Personally, as I’ve written in other threads, I found the IMBZBK straightforward to install with an excellent result, including being able to turn off screen protector mode. I remained open-minded about the Whitestone Dome, which although somewhat more expensive has been around longer and has a premiere reputation.
I’ve now seen a YouTube comparison of both screen protectors, including their installation and the results, along with eight others. See here (they’re the 9th and 10th shown). YMMV, but to me the Whitestone installation seems much more difficult with more opportunities for something to go wrong. Does anyone here have personal experience with both?
If I'm not mistaken, I've used Whitestone back on my Pixel 2 XL way back when, but I too am using a IMBZBK screen protector(film). This new method for installing the screen protectors has easily became my favorite out of everytime I've ever applied one and I'm really glad all the makers of screen protectors seem to be adopting the same installation method.
As for the Whitestone, I understand reputation and all, but if something just works, I don't see the need in spending the extra cash but to each their own.
I too don't use screen protector mode on my device and the only time my fingerprint doesn't work is if it's oily, basically just not fully clean.
Since getting used to the MOCA glue method screen protectors starting with the Pixel 6 Pro, I'm hesitant to try anything other than Whitestone. I know I used one of these types of screen protectors before - might have been this brand, and I had a bubble I just could never get out - most other bubbles I got out, but there was one that was the bubble from hell. With the MOCA glue Whitestone Dome, I never even get a bubble to begin with. With a discount for the Whitestone Dome on the Pixel 7 Pro, it was ~$35 for a kit of two, one for my wife and one for me. I can handle that.
I'll probably stick with Whitestone until/if I ever have a bad experience.
But yes, to each their own, and what works for you is good.
Edit: I don't use screen protector mode, either. Fingerprint is still fast.
roirraW edor ehT said:
Since getting used to the MOCA glue method screen protectors starting with the Pixel 6 Pro, I'm hesitant to try anything other than Whitestone. I know I used one of these types of screen protectors before - might have been this brand, and I had a bubble I just could never get out - most other bubbles I got out, but there was one that was the bubble from hell. With the MOCA glue Whitestone Dome, I never even get a bubble to begin with. With a discount for the Whitestone Dome on the Pixel 7 Pro, it was ~$35 for a kit of two, one for my wife and one for me. I can handle that.
I'll probably stick with Whitestone until/if I ever have a bad experience.
But yes, to each their own, and what works for you is good.
Edit: I don't use screen protector mode, either. Fingerprint is still fast.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Respectfully, the point of comparing the Whitestone to the IMBZBK is that it, too, is a LOCA install, but easier and less open to error than the Whitestone (unless the YouTube video is misleading).
RebDovid said:
Respectfully, the point of comparing the Whitestone to the IMBZBK is that it, too, is a LOCA install, but easier and less open to error than the Whitestone (unless the YouTube video is misleading).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Whoops, LOCA, guess I wasn't as used to it as I thought. I was also working on home network earlier, hence MOCA.
My point was that my experience wasn't less open to error for me, but what's good for one person isn't necessarily what's good for all.
I think one difference between the Whitestone and IMBZBK may be the thickness of the glass. Whitestone used to say their glass was .33mm thick (about 3 yrs ago). although I can't find a recent statement on how thick it now is (think I saw somewhere that it was .26mm for the Pixel 6, but not sure). IMBZBK says theirs is .16mm thick.
I've done both the kits and in my particular case the IMBZBK had multiple issues. One of the screen protectors didn't have protective film on the back but they put the sticker on the back of the glass. I found the nubs or little colored clamps whatever they were in my case lifted the glass too high in one area so the adhesive didn't flow all the way. 2nd attempt there was a bubble in the same area to a lesser extent. I ended up cleaning the third one off and using the film to remove dust and just did it freehand no jig etc (which I've done multiple times before) and the application was perfect. I saw some users had similar issues to me and others had no problem at all with the install via their jig. So to me that shows there's a QC issue. That and them using their ratings from other products to give the p7p a high rating is kind of scummy imo.
Got the Whitestone and took off the IMBZBK and installed the Whitestone first time no issues with the kit at all. To me the glass feels better than the IMBZBK and the olephobic coat seems better as well. Plus not having to use a weight on the FP sensor (another possible point of failure) is a plus to me. Longterm we know Whitestone's adhesive will hold up and not lift and have webbing appear on the sides. Only time will tell how well the IMBZBK will hold up. Hopefully IMBZBK steps up their game and sorts out their QC issues and show they have a high quality long lasting product as competition is always a good thing.
My Whitestone arrives later today. The installation routine debate not withstanding I do see in the comparison video that the Whitestone is SHORTER in length than the IMBZBK. In other words there is more uncovered screen space above the selfie as well as at the bottom of the screen. I assume this is to mitigate any contact with a case that could cause the protector to lift up. So I guess it all depends on the case you are using as to how the protector looks after installation. I will be using a Spigen Rugged Armor which also arrives today so I will see how much of a gap is left between the Whitestone and the Spigen.
Installed my Whitestone. Fits perfectly. Using a Spigen Rugged Armor case and as usual it fits perfectly. The uncovered area above the selfie and at the bottom edge are as minimal as anyone could want using the Spigen case. I cannot speak to any other case(s) but I am pleased. The Whitestone installation was easy. Maybe not as "easy" as the olden days when you could just lay a FLAT 9H tempered glass screen protector on just about any phone...but easy nonetheless. I do encourage watching the installation video at least once to get the procedure in mind before starting.
I also appreciate the clear "tape" for the camera bump. Any protection against micro scratches is better than no protection. I figure if it gets boogered up over time I can just peel it off...no biggie!
Highly recommend both the Whitestone and the Spigen! YMMV
P.S. I did not have to redo any of my fingerprints! I also did not have to change the sensitivity setting for the fingerprints. So everything is good to go for me!
One more P.S. The Whitestone feels much smoother than even the original unprotected screen. Again YMMV.
Is there any discount codes for ordering Whitestone via Amazon?
In IMBZBK and Whitestone, it appears we have two first-rate, curved tempered glass screen protectors for the Pixel 7 Pro, both using LOCA and UV-curing. The main differences appear to be:
IMBZBK is $5, or 12.5%, less expensive than Whitestone.
