Case+screen protector success story - Essential Phone Accessories

The inevitable happened this morning: my PH-1 fell 90cm (just under 3 feet) from the top of a bookshelf to a hard, tile floor. The Orzero screen protector popped off, but, thanks to it and the Tudia Glost case -- and perhaps to sound construction of the phone itself -- there's not a scratch, bump or crack anywhere on the phone. BTW, the phone didn't fall because it's slippery; I knocked it off when I was trying to retrieve my reading glasses.

I don't think you can attribute your phone not being damaged to the case or screen protector. People have reported dropping their naked Essential phone without it being damaged. Others have reported having both case and screen protector and their screens cracking anyway. A phone with an edge to edge screen simply isn't going to receive much if any drop protection from a normal case or from a screen protector. Whether the display cracks or not just seems to be a matter of luck. The only type of case that could provide drop protection for a skinny edge to edge screen phone like the Essential is something bulky that most owners very likely wouldn't want to use.

jhs39 said:
I don't think you can attribute your phone not being damaged to the case or screen protector. People have reported dropping their naked Essential phone without it being damaged. Others have reported having both case and screen protector and their screens cracking anyway. A phone with an edge to edge screen simply isn't going to receive much if any drop protection from a normal case or from a screen protector. Whether the display cracks or not just seems to be a matter of luck. The only type of case that could provide drop protection for a skinny edge to edge screen phone like the Essential is something bulky that most owners very likely wouldn't want to use.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Maybe so, but the case certainly didn't hurt any! Since it's a bumper case with a lip all around the top edge, it's certain that the case absorbed some of the shock.

varxx said:
Maybe so, but the case certainly didn't hurt any! Since it's a bumper case with a lip all around the top edge, it's certain that the case absorbed some of the shock.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If it's a bumper case then it might have done what it's designed to do and absorb part of the shock. The screen protector is another matter. Glass screen protectors are supposed to stay attached to the screen and crack instead of the display if there is a fall. They aren't supposed to pop off. If you are planning on using a screen protector again you should seriously consider a different brand.

jhs39 said:
If it's a bumper case then it might have done what it's designed to do and absorb part of the shock. The screen protector is another matter. Glass screen protectors are supposed to stay attached to the screen and crack instead of the display if there is a fall. They aren't supposed to pop off. If you are planning on using a screen protector again you should seriously consider a different brand.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yep, I suppose you're right that the screen protector didn't do its job. I'm still pleased with the job the case did, though.

When I read the thread title I thought this post was about you having success finding a screen protector and case that works together

Related

Screen Protector or not?

