Database Info

Issue with MX video player on HFS

First,sorry for my English ,it isn't my main language
We all know there is an issue with HW media acceleration for video decode.So,I using MX video player to watch video .The video work great without lag but after 10s the sound of the video gone when the other sound like press,keyboard,notification sound are still here.Anyone have this issue ? Are there any solutions for this?
Thank in advance for reading .

Make sure to set it to only use SW decoding. HW decoding doesn't work 100%.
Sent from my LG-P999 using xda premium

Yes, SW decoding for both Video and Audio. By default, I think mine was set to HW for Video, and SW for audio.
Sent from my LG-P999 using XDA

CM9 and can't play mkv files

Hi,
I just installed CM9 alpha 4 teamchopsticks ROM yesterday and I have been trying to play some 720p mkv tv files with MX Player. I have tried others but they just won't play... I've tried locally and across the network via samba share to no avail. Any ideas?
thanks in advance!
any ideas?

dahunt said:
Hi,
I just installed CM9 alpha 4 teamchopsticks ROM yesterday and I have been trying to play some 720p mkv tv files with MX Player. I have tried others but they just won't play... I've tried locally and across the network via samba share to no avail. Any ideas?
thanks in advance!
any ideas?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I would post this in the ROMs thread, but try a different player and if that doesn't work then its probably not supported in the ROM.
<---- someone w/ no knowledge

dahunt said:
Hi,
I just installed CM9 alpha 4 teamchopsticks ROM yesterday and I have been trying to play some 720p mkv tv files with MX Player. I have tried others but they just won't play... I've tried locally and across the network via samba share to no avail. Any ideas?
thanks in advance!
any ideas?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Mx player in market
Edit: see next post. I broke my own rule and didn't READ. DOH.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I727 using xda premium

I've been playing mkvs just fine. Make sure to enable software decoding if hardware decoding doesn't work on the codec
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I727 using XDA

xTRUEx said:
I've been playing mkvs just fine. Make sure to enable software decoding if hardware decoding doesn't work on the codec
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I727 using XDA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Odd... i can't get any MKV files to play at all in soft or hardware decoding. The 720p mp4 files play only in software decoding mode and not hardware. hmmmm maybe your using a different kernel?

dahunt said:
Odd... i can't get any MKV files to play at all in soft or hardware decoding. The 720p mp4 files play only in software decoding mode and not hardware. hmmmm maybe your using a different kernel?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nope. Stock cm9 alpha 4.
Sounds like you need a fresh start.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I727 using xda premium

[Q] A question which i can't find a proper answer for. Answers in first post.

So what is high bigmem and bigmem? I know that it gets me more usable ram with a sacrifice of something. For example my 720p mkv video playback was broken. Was it becasuse of the rom or the kernel? I came from stock rom. On the stock rom I could watch "How I met your mother" 720p mkv but now I can. So the question is. How can I get the HW accelerated 720p mkv video playback back without losing vodoo sound and others? I tried non high bigmem versions but just didn't work. Any help would be much apriciated!
Edit:
Here's the answers in case anybody come across to this problem in the future. It was kernel related. To be exact it's bigmem I think. I've installed the stock ROM (with stock kernel ofcourse) and the video just started using the hw decoder. smooth 720p mkv. No lag at all. With subtitles. After that I installed a kernel with bigmem ( marmite 5.1 stock edition) and the video playback no longer worked. Now I'm using stock ROM with Simple kernel. Damn! I didn't know the stock ROM is faster than the AOKP one.

Zunex95 said:
So what is high bigmem and bigmem? I know that it gets me more usable ram with a sacrifice of something. For example my 720p mkv video playback was broken. Was it becasuse of the rom or the kernel? I came from stock rom. On the stock rom I could watch "How I met your mother" 720p mkv but now I can. So the question is. How can I get the HW accelerated 720p mkv video playback back without losing vodoo sound and others? I tried non high bigmem versions but just didn't work. Any help would be much apriciated!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
download "dice player"
the best HW accelerated player ever

qaz2453 said:
download "dice player"
the best HW accelerated player ever
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thanks for the tip but it didn't work for me. I can hear the sound but no video. After a few seconds the player freezes. Nowhere near compared to the stock. Anybody please help. I don't know whether it's the rom or the kernel. I'm using rasbeanjelly with marmite v5.

