Related
Hello,
I got my Google Pixel literally two days ago and I was looking around xda and other websites for root on this phone. And so far, I haven't seen anything simple. I saw that Chainfire has rooted the Pixel and Pixel XL but I read some comments saying that if you installed the OTA update, then it won't work And I unfortunately installed an OTA that was available.
It was just overall confusing to read considering this isn't my first Android phone or is this my first root.
So I was wondering if I can still root the phone I have that's running Android 7.1.
I got my phone a few days ago as well, made sure everything was entirely up to date, and then rooted two days ago without a problem. I started with the boot-to-root version and then I updated to SR5... no problems thus far!
Fastboot boot TWRP and flash the newest SuperSU in the TWRP thread. Should work fine if you want stock recovery. But, this is Google.. boot TWRP then flash the TWRP zip then flash SuperSU. Be happy. Don't take otas and update via fastboot and repeat above steps.
???? said:
I got my phone a few days ago as well, made sure everything was entirely up to date, and then rooted two days ago without a problem. I started with the boot-to-root version and then I updated to SR5... no problems thus far!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What's an SR5 and what's the boot-to-root method?
k.s.deviate said:
Fastboot boot TWRP and flash the newest SuperSU in the TWRP thread. Should work fine if you want stock recovery. But, this is Google.. boot TWRP then flash the TWRP zip then flash SuperSU. Be happy. Don't take otas and update via fastboot and repeat above steps.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So fastboot boot TWRP, then the TWRP zip and finally SuperSU?
binaryn00b said:
What's an SR5 and what's the boot-to-root method?
So fastboot boot TWRP, then the TWRP zip and finally SuperSU?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, fastboot boot TWRP, once booted in, flash the TWRP zip (it flashes to both partitions) then flash the SuperSU zip. Reboot, profit.
k.s.deviate said:
Fastboot boot TWRP and flash the newest SuperSU in the TWRP thread. Should work fine if you want stock recovery. But, this is Google.. boot TWRP then flash the TWRP zip then flash SuperSU. Be happy. Don't take otas and update via fastboot and repeat above steps.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is updating via fastboot same as nexus format?
Fastboot flash boot/system/cache(na in pixel) /recovery(?)/vendor
Asking cause there's so many new files inside the Ota zip folder.
queerquirks said:
Is updating via fastboot same as nexus format?
Fastboot flash boot/system/cache(na in pixel) /recovery(?)/vendor
Asking cause there's so many new files inside the Ota zip folder.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Here's a good guide: http://www.androidcentral.com/how-manually-upgrade-your-nexus
binaryn00b said:
What's an SR5 and what's the boot-to-root method?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you see here there are different builds. SR3 (boot-to-root) does NOT use TWRP, so I used that and then I updated to SR5 here.
My Google Pixel will be here in a few days. I downloaded these files:
SR5-SuperSU-v2.78-SR5-20161130091551.zip
twrp-3.0.2-0-alpha2-fastboot-sailfish.img
(I also have twrp-pixel-installer-sailfish-3.0.2-0-alpha2.zip on hand in case I need it.)
Will this method work?
Copy SR5-SuperSU-v2.78-SR5-20161130091551.zip to the device
adb reboot bootloader
fastboot boot twrp-3.0.2-0-alpha2-fastboot-sailfish.img
From TWRP install the SR5 zip
I don't need TWRP for anything more than rooting (which I have always done on my Nexus devices), but I keep seeing instructions where a TWRP img is first booted, then a TWRP zip is installed. Is it necessary to install TWRP in order to root because of the new partition layout, or can I root by simply booting to TWRP?
CatThief said:
My Google Pixel will be here in a few days. I downloaded these files:
SR5-SuperSU-v2.78-SR5-20161130091551.zip
twrp-3.0.2-0-alpha2-fastboot-sailfish.img
(I also have twrp-pixel-installer-sailfish-3.0.2-0-alpha2.zip on hand in case I need it.)
Will this method work?
Copy SR5-SuperSU-v2.78-SR5-20161130091551.zip to the device
adb reboot bootloader
fastboot boot twrp-3.0.2-0-alpha2-fastboot-sailfish.img
From TWRP install the SR5 zip
I don't need TWRP for anything more than rooting (which I have always done on my Nexus devices), but I keep seeing instructions where a TWRP img is first booted, then a TWRP zip is installed. Is it necessary to install TWRP in order to root because of the new partition layout, or can I root by simply booting to TWRP?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can just root by booting twrp. Don't have to flash it if you don't want to. Though it could be useful for flashing other zips and kernels.
Sent from my Pixel using Tapatalk
CatThief said:
My Google Pixel will be here in a few days. I downloaded these files:
SR5-SuperSU-v2.78-SR5-20161130091551.zip
twrp-3.0.2-0-alpha2-fastboot-sailfish.img
(I also have twrp-pixel-installer-sailfish-3.0.2-0-alpha2.zip on hand in case I need it.)
Will this method work?
Copy SR5-SuperSU-v2.78-SR5-20161130091551.zip to the device
adb reboot bootloader
fastboot boot twrp-3.0.2-0-alpha2-fastboot-sailfish.img
From TWRP install the SR5 zip
I don't need TWRP for anything more than rooting (which I have always done on my Nexus devices), but I keep seeing instructions where a TWRP img is first booted, then a TWRP zip is installed. Is it necessary to install TWRP in order to root because of the new partition layout, or can I root by simply booting to TWRP?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i just did this, exactly. one thing I didn't anticipate is TWRP asking me for a 'password' in order to decrypt the filesystem. I had to provide my PIN as I don't use a password. everything went fine!
poolemit said:
i just did this, exactly. one thing I didn't anticipate is TWRP asking me for a 'password' in order to decrypt the filesystem. I had to provide my PIN as I don't use a password. everything went fine!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you for reminding me. I always keep screen lock disabled on my devices, so I assume I need to set up a PIN with the Pixel. I recall a bug in a prior version of TWRP for the Nexus 9 where there was a prompt for a password, but even after I set one up and tried again I couldn't get into recovery. It sounds like it actually works this time.
Thank you guys for all the help! I managed to successfully root my phone and install TWRP.
One thing I'm having trouble with right now is that in Titanium Backup, when I try to change the file directory, it says that I cannot access the '/' folder.
Any help?
Also, another small thing. I remember in the Pixel Launcher, instead of the date appearing next to the Google search icon, the weather would appear. I messed around with all the settings I could find, and I can't seem to change the date back to the weather. Is that something that can be changed in Nova Launcher or no? Because I'm gonna recreate the Pixel Launcher in Nova.
