Related
I used to have an SII, and then jumped on the large screen bandwagon (after using it in a store) thinking it wouldn't affect me much. Fast forward one year after my Note II's purchase, if there is one thing I want in my next phone, it is to be able to use it with one hand easily.
One handed usage - Reach all points on a phone, including all the navigational buttons without shuffling or moving the phone in your hands.
Now I have already tried the S4, and I couldn't use it with one hand (Mind you, I have average sized hands, it's just not easy to do it).
My questions are for those of you who have used these devices:
1. How does one handed usage compare between the Nexus 5 and S4? Is it a huge difference?
2. How does one handed usage compare between the Nexus 5 and HTC One? Is it a huge difference?
3. How does one handed usage compare between the Nexus 5 and G2? Is it a huge difference?
P.S. I will try the Nexus 5 in stores, though it's going to be some time before it comes in stores here.
UPDATE: I tried out the HTC One and it is possible for me to use it. But even a bit bigger would be impossible. I am more concerned about how the sharp edges of the Nexus 5 make it harder to use.
darkgoon3r96 said:
I used to have an SII, and then jumped on the large screen bandwagon (after using it in a store) thinking it wouldn't affect me much. Fast forward one year after my Note II's purchase, if there is one thing I want in my next phone, it is to be able to use it with one hand easily.
One handed usage - Reach all points on a phone, including all the navigational buttons without shuffling or moving the phone in your hands.
Now I have already tried the S4, and I couldn't use it with one hand (Mind you, I have average sized hands, it's just not easy to do it).
My questions are for those of you who have used these devices:
1. How does one handed usage compare between the Nexus 5 and S4? Is it a huge difference?
2. How does one handed usage compare between the Nexus 5 and G2? Is it a huge difference?
P.S. I will try the Nexus 5 in stores, though it's going to be some time before it comes in stores here.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I know you didn't list it, but I previously used an HTC One (similarly sized to the S4), and I have large hands. I can use the N5/One with one hand, but I wouldn't call it "comfortable," in fact I'd call it precarious, as in order for me to reach the notification drawer with my thumb, I have to rest the phone on the remaining four fingers and reach upward with my thumb. I never use the phone one handed when not sitting down or stable.
aznxk3vi17 said:
I know you didn't list it, but I previously used an HTC One (similarly sized to the S4), and I have large hands. I can use the N5/One with one hand, but I wouldn't call it "comfortable," in fact I'd call it precarious, as in order for me to reach the notification drawer with my thumb, I have to rest the phone on the remaining four fingers and reach upward with my thumb. I never use the phone one handed when not sitting down or stable.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The main one for me is to be able to use it with one hand in bed while looking at the ceiling. I think that is possible with the HTC One if I install navigational buttons (I don't care for real estate, one handed use is much more important to me).
I think the Nexus 5 is great to use one handed, the bottom bezel actually provides a nice area to hold, and the phone is easy to balance.
The HTC One has a slightly smaller screen than the S4, I think. Both are comfortable to reach the whole screen, but the One is more comfortable to hold in general due to its curved shape and tapered edges.
The G2/N5 are built on very smilar specs. I would guess they use the exact same screen panel. A 5 inch screen is a bit too big for my tastes. I could use them with my hands- average size but with longer versatle fingers that are good for manipulating devices- but it wouldn't be preferable. Plus, fitting such a large phone in my pocked would be a pain.
Of the choices you list, I would suggest the S4. I own the One, and recommend that above the S4. HTC really picked up their game since the old EVO days...
cbburtraw said:
I would suggest the S4. I own the One, and recommend that above the S4.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wait, what?!
I can tell you this - much harder to do than my N4, about the same as a Galaxy S3.
It is however manageable, and the curved back helps.
Once I stick it in my Spigen Slim Armor, it becomes a challenge for me, no way I can reach all points on screen one handed.
I do use my N5 with one hand on my way home from work. It is possible. But I need to move the phone in my hands in order to reach the top (e.g. address bar of browser) and the bottom (navigation keys) of the screen. This is dangerous because you can drop the phone if your are not very careful.
The width of the phone is not a problem for me.
I do not want to miss the large screen of the N5. But I am now 100% certain that I do not want an even larger phone.
