Possible to use Kaiser as an Analog Modem? - Tilt, TyTN II, MDA Vario III Windows Mobile ROM De

Hi All,
I posted a similar question before without too much response. So bear with me as I repost it here in this forum as you guys seems most knowledgeable.
In where I live, GPRS data cost an arm and a leg. They charge you something stupid like 10 dollars for 12 megs, WITHOUT the option of purchasing an unlimited plan. What I'm trying to find out is is it possible for our Kaisers to act as an analog modem so I can tether it to my laptop and dial-up to a local ISP? Sure the speed would be terrible, but at least I'll get connectivity without incurring tons of data charges.
Any insights would be greatly appreciated

shinji1 said:
[snip]
What I'm trying to find out is is it possible for our Kaisers to act as an analog modem so I can tether it to my laptop and dial-up to a local ISP? Sure the speed would be terrible, but at least I'll get connectivity without incurring tons of data charges.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It would really suck if you're moving such as on a train or such because this kinda of data doesn't handle tower swapping.
It should be possible, depending on your phone provider. I know at&t used to allow it, but it's unavailable with any new plan now, for instance.

NuShrike said:
It would really suck if you're moving such as on a train or such because this kinda of data doesn't handle tower swapping.
It should be possible, depending on your phone provider. I know at&t used to allow it, but it's unavailable with any new plan now, for instance.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hm... interesting. Technically my phone provider can "dis-allow" their customers from dialing into an ISP using a voice call, but in reality can they really prevent you from doing so? I mean from their end its just any voice call right?
But I digress. Does anyone know how I can set up something like this in WM6? I tried doing the following :
1. Create a new Connection
2. Select "Cellular Line" as my modem type
3. Enter the phone number of my ISP
4. Connect using this new connection
But it fails, saying that it got a problem establishing the connection. At first I thought it was failing to establish carrier with the ISP, but later I found out that it doesn't even dial out but changing the number to my home phone number.
Any ideas would be appreciated.. thanks!!

Actually, there is a circuit you can build, for the electronically inclined, that will connect the headphone/mic ports on the kaiser to the 2wire hole on your laptop, enabling you to use your minutes to DIAL aol or msn or whatever.

tyeo098 said:
Actually, there is a circuit you can build, for the electronically inclined, that will connect the headphone/mic ports on the kaiser to the 2wire hole on your laptop, enabling you to use your minutes to DIAL aol or msn or whatever.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Would that be akin to using a mini usb to rj11 adapter? That would certainly be doable! However, I would imagine some drivers needs to be installed. Say, for the WM6 device to act as a modem and for windows to detect it as a modem.

shinji1 said:
Hm... interesting. Technically my phone provider can "dis-allow" their customers from dialing into an ISP using a voice call, but in reality can they really prevent you from doing so? I mean from their end its just any voice call right?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm not sure how it's done, but my provider certainly does block it unless one is provisioned.
On my Sony Ericsson t637, I can ISP dialup on one sim that is provisioned on the monthly plan, but on the other cannot dial through. If you hand dial it, you can hear the other side's modem for fax (for example), but if you try tether dial for instance, it doesn't work. Either sim does not contain any network setup information and it's all on the same phone.

NuShrike said:
I'm not sure how it's done, but my provider certainly does block it unless one is provisioned.
On my Sony Ericsson t637, I can ISP dialup on one sim that is provisioned on the monthly plan, but on the other cannot dial through. If you hand dial it, you can hear the other side's modem for fax (for example), but if you try tether dial for instance, it doesn't work. Either sim does not contain any network setup information and it's all on the same phone.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's very interesting.... the fact that if you hand dial you hear the other side's modem but if you let WM6 dial through one of its connection setups you won't be able to connect.
This leads me to think it might be a software limitation. Any other thoughts?

I want to do this too and have the same issue of it not dialing. But if I hand-dial the number it connects (well, I hear the modem sound). Would it be possible to setup windows to work off those sounds? So instead of dialing, it will just send authentication information. Or dial without dial tone, then you hand-dial it on the cell, and route the "audio" to the modem?

It worked for me
Hi everyone
I use T-mobile in USA, I have the myFaves plan, it allows me to call 5 numbers of my choice for free. One of these numbers is a Dial-up number that I use to dial out and connect to the internet. However it takes about 20-30 attempts before I make a connection (or sometimes it connects in just 2 attempts).
The point is, I've done it and it actually works. All you need to do is go in 'Connections' and add a new connection. Select 'Cellular Line' and specify the phone number you wish to dial.
I would love to use this method of connection since its free, but the time it takes to connect is very frustrating. I came here looking for some free software that would allow the voice call to be easily recognized as a data call so that I can continue using this facility.
I called T-mobile a while back and asked as to why it was so inconsistent, the cusomer representative replied saying 'You are getting away with it, it's not supposed to happen'. He said that they needed to enable CSD for my line for it to actually work. I had the CSD inactive according to him. I argued that I used voice dialing and not CSD, he didn't agree with me.
Lets keep this thread active and search for a solution, let me know what you guys think.