I don't know if it neccessary to buy screen protector because N9 is built in Glorilla Glass 3.
Help Please !!!
roulyz said:
I don't know if it neccessary to buy screen protector because N9 is built in Glorilla Glass 3.
Help Please !!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I dont see the point..
roulyz said:
I don't know if it neccessary to buy screen protector because N9 is built in Glorilla Glass 3.
Help Please !!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Depends on how you'll be carrying the screen around with you.
If it's just a stay at home tablet, theres no real point, unless youre the type that likes to use your screen as a coaster or like to put other things on top of it.
If your carrying it around in a backpack, bag, or by hand, or throwing it on your carseat, then you're probably better off using case, cover, or sleeve for it. At this point, a screen protector will be redundant.
It's not like you're going to be carrying this thing in your pocket or anything where it might get scratched. I would say get a screen protector only if you hate the idea of having to use a case or cover.
mkygod said:
Depends on how you'll be carrying the screen around with you.
If it's just a stay at home tablet, theres no real point, unless youre the type that likes to use your screen as a coaster or like to put other things on top of it.
If your carrying it around in a backpack, bag, or by hand, or throwing it on your carseat, then you're probably better off using case, cover, or sleeve for it. At this point, a screen protector will be redundant.
It's not like you're going to be carrying this thing in your pocket or anything where it might get scratched. I would say get a screen protector only if you hate the idea of having to use a case or cover.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thanks for reply
Im definitely putting a screen protector on immediately. Even if you use the tablet exclusively at home it can still get scratched. I had a piece of what looked like glitter on my n5 when i went to wipe it off it scratched the screen. I bought a 3 pack made by mr. Shield on amazon for 4 dollars to hold me off until I can get my hands on a good tempered glass protector. Once you have tempered glass on you cant even tell there is a screen protector, and youll never have to worry about scratches. Plus, tempered glass will add protection in case of a drop. Its a no brainer for me. Screen protectors all the way.
Lokke9191 said:
Im definitely putting a screen protector on immediately. Even if you use the tablet exclusively at home it can still get scratched. I had a piece of what looked like glitter on my n5 when i went to wipe it off it scratched the screen. I bought a 3 pack made by mr. Shield on amazon for 4 dollars to hold me off until I can get my hands on a good tempered glass protector. Once you have tempered glass on you cant even tell there is a screen protector, and youll never have to worry about scratches. Plus, tempered glass will add protection in case of a drop. Its a no brainer for me. Screen protectors all the way.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So Screen Protector even on Gorilla glass ?
http://lifehacker.com/5937324/your-keys-arent-scratching-your-smartphone-its-the-sand-in-your-pocket
and
http://androidandme.com/2013/12/opinions/why-i-dont-use-screen-protectors-an-engineers-perspective/
good bathroom reading..
I am, probably a glass one since I don't like the feel of plastic. I use the ZAGG glass one on my G3 and its pretty awesome. So hopefully they'll come out with one for the N9.
roulyz said:
So Screen Protector even on Gorilla glass ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ya, gorilla glass 3 prevents scratches from keys and such, but small stuff like lint or whatever that shiny little glitter piece was will scratch the hell outta it.
Not me, I've never put a screen protector on a tablet and don't plan on starting now.
I've had a Nexus 5 (also gorilla glass 3) in my pocket without any screen protection. Not a scratch on it. I'm going to buy a cover for when I carry the Nexus 9 but no screen protector.
I would say probably no need. I'm not using a screen protector on my nexus 7, and it's quite alright. (I have a case on it) but I never take it out of my house, nor really ever out of the living room. It all depends on what you are going to be using the thing for, though.
If it will put your mind at ease, I would recommend a glass screen protector, maybe from zagg, or a good plastic one, like from amfilm.
But like I said, I don't really use a screen protector on my tablet, and I dont really think that it is necessary for me.
I'm using an amfilm screen protector. Cheap, effective, and not noticeable at all.
I never use one on any device, for me it ruins the experience. Won't be getting one for my N9
linelock said:
I never use one on any device, for me it ruins the experience. Won't be getting one for my N9
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
you should!
I always use screen protectors on my phones because despite what people tell you about gorilla glass eleventy-billion, it can and most likely will scratch from pocket carry. It is amazing how effective little bits of sand can be at scuffing up glass.
That said, for tablets I usually have some sort of case so I dont use screen protectors on them.
My N10 never saw a protector and the screen is still in top condition.... so I won't start using protectors now... IMHO the whole screen protector business is a scam. Or for careless people.
Gorilla glass 3 can scratch. I saw a Samsung rep who kept his note 3 in his pocket with keys and everything (his work phone he didn't care for) and the screen was badly scratched.
When it comes to glass screen protectors, why not get one as a bit of security and piece of mind? It'll cost less than a 10th of the device and arguably offer some protection of the most important part?
Glass screen protectors can be installed with 0 bubbles which make them near invisible. Plastic screen protectors are **** though and difficult to apply without bubbles and are often grippy, making for a painful experience. I would rather go naked than use a plastic screen protector.
If you keep it in the house with no kids then you probably don't need one though.
I already ordered a tempered glass for mine. I know I'll take it to the beach to read from and things like that.
Plus I like the drop protection that the tempered glass will give it.
NaterTots said:
I already ordered a tempered glass for mine. I know I'll take it to the beach to read from and things like that.
Plus I like the drop protection that the tempered glass will give it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
May I ask what was the product? I can't seem to find it for Nexus 9 (just previous models)...

