Will smartwatches survive a few minutes in sea water? - Huawei Watch 2

Hey guys so I was thinking of picking up a watch that can track my fitness activities but can also be used like a smartwatch, so I'm thinking between the Huawei Watch 2 and the Moto 360 Sport. The thing is that I also like to paddleboard and I'd like to track distance, speed etc. My only question is that will smartwatches with an IP68/67 rating be able to survive a minute or two under sea water just in case I fall in a few times? I'm not planning to use it while swimming but I just want to know if it will survive in case I fall a few times.

Yes they can but,
AFAIK, IP67/68 should holdup to seawater since it is water. But the downside is the seawater is salty (duh). So that it will be more corrosive than normal water. However seawater is not highly reactive like some other chemicals. So its fine to wear your IP 68/67 watch into the sea just like you would do in normal water (shorter the time, is better). After you got out, wash the watch thoroughly with normal water. And the watch will be fine. :good:
This is also the case for phones. remember to wash the charging port and headphone jack (if you are lucky ) thoroughly.

The manual says it's good for showering and getting caught in the rain only. I just happen to be reading through the manual before clicking on this thread.

Allexandross said:
Hey guys so I was thinking of picking up a watch that can track my fitness activities but can also be used like a smartwatch, so I'm thinking between the Huawei Watch 2 and the Moto 360 Sport. The thing is that I also like to paddleboard and I'd like to track distance, speed etc. My only question is that will smartwatches with an IP68/67 rating be able to survive a minute or two under sea water just in case I fall in a few times? I'm not planning to use it while swimming but I just want to know if it will survive in case I fall a few times.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
no, it will be damaged even if you wear it when you have a shower

geochem said:
no, it will be damaged even if you wear it when you have a shower
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
actually it's up to luck! my ip67 phone was fully under toilet water for 30 minutes and I didnt know! but was not damaged in anyway, but my friend's phone got damaged only by washing it for seconds!
they say it wont be damaged in shower, but hey, direct water might not damage it but what about humid air in there? also what are you gonna do if it gets damaged? Im too lazy to even go for warranty and wait for a new model!:laugh::laugh:

Huawei Watch 2 is IP68. No problem showering or washing dishes. I use it in the pool and never had a problem. Sometimes the speaker gets muffled but it is back in a few hours. I even tried it while kitesurfing a few times... no problem. I stopped doing that however, since a friend told me that salt water could damage the sealing of the watch. I still take it with me to the ocean to track my activities, but now I remove the armband and put it in a bag in my pocket (for kitesurfing) or in my swimming cap (for swimming) - no heart rate measure though while doing that.

Related

Shower with it?