Hello folks,
I have a Pixel sailfish and I am on Nougat 7.1.2. I would like to just root it via Magisk. Bootloader is unlocked and i tried the latest version of TWRP 3.2.1.2 and latest Magisk 16.0, Magisk Manager is 5.7. Heres the problem, if I tried to flash TWRP and then reboot into recovery (to check if TWRP sticks) I could not access my files because they are all encrypted. I did removed all pass codes, fingerprint etc. Is there a specific version of TWRP, Magisk that I need to install on Nougat 7.1.2? My process is as follow (assume fresh Nougat is onboard):
1. Boot into bootloader
2. Fastboot twrp zip
3. In twrp, flash twrp .zip
4. Reboot into recovery to see if twrp sticks
5. If 4 passes, then flash Magisk zip (version 16)
6. Reboot into system
7. Install Magisk manager apk file
8. Open Magisk manager.
Please let me know,
Thank you very much
I would like to point out that my main goals are: run stock 7.1.2 and root. That's it, no fancy kernels or anything. 8.1 and 8.0 stock are killing my battery so i would like to do some tests on 7.1.2.
You can try set a pin, twrp in nougat worked perfectly.
So when you go in twrp with a pin set, it will 100% ask you the pin for decrypt.
Also, not sure if you made a writing mistake, but you have to fastboot the img, not the zip of twrp
Thanks for this but i still have the same problem. Setting pin in Nougat, then reboot into bootloader, fastboot the .img file works. When in TWRP, it asks for my pin, i enter and manage to decrypt my data. Then I proceed to flash install tpwrp.zip. Process ends well but then when I reboot the phone, then reboot into TWRP (already installed). TWRP is there which means that the installation process is ok. However, this time, it does not ask for my PIN, there is only a slide bar to "Swipe to allow modifications". I did so and my file manager only has a bunch of files with weird letters. I assume these are encrypted. Obviously, I cannot flash install Magisk.zip here. So I tried the following:
1. Fastboot the twrp.img to get into TWRP
2. Do not install TWRP but go to file manager and flash the Magisk.zip
3. The process ended well. I rebooted
4. Phone booted fine. I then installed Magisk Manager v5.7 (latest from XDA) via apk.
5. Installation ended ok.
6. I opened up Magisk Manager and got stuck at the Boot Logo.
I hope these are detailed, please let me know if you can help me.
Thank you very much
TENN3R said:
You can try set a pin, twrp in nougat worked perfectly.
So when you go in twrp with a pin set, it will 100% ask you the pin for decrypt.
Also, not sure if you made a writing mistake, but you have to fastboot the img, not the zip of twrp
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
maxwell0312 said:
... there is only a slide bar to "Swipe to allow modifications". I did so and my file manager only has a bunch of files with weird letters. I assume these are encrypted...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Looks like some kinda problem with this twrp version.
Have you tried an older one, just to be sure? From what I remember, latest version made for nougat was 3.1.1 (?) but I'm not sure.
Maybe just try a 3.2.0, for example. Just boot it to avoid problems, don't flash the zip since you are not sure.
Otherwise, you can always try the manual boot.img patch method for magisk, so you don't have to use a recovery (official magisk thread -> installation instructions -> Via magisk manager)
These are only my ideas, not sure if they're gonna work or not.
TENN3R said:
Looks like some kinda problem with this twrp version.
Have you tried an older one, just to be sure? From what I remember, latest version made for nougat was 3.1.1 (?) but I'm not sure.
Maybe just try a 3.2.0, for example. Just boot it to avoid problems, don't flash the zip since you are not sure.
Otherwise, you can always try the manual boot.img patch method for magisk, so you don't have to use a recovery (official magisk thread -> installation instructions -> Via magisk manager)
These are only my ideas, not sure if they're gonna work or not.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you very much for your help, I managed to fix and make TWRP stick, so no problem there. Problem now is Magisk doesnt work. Is there a problem with my order:
Flash Magisk.zip in TWRP.
Reboot. Install Magisk Manager then open it. I got stuck at this step. Magisk Manager is frozen upon open.
If anyone has any ideas, please let me know.
Thank you
maxwell0312 said:
...
Flash Magisk.zip in TWRP.
Reboot. Install Magisk Manager then open it. I got stuck at this step. Magisk Manager is frozen upon open.
...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think for this you better ask in magisk forums. Stable version of magisk also installs the manager apk, I noticed that beta versions don't.
You can find better support in official magisk thread :good:
Hey
maxwell0312 said:
Thank you very much for your help, I managed to fix and make TWRP stick, so no problem there. Problem now is Magisk doesnt work. Is there a problem with my order:
Flash Magisk.zip in TWRP.
Reboot. Install Magisk Manager then open it. I got stuck at this step. Magisk Manager is frozen upon open.
If anyone has any ideas, please let me know.
Thank you
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What version of TWRP did you use..More like what did you do..I am having the same problem.
I used TWRP 3.1.2.0 and 3.2.1.0. All failed. I figured that after flashing TWRP.zip via TWRP Recovery (which you get to after you do fastboot boot twrp.img from PC) , you would need to pick the correct Slot to reboot. Once you boot into the correct slot, then flashing Magisk.zip would work, I think. I kept messing around with reboot into A and B and got tired of it. Now I switched to Resurrection OS for sailfish, got all I want: theming and rootless support. I actually tried to go back to stock 7.1.2 myself to test if batteries improved. It turned out that it didnt really matter much. Also, if you are into Substratum theming like I do, its better to use an OMS rom
Fixed (update)
hardhead808 said:
What version of TWRP did you use..More like what did you do..I am having the same problem.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I flashed TWRP 3.1.1-1 then of course went in a recovery bootloop...Just flash SU..... PROFIT
maxwell0312 said:
I used TWRP 3.1.2.0 and 3.2.1.0. All failed. I figured that after flashing TWRP.zip via TWRP Recovery (which you get to after you do fastboot boot twrp.img from PC) , you would need to pick the correct Slot to reboot. Once you boot into the correct slot, then flashing Magisk.zip would work, I think. I kept messing around with reboot into A and B and got tired of it. Now I switched to Resurrection OS for sailfish, got all I want: theming and rootless support. I actually tried to go back to stock 7.1.2 myself to test if batteries improved. It turned out that it didnt really matter much. Also, if you are into Substratum theming like I do, its better to use an OMS rom
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I found that when I use the uninstall magisk then flash magisk zip, if you watch closely, magisk will install some files to slot b also. Most of the time it will automatically download magisk manager. As far as battery life, my pixel XL was never better on 8.1. I installed the app is 9 preview 2 and my battery life is even better. You should move forward not back.