explorer82 said:
Hi everyone
I use T-mobile in USA, I have the myFaves plan, it allows me to call 5 numbers of my choice for free. One of these numbers is a Dial-up number that I use to dial out and connect to the internet. However it takes about 20-30 attempts before I make a connection (or sometimes it connects in just 2 attempts).
The point is, I've done it and it actually works. All you need to do is go in 'Connections' and add a new connection. Select 'Cellular Line' and specify the phone number you wish to dial.
I would love to use this method of connection since its free, but the time it takes to connect is very frustrating. I came here looking for some free software that would allow the voice call to be easily recognized as a data call so that I can continue using this facility.
I called T-mobile a while back and asked as to why it was so inconsistent, the cusomer representative replied saying 'You are getting away with it, it's not supposed to happen'. He said that they needed to enable CSD for my line for it to actually work. I had the CSD inactive according to him. I argued that I used voice dialing and not CSD, he didn't agree with me.
Lets keep this thread active and search for a solution, let me know what you guys think.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's very interesting! I have followed your steps exactly as above, however I can verify that mine doesn't actually dial out. Have you tried substituting your dialup number with your home phone number? That way you can verify at which stage the failure happens. For example, if your home phone rings, then we can conclude that you've managed to make WM6 dial out (which is further than what I've got), which most likely means it fails at the connecting stage.
That fact that I couldn't even get WM6 to dial out makes me think its a software issue more than a network limitation.

I think there's a problem with the Analogue CSD Modem on the TyTN II.
I've been trying to get mToken (http://www.choung.net/mToken/) to work as a simple VT100 async modem connection over the GSM cellular modem and have had no success. Works fine on my other WM5 device (XDA Orbit) using the same SIM card.
As another test I tried getting my ISP connection working over the dial-up Cellular Line (GSM) using start->settings->connections->connections and using then 'cellular line' option under modem selection. Again no success on the TyTN IIl. Again this works perfectly on my other XDA Orbit device.
I have a case open with HTC UK who are still investigating the analogue modem problem on this device.
There's another thread relating to this here:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=357234

I've managed to call my home phone using the "Cellular Line" option when creating new connection. I'm using Q-Mobile 1.2 ROM with radio 1.27.12.32...

svilendotorg said:
I've managed to call my home phone using the "Cellular Line" option when creating new connection. I'm using Q-Mobile 1.2 ROM with radio 1.27.12.32...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I can also dial out to any analogue phone no problem using the 'cellular line' modem. The trouble is the HTC's modem is not able to establish a connection if you have an analogue data modem at the other end - it just hangs indefinitely.

zoggo said:
I can also dial out to any analogue phone no problem using the 'cellular line' modem. The trouble is the HTC's modem is not able to establish a connection if you have an analogue data modem at the other end - it just hangs indefinitely.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Interesting... the problem of not being able to dial out seems more and more like a software problem. In particular, it looks tied to the Radio ROM since I'm on the 1.27.12.17
I'll try some other Radio's and report back the results. zoggo, if you don't mind, please tell us what version of radio are you using. Wouldn't hurt to let us know which rom you're running as well.
Thanks

explorer82 said:
Hi everyone
I use T-mobile in USA, I have the myFaves plan, it allows me to call 5 numbers of my choice for free. One of these numbers is a Dial-up number that I use to dial out and connect to the internet. However it takes about 20-30 attempts before I make a connection (or sometimes it connects in just 2 attempts).
The point is, I've done it and it actually works. All you need to do is go in 'Connections' and add a new connection. Select 'Cellular Line' and specify the phone number you wish to dial.
I would love to use this method of connection since its free, but the time it takes to connect is very frustrating. I came here looking for some free software that would allow the voice call to be easily recognized as a data call so that I can continue using this facility.
I called T-mobile a while back and asked as to why it was so inconsistent, the cusomer representative replied saying 'You are getting away with it, it's not supposed to happen'. He said that they needed to enable CSD for my line for it to actually work. I had the CSD inactive according to him. I argued that I used voice dialing and not CSD, he didn't agree with me.
Lets keep this thread active and search for a solution, let me know what you guys think.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Interesting, I wonder if my provider will charge me data for this

The topic becomes more and more interesting;
now i have an idea - to connect an old gsm phone to my linux server and configure it as a dial-in server/gateway, with free data plan between my Kaiser's SIM card and my server's one... This way i will have 500 free minutes of internet every month
The problem is...i don't know how to do it ...yet

12.32 is no good
shinji1 said:
Interesting... the problem of not being able to dial out seems more and more like a software problem. In particular, it looks tied to the Radio ROM since I'm on the 1.27.12.17
I'll try some other Radio's and report back the results. zoggo, if you don't mind, please tell us what version of radio are you using. Wouldn't hurt to let us know which rom you're running as well.
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have just tried the 12.32 radio and I'm still not able to dial out. Just to clarify, I couldn't even get the connection to dial out.
So this means something other than the radio rom is allowing zoggo and svilendotorg's kaiser to dial out to an analog number from a connection. If you dont mind zoggo, can you tell us what ROM you're running on? I myself am running on dutty's v3 final.
Thanks

shinji1 said:
I have just tried the 12.32 radio and I'm still not able to dial out. Just to clarify, I couldn't even get the connection to dial out.
So this means something other than the radio rom is allowing zoggo and svilendotorg's kaiser to dial out to an analog number from a connection. If you dont mind zoggo, can you tell us what ROM you're running on? I myself am running on dutty's v3 final.
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm running the original versions supplied with my Kaiser:
ROM version 1.56.405.5
ROM date: 08/28/07
Radio version: 1.27.12.11
Protocol version:22.45.88.07H