Whitestone includes a more useful to some, because clear, rear camera protector. (I myself am not using the IMBZBK rear camera protector.)
IMBZBK includes three screen protectors; Whitestone only two. (For people seeking to protect more than one P7P, this can increase dramatically the cost-saving from using IMBZBK.)
Installing IMBZBK may be somewhat less prone to user error (based on my watching several YouTube videos; I have no personal experience with Whitestone).
Whitestone has a longer track record, which may provide greater confidence when considering spending c. 2.5-4 times more than on most (often less satisfactory) screen protectors.
jaseman said:
Installed my Whitestone. Fits perfectly. Using a Spigen Rugged Armor case and as usual it fits perfectly. The uncovered area above the selfie and at the bottom edge are as minimal as anyone could want using the Spigen case. I cannot speak to any other case(s) but I am pleased. The Whitestone installation was easy. Maybe not as "easy" as the olden days when you could just lay a FLAT 9H tempered glass screen protector on just about any phone...but easy nonetheless. I do encourage watching the installation video at least once to get the procedure in mind before starting.
I also appreciate the clear "tape" for the camera bump. Any protection against micro scratches is better than no protection. I figure if it gets boogered up over time I can just peel it off...no biggie!
Highly recommend both the Whitestone and the Spigen! YMMV
P.S. I did not have to redo any of my fingerprints! I also did not have to change the sensitivity setting for the fingerprints. So everything is good to go for me!
One more P.S. The Whitestone feels much smoother than even the original unprotected screen. Again YMMV.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do you think either of these screen protectors will go on sale for black Friday?
swieder711 said:
Do you think either of these screen protectors will go on sale for black Friday?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm not ignoring you. I just don't know.
IMBZK is currently on sale at Amazon for $28 (20% off). I am returning my Skinomi protectors because the edges are lifting up. Bought the IMBZK. After the return credit, net cost was $20. Arrives in 1 day.
Curiousn00b said:
If I'm not mistaken, I've used Whitestone back on my Pixel 2 XL way back when, but I too am using a IMBZBK screen protector(film). This new method for installing the screen protectors has easily became my favorite out of everytime I've ever applied one and I'm really glad all the makers of screen protectors seem to be adopting the same installation method.
As for the Whitestone, I understand reputation and all, but if something just works, I don't see the need in spending the extra cash but to each their own.
I too don't use screen protector mode on my device and the only time my fingerprint doesn't work is if it's oily, basically just not fully clean.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm with you. I love the process of installing Film Screen Protectors. I'm using a TOCOL protector, but have the same results with Screen Protector Mode off.
Jeez! That IMBZBK one is like a science experiment. lol
So, what happens to the adhesive when it's time to trade the phone in?
I'm using this LK screen protection. Used on S22U & now on my P7Pro.
Everthing works well including the fingerprint. It goes all the way to the curves of the screen
https://www.amazon.fr/gp/product/B0BG63SQ8R/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o07_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1
HipKat said:
Jeez! That IMBZBK one is like a science experiment. lol
So, what happens to the adhesive when it's time to trade the phone in?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Usually there's hardly any trace of it. A quick wipe down and you're set to go.
First time using these glass protectors that require curing. The Whitestone kit looks like a science experiment, it was a bit intimidating when I saw all the parts. But I watched an installation video twice and got mine installed smoothly and flawlessly on the first go. They really made it pretty fool proof.
My gripe is while I prefer and like the clear camera bar protector, they had no labels so I had no way of telling which is the right side. That installation didn't go as well
My IMBZBK installation went terrible. First attempt there were bubbles. Second attempt, I worked to remove all the bubbles before curing. Still had some bubbles, but even worse the surface of the protector was sticky and streaky. Maybe some of the glue got on the surface while I was dapping the excess off.
Amazon Returns is sending me a replacement. While packing up the old kit, I noticed that the frame was broken/cracked.
Hopefully, the installation will go better with the replacement kit. I need to be extra careful getting rid of any bubbles and keeping any glue off of the top surface.
Related
The Note 8.0 doesn't come with anything like a Gorilla Glass. So I guess, a ScreenGuard would be pretty important, especially for Guys who carry the 8.0 everywhere. So post your experiences, recommendations here for everyone to see.
P.S. The Note 8.0 is yet to be launched in my country(India), but eBay is already full with 2-3 dozen listings for Scratch guards ranging anywhere between 5-20 USD!!
Sent from my Spice Mi-310 using XDA
agambhandari said:
The Note 8.0 doesn't come with anything like a Gorilla Glass. So I guess, a ScreenGuard would be pretty important, especially for Guys who carry the 8.0 everywhere. So post your experiences, recommendations here for everyone to see.
P.S. The Note 8.0 is yet to be launched in my country(India), but eBay is already full with 2-3 dozen listings for Scratch guards ranging anywhere between 5-20 USD!!
Sent from my Spice Mi-310 using XDA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
While Samsung doesnt explicitly advertise it, there is certainly some sort of treated glass on the Note 8. The glass is comparable to the glass on the Note 2 both in thicknesses and hardness. I tested on one of the bank's test units and it can certainly take abuse, even so far as resisting scratches from coarse granite.
Sent from my GT-N5110 using Tapatalk HD
robyr said:
While Samsung doesnt explicitly advertise it, there is certainly some sort of treated glass on the Note 8. The glass is comparable to the glass on the Note 2 both in thicknesses and hardness. I tested on one of the bank's test units and it can certainly take abuse, even so far as resisting scratches from coarse granite.
Sent from my GT-N5110 using Tapatalk HD
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thats good to know. Though I wonder why Samsung would choose to do so?
Even if doesn't want to pay royalties to Corning for the Gorilla Glass, at least it could write "scratch resistant glass" in its specs.
Would certainly improve our impression of the build quality of the Note8.
robyr said:
While Samsung doesnt explicitly advertise it, there is certainly some sort of treated glass on the Note 8. The glass is comparable to the glass on the Note 2 both in thicknesses and hardness. I tested on one of the bank's test units and it can certainly take abuse, even so far as resisting scratches from coarse granite.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That really is bizarre that Samsung doesn't seem to mention anything about the quality of the glass--that seems like a big oversight on their part! It is good to hear your first-hand experience though--that is encouraging!