-Tiz- said:
I do use my N5 with one hand on my way home from work. It is possible. But I need to move the phone in my hands in order to reach the top (e.g. address bar of browser) and the bottom (navigation keys) of the screen. This is dangerous because you can drop the phone if your are not very careful.
The width of the phone is not a problem for me.
I do not want to miss the large screen of the N5. But I am now 100% certain that I do not want an even larger phone.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you compare it to Nexus 4, S4, S3, or G2?
Getting to the top isn't easy even with big hands. Which is why I HAVE NO IDEA why so many devs put their bars AT THE TOP OF APPS.
Anyway, might go back and try out Nova launcher so i can swipe down for notficiation bar as Google refuses to implement gestures.
prawnguevara said:
Getting to the top isn't easy even with big hands. Which is why I HAVE NO IDEA why so many devs put their bars AT THE TOP OF APPS.
Anyway, might go back and try out Nova launcher so i can swipe down for notficiation bar as Google refuses to implement gestures.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's how I am using my Note II right now.
darkgoon3r96 said:
I used to have an SII, and then jumped on the large screen bandwagon (after using it in a store) thinking it wouldn't affect me much. Fast forward one year after my Note II's purchase, if there is one thing I want in my next phone, it is to be able to use it with one hand easily.
One handed usage - Reach all points on a phone, including all the navigational buttons without shuffling or moving the phone in your hands.
Now I have already tried the S4, and I couldn't use it with one hand (Mind you, I have average sized hands, it's just not easy to do it).
My questions are for those of you who have used these devices:
1. How does one handed usage compare between the Nexus 5 and S4? Is it a huge difference?
2. How does one handed usage compare between the Nexus 5 and G2? Is it a huge difference?
P.S. I will try the Nexus 5 in stores, though it's going to be some time before it comes in stores here.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
the swiftkey keyboard just got an update that includes a 'compact keyboard' that pushes it to one side or the other. at first I laughed at such a feature, i mean it looks out of place. but i think it's a very good feature for people who like the large screens but want to only use one hand to type
Enddo said:
the swiftkey keyboard just got an update that includes a 'compact keyboard' that pushes it to one side or the other. at first I laughed at such a feature, i mean it looks out of place. but i think it's a very good feature for people who like the large screens but want to only use one hand to type
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't have problems with the width. I have problems with the height.
I tell you its much easier to wield one handed then my previous Note 2. I was getting tired of hearing "what is that?" "it's so big" and it's even worse hearing people remark about my phone. So I wanted to downsize my handset and its a great size. I can one hand it for the most part but a little stretch for the top and bottom areas...
Itchiee said:
I tell you its much easier to wield one handed then my previous Note 2. I was getting tired of hearing "what is that?" "it's so big" and it's even worse hearing people remark about my phone. So I wanted to downsize my handset and its a great size. I can one hand it for the most part but a little stretch for the top and bottom areas...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So you can reach all the areas without shuffling the phone in your hand?
darkgoon3r96 said:
So you can reach all the areas without shuffling the phone in your hand?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Almost, the top and bottom are a slight stretch but my thumb can reach the other side again. So i can use swype one handed which was an issue with my note 2.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
I jumped directly from S2 two nexus 5..most of the time I can reach all parts of the screen with one hand(thumb).. perfect size, not too big like note 3 or too small like iPhone 5s..
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
allyrocky said:
I jumped directly from S2 two nexus 5..most of the time I can reach all parts of the screen with one hand(thumb).. perfect size, not too big like note 3 or too small like iPhone 5s..
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
At what times are you not able to reach all parts of the screen?
Say I'm using left hand and trying to reach setting in notification bar.. I won't be able to do that.. But don't find it an issue since I'm right handed
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
allyrocky said:
Say I'm using left hand and trying to reach setting in notification bar.. I won't be able to do that.. But don't find it an issue since I'm right handed
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Setting is actually a big button on stock android.. When using right handed, can you reach the new tab button on chrome at the top left? Can you also reach the profile picture in the notification tray (the button next to brightness)?
