[suggestion]check list of ROM before release - myTouch 3G, Magic Android Development

This is not direct develop but I still would like to post this thread here.
Can we develop a check list for the ROM before releasing?
Everybody can help to create a comprehensive(at least rather comprehensive) so that we can check the rom thoroughly and are not going to have some many bugs in the future?

A ROM would never be released publically then. Everyone is basically a beta tester. A ROM won't improve if only 1 or 2 ppl test it.

eViL D: said:
A ROM would never be released publically then. Everyone is basically a beta tester. A ROM won't improve if only 1 or 2 ppl test it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'll agree with that.
Some Functions I can't Test Due to Time. It's easier to release it into the wild and get Feedback.

eugene373 said:
I'll agree with that.
Some Functions I can't Test Due to Time. It's easier to release it into the wild and get Feedback.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
OK, fair enough, time is another constrain during the development work.

Related

HTC Soak testing ICS for Thunderbolt now!!

Saw this wonderful anouncement,
http://phandroid.com/2012/03/02/htc...sting-can-taste-that-sweet-ice-cream-already/
Maybe a leak is on it's way?
Is there a way to sign up for these kind of things? or is it random?
Randomhero180 said:
Is there a way to sign up for these kind of things? or is it random?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If there was, it would be with HTC, not Verizon. Remember this is an HTC soak test (if it is indeed legit) and NOT Verizon, so don't get your hopes up for the update this soon.
Since there are only ten devices going out, what do you think the chance is that someone who wants to upload it here will get one?
Sent from my ADR6400L using XDA
gammaxgoblin said:
Since there are only ten devices going out, what do you think the chance is that someone who wants to upload it here will get one?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The chance is around zero or less. Anyone who gets one of the phones will surely have to sign a NDA and I'll bet it'll be an NDA with teeth in it....
Question
I had a quick question what exactly does a soak test imply? I just see that term around and wondered what it meant. Thanks
HTC sends a preview, kind of a rough draft to a few people for feedback. This info helps them work out kinks and glitches before releasing to the masses. Hopefully someone that gets to do this testing will be kind enough to share with us.
Posted from my 1.34ghz, Infected, Themed Out, Lightningbolt.
Don't count on it. Pretty sure there are strict rules for being a tester
Sent from my ADR6400L using xda premium
Yea, I'm sure. No reason a man can't dream though
Posted from my 1.34ghz, Infected, Themed Out, Lightningbolt.
If you could test what would you like to test for? It not the easiest thing in the world to do and takes a lot of your time. You have to report in with your testing and write up reports about the testing.
NorthlandAZ said:
If you could test what would you like to test for? It not the easiest thing in the world to do and takes a lot of your time. You have to report in with your testing and write up reports about the testing.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I wouldnt do it because you would likely not be able to be rooted
Rooting a phone that's being tested would sort of defeat the purpose right?
Here, sir, please root our test build and let us know the flaws...
Come on, man.
Sent from my ADR6400L using xda premium
the reason you want to test is so you can leak the rom
jellydroid13 said:
the reason you want to test is so you can leak the rom
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I suspect testers will have to sign an NDA. Since there's so few it should be easy to find anyone who leaks the ROM.
None the less, I sure hope someone does leak it SOON!
... maybe just leak a couple drivers, kernel and radio
xs11e said:
I suspect testers will have to sign an NDA. Since there's so few it should be easy to find anyone who leaks the ROM.
None the less, I sure hope someone does leak it SOON!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I dont think so, we had same issue with Sensation and Elevate program, but as soon as rom landed on HTC servers, xda community was able to grab rom and enjoy ... I think same thing will happen for Thunderbolt..... finger crossed

