Hi All,
Having a strange issue with Magisk.
I performed the upgrade today coming from renovate ice (Magisk module).
I followed the instructions of flashing the full OTA of the pie update. And then the blusparks TWRP. I rebooted into recovery and then flashed Magisk 17.1 as per the guide.
Booting back into the OS I can see that Magisk Manager is missing and my rooted apps are unable to get root either. Also when I try to goto the themes section inside settings the settings app crashes on me.
I attempted to reinstall Magisk but this did not work. I only noticed that when I was running the uninstaller for Magisk it did detect my boot image is Magisk rooted despite the OS not reflecting this.
Any ideas? My next step is 17.2 but I have my doubts on it.
EDIT: I tried 17.2 beta release and it made no difference. Exact same symptoms
spartan268 said:
Hi All,
Having a strange issue with Magisk.
I performed the upgrade today coming from renovate ice (Magisk module).
I followed the instructions of flashing the full OTA of the pie update. And then the blusparks TWRP. I rebooted into recovery and then flashed Magisk 17.1 as per the guide.
Booting back into the OS I can see that Magisk Manager is missing and my rooted apps are unable to get root either. Also when I try to goto the themes section inside settings the settings app crashes on me.
I attempted to reinstall Magisk but this did not work. I only noticed that when I was running the uninstaller for Magisk it did detect my boot image is Magisk rooted despite the OS not reflecting this.
Any ideas? My next step is 17.2 but I have my doubts on it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Manually download and install magisk manager app then try to open root apps.
Then give root permission that works
pankspoo said:
Manually download and install magisk manager app then try to open root apps.
Then give root permission that works
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It errors out saying "App not installed" when I try the manager APK.
spartan268 said:
It errors out saying "App not installed" when I try the manager APK.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Are u able to see magisk manager app in apps under sysytem apps?
If yes then remove or disable that
pankspoo said:
Are u able to see magisk manager app in apps under sysytem apps?
If yes then remove or disable that
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nothing there either...
pankspoo said:
Are u able to see magisk manager app in apps under sysytem apps?
If yes then remove or disable that
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I was able to resolve the issue by performing a factory reset without having to wipe data. I'm guessing something old must have been left behind. Thanks for the help you provided, I appreciate it
Hi, im new to A/B partitions and PIE. I was Using OnePlus 3T before this. I have few questions.
1. Can i restore Titanium backup apps+data from Oreo to PIE?
2. Can i use magisk modules from Oreo?
3. Which modules are you guys using?
I wouldn't restore app data from Oreo to Pie. Personally I'm just running stock rooted, nothing more nothing less
1. Yes, titanium backups can be restored without any problem
2. Depends on the module. Check the module if it's compatible/updated for Pie.
3. Google Framework so i can use Google Dialer/Phone app. I'm also using Viper4Android module
Punkid said:
1. Yes, titanium backups can be restored without any problem
2. Depends on the module. Check the module if it's compatible/updated for Pie.
3. Google Framework so i can use Google Dialer/Phone app. I'm also using Viper4Android module
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can u share the link for Pie? ive found some threads, but they support till Oreo.
Can you use Google framework on stable pie? I'm rooted with magisk on stable pie and I really want the Google dialer
Hi all,
Am on Android 10 and phone has the latest TWRP, Magisk and busy box. In Magisk the Ramdisk is a YES. Titanium can disable internal apps no problem and seemingly uninstall them but after restarting the phone those apps re-appear. Also, though the latest MixPlorer and Root Explorer can edit/change Mixer_Paths, the original values come back after restarting the phone.
Can anyone advise how to solve this mystery.
Thanks in advance.
A10 and later , doesn't allow changing system files you need to do this via a magisk module systemless.
@soka said:
A10 and later , doesn't allow changing system files you need to do this via a magisk module systemless.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for that. I googled 'magisk module systemless' but it came up with loads of different things. Not sure what I should look for.
Use the magisk module Debloater from magisk repo, you also need BusyBox module and Termux app from playstore.