Good luck
fiverings said:
I found that when I use the uninstall magisk then flash magisk zip, if you watch closely, magisk will install some files to slot b also. Most of the time it will automatically download magisk manager. As far as battery life, my pixel XL was never better on 8.1. I installed the app is 9 preview 2 and my battery life is even better. You should move forward not back.
Good luck
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What is your SOT when go back with root? Also, what are the versions of TWRP and magisk that you use?
maxwell0312 said:
What is your SOT when go back with root? Also, what are the versions of TWRP and magisk that you use?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
TWRP version is 3.2.1-2
Magisk is 16.0 version
Magisk is 16.4 installed version
Magisk Manager is 5.7.0
I read somewhere that I should be on 16.2 or 16.3 I read that after I installed 16.4 it didn't work at first, but about 4 or more hours later it started working. I'm certified and pass all tests. After installing Magisk, I always clear cache & data from play store app, then clear just cache from play store services.
Sot, I usually can get around 8 with 15-20% left
Good Luck
fiverings said:
TWRP version is 3.2.1-2
Magisk is 16.0 version
Magisk is 16.4 installed version
Magisk Manager is 5.7.0
I read somewhere that I should be on 16.2 or 16.3 I read that after I installed 16.4 it didn't work at first, but about 4 or more hours later it started working. I'm certified and pass all tests. After installing Magisk, I always clear cache & data from play store app, then clear just cache from play store services.
Sot, I usually can get around 8 with 15-20% left
Good Luck
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks. I am on the smaller OG Pixel with 2770 mAh battery. I got 6h15 mins of SOT with 5% left. Not sure if this is normal
Was this problem ever resolved? I've been having problems that seem similar. I'm trying to use TWRP with Magisk and the stock google 9.0 for my Pixel, but I keep getting stuck. Wonder if someone has complete set of steps with specific versions of each of the necessary components.
bad post
Hello, I'm still a noob trying to learn, so far with help of this forum I've learned to unlock and root my first android phone, now I'm trying to learn how to properly keep my device updated!
Can someone please give a little rundown to what are the correct steps to update OTA on a rooted twrp device?
I've been browsing the forums a lot but I seem to find a lot of different approaches, or too vague instructions.
It would be greatly appreciated if someone could help me out, step by step, and explain the steps with the commands I need to put in, if there are any.
Thank you
download the ota from here
place it on your phone
go to update on you phone then hit the cog and hit local update
let it up date
reboot to boot loader
fastboot twrp img again
then flash the installer
reboot recovery
then it will boot back in to recovery again
flash root
job done
Hello,
To save you having to fastboot boot TWRP, do the following:
Save the following files to your SDCard:
OTA.zip
Magisk.zip
TWRP.zip
Boot into TWRP
Flash OTA.zip first, then TWRP.zip straight after, then Magisk.zip straight after that, reboot.
@Swatto86 By twrp do you mean TWRP recovery or TWRP installer? I assume that you mean the installer
audinak2 said:
@Swatto86 By twrp do you mean TWRP recovery or TWRP installer? I assume that you mean the installer
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry yes, put the installer zip on the sdcard
Thank you everyone for the quick replies,
What exactly is it to 'flash' the installer? Is it something I can do from the TWRP screen, just tap on it? Or will I have to put in command prompts?
audinak2 said:
@Swatto86 By twrp do you mean TWRP recovery or TWRP installer? I assume that you mean the installer
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have followed this guide https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Es80k627kTc to unlock/twrp/root, I have a TWRP recovery as far as I know, I'm not sure about 'installer'.
Thanks!
i just download and install the OTA through system updates. Then boot to Trwp recovery and flash magisk . Profit
DampDeceiver said:
Thank you everyone for the quick replies,
What exactly is it to 'flash' the installer? Is it something I can do from the TWRP screen, just tap on it? Or will I have to put in command prompts?
I have followed this guide
to unlock/twrp/root, I have a TWRP recovery as far as I know, I'm not sure about 'installer'.
Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can flash the installer zip for TWRP through TWRP itself.
Doesn't installing OTA through system settings wipe TWRP? That's why I perform all my updates from TWRP directly.
DampDeceiver said:
Thank you everyone for the quick replies,
What exactly is it to 'flash' the installer? Is it something I can do from the TWRP screen, just tap on it? Or will I have to put in command prompts?
I have followed this guide https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Es80k627kTc to unlock/twrp/root, I have a TWRP recovery as far as I know, I'm not sure about 'installer'.
Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You have to do twrp/root again after updates. Unlock sticks, but twrp and root don't.
there must be something strange with me then , OTA update doesnt wipe my twrp , i just flash magisk after OTA
Ajaykumar21066 said:
there must be something strange with me then , OTA update doesnt wipe my twrp , i just flash magisk after OTA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It prob doesn't overwrite until u reboot so twrp may not have been overwritten on that partition yet, so would make sense, I need to try it out sometime
When you install OTA via system settings and reboot, the slot switches to the inactive one (where the OTA installed to) and boots. This means the previous slot (prior to reboot) still has TWRP installed.
You are probably going direct to recovery after the OTA install without doing a full reboot first.
Swatto is correct. The risk when using twrp is that you must reboot to recovery immediately after flashing the twrp installer zip, or you will boot to the old slot and things will be broken. Rebooting to recovery gets you onto the active, updated slot.
When you reboot to recovery and flash an OTA, you are flashing it to the other slot. The current slot is untouched, while the new active one is completely stock. The twrp installer zip flashes twrp to both slots.
This is the procedure to follow if you want to update via twrp. Personally, I prefer taking the OTA and reinstalling via fastboot just to make sure everything is clean.
lollyjay said:
I have personally tested the following with TWRP already installed and twrp-installer-enchilada-3.2.1-0.zip on your phone:
Download full (not incremental) OOS ROM to your phone and check MD5
Reboot to your installed TWRP
Install the OOS ROM
Do not reboot instead stay in TWRP
Install twrp-installer-enchilada-3.2.1-0.zip
Reboot Recovery
Wipe cache
Reboot System
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Alright everyone, thanks for all the replies. I have to say even with all your help things were still really confusing for me. I went ahead and ditched TWRP (since I don't really need it anyway), updated OTA through the system, reinstalled magisk before reboot on 2nd slot (the OTA option), and rebooted. And so far all seems fine, I'm on the latest OOS version and I'm still rooted, everything seems to work. Can I do this again in the future and completely overwrite my TWRP installation on my A slot?
