Related
Besides the missing flash for the camera, the fingerprint addicted plastic cover of the otherwise great Galaxy S has been the main target of critics.
To solve this issue there are a lot of extra covers available. Some replace the original accu cover, some span the whole phone.
I myself have been looking quite some time to find the right cover for me and ended up with some covers in my possession.
I hope to be of any help to others on the same journey I give you a short review and comparison of the covers I got here. Pics included.
To clarify what we are dealing with I'll start with the original cover.
Original Galaxy S cover
Few to add. Standard cover that comes with the phone.
Pro:
- free
Contra:
- attracts fingerprints as light the moth
- slippery
- cheap look
Mumbi silicon case
I bought this from amazon for around € 5. Main purpose was to protect the phone for my vacation abroad.
Pro:
- Great grip and handling. The former slippery tiny SGS becomes a real something in your hand.
- cheap
- good protection against dropping damage
- makes your phone a real outdoor device
Contra:
- adds about 2 mm to each sides
- gives the stylish SGS a real tweedy look.
- attracted dust and fabric fibres in the pocket
- display is hard to clean - you cant just rub it anywhere because the cover stands over the display about 1 mm.
Case Mate barely there silicon cover
This one was a present from my wife and is my favourite so far.
Pro:
- nothing slippery anymore. Great grip.
- adds barely some width to the phone
- looks very clean
- doesn't attract dust ore fibres
- very tight
Contra:
- quite expensive ( well not for me )
- sometimes a little hard to apply or get off the phone. I was at first affraid I might damage the hull of the SGS but its fine since a lot of on-off.
- will probably stain underneath cover, see: Update.
Long-term information:
After using the barely there cover for some weeks I noticed some damageto the underlying basic cover . So if you are using a softer basic cover underneath the barely-there-casemate-cover you will likely notice som stains after a while. Not a big issue, but for me I decided to reattache the original basic cover to avoid spoiling my nice rubbery basic cover.
Matte black accu cover from ebay
This cover attracted my attention via the SGS Matte/rubberized battery cover-Thread in this very forum. It's nearly perfect for me and I use it under any extra cover. Update: Well not anymore - see update for casemate-barely-there above.
Pro:
- Good grip (though not a good as the Case Mate Cover)
- cheap (about € 7 incl. shipping via ebay)
- adds no extra space to the phone
Contra:
- No extra protection
Nillkin Tough Shield
This case was provided by www.casesss.com and can be purchased there. It came with the two Rock Naked Shell covers. It is very similar to my favourite (the case mate barely there cover), but has some definite advantages.
For overall comparison I added a picture of the case mate, the Nillkin and the Rock cases.
Pro:
- its about half the price (in €) as the case mate cover from amazon.de
- this Nillkin case DOES NOT have this ugly stand offs that damage your underneath cover (See details at the case mate review above).
- Overall good quality, good grip and perfect fit.
- Screen protector shield included
Contra:
- None, so far.
Note:
I will add some long term use infos about the cover in the futere.
Rock "Naked Shell" Cover
This one was also supplied by www.casesss.com. It's tends to become my new favourite. It is labeled to be used with the Galaxy S Plus i9001 - but as both share the same form, it also fits for the Galaxy S i9000. It comes with a free screen shield and a little plastic stand. This also lacks the annoying little rubber stand-offs that go with the barely there case (see details there).
Pro:
- Its very silky and smooth. Great feel and look!
- No stand-offs that damage your basic cover
- Good price
- Shield included
- plastic stand included
Contra:
- None, so far
Note:
Long term use info will be given.
Rock "Naked Shell Pearly Red"
Another one from www.casesss.com. It has a nice pearly look I havent seen so far. Very classy! Feels equally silky as the black Rock Naked Shell cover. As all Rock Cases it also comes with free screen shield and plastic stand (see pics above).
