Related
Just got my Nexus S 4G, running it 100% stock and not sure if I will ever root/ROM it yet. I can tether fine using built-in Wifi hotspot. As we know, the tether kills 4G and forces 3G when active.
I only actually have 3G at my house, so I can't test any other methods, but I am wondering if any other tethering tools will allow 4G tether? For example, Barnacle wifi or PDAnet USB... tools I've used in the past on rooted phones. And if either of these methods does work for 4G tethering... is root required? Would appreciate hearing from anyone who has 4G available nearby and has tested these methods on rooted/unrooted phones.
Thanks!
The111 said:
Just got my Nexus S 4G, running it 100% stock and not sure if I will ever root/ROM it yet. I can tether fine using built-in Wifi hotspot. As we know, the tether kills 4G and forces 3G when active.
I only actually have 3G at my house, so I can't test any other methods, but I am wondering if any other tethering tools will allow 4G tether? For example, Barnacle wifi or PDAnet USB... tools I've used in the past on rooted phones. And if either of these methods does work for 4G tethering... is root required? Would appreciate hearing from anyone who has 4G available nearby and has tested these methods on rooted/unrooted phones.
Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wifi tether for root users works, but it creates an ad-hoc network, so you can't connect with another android device. A laptop will be able to connect though
Sent from my Nexus S using XDA Premium App
Thanks... this might be the one thing that will drive me to root this phone eventually. Other than that I am fine with a 100% stock experience so far...
The111 said:
Thanks... this might be the one thing that will drive me to root this phone eventually. Other than that I am fine with a 100% stock experience so far...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can root and leave everything else stock. Rooting on this phone is trivial.
Non-root tether apps like Pdanet and EasyTether all run as regular apps on the phone. If running a normal app like Pandora preserves 4g status, then the 4g status should remain with those as well.
As for speed, you can look at a comparison that someone ran a few days ago across the popular USB tether apps:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1153780
krohnjw said:
Wifi tether for root users works, but it creates an ad-hoc network, so you can't connect with another android device. A laptop will be able to connect though
Sent from my Nexus S using XDA Premium App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
do you know why wireless tether works on the evo? my xoom can connect to an evo using wireless tether but my xoom cannot connect to a nexus s running wireless tether, i wonder why?
p-slim said:
do you know why wireless tether works on the evo? my xoom can connect to an evo using wireless tether but my xoom cannot connect to a nexus s running wireless tether, i wonder why?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Using the same wireless tether app or using the hotspot functionality built into the evo?
Sent from my Nexus S using XDA Premium App
krohnjw said:
Using the same wireless tether app or using the hotspot functionality built into the evo?
Sent from my Nexus S using XDA Premium App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
using the same wireless tether app, but don't worry i figured out the answer. Most androids tether thru adhoc but for some reason the evo is different and uses infrastructure mode, thats why my xoom can't pick up the nexus s signal but it can from the evo.
p-slim said:
using the same wireless tether app, but don't worry i figured out the answer. Most androids tether thru adhoc but for some reason the evo is different and uses infrastructure mode, thats why my xoom can't pick up the nexus s signal but it can from the evo.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's not entirely correct. Most newer phones have the capability to create an infrastructure network. It was more hit or miss on older phones.
The built in hotspot app does create an infrastructure network on the Nexus S. The 3rd party wifi tethering app creates an ad-hoc network though on the Nexus S for some reason. Unfortunately the built in tethering doesn't utilize the wimax radio currently.
The hardware on the nexus s does support creating an infrastructure network though, so I don't know why the wifi tethering app is creating an ad-hoc network if it has the capability to do infrastructure.
Sent from my Nexus S using XDA Premium App
krohnjw said:
That's not entirely correct. Most newer phones have the capability to create an infrastructure network. It was more hit or miss on older phones.
The built in hotspot app does create an infrastructure network on the Nexus S. The 3rd party wifi tethering app creates an ad-hoc network though on the Nexus S for some reason. Unfortunately the built in tethering doesn't utilize the wimax radio currently.
The hardware on the nexus s does support creating an infrastructure network though, so I don't know why the wifi tethering app is creating an ad-hoc network if it has the capability to do infrastructure.