I kinda went with TWRP as it's supposed to be more safe for noobs but it ended up making things a lot more difficult to manage.
Thank you
DampDeceiver said:
Alright everyone, thanks for all the replies. I have to say even with all your help things were still really confusing for me. I went ahead and ditched TWRP (since I don't really need it anyway), updated OTA through the system, reinstalled magisk before reboot on 2nd slot (the OTA option), and rebooted. And so far all seems fine, I'm on the latest OOS version and I'm still rooted, everything seems to work. Can I do this again in the future and completely overwrite my TWRP installation on my A slot?
I kinda went with TWRP as it's supposed to be more safe for noobs but it ended up making things a lot more difficult to manage.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have not tried that method as I want twrp, but that is the recommended approach.
I know things have changed with twrp, but it's not that hard once you get used to it. You just have to remember that your phone will switch active slots every time it gets an update or you flash an ota (for example, to go back to stock), so twrp, etc, have to be installed on the other slot before you boot to it. Once you get comfortable with that idea, the rest of it is pretty easy.
Well, I am glad to read this post. Its always interesting how things can be slightly different in every phone manufacturer's setup.
After my lady Huawei device (Honor 6x), I did not want to have to deal with their style of... Control over their devices.
And things seem much easier here, while also being a little confusing right now. I don't fully get the slot a/b stuff yet but it sounds like it's a system to ensure stability on the phone in cases where the newest update could install incorrectly the alternative slot has a backup to ensure the device will function.
Sorta sounds like the dual bios setup on some motherboards. It's good!
Right, so to summarise to ensure I got it right:
1) Downloaded large (1gb+) ota zip from one of these threads, official twrp recovery installing zip, new version of magisk recovery installing zip
2) in recovery install all 3 of those zips in that listed order
3) reboot to recovery again to ensure twrp is still installed
4) profit
Which twrp thread should I take the zip from? There are a few different threads. I shouldn't care about the fastboot version when I already have twrp installed, right?
Either way, it can be much easier than what I had to do on Huawei phones. (currently the easiest phone I used for customisation like this was Nexus 4, but gladly OP6 is getting pretty close to that same level).
Sent from my OnePlus 6 using XDA Labs
You're best off downloading from the official twrp site. If you already have it installed, no need to use the fastboot boot method. You should to reboot to recovery in between flashing twrp and magisk to be sure magisk gets installed on the active slot.
Swatto86 said:
When you install OTA via system settings and reboot, the slot switches to the inactive one (where the OTA installed to) and boots. This means the previous slot (prior to reboot) still has TWRP installed.
You are probably going direct to recovery after the OTA install without doing a full reboot first.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Question, more of a scenario really. So if I'm on slot A and have TWRP and Magisk installed, would it be alright to just do a local update and reboot, giving me a perfectly clean install in slot B? Does it work that way? Thanks!
I'm actually using a 6t, but worst case scenario I just use the MSM Download tool, still I wanna get the hang of these confusing A/B devices.
So I am not an entire noob when it comes to these things, I've flashed ROMs on phones for 8 years now, but this Moto G7 Power screwed me up good.
I tried installing CrDroid from this post. I didn't even notice the A/B part at first, I went through all the usual steps, I booted TWRP, then flashed it, rebooted into the installed TWRP, flashed CrDroid, GApps and Magisk and rebooted, hoping to start Android up. At that part it all screwed up. The phone didn't boot AT ALL, and after a while I found that blankflash zip file and managed to get into the bootloader again. The only thing I can do now is boot into TWRP, not flash, and when I boot, the touchscreen does not work.
So, where do I go from here? I now only have an unlocked bootloader to play with. What are the exact steps to flash the firmware? Why do I need to flash firmware to slot A anyway? Isn't or wasn't there firmware out of the box on the device? The guides for this phone are vague and people write really short and rambling sentences in the steps and mention certain files out of the blue without explanation or download link.
1 - Which firmware file do I need? I have an XT1955-4 bought in a Dutch shop called Belsimpel with no sim. I assume it's an international variant. Here is a download list of all the firmware variants, but how do I know which one to pick? Will it wipe things like IMEI data? The box says the type is M3C94, and it seems to be this international variant.
2 - In the bootloader, what commands do I need to put into adb when I want to flash the firmware to partition A?
3 - When I boot into TWRP, my touchscreen does not work, so how can I even use it?
4 - The 'guide' in the CrDroid thread suddenly mentions copypartitions.zip. What is that file, and why do I need to flash it? It says I have to flash it in Slot A. Does TWRP give options to switch slots? I wish I could check but since my touch screen doesn't work in TWRP..
5 - During the actual ROM install part, the guide says Flash ROM.zip + TWRP_installer/boot.img ramdisk method Why do I need to install TWRP again? And what is the ramdisk method? How do you do that?
Can someone please explain in detail step by step what I need to do?
kerelberel said:
So I am not an entire noob when it comes to these things, I've flashed ROMs on phones for 8 years now, but this Moto G7 Power screwed me up good.
I tried installing CrDroid from this post. I didn't even notice the A/B part at first, I went through all the usual steps, I booted TWRP, then flashed it, rebooted into the installed TWRP, flashed CrDroid, GApps and Magisk and rebooted, hoping to start Android up. At that part it all screwed up. The phone didn't boot AT ALL, and after a while I found that blankflash zip file and managed to get into the bootloader again. The only thing I can do now is boot into TWRP, not flash, and when I boot, the touchscreen does not work.
So, where do I go from here? I now only have an unlocked bootloader to play with. What are the exact steps to flash the firmware? Why do I need to flash firmware to slot A anyway? Isn't or wasn't there firmware out of the box on the device? The guides for this phone are vague and people write really short and rambling sentences in the steps and mention certain files out of the blue without explanation or download link.
1 - Which firmware file do I need? I have an XT1955-4 bought in a Dutch shop called Belsimpel with no sim. I assume it's an international variant. Here is a download list of all the firmware variants, but how do I know which one to pick? Will it wipe things like IMEI data? The box says the type is M3C94, and it seems to be this international variant.
2 - In the bootloader, what commands do I need to put into adb when I want to flash the firmware to partition A?
3 - When I boot into TWRP, my touchscreen does not work, so how can I even use it?
4 - The 'guide' in the CrDroid thread suddenly mentions copypartitions.zip. What is that file, where do I download it, and why do I need to flash it? It says I have to flash it in Slot A. Does TWRP give options to switch slots?