Pro:
- Unique look
- Good price
- Perfect fit
- No stand-offs
- Shield included
- plastic stand included
Contra:
- None so far
Note
Long term infos will be added.
________________________________________________________
Reviews by other members:
Mesh cover WHITE Galaxy S by DeGygii
purchased at www.Ricardo.ch
Pro:
- very stylish
- is realy thin
- fits perfect
- not slippery coz of the holes
- protects the phone from drops
Contra:
- not rubberized
- a bit expensive (15 €)
DeathMetalX said:
Besides the missing flash for the camera, the fingerprint addicted plastic cover of the otherwise great Galaxy S has been the main target of critics.
To solve this issue there are a lot of extra covers available. Some replace the original accu cover, some span the whole phone.
I myself have been looking quite some time to find the right cover for me and ended up with some covers in my possession.
I hope to be of any help to others on the same journey I give you a short review and comparison of the covers I got here. Pics included.
To clarify what we are dealing with I'll start with the original cover.
Original Galaxy S cover
Few to add. Standard cover that comes with the phone.
Pro:
- free
Contra:
- attracts fingerprints as light the moth
- slippery
- cheap look
Mumbi silicon case
I bought this from amazon for around € 5. Main purpose was to protect the phone for my vacation abroad.
Pro:
- Great grip and handling. The former slippery tiny SGS becomes a real something in your hand.
- cheap
- good protection against dropping damage
- makes your phone a real outdoor device
Contra:
- adds about 2 mm to each sides
- gives the stylish SGS a real tweedy look.
- attracted dust and fabric fibres in the pocket
- display is hard to clean - you cant just rub it anywhere because the cover stands over the display about 1 mm.
Case Mate barely there silicon cover
This one was a present from my wife and is my favourite so far.
Pro:
- nothing slippery anymore. Great grip.
- adds barely some width to the phone
- looks very clean
- doesn't attract dust ore fibres
- very tight
Contra:
- quite expensive ( well not for me )
- sometimes a little hard to apply or get off the phone. I was at first affraid I might damage the hull of the SGS but its fine since a lot of on-off.
Matte black accu cover from ebay
This cover attracted my attention via the SGS Matte/rubberized battery cover-Thread in this very forum. It's nearly perfect for me and I use it always under any extra cover.
Pro:
- Good grip (though not a good as the Case Mate Cover)
- cheap (about € 7 incl. shipping via ebay)
- adds no extra space to the phone
Contra:
- No extra protection
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hello mate, i like ,,Matte black accu cover from ebay'', this is the right one for me. Is it from ebay.de cuz i cant shop from ebay, so i will have to ask a friend who lives in Germany. In Romania we cant find only the rubber case for i9000.
Thanks for the info
Just check the thread I linked. As I say: Its from ebay, yes. Just check the Thread and see for youself where they ship to.
Greets DMX
Great comparison, bought few covers but didn't really like them (most shops around here ain't carrying them so have to buy online).
Think i'll get case mate now, didn't wanna bother spending money on it, incase it turned out like rest of the covers
Glad to be of assistance. dont forget the Thanks Button
I love the Casemate Barely There case! I've been using it for 7 months now,I love it. Highly recommended!
The look and feel is really good, the material that they used is not sticky or a "lint magnet" compared to other cases.
Nice comparison there dude, i got a SGP Ultra Slider instead in the end due to the buttons thingie (case mate barely there last i check had a rubber piece protecting the buttons)Sad thing is cases for SGS are hard to get here too
Thanx. I'll try to add more and more Cases on the go. If anybody has a suggestion, shoot. I`ll be happy to add more Cases.
SGP Ultra Silke
Hi there,
I bought the SGP Ultra Silke Case about a month or two ago and I'd like to offer my opinion on the case.
The case is made out of silicone but it is apparent that there is some sort of matte/anti grip coating that feels like...paper. However, there's none of the roughness, so it feels like very smooth, high quality paper.