RokCruz said:
Use the magisk module Debloater from magisk repo, you also need BusyBox module and Termux app from playstore.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Much appreciated. Cheers
My phone is rooted with Magisk after installing TWRP recovery and it's working fine except banking apps which do not run due to rooted phone
I don't use functions of rooted phone so much, only in extracting whatsapp keys to backup my whatsapp chats etc
1) Can I uninstall/unroot Magisk anytime and reinstall/root again smoothly whenever the need arises?
2) Does installing/uninstalling root wipe data?
3) I saw following para in https://magiskmanager.com/uninstall-magisk
Your phone will be rebooted automatically. Don’t worry it is normal
That’s it! You have successfully uninstalled Magisk from your phone.
This process will completely delete all the files from your phone, and you don’t need to worry about anything.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What's meaning of "This process will completely delete all the files from your phone" here?
Thanks & regards,
Maria.
AFAIK any tampering of a phone's Stock ROM can get detectected by banking / payment apps - if they want to. IMO the very only method to remove all traces of modifcations applied to phone's Stock ROM is to re-flash phone's Stock what in turn causes the loss of all user data stored on phone.
1) Can I uninstall/unroot Magisk anytime and reinstall/root again smoothly whenever the need arises?
Yes.
2) Does installing/uninstalling root wipe data?
No. As long as you're not locking/unlocking your bootloader, you should be fine. Always a good idea to back up your data and system bacakup since you have TWRP anyway.
3) I saw following para in https://magiskmanager.com/uninstall-magisk
I believe this is reffering to all the MAgisk data only.
Andrologic said:
1) Can I uninstall/unroot Magisk anytime and reinstall/root again smoothly whenever the need arises?
Yes.
2) Does installing/uninstalling root wipe data?
No. As long as you're not locking/unlocking your bootloader, you should be fine. Always a good idea to back up your data and system bacakup since you have TWRP anyway.
3) I saw following para in https://magiskmanager.com/uninstall-magisk
I believe this is reffering to all the MAgisk data only.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you very much for your reply
Maria2014 said:
I am having the same problem. I want to ask if you tried uninstall magisk ? What happened ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My dear, I install and uninstall Magisk all the time. Legitimately speaking, never once did it wipe my data ever. Unless you unlock or relock your bootloader, you will be completely fine.
Shabeeh Manappurath said:
My dear, I install and uninstall Magisk all the time. Legitimately speaking, never once did it wipe my data ever. Unless you unlock or relock your bootloader, you will be completely fine.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi,
Could you advice pls.
After updating magisk it stopped working..
Shuld I uninstall it and then reinstall?
Will my modouls be earased? I am very worried taking this step..
Thanks in advance
tuvia_g123 said:
Hi,
Could you advice pls.
After updating magisk it stopped working..
Shuld I uninstall it and then reinstall?
Will my modouls be earased? I am very worried taking this step..
Thanks in advance
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My advise is, Incase you feel your modules will be erased, just take a screenshot of ur magisk Modules. Screenshot which you can use to later download the exact same modules. Or u can keep magisk module downloaded before hand. Now if magisk is not working, magisk Modules will not show for you.
If magisk is not working, you don't need to uninstall it. Just go to recovery and reflash the magisk.zip or magisk.apk. both will work, bcos that is how it is. Magisk.apk can be directly flashed from recovery menu. Once you reinstall magisk from recovery and it should start working. If after reboot, it is still not working, then just install magisk.apk while you are in android. (Not in recovery, but normal mode) and then open it and see what it says.
If I can help, I will surely. Let me know how it goes. Usually no data is erased. Don't worry. Magisk Modules or magisk, don't effect the system. U can also download magisk uninstaller.zip if you want to completely uninstall magisk.
Shabeeh Manappurath said:
My advise is, Incase you feel your modules will be erased, just take a screenshot of ur magisk Modules. Screenshot which you can use to later download the exact same modules. Or u can keep magisk module downloaded before hand. Now if magisk is not working, magisk Modules will not show for you.
