New Nexus 5 Owner, Stock VS Custom ROM - Nexus 5 Q&A, Help & Troubleshooting

I bought a nexus 5, should arrive this week, to be activated on straight talk. Being a nexus 7 owner, I already know how custom Roms and kernels can help the device be more speedy.
Since the nexus 5 is already a fast device, is a custom ROM really needed? Or would xposed framework modules be sufficient enough along with optimized bionic and dalvik patches.
As for kernels, same question. I don't intend on over clocking, but is there any other advantage?
Thanks.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using xda app-developers app

datallboy said:
I bought a nexus 5, should arrive this week, to be activated on straight talk. Being a nexus 7 owner, I already know how custom Roms and kernels can help the device be more speedy.
Since the nexus 5 is already a fast device, is a custom ROM really needed? Or would xposed framework modules be sufficient enough along with optimized bionic and dalvik patches.
As for kernels, same question. I don't intend on over clocking, but is there any other advantage?
Thanks.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
For me I'm happy with stock rooted plus xposed. I removed the optimized bionic and dalvik patches as I couldn't run asphalt 8 without it.

I use custom ROM but close to stock as possible, with a custom kernel for additional controls over hardware and xposed Gravity to customize layouts.

If you're going to change ROMS for speed, there's honestly no point. The battery, speed, etc, are all great on stock .
Sent from my Nexus 5 using xda app-developers app

It's the same thing, xposed or custom, I prefer full package

I think the moderators will see this thread as a "best ROM thread"

mistahseller said:
I think the moderators will see this thread as a "best ROM thread"
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Because it pretty much is.
Just check out the roms and read the first post and see which one has the features you want.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk

After getting the device a couple months ago, I was on stock with xposed and franco for the first month. I decided to try out some custom ROMs but ultimately came back to stock. Xposed gives me all the customization I need.

Xpose FTW!
datallboy said:
I bought a nexus 5, should arrive this week, to be activated on straight talk. Being a nexus 7 owner, I already know how custom Roms and kernels can help the device be more speedy.
Since the nexus 5 is already a fast device, is a custom ROM really needed? Or would xposed framework modules be sufficient enough along with optimized bionic and dalvik patches.
As for kernels, same question. I don't intend on over clocking, but is there any other advantage?
Thanks.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've had my Nexus 5 for about 2 weeks now. I previously had a Samsung Galaxy S4 that was rooted with Xposed & Wanam Xposed and several other modules. When I came to Nexus 5, I unlocked the bootloader, but haven't flashed any other ROMs yet. I am running stock KitKat with Xposed & GravityBox installed. I am loving it. Also using a few other xposed modules like Crappalinks, etc. Gravitybox does about everything I need and I think I am about to donate to get the newly added "light flow" like features. Great Module!
I am also running the Franco Kernel & have installed the optimized Dalvik & Bionic. Phone is smooth as butter. Of course I'm using the Donation version of Greenify also. I've read up on quite a few Custom ROMs, but right now I don't see any major advantage to flashing one. Gravitybox & other Xposed modules give me all I need. Samsungs Knox & and AT&T's locked bootloader drove me away from the S4. Even though I don't have a custom ROM right, I always have the option if something great comes out. N5 is great because it's so open. Custom Recovery was a big deal for me also. TWRP all the way! Good luck with the phone when it arrives. You are going to love it!
- Jeremy

Thanks for all the feedback.
Not really trying to initiate a "best ROM" thread, just seeing if custom Roms are worth it.
On my nexus 7 I've found stock, elementalx kernel for OC, xposed, and the optimized patches worked best. Wasn't sure if this was also true for the nexus 5.
Looking forward to the phone!
Sent from my Nexus 7 using xda app-developers app

Related

Which 4.1.2 ROM do you recommend?