Should you, could you, would you, take a shower with the Gear 2?
[CONCLUSION]
Manual says soap is not advisable, but if you forget that you are wearing it while walking in to the shower its no problem.
Should I? Not unless it's something I CANNOT miss (probably the only time is if a baby is on the way). I can spare 5 seconds to take watch off and on.
Sent from my SM-N900V using xda app-developers app
Darth Ziggurat said:
Should you, could you, would you, take a shower with the Gear 2?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The Gear 2 is water resistant up to 3 meters for 30 minutes. You could. I am not sure you should. What is the point of wearing the watch in the shower? I wouldn't because I have no reason too.
I wouldn't fret about walking to my vehicle in the rain however.
This video shows the Galaxy Gear water test... and the Galaxy Gear was not rated as waterproof at the Gear 2.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AumcFF-9F9U
It is Waterproof
I have took two showers with it already and it is working fine have had no problems it is even touchable in the shower but not like it is when it is dry very nice though
Breach said:
The Gear 2 is water resistant up to 3 meters for 30 minutes. You could. I am not sure you should. What is the point of wearing the watch in the shower? I wouldn't because I have no reason too.
I wouldn't fret about walking to my vehicle in the rain however.
This video shows the Galaxy Gear water test... and the Galaxy Gear was not rated as waterproof at the Gear 2.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AumcFF-9F9U
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
tonyd371 said:
I have took two showers with it already and it is working fine have had no problems it is even touchable in the shower but not like it is when it is dry very nice though
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I wasn't saying that its not possible. I was pretty sure it would be fine since it's rated IP67 (one meter for 30 minutes), but I don't see the point.. wait.. Ahh.. hmm.. Are you watching porn on than tiny screen? lol
According to the manual, soap is not advisable. Which kinda defeats the point of a shower really
Sent from my SM-N9005 using Tapatalk
No but haven't tried watching movies yet
takes too long to transfer. and porn haven't tried to transfer movies to it unknown as of yet if they will play. i will try to download movies to it and see but as you say the screen is small. the note 3 has a better picture so i wouldn't waste battery for it. it already drains playing music
Breach said:
I wasn't saying that its not possible. I was pretty sure it would be fine since it's rated IP67 (one meter for 30 minutes), but I don't see the point.. wait.. Ahh.. hmm.. Are you watching porn on than tiny screen? lol
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks guys, I updated my main post with the conclusion that its not advisable because of soap, but if you forget you are wearing it its no problem.
why not but would not
I took a shower with it
The speakers stop functioning if they get in contact with water (this also happens if you put your watch in glass of water. thereafter, the speakers don't work for a short time)
That's the only thing I've noticed so far
everything else works fine
I've showered everyday with it... no problems here. I take it off and wipe it clean and put it back on. You never know when you might miss an important phone call
I wont chance it. Nothing is that important it cant wait for my 20 min shower.
smeiff said:
I've showered everyday with it... no problems here. I take it off and wipe it clean and put it back on. You never know when you might miss an important phone call
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've showered with it since I got it and it's holding up just fine. No point in having a waterproof watch if you can't even shower with it. Next up; Waterworld and the beach in Maui! We'll see how this goes... lol
Helga Pataki said:
I took a shower with it
The speakers stop functioning if they get in contact with water (this also happens if you put your watch in glass of water. thereafter, the speakers don't work for a short time)
That's the only thing I've noticed so far
everything else works fine
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Speakers don't stop working, there is too much water on the little hole, just blow some air with your mouth or lightly with an air dust pc spray.
Sent from my SM-N900T using xda app-developers app
took mine for a dip in the hottub last night was in there for about 45 min just relaxing with some friends.
checked a few xda posts, text notifications ect ..
tested out music player on it , and as others stated it gets all muffled , just have to blow on speaker and its fine a few minuets later.
only thing I would worry about is long term affect from the chemicals in the hottub we run bromine in ours and over time it could degrade the plastic or the strap I'm thinking .
Chemicals in the water (shower, pool, hot tub) will eventually degrade the seals and you will end up with a brick. This is not a Suunto. And I doubt Samsung intended it to be exposed to water for long periods of time on a regular basis.
extremetm said:
Chemicals in the water (shower, pool, hot tub) will eventually degrade the seals and you will end up with a brick. This is not a Suunto. And I doubt Samsung intended it to be exposed to water for long periods of time on a regular basis.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The user guide specifically says not to expose it to soapy water (as in a shower)! It also points out in the user guide that the pressure of the water may exceed standing water at 1m depth, for example in a waterfall, crashing waves in the sea....and I would think this would extend to a higher pressure shower. It also says that you should dry the watch whenever it has become wet!
It really is water resistant...NOT waterproof and certainly not intended for underwater operation.
I made 2 baths and a couple of showers with the gear 2 and everything is ok. I will take the gear of only in pool or at sea.
Sent from my SM-G900F using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
How do you guys wash your wrist under the watch? That's one of the places I sweat the most.
JimSmith94 said:
How do you guys wash your wrist under the watch? That's one of the places I sweat the most.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Exactly... I jog all the time and one thing I hated with the Gear 1 that it was not waterproof so I took a lot of time to clean it on the inside of the band since I tend to dress-up for work daily wearing the Gear. Plus being a real runner you will get caught in rain...but my sweat counts more than rain since I live in the HOT humid South.
So I shower in mind to clean it and I don't put soap directly on it but by all means I clean the stink of the nasty sweat off my arm and inner band of the watch...more water very mild amount of soap...same as I did with Gear 1 but never put it in the shower...
If Samsung is going to be serious about a workout gear then water, sweat, etc is part of it so if they say it can withstand water damn I am going to get it in water...if fails then why I have a warranty...
By all means if you work out in it please clean it...under the band can smell like an a$$ if you not cleaning ANY of your workout gear that includes the arm holder for my Note 3 when I jog....