Curved screen and protectors

They said it would not cover the whole screen but I didn't think it would be this extreme. Looking straight down on the device you'd see pixels outside of the screen protector on both sides.
Riffue.cn
This one is wider and covers all the pixels, but since it does not follow the screen curve there's about 1.5mm of free hanging protector on each side.
Panzer.me
For this one they tried to curve it along the screen edge, but it didn't quite fit, which caused large areas where the protector would lift from the screen. The downwards facing edge of the protector seems to be covered in the glue like substance, the central area of the protector did not stick to the phone in any way. Possibly because of the bad fit there would be some air between the protector and phone in the middle of the screen, this caused some missed taps. Away of the center of the protector the touch recognition would be better. This one seemed the least susceptible to fingerprints.
Thank you for the testing.
So I will not buy one of these.
Maybe I will try a thin l foil or I will use it without any protection.
thanks to who invented these fu*king curved screens.. for us that always use glass protectors it is simply a nightmare.. or you use protectors as big as the pixeled area and live with the edges coming off, or you take protectors smaller than the pixeled area that looks bad and don't protect all the screen.. damn
curious to know if this curved glass would be any better?
https://www.roxfit.mobi/collections...ed-clear-tempered-glass?variant=2219880841228
I am on the road so I cant post any pics, but I have the roxfit curved protector. It does match the screen except the curve isn't perfect thus the very edge around the entire screen is collecting dust. With the screen sensitivity issue however I'm debating on pulling it off. Hitting the same button 2-3 times to get something to register sucks
To be honest, this is what is putting me off buying this phone is the curved screen, i really dont see the point of it to be honest, tempted to jusct pick up the XZ1 compact instead.
You really can't even tell the screen is curved at all. Just the edges are slightly. It's not even noticeable.
yeah if the curved screen is the only thing preventing you from getting this phone, forget it, apart from this (and you'll notice just if you use glass protectors) the phone is simply wonderful in all other aspects l
mattnathaniel12 said:
You really can't even tell the screen is curved at all. Just the edges are slightly. It's not even noticeable.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
FcukBloat said:
yeah if the curved screen is the only thing preventing you from getting this phone, forget it, apart from this (and you'll notice just if you use glass protectors) the phone is simply wonderful in all other aspects l
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks both, best go and check it out in person, perhaps judging it before i have seen it in my hand is a bit negative.
Thanks
Bugs of a new phone. The protector I got also overhanged into the curve. (I was under the impression that it was a curved screen protector when buying it, but it was not.) I assume these companies didn't have exact specs or physical phones to get it perfect with, and since we all want our phones protected from day one, they have to release what they got. :/
Has anyone found a screen protector that fits halfway decently yet?
i used a liquid screen protector called nanofixit in the netherlands. it makes the screen super smooth and didn't have a scratch after a week usage without any case. i had to send it back for repair and will have it back tomorrow.
Roxfit
mattnathaniel12 said:
I am on the road so I cant post any pics, but I have the roxfit curved protector. It does match the screen except the curve isn't perfect thus the very edge around the entire screen is collecting dust. With the screen sensitivity issue however I'm debating on pulling it off. Hitting the same button 2-3 times to get something to register sucks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've tried this one as well and might have a worse fit than what you're experiencing. It was impossible to get a complete seal in the glue around the edge. The bad fit made the center of the screen an especially bad place the get touches registered, even worse then the panzer.me glass. IIRC there was also a shimmering issue between the edge of the LCD and whatever non-stick film they've put under the protector.
Does curved screen protectors exist for other phones that does not rely on a glue around the edges to stay put?
nanofixit
Dxue said:
i used a liquid screen protector called nanofixit in the netherlands. it makes the screen super smooth and didn't have a scratch after a week usage without any case. i had to send it back for repair and will have it back tomorrow.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Based on threads in this forum:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/note-4/accessories/nanofixit-liquid-screen-protector-nano-t3215739
and amazon reviews:
https://www.amazon.com/Nanofixit-ONE-Titanium-OFFICAL-antibacterial/product-reviews/B019Y4IPU4
it seems the nanofixit products might not be worth the asking price. (Scam perhaps?)
Did you get your phone back? What was the issue? Do you usually get scratches on phones in a weeks time?
I'm asking because fail to see how a thin layer of liquid could provide any scratch resistance, besides whatever the screen already has. And as such it might just make liquid slide off the screen easily for a while and not much else.
It is my belief the nano liquid products are a scam. Granted I've never tried it myself.....but I don't see how it could possibly work.
Based on threads in this forum:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/not...-nano-t3215739
and amazon reviews:
https://www.amazon.com/Nanofixit-ONE...ews/B019Y4IPU4
it seems the nanofixit products might not be worth the asking price. (Scam perhaps?)
Did you get your phone back? What was the issue? Do you usually get scratches on phones in a weeks time?
I'm asking because fail to see how a thin layer of liquid could provide any scratch resistance, besides whatever the screen already has. And as such it might just make liquid slide off the screen easily for a while and not much else.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It is my belief the nano liquid products are a scam. Granted I've never tried it myself.....but I don't see how it could possibly work.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
it was my misstake for not being clearer when posting my message, I have another problem with the phone which is not related to the screen at all. My phone can't receive incoming calls for some reason. The screen is still in a tip top shape and i have also accidentally dropped the phone on a stone floor from around 0,5 meters. Nothing to see on the screen (or the phone for that matter). The reason that it can work in my opinion is that you can have very hard plastic nowadays that is not worse than metal (see carbon fiber for example). If they can keep it in a liuid state and it can harden itself out when in contact with air, why is it not possible? Chemistry is nowadays so advanced I wouldn't be surprised if they can make even better nano coatings, if you have enough money for it
Bought Skinomi's protector and it was a perfect fit. It is not a hard screen protector its more of a clear flexible skin. Due to it being flexible it molded right to the curved edges of the screen without any issues. Until they come up with a hard protector this should do just fine though, atleast itll keep minor scuffs and scratches to a minimum.
Ultimate Shield seems to do its job - at least for me. Uses glue to stick, but covers the whole screen. Makes a bit harder to register touch sometimes.