If magisk is not working, you don't need to uninstall it. Just go to recovery and reflash the magisk.zip or magisk.apk. both will work, bcos that is how it is. Magisk.apk can be directly flashed from recovery menu. Once you reinstall magisk from recovery and it should start working. If after reboot, it is still not working, then just install magisk.apk while you are in android. (Not in recovery, but normal mode) and then open it and see what it says.
If I can help, I will surely. Let me know how it goes. Usually no data is erased. Don't worry. Magisk Modules or magisk, don't effect the system. U can also download magisk uninstaller.zip if you want to completely uninstall magisk.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you very much for your detailed and clear answer.
In the next few days I will find time and try.
Of course I will update you.
tuvia_g123 said:
Thank you very much for your detailed and clear answer.
In the next few days I will find time and try.
Of course I will update you.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Alright Dear, take your time, and let me know, I hope everything works out for you. And Your Welcome
Shabeeh Manappurath said:
Alright Dear, take your time, and let me know, I hope everything works out for you. And Your Welcome
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hello dear friend,
Looks like I deleted the original zip file.
Can you pls. attach a link that wont be malware of a magisk zip?
Thanks a lot
tuvia_g123 said:
Hello dear friend,
Looks like I deleted the original zip file.
Can you pls. attach a link that wont be malware of a magisk zip?
Thanks a lot
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The best, and only official place to download magisk from is GitHub. At least I think. And well there is one another website I download it from, it's not malware, but I will provide you with the GitHub link itself.
For Magisk v23.0 (One with MagiskHide)(This release also has online module repo, where you can download extra supported modules for your device from online repo of magisk)
https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/releases/download/v23.0/Magisk-v23.0.apk
For Magisk v25.2 (It does not have MagiskHide, but this is much more better, and there are more effective ways to hide root using Zygisk (new feature in Magisk v24 onwards I believe) (This one does not have Online Repo for Magisk modules, it was also removed in a previous version of Magisk, and you can use Fox's Magisk Modules manager if you want to access and download magisk Modules for any of the future releases for Magisk) If you want the link for Magisk v25.2 then here it is:
https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/releases/download/v25.2/Magisk-v25.2.apk
Just if u face any difficulty in flashing the apk file in recovery, just rename it to magisk v23/v25.2 (whichever u choose, I kinda recommend using the latest version) and rename it into . Zip. And if u plan on going with v25.2 and want to access the latest online repo and some of their own Magisk modules, then here is the link for the latest version of Fox's Magisk Modules manager:
Release 0.6.1 - Maintenance Update · Fox2Code/FoxMagiskModuleManager
Add Androidacy test-mode fix to non test-mode Update Brazilian translations by @DanGLES3
github.com
I am currently using the latest Magisk v25.2 on my phone, and currently running on the latest version of Fox's Magisk Modules manager as well. And also, using the method for hiding root that I mentioned before, I am completely successful in covering my root, and my safety net is passed. Completely Passed. Play store or any other app I don't want it detecting root, does not detect root. So we all good if you want to flash the latest update of Magisk.
Shabeeh Manappurath said:
The best, and only official place to download magisk from is GitHub. At least I think. And well there is one another website I download it from, it's not malware, but I will provide you with the GitHub link itself.
For Magisk v23.0 (One with MagiskHide)(This release also has online module repo, where you can download extra supported modules for your device from online repo of magisk)
https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/releases/download/v23.0/Magisk-v23.0.apk
For Magisk v25.2 (It does not have MagiskHide, but this is much more better, and there are more effective ways to hide root using Zygisk (new feature in Magisk v24 onwards I believe) (This one does not have Online Repo for Magisk modules, it was also removed in a previous version of Magisk, and you can use Fox's Magisk Modules manager if you want to access and download magisk Modules for any of the future releases for Magisk) If you want the link for Magisk v25.2 then here it is:
https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/releases/download/v25.2/Magisk-v25.2.apk
Just if u face any difficulty in flashing the apk file in recovery, just rename it to magisk v23/v25.2 (whichever u choose, I kinda recommend using the latest version) and rename it into . Zip. And if u plan on going with v25.2 and want to access the latest online repo and some of their own Magisk modules, then here is the link for the latest version of Fox's Magisk Modules manager:
Release 0.6.1 - Maintenance Update · Fox2Code/FoxMagiskModuleManager
Add Androidacy test-mode fix to non test-mode Update Brazilian translations by @DanGLES3
github.com
I am currently using the latest Magisk v25.2 on my phone, and currently running on the latest version of Fox's Magisk Modules manager as well. And also, using the method for hiding root that I mentioned before, I am completely successful in covering my root, and my safety net is passed. Completely Passed. Play store or any other app I don't want it detecting root, does not detect root. So we all good if you want to flash the latest update of Magisk.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi,
I prefer v 23 because it has the hide option builtin.