Water resistance experience

Has any brave soul tried this feature? If so give us your experience!
Personally I have not, knowing my luck my device would be the one with faulty ports/leaks ?
Some people have tried it and damaged their phone. Others have been fine. The phone is water resistant not waterproof so I would recommend against dipping it in water.
Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk
I personally placed my wife's S7 Edge screen under a running tap for a few seconds. Phone still works fine. Having said that the iPhone 6S has some great water resistant features and it doesn't even have an IP rating. Yet my old iPhone 5s died after siting in a little puddle of water on the bathroom basin bench, which was barely as deep as the back cover. At least with some certified proof of water resistance protection on the S7's, I won't be taking mine swimming or showering, but its surely great to know that it could
handle some very common water contact.
If it spoils easily regardlessof having water resistance why does samsung make all these ads with lil john dunking his phone in the aquarium and whatnot. Theyre tempting us to do so and if the phone is broken they should never void the warranty as long as it adheres to the phone being not deeper than 1.5 meters for not longer than 30 mins
As above, i've run mine under the tap a few times and it's been fine. I've never submerged it though, I don't dare yet. I also don't have a need to, so don't anticipate I will anytime soon.
I finally had it tested and it was an accidental situation which makes it seem useful and not just intentionally testing it for the sake of it. We left my wife's S7 on the coffee table and there was a cup of water on there. We came back and the water got knocked over, the phone was kind of in a puddle of it. I was actually excited to test it, but pissed that my cat has been ****ing with filled cups of water lately.
Tried dipping it while i was in the gym pool lol charged it after 2 hrs moisture detected, wiped the inside with some tissue all good ?
Sent from my SM-G935T using Tapatalk
I use it to watch the news in the shower every day, and I tested under running water for a few minutes when I first got it. Water proofing is the biggest single reason why I bought this phone. If it doesn't work as advertised, I would have returned it. This thing is designed to handle water, so don't be afraid. I wouldn't swim with it, but a couple of drops of water from the shower or caught out in a rain storm, are nothing to worry about.
It is sold as a waterproof phone, not just water resistant. IP68 means full submersion in water, up to 5 feet for 30 minutes. That is waterproof. If the device fails from less than that, Samsung would legally have to replace it for you under warranty.
toptekjon said:
I use it to watch the news in the shower every day, and I tested under running water for a few minutes when I first got it. Water proofing is the biggest single reason why I bought this phone. If it doesn't work as advertised, I would have returned it. This thing is designed to handle water, so don't be afraid. I wouldn't swim with it, but a couple of drops of water from the shower or caught out in a rain storm, are nothing to worry about.
It is sold as a waterproof phone, not just water resistant. IP68 means full submersion in water, up to 5 feet for 30 minutes. That is waterproof. If the device fails from less than that, Samsung would legally have to replace it for you under warranty.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
that's all true but they get you with the "water pressure" crap. running it under a slowly pouring tap should be fine, but running it under heavy/fast flowing water flowing from the tap could be a problem, also the entire submersion thing, drop it in slow it should be fine, throw it in water and it could cause issues.
The IP68 rating is simply a bonus for me. I will treat it no differently than any other phone but it's good to know that, should an accident occur, and it ends up in the sink or something similar, it should be alright. Being able to use it in the rain is quite nice too. However, people who put their new phone in a bowl of water the day they get it to prove some sort of point deserve any issues they end up with.
1.5m 30mins. With that rating i would say it's safe to bring it with you when you swim(not dive), and would not recommend to bring it to snorkel. I saw someone dropped their phone to a 40 feet river.. that for sure are gonna break the phone..
Sent from my Nexus 6P using Tapatalk