Perhaps at some point you or others could give a more detailed analysis of the glass quality, specific abuse it can withstand, etc.?
Even Gorilla Glass can be scratched from normal usage (as numerous reports by XDA users on various devices will attest). So don't take for granted that treated glass or GG makes your screen impossible to scratch.
Many people prefer the feel of going bareback with no protection, which is understandable. And its certainly a matter of preference. But its a simple fact that once you do scratch it, it really can't be undone. So if you are worried about scratches, better to protect it now, and not have to regret it later.
As far as what protector to buy, my recommendation would be to avoid the cheap ones. They tend to scratch easily, attract fingerprints, and you will be lucky to get them to last a couple months. Get a quality one in the $20 US range, as these are typically very difficult to scratch, actually attract less fingerprints and grime than the bare screen, and last a long time. I've had good quality protectors on my phone and my old tablet, that have been on for a year of more, and still look great. So in terms of durability and sheer quality, buying a good quality protector really pays off. Also, the wet apply type is much easier to install than dry.
Not sure what brands are available in the OPs home country. But I've had good luck with Skinomi and Zagg, but there are other high quality brands, as well.
redpoint73 said:
Even Gorilla Glass can be scratched from normal usage (as numerous reports by XDA users on various devices will attest). So don't take for granted that treated glass or GG makes your screen impossible to scratch.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1 to your opinion. Have seen some Gorilla glasses scratched.
Regards to applying, I would actually from a brick-and-mortar mobile shops, those guys are real experts at applying these.
Also, can anybody tell me the effect of the screen guard on the S-pen experience. Glossy or Matte. Which one would be preferrable? so as to not deteriorate the experience much
Sent from my Spice Mi-310 using XDA
redpoint73 said:
Even Gorilla Glass can be scratched from normal usage (as numerous reports by XDA users on various devices will attest). So don't take for granted that treated glass or GG makes your screen impossible to scratch.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well said!
agambhandari said:
Also, can anybody tell me the effect of the screen guard on the S-pen experience. Glossy or Matte. Which one would be preferrable?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm wondering about these questions too.
agambhandari said:
Regards to applying, I would actually from a brick-and-mortar mobile shops, those guys are real experts at applying these.
Also, can anybody tell me the effect of the screen guard on the S-pen experience. Glossy or Matte. Which one would be preferrable?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The wet apply screen protectors are pretty forgiving, and easy to apply. But having a pro do it is not a bad idea, if you are uncomfortable trying. If they mess it up, they typically just take it off and try again with a new protector (at no charge to you). Obviously not an option, if you do it yourself.
Can't comment personally on matte protectors. But some folks over at the HTC Flyer forum (my old tablet, that also has pen support) seemed to like the matte protectors, as the slightly textured surface felt a bit more like writing on paper. Using the pen on the glossy or non-matte variety is very similar to how it feels on the bare screen.
Matte protectors also cut down on glare. But they tend to give a "hazy" look to the screen that I find unacceptable.
redpoint73 said:
The wet apply screen protectors are pretty forgiving, and easy to apply. But having a pro do it is not a bad idea, if you are uncomfortable trying. If they mess it up, they typically just take it off and try again with a new protector (at no charge to you). Obviously not an option, if you do it yourself.
Can't comment personally on matte protectors. But some folks over at the HTC Flyer forum (my old tablet, that also has pen support) seemed to like the matte protectors, as the slightly textured surface felt a bit more like writing on paper. Using the pen on the glossy or non-matte variety is very similar to how it feels on the bare screen.
Matte protectors also cut down on glare. But they tend to give a "hazy" look to the screen that I find unacceptable.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the quick reply.
As a screen itself, I find Matte ones to be better, the viewing angles and sharpness can feel a notch down than the glossy, but the reduction in glare is pretty significant. I have it on one of my Laptops(also Samsung) and it feels very good.
I guess have to wait for others' views on the S-pen experience. Probably other Note devices have some opinions on other XDA sections, will try to find out
I hired the Geek Squad to install one of those InvisibleShield protectors from BestBuy when I got my Note 8, and had it on my tablet for about three hours. I took it off because it creates an incredible amount of friction with the S Pen's nub, making writing with the thing a fantastically aggravating chore (not to mention that the pen left track marks). I'm not saying that all screen protectors are so bad when it comes to this thing's core functionality, but InvisibleShield sure is. I'd be very curious about a protector with the lubriciously of the actual screen.
ZaphodAK42 said:
I hired the Geek Squad to install one of those InvisibleShield protectors from BestBuy when I got my Note 8, and had it on my tablet for about three hours. I took it off because it creates an incredible amount of friction with the S Pen's nub, making writing with the thing a fantastically aggravating chore (not to mention that the pen left track marks). I'm not saying that all screen protectors are so bad when it comes to this thing's core functionality, but InvisibleShield sure is. I'd be very curious about a protector with the lubriciously of the actual screen.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Could you throw some light on the material of the Screen Guard, was it glossy or matte?
So are you without the Guard now?
Sent from my Spice Mi-310 using XDA
Check out the thread I just made for the MiniGuard. It works very well!
Sent from my GT-N5110 using xda app-developers app
agambhandari said:
Could you throw some light on the material of the Screen Guard, was it glossy or matte?
So are you without the Guard now?
Sent from my Spice Mi-310 using XDA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The guard was glossy, near as I can remember. I am indeed without the protector.
Sent from my GT-N5110 using XDA Premium HD app
ZaphodAK42 said:
I hired the Geek Squad to install one of those InvisibleShield protectors from BestBuy when I got my Note 8, and had it on my tablet for about three hours. I took it off because it creates an incredible amount of friction with the S Pen's nub, making writing with the thing a fantastically aggravating chore (not to mention that the pen left track marks). I'm not saying that all screen protectors are so bad when it comes to this thing's core functionality, but InvisibleShield sure is. I'd be very curious about a protector with the lubriciously of the actual screen.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The ZAGG InvisibleShield screen protectors are the type applied with a liquid solution. Any of these type of screen protectors need to sit untouched for at least 24 hours to completely dry and become hard. Otherwise if you use your device before the skin has had a chance to completely dry, it will be slightly gummy at first, then a bit harder but still a bit of a rubber-type surface when using a stylus, which causes the stylus tip grab or stutter across the surface. Even when dry, these have a slight Orange Peel surface that I don't care for. YMMV. IME these also don't work well or last very long in Tropical or humid enviroments.