Are screen protectors still necessary on modern phones?

I have a hard time finding a screen protector for my Oneplus 3T.
It has to cover the whole display, has to have glue on the entire surface.
I only found one TPU protector and had a really hard time fitting it without bubbles (I am experienced in mounting glass protectors).
Currently it is mounted properly, but it will come off eventually.
Are screen protectors still necessary on modern phones, especially OP3T with Gorilla Glass?
I have a Tudia Armor case for it, giving it some rubber protection on the sides, but nothing on the lit screen itself.
I always put my phone in my right front pocket. I never have anything else in this pocket except dust.
nadastry said:
I have a hard time finding a screen protector for my Oneplus 3T.
It has to cover the whole display, has to have glue on the entire surface.
I only found one TPU protector and had a really hard time fitting it without bubbles (I am experienced in mounting glass protectors).
Currently it is mounted properly, but it will come off eventually.
Are screen protectors still necessary on modern phones, especially OP3T with Gorilla Glass?
I have a Tudia Armor case for it, giving it some rubber protection on the sides, but nothing on the lit screen itself.
I always put my phone in my right front pocket. I never have anything else in this pocket except dust.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yes, they are. I left my iPhone X unprotected for 2 months and the screen picked up multiple scratches.
As far as my opinion I would say no if you are good with few minor scratches and not using it roughly
It depends on how long you want to keep your screen in perfect condition. Without the protective film, you'll see minor scratches in a year's time, even if you're careful
Depends on your usage, case, and device...
Double Sided Full Body PVC case also do the trick.

Question Cases and Screen Protector

Hello everyone, just got myself a S7 Tab FE and was looking around for cases. Has anyone found a nice case as well as screen protection?
Something with a screen this size im guessing it's important to keep it in a very nice sturdy shock proof case.
The problem with device is the thinness and large size. Even with a good case a drop may break the display... try to avoid doing it. Perhaps tethering the case may help.
As for screen protectors I use these on my N10+'s. The are an easy wet apply and last an average of 6 months. Even the spen doesn't bugger them up; they are self healing to a certain extent. Exhibit almost no yellowing over their lifespan.
blackhawk said:
The problem with device is the thinness and large size. Even with a good case a drop may break the display... try to avoid doing it. Perhaps tethering the case may help.
As for screen protectors I use these on my N10+'s. The are an easy wet apply and last an average of 6 months. Even the spen doesn't bugger them up; they are self healing to a certain extent. Exhibit almost no yellowing over their lifespan.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes it feels awkwardly large and thin. Might try the S7 keyboard. Not sure how well it would function as a case tho.
I might check this screen protector out however on my N20 I prefer the glass screen protector rather then the film ones
derrickdroid said:
Yes it feels awkwardly large and thin. Might try the S7 keyboard. Not sure how well it would function as a case tho.
I might check this screen protector out however on my N20 I prefer the glass screen protector rather then the film ones
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Another member had a case and tempered glass protector on their's and broke the display recently.
The IQ Sheild will protect it from marring and scratches. Temper glass protector or not I would assume any sizable impact is likely to break the display.
Think about where you are and what you're doing when handling it... you know how it goes.
Lol, put away getting drunk
I bought the Tab S7 plus book cover it fits well with magnets
with a tempered glass screen protector they are here since I bought the device 3 months ago and they are fine
I put my tablet in my backpack so it's not a big deal
original book cover or keyboard cover are nice. But expensive and do not offer any more protection then some generic 15$ ones. I have one of those generic ones for home use because I need kickstand feature. Also have a spigen rugged armor, which I use while working on the filed. That one also has a sand feature but the case as such is pretty stiff so it needs more attention to use it that way. Not really cheap but certainly gives more protection then the original ones for less money.
And for screen, I don''t use any screen protectors, glass is scratch resistant enough for a while now and with screens huge as this or devices thin like this nothing really helps against cracking it. Need to be careful, that is the only thing that will help.
I went with a Poetic rubber-ish case and SuperShieldz tempered glass screen protector. The case is nice. Fits well with the screen protector, and even redirects the speakers toward your face which is awesome for watching movies or gaming.