BTW, make sure you never subject it to soapy water. Its water resistance relies on the surface tension of the water. Soap lowers water's surface tension, allowing the water to flow into places it normally wouldn't, as this guy found out the hard way:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/galaxy-s7/how-to/water-damage-story-t3337463
toptekjon said:
I use it to watch the news in the shower every day, and I tested under running water for a few minutes when I first got it. Water proofing is the biggest single reason why I bought this phone. If it doesn't work as advertised, I would have returned it. This thing is designed to handle water, so don't be afraid. I wouldn't swim with it, but a couple of drops of water from the shower or caught out in a rain storm, are nothing to worry about.
It is sold as a waterproof phone, not just water resistant. IP68 means full submersion in water, up to 5 feet for 30 minutes. That is waterproof. If the device fails from less than that, Samsung would legally have to replace it for you under warranty.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
doing the same as you better to test the warranty while its still hot
it froze on me on 2nd shower, high pressure test video recording but im sure it was the fact that ive got like 5% space left on the memory.
I also run it under cold fast water if it heats up, i do block the charge port, then its cooled down enough for some day charging...
its quite a well built phone and I would be shocked if it does get water damage, but im worried, samy warranty is good service.
I couldn't resist testing this out. After all, if it's not working as advertised I'd want a replacement. So I filled up the sink and then carefully placed the phone at the bottom. The screen doesn't work while under water but once I took it out everything was back to normal. Awesome feature!
I don't need the water resistance features of the phone, but I do believe that if it's water resistant then it's less likely for moisture and corrosion to hamper with buttons, contacts and other internals. I had 3-4 phones with unresponsive power buttons over time, so if Samsung used good, oxidation-resistant materials for water resistance purposes then it will probably be beneficial for overall mechanical health of the phone as well.
Anyone else have any experiences to share?
Was at a party this past weekend with a lot of friends. I had my phone in my hand, browsing something, and my buddy asked what phone I had. When I told him it was the S7 Edge, he promptly entered Lil Wayne mode and poured his beer onto my phone. Laughs were had. Took it to the bathroom and rinsed it under the sink for a few seconds, and all is well.
Nitemare3219 said:
Anyone else have any experiences to share?
Was at a party this past weekend with a lot of friends. I had my phone in my hand, browsing something, and my buddy asked what phone I had. When I told him it was the S7 Edge, he promptly entered Lil Wayne mode and poured his beer onto my phone. Laughs were had. Took it to the bathroom and rinsed it under the sink for a few seconds, and all is well.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If someone did this to my phone without my consent I would enter Bruce Lee mode with them.
Ontopic: I tested my phone a lot. When I first got it I washed it with clean water everyday. I also washed it with soap a few times, I never had any problems.
After I received my dbrand skin I also washed it a couple of times, once with soap as well, to make sure the skin is water resistant (it is).
Now that the "new toy" syndrome has passed, I use my phone normally, but if someone asked me to take a selfie while the phone is underwater, I would do it
Dropped my phone in the bath and continued to leave it in there to show it off to the mrs as her iphone can't do it. Screen came out working fine including buttons, however the speaker was very distorted which kinda made me panic but it dried out overnight and all was well in the morning.
Needless to say I never lost my nerve round my partner and kept echoing your iPhone can't do that....
lvnatic said:
If someone did this to my phone without my consent I would enter Bruce Lee mode with them.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Haha, well since it was in my hand it's not like it got very wet. With the water resistance, I really didn't care. Gave me my first opportunity to test it out.
My son wanted to get a video underwater at the pool last weekend.
https://youtu.be/3UL4qcH7rJs
Sent from my SM-G935P using Tapatalk

Removing rear cover of Gear S2 R720.