Zunex95 said:
thanks for the tip but it didn't work for me. I can hear the sound but no video. After a few seconds the player freezes. Nowhere near compared to the stock. Anybody please help. I don't know whether it's the rom or the kernel. I'm using rasbeanjelly with marmite v5.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
try air kernel or matrix
or it maybe the case of just re-flashing the ROM

qaz2453 said:
try air kernel or matrix
or it maybe the case of just re-flashing the ROM
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'll try matrix kernel! I've used air kernel for about 2-3 (when new version came out I upgraded immediately) but I could not watch 720p mkv either. I really miss 720p mkv playback feature but I just don't wanna go back to stock. So all my hope is in matrix kernel

Zunex95 said:
I'll try matrix kernel! I've used air kernel for about 2-3 (when new version came out I upgraded immediately) but I could not watch 720p mkv either. I really miss 720p mkv playback feature but I just don't wanna go back to stock. So all my hope is in matrix kernel
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
o ok
im running Stock rooted 4.1.2 (100.1% google experience rom) with air kernel and it works fine with dice player
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1854366 im telling you 4.1.2 is amazing!! jelly bean never worked on my phone but this works soo smoothly its unbelievable

qaz2453 said:
o ok
im running Stock rooted 4.1.2 (100.1% google experience rom) with air kernel and it works fine with dice player
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1854366 im telling you 4.1.2 is amazing!! jelly bean never worked on my phone but this works soo smoothly its unbelievable
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yes it's really cool! Latest rasbean jelly is 4.1.2. I would flash the stock rom if it had volume rocker music controls. it's the only thing which is holding me back.

On my Vibrant which is the same hardware, I use MX Player, generally h/w acceleration for video and set audio to software decoding. Play most MKV with no problem. The older version 1.6 also have a fast software mode that make it capable of playing almost any videos smoothly, but they took it away with the new version.
The bitrate of the video and your internal storage read speed do determine the playback smoothness.

eksasol said:
On my Vibrant which is the same hardware, I use MX Player, generally h/w acceleration for video and set audio to software decoding. Play most MKV with no problem. The older version 1.6 also have a fast software mode that make it capable of playing almost any videos smoothly, but they took it away with the new version.
The bitrate of the video and your internal storage read speed do determine the playback smoothness.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm using mx player too but it only plays that in software decoding mode. When I choose hw decoding mode it says that it cannot play it in hw decoding mode. Hw+ decoding mode won't work either. Tomorrow I'll flash back the stock rom with different kernel. See if it works.
Ps: Matrix kernel didn't work either. No hw playback.

It means the player do not have codec to decode that video, maybe you should reencode it to h.264 in mp4 container.
Also I recommend keeping a copy of the MX Player 1.6, it can even manage most hd video in software fast decoding. Sure it won't be highest quality, but the Nexus screen isn't exactly HD.

Zunex95 said:
yes it's really cool! Latest rasbean jelly is 4.1.2. I would flash the stock rom if it had volume rocker music controls. it's the only thing which is holding me back.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Playerpro music player has volume rocker controls.

If I recall correctly while the vibrant has basically the same hw it also has different hw. Including decoders. Like with the missing encoder for 720p video recording with the camera for example.
Can't remember exactly but I think it was Samsung with the galaxy s line that was able to play back mostly anything because they included encoders and all the licensing that goes along with it. Then again maybe not. I'm sure others know more or you can just investigate it yourself

albundy2010 said:
If I recall correctly while the vibrant has basically the same hw it also has different hw. Including decoders. Like with the missing encoder for 720p video recording with the camera for example.
Can't remember exactly but I think it was Samsung with the galaxy s line that was able to play back mostly anything because they included encoders and all the licensing that goes along with it. Then again maybe not. I'm sure others know more or you can just investigate it yourself
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'll try different combinations as soon as i got home. I know it works. It used to work tho.
Edit: I've edited the first post. Got my answers now. Thanks for the help guys!