New developments
Thank you all for the feedback, I was on phone with the T-mobile Customer care (level 3 data) today. According to this very knowledgeable person, it is 'supposed' to work and we are 'supposed' to connect without any problems.
This also goes with the fact that there wont be any data call charges if we use the dial-up connection. However we will be using our voice minutes, depends on your plan.
The representative explained to me that CSD was only used for incoming data calls, like fax etc. and assured me that I did not need CSD for it to work properly (he proved my point). T-mobile offers CSD option for additional fee every month. I also told him that I was able to connect many times before, but the connection was inconsistent (30 attempts etc.).
To shinji1: I used Q-Mobile 1.1 with radio ROM 1.27.12.32 and was able to dial out properly (In fact, I personally think that this is the best radio ROM for this purpose). Currently I use dutty's v3 ROM with the same radio and was able to establish a dial-up connection many times before. You better flash to these ROMs; there is no tweaking involved, just flash and try to connect.
The mToken utility looks very promising. I'll tinker with it later and let you guys know my progress. As zoggo pointed out, this indeed could be yet another HTC software problem (or even the new windows mobile problem), lets hope they solve it.
Finally, I noticed that I am able to establish a connection on some days and failing to do the same on others (no matter how many times I try). So if its not working for you, try connecting again after 2-3 days? Its just a hunch, but its an observation I made.

explorer82 said:
Thank you all for the feedback, I was on phone with the T-mobile Customer care (level 3 data) today. According to this very knowledgeable person, it is 'supposed' to work and we are 'supposed' to connect without any problems.
This also goes with the fact that there wont be any data call charges if we use the dial-up connection. However we will be using our voice minutes, depends on your plan.
The representative explained to me that CSD was only used for incoming data calls, like fax etc. and assured me that I did not need CSD for it to work properly (he proved my point). T-mobile offers CSD option for additional fee every month. I also told him that I was able to connect many times before, but the connection was inconsistent (30 attempts etc.).
To shinji1: I used Q-Mobile 1.1 with radio ROM 1.27.12.32 and was able to dial out properly (In fact, I personally think that this is the best radio ROM for this purpose). Currently I use dutty's v3 ROM with the same radio and was able to establish a dial-up connection many times before. You better flash to these ROMs; there is no tweaking involved, just flash and try to connect.
The mToken utility looks very promising. I'll tinker with it later and let you guys know my progress. As zoggo pointed out, this indeed could be yet another HTC software problem (or even the new windows mobile problem), lets hope they solve it.
Finally, I noticed that I am able to establish a connection on some days and failing to do the same on others (no matter how many times I try). So if its not working for you, try connecting again after 2-3 days? Its just a hunch, but its an observation I made.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did he explain why it doesn't work consistently?

Related

Any other way to connect to the internet?

Well usually I never post anything, but I have a 6800 that I got way back in July and I've herd many different ways to connect to the internet on your PDA phone, like using Dial-Up internet, however my service provider is "Bell Mobility" and well, I hate them with a pure passion, however I have no other choice at the moment. But onto the question, I am trying to find another way to connect to the internet when I am traveling either than using Data. (Expensive!?) Now, if I were to go out and buy a 50$ cheap phone, I can get browser etc. for 7$, I just don't understand. Can someone this up for me, because when I phone Bell, well, they just tell me No! all the time. (Oh, and thanks for all the great programs etc. )
with wifi then you can connect to the internet and if you have dial up internet service then just get the number that the computer dials and the user name and password. then just add a new internet connection on the settings. but using dial up you will be using minutes and it will be slow but usable
Ok, I have signed up with 2 different dial-up providers and tried using my 10 hours of free dial-up through my isp, and I continue to get an error, I am quite frustrated and I'm not too sure if I'm doing something wrong. But thanks for the reply.