However after flashing it(i think succesfuli) i do not find any new app in my fhone..
tuvia_g123 said:
Hi,
I prefer v 23 because it has the hide option builtin.
However after flashing it(i think succesfuli) i do not find any new app in my fhone..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Alright your preference is your own, but maybe hear me out, v23 will soon become outdated, as in some magisk Modules will stop working for it. And the magisk hide, according to the founder of Magisk @topjohnwu, he said that magisk hide is become really ineffective in blocking root, or stopping apps from detecting root. If you want a more powerful version of Magisk hide, update to v25.2 and I will show you how to activate it step by step. It's not built-in, rather it is a new module. So yeah.
Alright and about your question; if you don't find the app in your phone, in your apps drawer, just open file explorer, go to the location where u have kept the magisk.zip file or magisk.apk file. If u have the apk file then just install it once more, from android while in normal mode. If you have the zip file, then just rename to .APK and install it same like above. Then open magisk to continue (mostly after proper install, magisk will reboot your phone once more). Any steps you are stuck in, pls sent me a screenshot, so that I can help.
Shabeeh Manappurath said:
Alright your preference is your own, but maybe hear me out, v23 will soon become outdated, as in some magisk Modules will stop working for it. And the magisk hide, according to the founder of Magisk @topjohnwu, he said that magisk hide is become really ineffective in blocking root, or stopping apps from detecting root. If you want a more powerful version of Magisk hide, update to v25.2 and I will show you how to activate it step by step. It's not built-in, rather it is a new module. So yeah.
Alright and about your question; if you don't find the app in your phone, in your apps drawer, just open file explorer, go to the location where u have kept the magisk.zip file or magisk.apk file. If u have the apk file then just install it once more, from android while in normal mode. If you have the zip file, then just rename to .APK and install it same like above. Then open magisk to continue (mostly after proper install, magisk will reboot your phone once more). Any steps you are stuck in, pls sent me a screenshot, so that I can help.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi,i took your advice and flashed v. 25.2, however i think that the installation failed..
tuvia_g123 said:
Hi,i took your advice and flashed v. 25.2, however i think that the installation failed..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hey, I see, okay use magisk uninstaller to completely remove v23 first, and then flash v25.2 afterwards.
From what I researched, it seems u can easily uninstall magisk by renaming magisk v25.2.apk (the file we downloaded) rename it into uninstall.zip
And then reboot to recovery, flash it from recovery to completely uninstall magisk v23. (Make a copy of the file before renaming into uninstall.zip.) that way we can flash v25.2.apk /v25.2.zip directly.
Hope everything works for you.
Shabeeh Manappurath said:
Hey, I see, okay use magisk uninstaller to completely remove v23 first, and then flash v25.2 afterwards.
Just to be sure,v. 23 that I want to uninstall not to rename?
From what I researched, it seems u can easily uninstall magisk by renaming magisk v25.2.apk (the file we downloaded) rename it into uninstall.zip
And then reboot to recovery, flash it from recovery to completely uninstall magisk v23. (Make a copy of the file before renaming into Uninstall.zip.) that waysure that I understood.. we can flash v25.2.apk /v25.2.zip directly.
not sure that i understands.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Shabeeh Manappurath said:
Not
Hope everything workNs for you.
Hey, I see, okay use magisk uninstaller to completely remove v23 first, and then flash v25.2 afterwards.
