Related
I pressed the Home button+Trackball+Power Button.....when starting my G1.
The Phone doesn't "power on" but the led light comes on BLUE and stays lit.
Any idea what this is for or means?
Dude pull battery out and reboot (nub)
mdabeezy said:
Dude pull battery out and reboot (nub)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wow, clearly you have no brain. My phone is bricked, check the New SPL and IME thread and maybe you'll have the slightest clue what I'm talking about.
MY QUESTION HERE IS VERY SIMPLE.
While trying to get past G1 boot screen, I pressed the
Home button+Trackball+Power.....
The Phone doesn't "power on" but the led light comes on blue and stays lit.
Battery pulls have been done numerous times over the past 2 hours. If you don't have a clue as to what the blue light represents, then don't bother replying to this thread. Ok.
Thanks.
when u installed the new spl did u reflash the rom?
cuz thats the problem
when the new spl is added you have to reflash the rom u were using
dont wipe so you wont lose your apps
A customer came into my store 2 days ago with a g1 that would not turn on and all it had was just a blue led lit. Tried everything to get a screen to come up and no luck.
That same update bricked my phone, t-mobile boot is all i see
home+power = dont work
camera+power= dont work
nothing did now i have to return it
bigballa said:
when u installed the new spl did u reflash the rom?
cuz thats the problem
when the new spl is added you have to reflash the rom u were using
dont wipe so you wont lose your apps
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I rephrased my 1st post so I could get an answer about what this post is for. I'm not an idiot, I know how to flash an SPL/ROM/ whatever.
The phone is bricked, I am one of many, check the New SPL and IME thread.
That has nothing to do with my topic here though. Thanks.
deviusdragger said:
A customer came into my store 2 days ago with a g1 that would not turn on and all it had was just a blue led lit. Tried everything to get a screen to come up and no luck.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I can get the G1 screen to come up, but that's all. I just didn't know if the combo of keys I pressed to start the phone meant something.
Turns out if you just press the trackball in and press power that will trigger just the Blue LED light to come on as well.
Just trying to figure out if this is useful or just more G1 shananigans. lol.
is the G1 screen comes up your phone is NOT bricked...
try flashing the regular JF ADP1.5.. if that dont go, start flashing old roms(RC29, RC30 etc..) hope that works
Saw this posted on a forum for T-Mo
the omniscient Google sez:
(found on forums.tmonews.com)
The problem is caused by ppl powering the device on, and when they press the red END key they are also holding down the MENU and pushing in the track ball at the same time.
This then enables a lock on the phone the only way around this is to pull the battery and turn the phone back on with/out pressing an holding the menu and trackball.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Another posted solution:
(www.fixya.com)
well plug the charger into the phone with the battery still intact.....then remove the battery while the phone is still plugged in. then unplug the charger and plug it back in........place battery back into phone and then power it up. That worked for me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Good fortune
AbsoluteDesignz said:
is the G1 screen comes up your phone is NOT bricked...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It actually can be bricked head over here --> http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=515822 and you will see that it is. Persons are not able to get into recovery even unable to get into the boorloader screen. By pressing home + power or camera + power. it can be bricked and show the G1 boot screen there are 7 or so phones that are like this now.
arqueware said:
the omniscient Google sez:
(found on forums.tmonews.com)
Another posted solution:
(www.fixya.com)
Good fortune
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just a generic lock? awesome. That's all I was wondering. Thank you!
Blue light happened when I washed my G1. I can occasionally get it to start up, try hitting the power button for a sec, hit it a gain a few times and see what happens. Throwing some trackball presses in there seemed to help too. G1 is an odd creature...
7 phones bricked and still counting thanks to the H special SPL.
Not so sure it's the SPL
one correspondent who purports to be an associate of T-Mo suggests that that button-press combination invokes a hardware lock that can be undone. see above
the BLUE LED of DEATH
barlev869 said:
Just a generic lock? awesome. That's all I was wondering. Thank you!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
W/B if that solution works for you; maybe it'll help the other 6 stricken G1s too
sir*mez:
If it gets to the T-Mobile-screen, the phone is NOT bricked.