Pda are skype locked from MS

Hi,
I am almost sure that all Windows Mobile devices are softwarly unable to use skype properly...I have a Kaiser, which have a UMTS HSDA connection. Think about the following tests I have done.
Everyone is able to make skype call if the Pda is connected through wifi, so the device has no cpu problem using the skype codec, it can handle it.
If you try to make a skype call using the UMTS and even HSDPA connection, the service is not usbale (you hear one word on three!!) So the first thing you think is: the HSDPA data connection is not enough for skype, but, here is the point: if you use your pda as modem with your Pc, you can use skype with no problem on your Pc, using the same data connection as before, even if you make a video call! No delay for sound...so you will think: the problem could be that the cpu radio (if there is one, I am not so expert on Pda hardware) is not so powerful to handle all the data traffic that skype generates, maybe when we use them as modem is not the Pda to manage the traffic (I do not know), but, if you try to download a file from the web using pocket IE or Opera mobile, you will se that our wonderful Pda download it at the same speed you will download the same file from the Pc using the Pda as modem...the same speed and the same time spent for download...it means that the Pda has absolutely no problem using its data connection at its 100% of power.
Thinking about all of this, do not you think that our devices are "blocked" using skype through UMTS connetcion? I also thought, maybe the problem is that the skype client itself is buggy, but it works so well using wifi!
What do you think about that?
Hey Alex,
haven't tried Skype over UMTS/HSDPA, but I know that some carriers block SIP(skype and co) and IM(msn,icq,aim,y!..) over the data connection!
Greetings
tomoffel said:
Hey Alex,
haven't tried Skype over UMTS/HSDPA, but I know that some carriers block SIP(skype and co) and IM(msn,icq,aim,y!..) over the data connection!
Greetings
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I know that, but in that case it does not work at all. If the carriers does not block SIP it should work well, it is impossible that I hear one word on three, or they block it or they allow it ...try to make some test if your carriers allow SIP, I am really thinking that tere is a software block.
Okay, tested it and it worked fine for me over 2mins T-Mobile Germany (x-tra prepay)! Have atm just EDGE, but will test it if I have UMTS!
Maybe the carrier is to "slow" to block the skype call in the moment you connect.. and you have a little delay (the two/three words).. and then the carrier cuts the call?
alex_time said:
I know that, but in that case it does not work at all. If the carriers does not block SIP it should work well, it is impossible that I hear one word on three, or they block it or they allow it ...try to make some test if your carriers allow SIP, I am really thinking that tere is a software block.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
tomoffel said:
Okay, tested it and it worked fine for me over 2mins T-Mobile Germany (x-tra prepay)! Have atm just EDGE, but will test it if I have UMTS!
Maybe the carrier is to "slow" to block the skype call in the moment you connect.. and you have a little delay (the two/three words).. and then the carrier cuts the call?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, I can go on for minutes and minutes, it is not a carriers fault. It is interesting knowing that calling are fine for you in EDGE, it proves that the problem is only on my Kaiser, or on UMTS, or my carrier is joking with us in Italy (H3G) creating this holes on calling. Your test show that there is not any kind of software block by MS. There is someone else that can make other test with different devices, data connection and carriers?
Moved to Q&A
nir36 said:
Moved to Q&A
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks, I thought it was an hacking matter.
Skype works and has worked for over a year now for me on whaatever signal I feed it. UMTS, HSDPA, EDGE, WiFi, ActiveSync, they all work for me. FWIW, I have a Touch Cruise and I'm on ATT's network in the US.
sonus said:
Skype works and has worked for over a year now for me on whaatever signal I feed it. UMTS, HSDPA, EDGE, WiFi, ActiveSync, they all work for me. FWIW, I have a Touch Cruise and I'm on ATT's network in the US.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So it seems that the problem is my own Kaiser or my carrier...anyone else has other expirience with different devices and carriers?
is it possible that you have other programs running in the background and your phone is out of memory?
JR_de said:
is it possible that you have other programs running in the background and your phone is out of memory?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
absolutely not, I made tests even after flashing new rom without installing anything.
Today I made a test after month, I tried to use skype over wifi and...it does not work as when I am under UMTS, is my Kaiser broken??? I mean, I hear one word on three, and under wifi it is not a data speed problem...

3G - voice and data (do all calls take you to 1x)?

Hi All -
Sorry for a weird (simple) question:
I am used to GSM / At&T - where if you had a 3G connection you could talk on the phone and be on the internet at the same time.
Is CDMA / VZW different? I just talked to a tech and she said it wasn't possible.
Confused...
-Daniel
According to what I have read on this forum and experienced, with CDMA, you cannot be on the internet and on the phone at the same time.
If I am incorrect, I am sure someone will correct me!
KD8FRE
that is correct. It's not possible on CDMA.
Wow. Interesting.
I guess there's a map for that in AT&T's future.
Thanks all - appreciate it.
-D
I never really noticed any kind of problems with it. I can make a phone call while my phone is tethered and I can still also receive calls, I think it probably temporally boots you off 3G during the phone call but put you back on right after.
Yeah EVDO is "1x Evolution Data Only/Optimized" which means that once a voice call comes in you are switched to 1X mode.
The latest SVDO specification (recently released) allows carriers to quadruple their voice calls and also allows data and voice at the same time. However nobody has implemented this yet.
I believe no one will implement this.... Because all providers are going HSPA or right to LTE... Where we will be able to have data and voice at the same time.
3G - voice and data
You can talk and surf the internet but only if you establish a Wifi connection
relicsoul said:
You can talk and surf the internet but only if you establish a Wifi connection
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
or if you use VoIP
Seriously though, what's the benefit of having an internet connection going at the same times as making a phone call? Please note, I'm not trying to be rude about this, I'm just curious about it.
Doesn't navigation(on sprint) use the internet? Im able to talk on the phone and still use navigation
There are some "live caller id" services which will do an online 411 lookup for any number that calls you, plus it's nice to be able to browse the internet to look something up while talking with someone (usually handsfree) for example if we're trying to decide on a movie or dinner or where to go out - all very handy to have a simultaneous internet and voice connection.
AstarteSV said:
Seriously though, what's the benefit of having an internet connection going at the same times as making a phone call? Please note, I'm not trying to be rude about this, I'm just curious about it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Two big ones:
1. Conference calls with email coming in. Like - your next meeting has been moved (exchange, push).
2. On phone call - someone asks a question that needs internet connection (I found it this way - they asked what the weather would be like on Sat (it was Monday). I said... hold on a sec... I'll find out... then realized that there is no internet... so I pulled my iPhone out of my pocket and checked it instead. Again - this is something that AT&T does today - just didn't think CDMA was behind the curve on it...
-Daniel
Cool, thanks for showing me the light
My problem (with Sprint) when I had to have a CDMA device is that there is a difference in signal between EVDO and 1X. For instance, I had full signal for EV, but hardly any for 1X... Thus I could be on data all I want, but I had troubles with phone calls....
AstarteSV said:
Seriously though, what's the benefit of having an internet connection going at the same times as making a phone call? Please note, I'm not trying to be rude about this, I'm just curious about it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yeah honey, i'll meet you ... where was that? let me punch it in my google maps... o wait CDMA FAIL