Giving my wife the White Galaxy S3 Verizon for Xmas and wanted to get recommendation which stock based ROM to install?
1. Hyperdrive
2. Jelly "Beans"
3. Axis
4. stock Verizon 4.1.2
5. other 4.1.2 based
I'm primarily interested in rock solid stability, and some of the Touchwiz experience. She might be getting the Note 3 in the future so I want her to get used to using some of Samsung apps. I have a second S3 for me and I'm testing 4.4 roms, currently installed CyanFox. So please keep discussion relevant to 4.1.2 roms and experience. I know 4.3 is out for Verizon, but I'll wait for Devs to build it into ROMs.
thanks and see visist my blog
tabletuser.blogspot.com LINK
In b4 thread lock.
Bone stock or cleanrom
Sent from my SCH-I535 using xda app-developers app
Bad to the Bone!
bby144 said:
In b4 thread lock.
Bone stock or cleanrom
Sent from my SCH-I535 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Bone stock looks awesome, going to give it a test run. Thanks
i run clean rom 7
bby144 said:
In b4 thread lock.
Bone stock or cleanrom
Sent from my SCH-I535 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Lol! Can't go wrong with those.
Light and clean (more optimized, less theming):
Tkrom, bonestock, cleanrom, obsessed
More heavily modified (extra mods and themes,):
Hyperdrive, goodness, axis, jellybeans, moar, wicked sensations, the people's rom
I'm maybe leaving a few out, but look them over and see what you want. If you want something simple and easy you can't go wrong with the top 4.
Some phones handle roms better than others, so if one isn't working out well then don't be afraid to try another.
I also want to point out that you have to make sure your wife's phone isn't on the 4.3 base (vrucml1). If it is, do not flash any custom roms, that bootloader is completely locked down.
Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
I've tried every single 4.1.2 TW rom out there, and my phone seems to run the best (least "Touchwiz" lag) on Hyperdrive with faux kernel. Completely stable, too. I also like the multitude of changes you can apply. However, you really can't go wrong with any of them. They all are great!
Like the above comment mentioned, make sure the OTA wasn't taken, although you probably know this.
They are all great, try them all.
As XDA is not a support site, users are expected to make this determination based on their own, individual use.
Thread closed

Switch from lg ROM to asop?

I have had many phones in the past and I always root and flash cm/aokp/etc roms. But for some reason I love the stock lg ROM. The only problem I am haven't is no one is making kernels for the 4.4.2. Rom and I don't want to back track too 4.2.2.
Has anyone switch to the asop ROM and has been happy with it?
Sent from my LG-D800 using Tapatalk
dondadah88 said:
I have had many phones in the past and I always root and flash cm/aokp/etc roms. But for some reason I love the stock lg ROM. The only problem I am haven't is no one is making kernels for the 4.4.2. Rom and I don't want to back track too 4.2.2.
Has anyone switch to the asop ROM and has been happy with it?
Sent from my LG-D800 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
well you do need to remember that 4.4 just came out about a month ago but it rolled out slowly and even now there are devices which haven't been updated yet plus the kernel needs to be modified to support the old boot and thus supporting custom recovery so people would need to incorporate that and the stuff they used in there previous kernels so we must be patient, plus today I saw the first kk kernel surface sadly it was for t-mo but that means can get one soon too
Edit: seems dorimanx might finally start working on kk kernel
Yea having a nexus 4 spoiled me by bad. But the nexus 5 is "half" the phone the g2 is. I'm currently looking at the cloudy roms something that doesn't have a lot of bloat in it but I can't live with out these features lg has incorporated in this rom
Sent from my LG-D800 using Tapatalk
dondadah88 said:
Yea having a nexus 4 spoiled me by bad. But the nexus 5 is "half" the phone the g2 is. I'm currently looking at the cloudy roms something that doesn't have a lot of bloat in it but I can't live with out these features lg has incorporated in this rom
Sent from my LG-D800 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've read a lot of good feedback on the the cloudystock and cloudypro plus I think the nexus is kinda bland in development sure it has a lot roms but there all the same aosp here there is variety flex/pro 2 and good devs/people
Sent from my LG-D800 running stock kk, rooted with philz using XDA app
I've always run CM (since OG Evo) but I was pretty impressed with the G2 stock system. LG has one of the most bloated interfaces on the market, but the camera app was really good.
I pretty much immediately put CM on it, and I'm pretty happy. For one thing, the very important knock-on and knock-off work very well with CM11 M4. The camera isn't quite as good as it is from the stock rom, but it is solid. Certainly a step up from my Nexus 4 on CM.
I might go back and try the LG rom again some more, good luck.

Who likes Stock CM Mod Better than Stock?

So I`m thinking of making the change over to CM Mod nightlys.
So I have just been running stock 4.4.2 with xposed.
Thinking about just using CM mod nightlys (I read that the nightlys are sometimes more stable than the snapshots)
And things seem nice and quick just playing around but I need something That wont give to many problems How has CM been lately? Also how is OTA updates? are they reliable enough to not have to keep wiping each time theres an update?
Thanks
Also Does Xposed Modules work on CM roms?
And is there a recommended kernel besides using the stock CM One?
There are alot of great roms... Alot better than cm.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using xda app-developers app
Kreateablaze said:
There are alot of great roms... Alot better than cm.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1000[emoji106]
sent from my Hammerhead Nexus
if you use nightlies of cm you will regular updates for sure.... you don't need to wipe anything for each update...it wont affect your data..
Sent from my LG-E975 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
Just try it for a while, at the end of the day its just about preference. The CM rom itself is rockstable and the stock kernel performs very well and offers good batterylife.
gee2012 said:
Just try it for a while, at the end of the day its just about preference. The CM rom itself is rockstable and the stock kernel performs very well and offers good batterylife.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What this guy said but to add, keep an open mind there are a lot of good ROM's out there. Purity and Mahdi come to mind. On my n4 I used carbon and couldn't wait to flash the next nightly but I got away from that.
I recommend Chaos Kernel since they went CAF or Elemental X has CAF version