[Q] cant play some mkv's

Hey there,
I mainly use my tab for videos and ebooks, and i faced problems in running some mkv's.
basically i was trying to play an anime video by coal girls but the player did not play it.
These are 720p videos with flac audio.
Also happens with videos by re-packers like horrible subs and gotwoot...
I know that the tab can play 720p mkv's watched a lot of 720p movies on it flawlessly. But then why does it fail to run these.
P.S. : I also tried mxplayer but it plays the video on s/w decoder and that too very poorly even after enabling multi core decoding for s/w decoder.
Thanks in advance.

a1shakes said:
Hey there,
I mainly use my tab for videos and ebooks, and i faced problems in running some mkv's.
basically i was trying to play an anime video by coal girls but the player did not play it.
These are 720p videos with flac audio.
Also happens with videos by re-packers like horrible subs and gotwoot...
I know that the tab can play 720p mkv's watched a lot of 720p movies on it flawlessly. But then why does it fail to run these.
P.S. : I also tried mxplayer but it plays the video on s/w decoder and that too very poorly even after enabling multi core decoding for s/w decoder.
Thanks in advance.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you upload a trailer or short clip you can't play(not too big just 3-4 minutes in which i can see problem).i will try to find a solution!!!

here is a sample
Droidlover123 said:
Can you upload a trailer or short clip you can't play(not too big just 3-4 minutes in which i can see problem).i will try to find a solution!!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
here is a sample
http://www.2shared.com/video/Clmodmua/Coalgirls_Magical_Girl_Madoka_.html

cant play 10 bit video's as well
well i tried playing some more videos, could'nt play 10 bit-720p-BD-AAC video's as well.. :crying:
Tried a lot of players, default samsung can't play it and players like mx and dice default to s/w which stutters so much that the video is unwatchable ...
I was hoping that someone had experienced it before and tried a custom ffmpeg i.e custom codecs to solve the problem.

a1shakes said:
well i tried playing some more videos, could'nt play 10 bit-720p-BD-AAC video's as well.. :crying:
Tried a lot of players, default samsung can't play it and players like mx and dice default to s/w which stutters so much that the video is unwatchable ...
I was hoping that someone had experienced it before and tried a custom ffmpeg i.e custom codecs to solve the problem.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Bro sorry I can't reply at the moment....pls wait a bit....
On which ROM u are???
Sent from my GT-P3100 using xda app-developers app

stock rom
Droidlover123 said:
Bro sorry I can't reply at the moment....pls wait a bit....
On which ROM u are???
Sent from my GT-P3100 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm on stock samsung unrooted 4.1.2 rom..

a1shakes said:
I'm on stock samsung unrooted 4.1.2 rom..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did you tried h/w+ mode in MX player?
See screenshot
Sent from my GT-P3100 using xda app-developers app

Yup tried that, didn't work
yup i tried that even allowed the 10 bit video option, the video which i have uploaded just won't play on h/w or h/w+........
Can't see any other option now.Why don't you try to play the video i have uploaded...
If you want the details :
Stream #1 :
type : video
codec : H264/AVC/ MPEG4-AVC/MPEG4 part 10
Resolution : 1280 x 720
Frame rate : 23.97602
Stream #2:
Type : audio
Codec : FLAC
Channels: stereo
Description : flac 2.0
Stream #3:
Type: subtitles
codec : ssa

plays fine on nexus 7
I played the same video on friend's nexus 7 and s2 which plays it pretty well on s/w decoder, however the tab 2 lags like hell in s/w decoder.....
Don't know what to do now...
Can anyone try the video sample i uploaded in post 3 and post the results....