[Q] Unfinished ROM's

Just curious, but...
It seems like, as of late, someone starts to build a new ROM, then stops updating after 2 or 3 rc's, leaving the ROM unfinished. I understand the ROMs are created in someone's spare time, but why start a ROM if you never intend to finish it? Why not finish it before you start something else, or just delete the development thread so we're not sitting here waiting for the next release that never seems to come? No offense to anyone, just curious.
Roms are never really finished you can always add new functions
, themes etc.
Sent from my BlackBerry Runtime for Android Apps using XDA App
PhantomSectre said:
Just curious, but...
It seems like, as of late, someone starts to build a new ROM, then stops updating after 2 or 3 rc's, leaving the ROM unfinished. I understand the ROMs are created in someone's spare time, but why start a ROM if you never intend to finish it? Why not finish it before you start something else, or just delete the development thread so we're not sitting here waiting for the next release that never seems to come? No offense to anyone, just curious.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Quit flashing ROMs since you'll never have a 100% guarantee that someone will finish a ROM. Go back to stock GB which has a bad modem and reboot problems. Oh wait, Samsung didn't exactly give you a good ROM either.
Why is it that if the ROM never gets a final version its assumed its unfinished? The unfinished ROMs, ics mutt, cm7, miui, are all still works in progress (well maybe not miui, not sure of it's future). Seems to me everything else is fully functional and doesn't require anything else.
All the the most recent ones, unnamed, vb, icbinb, scom, these are problem free. Just find the right kernel and modem for your phone and they qualify as finished.
Sent from my SGH-T959V using xda premium
Im still updating mine but this post makes me not want to
And like the post above me said the title doesnt have to be final for it to be final. Also, the dev can choose to start a new rom bc people want the new mod they are bringing to it along with a new theme and tweaks.
So thank you devs for the many roms you guys release.
if you ain't first you're last
I think you should aim to non beta ROMs. At least this way you know you get a fully functional ROM. Regarding Final version, forget about it. Won't happen, won't be announced.
Sent from my SGH-T959V using XDA
itzik2sh said:
I think you should aim to non beta ROMs. At least this way you know you get a fully functional ROM. Regarding Final version, forget about it. Won't happen, won't be announced.
Sent from my SGH-T959V using XDA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Final version of which are u sure won't be announced?
if you ain't first you're last
most developers acknowledge that there are going to be some dev cycles involved in their releases. I guess some non-developers either don't realize that or haven't picked up on that yet.
Nothing's perfect so take it as it is and don't complain, and if it has a "final" tag on it, it just means the developer is done working on it. Beggars can't be choosers, and choosers can download the source and modify it themselves (or fsck it up even more ).
Quit your belly aching dude, instead, a little appreciation would be a welcome change. We have so many different options to choose from. And every time my noob ass bricks my phone these guys have a post on how to fix it. Fb is right, go back to stock if it bothers you so much, but I'll stick with my 2 day battery life.
side note: on dictionary. com the word of the day is ungrateful turdlicker.
Sent from my SGH-T959V using xda premium
I think that people get desperate when devs release and early version of a rom instead of an almost final. I think it would be best to release the "final" version to public and since there are many devs with the phone and so many wise users that know how to test and report correctly. In my humble opinion, a dev should pick a group of testers, silently and then release a "final" that probably would have 0 to very few changes. That way devs don't get pissed when people ask same questions and bring up many problems.
I have no problem testing or trying alpha, beta, charlie, delta......... zeta releases, but my concern is with devs releasing lots of projects and getting mad by people asking how to this and how to that. Yeah, read... blablabla yadda yadda... I know no one is in the obligation of doing nothing, either flash or develop or answer questions or help. Thing is that this is a community very diverse and noobs are going to be noobs, haters gonna hate and passive people will be passive...
No need to flame the OP. I think it's a good question, tho.
considering i no longer have a sgs4g it would be hard to update it. The rom itself is fine.. Don't see an issue. If you don't like the theme change it. If you don't like the rom learn how to make your own.
chris31jct said:
I think that people get desperate when devs release and early version of a rom instead of an almost final. I think it would be best to release the "final" version to public and since there are many devs with the phone and so many wise users that know how to test and report correctly. In my humble opinion, a dev should pick a group of testers, silently and then release a "final" that probably would have 0 to very few changes. That way devs don't get pissed when people ask same questions and bring up many problems.
I have no problem testing or trying alpha, beta, charlie, delta......... zeta releases, but my concern is with devs releasing lots of projects and getting mad by people asking how to this and how to that. Yeah, read... blablabla yadda yadda... I know no one is in the obligation of doing nothing, either flash or develop or answer questions or help. Thing is that this is a community very diverse and noobs are going to be noobs, haters gonna hate and passive people will be passive...
No need to flame the OP. I think it's a good question, tho.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
When a rom is release an OP comes with it where bugs known are said from the get go. As for bug reported devs are fine with them as long as logs are attached and they are real bugs and not just "I want a better theme" or "how do I install this rom".
As for flaming, it's actually a rule that we can't do this to one another on xda.
if you ain't first you're last
With posts like this, why even try?
Sent from my SGH-I897 using XDA
thomas.raines said:
With posts like this, why even try?
Sent from my SGH-I897 using XDA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yup I don't think people appreciate the time put in. And the reason we get early releases is because we all want something new, and we can help bug test. But eh.
if you ain't first you're last
Eric, what if we say "no offense " before we flame someone... Then it's cool right?
Sent from my SGH-T959V using xda premium
jwalters1123 said:
Eric, what if we say "no offense " before we flame someone... Then it's cool right?
Sent from my SGH-T959V using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nope, if you read my posts I'm not flaming the guy but I am sharing my view on this. I haven't insulted the OP but like him shared my view on why roms get released early and why we don't get final builds.
if you ain't first you're last
Oh
Sent from my SGH-T959V using xda premium
jwalters1123 said:
Oh
Sent from my SGH-T959V using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Lmao now idk if you're trying to imply something on me or you're being genuine lol
But yea we all have our opinions but this kind of thread discourages devs and before we get a troll saying that's a lie just look up and you'll see thomas(a dev) doensnt like this.
if you ain't first you're last
Don't get me wrong. I appreciate all dev work even if it's "unfinished" or w/e. Is just that this kind of discussion has been around since the beginning and people knew this phone ain't easy. Not trying to discourage any further development.
Lol, I'm just being extremely sarcastic, dude should try fb's vb by raver, that thing is tits!
Sent from my SGH-T959V using xda premium