[Q] DTMF problem when dialing D2G GSM

I have a D2G that I'm using an AT&T SIM in for GSM use only. The phone stays in GSM mode all the time.
I'm having an interesting issue with the way the phone detects that it has completed a call.
On a normal CDMA phone (my DX) after you dial a number and hit send, the "call timer" starts counting up as soon as the phone has connected to the network and the call starts ringing. If you want (though there would be little reason to do so) you can bring the dialpad back up and start sending DTMF tones even while the other end is still ringing (hasn't answered yet).
On the D2G in GSM mode (don't know about CDMA mode because I've not used this phone in CDMA mode) when you dial a call, the call timer doesn't start counting up until the phone senses that the other end has actually answered (receives a connect signal). While the line is ringing (before anybody answers) you can bring up the dialpad, but pressing keys does not send any tones. Once the called party answers, pressing keys then sends tones.
The problem comes when trying to dial into a conference bridge where you have to enter the bridgeline passcode, or while trying to use a calling card. Both these systems appear to not send the "connected" signal when they first answer. They wait until you get connected to the desired conference call, or until you've entered all the calling card information and are rung through to your ultimate target before sending the connected signal.
Since the D2G in GSM mode is actually waiting for this "connected" signal before starting the call timer, and since it won't allow you to send DTMF tones until the call timer starts, it is basically impossible to use a conference bridge or calling card.
I have tried numerous add-on dialers, but all hand off to the OEM phone/dialer app after initial dialing. I've tried add-on DTMF generators, but of course they just generate the tones locally (speaker) and not onto the ongoing call. I've been all through build.prop, etc. looking for a setting that would tell it not to wait for a connect signal to enable the "connected" behavior and not found anything.
Putting pauses or waits in the dial string doesn't work either because the phone doesn't even start "pausing" or "waiting" until it senses that it has connected (which doesn't happen before the other end gives up waiting for me to enter the code).
That's the really irritating part. When the conference bridge or calling card system gives up waiting and connects me to the thing that tells me my time to enter the codes has expired and it is going to hang up on me, then it sends the "connected" signal and I can enter all the tones I want on top of the "please call back when you can figure out how to use a phone" message.
I've had someone running a newer firmware test to see if they have this same behavior and they do. If anyone wants to see if they have the issue, they could call the Sprint calling card access number (800-366-2255) and you should find you can't enter any tones once it has answered. Again, this is on a D2G in GSM mode. I'd expect in CDMA mode it would work fine.
Possible avenues of resolution:
Make the phone treat the call as connected immediately instead of waiting for the other end to answer
Have an external app that can send DTMF tones on an active call (Google says that is a common desire that is generally not possible)
Somehow make the built-in dialer allow number presses to generate tones even if it doesn't think the other end has answered yet
Thanks in advance for any suggestions.
Are you trying to say you use the phone on AT&T in USA?
Try switching phone to GSM/UMTS in settings instead of 'global' I remember having some issues with ring back tone while in global mode using GSM network which went away once I switched to GSM/UMTS only.
Sent from my DROID2 GLOBAL
leobg said:
Are you trying to say you use the phone on AT&T in USA?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yep. Other than the undesirable behavior of the call progress timer, it works perfect. Although the data works great, I keep data disabled because on AT&T prepaid data costs like 1 cent per kilobyte. That doesn't seem like much until you think about 1024 kilobytes in a megabyte which means you're paying $10.24 per megabyte which is insane. Fortunately I can bring up 3G Mobile Hotspot on my DX (which has unlimited data) and tether my D2G through my DX and have full Internet. It sounds retarded, but the only time I use this setup is when I need my DX to do mobile VPN for work, and then use my D2G for voice calls. AT&T prepaid is only like $1.99 a day for unlimited voice and text, and you only pay on the days you use it (which is almost never for me).
leobg said:
Try switching phone to GSM/UMTS in settings instead of 'global' I remember having some issues with ring back tone while in global mode using GSM network which went away once I switched to GSM/UMTS only.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the suggestion. Actually I was already in GSM/UMTS mode but tried switching it to "Global" mode. Unfortunately the behavior was the same.
Somehow I imagine if I trot down to the Verizon store to ask them about it they won't really be super inclined to help. I have considered trotting down to the AT&T store where I bought the prepaid SIM and seeing what they think. But I don't imagine it would be good for much other than the amusement of their confusion.
Droid 2 Global is configured so it doesn't get service with any GSM/UMTS provider located on the teritory of the United States of America. How is yours working on AT&T is really a huge surprise to me and many other members of this and other online forums.