I've never liked any of the wet-application protectors for these reasons...I've tried the Zagg's, Skinomi's and one other I can't remember. I'll stick to the SGP/Steinhill Ultra Crystal dry-application protectors. Unfortunately, these aren't available yet for the Note 8.0.
Just my .02
bbfoto said:
The ZAGG InvisibleShield screen protectors are the type applied with a liquid solution. Any of these type of screen protectors need to sit untouched for at least 24 hours to completely dry and become hard. Otherwise if you use your device before the skin has had a chance to completely dry, it will be slightly gummy at first, then a bit harder but still a bit of a rubber-type surface when using a stylus, which causes the stylus tip grab or stutter across the surface. Even when dry, these have a slight Orange Peel surface that I don't care for. YMMV. IME these also don't work well or last very long in Tropical or humid enviroments.
I've never liked any of the wet-application protectors for these reasons...I've tried the Zagg's, Skinomi's and one other I can't remember. I'll stick to the SGP/Steinhill Ultra Crystal dry-application protectors. Unfortunately, these aren't available yet for the Note 8.0.
Just my .02
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Huh... that liar. The guy at BB told me that the protector would be just fine and dandy after two hours, which is why I bailed after trying to use it for an hour. Oh well. At least it provided about an hour of amusement as my buddy and I attempted to rip or puncture the plastic with everything we had in the house (we were unsuccessful, even with ceramic knives and a motorized hand drill) (edit- after I had taken the protector of my tablet, of course). I'll keep an eye out for one of the dry applicators that you mention. And I'll apply it myself, after reading the instructions with my own eyes.
Sent from my GT-N5110 using XDA Premium HD app
ZaphodAK42 said:
I'll keep an eye out for one of the dry applicators that you mention. And I'll apply it myself, after reading the instructions with my own eyes.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Be aware that dry apply is much more difficult to put on. With wet apply, you have time to slide it around, into just the right position, before you squeegee the excess application fluid out. With dry apply, its basically like a sticker, if you are off by just millimeters as you start to place it, you have to peel it back and start over, likely getting more fingerprints on the edges every time you do that.
Also, for some reason I can't explain, the wet apply gets much less dust under the protector as you apply it. The wet apply protectors I've used (twice now) have gone on flawlessly, and dust free as far as I can see. Before this, I used the dry apply many times. It took some practice before I could really get a dust free application. The first few I did, had a good amount of dust under them until I learned to go it just right. Even with experience, it takes a lot of care to get a dust free install with the dry apply. With wet apply, its pretty effortless.
I couldn't tell you why the wet apply seems to get less dust under them during installation. It doesn't make sense by conventional wisdom. Maybe dust particles just get carried away, when you squeegee the excess application fluid away.
I'd recommend doing the shower trick with the dry apply type (and it doesn't hurt with wet apply either) to reduce the amount of dust in the air while you do the install. That is, run a hot shower for 10 minutes or so, to steam up your bathroom. This pulls much of the dust out of the air. Then bring your tablet in there and apply the protector (don't leave it in there before or after the install, to minimize the time the device is exposed to high humidity).
Its true that dry apply does have a smoother finish and less tacky feel then wet apply. They tend to not suffer from the "orange peel" look. But the orange peel look on good quality wet apply protectors tends to be hardly visible when the screen is off, and not visible at all when the screen is on. But this might vary depending on the room's lighting conditions. To me, the orange peel is not a bother, but that is probably a personal preference.
The experts who put the guards here, first polish the device display to a great extent and then put the guard straightaway.
The one they applied on my phone, had a good protective covering which was peeled as the guy applied more and more. Even after this, there was another protection over the actual guard.
Also the screen guard wasnt specifically for my device, he also cut it out as per my device after the application.
Sent from my Spice Mi-310 using XDA
bbfoto said:
The ZAGG InvisibleShield screen protectors are the type applied with a liquid solution. Any of these type of screen protectors need to sit untouched for at least 24 hours to completely dry and become hard. Otherwise if you use your device before the skin has had a chance to completely dry, it will be slightly gummy at first, then a bit harder but still a bit of a rubber-type surface when using a stylus, which causes the stylus tip grab or stutter across the surface. Even when dry, these have a slight Orange Peel surface that I don't care for. YMMV. IME these also don't work well or last very long in Tropical or humid enviroments.
I've never liked any of the wet-application protectors for these reasons...I've tried the Zagg's, Skinomi's and one other I can't remember. I'll stick to the SGP/Steinhill Ultra Crystal dry-application protectors. Unfortunately, these aren't available yet for the Note 8.0.
Just my .02
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I emailed Spigen SGP asking if they were going to make one for the Note 8 and they said they had no plans to do so. i was certainly disappointed to hear that. I have one of their protectors on my note 2 and its great. I agree with you, the dry apply protectors are so much smoother than the wet ones and do not have orange peel or get that "sticky" feeling.
there is another thread with a review of the MiniGuard protectors which look to be of the dry apply variety. i almost bought some the other day when i ran across them at amazon and now that the review confirmed it (with pics too), this looks like the best option since Spigen wont be making anything.
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00BXQUQ9U/ref=oh_details_o01_s00_i00?ie=UTF8&psc=1
Turbo Brian said:
there is another thread with a review of the MiniGuard protectors which look to be of the dry apply variety. i almost bought some the other day when i ran across them at amazon and now that the review confirmed it (with pics too), this looks like the best option since Spigen wont be making anything.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That is too bad about Spigen SGP. If you (or others) try out the MiniGuard protectors consider letting us all know your impressions (and whether you went with Clear or Anti-Glare). @JokeZony0u has done a great review of the Clear protectors, but I think it is still helpful to have multiple datapoints for these kinds of things.