5 - During the actual ROM install part, the guide says Flash ROM.zip + TWRP_installer/boot.img ramdisk method Why do I need to install TWRP again? And what is the ramdisk method? How do you do that?
Can someone please explain in detail step by step what I need to do?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
1. go to settings - system - about phone check build number, this is the firmware you'll need
2. there's a thread here regarding that matter check again
3. I'm not aware of this issue
4. you'll only need to flash that file once coming from stock rom - https://androidfilehost.com/?fid=4349826312261636295
5. because it be overwritten by lineage recovery.
ramdisk method is just another way of installing twrp back when we still dont have the installer zip
vinoxflame said:
1. go to settings - system - about phone check build number, this is the firmware you'll need
2. there's a thread here regarding that matter check again
3. I'm not aware of this issue
4. you'll only need to flash that file once coming from stock rom - https://androidfilehost.com/?fid=4349826312261636295
5. because it be overwritten by lineage recovery.
ramdisk method is just another way of installing twrp back when we still dont have the installer zip
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I only have the boot loader, no stock ROM. I wiped that when I tried installing CrDroid, as I have written in my post. So I can't check my firmware if I don't have ROM installed. And I know which thread you mean because I linked the list of firmware from that thread in my post.
The big issue here is the touch screen not working. I can't do anything inside TWRP.
kerelberel said:
I only have the boot loader, no stock ROM. I wiped that when I tried installing CrDroid, as I have written in my post. So I can't check my firmware if I don't have ROM installed. And I know which thread you mean because I linked the list of firmware from that thread in my post.
The big issue here is the touch screen not working. I can't do anything inside TWRP.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
then try another version of twrp or the unofficial orangefox recovery for our device
vinoxflame said:
then try another version of twrp or the unofficial orangefox recovery for our device
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I tried an older version of TWRP which didn't work either. I am not aware of Orangefox, but I don't see any mention, official or unofficial for the G7 Power. There's no mention in the G7 Power forum either.
kerelberel said:
I tried an older version of TWRP which didn't work either. I am not aware of Orangefox, but I don't see any mention, official or unofficial for the G7 Power. There's no mention in the G7 Power forum either.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
it's on the telegram group
vinoxflame said:
it's on the telegram group
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No it is not. There's no mention of G7 Power in the search results. Only E5.
kerelberel said:
No it is not. There's no mention of G7 Power in the search results. Only E5.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
deleted
vinoxflame said:
https://t.me/mG7Power
tell me if it is not!!!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
From the desktop search in this one I couldn't find it: https://t.me/OrangeFoxRecovery I didn't know there was a separate chat for each device. But thanks.
FWIW when this happened to me I did the blankflash thing to get it back to bootloader. Then I used the LMSA tool from Motorola to do a rescue/restore.
I also used LMSA to force the update to the most recent security update. In general, it seems a very useful utility.
https://www.motorola.com/us/lenovo-motorola-smart-assistant
I had this issue after blankflashing this temperamental device out of a brick. While in twrp you can do "adb shell" then "twrp install /path/to/zip" I think this has to do with new twrp versions on older firmwares
kerelberel said:
I only have the boot loader, no stock ROM. I wiped that when I tried installing CrDroid, as I have written in my post. So I can't check my firmware if I don't have ROM installed. And I know which thread you mean because I linked the list of firmware from that thread in my post.
The big issue here is the touch screen not working. I can't do anything inside TWRP.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
When i had this issue go reboot fastboot
then fastboot boot recovery.img or twrp as your boot img do what you need to do just dont flash it to boot only boot from it so you preserve your real boot should fix the touch screen part only time i had prob like this is when i flashed twrp to recovery without disabling dm verity etc. But I cant even get a stock OTA since I flashed twrp as recovery nor can I find a RETUS stock recovery.img so far if i had that I can update and keep magisk etc, then reflash twrp when im done.
---------- Post added at 06:06 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:58 PM ----------
kerelberel said:
I only have the boot loader, no stock ROM. I wiped that when I tried installing CrDroid, as I have written in my post. So I can't check my firmware if I don't have ROM installed. And I know which thread you mean because I linked the list of firmware from that thread in my post.
The big issue here is the touch screen not working. I can't do anything inside TWRP.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
When i had this issue go reboot fastboot
then fastboot boot recovery.img or twrp as your boot img do what you need to do just dont flash it to boot only boot from it so you preserve your real boot should fix the touch screen part only time i had prob like this is when i flashed twrp to recovery without disabling dm verity etc. But I cant even get a stock OTA since I flashed twrp as recovery nor can I find a RETUS stock recovery.img so far if i had that I can update and keep magisk etc, then reflash twrp when im done. The latest stock RETUS build i can find is here https://mirrors.lolinet.com/firmwar...ubsidy-DEFAULT_regulatory-DEFAULT_CFC.xml.zip but if i do that i will lose all my apps AGAIN etc I am trying to just get the stock recovery img from previous version so I can install the ota in magisk you just tap uninstall tap restore images to get stock boot as well then ota should work once its done go back into magisk and install to inactive slot but you will or could need TWRP A/B retention script so that you keep it even after ota...which you will first go in magisk tap uninstall restore images, but must have stock recovery not twrp installed at this time either from what i can tell, once ota is successful install the TWRP A/B Retention script but do this before you install magisk to inactive slot from magisk manager after that it should work. But I cannot locate a stock recovery.img thus far.... and I dont wanna redownload my apps right now, so I may just wait til I see a rom i really think ill like and say screw it.
kerelberel said:
I only have the boot loader, no stock ROM. I wiped that when I tried installing CrDroid, as I have written in my post. So I can't check my firmware if I don't have ROM installed. And I know which thread you mean because I linked the list of firmware from that thread in my post.
The big issue here is the touch screen not working. I can't do anything inside TWRP.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I also installed crDroid and after that twrp-3.3.1-2-ocean.img was not responding to touch, but twrp-3.3.1-0-ocean.img works. (btw I was doing a fastboot -w in between.)
Edit:
Ah nevermind, I have it constantly when installed, with both versions.
s33b said:
I also installed crDroid and after that twrp-3.3.1-2-ocean.img was not responding to touch, but twrp-3.3.1-0-ocean.img works. (btw I was doing a fastboot -w in between.)
Edit:
Ah nevermind, I have it constantly when installed, with both versions.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've flashed another stock rom (https://forum.xda-developers.com/g7-power/how-to/guide-moto-g7-power-supra-flash-to-t3927138) and it worked with twrp-3.3.1-0-ocean.img not with the newest.
kerelberel said:
2 - In the bootloader, what commands do I need to put into adb when I want to flash the firmware to partition A?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You use fastboot commands in the bootloader.