The 4 small screws which hold the rear cover of the Gear S2 have a "Y" Shape or "Tri-Wing" screw head.
I am trying to find the size of this special screwdriver and where I can obtain one please?
I have a tri-wing bit to my miniature screwdriver set that I always use open up electronics, but it is not small/sharp enough for these screws. Just today, I orderered this set from amazon: https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0089NNRL4/. I I will try to report back in a few days to let you know if it has one that works.
Wore my Gear S2 snorkling...only went down about 8 feet, but apparently too much for the supposedly ip86 certified S2 Classic. I am optimistic that opening it up and drying it out will get it running again.
DaveKnowsAll said:
Wore my Gear S2 snorkling...only went down about 8 feet, but apparently too much for the supposedly ip86 certified S2 Classic. I am optimistic that opening it up and drying it out will get it running again.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sucks to hear, but thrashing your hands swimming probably did the damage. Or going below the 5 foot recommended by Samsung..
The gear s2 is IP68 rated for water, it means that it is not safe to swim, shower, or dive with it on. The IP68 rating is for dust resistance and a submerged depth of 3.3 feet.
I don't know that taking apart the watch will better dry it out, it does take a long time for electronics to dry safely, however it does not guarantee that they will still work.
I would recommend placing it in a silica gel, instant oat meal, or even cat litter. The rice method is not that effective at drying electronics.
alorora said:
The gear s2 is IP68 rated for water, it means that it is not safe to swim, shower, or dive with it on. The IP68 rating is for dust resistance and a submerged depth of 3.3 feet.
I don't know that taking apart the watch will better dry it out, it does take a long time for electronics to dry safely, however it does not guarantee that they will still work.
I would recommend placing it in a silica gel, instant oat meal, or even cat litter. The rice method is not that effective at drying electronics.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
According to Samsung, IP68 (only the "8" matters for water, the "6" is for dust) means that it can "be submerged in 1.5 meters of water, and be submerged in less than 1.5 meters of water for up to 30 minutes". This is consistent with the standards required to achieve an IPx8 rating. Unfortunately, that does not mean they warranty it for that (they don't). In actual practice, my gear S2 classic lived up to their promise. I swum actively, in pools, waterfalls, and the ocean while wearing the watch on many occasions. It was not until I snorkeled to depths below 1.5 meters that I had a problem.
I should receive my screwdrivers this afternoon, so I'll report back on the results. I have much experience with family members dropping electronics in water, and opening them up to dry out/clean out is always the best option to get them working again. Rice/silica, etc. is a substitute for people who can't/won't open their electronics (which usually voids the warranty), but is never as quick or effective.
The "X" in a ipx rating means that it is rated for water resistants but not tested for it. the ip68 certification is also for static water tests, meaning that the test does not cover movement, just submergesion. Also any movement in water on objects almost doubles the pressure rate.
When a watch is rated at 30m it really means that it is not water proof but water resistant. To dive with a watch or swim with one on it must have a minimal rating of 3bar: to surface swim, to dive, 300+m, for deep dives with mixed gasses: 3000+m is needed.
The most miss leading thing about electronics that are ip68 is that they are water 'resistance' not waterproof, and even when it says it is waterproof it is only for a set amount of time up to set time.