^^Thanks for that. Yeah, it looks as if the MiniGuard is the dry-app protector to get since Spigen SGP is out of the equation. Hopefully we'll get more good reviews of other protectors as well.
I agree that the hot, steamy shower technique is good. Also have some small, clean pieces of 3M Scotch Tape handy to pluck off any dust particles from the screen or the contact side of the protector film. I use a large microfiber cloth lightly dampened with isopropol alcohol to clean the entire device beforehand. Then I use the included microfiber cloth to further clean the screen just before applying the protector.
There's a good YouTube video on the best way to apply the dry protectors.
You line the protector up on your screen first (before removing any layers).
Then once the film is aligned properly, hold it in place and attach two pieces of blue painter's tape to the top of the protector film and just along ONE SIDE of the phone/tablet...one near the top and one near bottom, so that the screen protector flaps open to one side like a page in a book, using the blue painter's tape as a hinge.
Flip it open & out of the way and clean the screen again with your microfiber cloth. Double-check your alignment and readjust if necessary.
Then peel back the bottom film layer, remove it completely, and slowly apply the screen protector from the taped side to the free side.
Sqeegee out any bubbles.
Lift the protector just slightly with another small piece of blue painter's tape if you need to remove any dust particles with your Scotch Tape.
Sqeegee again and make sure the alignment is good.
Only remove the side positioning tape if you are satisfied with the application and alignment.
Finally, carefully remove the temporary top layer from the main screen protector film, being careful not to lift the main protector film.
I've used these on a couple different devices now, and in my opinion/experience they are by far the best screen protectors! For years I bought Ghost Armor screen protectors, but I'd never go back to Ghost Armor now. Techmatte protectors are priced much lower, yet still offer a lifetime warranty, and they feel and look MUCH better! I installed it almost 3 weeks ago, but wanted to review it after I had for used a while so I could say how it looked and held up over time. Fortunately, just like every TechMatte protector I've used in the past these don't scratch and don't peel up over time. So 2 weeks after installing it still looks absolutely perfect! On the Note 4 they cover the screen up to where the glass begins to curve, so there is no issue of it not sticking anywhere or causing any odd visual appearance like glass protectors do. The cutouts for the camera, sensors, speaker, and home button are all perfect and precisely where they should be. In the package you receive 3 screen protectors, micro-fiber cleaning cloth, squeegie, 5 hinge stickers, rubber bands for holding the protector in place while you're applying the hinge stickers, and instruction manual. Anyone who's used the hinge method for installation in the past will tell you that there is no better way. I won't install a screen protector without doing the hinge method now, as it makes the installation fool proof and assures a perfect install. I had never used rubber bands prior to this installation, but it really helped out a lot. I got the install done perfectly the first try, as the hinge method assures everyone will, and installing in the bathroom while the shower is running hot water will keep any dust out of the air. Feel free to ask any question you have.
http://www.amazon.com/Protector-amF...merchant-items&ie=UTF8&qid=1417850152&sr=1-20
EDIT : A few pics added
Completely agree with everything you said. I've only had mine on for 3 days and its like it isn't even on the device.
The feeling of a glass protector is the best, but with none of those really working for the Note4, these protectors cannot be beat.
For $3.99 it's a hell of a bargain.
Do you mind posting a picture of the screen protector itself or on your phone? The picture on the product page isn't very clear.
I've had it on my Note 4 for two weeks now. I don't worry about having keys in the same pocket now. Damn near invisible with the Speck CandyShell Grip Case. I'm actually thinking about cutting one of the protectors down multiple times to make some camera lens protectors, since I ordered 2 packets at that price. I'll post here if successful.
Just installed mine last night and am happy with it.
Added a few pics. Let me know if you want to see a close-up of a specific area, specific angle, whatever. I'll take my Note 3 with me tonight, just in case any has any requests.
Thanks for posting pics. I was hoping the screen protector would extend farther than the display and up until where the glass starts to curve.
Now that people are starting to receive their phones and accessories from OnePlus, I am very curious to hear people's thoughts on the official tempered glass protector offered from OnePlus.
Specifically, how does it fit with the OEM cases OnePlus offers. Most importantly, does it fit with the thicker OnePlus Bumper cases?
The good news, according to OnePlus's official install video posted on their website, it does look like it fully adheres to the screen.
https://www.oneplus.com/oneplus-6-3d-tempered-glass-screen-protector
Looking forward to feedback before I place an order for one to potentially replace the pre-applied plastic screen protector.
sn0warmy said:
Now that people are starting to receive their phones and accessories from OnePlus, I am very curious to hear people's thoughts on the official tempered glass protector offered from OnePlus.
Specifically, how does it fit with the OEM cases OnePlus offers. Most importantly, does it fit with the thicker OnePlus Bumper cases?
The good news, according to OnePlus's official install video posted on their website, it does look like it fully adheres to the screen.
https://www.oneplus.com/oneplus-6-3d-tempered-glass-screen-protector
Looking forward to feedback before I place an order for one to potentially replace the pre-applied plastic screen protector.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't get my phone until later today, so I can not confirm until then. But the two different customer service reps I talked to guaranteed the TGP works with the OEM bumper cases. They said the only case it isn't compatible with is the outterbox case.
suprstar29 said:
I don't get my phone until later today, so I can not confirm until then. But the two different customer service reps I talked to guaranteed the TGP works with the OEM bumper cases. They said the only case it isn't compatible with is the outterbox case.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Looking forward to your results! If it does fit with the OEM bumper case (specifically the Nylon bumper case for me) I'll use my $20 promo voucher to order the glass protector as well.
I will say the preapplied plasic protector surprised me.wkth how good it feels. I usually do a glass protector but once I get my I will probably leave the plasitc on to see how it wears. Be good for the long term review since most on even know it's there at first
Sent from my Pixel 2 using Tapatalk
Here take a look at this. I''ve just posted it to the official forums to I'll C+P here;
----
Hi all,
Hope you've not forgotten me! I'm back. I went down to the London launch as I was super excited to see the OnePlus 6 in person and I've now got my hands on the phone and the official tempered glass. So as I have done every year, I'm going to be testing out as many accessories that I can get my hands on, starting with the Official Tempered Glass Screen Protector!