The firmware contains a flash file with all fastboot commands you'll need.
kerelberel said:
3 - When I boot into TWRP, my touchscreen does not work, so how can I even use it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
TWRP has adb enabled by default. So instead of TWRP you can use
Code:
abd shell twrp --help
So you can use the basic functions like backup, install, and so on.
I had the same issue...
I'm not sure everyone is experiencing the same issue here, but I've been dealing with that exact problem the entire time I've had this phone. While this work around won't work every time, it will eventually work (for me within 3 tries). It doesn't matter if your "fastboot boot twrp.img" or running an installed version, all are the same. Even the latest 3.4.0.0.
As soon as you start recovery, start tapping the area of the screen where the "Advanced button" is in recovery. I mean tap as fast as you can, use two fingers if you need to. If it doesn't work right away, "adb reboot bootloader" and try again. I can get this to work within 3 tries. Its sucks and its stupid, but it works.
TheGuysGuysGuy said:
I'm not sure everyone is experiencing the same issue here, but I've been dealing with that exact problem the entire time I've had this phone. While this work around won't work every time, it will eventually work (for me within 3 tries). It doesn't matter if your "fastboot boot twrp.img" or running an installed version, all are the same. Even the latest 3.4.0.0.
As soon as you start recovery, start tapping the area of the screen where the "Advanced button" is in recovery. I mean tap as fast as you can, use two fingers if you need to. If it doesn't work right away, "adb reboot bootloader" and try again. I can get this to work within 3 tries. Its sucks and its stupid, but it works.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I getba link to one that works for u. https://t.me/CustoKernal_JavaShin_Mods/565. Fastboot boot (name of recovery)
roadkill42 said:
I getba link to one that works for u. https://t.me/CustoKernal_JavaShin_Mods/565. Fastboot boot (name of recovery)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Again not everyone is experiencing this same issue. A custom kernel isn't going to help when its incompatible with my ROM. My stupid workaround works for "No Touch Screen Response" in TWRP as well as OrangeFox. Its happened to me in both. Happily cruising along on Paranoid Android Quartz.
TheGuysGuysGuy said:
Again not everyone is experiencing this same issue. A custom kernel isn't going to help when its incompatible with my ROM. My stupid workaround works for "No Touch Screen Response" in TWRP as well as OrangeFox. Its happened to me in both. Happily cruising along on Paranoid Android Quartz.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The problem with the touch is the right driver needs to b installed that kernel I shared makes it work and stick I'm on it now go to tellagram group Moto g7 power support group both twrp and ofox there that works not the one from twrp it's self and the twrp there has some other features that one from official one has that don't work
This boot image gave me a touchscreen and allowed me to flash a regular twrp: hxxps://f.emvn.me/android-roms-and-stuff/twrp.3.4-kakarot.boot.img
Thanks to whoever made it.
I am running 10.05, I can't decide whether to install twrp, dd root, or magdisk. Given that I have the most current version of oxygen os, what would be the best way to root my phone?
Don't misinterpret my ignorance for lazyness, a majority of guides I've seen aren't recent and don't go over pros & cons of the method.
Thank you, I'm willing to donate for help.
Edit: I'm stupid, I was in wrong forum. Please ignore this post and what I've said!
You only need a patched image if you don't want to install TWRP. If you install TWRP, I'd simply ADB sideload Magisk to get root.
That's what I've done and it works just fine.
This assumes that you're using a OnePlus 7 Pro, and not a 7T Pro. Not got a 7T, so can't comment on that.
Sent from my GM1913 using Tapatalk
Bagpuss said:
You only need a patched image if you don't want to install TWRP. If you install TWRP, I'd simply ADB sideload Magisk to get root.
That's what I've done and it works just fine.
This assumes that you're using a OnePlus 7 Pro, and not a 7T Pro. Not got a 7T, so can't comment on that.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Edit: I'm stupid, I was in wrong forum. Please ignore this post and what I've said!
Lossyx said:
TWRP doesn't work on devices launched with Android 10, which has been discussed many times.
My reply above stands true, a patched boot image is the only way as for right now.
(And we're on a 7T Pro forum)
Sent from my OnePlus7TPro using XDA Labs
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Are you positive? I see TWRP install guides everywhere. From what I've read TWRP with magdisk (not SuperSU, us it's not open source) is the best way to root with the most flexibility. What if I'm running 10.03.0GM21AA, and there is no patched image? Do I need to roll back?
Lossyx said:
There is only one way to root, and that is by using a patched image. Check the guides section, there's probably a patched image of your device, if not, you'll have to make your own.
And what's your version? AA or BA?
Sent from my OnePlus7TPro using XDA Labs
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
AA. So do I need to roll back? I bought the OP7P because I stupidly assumed it would be as easy/flexible to root as my past OP devices. It's ironic I switched from a Samsung devices to a OP for the ability for a stress-free rooting experience and I got the same problem lol. I might just return the phone for another, I'd prefer something with an SD card slot anyway.
What's the best phone with SD card feature that can run TWRP magdisk without issues like using banking apps and Netflix?
Forgive my ignorance, I am still in the learning process.
Lossyx said:
TWRP doesn't work on devices launched with Android 10, which has been discussed many times.
My reply above stands true, a patched boot image is the only way as for right now.
(And we're on a 7T Pro forum)
Sent from my OnePlus7TPro using XDA Labs
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No we're on a 7 Pro forum. And TWRP works fine on the 7 Pro, but you need a patched version of some sort last time I checked.
sixisixsix said:
I am running 10.05, I can't decide whether to install twrp, dd root, or magdisk. Given that I have the most current version of oxygen os, what would be the best way to root my phone?
Don't misinterpret my ignorance for lazyness, a majority of guides I've seen aren't recent and don't go over pros & cons of the method.
Thank you, I'm willing to donate for help.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
To root my phone, I didn't even use TWRP. I downloaded the lastest OOS version from OnePlus, extracted the boot image, copied that to my phone, Magisk patched that boot image file (you don't need root for that, you can use the Magisk manager). Then unlocked the phone, and installed the bootloader I just patched while the phone was in bootloader mode (fastboot flash boot boot.img or whatever).
Might not be the easiest, but I think it's clean, however back then I did not know about the option to properly use TWRP. Maybe I can find it, but I know it's possible to just unlock the 7 Pro, and then from the bootloader boot to TWRP once without flashing it, and install Magisk.