If it's able to show the picture, it furthermore shows that atleast that part of the flash is intact (The picture resides on the splash1 partition, while the secondary is on splash2).
barlev869 & arqueware:
Hardware-lock? My bet would be this is some sort of test-mode, maybe for hardware-diagnostics?
It's not a lock if it can be avoided by just rebooting the phone (Which it can, i've been in the blue-led mode several times to try to guess what it was doing when booted like that...).
Joushou said:
sir*mez:
If it gets to the T-Mobile-screen, the phone is NOT bricked.
If it's able to show the picture, it furthermore shows that atleast that part of the flash is intact (The picture resides on the splash1 partition, while the secondary is on splash2).
barlev869 & arqueware:
Hardware-lock? My bet would be this is some sort of test-mode, maybe for hardware-diagnostics?
It's not a lock if it can be avoided by just rebooting the phone (Which it can, i've been in the blue-led mode several times to try to guess what it was doing when booted like that...).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
*sighs in disbelief* look another none believer that seems to say the say as the rest. Look the phone is dead there 9 people now to say that the spl bricked the phone. I'm not alone here.
Joushou said:
sir*mez:
If it gets to the T-Mobile-screen, the phone is NOT bricked.
If it's able to show the picture, it furthermore shows that atleast that part of the flash is intact (The picture resides on the splash1 partition, while the secondary is on splash2).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
From my understanding of the problem, You're half right. Part of the system does indeed come up but unfortunately that isn't enough to get adb to run or to boot into recovery mode or into fastboot. Basically, while you're right that it's not fully bricked and it is theoretically possible to fix it, the phone doesn't have any interface at all to do so. It'd be like trying to fix BIOS settings on a computer when you don't have a keyboard.
NOTE: I haven't flashed the new SPL so haven't been able to run into any problems with it, but from reading other people's descriptions of what happened, the above seems to be the case.
Problem solved
Same issue here. If you find a solution let me know. Asus rejected my rma.
saph27 said:
Same issue here. If you find a solution let me know. Asus rejected my rma.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you can access fastboot then you could flash a custom recovery .
saph27 said:
Same issue here. If you find a solution let me know. Asus rejected my rma.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well, my problem is solved
JHEJL10 said:
Well, my problem is solved. But my solution may not be what you are looking for.
If you can't get to the bootloader, the device is bricked for good beyond repair.
Only ASUS knows what they can do next with it from scrapping it to just trashing it.
I took my tablet back to Best Buy and said I downloaded some apps and when I restarted the tablet it didn't work. They bought it, and said it was defective. They gave me a brand new one.
My suggestion would be to find your receipt and take it to where you bought it. When you get to customer service, play dumb. Do not talk about how you rooted and unlocked it. Make a simple explanation that is reasonable.
With this fortunate event of getting another functioning tablet, I'm taking extended precaution. I'm not rooting, nor unlocking my bootloader, at least until there is a better tutorial, and fool proof way to get to the custom recovery. There is too many precautions and not enough certainty that the recoveries will even work.
Good luck
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Interesting. Unfortunately I bought from Amazon and my return period is up.
JHEJL10 said:
Well, my problem is solved. But my solution may not be what you are looking for.
If you can't get to the bootloader, the device is bricked for good beyond repair.
Only ASUS knows what they can do next with it from scrapping it to just trashing it.
I took my tablet back to Best Buy and said I downloaded some apps and when I restarted the tablet it didn't work. They bought it, and said it was defective. They gave me a brand new one.
My suggestion would be to find your receipt and take it to where you bought it. When you get to customer service, play dumb. Do not talk about how you rooted and unlocked it. Make a simple explanation that is reasonable.
With this fortunate event of getting another functioning tablet, I'm taking extended precaution. I'm not rooting, nor unlocking my bootloader, at least until there is a better tutorial, and fool proof way to get to the custom recovery. There is too many precautions and not enough certainty that the recoveries will even work.