Cleaning your watch

OK, so i wear my watch from wake up to sleep.
I workout every day of the week, and have started to notice that my watch is smelly. I have taken bands off and soaked over night in soapy water and disinfectant to help. But it seems that it is the "watch" that is smelling.
Has anyone had this problem, and if so did you find a remedy. I have washed off, just afraid of spraying with any chemicals due to possible damage.
I have tried wiping off before and after each session with alcohol wipes, but doesnt seem to help much.
primus123 said:
OK, so i wear my watch from wake up to sleep.
I workout every day of the week, and have started to notice that my watch is smelly. I have taken bands off and soaked over night in soapy water and disinfectant to help. But it seems that it is the "watch" that is smelling.
Has anyone had this problem, and if so did you find a remedy. I have washed off, just afraid of spraying with any chemicals due to possible damage.
I have tried wiping off before and after each session with alcohol wipes, but doesnt seem to help much.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I never washed it. I got it 2 weeks ago and I'm afraid it will die. Got it from a Samsung Store for 150 bucks and was a bargain. I just want to ask, is the watch water resistant without the bands? because my bezel around the watch is a tiny bit loose. Is it normal if it's loose? Is it actually water resistant without bands?
Thanks, Fritz_Frigursson
OP, do you use the original leather straps? If yes, its totally normal.
Leather naturally smells like something stinky, and it gets worse since it absorbs sweats and holds it inside.
My advice : replace it with rubber straps, or metal.
Fritz_Frigursson said:
I never washed it. I got it 2 weeks ago and I'm afraid it will die. Got it from a Samsung Store for 150 bucks and was a bargain. I just want to ask, is the watch water resistant without the bands? because my bezel around the watch is a tiny bit loose. Is it normal if it's loose? Is it actually water resistant without bands?
Thanks, Fritz_Frigursson
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The Samsung Gear S2 /Gear S2 Classic devices have all been certified to an IP68 Rating which means that these devices are protected against water ingress to a maximum depth of 1.5 metres of water for up to 30 minutes, as well as protected against dust ingress.
So you could take a shower, i do wash mine i just make sure that i am careful, when doing so.
cacingbesar said:
OP, do you use the original leather straps? If yes, its totally normal.
Leather naturally smells like something stinky, and it gets worse since it absorbs sweats and holds it inside.
My advice : replace it with rubber straps, or metal.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have some straps that i bought off Amazon, the OG straps that come with it ripped after a couple weeks, the screw holes come out, weird. And when i tried a warranty claim, was told only the actual device was covered not accessories. So I bought some. I might buy more, and just change them when i work out. or just take it off.
I have worn it many times in the shower. Even had soap on it. Nothing happened. I am using the gear s2 from October of last year and still loving it. Though had issues with the original strap glue coming off and the terrible customer support to get it replaced.
Washing
I wear mine all the time, apart from in the bath. Shower and hand washing no problem, give it an occasional rinse under the tap.
Before I got my S2, I went through a watch per year in the workplace. On a day to day basis, mine is subjected to dust, dirt, water, cement, plaster, silicon sealant, grease, never misses a beat and original strap.

Waterproofness....