[APP] 6thGear-RomControl [v3.0]

Nothing here
:silly:
Sent from my mido using XDA Labs
i actually dunno where to start from..
first of all you suppose we left the project?
about your comits i have a simple question: why did you set the target sdk to higher vs?
and i am not really sure you know why it was set like that.. if you just took the time to read the original tread instead of just forking a repo, click OK on update message when prompted and call it v3, maybe you would know.. btw! yeah HUGE update, it really deserves a vs naming upgrade..
Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk
Wuby986 said:
i actually dunno where to start from..
first of all you suppose we left the project?
about your comits i have a simple question: why did you set the target sdk to higher vs?
and i am not really sure you know why it was set like that.. if you just took the time to read the original tread instead of just forking a repo, click OK on update message when prompted and call it v3, maybe you would know.. btw! yeah HUGE update, it really deserves a vs naming upgrade..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi there
I just did one commit for now, gradle deps update, but i intend to do some optimizations with the current code plus some redesigning etc. I don't have time to work on it now, as I have some exams and yes I agree that naming it v3 would be too unreasonable, I'll change that. After exams, I'll probably start working on it ;-;
I set it to higher cause many old(lp/mm) roms that use rom control has stopped development, and it's mostly newer roms that are based on nougat that are constantly pushing out new updates, hence I targeted 25.
I know you guys left the project and thus i wanted to continue with some minor updates
ala_mo said:
Hi there
I just did one commit for now, gradle deps update, but i intend to do some optimizations with the current code plus some redesigning etc. I don't have time to work on it now, as I have some exams and yes I agree that naming it v3 would be too unreasonable, I'll change that. After exams, I'll probably start working on it ;-;
I set it to higher cause many old(lp/mm) roms that use rom control has stopped development, and it's mostly newer roms that are based on nougat that are constantly pushing out new updates, hence I targeted 25.
I know you guys left the project and thus i wanted to continue with some minor updates
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The project is still ongoing.
Hwile it's true that it's all under gpl, and you're free to use whole or parts of it as you please, you cannot make v3.0 of the original project. It just doesn't work like this. You're not part of the team. You want to have your own project, you're welcome to the code or parts of it. But you don't get to create the new version of an existing project without at least consulting with us first. The project is still ongoing. The latest version is v2.1. What you did here is ridiculous at the very least.
We haven't stopped the project. The development on it continuous. And BTW setting the target sdk to nougat will render it unusable as data app. And if you were an Android developer, you would understand that. It's well explained on our original thread, where btw, the development continues.
So yeah... Have a great day.
Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk
daxgirl said:
The project is still ongoing.
Hwile it's true that it's all under gpl, and you're free to use whole or parts of it as you please, you cannot make v3.0 of the original project. It just doesn't work like this. You're not part of the team. You want to have your own project, you're welcome to the code or parts of it. But you don't get to create the new version of an existing project without at least consulting with us first. The project is still ongoing. The latest version is v2.1. What you did here is ridiculous at the very least.
We haven't stopped the project. The development on it continuous. And BTW setting the target sdk to nougat will render it unusable as data app. And if you were an Android developer, you would understand that. It's well explained on our original thread, where btw, the development continues.
So yeah... Have a great day.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah got it. I thought the development is stopped for good, thats why I wanted to (unofficially)continue it. I'll ask a mod to close this thread now ;-;
Sorry for the inconvenience caused
ala_mo said:
Yeah got it. I thought the development is stopped for good, thats why I wanted to (unofficially)continue it. I'll ask a mod to close this thread now ;-;
Sorry for the inconvenience caused
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not close. Remove. Permanently. I got too many pm about it already. Thank you.
Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk
daxgirl said:
Not close. Remove. Permanently. I got too many pm about it already. Thank you.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wait you can delete a thread?
I deleted the OP too
Thread closed per OP request. As a rule, we don't delete threads (Le Goog no likey!), but the OP has been deleted and the thread closed, so that should suffice. If you have any questions or concerns, please feel free to send me a PM.
Thanks,
coal686
Senior Moderator