Sent from my Nexus S using XDA Premium App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah this is putting me between a rock and a hard spot. I can root my xoom to pick up ad-hoc but I really want to keep it stock to be able to watch movies. sigh
Sent from my Nexus S 4G using Tapatalk
p-slim said:
Yeah this is putting me between a rock and a hard spot. I can root my xoom to pick up ad-hoc but I really want to keep it stock to be able to watch movies. sigh
Sent from my Nexus S 4G using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Why can't you watch movies rooted? I'd never watch a movie on a phone anyway, but the problem does make me curious.
p-slim said:
Yeah this is putting me between a rock and a hard spot. I can root my xoom to pick up ad-hoc but I really want to keep it stock to be able to watch movies. sigh
Sent from my Nexus S 4G using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Maybe shoot the dev an email. The hardware supports infrastructure and the AP can clearly do it. It may be a simple error in logic preventing the Nexus s from being detected as a device capable of infrastructure.
Sent from my Nexus S using XDA Premium App
The111 said:
Why can't you watch movies rooted? I'd never watch a movie on a phone anyway, but the problem does make me curious.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The movies app won't work on rooted devices. This is problematic if you use your tablet and the.movies app for renting movies.
Sent from my Nexus S using XDA Premium App
The111 said:
Why can't you watch movies rooted? I'd never watch a movie on a phone anyway, but the problem does make me curious.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I want to watch movies from the native movie app but it doesn't work on rooted devices. I like to watch movies from my Motorola xoom. I will send the dev an email but I'm pretty sure he knows about this
Sent from my Nexus S 4G using Tapatalk
I am assuming the photon only does ad-hoc. I have tried changing wifi tether to epic, evo, galaxy tab with no luck. I cant get the touchpad to discover my photon to try the bluetooth method. Any ideas?
Sent from my MB855 using XDA App
I thought using wifihotspot works and the tp picks up the signal and connects
Sent from my Desire HD using XDA App
Im using the wifi tether app, not the built in hotspot
Sent from my MB855 using XDA App
TP does not support Adhoc tething and some android phones can only do adhoc tethering and not true wifi/hotspot. I know some Android phones are using the beta version of wireless tethering but my phone won't run it, keep getting errors. So someone like me can't use their phone with their TP unless someone can develop a patch that would allow TP to accept Adhoc connections.
I am looking for the solution to this same problem. I have a photon and have used the wifi-tether app and my touchpad will not detect it. I know its because of the ad-hoc mode but is there a patch I can dl on the touchpad that can support ad-hoc mode?
we might have to wait until the port is done. Hopefully they will write it in.
tethering apk
I tether with my evo3d using beta v3 and I also tether with my wifes EVO shift and its using a tethering app from the market. No issues works with 3g and 4g
Sent from my PG86100 using XDA Premium App
Can't tether with my iPhone 3G and Vodafone 845. I know the phones can't do infrastructure mode, so it's obviously a limitiation of the touchpad/webOs lacking support for ad-hoc wifi.
We need something that at least enables ad-hoc mode on the touchpad, even better a new BT stack with DUN/PAN included.
jes24cap said:
tethering apk
I tether with my evo3d using beta v3 and I also tether with my wifes EVO shift and its using a tethering app from the market. No issues works with 3g and 4g
Sent from my PG86100 using XDA Premium App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
what(Preware) Kernel are you using?
I can tether to my X10a using 2.3.3 as a hotspot. I don't have the micro to micro usb to try the usb tether.
What I really like is the unmentioned 5Ghz Wifi. I can get 40 mbps via speedtest.net (I have 50 mbps at home).
Sent from my X10a using xda premium
I believe the evo's have infrastructure capabilities, where the photon does not.
dmoney94 said:
what(Preware) Kernel are you using?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Stock
Sent from my PG86100 using XDA Premium App
You need to use the built in tethering. I know Motorola has infrastructure mode. Not sure if the photon has the entitlement hack.
Trolling from my ATRIX 4G on probably the crappiest main US carrier
I don't seem to be able to access the Web on my gt+ if I wifi tether to my galaxy s2. Does it work for anyone here?
Sent from my GT-I9100 using xda premium
I tether to my Verizon SGS1 by using "Wireless Tether for Root Users" on market. If you are using an actual tether plan but it isn't working then I hope someone answers you as I think I'll run into a similar issue inside of 6 months.
Wireless tether for root doesn't work with wifi or Bluetooth on the s2 with standard rom or with hyperdroid ( the rom I use and arguably the best) I think it does on cm7 though
However I missed the built in wifi AP option on my s2 and through that I CAN connect!
I'm just about to put cm9 on my s2 to see what works with that
Sent from my GT-P6210 using xda premium
n
crunchie-uk said:
Wireless tether for root doesn't work with wifi or Bluetooth on the s2 with standard rom or with hyperdroid ( the rom I use and arguably the best) I think it does on cm7 though
However I missed the built in wifi AP option on my s2 and through that I CAN connect!