Feel free to watch the video to get all this information, or just scroll down and read it if you prefer!
Some of you wonder why take of the pre-applied factory screen? Well for me, it's all about finding the best protection for your device and from experience the pre-applied screen is not that. It's a nice bonus, as if you're not buying the official you'll have to wait around a week or so before third party manufacturers get screens ready for sale. Mine was also riding slightly high on the screen, which meant using it whilst having gestures turned on was a bit of a nightmare.
As usual the screen protector, comes well packaged, with some excellent tools- most of which you won't need if you're taking the pre-applied screen off and then putting this one on straight away.
The screen protector as with the last few years comes on a single slab of plastic/glass, which you will need to be careful off when you're removing the screen protector from it. I've seen many people CRACK their screen protector at this point. Don't be that person! Go slow, but surely. And for goodness sake once you've peeled it off, don't turn it around and let all the dust particles in your house get on it!
The screen protector fits nicely on the phone and feels pretty decent. High quality!
Postives -
- Feels good
- Looks good
- Fits with the free case
Negatives -
- Finger print magnet - seriously, had it on for a few minutes and it was covered.
- Still has the black border, so you DO still get a 3D effect where you're missing an (admittedly small) portion of your screen
- Hardest OP screen protector I've ever put on.
Let me know if you have any questions on it, and I'll endeavor to keep you all updated on how it functions!
Thanks!
^ Dang! I can't believe how difficult it was for him to remove the bubbles with that protector. And in the end it still had a bubble that kept returning. This sure did make me glad I opted not to pay extra for that tempered glass protector. It's almost as if it doesn't have strong enough adhesive.
Regardless, I plan on sticking with the pre-applied screen protector for a bit before making a decision on a glass protector. In fact, if the pre-applied protector holds up well, I may not ever bother taking it off. I must say that it would be really nice to finally get a phone and never even worry about spending money on a screen protector, or trying to perfectly apply one, for that matter.
I just hope my pre-applied protector isn't positioned too high, as the above video reviewer mentioned his was.
unfortunately my preapplied screen protector is a tiny bit too high for my taste too, so when swiping up with gestures enabled you can feel the slight edge :/
I really hope whitedome is going to bring a TGSP for the OP6 on the market
niijonodhg said:
Here take a look at this. I''ve just posted it to the official forums to I'll C+P here;
----
Hi all,
Hope you've not forgotten me! I'm back. I went down to the London launch as I was super excited to see the OnePlus 6 in person and I've now got my hands on the phone and the official tempered glass. So as I have done every year, I'm going to be testing out as many accessories that I can get my hands on, starting with the Official Tempered Glass Screen Protector!
Feel free to watch the video to get all this information, or just scroll down and read it if you prefer!
Some of you wonder why take of the pre-applied factory screen? Well for me, it's all about finding the best protection for your device and from experience the pre-applied screen is not that. It's a nice bonus, as if you're not buying the official you'll have to wait around a week or so before third party manufacturers get screens ready for sale. Mine was also riding slightly high on the screen, which meant using it whilst having gestures turned on was a bit of a nightmare.
As usual the screen protector, comes well packaged, with some excellent tools- most of which you won't need if you're taking the pre-applied screen off and then putting this one on straight away.
The screen protector as with the last few years comes on a single slab of plastic/glass, which you will need to be careful off when you're removing the screen protector from it. I've seen many people CRACK their screen protector at this point. Don't be that person! Go slow, but surely. And for goodness sake once you've peeled it off, don't turn it around and let all the dust particles in your house get on it!
The screen protector fits nicely on the phone and feels pretty decent. High quality!
Postives -
- Feels good
- Looks good
- Fits with the free case
Negatives -
- Finger print magnet - seriously, had it on for a few minutes and it was covered.
- Still has the black border, so you DO still get a 3D effect where you're missing an (admittedly small) portion of your screen
- Hardest OP screen protector I've ever put on.
Let me know if you have any questions on it, and I'll endeavor to keep you all updated on how it functions!
Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for this! Your videos are always great when it comes to these things. Keep up the great work!
Do you think the bit the pops up might simply be just because of the curvature of the screen towards the corner?
(curved screened phones are always a nightmare when it comes to putting screen protectors on). If the underside of the screen protector is curved aswell in order to fit the curved screen of the device, even a fraction of difference can cause these kinds of problems, whereas flat ones you can even get away with them positioned slightly off, and they will always sit down perfectly flat.
Can you confirm whether the curvature of the OnePlus 6's screen is just around the edges, or is it the whole of the front that is actually curved?
(If you see what I mean).
I could be wrong, but from what I can see on the video, it does almost look like it's the whole screen that is rounded and not just the edges (but it's hard to tell from a video, so can't know for sure)
sn0warmy said:
^ Dang! I can't believe how difficult it was for him to remove the bubbles with that protector. And in the end it still had a bubble that kept returning. This sure did make me glad I opted not to pay extra for that tempered glass protector. It's almost as if it doesn't have strong enough adhesive.
Regardless, I plan on sticking with the pre-applied screen protector for a bit before making a decision on a glass protector. In fact, if the pre-applied protector holds up well, I may not ever bother taking it off. I must say that it would be really nice to finally get a phone and never even worry about spending money on a screen protector, or trying to perfectly apply one, for that matter.
I just hope my pre-applied protector isn't positioned too high, as the above video reviewer mentioned his was.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My pre-applied protector only lasted an hour on mine. The edges don't stick enough to avoid random lint and dust from sliding just a bit underneath it. Also the swipe up gestures from the bottom of the phone feel weird as you bump the protector. I'm not sure but I think it's because the protector is a bit thick.
Sent from my ONEPLUS A6003 using Tapatalk
jlczl said:
My pre-applied protector only lasted an hour on mine. The edges don't stick enough to avoid random lint and dust from sliding just a bit underneath it. Also the swipe up gestures from the bottom of the phone feel weird as you bump the protector. I'm not sure but I think it's because the protector is a bit thick.