Case itself looks great, all the holes line of perfectly and there is no trouble in pressing the buttons. I love the minimalistic look that it conveys. On the front of the phone, the case lip is angled and feel like part of the phone.
Problem: Why oh why does the finish wear off? After a couple of days of use I could feel the outside edge where my hands came into contact often was worn out. Now patches all around the case have worn off and the resulting bare finish attracts dust.
DeathMetalX said:
Thanx. I'll try to add more and more Cases on the go. If anybody has a suggestion, shoot. I`ll be happy to add more Cases.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nice write up. I had used the casemate too but now my fav is my current Otterbox Commuter. You may wat to try it.
My 2nd bes fav is the SGP Ultra Slider.
sirbrian said:
Nice write up. I had used the casemate too but now my fav is my current Otterbox Commuter. You may wat to try it.
My 2nd bes fav is the SGP Ultra Slider.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You should upload some photos with the cases u r using
Yes, please. Anybody feel free to add further reviews and pics. I can even add them to the startpost.
Will gladly add one on my next purchase of another Ultra Slider. If the thing fades,it might be fake? (since tons of SGP fake stuff are going around atm)
LacusClyne said:
Will gladly add one on my next purchase of another Ultra Slider. If the thing fades,it might be fake? (since tons of SGP fake stuff are going around atm)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The SGP ultra slider finishing is very lasting. Mine is still pretty good except of the top corners as I always inverted the phone i place into my pants pocket...
cioconebunu said:
You should upload some photos with the cases u r using
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Will do so when I get back to office tomorrow. Got to use another digital camera to take the phone with the case...
Case mate
recently got the case mate... works great for me. the only downside is the price.
Case-mate for me to..had one for a few months now and its been outstanding...combined with a good quality screen protector of course.
LacusClyne said:
Nice comparison there dude, i got a SGP Ultra Slider instead in the end due to the buttons thingie (case mate barely there last i check had a rubber piece protecting the buttons)Sad thing is cases for SGS are hard to get here too
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think what you saw was the silicone case. Because the "Barely There" only have holes for the buttons.
I Swyped this on my Galaxy S
If anyone could take pics of the cases I didnt cover ( ), that would be great. I will add them to the starting post. This way the readers won't have to scroll through the whole thread.
Some links would be very nice.
Hey all, thought I'd provide some comparison pictures for anyone who is not sure whether to pick up the D3O case ($24.99 from T-Mobile) or the Diztronic Matte Back Transluscent Black case ($9.90 from Amazon).
I originally bought the D3O because I was desperate for some protection. I had already dropped my phone on my apartment's concrete floor (luckily, not a single scratch or dent) and that made me nervous every time I pulled it out of my pocket. The D3O provides excellent protection but adds considerable bulk around the outside of the phone. Also, something bothered me about the thickness of the outer border relative to the size of the silver strip on the top of the phone (this would only be a problem for the T-Mobile gradient blue since the top is silver). Anyway, the thickness of the border and silver strip are about the same size and I thought it made the phone look weird. The bulkiness also made the phone a little more difficult to use one-handed because even though I have large hands (I'm 6'2"), it was much harder to reach the opposite/top corner of the phone using my thumb.
I then came across the Diztronic case online and saw someone post a picture of it here on XDA. It seemed to get good reviews and looked good, so I ordered that from Amazon. I feel like the phone has a much better look with this case as it retains its natural sleekness. The case doesn't add much bulk at all, yet it does provide some protection for the sides, top, and bottom. It's enough protection to prevent the phone from getting scratched up by carelessly placing the phone down onto surfaces, but it's not enough protection to make me feel completely safe about dropping the phone 4 or 5 feet onto concrete (although I do think the screen would be protected if it dropped flat onto a straight surface since the case does create a lip of protection for the screen - the case also came with a screen protector, which I do not care to use).