Good luck
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just for future reference, if you are rooted and unlocked, when you install Goomanager, you just go into the menu (three dots in upper right hand corner of screen) and choose install open source recovery. The app does the work. No need to use fastboot. Then...and this is very important...only boot into recovery using hardware buttons: power down, then hold power and volume down, you will feel haptic vibration, then you should see ASUS splash screen and some white script in upper left hand corner. as soon as you see this, slide your finger over to volume up. You will enter TWRP recovery (blue curtains)...it will take several moments for the curtain to rise. then you have your full recovery menu in front of you. I really like using TWRP recovery (and I tried everything out there, I think). It's so easy to navigate. Makes flashing/backup/restoring a breeze.
okantomi said:
Just for future reference, if you are rooted and unlocked, when you install Goomanager, you just go into the menu (three dots in upper right hand corner of screen) and choose install open source recovery. The app does the work. No need to use fastboot. Then...and this is very important...only boot into recovery using hardware buttons: power down, then hold power and volume down, you will feel haptic vibration, then you should see ASUS splash screen and some white script in upper left hand corner. as soon as you see this, slide your finger over to volume up. You will enter TWRP recovery (blue curtains)...it will take several moments for the curtain to rise. then you have your full recovery menu in front of you. I really like using TWRP recovery (and I tried everything out there, I think). It's so easy to navigate. Makes flashing/backup/restoring a breeze.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the tip. I remember I downloaded the Goomanager app from the play store after I was rooted and unlocked. I went to the menu, like you said. I downloaded the recovery from their, and tried to reboot, but it wouldn't let me. I never thought to try the hardware buttons to get to the recovery. I just assumed that you could reboot straight into recovery like other devices. Anyways, I may try this later on, but I'm gonna research more and watch more tutorials because seeing my device in bricked status once has kinda scarred me and made me apprehensive on modding my tablet ( my galaxy nexus on the other hand, Not so much I'll mod that all the time)
Hi folks,
I suspect I'm having what some people around here appear to refer to as a Hboot problem. But this is my first Android phone, and I couldn't know any less about RUUs or booting or roms or anything like that. I'm posting a new thread because it seems like anyone who had a problem like mine had tried to, or wanted to know how to root their device. I didn't do that and am not trying to, but I've still got these problems.
I bought the phone "new", and it came in just today, from eBay, supposedly in a sealed box. Maybe that's part of the problem, I'm not sure. All I've done is: turn it on, install some apps, get in over my head with Apex launcher, and try to update Android.
I chose update from the menu, left my phone plugged in, and when I came back to it, nothing was on the screen. I pressed power, and it showed a screen similar to the first image (black screen, phone icon, green arrows in a circle). I assumed it was installing. I let it be and came back to the white screen with the numbers and barcodes. I panicked and chose "recovery" from the menu, and after a reboot it seemed to be back to normal.
However, just now, as I was attempting to reboot the phone due to not having any volume, I again got the white screen followed by the green arrows and finally the red warning icon.
Somehow or another, the phone resets itself and comes back on, but where is this coming from? Did I do something wrong? What does the screen mean, and did I get hosed by my seller? Thanks all
zbo-50 said:
Hi folks,
I suspect I'm having what some people around here appear to refer to as a Hboot problem. But this is my first Android phone, and I couldn't know any less about RUUs or booting or roms or anything like that. I'm posting a new thread because it seems like anyone who had a problem like mine had tried to, or wanted to know how to root their device. I didn't do that and am not trying to, but I've still got these problems.
I bought the phone "new", and it came in just today, from eBay, supposedly in a sealed box. Maybe that's part of the problem, I'm not sure. All I've done is: turn it on, install some apps, get in over my head with Apex launcher, and try to update Android.
I chose update from the menu, left my phone plugged in, and when I came back to it, nothing was on the screen. I pressed power, and it showed a screen similar to the first image (black screen, phone icon, green arrows in a circle). I assumed it was installing. I let it be and came back to the white screen with the numbers and barcodes. I panicked and chose "recovery" from the menu, and after a reboot it seemed to be back to normal.
However, just now, as I was attempting to reboot the phone due to not having any volume, I again got the white screen followed by the green arrows and finally the red warning icon.