This so called "band lock" (google for Droid 2 global band lock) can reportedly be circumvented, but there is no publicly available method to do it. Unless you got yours 'band unlocked', it is not supposed to get any service from neither AT&T nor T-Mobile. Or maybe you bought it from someone who was working on this 'band lock'
Could you share more info with us?
leobg said:
Droid 2 Global is configured so it doesn't get service with any GSM/UMTS provider located on the teritory of the United States of America. How is yours working on AT&T is really a huge surprise to me and many other members of this and other online forums.
This so called "band lock" (google for Droid 2 global band lock) can reportedly be circumvented, but there is no publicly available method to do it. Unless you got yours 'band unlocked', it is not supposed to get any service from neither AT&T nor T-Mobile. Or maybe you bought it from someone who was working on this 'band lock'
Could you share more info with us?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The phone has been unlocked with the TBH/DBU unlock. It is running 2.4.29 firmware and has to stay on 2.4.29 for the unlock to be preserved. The unwanted call progress behavior (the purpose of my original post) has been tested and confirmed on another phone running 2.4.330 so it's not a 2.4.29 issue. I'd bet that all of the Blur dialers probably do the same thing (disable tones after Send and until the call progress timer starts running). Just in CDMA mode the call progress timer starts running as soon as the call starts ringing and in GSM it waits for an actual connect signal. The D2G is truly like two complete phones in one, so seeing this type of disparity in behavior between the two different modes (I assume when in CDMA mode it would work just like all other CDMA models and not have the issue) isn't really surprising at all. I would expect that anybody who is using the GSM mode of their D2G would have this issue when dialing into a conference bridge or calling card provider where the "connect" signal is not given until after all of the secondary dialing has been completed. It would seem however that this issue would have come up before since I can't be the only person that works for a huge company and spends most of his day dialed into conference bridges for meetings (and might just want to dial into those meetings from his spiffy GSM phone).
I've been though the AOSP source for the phone/dialer before (when troubleshooting something else), so when I get a chance, I'll go through again and find the section where it enables and disables the tone sending. I'd guess it would be trivial to remove the part that disables tones during the period between Send and call-progress-timer-start, compile it, and just replace the dialer on the phone. I've been through all the build.prop and everything else hoping a setting would jump out at me, but no luck.
About the TBH/DBU unlock -- after the unlock there's nothing special about sticking an AT&T, TMobile, etc. SIM in there, but I only have first hand experience with the AT&T. I just went into the local AT&T store and told them I wanted to buy a prepaid SIM. They asked what kind of phone and I think I told them I had a Samsung Captivate (not that it really matters). The SIM was basically free and I put $25 on it. Stuck it in the phone, changed to GSM/UMTS mode, phone blurred while it was changing modes, and now has AT&T banner on the lock screen. Pretty much a non-event.
I didn't get a chance to go down to the AT&T store yet, but I plan to. If nothing else I'd like to test calling into the same Sprint calling card number from another GSM phone -- especially an Android phone if they have a working model there -- and see if it too has a problem.
Sorry for rambling. I hope I addressed your questions.
My friend MotoCache1 is the "other" member of TBH, just an FYI!
We haven't discussed the status of the band unlock on XDA out of respect for the rules here regarding paid services.
Well, that explains the things
Btw- mine is on Rogers Canada, i can use comma to add pause to dial extensions conference bridges without issues.
However, when I try my Telus Canada sim in, when I dial number, dialer says hang up, 00:00, then connects the outgoing call, sort of like a call back service, but without ringing back - hang up, then the very next second call connects and phone issues ring back tone. But this "hangup" on the middle prevents me from dialing extensions or conference bridges bu using pause in the number dialed. Everything else is fine (data, messaging/etc). So it is kind of crippled on Telus. Wonder if it is the same thing you get on AT&T.
Sent from my DROID2 GLOBAL
Hmmm. Interesting. Forgive the ignorance, when using Rogers is that CDMA? Or are you using GSM for both carriers?
I tried the same scheme, using commas in the dial string, but unfortunately the phone doesn't ever get to the part after the commas because it waits for connect before continuing the dial string. I don't get the hang up behavior you describe though. I'm a complete newb to GSM, so what I'm about to suggest may be stupid, but I wonder if the carriers have any sort of call handling parameters that are stored on the SIM?
I happened to be in a VZW store to get an extended battery for my DX and asked them if they had a demonstrator D2G in GSM mode so I "could test a bug I read about on the Internet". Moments after the question left my mouth I realized I was stupid for asking it, and he confirmed that by saying "no, we can't use the phones in GSM mode because GSM on that phone doesn't work in the US". Oops, duh.
He asked what the bug was and I told him. He said that he hadn't heard of that, but it sounded like something that would be fixed in a software release. He looked to see if any such releases were listed for the D2G, but found none. Surprisingly (to me anyway) there is a recent release listed for the D1 to fix an "unwanted recipients" problem (for messages), and some other thing (I don't recall).