Does anyone LIKE the size of the chin? I found myself instantly pleased with the added area to handle my phone. I actually left the sim in my 5x for a while to be sure. But I've never noticed how much I use the top and bottom bezels in portrait view. Especially when. Showing someone pictures or portrait videos. I dunno... I'm loving it. Perfect size where my thumbs never bumps the touchscreen.
Am I the only one?
I have no problem with it either. Take a look at the iPhone 6, which I have, and the bezel is about the same size as the Pixel. Actually the whole phone looks similar with a very similar feel. The Pixel is a little larger screen dimension wise but both are beautiful devices. And let's be honest here, if you can compare to an iPhone you're saying something. This device is a jewel if the battery can hold up.
I just got my Pixel today, and I wish the chin was a bit smaller to be honest. The onscreen buttons take up a good chunk of space that I feel makes it look a bit...iPodish? That's for sure not an accurate assessment, but it is what I think when I look at the chin of the phone especially. Like I said, first day and all. I love everything else about this phone though. I even think the price is justifiable.
I actually like the chin too. I find it helps my thumb reach the home button much more comfortably when using it one handed, rather than over extending my thumb to reach the bottom of my phone.
Plus it gives the phone a very minimal/elegant look. So no complaints from me!
No complaints here! Keeps the phone looking balanced
Sent from my Pixel using XDA Labs
I like the large chin. Im with you, I think its nice for handling the phone.
Zer0_ said:
I actually like the chin too. I find it helps my thumb reach the home button much more comfortably when using it one handed, rather than over extending my thumb to reach the bottom of my phone.
Plus it gives the phone a very minimal/elegant look. So no complaints from me!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes same here... While at first I thought it was huge and unsightly, when I think about it, I wouldn't want my thumb to have to reach any further down to get to the nav bar. It keeps the nav bar at a perfect height. Still seems kind of boring though. But I'm also glad they didn't put any branding there so kind of a conundrum for me.
Sent from my Pixel using Tapatalk
I dont mind the bottom too. It's not super noticeable and I agree that it makes the nav bar easier to reach.
I just wish people would stop calling it a "chin" - it's a bezel, not a chin. Look at the original G1 for a "chin".
bobby janow said:
I have no problem with it either. Take a look at the iPhone 6, which I have, and the bezel is about the same size as the Pixel. Actually the whole phone looks similar with a very similar feel. The Pixel is a little larger screen dimension wise but both are beautiful devices. And let's be honest here, if you can compare to an iPhone you're saying something. This device is a jewel if the battery can hold up.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Totally... A lot of people seem to want this phone to be the opposite of iPhone. But we already had that... The Nexus lineup. Sure some were better than others but they were never trying to compete with anyone directly. Just good enough with a great price.
mmaaddict78 said:
I just got my Pixel today, and I wish the chin was a bit smaller to be honest. The onscreen buttons take up a good chunk of space that I feel makes it look a bit...iPodish? That's for sure not an accurate assessment, but it is what I think when I look at the chin of the phone especially. Like I said, first day and all. I love everything else about this phone though. I even think the price is justifiable.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just got mine last night. And I honestly looked at it and said 'why is everyone complaining about the chin?' to my girlfriend.
I agree, I am totally satisfied with the price now that the phone is in hand. Speed/Feel is amazing.
Zer0_ said:
I actually like the chin too. I find it helps my thumb reach the home button much more comfortably when using it one handed, rather than over extending my thumb to reach the bottom of my phone.
Plus it gives the phone a very minimal/elegant look. So no complaints from me!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I never noticed that the home button was more comfortable on the Pixel until I used my 5X and Pixel side by side.. thanks for pointing that out! Of course I can't say much about the XL cause I didn't get that one.
brangalm said:
I dont mind the bottom too. It's not super noticeable and I agree that it makes the nav bar easier to reach.
I just wish people would stop calling it a "chin" - it's a bezel, not a chin. Look at the original G1 for a "chin".
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
HAH. I've been Androiding since the G1... and yea, that thing had a Joe Swanson Chin for real.
I just joined the chin lingo cause everyone else seemed to be doing it... Peer pressure!
this is #13 of a long list of reasons i'm returning the Pixel. this phone makes so little sense to me i cannot even wrap my head around it, probably because i don't talk TO my damn phone. leave the AI for the kiddos. going back to my ****ing galaxy S3. maybe HTC 10 after that. dunno.