D3O Pros
Much more protection (thickness and softness of the rubber)
*Slightly* more grip than Diztronic
Diztronic Pros
Much better looking (opinion)
Easier to use one-handed
Much cheaper
Note, both cases are great looking in the back. The D3O has a matte finish (front & back) and that gives it almost a charcoal grey look. The Diztronic is a dark matte grey color and *slightly* translucent. Both of them look great with the blue "pop" from the rear camera.
The front of the D3O is all matte and has a thick border (makes it ugly with the grey strip showing through up top - see my commentary from above). The front of the Diztronic is grey, thin, and more of a reflective plastic or rubber. Again, it's slightly transluscent, and this combination (of size, color, and reflectivity) complements the front of the phone really well (IMO).
Some other notable features before I submit:
The D3O has covers for the power button and volume rocker (cut-outs for everything else). The coverings are rather stiff and this makes it difficult to activate the buttons.
The Diztronic has a cover for the volume rocker and an opening for the power button. The opening for the power button makes it easy to "locate" the power button with your finger, which in turn, makes it easy to activate. The covering on the volume rocker is not nearly as stiff as the D3O.
Both cases seem EXTREMELY well made and have almost PERFECT cut-outs, but I do prefer the larger cut-out for the microphone on the Diztronic.
In conclusion, I prefer the Diztronic. Going to try to return my D3O (although I just noticed my receipt says that accessories can't be returned, so I might be stuck with both).
Hope my [anal]ysis was helpful.
Nice review, and I work at t-mobile...you can return accessories including D3O.
Sent from my HTC one S using xda premium
Thanks!
Yeah, I attempted the return today not realizing that I purchased the case from an authorized dealer and not a corporate store. I was in upper Manhattan over the weekend when I bought it and I could have sworn the place was a corporate store but the receipt says "Wireless Champs" on the top. It looked just like a corporate store in there. Anyway, I live pretty far from Upper Manhattan so I might just try to sell it on Craigslist.
LG CCL-320
A little bit expencive but looks great.Bad thing that i couldn't find it in my country anywhere...
Product description:
- Professional and stylish, the CCL-320 is designed specifically to work with you LG Optimus 3D.
- The LG CCL-320 is made from genuine leather which provides rugged protection against scratches and knocks, and features a plastic rail on the inside to securely hold your phone in place. The case and the support rail features cut outs which allow you to access all of the ports and features of your LG Optimus 3D without removing it from the case.
- This case is a horizontal pouch with an integrated viewing stand, so once you've recorded your high-definition 3D movies you can watch them back in comfort. The case also features a magnetic closure which securely holds the case shut ensuring that, when not in use, your phone will remain protected at all times.
- With a case like this, you can confidently store your handset in your pocket, bag or briefcase without worrying if it will get damaged. If your taste is more a classic than funky style, then this is the case for you.
Case-Mate POP!
I'm going to buy this one for sure...
Product description:
LG Optimus 3D P920 Pop Case integrates two materials in a seamless way, a high gloss plastic shell executed with modern technique and a soft interior material to create a co-molded racing glove!
- Co-molding of lightweight plastic and soft rubber for a seamless protective case
- Form fit feature covers back and corners
- Protective lay flat design keeps your screen from hitting surfaces when device is placed on its face
- Impact resistant, flexible plastic shell
- Access to all ports and functions
- Comes in many different colours
Teracell TPU Case
I personally use this. It's lightweight, made of durable material, not slippery and fits our P920 like a glove. :laugh:
Product description:
- Made of solid silicone which fits perfectly on the phone and protects it maximum from the damage from falls and use.
- There are openings for the cameras, LED flash, 3.5mm jack, speaker and microphones.
- Very easy to install and remove from the phone.
- Silicon thickness less than 1mm so very little influence on the size of the device.
- Top quality trim.