Accessories Whitestone Dome cracking

Hi Y'all.
I've applied Whitestone Dome protector twice now.
No bubbles and application appears perfect.
Fingerprint sensor works albeit not quite as well as before application.
All well & fine - but: both times the protector cracks in the lower left corner.
I haven't observed any physical reason - i.e. drops or otherwise - for this to happen.
I ordered a new package.
Thoughts/experience welcome?
Regards
elo
You using a case?
Otherwise dimensions are off, mounted off center or surface not level.
QC and customer service sucks with Whitestone, that was my experience with them; to sum it up it was very unpleasant. I won't touch their offshore junk again.
This phone needs a good case like the Zizo Bolt or it will get damaged. These are heavy, hard hitting phones in a drop that wuv to corner hit and face plant. The case provides the primary protection. Something like the Gorilla IQ Sheild provides good scratch/mar protection, is inexpensive but doesn't feel like glass, obviously.
I've use both on my N10+'s for years; zero damage in spite of hard drops onto concrete.
I gave up on glass screen protectors and switched to quality TPU protectors.
Cheaper, better, easy to install. EGV Screen Protector
hand-filer said:
I gave up on glass screen protectors and switched to quality TPU protectors.
Cheaper, better, easy to install. EGV Screen Protector
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yep...glass protectors are crap. They chip and break so easily. I use TPU and they're way better.
pjaysnowden said:
Yep...glass protectors are crap. They chip and break so easily. I use TPU and they're way better.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
hard disagree
Using this since day 1 and it is still perfect.
There's also no hole/cutout on top like that piece of **** whitedome.
If his protector keep cracking at the exact set spot, chances are his case is the problem.
I am using the official Samsung leather case and there's zero issue, it fits like a glove with protector on.
i use whitestone for the last 7 months with a case that fit perfect and i have zero cracks. i am still on first glass. very satisfied.
Polar67 said:
Hi Y'all.
I've applied Whitestone Dome protector twice now.
No bubbles and application appears perfect.
Fingerprint sensor works albeit not quite as well as before application.
All well & fine - but: both times the protector cracks in the lower left corner.
I haven't observed any physical reason - i.e. drops or otherwise - for this to happen.
I ordered a new package.
Thoughts/experience welcome?
Regards
elo
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you attache photos?
Are you sure that it's crack glass?
I use DomeGlass from Note 9>N20U>S22U and even perfect application usually after few months I see just like cracks in corner/corners/edges but it's fault glue under glass which look like this.
I don't know why is this happening.
hhwong said:
hard disagree
Using this since day 1 and it is still perfect.
There's also no hole/cutout on top like that piece of **** whitedome.
If his protector keep cracking at the exact set spot, chances are his case is the problem.
I am using the official Samsung leather case and there's zero issue, it fits like a glove with protector on.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i applied this type of glass but after 1-2 weeks edges starting peeling..
khachanedhaval said:
i applied this type of glass but after 1-2 weeks edges starting peeling..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Your glue was not cured properly, it happens when you don't give it enough UV or still have air on the edge.
It also happens when you have a case that's constantly pushing the edge.
All I'm saying is the Samsung official leather case works perfectly with the protector I have in pic, that's all

Categories

Resources