QUBiCA said:
No we're on a 7 Pro forum. And TWRP works fine on the 7 Pro, but you need a patched version of some sort last time I checked.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Oh damn, I'm actually stupid... How did I miss were on 7 Pro?!
@sixisixsix please ignore everything I've said! I will edit my posts.
Sorry once again
Sent from my OnePlus7TPro using XDA Labs
sixisixsix said:
AA. So do I need to roll back? I bought the OP7P because I stupidly assumed it would be as easy/flexible to root as my past OP devices. It's ironic I switched from a Samsung devices to a OP for the ability for a stress-free rooting experience and I got the same problem lol. I might just return the phone for another, I'd prefer something with an SD card slot anyway.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've found OP devices (having owned two now) to be easy to root, and very friendly to the mod/root community such as XDA. Samsung is the opposite, in my experience (although each Sammy device is different, some better than others in this regard).
The main complexity with the 7 Pro is not that it is an OP device per se; but that it has something called A/B partitions, which are used for "seamless" OTA updates (Pixel devices use this scheme also - as well as a number of other phones).
The thing with A/B partition devices, is that they do NOT have a discrete recovery partition that you can just flash TWRP to. Therefore, you need to patch the boot.img partition (which on A/B devices contains both kernel and recovery, along with ramdisk). It is a little trickier, and somewhat more of a learning curve. But once you've learned that basic difference, it is not too bad.
It seems that the list A/B partitions devices is growing. So while I'm not an expert in the industry or anything, it appears that this is where Android is going (A/B is certainly not going away anytime soon, in any case).
So while the SD card feature is a legitimate difference (and a discriminator for some), I would say you should not make the A/B partition difference scare you away from OP devices. Maybe "too much information", but you can read more about the A/B partition scheme here: https://www.xda-developers.com/how-...ess-updates-affect-custom-development-on-xda/
---------- Post added at 10:13 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:05 AM ----------
QUBiCA said:
To root my phone, I didn't even use TWRP. I downloaded the lastest OOS version from OnePlus, extracted the boot image, copied that to my phone, Magisk patched that boot image file (you don't need root for that, you can use the Magisk manager). Then unlocked the phone, and installed the bootloader I just patched while the phone was in bootloader mode (fastboot flash boot boot.img or whatever).
Might not be the easiest, but I think it's clean, however back then I did not know about the option to properly use TWRP. Maybe I can find it, but I know it's possible to just unlock the 7 Pro, and then from the bootloader boot to TWRP once without flashing it, and install Magisk.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Certainly a valid approach (fastboot flash a patched boot image). The "other" (TWRP) method works as well, and probably a little easier for most folks:
1) Unlock bootloader
2) fastboot boot twrp.img
Note that this is just remote booting a TWRP image, not installing it. It simply allows the next steps. You can't flash a TWRP image directly, for the reason I've noted above.
3) Once booted to TWRP, flash TWRP installer zip (OPTIONAL). This patched the boot.img so that TWRP is installed. You only need to do this if you want TWRP installed on the phone.
4) Also in "booted" TWRP, flash the Magisk zip.
The main fundamental difference, is that Magisk is patching the boot.img for you, instead of doing it yourself. Have the files (TWRP.zip and Magisk) on the phone before starting the process, and it is really pretty simple and fast.
The nice thing about the patched boot.img method, is that is worked even when TWRP method did not. This applied to when the phone was first released, and the command "fastboot boot" was broken (therefore not possible to fastboot boot TWRP). This happened again when the device was updated to Android 10. Although the developer got fastboot boot working fairly quickly in both circumstances.
Lossyx said:
Edit: I'm stupid, I was in wrong forum. Please ignore this post and what I've said!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
redpoint73 said:
I've found OP devices (having owned two now) to be easy to root, and very friendly to the mod/root community such as XDA. Samsung is the opposite, in my experience (although each Sammy device is different, some better than others in this regard).
The main complexity with the 7 Pro is not that it is an OP device per se; but that it has something called A/B partitions, which are used for "seamless" OTA updates (Pixel devices use this scheme also - as well as a number of other phones).
The thing with A/B partition devices, is that they do NOT have a discrete recovery partition that you can just flash TWRP to. Therefore, you need to patch the boot.img partition (which on A/B devices contains both kernel and recovery, along with ramdisk). It is a little trickier, and somewhat more of a learning curve. But once you've learned that basic difference, it is not too bad.
It seems that the list A/B partitions devices is growing. So while I'm not an expert in the industry or anything, it appears that this is where Android is going (A/B is certainly not going away anytime soon, in any case).
So while the SD card feature is a legitimate difference (and a discriminator for some), I would say you should not make the A/B partition difference scare you away from OP devices. Maybe "too much information", but you can read more about the A/B partition scheme here: https://www.xda-developers.com/how-...ess-updates-affect-custom-development-on-xda/
---------- Post added at 10:13 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:05 AM ----------
Certainly a valid approach (fastboot flash a patched boot image). The "other" (TWRP) method works as well, and probably a little easier for most folks:
1) Unlock bootloader
2) fastboot boot twrp.img
Note that this is just remote booting a TWRP image, not installing it. It simply allows the next steps. You can't flash a TWRP image directly, for the reason I've noted above.
3) Once booted to TWRP, flash TWRP installer zip (OPTIONAL). This patched the boot.img so that TWRP is installed. You only need to do this if you want TWRP installed on the phone.
4) Also in "booted" TWRP, flash the Magisk zip.
The main fundamental difference, is that Magisk is patching the boot.img for you, instead of doing it yourself. Have the files (TWRP.zip and Magisk) on the phone before starting the process, and it is really pretty simple and fast.
The nice thing about the patched boot.img method, is that is worked even when TWRP method did not. This applied to when the phone was first released, and the command "fastboot boot" was broken (therefore not possible to fastboot boot TWRP). This happened again when the device was updated to Android 10. Although the developer got fastboot boot working fairly quickly in both circumstances.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you for taking the time to respond to my post in such detail! Wouldn't installing TWRP give me more flexibility for future updates? If I go the flashed image route won't I need erase my data on my phone every time I update?
sixisixsix said:
Thank you for taking the time to respond to my post in such detail! Wouldn't installing TWRP give me more flexibility for future updates? If I go the flashed image route won't I need erase my data on my phone every time I update?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't think TWRP would give you more flexibility when it comes to updates, unless you are planning on switching ROMs often, but if this phone is your daily driver I would recommend against that.