Somehow or another, the phone resets itself and comes back on, but where is this coming from? Did I do something wrong? What does the screen mean, and did I get hosed by my seller? Thanks all
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
to get to the bootloader menu (the white one with the pink writing), you have to reboot and allow it to boot with the volume down button held. It looks like your volume rocker is getting stuck on down - given that you are losing volume and it keeps booting into the bootloader menu. If it is in a case, try removing it from the case and see if the issue persists.Otherwise, it is likely a hardware issue. so you should return it for a warranty repair/replacement (as you said you bought it new in a box).
codeprimate said:
to get to the bootloader menu (the white one with the pink writing), you have to reboot and allow it to boot with the volume down button held. It looks like your volume rocker is getting stuck on down - given that you are losing volume and it keeps booting into the bootloader menu. If it is in a case, try removing it from the case and see if the issue persists.Otherwise, it is likely a hardware issue. so you should return it for a warranty repair/replacement (as you said you bought it new in a box).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You coulsnt be more wrong I'm [email protected] op ill get you back up and running in a sec
tactical kitten said:
You coulsnt be more wrong I'm [email protected] op ill get you back up and running in a sec
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
lol!
tactical kitten said:
You coulsnt be more wrong I'm [email protected] op ill get you back up and running in a sec
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Kitten - what do you think is the problem? The OP says they lost volume and they keep rebooting into the bootloader. The stuck volume rocker sounds like the easiest way to explain both issues. I might be wrong, but not given the symptoms listed in the OP. If more information is required to diagnose the issue, we can at least start by eliminating the obvious.
codeprimate said:
Kitten - what do you think is the problem? The OP says they lost volume and they keep rebooting into the bootloader. The stuck volume rocker sounds like the easiest way to explain both issues. I might be wrong, but not given the symptoms listed in the OP. If more information is required to diagnose the issue, we can at least start by eliminating the obvious.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you very, very much - I believe that's exactly the issue. I had no idea pressing the volume down button during a reboot would get you to that menu, but I am using the Trident Kraken case which apparently has an issue lining up with the volume down rocker on this particular phone.
I will try to reproduce the problem sans case to make sure, but this sounds absolutely right. Thanks for helping a complete newbie - I don't think I'd ever have put that together. I was very worried I'd been sold a bill of goods.
So I've tried factory wiping and installing a few different roms and no matter which one I go to I keep getting these random reboots. This is particularly troubling when I restore an older rom that I know I was not having this particular issue on.
It is making my phone pretty close to unusable since it will often go into an "Optimizing apps!" speil draining battery and taking an obnoxiously long time to reboot. Not sure what is up. Any suggestions?
Snow_fox said:
So I've tried factory wiping and installing a few different roms and no matter which one I go to I keep getting these random reboots. This is particularly troubling when I restore an older rom that I know I was not having this particular issue on.
It is making my phone pretty close to unusable since it will often go into an "Optimizing apps!" speil draining battery and taking an obnoxiously long time to reboot. Not sure what is up. Any suggestions?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Try with a clean flash (or the factory images) without user data/modifications and see if your RRs are still there.
Is the power button stuck by any chance?
Primokorn said:
Try with a clean flash (or the factory images) without user data/modifications and see if your RRs are still there.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've factory reset a few times and wiped everything except internal storage pretty much. Even tried wiping user data just to see if it would help
dicecuber said:
Is the power button stuck by any chance?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't think it's getting stuck it still seems to go in and out properly. I even took it out the case just to make sure there wasn't something I couldnt' seee putting pressure on it
Snow_fox said:
I've factory reset a few times and wiped everything except internal storage pretty much. Even tried wiping user data just to see if it would help
I don't think it's getting stuck it still seems to go in and out properly. I even took it out the case just to make sure there wasn't something I couldnt' seee putting pressure on it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The button will NOT seem to be stuck, even if it is, as the contact is made internally. My bro´s Nexus had this problem, and by the end it kept rebooting constantly because the button was making contact on its own. I fixed it by tapping vigorously at the area between the power button and the camera and that made it work.
A way to know if it is stuck could be to press the volume down key as soon as it restarts, if it goes into recovery, then there is no doubt the power button is stuck.
Don´t dismiss hardware problems, as many Nexus are affected by the power button issue and you already tried software solutions which didn´t work.
Hope you sort it out. Remember to use an app to avoid pressing the button so much, such as when waking the device. I recommend Gravity Screen, but there are many other options.
simonarturo said:
The button will NOT seem to be stuck, even if it is, as the contact is made internally. My bro´s Nexus had this problem, and by the end it kept rebooting constantly because the button was making contact on its own. I fixed it by tapping vigorously at the area between the power button and the camera and that made it work.