a1shakes said:
I played the same video on friend's nexus 7 and s2 which plays it pretty well on s/w decoder, however the tab 2 lags like hell in s/w decoder.....
Don't know what to do now...
Can anyone try the video sample i uploaded in post 3 and post the results....
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yep bro I tried and it was a ****ty performance but still you can convert video in an supported format and it will be fine.......
Sent from my GT-P3100 using xda app-developers app

found a temporary solution
Droidlover123 said:
Yep bro I tried and it was a ****ty performance but still you can convert video in an supported format and it will be fine.......
Sent from my GT-P3100 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Or you can use splashtop 2 (free on market) to stream the video to the tab... Works perfectly for those who don't want to convert tons of videos...
Final conclusion : There seems to be a problem with the native h/w rendering capabilities...so no software can help it..
720p mkv + flac audio or 10 bit 720p videos are not playable natively mostly due to the poor gpu, and poor performance with s/w decoders.

I use BS player. It plays everything, using H/W decoder. Plays local, or off the network.
Use the ARMv7 version, and also download the BS hardware decoder, it is vastly improved over the stock or AOSP one.
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.bsplayer.bspandroid.free

Tried it but fails to work in h/w
wowmail said:
I use BS player. It plays everything, using H/W decoder. Plays local, or off the network.
Use the ARMv7 version, and also download the BS hardware decoder, it is vastly improved over the stock or AOSP one.
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.bsplayer.bspandroid.free
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Installed bs player free + arm v7 vfp cpu from market, but it still plays the video using s/w decoder with terrible frame rates. Frame dropping option also dosen't help. And when i choose h264 hi10 to be played on h/w decoder , there is black screen with only audio.
Try the sample which i have uploaded in post 3 and post the results. I'm on stock rom so maybe cm/aosp plays it better. If so i may install a custom rom..

not possible to play 10 bit videos at the moment
So i finally dug around the forums myself and realized that there is no android device that can play 10 bit encoded videos at the moment, not even tegra 3.......
source : http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1425664
At the moment, 10 bit encoding i fairly new and requires much more power than ur 8 bit mkv's which were used to have earlier.
So basically our tab can play 8 bit 1080p videos flawlessly, but fails to do so for a 10 bit 720p video on h/w decoding i.e ur stock samsung player will refuse to play it and all the players that u will try will play it on s/w decoder no matter what u try and yet u'll get very bad frame rates.
SO the solution is to :
1) re encode the videos, which did'nt work for me cuz i lose the subtitles while converting(some error)
2) can stream using splashtop2 ( free in play store) which is okay but need to have very high net speeds..... :/
If u cant play ur vid's properly, first see the details if they are 10 bit or hi10p if yes try the above.
Cheers

H/W decoder for MX player

Hi
I used h/w in MX for playing some mkvs without lag in some ROMs such as crdroid and candy ...
But now I'm using stock and I really need those codecs
Any idea what i should do?
PS I did try updated GPU drivers ... Same as before
Tnx a lot

SirMatin said:
Hi
I used h/w in MX for playing some mkvs without lag in some ROMs such as crdroid and candy ...
But now I'm using stock and I really need those codecs
Any idea what i should do?
PS I did try updated GPU drivers ... Same as before
Tnx a lot
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There is (or was at least) codecs in the Playstore for MX by the dev. I used to use them at least on previous devices.

Question belong in the Q&A section
Thread moved

radicalisto said:
There is (or was at least) codecs in the Playstore for MX by the dev. I used to use them at least on previous devices.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That is for old devices and has nothing to do with h/w

no idea?!

Have you tried VLC player? HW decoder seems to work fine by default.

Hd video player
i use HD VIDEO PLAYER by turtierun on playstore work's well on the new preview. regard's/ sorry greg just had to add that.

SirMatin said:
That is for old devices and has nothing to do with h/w
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There are neon codecs available through the app menu to allow h/w decoding of DTS over the network, if thats what you mean?

rootSU said:
There are neon codecs available through the app menu to allow h/w decoding of DTS over the network, if thats what you mean?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I did try that ... hw is still laggy

SirMatin said:
I did try that ... hw is still laggy
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Never had an issue with the correct settings. I'm on L now though so can't really compare now.

I finally figured it out
Its based on kernel. I flashed uber and hw was working without any laggs