Mate 9 Oreo EMUI 8 beta tester

Currently selected as one of the USA beta tester but no one in the Slack chat room is a Huawei developer or gainfully trying to capture/resolve the problems. Any senior member knows what's going on with this beta test? So far it's been a joke!
Huawei is on holiday.
Thanks. For how long?
Beta Test
Matrix003 said:
Currently selected as one of the USA beta tester but no one in the Slack chat room is a Huawei developer or gainfully trying to capture/resolve the problems. Any senior member knows what's going on with this beta test? So far it's been a joke!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nobody on XDA is an official Huawei developer, bug reports for the beta test are supposed to be reported to them through the beta test app that you should have installed on your device, not here on XDA. That's the whole idea of being a beta tester, find bugs and report them to Huawei. If that's not your cup of tea then leave the program and roll back to Nouget and wait on the official release
...
revjamescarver said:
Nobody on XDA is an official Huawei developer, bug reports for the beta test are supposed to be reported to them through the beta test app that you should have installed on your device, not here on XDA. That's the whole idea of being a beta tester, find bugs and report them to Huawei. If that's not your cup of tea then leave the program and roll back to Nouget and wait on the official release
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Rev did you read my comments? No one from Huawei is responding to the bugs being reported. Maybe your cup of tea isn't responding to questions.
P51 answered my question. No need for your comments.
Rudeness
Matrix003 said:
Rev did you read my comments? No one from Huawei is responding to the bugs being reported. Maybe your cup of tea isn't responding to questions.
P51 answered my question. No need for your comments.[/QUOTE
Yeah i read the ONE comment you had posted, and I have you an answer, Those folks in China don't celebrate Thanksgiving, and they're not on holiday, they are just a little slow and sometimes don't respond at all (a lot of times they do just that). All they want is for people to report bugs with as much detail as you can give them.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
revjamescarver said:
Matrix003 said:
Rev did you read my comments? No one from Huawei is responding to the bugs being reported. Maybe your cup of tea isn't responding to questions.
P51 answered my question. No need for your comments.[/QUOTE
Yeah i read the ONE comment you had posted, and I have you an answer, Those folks in China don't celebrate Thanksgiving, and they're not on holiday, they are just a little slow and sometimes don't respond at all (a lot of times they do just that). All they want is for people to report bugs with as much detail as you can give them.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok, I agree and believe our moderator may have taken a few days off but didn't let us know. I recorded a few videos of the bugs. When he returns hopefully will get some closure. Sick at home today and was getting a little antsy.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Glad to hear it
Matrix003 said:
revjamescarver said:
Ok, I agree and believe our moderator may have taken a few days off but didn't let us know. I recorded a few videos of the bugs. When he returns hopefully will get some closure. Sick at home today and was getting a little antsy.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That is understandable, sorry if I sounded a little gruff in my response to your question, some of these threads are flooded with people that just don't get it, glad you could document some of the bugs. I'm running MHA-L29 8.0.0.321 (C567) which I presume is the same build you are a beta tester for, I haven't really noticed any "bugs" of any consequence. There are a few things that aren't working properly, like pip (doesn't work under EMUI, but does under my pixel 2 launcher I have installed), but it's pretty much useless anyway. Have you had any major issues with the Oreo build you are running as far as major functions go? I installed it mainly as I wanted the security update and the 4.4 kernel (a lot of code changes between 4.2 and 4.4)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse

Pixel Experience!!!! Please someone continue the project!