Now that I have my phone, in person, I don't mind it. I prefer balance/symmetry and the chin provides that. I would prefer a speaker there instead, but oh well …
The chin I actually don't notice. Maybe it's because I have the 5' black version. To me, the chin makes it better for one handed use. The galaxy s7 was hard for one handed use for me anyway. I think the chin thing is really blown out of proportion. Just my two cents.
In theory I'd like to see a smaller chin/ bezel and increase the screen size while keeping the overall size the same.
In practice, I don't mind the chin. I don't notice it at all.
I hear y'all but that Jay Leno chin and fivhead are fails to me. I do appreciate all the reasons why you like them but the could have put like 8 speakers in that space. Subs, tweeters and all that! Still love the phone though.
Sent from my Pixel using XDA-Developers mobile app
Looks weird I'd rather have it to help with holding the phone and keeping the navbar at a decent height
Sent from my Pixel using XDA-Developers mobile app
The bottom bezel adds balance, symmetry and consistency to the device.
I am still upset it gave up the speaker grill. But sure look uber minimalistic.
Sent from my Pixel using XDA-Developers mobile app
troy` said:
Does anyone LIKE the size of the chin? I found myself instantly pleased with the added area to handle my phone. I actually left the sim in my 5x for a while to be sure. But I've never noticed how much I use the top and bottom bezels in portrait view. Especially when. Showing someone pictures or portrait videos. I dunno... I'm loving it. Perfect size where my thumbs never bumps the touchscreen.
Am I the only one?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Jay approves..
daewond3r said:
Now that I have my phone, in person, I don't mind it. I prefer balance/symmetry and the chin provides that. I would prefer a speaker there instead, but oh well …
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
subhani said:
The bottom bezel adds balance, symmetry and consistency to the device.
I am still upset it gave up the speaker grill. But sure look uber minimalistic.
Sent from my Pixel using XDA-Developers mobile app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Totally agree with both of you. I think it really adds the balance. When I saw it at first I wondered, but once I used it I don't mind a bit. I use headphones so I dont care about huge speakers.
Coming from the BB Z30 I am use to the chin and prefer it becuase of the way I hold the phone and navigate with my thumb. Now if only google would pick up a bb 10 device and take down some notes. Like moving things down low so I dont have to stretch my hand to the top.
twilk73 said:
Coming from the BB Z30 I am use to the chin and prefer it becuase of the way I hold the phone and navigate with my thumb. Now if only google would pick up a bb 10 device and take down some notes. Like moving things down low so I dont have to stretch my hand to the top.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Same here, I only use my phones one-handed, whether it's the Pixel, Notes, iPhone 7+, etc. The extra space is where my palm digs into. The BlackBerry Classic is the only device I have to use two hands, but da*n, that physical keyboard is sooo worth it.
I bought a case from Luvvitt for the S+ Plus and it arrived yesterday. I held the case in my hand and it's definitely smaller across than the LG V20 which I cannot reach across with my thumb when I'm holding it in one hand. Yes, this may all be obvious, but didn't I read that the S8+ had a 6.2" display? Am I missing something about the screen size or phone size that I'm not understanding? I put the case up against the LGV20 and it's not that much bigger than the V20 I have now which is 5.7". I am glad the S8 Plus is narrower, which will make it easier to use one-handed, but the length seems odd to me.
The s8+ is slightly shorter than the V20 and thinner. This is due to the screen aspect ratio.
Sent from my Note 7, S7 Edge or S6
The s8+ is almost 5mm narrower, the screen is bigger because its a taller screen, its not 16:9 anymore like the v20 but 18.5:1
force70 said:
The s8+ is slightly shorter than the V20 and thinner. This is due to the screen aspect ratio.
Sent from my Note 7, S7 Edge or S6
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I was reading about screen aspect ratio, way too much math. I gave up.
Bigger screen in a small foot print..
The s8+ is slimer and taller the most phones.