N
From what I researched, it seems u can easily uninstall magisk by renaming magisk v25.2.apk (the file we downloaded) rename it into uninstall.zip
And then reboot to recovery, flash it from recovery to completely uninstall magisk v23. (Make a copy of the file before renaming into uninstall.zip.) that way we can flash v25.2.apk /v25.2.zip directly.
Hope everything works for you.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not sure that I understood.
Not to rename Version 23 that I want to uninstall?
Rename v25 that we want to keep?
https://drive.google.com/uc?export=download&id=1XvA2wCzCfSgQGJRgzJ-yklOYn99DDjBQ
Just Flash that, in order to uninstall Magisk from your device. And then, install the latest Magisk v25.2
Shabeeh Manappurath said:
https://drive.google.com/uc?export=download&id=1XvA2wCzCfSgQGJRgzJ-yklOYn99DDjBQ
Just Flash that, in order to uninstall Magisk from your device. And then, install the latest Magisk v25.2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi dear,
First of all thank you again.
After flashing this when i am entering again to recovery I don't get the screen of twarp as before.
However installation of v. 25.2 (in recovery)failed again..
Atached screen shots.
Hello guys,
I have poco x3pro and it is running Lineag os 18. Now i have an app called HDFC netbanking but while installing it shows "app does not support rooted device". i have learnt that with Magisk app i can buy pass it. so, how can i do that ? do i have to flash again? yours suggestions are welcomed.
Dezun said:
Hello guys,
I have poco x3pro and it is running Lineag os 18. Now i have an app called HDFC netbanking but while installing it shows "app does not support rooted device". i have learnt that with Magisk app i can buy pass it. so, how can i do that ? do i have to flash again? yours suggestions are welcomed.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did you root with magisk?
If old version
https://xiaomiui.net/how-to-use-magisk-hide-5610/
In Magisk settings, enable Zygisk and Enforce denylist, restart device, go to magisk settings again > configure denylist and check apps you want to hide from root.
NOSS8 said:
Did you root with magisk?
If old version
https://xiaomiui.net/how-to-use-magisk-hide-5610/
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No i flash with Twrp
Popletenec said:
In Magisk settings, enable Zygisk and Enforce denylist, restart device, go to magisk settings again > configure denylist and check apps you want to hide from root.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is the answer
samsungics1200 said:
This is the answer
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ok.. but do ihave to flash magisk ?
i have installed app but in magisk app setting i cant see the option mentioned.
Comdirect photoTAN app detecting root
Since version 8.3.0 additional measures to detect root have been added, do not update as MagiskHide won't be able to prevent detection. Until a solution is found I would recommend staying on the previous version for as long as possible. Finding...
forum.xda-developers.com
here is a lengthy thread with another bank, where you can find many many suggestions on how to fix the problem.
i am having x3pro myself using the app mentioned there, but not using LOS18 A11 but Miui A12
with the newer magisk versions
- denylist active
- maybe try shamiko module (denylist enforce off)
- maybe try without shamiko (denylist enforce on)
- maybe magiskhide props config module
- universal safetynet fix
- magisk package renamed
- make sure to enable all options on your denylist application selection to hide all processes
- the application might get root info from google play services (GMS) or play store, where you should also delete cache after making changes and rebooting to see if your change does take effect.
Dezun said:
ok.. but do ihave to flash magisk ?
i have installed app but in magisk app setting i cant see the option mentioned.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
you need to install the latest version of magisk app and flashable zip suitabe for your android version magisk 23 is for android 11 while magisk 24 is compatible upto latest but flash latest fpr maximum compatibility
Dezun said:
ok.. but do ihave to flash magisk ?
i have installed app but in magisk app setting i cant see the option mentioned.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Why don't you try ih8sn since you are on LineageOS.
Was this resolved? I am facing this issue myself at the moment with HDFC App.
ROM - Pixel experience 13 Plus
Device - OP7
Magisk v- 26.1
Universal Safety Net - 2.4.0
Deny List - enabled with many more apps
Example - Gpay, PhonePe, Paytm (All working fine)
YASNAC - Both checks passed