Sent from my ONEPLUS A6003 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That’s a shame. My phone arrives today and we leave for Mexico tomorrow for a week. I was hoping the pre-applied protector would be perfect. The edges of it are probably going to look like garbage by the time we get back.
the protective film, can not attach clean and then Euro 22, so I can not recommend. Shade for the money
unix2208 said:
the protective film, can not attach clean and then Euro 22, so I can not recommend. Shade for the money
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What?
I really like the TGP. It fits seamlessly with the nylon case where the edges go all the way to the case and it feels completely natural. I thought the black outlining would bother me, but it works really well with the phone. I highly recommend the OEM TGP. No issues with it being compatible with the bumper case.
I have read on a Dutch forum that there is only glue on the edges of the screen protector. The middle is coated with some sort of oil so you won't see any bubbles.
This would explain the YouTube video with the corner not sticking. Could somebody confirm this?
This is a problem with all "curved edge" phones. Really makes me wish Samsung did not have as much sway in the market as they do. We would still have flat screens!
JCreations said:
I have read on a Dutch forum that there is only glue on the edges of the screen protector. The middle is coated with some sort of oil so you won't see any bubbles.
This would explain the YouTube video with the corner not sticking. Could somebody confirm this?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sent from my Pixel 2 using Tapatalk
suprstar29 said:
I really like the TGP. It fits seamlessly with the nylon case where the edges go all the way to the case and it feels completely natural. I thought the black outlining would bother me, but it works really well with the phone. I highly recommend the OEM TGP. No issues with it being compatible with the bumper case.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
More importantly, how difficult was it to get a bubble free install?
JCreations said:
I have read on a Dutch forum that there is only glue on the edges of the screen protector. The middle is coated with some sort of oil so you won't see any bubbles.
This would explain the YouTube video with the corner not sticking. Could somebody confirm this?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The tempered glass screen protector from OnePlus has adhesive throughout the entire protector, not just around the sides. Watch an install video and you'll see.
sn0warmy said:
More importantly, how difficult was it to get a bubble free install?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It wasn't to bad. There were a couple of stubborn small bubbles, but it you press and hold on them for a second or two with the included tool they go right away. I have a completely bubble free TGP that took maybe 2 minutes to put on
suprstar29 said:
It wasn't to bad. There were a couple of stubborn small bubbles, but it you press and hold on them for a second or two with the included tool they go right away. I have a completely bubble free TGP that took maybe 2 minutes to put on
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well crap. Now I wish I went ahead and ordered the protector with the phone. Now I've got to get through a week in Mexico with the pre-applied protector and hope it doesn't peel up until I get back.
Ordering the TGSP from OnePlus right now. Thanks for your input.
Just installed it and it looks great in my opinion! Wasn't that hard. If you apply it with the included case on, it helps a ton with lining it up; you literally just need to drop it into place.
I did get a couple pieces of dust underneath but they are super small and hardly noticeable, so I don't want to risk lifting the protector to remove it (risking more dust to get under) (or risking losing adhesion).
It does have a bit of that "3D look" but I got used to it very quick and now I don't notice it.
If there is text way at the edge of the screen, it does slightly get cut off but luckily most apps/websites don't have text that close to the edge.
Overall it's a solid protector and I'm probably going to stick with it until the end of its life (unless it cracks or something of course lol).
Are you gong to buy a Tempered glass screen protector for your S10? First screen protector that comes into mind is the Whitestone Dome but this one is going to be very expansive. What screen protector are you going to use?
If you really want a great protector that's the one I would buy...I think you get two in package... I'm planning on not installing one of the phone comes with pre installed one ...if. I do get one it will be White Dome
iPhone X
My tip is to hold off on getting tempered glass protector first because of how it might affect the ultra sonic fp sensor
geekhunt said:
I have ordered mine from GadgetShieldz you can give it a shot. There screen protector seems to work completely fine with the ultra sonic fingerprint sensor.
https://www.gadgetshieldz.com/galaxy-screen-protectors-guards-covers/
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That is NOT tempered glass, and the phone already comes pre-installed with one of these types of screen protectors on it... So you just wasted $10 lol.
JoeFCaputo113 said:
That is NOT tempered glass, and the phone already comes pre-installed with one of these types of screen protectors on it... So you just wasted $10 lol.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Lol, the pre-installed screen protectors that you are talking about is a joke. These cheap ones get scratched up in no time. Tempered Glasses don't work with the Ultrasonic Fingerprint scanner on the S10 phones. The ones that work (white stone) are not available until 3/22 and don't ship outside US.
I got this Gadgetshieldz one as these kind of self healing TPU screen protectors are the ones that are compatible with the S10 series phones currently. Like the Zagg invisible shield. MKBHD even did a test on these. And for the 10$, I am getting a screen protector, a protector for the back, sides and camera lens. Might change these once something reasonable is available.
geekhunt said:
Lol, the pre-installed screen protectors that you are talking about is a joke. These cheap ones get scratched up in no time. Tempered Glasses don't work with the Ultrasonic Fingerprint scanner on the S10 phones. The ones that work (white stone) are not available until 3/22 and don't ship outside US.
I got this Gadgetshieldz one as these kind of self healing TPU screen protectors are the ones that are compatible with the S10 series phones currently. Like the Zagg invisible shield. MKBHD even did a test on these. And for the 10$, I am getting a screen protector, a protector for the back, sides and camera lens. Might change these once something reasonable is available.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Mobilefun have stock and ship outside the US
bkdodger said:
If you really want a great protector that's the one I would buy...I think you get two in package... I'm planning on not installing one of the phone comes with pre installed one ...if. I do get one it will be White Dome
iPhone X
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Whitestone has been proven to work with the security on the phone. Pricey. 50 bucks but you get 2 glass shields in case you do break one
I HIGHLY recommend the Whitestone protectors. The adhesive makes them SUBSTANTIALLY more chip/crack resistant and the touch sensitivity is light years ahead of other protectors (like ZAGG). It was my go-to on Note and now S10+.