Cataclysm Rom orphans thread

Since development on Cataclysm Rom has stopped I was wondering which roms Cataclysm Rom orphans are switching to ? I cant decide between Chroma and PureNexus
Chroma is great Pure NExus is also good. Give them both a go and pick one. I stuck with Chroma for a couple days and it was solid.
Maybe Atl4ntis will post his mod in some other way, when new source is out...
why you need to switch it now ?!
i have strong belief that Atl4ntis will come up with new mod when new factory image will arrive...he won't punish tons of loyal users just because of few morons ! :fingers-crossed:
so just have faith and wait ( if you don't have any other reason to switch the rom ,i personally don't find any reason to ditch cataclysm as of now )
what happened? Can you link me to the post, please?
I use the latest PureNexus ROM with ElementalX kernel. Very smooth and functional Android Experience. Battery is also not bad with about 5h Screen-On Time. (2G, WiFi, Messenger, Tapatalk, Feedly, Spotify)
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
I smell jealous competition...
Sent from my Nexus 6 using Tapatalk
Talvathir said:
I smell jealous competition...
Sent from my Nexus 6 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
looks like so.
but i still hope he will continue . or I also need to find new rom, where I can find almost same catalysm settings.
Good Lord - I guess I'd just thought I'd seen whiny douchebags until I read that link. Cry boy even has a fan club of sycophants. Not going anywhere for now, so I'll wait until the next release and see what happens. Too bad jealousy by a few ruin a good thing.
ranasrule said:
Since development on Cataclysm Rom has stopped I was wondering which roms Cataclysm Rom orphans are switching to ? I cant decide between Chroma and PureNexus
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Why development of cataclysm stopped............will it continue in near future................(noob)
officialrooter said:
Why development of cataclysm stopped............will it continue in near future................(noob)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
A link has already been posted.
I haven't had any issues with the Jan 5 Stable version, so I don't plan on going anywhere.
dinggus said:
A link has already been posted.
I haven't had any issues with the Jan 5 Stable version, so I don't plan on going anywhere.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Where is the link...............
officialrooter said:
Where is the link...............
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's on atl4ntis's android file host directory.
It's a shame that on xda, developers gets so frustrated by the community to leave it every month. I would lock the thread as read only and just post links, to report bug there could be just a thread in general section
Sent from Tapatalk using my Nexus 6P
Well, cataclysm is most stable rom around.
CM nightlies are not really stable (nobody expects so), and other ROMs which are mashups of all commits "dev" managed to merge can't be stable.
does someone have tried to flash catalysm 5.jan mod to stock MMB29Q?
Such a shame Cataclysm has disappeared. I enjoyed using it when I tried it last year. Well, I'm on stock unrooted as always these days. I like custom ROMs and the idea behind it, but seamless updates and mostly stability sway me in the direction of stock.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
Mairo said:
does someone have tried to flash catalysm 5.jan mod to stock MMB29Q?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yes you can use Jan 5 mod on 29Q.
Is anyone staying on Cataclysm or jumping ship?
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
Staying. Until android N. Or if there will be significant changes in between but I doubt there will be.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
I too am a Cataclysm orphan. I came across this thread, and am surprised I didn't see a link to the thread linked below. It is a great initiative by @magnamentis and @ben_pyett to create a support thread for users who want to keep using Cataclysm and help each other.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/android/general/info-cataclysm-mod-dead-t3307703
CataclysmMOD can indeed be flashed over Google's February Stock images, and possible later monthly Google Stock images as well.
It is quite remarkable that a ROM with such a rich feature set and so many customizations, no to mention rock solid stability, has been reduced to such a tiny mod (just 13 files plus the kernel) which can be flashed over stock images!

What's the best most popular custom rom? wanting to root my nexus 5 for first time.

Hi, what's the best most popular/stable custom rom image? one that's based on marshmallow 6.0+?
Or better yet using the stock android that allows root, which i'm guessing requires a pre modded flash image.
Is this the correct way to root? http://wccftech.com/flash-and-root-nexus-5-on-android-6-0-1-mmb29k/
thanks
Yes sir should be good. There is many to choose from Pure Nexus, Chroma, or CyanogenMod.
Stability is real good with Cataclysm is you can still find it.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
1. Read again and again
2. Flash again and again
3. Keep the one that fits your needs
CM based roms are pre-rooted so you don't need to flash SuperSU. BTW the mentioned guide uses outdated information. You should use XDA tutorials instead
marcusva79 said:
Yes sir should be good. There is many to choose from Pure Nexus, Chroma, or CyanogenMod.
Stability is real good with Cataclysm is you can still find it.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Here: http://forum.xda-developers.com/google-nexus-5/development/rom-cataclysm-nexus-5-t2518660

Categories

Resources