debates about "best roms," which creates unnecessary drama.
They also annoy the devs, and can lead to hurt feelings.
The devs almost unanimously do not like them, and if you haven't gathered from the name of this site, this is a developer forum.
This thread will be locked like the 500 others like it before this.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
well I now know that so this one can be locked as well at least it solved my curiosity

joshuadjohnson22 said:
it is not for me... I have tried all the main ones, its for new people. I don't care either way I just thought it would be nice if you just got your phone. But if you didn't read my post I guess you didn't see that
I love my Viper, or for a change up I got Jellybam and I couldn't be happier
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Who cares who its for? Its still against the rules.
Sent from my Nexus 4

Joshua I dint think you're getting the main reason of the rule..it all kinda comes down to common courtesy..the devs aren't paid to dev nor do they have to share their work with us... You as the user can at the least say thanks to them..best Rom or most popular threads has a chance of putting certain rom devs down...each rom is great I've tried almost every one in this forum

a box of kittens said:
Joshua I dint think you're getting the main reason of the rule..it all kinda comes down to common courtesy..the devs aren't paid to dev nor do they have to share their work with us... You as the user can at the least say thanks to them..best Rom or most popular threads has a chance of putting certain rom devs down...each rom is great I've tried almost every one in this forum
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No i understand... We have the best devs and I don't want to cause anything that would hurt or start fights. I'm perfectly fine with it. I never thought of that before

joshuadjohnson22 said:
No i understand... We have the best devs and I don't want to cause anything that would hurt or start fights. I'm perfectly fine with it. I never thought of that before
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Okay guys, he got the message!

Okay then ......
Closed
XDA Moderator