I am a minimalist and finally found a case that's thin but also adds SOME protection. TORRAS on Amazon. The hard plastic has a matte finish, amazing touch and feel but little protection. The silicone option is thin, has ridges to protect camera and screen but slides in pants and pockets easily. It DOES offer drop protection relatively.
hey guys came across this,
cheap alternative to whitestone.
I think its only for aus. not sure.
https://www.amazon.com.au/Adhesive-...552533038&sr=8-1&keywords=galaxy+s10+nalistic
whitestone dome doesn't work
clueless25 said:
Whitestone has been proven to work with the security on the phone. Pricey. 50 bucks but you get 2 glass shields in case you do break one
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Whitestone dome glass protector disables my finger print sensor effectively. My hit rates are less than 50% on the scanner. I've tried everything to get this to work such as re-registering prints, enable touch sensitivity, updating software. My install was perfect since I've had experience with this product before. I really wanted this to work, further their customer support is impossible to get ahold of.
I have 1 Whitestone TGSP but I'm not installing it until I get the two pack. I have never installed this before so I want the extra ones to use in case I goof the first install, and then (hopefully) have a spare if I crack the 2nd one.
johnny_debt said:
Whitestone dome glass protector disables my finger print sensor effectively. My hit rates are less than 50% on the scanner. I've tried everything to get this to work such as re-registering prints, enable touch sensitivity, updating software. My install was perfect since I've had experience with this product before. I really wanted this to work, further their customer support is impossible to get ahold of.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Actually it doesn't! Numurous vids on ytube show it. If your concerened, de register your fingerprint, install Whitestone and them re-register your prints. If you follow some of the comments here. People are using it., when you get into the system. delete the current prints and redo them
Edit: on a side note. I actually redid my fingerprints today because now I am getting familiar with the phone and how im holding it. Once I did that, now it unlocks wayyy better. I havent installed whitestone yet. price changed and 80 bucks for 2 Yikes! You said 50% of the time you can gt in the phone. when you do, delete the current ones and turn off the finger print sensor, turn the phone off and then back on and re-register
clueless25 said:
Actually it doesn't! Numurous vids on ytube show it. If your concerened, de register your fingerprint, install Whitestone and them re-register your prints. If you follow some of the comments here. People are using it., when you get into the system. delete the current prints and redo them
Edit: on a side note. I actually redid my fingerprints today because now I am getting familiar with the phone and how im holding it. Once I did that, now it unlocks wayyy better. I havent installed whitestone yet. price changed and 80 bucks for 2 Yikes! You said 50% of the time you can gt in the phone. when you do, delete the current ones and turn off the finger print sensor, turn the phone off and then back on and re-register
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Those are YouTube videos that show it works on a single unlock. I'm not disputing that it never works, it just doesn't work adequately enough. A youtuber showing a single unlock does not mean it works. When compared to a physical sensor on prior galaxy devices the success rate is likely almost 100%. The whitedome stone glass makes it incredibly harder to get an unlock on the s10 (less than 50% success for me). See the amazon reviews, there are numerous reviews claiming issues with this glass protector. Further you can find additional evidence of the issues on subreddit for galaxys10.
I understand that some may not be installing this correctly, but I know i have since I've done this numerous times. As stated above, i've re-registered finger prints, updated software and enabled touch sensitivity. I don't think this is a dud either since there are numerous reports of it not working properly.
johnny_debt said:
Those are YouTube videos that show it works on a single unlock. I'm not disputing that it never works, it just doesn't work adequately enough. A youtuber showing a single unlock does not mean it works. When compared to a physical sensor on prior galaxy devices the success rate is likely almost 100%. The whitedome stone glass makes it incredibly harder to get an unlock on the s10 (less than 50% success for me). See the amazon reviews, there are numerous reviews claiming issues with this glass protector. Further you can find additional evidence of the issues on subreddit for galaxys10.
I understand that some may not be installing this correctly, but I know i have since I've done this numerous times. As stated above, i've re-registered finger prints, updated software and enabled touch sensitivity. I don't think this is a dud either since there are numerous reports of it not working properly.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's a bummer! There was 1 vid I was trusting, he didnt just unlock it once... It makes me wonder about the readng/light sensitivity with the new system. BUT I wouldnt want samsung to dumb it down and leave us at risk
clueless25 said:
That's a bummer! There was 1 vid I was trusting, he didnt just unlock it once... It makes me wonder about the readng/light sensitivity with the new system. BUT I wouldnt want samsung to dumb it down and leave us at risk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Believe me when I say that I really wanted this to work because I love glass protectors. But it just simply didn't after everything I've tried.
Not sure I understand the light sensitivity you are referring to but this is an ultra sonic finger print reader which basically uses sound waves that bounce off your finger to map your prints. I think the issue is that these sound waves are having issues propagating through the glass protectors/loca glue, although they seem to have no issue going through the gorilla glass.
Would anybody be interested in a write-up on how I finally figured out the perfect DIY Whitestone dome equivalent for the Pixel 4 and Pixel 4 XL? When I say equivalent, I mean equivalent, not a bootleg janky version but a version I believe even surpasses white stone in a few aspects. It took me about a year and around $200 total before coming to this combination I use now and I was just curious if anyone else was as heartbroken as me when Whitestone did not come out with a protector for our phones and if so, be interested in my findings?
Some of you may be wondering what the benefit would be of using a liquid adhesive install over the millions of full adhesive screen protectors you can get on Amazon nowadays. Well, the biggest one is actually touch sensitivity. You may think your touch is perfect with a regular screen protector but once you try this white stone equivalent you will be surprised by how much more sensitive and immediate everything is. The second advantage is screen protection. The liquid adhesive ends up giving a bit more substance than the adhesive that comes on screen protectors, giving your phone a much better barrier between the protector and screen also there's better shock absorption.
If enough people are interested in my findings I will Make a detailed write up with install instructions and where and what products to purchase.
Reserved
I'm interested to see what worked for you. I've been using an Omoton brand protector on my 4 and it's been working well so far. I've gotten into the habit of applying LOCA (liquid optically clear adhesive) for screen protectors around the edges after applying it to prevent lifting. It also just cleans up the look a bit as the edges don't show as much anymore.
I'm interested.
Please share