Anyone dared to submerge their lovely new shiny phone in water yet?
Edit: Could mods move this to General/discussion please, my bad.
I did, I dropped it in the tub. Only for a couple of seconds though. Running fine no issues.
I am coming from a mate 9 the only thing I see different is the sim card tray has a big rubber seal on it. I guess if they added the same seal on the mate 9 it could qualify for IP68+. I did drop coffee on the mate 9 and the sim tray became almost glued but it kept on humming until I tried to remove it today. It came out but half the sim card seems to have Melted inside the phone.
Good to know, i'm still dubious of any device that has charging port, headphone jack, speaker, microphone and no visible covers.........and being a fisherman it's a bonus knowing that a dip in the lake would still leave the phone working.
For your entertainment!
https://youtu.be/OwqFGSqOMaI
Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk
crankshaft said:
For your entertainment!
https://youtu.be/OwqFGSqOMaI
Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did you do that? Kudos my friend.
craftycarper1 said:
Did you do that? Kudos my friend.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
For sure!
Here's another!
https://youtu.be/gcta3h5dA2M
Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk
havent yet with my new phone but my s7e has seen the water many times even recorded underwater
Took the plunge and tried it myself..........won't be trying it again as it just doesn't feel right submerging the phone!!
https://youtu.be/_aXNcS0gajI
I wouldn't make it a habit of purposely using the phone underwater.
Yes, it can take it.
Should you do it, on purpose? Not really.
Just as you don't test a fire extinguisher or even an airbag, it's reassurance in case of accident that your device won't be rendered inoperable.
Water still gets in things even though it doesn't get inside. The headphone jack has internal contacts and these will get contaminated with mineral deposits left behind from being exposed to water. Sea water is far worse as the salt residue that's left behind is highly hygroscopic (meaning it absorbs moisture) so every time the device is in a humid environment those surfaces become wet to the touch and that wetness is both highly corrosive AND conductive. This is why any gear, no matter what its waterproofness rating is, must be rinsed with *fresh* water after use in marine environments.
In short, your device continues to operate but make no mistake about it, you're reducing its useful lifespan with repeated dunks and swims.
I don't intend on giving mine any more dips.....and wouldn't dream of putting it in salt water...........but curiosity got the better of me when i went to the lake to see a couple of mates fishing
same if not better then the s7 edge.
I wash off my s7 edge before because i was working a car and grab te phone and it got dirty.
Also install water screen protector on my s7e , note 7 and s8+ all work fine.
cpufrost said:
I wouldn't make it a habit of purposely using the phone underwater.
Yes, it can take it.
Should you do it, on purpose? Not really.
Just as you don't test a fire extinguisher or even an airbag, it's reassurance in case of accident that your device won't be rendered inoperable.
Water still gets in things even though it doesn't get inside. The headphone jack has internal contacts and these will get contaminated with mineral deposits left behind from being exposed to water. Sea water is far worse as the salt residue that's left behind is highly hygroscopic (meaning it absorbs moisture) so every time the device is in a humid environment those surfaces become wet to the touch and that wetness is both highly corrosive AND conductive. This is why any gear, no matter what its waterproofness rating is, must be rinsed with *fresh* water after use in marine environments.
In short, your device continues to operate but make no mistake about it, you're reducing its useful lifespan with repeated dunks and swims.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
A sensible reply. Ever since the Sony Xperia Z was released I have been debating (arguing like crazy) with peers that these mobiles are NOT waterproof, they have the smallest amount of water resistance. If one reads the manual, and very VERY few owners do, they will realise this water resistance is more of a 'splash resistance' in reality.
Sure Sony had adverts with people making calls while standing in a swimming pool etc BUT soon realised their marketing mistakes. Swimming pool chemicals destroy the protective membranes and cause no end of other problems. I wished all manufactures would simply refer to the mobile as splash resistant.
I have written pages on this very subject. Even though Samsung write that the mobile may be submerged in water to a depth of 1.5M for 30 minutes this is so woefully subjective. Even at surface level immersion in water if you swish the mobile about the force of water induced by movement can and will penetrate the mobiles membranes, its simple lores of science. Sure if one very gently and slowly submerges the mobile to 1.5M for a short period in theory all should be well. WHO is going to do that and why would they?