I remeber having my s7 edge and note 7. The note felt smaller even tho the screen was a bit bigger.
sanjsrik said:
... but didn't I read that the S8+ had a 6.2" display? ..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
We cannot use inches as a measurement anymore on these kinds of phones (mi mix, LG g6, Samsung s8/s8+)
Yes it's 6.2" diagonally, but it doesn't matter anymore since it's not 16:9
Due to the aspect ratio it has way less screen realestate compared to other phones using the traditional 16:9 width/height .
Without going into math i can tell you basically it's not like a "regular" 6.2" phone. Using it will be more similar to a 5.7"ish phone in terms of stuff you can have on screen and the width of the phone.
Let nobody tell you different: This is NOT the same as a "normal" 6.2" phone. It doesn't NOT give you a 6.2" phone experience.
This still isn't necessarily bad, you'll get the nicest screen in existence and a phone you can handle with one hand. It's just not comparable to a 6+" phone.
Sent from my Nexus 6 using Tapatalk
Eddiemc said:
This still isn't necessarily bad, you'll get the nicest screen in existence and a phone you can handle with one hand. It's just not comparable to a 6+" phone.
Sent from my Nexus 6 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Actually being that tall basically kills your chance for one handed use of things like the notification area and/or indeed reaching the navigation buttons, no?
This is a phablet through and through. The last trully one handed phone Samsung made was S4 ... since then then they breached the 140x70mm "barrier" and we get (got?) devices that are bigger than phones yet smaller than phablets. S8 made the transition to the phablet form almost exclusively.
And I mean that's OK, people want more information at once, ease of use is secondary to that. Apple made a fortune merely by adding 0.7 inches to her phone. But -yeah- one handed use went the way of the dodo , we occasionally use it but only for few things. We mostly use our ... pocketable tablets two handed these days.
Stevethegreat said:
Actually being that tall basically kills your chance for one handed use of things like the notification area and/or indeed reaching the navigation buttons, no?
<snip>
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Depends on the size and flexibility of your hands as well as where you chose to grip the phone. I use my V20 one handed all the time and its physically a bigger phone. I'm only slightly taller than average.
http://www.phonearena.com/news/Samsung-Galaxy-S8-display-Whats-the-deal-with-the-new-aspect-ratio_id92777
Heres a nice link to an explanation.
bishmaster5000 said:
Depends on the size and flexibility of your hands as well as where you chose to grip the phone. I use my V20 one handed all the time and its physically a bigger phone. I'm only slightly taller than average.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I assume you're a man. Being taller than average for a man means that you're the 25th percentile (at least 75% of people are smaller than you) so even if true you'd be a minority. However I doubt is true as it is physically impossibly to reach all 4 corners without constantly adjusting your grip. You probably do have some limited one-handed use, but that's not what I mean. That's what I meant (or something close to that): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O99m7lebirE
Lastly s8+ has a far taller screen than V20, so even if you were somehow able to reach both upper and lower corners without adjusting your grip, you most possibly wouldn't be able to do the same with S8+
Stevethegreat said:
<snip>
You probably do have some limited one-handed use, but that's not what I mean. That's what I meant (or something close to that): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O99m7lebirE
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The video you linked is not how I hold my phone, the manner in which they hold it is to emphasize their marketing shill, ie if you hold a phone like that you can barely use a tiny phone one handed. Like I said, it depends on where you grip the phone.
All you said was accessing navigation buttons and notification area, which I can easily do 1 handed. I'm not going to one handed type out text or do heavy surfing, but I can quickly check notifications or do light activity one handed with ease. Your refusal to believe me does not change the fact that I can operate the V20 and the S8+ in the manner in which you specified. Next time qualify your ridiculous claims with something more concrete.
bishmaster5000 said:
The video you linked is not how I hold my phone, the manner in which they hold it is to emphasize their marketing shill, ie if you hold a phone like that you can barely use a tiny phone one handed. Like I said, it depends on where you grip the phone.
All you said was accessing navigation buttons and notification area, which I can easily do 1 handed. I'm not going to one handed type out text or do heavy surfing, but I can quickly check notifications or do light activity one handed with ease. Your refusal to believe me does not change the fact that I can operate the V20 and the S8+ in the manner in which you specified. Next time qualify your ridiculous claims with something more concrete.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't refuse to believe you, especially since you just accepted that your one handed use is partial, that is exactly what I expected.