If you unlock the phone your data will be wiped, but only once. After that it is completely up to you, if you switch ROMs and pick something that is completely different from stock, it is indeed recommended to wipe data to prevent weird issues. But for a regular system update (if you simply stick with the stock ROM and use Magisk for root, you can still receive normal updates from OnePlus), or an update of the same custom ROM, you do not need to wipe data. I wiped data only once, when I unlocked it, because I had to.
Flashing/installing TWRP generally is not necessary and like @redpoint73 explained, with the "new" A/B system, it is not advised to flash TWRP as it is combined with the boot image (which your phone needs to start up, and is updated after every update, so after every update you will lose TWRP again if I am correct). What @redpoint73 explained is that instead of installing (AKA flashing) TWRP, it is possible to just start it up (boot it) once without installing it. From there you can install Magisk on your stock OnePlus ROM and use the benefits of a rooted system.
QUBiCA said:
Flashing/installing TWRP generally is not necessary and like @redpoint73 explained, with the "new" A/B system, it is not advised to flash TWRP as it is combined with the boot image (which your phone needs to start up, and is updated after every update, so after every update you will lose TWRP again if I am correct).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It is correct that you lose the TWRP install when you update (as well as losing root). But it is just a simple matter of flashing the TWRP installer zip after the update (I do this the same time as re-flashing Magisk after OTA update), which takes about 10 seconds to accomplish. I wouldn't personally take that as a reason to "not" flash TWRP. But it is a personal preference whether to install TWRP or not. The reasons to have TWRP installed on the phone are much reduced from previous devices. In the past I would have said that being rooted without a custom recovery is asking for trouble. But now, with A/B partitions, along with the fastboot stock ROMs, the choice becomes much less clear. To the point that installing TWRP is purely optional.
I still personally believe that having TWRP installed gives you more recovery options. But again, it is a personal choice, and certainly not mandatory by any means.
---------- Post added at 09:11 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:01 AM ----------
sixisixsix said:
Wouldn't installing TWRP give me more flexibility for future updates?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Actually, no (as QUBiCA touched on above).
Reason being, OTA updates will still come through on this device (even rooted). And you can still flash (or put OTA files on the phone to flash) using the built-in update engine in the phone's settings menu. Which gives you the option to update to either A/B partition slot. Plus, you can just re-flash TWRP (if desired) and Magisk after the update, straight from the Magisk Manager.
The trick is to make sure you do NOT reboot immediately after an OTA update (when rooted). Then simply open Magisk Manager, flash TWRP as if it were a Magisk module (optional, if you want TWRP installed again). Then install Magisk again through the Magisk Manager as well.. Now you can reboot, and you will be updated with root.
sixisixsix said:
If I go the flashed image route won't I need erase my data on my phone every time I update?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No (again, just backing up the answer already provided). There is not a big difference between the two methods. In either case, you are patching the boot.img partition to be rooted (whether you flash a patched boot.img, or you have Magisk patch it for you). And in both cases, you don't need to wipe your data.
redpoint73 said:
It is correct that you lose the TWRP install when you update (as well as losing root). But it is just a simple matter of flashing the TWRP installer zip after the update (I do this the same time as re-flashing Magisk after OTA update), which takes about 10 seconds to accomplish. I wouldn't personally take that as a reason to "not" flash TWRP. But it is a personal preference whether to install TWRP or not. The reasons to have TWRP installed on the phone are much reduced from previous devices. In the past I would have said that being rooted without a custom recovery is asking for trouble. But now, with A/B partitions, along with the fastboot stock ROMs, the choice becomes much less clear. To the point that installing TWRP is purely optional.
I still personally believe that having TWRP installed gives you more recovery options. But again, it is a personal choice, and certainly not mandatory by any means.
---------- Post added at 09:11 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:01 AM ----------
Actually, no (as QUBiCA touched on above).
Reason being, OTA updates will still come through on this device (even rooted). And you can still flash (or put OTA files on the phone to flash) using the built-in update engine in the phone's settings menu. Which gives you the option to update to either A/B partition slot. Plus, you can just re-flash TWRP (if desired) and Magisk after the update, straight from the Magisk Manager.
The trick is to make sure you do NOT reboot immediately after an OTA update (when rooted). Then simply open Magisk Manager, flash TWRP as if it were a Magisk module (optional, if you want TWRP installed again). Then install Magisk again through the Magisk Manager as well.. Now you can reboot, and you will be updated with root.
No (again, just backing up the answer already provided). There is not a big difference between the two methods. In either case, you are patching the boot.img partition to be rooted (whether you flash a patched boot.img, or you have Magisk patch it for you). And in both cases, you don't need to wipe your data.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So if I used the patched version of 10.3.0 and another new version comes out I can just download it through settings and I will remained rooted?
Sent from my Redmi Note 8 Pro using Tapatalk
sixisixsix said:
So if I used the patched version of 10.3.0 and another new version comes out I can just download it through settings and I will remained rooted?
Sent from my Redmi Note 8 Pro using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
NO.
You need to go through the process and flash Magisk from inside Magisk Manager.
tech_head said:
NO.
You need to go through the process and flash Magisk from inside Magisk Manager.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Okay so I downloaded magdisk manager, I flashed the patched version of 10.03, then when I rebooted I hit install update on magdisk and when the phone rebooted it was no longer rooted.
Even the guides for flashing aren't in depth enough for me. Can you help me out real quick?
sixisixsix said:
So if I used the patched version of 10.3.0 and another new version comes out I can just download it through settings and I will remained rooted?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You should get the OTA update and be able to download it through settings. BUT, after you install the update, you still need to do as I already said in order to remain rooted:
redpoint73 said:
The trick is to make sure you do NOT reboot immediately after an OTA update (when rooted). Then simply open Magisk Manager, flash TWRP as if it were a Magisk module (optional, if you want TWRP installed again). Then install Magisk again through the Magisk Manager as well.. Now you can reboot, and you will be updated with root.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
---------- Post added at 09:28 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:00 AM ----------
sixisixsix said:
Okay so I downloaded magdisk manager, I flashed the patched version of 10.03, then when I rebooted I hit install update on magdisk and when the phone rebooted it was no longer rooted.
Even the guides for flashing aren't in depth enough for me. Can you help me out real quick?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You seem to be mixing the two processes: Install update in Magisk is for when you update in the future. You shouldn't have to do this rooting the existing ROM with the patched boot.img method.
For the patched boot.img method, you should just be able to flash the patched boot.img, flash the Magisk apk, and open Magisk, and it should say rooted.
My recommendation is follow this guide: https://forum.xda-developers.com/oneplus-7-pro/how-to/guide-bootloader-unlock-twrp-install-t3940368
I can't possibly see how it can be any more in depth.