The IP rating is in reality just saying one can answer the phone with wet hands and make a call in the rain. The mobile device is very VERY far from an underwater camera that is designed for that purpose.
To close, its not truly about depth of water and time but water pressure FWIW. Soap box awayyyyyy:laugh:
Ryland
Ryland Johnson said:
.
To close, its not truly about depth of water and time but water pressure FWIW. Soap box awayyyyyy:laugh:
Ryland
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is water pressure not down to the depth of water?
Depth pressure is a static reading.
If you toss the phone into a pool that's 1 meter deep the actual realized pressure, albeit brief, is going to be much higher.
This is why you cannot snorkel with a wristwatch rated at 50 meters. The deeper you want to go the more evident this becomes.
Ryland brings up this point that I left out but is painfully obvious to those familiar with it.
Showering with a device is much different than wearing it on your wrist or hip and walking around even if only submersed under a foot or two of water.
I've seen rainproof electrical enclosures fail and upon inspection find them full of water as if their covers were off during the storm. This happens because heavy rain with no wind and heavy rain with 100mph wind gusts are completely different things. They do make such enclosures that are designed for these conditions and they are much more expensive.
If you really want to play with your devices around the pool including dunking and shooting video underwater, invest in a waterproof case. And even then a few drops of water inside the case won't affect your device. Protection is always better in layers.
Just copied this from W'Pedia. I use watches as an example of how the general public are fooled into believing what is written on the back of ones daily watch, vis:..... Quote........
"Water resistance classification[edit]
Watches are often classified by watch manufacturers by their degree of water resistance which, due to the absence of official classification standards, roughly translates to the following (1 metre ≈ 3.29 feet). These vagueries have since been superseded by ISO 22810:2010, in which "any watch on the market sold as water-resistant must satisfy ISO 22810 – regardless of the brand." [5]
Water resistance rating Suitability Remarks
Water Resistant 3 atm or 30 m Suitable for everyday use. Splash/rain resistant. Not suitable for showering, bathing, swimming, snorkelling, water related work and fishing. Not suitable for diving.
Water Resistant 5 atm or 50 m Suitable for swimming, white water rafting, non-snorkeling water related work, and fishing. Not suitable for diving.
Water Resistant 10 atm or 100 m Suitable for recreational surfing, swimming, snorkeling, sailing and water sports. Not suitable for diving.
Water Resistant 20 atm or 200 m Suitable for professional marine activity, serious surface water sports and skin diving. Suitable for skin diving.
Diver's 100 m Minimum ISO standard (ISO 6425) for scuba diving at depths not suitable for saturation diving. Diver's 100 m and 150 m watches are generally old(er) watches.
Diver's 200 m or 300 m Suitable for scuba diving at depths not suitable for saturation diving. Typical ratings for contemporary diver's watches.
Diver's 300+ m for mixed-gas diving Suitable for saturation diving (helium enriched environment). Watches designed for mixed-gas diving will have the DIVER'S WATCH xxx M FOR MIXED-GAS DIVING additional marking to point this out." End quote.
As you can see a wrist watch rated at 30M is ONLY splash-rain proof!!!!!! Though I am not a horologist some of my family have been for generations and the topic of water resistance is very close to my heart after ruing a VERY expensive watch some many years ago in the shower?!
Ryland
I keep phones on average 3 months. I'm a serial upgrader. Ever since my s6 I've been habitually swimming with my phone's. Never had a issue other than maybe for 24 hours the speaker is miffeled....Now if you plan on actually keeping the phone for longer than the blink of an eye then if baby it. But I jump on demand waaaaaay too often.
craftycarper1 said:
Is water pressure not down to the depth of water?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes BUT. Its an awful lot more complex than that. There is static water pressure ie 1ATM per 10.33M of depth. Remember the surface is already measured at 1ATM . Add force of movement and those figures can go through the roof.
Fill your bath with water and allow your mobile to slowly sink to the bottom, generally no problem BUT if you hold the mobile in your hand and force it through the water even at 1" depth the force becomes another dimension of added pressure.
Our kids splash us with a garden hose and we all laugh. Get hit by a professional fire hose and it will take you for a ride down the street. Yet another example of water pressure.
The above poster says he regularly swims with his mobile. He adds he changes them every three months. Not only will the constant exposure to swimming pool chemicals degenerate the membranes on the mobile but one fine day he will be very surprised to find he has one screwed mobile.
Its a 1k€ device. I respect it for what it is. I also change phones at least 3-4 times a year but when I sell them they are brand new and have not been subjected to misuse. :highfive:
Ryland

Categories

Resources