One handed phones can do everything in one hand. Motorola Moto X was like that, the first iphones were like that and to those with bigger fingers Galaxy S4 was that ... after that mostly chaos.
S8+ is quite taller than V20, so even partial one handed use is impossible for most people. Which is what I said in my initial post. If they wanted one handed use they should at least tried a more reasonable aspect ratio.
Stevethegreat said:
I don't refuse to believe you, especially since you just accepted that your one handed use is partial, that is exactly what I expected.
One handed phones can do everything in one hand. Motorola Moto X was like that, the first iphones were like that and to those with bigger fingers Galaxy S4 was that ... after that mostly chaos.
S8+ is quite taller than V20, so even partial one handed use is impossible for most people. Which is what I said in my initial post. If they wanted one handed use they should at least tried a more reasonable aspect ratio.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The s8 plus is .2mm shorter than the V20 as per gsm arena.
I was surprised also actually
Sent from my Note 7, S7 Edge or S6
jpinks said:
http://www.phonearena.com/news/Samsung-Galaxy-S8-display-Whats-the-deal-with-the-new-aspect-ratio_id92777
Heres a nice link to an explanation.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
http://www.phonearena.com/phones/size#/phones/size/LG-V20,Samsung-Galaxy-S8/phones/10202,10312
heres a visual comparison against the v20
force70 said:
The s8 plus is .2mm shorter than the V20 as per gsm arena.
I was surprised also actually
Sent from my Note 7, S7 Edge or S6
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I meant the screen is taller. Even if the device is shorter your fingers have to reach further hence why it is harder to operate despite being a smaller device in overall footprint.
I just received a case for my s8+ and it's about the same height and norrower than my v20.
Sent from my LG-LS997 using Tapatalk
All the YouTube dread over the location of the fingerprint scanner will not be a problem for most. This is a Urban Armor Gear Case (UaG) for the Galaxy S8+. It will not be a problem for me.
Everyone has different sized and shaped hands, that's where the problem lies, it not being a problem for you doesn't mean that it will work for everyone. Left handed people will also have to hold their hands in an awkward position to hit the scanner, I personally won't have any problem with it, but I know that people with smaller hands will
BleedCrimson said:
All the YouTube dread over the location of the fingerprint scanner will not be a problem for most. This is a Urban Armor Gear Case (UaG) for the Galaxy S8+. It will not be a problem for me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You do realise you are going to be putting greasy fingerprints right over the camera lense every time you try to unlock it right? It is slightly less of a problem for people holding it/unlocking it with their left hand (i hold with left and tap with right so its not quite so bad for me) but its still stupid placement. Putting it BELOW the camera instead of next to it would have made it easier to reach for smaller hands, easier to reach for people unlocking with the right hand, and greatly reduce the chances of hitting the camera lense instead.
It's just plain dumb design and that was obvious right from the first leaks showing where it was, so how the geniuses at samsung couldn't see that right from the start I have no idea. It was probably a rush decision after they failed to integrate it into the screen but its so clearly a stupid location for it that even a rush decision shouldn't have resulted in locating it there.
I may be slightly harsh, but this isn't a mid range phone, its the very top end of the top end and for the money they decided to charge for it, it should be damn near perfect.
I'm a lefty so I'm just going to run my finger along the back until I feel the sensor. Doubt I'll have many problems with wiping my camera lense. And I also rarely take pictures so I have that going for me as well.
Looks like you will be covering up at least 50% of the camera at the same time.
I dont even think about to use fingerprint sensor on s8+
Nope!
I'm just the opposite. If I try to do it with my left index finger, the scanner is too close. It's awkward for me to try using my left index finger. With the UAG case, I'll easily be able to keep away from the camera lense.
ewokuk said:
You do realise you are going to be putting greasy fingerprints right over the camera lense every time you try to unlock it right? It is slightly less of a problem for people holding it/unlocking it with their left hand (i hold with left and tap with right so its not quite so bad for me) but its still stupid placement. Putting it BELOW the camera instead of next to it would have made it easier to reach for smaller hands, easier to reach for people unlocking with the right hand, and greatly reduce the chances of hitting the camera lense instead.