I'm just about to put cm9 on my s2 to see what works with that
Sent from my GT-P6210 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
in wireless tether for root app u need to enable the access control in setting
It looks like wireless tether is discontinued now and replaced with wifi tether 3
That seems to work on my s2 but whats the point when the phone has wifi AP built in anyway?
Sent from my GT-I9100 using xda premium
I think the idea behind it is to do tethering where the manufacturer or carrier has REALLY crippled tethering on the device. Pointless on any S2 - worst case you need to nuke AT&T's bigbrotherware on I777s.
Native tethering is superior to nearly all of the apps - it actually puts the device into access point mode, most other solutions use adhoc mode, which few Android devices support without hacks. Unfortunately, after talking to garyd9, it sounds like the Tab Plus has some weird Atheros customizations to wpa_supplicant, which means the adhoc-support-modified variants will probably fail on the 7 Plus.
tethering
Have you removed the tethering app from your S2? If not you need to remove that app using root file explorer from system, if you are rooted this will enable you to tether. I know it sounds too easy but it works. If it works for you please thank me.
pete0726 said:
Have you removed the tethering app from your S2? If not you need to remove that app using root file explorer from system, if you are rooted this will enable you to tether. I know it sounds too easy but it works. If it works for you please thank me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have never ran a stock ROM on my phone, could be why I've never had problems tethering. Been running miui on my mt4g pretty much the whole time I've had it. If you want native tethering in AP mode, flash either a cm or miui ROM
Sent from my HTC Glacier using Tapatalk
Works very well with sgs and sgss2 and my gt6210, all with root, but I dont remenber if I ma de the test before or after I root the tab
Anyway I use stock software to do it on each device, and no problème, it is like bluetooth, very easy and simple
Tethering works perfectly on any i9100 (as long as the user has a data plan)
Tethering on US iterations of the i9100 are completely carrier dependent.
Is it just me or is native tether slower than WiFi tether? Also can someone direct me to the latest WiFi tether treve mod apk please? Thanks.
Edit: OK so my native tether was working earlier today. Now when I go to use it, it reboots the hone everytime. While rebooting has been a natural thing on aosp roms, it always works after first reboot. Thoughts?
Sent from my SCH-I535 using xda premium
I have always found that the native tether does not work as well as an app for some reason but nobody has ever been able to tell me why.
Sent from my SCH-I535 using xda app-developers app
Anybody want to run some speed tests? It would be interesting to see, in numbers, the difference.
Sent from my SCH-I535 using xda app-developers app
I have personally done many,many, many speed test in the past and tested this issue b4 and from my experiences with it, app tethering is almost twice as fast and has a much more stable connection than native tethering. Feel free to d/l apps and try for yourself because I've done it and this is what I think. I use around 20 gigs a month tethering my ps3, personal business computer internet, streaming project free.tv. plus much more. I've spent plenty of time trying to get the fastest tethering speeds for these reason's and I use an app.
Sent from my SCH-I535 using xda app-developers app
i can test native because i pay for it
So I found the thread for the trevE mod tether. http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1988735
Also there is some good advice to get it working if it does not work. I finally got my WiFi tether app working by following suggestions on the thread.
Sent from my SCH-I535 using xda premium
CleanROM R2
CleanROM R2 allows tethering right out of the box for free using the native app. SpeedTest shows the same for me with it or PDANet+. In fact, it seems like PDANet+ is just a work-around frontend for the native app. FoxFi appears to be gone. When run, it just opens PDANet+.
For now, at least with CR R2, the native hotspot is all you need and CR has a toggle for that. Too cool!.
I know many ROMs now come with the native being functional and it is super nice to have a toggle or quickset tab for it, but like I said before, it just seems unreliable.
Sent from my SCH-I535 using xda premium
Hey guys I was just wondering what's the best setup or what you prefer. Right now I'm on ICS heard it and gb in some way were better for tethering and I'm using clockwork mod tether atm. Anyone got some tips/tricks I'm trying to game over it right now its almost not bearable. What's the best 4g modem also or does it all depend where your located
Sent from my SGH-T959V using xda app-developers app
Regarding modem, it all depends. Everyone's phone and location is slightly different, and so each modem option varies slightly.
Regarding the tethering, it all depends on what you want. If you just want something basic, if you want something complicated, if you want bluetooth tethering, if you want usb tethering, if you want wifi tethering. Also, remember that our phone only has G wireless, so it has speed limitations there.
For tethering apps, I'm a fan of both Barnacle (because it's been around forever and just works) and Wifi tethering for root users. Both work well, are free, and have a moderate scattering of options.
Thx a bunch did not know about the wireless limitations I will just USB tether from now on thx
Sent from my SGH-T959V using xda app-developers app