I'm at Bike Week right now (sitting in the bath tub typing this on my DX -- yay Swype) but will give the AT&T store a shot when I get back. I'll also borrow a buddy's Tmobile SIM and see if it behaves any differently. He has an actual Tmobile branded android phone, (a Samsung, but I don't remember which one right off) so I can do the conference bridge test on his phone too.
Both Rogers and Telus now sport GSM/UMTS (Telus only UMTS) networks. Gone are the days when Rogers had CDMA network, almost 10 years now. Telus still has CDMA alive, but they are phasing that out. My CDMA radio is sleeping, until I get to the States next time I guess (my D2G is active on a pay-go plan) I will be doing some travelling in May/Jun across Europe, so I will try with european sims too.
Sent from my DROID2 GLOBAL
leobg said:
Both Rogers and Telus now sport GSM/UMTS (Telus only UMTS) networks. Gone are the days when Rogers had CDMA network, almost 10 years now. Telus still has CDMA alive, but they are phasing that out. My CDMA radio is sleeping, until I get to the States next time I guess (my D2G is active on a pay-go plan) I will be doing some travelling in May/Jun across Europe, so I will try with european sims
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the details. Interesting that you see two completely different behaviors just by changing the SIM. That leaves the question of whether the difference is due to the way each network is handling the call progress, or if it is some sort of information on the SIM itself that makes the difference.
I looked into SIM editors to see what sorts of things the various editors claimed to be able to read/edit on the SIM. I haven't seen anything along the lines of call processing characteristic parameters, etc., so I'm leaning toward the difference being in the signaling received from the network. I'll be able to get a better idea of what's going on when I get back home and can experiment with a Tmobile SIM, and/or put my AT&T SIM in another phone and see what it does.
OK, back from Bike Week (last week actually) and grabbed a T-Mobile SIM. Really odd results. The very first call I dialed on the T-Mobile SIM, the call timer started immediately, and I could send DTMF tones immediately. Every call since then has exhibited the same behavior I was seeing with the AT&T SIM -- the call timer doesn't start until a formal connect happens (which the calling card and conference bridge sites don't send upon initial connect -- thereby preventing sending the tones to access the service).
I spent just a little time going through the source code of: [platform/packages/apps/Phone.git]/src/com/android/phone/CallTime.java and found the spot where the call gets switched to "active":
Code:
/**
* Sets the call timer to "active call" mode, where the timer will
* periodically update the UI to show how long the specified call
* has been active.
*
* After calling this you should also call reset() and
* periodicUpdateTimer() to get the timer started.
*/
/* package */ void setActiveCallMode(Call call) {
if (DBG) log("setActiveCallMode(" + call + ")...");
mCall = call;
// How frequently should we update the UI?
mInterval = 1000; // once per second
}
I started looking around to see "who" all calls that and right off I only see CallCard.java calling it. I was expecting to see it called somewhere in PhoneApp.java (after observing a connect or something), but it's not called there.
There's lots of hunting yet to do, but I wanted to post progress in case anybody out there cares.
In some hunting I happened to stumble on a pretty detailed page outlining the exact same problem on an iPhone. It's understandable that this type of problem might exist and persist on a closed source device like an iPhone. Fortunately, something like this should be very solvable on an open source device.
I haven't had my buddy with a T-Mobile issued Android phone (Samsung Vibrant) test this yet. That's on the "to do" list.
More updates as I have them.
So what I've figured out on this is that you pretty much just can't use conference bridges or calling cards on a GSM phone. I've used my Tmobile and AT&T SIMs in a bunch of phones now:
1. Droid 2 Global
2. Droid Pro Global
3. Motorola Napoleon
They all do the same thing. Heck, the Napoleon isn't even Android - it's Windows Mobile. I also tried with my friend's Samsung Vibrant (which he has on Tmobile) and it does the same thing -- call timer never starts running and if the call timer isn't running you can't generate tones to put in your access code for the conference bridge, etc. Apparently the AT&T iPhones do the same thing, so again, this is a GSM thing.
Which begs the question again -- doesn't anybody with a GSM phone need to call into conference calls? I was under the impression that most big companies used conference bridges for most of their meetings.
Anyway, when I get some time I'll get back to taking a stab at hacking on the dialer -- just no free cycles to tackle it right now.
It must be something with that conference bridge you are trying it on. I know many phone switches do not connect the call while you are in the IVR/menu trees - it is usually done in order to avoid inaccurate call metrics on the receiving end. We are running a contact centre in our company and I know how important this is (and we do it to - we don't connect the call until operator answers the call). Billing is not supposed to start until call is connected on the receiving end. Apparently GSM operators like T-Mobile and AT&T care about call connect parametter and Verizon is simply ignoring it, I guess.