It's just plain dumb design and that was obvious right from the first leaks showing where it was, so how the geniuses at samsung couldn't see that right from the start I have no idea. It was probably a rush decision after they failed to integrate it into the screen but its so clearly a stupid location for it that even a rush decision shouldn't have resulted in locating it there.
I may be slightly harsh, but this isn't a mid range phone, its the very top end of the top end and for the money they decided to charge for it, it should be damn near perfect.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The LG V20 has the fingerprint scanner on the back. I don't know until I see the actual device, but I think the S8 once you get used to it, it should be fine.
I don't think it will be much of an issue either. But the S8 is just so fantastic you need to find a con somewhere
Honestly, I won't even use it. I hold my phone really low compared to most, I guess.
Can someone confirm how fast/reliable the iris scanner is? Also, does having it on make a noticeable impact on battery life?
im using an iphone 7 plus and i wipe my camera every time i use it and theres no fingerprint scanner back there hahahaha people are weird
galaxyYtester said:
Everyone has different sized and shaped hands, that's where the problem lies, it not being a problem for you doesn't mean that it will work for everyone. Left handed people will also have to hold their hands in an awkward position to hit the scanner, I personally won't have any problem with it, but I know that people with smaller hands will
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I hear you and agree with the caveat that people with small hands need to purchase a mobile that they can handle efficiently. The S8 and S8+ are not designed for people with small hands? Its very much a question of compromise. If one desires a screen as large as the S8's then one will need larger than average hands or accept small handed users will need two handed operation. :good:
I don't mind the scanner being where it is. I owned a zenphone with the scanner on the back right underneath the camera. I had zero problems after acclimatising myself to such a layout.
Ryland
I can comment on the fingerprint scanner, it is very fast - near instantaneous, the only issue is that it takes longer to hit the right spot that it does for it to open the phone. as everyone already mentioned it is in a bad/awkward spot. i tend to either hit the camera or the flash when trying to use it. eventually ill train myself to hit the right area, but its not intuitive.
Just checked the s8/s8+ out at Best Buy. The s8+ was perfect for me just doing a quick hands on with the finger print scanner. I thought it would be weird but it was easy for me to use but my hands are bigger than average.
Not looking forward to getting used to this. I have smaller than average hands and I know it will be awkward, but I'll try to survive.
I also am aggravated by the fact that it is impossible for one handed operation on a desk or table. I am work and it just takes a finger swipe with my phone on the desk, but now it will take entering a pin since the FP scanner is on the back and the my face isn't over the screen.
dumpyloser said:
Not looking forward to getting used to this. I have smaller than average hands and I know it will be awkward, but I'll try to survive.
I also am aggravated by the fact that it is impossible for one handed operation on a desk or table. I am work and it just takes a finger swipe with my phone on the desk, but now it will take entering a pin since the FP scanner is on the back and the my face isn't over the screen.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That is the other irritating thing about it being on the back, when I have the phone in a dock or on the desk I am going to end up picking it up to unlock it instead of just putting my finger on a front facing scanner. I know you can have the iris scanner AND the fingerprint scanner active, but with the iris scanner i would still have to pick the phone up to point it at my eyes so its pretty useless, it will need a pin like you said.
On the back is a way better place for the fingerprint scanner than on the front. On my Nexus 6P I can unlock the phone whilst picking it up single handedly. If the finger print scanner were on the front I'd have to pick it up with one hand and use the other hand to unlock it. The size of the phone, the Nexus 6P and the S8 (The plus in particular) mean that bringing your thumb to where a home button would be would be difficult/painful.
Lagamorph said:
On the back is a way better place for the fingerprint scanner than on the front. On my Nexus 6P I can unlock the phone whilst picking it up single handedly. If the finger print scanner were on the front I'd have to pick it up with one hand and use the other hand to unlock it. The size of the phone, the Nexus 6P and the S8 (The plus in particular) mean that bringing your thumb to where a home button would be would be difficult/painful.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ummm, so how do you use the phone with 1 hand if you cant reach the home or back buttons??