A way to know if it is stuck could be to press the volume down key as soon as it restarts, if it goes into recovery, then there is no doubt the power button is stuck.
Don´t dismiss hardware problems, as many Nexus are affected by the power button issue and you already tried software solutions which didn´t work.
Hope you sort it out. Remember to use an app to avoid pressing the button so much, such as when waking the device. I recommend Gravity Screen, but there are many other options.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Holding down volume after one reset actually put me into recovery. Plus it's restarting at times in recovery now :/
I doubt it's under warranty since I got it in feb 2014 x.x
Snow_fox said:
Holding down volume after one reset actually put me into recovery. Plus it's restarting at times in recovery now :/
I doubt it's under warranty since I got it in feb 2014 x.x
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you got it directly from Google, I'd try calling them up and asking for a replacement even if you are a few months off the warranty period, I have read some stories of them honoring warranties in order to get rid of stock. That'd be true even now that the new Nexus is supposedly releasing this year. Nothing wrong with trying, you might get a new, shiny phone.
That being said, don't worry, it's perfectly fixable. The part that gets stuck is not the button itself, but the part that goes into the motherboard, so don't bother fiddling with the black button. I managed to fix my brother's button by doing the following:
- Clean the area between the button and phone of debris or any dirt that could be causing it to be stuck. This is just to be on the safe side, as it is unlikely that it is the cause of the malfunction.
- Take the case off the phone if you haven't, and then put it upside down and tap vigorously with your fingers in the area between the camera and the power button. It might not work the first few times, but it eventually will release the part that is stuck.
- As soon as you can get it to turn on without rebooting itself, install Gravity Screen, or any other app that replaces the power button to wake up or turn the screen off. You are looking to use the button as few times as possible.
After doing that, his Nexus went for being unusable due to constant reboots to working fine. It's been almost 6 months since it happened so it is bound to work, just don't lose heart and patiently work at it. Tap a bit harder if it's not working. Let us know whether you managed to fix it.
simonarturo said:
The button will NOT seem to be stuck, even if it is, as the contact is made internally. My bro´s Nexus had this problem, and by the end it kept rebooting constantly because the button was making contact on its own. I fixed it by tapping vigorously at the area between the power button and the camera and that made it work.
A way to know if it is stuck could be to press the volume down key as soon as it restarts, if it goes into recovery, then there is no doubt the power button is stuck.
Don´t dismiss hardware problems, as many Nexus are affected by the power button issue and you already tried software solutions which didn´t work.
Hope you sort it out. Remember to use an app to avoid pressing the button so much, such as when waking the device. I recommend Gravity Screen, but there are many other options.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
simonarturo said:
If you got it directly from Google, I'd try calling them up and asking for a replacement even if you are a few months off the warranty period, I have read some stories of them honoring warranties in order to get rid of stock. That'd be true even now that the new Nexus is supposedly releasing this year. Nothing wrong with trying, you might get a new, shiny phone.
That being said, don't worry, it's perfectly fixable. The part that gets stuck is not the button itself, but the part that goes into the motherboard, so don't bother fiddling with the black button. I managed to fix my brother's button by doing the following:
- Clean the area between the button and phone of debris or any dirt that could be causing it to be stuck. This is just to be on the safe side, as it is unlikely that it is the cause of the malfunction.
- Take the case off the phone if you haven't, and then put it upside down and tap vigorously with your fingers in the area between the camera and the power button. It might not work the first few times, but it eventually will release the part that is stuck.
- As soon as you can get it to turn on without rebooting itself, install Gravity Screen, or any other app that replaces the power button to wake up or turn the screen off. You are looking to use the button as few times as possible.
After doing that, his Nexus went for being unusable due to constant reboots to working fine. It's been almost 6 months since it happened so it is bound to work, just don't lose heart and patiently work at it. Tap a bit harder if it's not working. Let us know whether you managed to fix it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm going to get in contact with google. I tried pushing down on the area between the camera and it didn't help much. It has started working again properly after a really peculiar work around. I just don't want to have to be super cautious of a button for the rest of the time i own my device :/
Snow_fox said:
I'm going to get in contact with google. I tried pushing down on the area between the camera and it didn't help much. It has started working again properly after a really peculiar work around. I just don't want to have to be super cautious of a button for the rest of the time i own my device :/
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Please detail the peculiar work around you mention...