Case-Mate Tough Case
Product description:
Built to withstand sudden drops and accidental falls, the Tough case is the epitome of protection. A snug, form fitting silicone wrap provides shock resistance, while the polycarbonate hard shell protects against impact. The lightweight, slim case adds support and shields your phone, keeping your emotional state intact, one drop at a time.
- Dual layers of silicone and polycarbonate hard shell combine for secure protection
- Form fit feature covers back and corners
- Impact resistant, flexible plastic shell
- Access to all ports and functions
Ballistic SG Shell Gel Case
Little bit bulky but I assume that it gives premium protection...
Product description:
The Ballistic Shell Gel (SG) Series case offers amazing protection for your LG optimus 3D P920. The Ballistic Shell Gel (SG) Series Case with not one, not two, but THREE layers of protection. The first and outermost layer is made of Ballistic shock absorbent polymer. Number 2, which is made of a tough impact resistant polycarbonate. Last but not least, layer number three, which is the inner-most layer, made of a soft silicone. This layer also includes the Ballistic Corners which means all four corners have extra shock absorption where you need it the most!
- Advanced three layers of protection.
- Layer 1 - Ballistic shock absorbent polymer.
- Layer 2 - Tough impact resistant polycarbonate shell.
- Layer 3 - Soft silicon, equipped with Ballistic Corners.
- Lay-on-table feature.
- Pocket-able protection.
- Sleek, slim fit to the LG optimus 3D P920 device.
- Additional bump, scratch & drop protection.
- Fully interactive through the case.
Seidio ACTIVE Case and Holster
Product description:
Seidio’s ACTIVE Combo includes a ACTIVE case and ACTIVE holster. The ACTIVE case is thin and protects your LG Thrill 4G/Optimus 3D from scratches and drops, while adding minimal bulk. Slip the case into a secure spring-clip ACTIVE holster for the ultimate carrying solution for your device.
ACTIVE case
- Sleek case that provides scratch protection without adding much bulk
- Precision cut-outs for access to the ports, cameras, and controls
- Unique slide-in design makes putting on and removing your case easy
ACTIVE Holster
- Felt-lined holster with face-in design keeps your LG Thrill 4G/Optimus 3D safe
- Top clip allows for easy access and belt clip swivels in up to seven directions
- For use with ACTIVE case only
Seidio SURFACE Case (with kickstand)
Product description:
The SURFACE case is the right case for those who are looking for sleek protection. This case protects your LG Thrill 4G/Optimus 3D from scratches and drops while adding minimal bulk. Durable plastic is accompanied by our soft-touch coating, which enhances the look of your device without attracting lint.
The built-in kickstand can be used in landscape or portrait orientations for a hands free experience when viewing multimedia, managing photo slideshows, and displaying clocks and calendars.
- Sleek case that provides scratch protection without adding much bulk
- Precision cut-outs for access to the ports, camera, and volume buttons
- Unique slide-together design and interior felt lining
- Kickstand extends ~80 degrees from its point of origin and easily snaps back into place after use
- Compatible with SURFACE holster (not included)
iGadgitz Black Silicone Skin Case Cover with Tyre Tread Design
Product description:
- Custom made for LG Optimus 3D P920 with our classic tyre tread design.
- Supplied with stick-on screen protector.
- Produced from superior quality, shock absorbant, ATS (anti-static) silicone.
- This silicone skin protects your Optimus 3D from nasty chips and scratches.
- Full access to all controls, functions and docking while skinned.
- Cut-outs for camera, flash and headphone port.
ubabic said:
LG CCL-320
A little bit expencive but looks great.Bad thing that i couldn't find it in my country anywhere...
Product description:
Professional and stylish, the CCL-320 is designed specifically to work with you LG Optimus 3D.
The LG CCL-320 is made from genuine leather which provides rugged protection against scratches and knocks, and features a plastic rail on the inside to securely hold your phone in place. The case and the support rail features cut outs which allow you to access all of the ports and features of your LG Optimus 3D without removing it from the case.