And you could just pick it up so your thumb CAN reach the front, seeing as you will have to use the home buttons and back buttons anyway....
ewokuk said:
Ummm, so how do you use the phone with 1 hand if you cant reach the home or back buttons??
And you could just pick it up so your thumb CAN reach the front, seeing as you will have to use the home buttons and back buttons anyway....
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
When I unlock the phone it's usually got my internet browser open which is likely what I'm going to be using, so I'm not looking to use the Home/Back buttons.
Please, no "that's what she said" jokes. Rate this thread to express how you think the Samsung Galaxy S10e feels in-hand. A higher rating indicates that it's comfortable to hold for long periods of time, even in one hand. Resist the urge to say "TWSS" just now. Seriously.
Then, drop a comment if you have anything to add!
Coming from a Pixel 2, and both phones in OtterBox Defenders are almost exact size, which is nice. One thing I don't like is the button placement. Pixel 2's buttons are in a perfect location. The S10e's are way too high on the phone in my opinion, at least to easily use one-handed.
Sent from my SM-G970U using Tapatalk
The FPS placement is terrible IMO. I am a lefty and have to adjust (or change hands) every time I want to use it.
First world problems for sure but a show-stopper for me given how many times per day I need to use it.
53fireman said:
Coming from a Pixel 2, and both phones in OtterBox Defenders are almost exact size, which is nice. One thing I don't like is the button placement. Pixel 2's buttons are in a perfect location. The S10e's are way too high on the phone in my opinion, at least to easily use one-handed.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So which one feels better between pixel 2 and s10e overall according to your experience?
The phones in the Defender case are almost identical, so no difference there. I prefer the Pixel 2 button placement, but not that big of a deal for me. The Pixels lack Band 14 and the new tech with WiFi and ATT's "5g" on the Samsung is really the ticket for me.
---------- Post added at 10:05 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:03 AM ----------
arsenal74 said:
The FPS placement is terrible IMO. I am a lefty and have to adjust (or change hands) every time I want to use it.
First world problems for sure but a show-stopper for me given how many times per day I need to use it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I almost feel like using my left index finger would be easier if I were a lefty... But I'm not so I can't say definitively.
Nice size of the device. No problem to reach the opposite corner of the phone when using with one hand
No 5G on 10e
53fireman said:
The phones in the Defender case are almost identical, so no difference there. I prefer the Pixel 2 button placement, but not that big of a deal for me. The Pixels lack Band 14 and the new tech with WiFi and ATT's "5g" on the Samsung is really the ticket for me.[COLOR="Silver"]
If you bought the 10e thinking you are getting 5G, you got ripped off.
Only the largest 6.7 inch S10's have 5G.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hence the " ". Regardless,speeds are great on the fake 5g
I really like the size of this phone, the thickness, height for me is perfect. Display size for me is perfect. I had the S9 before although very close to the same size it feels comfortable. in the hand.
Feels much better in my hand than my previous phone, the GS8+. That thing was a monster.
Something special about holding it once you wipe down all the finger oils, fingerprints and dust
Nice size, but buttons are placed oddly. I often end up taking an accidental screen shot when pressing volume-down with left thumb (finger inadvertently touches power-button).
I use bxActions to set the Bixby button to screen toggle on single-press, flashlight goggle on double-press.
The ergonomics are terrible.
Would be so much better if the power button/finger print sensor was on the top in the center, or if the finger print sensor was built into the bottom center of the screen. This way left- and right handed users could simply unlock the phone with their index finger.
And why not replace the volume rocker by vol up and vol down buttons on the top left, with the top right for camera and bixby buttons. This would open up the possibility to switch these buttons around, so lefties and righties could set their favorite button setup.
Oops! I shouldn't post this here before applying for a patent .
Symmetric layouts cater much better for left/right-handed use.
Glass backs are sooo 2015! They're heavy, slippery, and they break easily. Plastic may look cheap, but it's way more functional. Glass backs have no place on compact phones that are meant to be light.
Since the display doesn't really go edge-to-edge, raising the body around it slightly would protect the screen against falls on smooth surfaces.
And that camera box sticking out of the back? Make the phone half a milimeter thicker and recess the camera lens a bit. This also creates room for a slightly bigger battery. Win/win!