This has been my daily driver from when it started... Now seeing the that Pixel Experience will no longer receive any update! It feels so sad now! Please.... Someone keep it alive!
Keep patience, and donate some value to Henrique, to support RN5Pro support.
jimmy123322 said:
Keep patience, and donate some value to Henrique, to support RN5Pro support.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Honestly, i dont think someone should. This community doesnt deserve this lol. Why would someone spend their time, only to get bothered with nonsense questions, requests, demands all the time. Get blamed for bugs, which arent even rom fault, never get any logs etc etc.. I could continue this list on and on and on. 80% of users here are ungrateful noobs that cant even read OP or last 3 posts, not even talking about using search function. So yeah, i dont wish that to any dev. Thats all my for my rant.
Plekst said:
Honestly, i dont think someone should. This community doesnt deserve this lol. Why would someone spend their time, only to get bothered with nonsense questions, requests, demands all the time. Get blamed for bugs, which arent even rom fault, never get any logs etc etc.. I could continue this list on and on and on. 80% of users here are ungrateful noobs that cant even read OP or last 3 posts, not even talking about using search function. So yeah, i dont wish that to any dev. Thats all my for my rant.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You said it: 80% are ungrateful. That means that 20% correctly thank the work of @jhenrique09 . Please dev, continue your great work for that 20% of people in this community.
Just to say i will greatly miss this rom too...
Plekst said:
Honestly, i dont think someone should. This community doesnt deserve this lol. Why would someone spend their time, only to get bothered with nonsense questions, requests, demands all the time. Get blamed for bugs, which arent even rom fault, never get any logs etc etc.. I could continue this list on and on and on. 80% of users here are ungrateful noobs that cant even read OP or last 3 posts, not even talking about using search function. So yeah, i dont wish that to any dev. Thats all my for my rant.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree with you too! They always complain about useless stuff! But please!!! It's absurd but I've fallen in love with Pixel Experience! And if there's no further update.... I don't think I'll switch to any other rom either! PE is just sooo awesome! And ...again I understand what you say, but believe me.... There are some who genuinely appreciate all Devs works! And love to use their products! Anyways... I still hope a resurrection of PE someday ?
kamnikaz said:
Just to say i will greatly miss this rom too...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Same mate!
+1... It was best ROM for Whyred
Just move one. There is lots of ROM out there don't know why people freaking about it lol.
Here's what Whyred XDA Community deserve.
Community really never helped the developer Who has developed the rom without the device (and yes, it was painfull for him with 300 reported problems and zero logs).
0veR said:
Just move one. There is lots of ROM out there don't know why people freaking about it lol.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
been using many rom, on many devices and for many years now.
This one was for me on whyred the most stable (or the most quickly fixed), keeping battery pretty good and with a good concept. I even used it on other devices since i liked it a lot.
That's the reason why it bother us.
the dev made a great job maintaining this ROM and was updating it regularly. for the first time i consider staying on a ROM that is potentially no more developped
The best custom rom, it's custom but it's cleanest
If you ever wonder why devs struggle to find motivation to work for the community, just find the first Pie FW update from henrique in PE thread and read the posts until the last page. Despite the fact that it was clearly noted to update firmware to Pie version and it was written how to do it, there were 4-5 pages per day (not posts, PAGES) filled with questions:
- bootloop, help pls
- can't flash, error in twrp
- how to update
Literally.
And that's everything you need to know about Whyred community.
1- If the rom is stable, you can live without updates.
2- José is "back", he bought a new whyred.
onliner said:
1- If the rom is stable, you can live without updates.
2- José is "back", he bought a new whyred.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah... If people just explore the forum more and do what he says to do... There wouldn't be any problems... The fill pages writing about questions. And it isn't a sign of wit! But PE is like love for a few people! And I eagerly want it comes back!
Never bothered to update my PE (december 5 rom) since it came out. Is running as smoothly as can be, so why mess with a good thing? Will probably keep it until next device, maybe next year.
Is there an archive with the older pixel experience roms and their respective changelogs somewhere?
taco9 said:
Never bothered to update my PE (december 5 rom) since it came out. Is running as smoothly as can be, so why mess with a good thing? Will probably keep it until next device, maybe next year.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The latest update has much more features, there May be more coming. Plus, security updates.
Sent from my Xiaomi Redmi Note 5 using XDA Labs
The developers must link their jobs, social life etc. with making great roms. They need to sacrifice their free time to maintain the rom, fix the problems they encounter with debugging and people complain because they almost never read OP. Without thanking the dev, supporting him, what kind of monsters have this community become? Asking simple questions, which they just can search in like 5 seconds to find an answer... Shame on those people, may they regret now what've they done.
N1ck474 said:
Here's what Whyred XDA Community deserve.
Community really never helped the developer Who has developed the rom without the device (and yes, it was painfull for him with 300 reported problems and zero logs).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Most of the devs are stopping because of the annoyances of the users, even more when the person does not have a device, it gets worse.

Categories

Resources