This case is a horizontal pouch with an integrated viewing stand, so once you've recorded your high-definition 3D movies you can watch them back in comfort. The case also features a magnetic closure which securely holds the case shut ensuring that, when not in use, your phone will remain protected at all times.
With a case like this, you can confidently store your handset in your pocket, bag or briefcase without worrying if it will get damaged. If your taste is more a classic than funky style, then this is the case for you.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
hi, how about the link? where can i buy this?
schubeir
schubeir said:
hi, how about the link? where can i buy this?
schubeir
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's not so hard to find using search button on Google...
There are many other good cases for our O3D...I will post their reviews when I find some time to research...
MOMAX iCase Pro
Product description:
- 2 in 1 Materials: PC + TPU
- Shock-adsorbing rubber edge & transparent plastic back
- Durable, flame, scratch resistant & washable
- Cut outs openings for your easy access to all ports
- Slide Out the phone easily
- Free Gift: Anti-Glare Screen Protector
Jekod Super Cool Case
Product description:
- Quality imported PC material
- Precise tailoring,closely linked to the body
- Slim design,light as a substance
- Easy assembly and disassembly
- Super dust proof cut design
- Super protection,not easy to break
- Color: black, brown, red, white
ROCK LG Optimus 3D P920 Naked Ultra-thin Case
Product description:
- Extra-strong quality polycarbonate material
- Not easy to deform and difficult to scratch,
- Frosted smooth process
- No fingerprints
- Color: Black, Wine-red
- Attached Gift: Screen protecting film, High-fiber lens-cleaning cloth
MERCURY Jelly Case
Product description:
- Prevents your mobile from scratches, damages and dust.
- Fully compatible with your LG Optimus 3D
- Ultra Slim fit and super light-weight
- Easy access to all controls and ports
http://www.amazon.com/Moto-Style-Pu...=1445563528&sr=1-65&keywords=moto+x+pure+case
other colors too same price http://www.amazon.com/LK-Absorption...=1445563842&sr=1-76&keywords=moto+x+pure+case
-Dual layer
-black
-sizeable cutout of the moto signature color accent on back
-shock absorbent
-No known bugs, You tell me.
It's a case, why would there be bugs? lol
love these type of cases! thanks!
Complementary bugs in your cases packaging maybe?
The CIMO wave case has been awesome for me, it's very slim and adds grip in right places. Had an incipio octane prior to the cimo, it was bulky and didn't feel good to the touch.
Got two of them, I'm not a big fan of mine. My wife likes her pink one though. It's too thick... way to thick for pocket users.
I've had this two weeks. Pros - easy to extract phone to fit in my armband for workouts, very low cost. Cons - It's too easy to remove the case. I've picked the phone up a few times and noticed one or two corners coming free. The pliable inner layer is all that protects the corners, and this layer is neither as thick at the corners nor as dense as I'd like (my ideal being a Ballistic Shell Gel). I'm happy to put up with bulk for protection, but I'm not confident this protects my phone adequately.
This one looks identical in every respect, but comes in eight colors and is cheaper at $6.99.
I received this case for review and I absolutely love it. the design is sleek but rugged so that it feels like it's properly protected as well as being protected. I love that the buttons for the volume are covered by rubber so that you can easily distinguish the fingerprint/power button. The opening mechanism is very smooth and feels great every time. the front of the phone when opened is surrounded by that protective rubber with cutouts exactly where you need them. I like that the logo is placed just so it's there but not in your face. When closed the phone is encased and fully protected with openings only where you need them. The case has a raised area around the outer screen and cameras so that when laid down they don't touch. I love that the outside is kept sleek without unnecessary grooves and ridges because it allows me to attach my grip mount to the back of the phone. I really don't see how you could make a better case. I got it in black which is awesome but wouldn't mind having a color-matched case, that's a minor thing compared to the fact that it is one of the best cases I've used for my Flip 4.