[Q] Classic Dial up with no PC

Hi,
I sometimes need to travel to places with just GSM. I want to establish a connection to the internet using classic dial up as in 56k modem type connection. I would Ideally like to do this with an android phone but i'm open to suggestions.
Any Ideas?
AW: [Q] Classic Dial up with no PC
With 2G (GSM) you should already have a data plan incorporated. Just start the browser.
If your mobile has a modem of course...
<i9001 0x07 board running ivendor CM10beta3 on CastagnaITkernel 10.6 with i9001XXKPO baseband>
Takalani said:
Hi,
I sometimes need to travel to places with just GSM. I want to establish a connection to the internet using classic dial up as in 56k modem type connection. I would Ideally like to do this with an android phone but i'm open to suggestions.
Any Ideas?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You want that connection for your mobile of for your laptop? What phone do you have?
inherit said:
You want that connection for your mobile of for your laptop? What phone do you have?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No PC. just straight out dialup connection to connect my phone to a classic dialup network. I currently have an SG3. I travel to places where i have just GSM. I don't want to take a PC with. I just want to be able to dial into a server the old fashion way through my phone, for my phone.
Takalani said:
No PC. just straight out dialup connection to connect my phone to a classic dialup network. I currently have an SG3. I travel to places where i have just GSM. I don't want to take a PC with. I just want to be able to dial into a server the old fashion way through my phone, for my phone.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well, as far as I know, you have to obtain connection settings from your phone carrier. Bhere is no difference between GPRS, EDGE, 3G and HSDPA, except speed! Connection setting are the same and the phone will switch automaticaly to the best connection. Google the internet for the settings for your location and your carrier.
inherit said:
Well, as far as I know, you have to obtain connection settings from your phone carrier. Bhere is no difference between GPRS, EDGE, 3G and HSDPA, except speed! Connection setting are the same and the phone will switch automaticaly to the best connection. Google the internet for the settings for your location and your carrier.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I want to dial the old DialUp way. Dial through GSM to an internet service provider through a telephone number like a classic fax 56k modem.
GPRS won't work because i there is no coverage.
I want a way to do good old classic v92 56k modem type dialing
Takalani said:
I want to dial the old DialUp way. Dial through GSM to an internet service provider through a telephone number like a classic fax 56k modem.
GPRS won't work because i there is no coverage.
I want a way to do good old classic v92 56k modem type dialing
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well, if there is no coverage.... this means that you cannot use your phone at all. The lowest transfer rate is GPRS, and it can by dialed IF you have any signal prom you phone carrier. So, if you can use you phone to make calls, you can cake a GPRS connection. I don't think if there is any phone company that allow dialup connection other that in they own network, and if they allow... well, it will cost big money.
So, I repeat: if you can make phone calls, this means that you have signal from your telephone company and you can make a dialup connection if you know the correct settings! Connection speed depends on signal and phone performance!
Takalani said:
I want to dial the old DialUp way. Dial through GSM to an internet service provider through a telephone number like a classic fax 56k modem.
GPRS won't work because i there is no coverage.
I want a way to do good old classic v92 56k modem type dialing
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Why?
Sent from my EVO using xda premium
inherit said:
Well, if there is no coverage.... this means that you cannot use your phone at all. The lowest transfer rate is GPRS, and it can by dialed IF you have any signal prom you phone carrier. So, if you can use you phone to make calls, you can cake a GPRS connection. I don't think if there is any phone company that allow dialup connection other that in they own network, and if they allow... well, it will cost big money.
So, I repeat: if you can make phone calls, this means that you have signal from your telephone company and you can make a dialup connection if you know the correct settings! Connection speed depends on signal and phone performance!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
3rd world country, anything is possible, including GSM with no GPRS . I don't mind paying voice call rates for a data connection.
change the way the question is asked
Background info. I just switched to AT&T a week ago. I can only afford a 1GB data plan (retired). Before I changed to AT&T (stay with me) I had a Verizon "unlimited data plan", (would take too long to explain why I switched). Anyway, I forgot to change the settings, in the phone, to turn off the "Mobile Network" so I burned through 90% of my data plan in 1 week.
I have a crazy idea. I have unlimited "talk" on my plan. So I want to use the "talk" minutes on my plan for my Galaxy S3 to access the internet through free Dial-up", so I won't go over on my "data Plan" limit. Don't want to link to a PC.
Note to ALL Cellular providers: You guys brought the "Smartphone" to market and hyped them to get us to buy them and use them. Then you hyped "unlimited" data. Then we started using our smartphones and a lot of data. Now your networks can't support the data usage, so you started charging more and more for the data and took away the unlimited plans to limit the data usage. Shame on you!!
sdiCharge said:
Background info. I just switched to AT&T a week ago. I can only afford a 1GB data plan (retired). Before I changed to AT&T (stay with me) I had a Verizon "unlimited data plan", (would take too long to explain why I switched). Anyway, I forgot to change the settings, in the phone, to turn off the "Mobile Network" so I burned through 90% of my data plan in 1 week.
I have a crazy idea. I have unlimited "talk" on my plan. So I want to use the "talk" minutes on my plan for my Galaxy S3 to access the internet through free Dial-up", so I won't go over on my "data Plan" limit. Don't want to link to a PC.
Note to ALL Cellular providers: You guys brought the "Smartphone" to market and hyped them to get us to buy them and use them. Then you hyped "unlimited" data. Then we started using our smartphones and a lot of data. Now your networks can't support the data usage, so you started charging more and more for the data and took away the unlimited plans to limit the data usage. Shame on you!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't think you'll find a way to trick AT&T... "talk" minutes use voice connection so I do not think you'll be able to make a dial-up connection using your "talk" minutes. If you're going to manage this, many phone companies will have to change their rate plans!
1GB should be enough for a commonly used: email, chat, news...

Categories

Resources