Hey Guys, can someone tell me what Magisk version works and does not result in a bootloop or has other negative effects? The last time I used Magisk I had problems with 15.x, are all issues are now fixed or are there still some remaining?
Lukke2804 said:
Hey Guys, can someone tell me what Magisk version works and does not result in a bootloop or has other negative effects? The last time I used Magisk I had problems with 15.x, are all issues are now fixed or are there still some remaining?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am using v15. 3 without any problems..
Magisk hide is having some problem with fingerprint recognition.. Some times when magisk hide is on finger print wont work. Its a problem with all the magisk versions i tried . So i turned it off.
Latest version works for me, although it doesn't pass the Safety net checks. Therefore some finance programs may not work, but root and modules work fine.
So I'm on Android DP4 and I didn't install magisk or anything and Snapchat is failing I can't download Netflix and nothing's quite working so I guess they just trigger the safety net for just being on a developer preview? Like on DP3 I could still.use Snapchat just fine this one won't let me log in just keeps saying my password is wrong
You presumably have an unlocked bootloader. Have you flashed a custom kernel? You'll need one which has patched the something-something. All custom kennels do. I don't know if there are custom kernels that are compatible with DP4 yet but I suspect there are. Try flashing one and then checking if safety net still fails.
AaronGavin said:
So I'm on Android DP4 and I didn't install magisk or anything and Snapchat is failing I can't download Netflix and nothing's quite working so I guess they just trigger the safety net for just being on a developer preview? Like on DP3 I could still.use Snapchat just fine this one won't let me log in just keeps saying my password is wrong
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Google had to fix their end. It's fixed.
Sent from my Pixel 2 using Tapatalk
I've recently encountered a problem. I rooted My Pixel 3a when it had stock Android 10 and passed the SafetyNet checks.
I then upgraded to stock Android 11 (RP1A.201005.004, Oct 2020) and re-rooted. However, the Magisk SafetyNet check now reports as 'attestation failed'. basicIntegrity passes but ctsProfile now fails (evalType HARDWARE).
Can anyone help in identifying the problem and how to resolve it?
largeruk said:
I've recently encountered a problem. I rooted My Pixel 3a when it had stock Android 10 and passed the SafetyNet checks.
I then upgraded to stock Android 11 (RP1A.201005.004, Oct 2020) and re-rooted. However, the Magisk SafetyNet check now reports as 'attestation failed'. basicIntegrity passes but ctsProfile now fails (evalType HARDWARE).
Can anyone help in identifying the problem and how to resolve it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Same, passed it about a week ago and failed it today - I've had the October update since release and it has been fine so something has changed in the last few days ?
Magisk 21005
Manager 311
Cananry update channel
captain sideways said:
Same, passed it about a week ago and failed it today - I've had the October update since release and it has been fine so something has changed in the last few days
Magisk 21005
Manager 311
Cananry update channel
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You have to use magiskhide props module. See its XDA thread.
magjir said:
You have to use magiskhide props module. See its XDA thread.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks very much for that - I did try that but it didn't work for me - went on a few searches and this module I found elsewhere on here did work.
I just flashed it and my cts profile passes - there some interesting posts round it as well:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=83028387&postcount=40655
Relevant: https://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=83028387&postcount=40655
@largeruk @captain sideways
Hey, I hate to steal the thread, but I wanted to ask if either of you would please upload a copy of the Magisk patched boot image file that you used. The ones that I have been generating using MM 8.0.2 and the latest sargo factory boot image have consistently failed to boot for me and I would like an image that has been proven to work. I would greatly appreciate you help!
UPDATE
Thanks for the file! It worked for me.
captain sideways said:
Thanks very much for that - I did try that but it didn't work for me - went on a few searches and this module I found elsewhere on here did work.
I just flashed it and my cts profile passes - there some interesting posts round it as well:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=83028387&postcount=40655
Relevant: https://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=83028387&postcount=40655
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
THANKS!!! I recently ran into this issue and have tried the modules and changes through terminal, unrooting, flashing complete stock, but the only thing that worked was locking the bootloader. Once I had my 3a wiped and back to stock, I kept experimenting and located your fix. Magisk (cts profile) still won't pass safety net, but GPay works again (at least I could re-add cards without an error message--haven't tried to use it at a pay terminal yet) which was the whole point. I hope it's long-lasting. I can't believe more people aren't running into this issue.
@largeruk @captain sideways
Just to clarify, this is not an Android 10 or 11 issue. Newer (starting around October 22) versions of Google Play Services changed how SafetyNet works and ctsProfile fails with evalType HARDWARE.
The "Hardware Off" module no longer fixes the ctsProfile failure. I have seen mention of a new module here, but I'm not sure I trust the source: https://droidholic.com/safetynet-cts-profile-failed-fix/
Anyone have updates on this issue with the latest February Android 11 release?
madmartian said:
The "Hardware Off" module no longer fixes the ctsProfile failure. I have seen mention of a new module here, but I'm not sure I trust the source: https://droidholic.com/safetynet-cts-profile-failed-fix/
Anyone have updates on this issue with the latest February Android 11 release?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/magisk-module-universal-safetynet-fix-1-1-0.4217823/ it does work.
Edit: there is also a link to the github in the thread so you can check the code if you wish.
Hi i flashed pixel experience on my moto g7 power and i cant get the cts profile match to not fail does anyone know how to do this
Hello everyone,
I switched Magisk to c3b4678f (25204)(34) tonight, as I am on the Canary versions. But unfortunately, I notice while using Yasnac that my Pixel 3a does not pass SafetyNet anymore. The evaluation type remains Basic but Basic Integrity and CTS profile are both set to False. I uninstalled the safetynet fix from kdrag0n before reinstalling it (after rebooting each time) but nothing works! I even did a flash of the boot.img patched by Magisk but nothing to do. Do others have the same problem? What can I do?
During this night, Magisk developers pushed an update because of a deny list issue. They fixed it in the new version a468fd94 (25205)(34). And right after the update, Safetynet passes again !
I worried too quickly !
I just rooted my device again on miui 14 and just found out that NFC no longer works. I get an error everytime phone boots up. Anyone else experiencing this? Any fix without resetting entire device?
I can't turn on NFC as well... Anyone has a solution for this?
For me error caused one of maigsk modules. When I started turning them off one by one, the problem disappeared.
SafetyNet and nfc payments working too with LSposed XPrivacyLua module on MIUI14