Sent from my XT1095 using Tapatalk 2
mazubo said:
Please detail the peculiar work around you mention...
Sent from my XT1095 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well someone mentioned maybe trying to clean it out somehow. I tried canned air and that didn't do anything so I formed a seal over the button using my mouth and then proceeded to exhale. It has yet to give me any trouble since then.
Had exactly the same issue, reboots over and over again, couldn't boot to bootloader without reboot...
What helped for me was something I read somewhere else, don't remember where, was knocking on the back cover between camera lense and the power switch, did it 4 days ago and it works since than..
Snow_fox said:
I formed a seal over the button using my mouth and then proceeded to exhale.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sounds sexual
You can take the back cover off, and if you are careful there is no sticker or seal that would tell google you have opened the device. It is difficult to pull all the way off, the vibration motor is attached to the case back and comes off with it so it would seem stuck. You just have to keep pulling.
aaargh777 said:
Had exactly the same issue, reboots over and over again, couldn't boot to bootloader without reboot...
What helped for me was something I read somewhere else, don't remember where, was knocking on the back cover between camera lense and the power switch, did it 4 days ago and it works since than..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Pressing on the area between the camera and the on switch seems to help a lot of people it didn't seems ot have much of an effect for me. While my phone hasn't given me issues since shortly after I posted this thread I'm kinda worried I'm one drop away from the issue coming back
dicecuber said:
Sounds sexual
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No way to avoid it sounding that way I fear.
fwayfarer said:
You can take the back cover off, and if you are careful there is no sticker or seal that would tell google you have opened the device. It is difficult to pull all the way off, the vibration motor is attached to the case back and comes off with it so it would seem stuck. You just have to keep pulling.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Would this allow me to repair it?
Yeah but you'd need to unscrew a plastic cover that is inside the phone. Phillips head screws, jewelers screwdriver size. Depends on if its dirt or a broken switch though.
fwayfarer said:
Yeah but you'd need to unscrew a plastic cover that is inside the phone. Phillips head screws, jewelers screwdriver size. Depends on if its dirt or a broken switch though.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry to disappoint everyone but this is a widespread problem that google is aware of fro some time now. It's not the power button but it's burried deep in the software and appreas to have popped up right after the Lollipop 5.1 up date. Check out all the posts on Google
https://productforums.google.com/forum/#!topic/nexus/IJSOuc7gw0w[376-400]
While it apprears to be confined to the Nexus 5 I have had it happen with my nexus 4 just running stock L 5.1
I hope that casts some light on it
Weirdly enough, my power button works flawlessly on 5 and 5.1. Red 32gb from the google play store. I've opened the case multiple times and put Arctic silver knockoff heat compound in sloppily and without regard, no issues other than sprint screwing up their spark LTE rollout.
Blacksmith5 said:
Sorry to disappoint everyone but this is a widespread problem that google is aware of fro some time now. It's not the power button but it's burried deep in the software and appreas to have popped up right after the Lollipop 5.1 up date. Check out all the posts on Google
https://productforums.google.com/forum/#!topic/nexus/IJSOuc7gw0w[376-400]
While it apprears to be confined to the Nexus 5 I have had it happen with my nexus 4 just running stock L 5.1
I hope that casts some light on it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry, I disagree. While some instances might be related to software, it has been proven that there is in fact a problem with the physical button getting stuck on Nexus 5 phones. You can check it online and will find lots of hits and even YouTube videos, most of them around the time before lollipop.
Best way to check whether it is software or hardware is to press the volume down key when your phone reboots by itself. If it takes you to the recovery, you can bet your cat that it is not lollipop's fault
So I'm suspecting that I have the wonky power button too but.....
I haven't been able to get it to go to recovery when pressing power down and I've defintely had a few restarts very recently.
More importantly, and something that I haven't seen anyone else post about; more often than not my N5 just shuts down. It's usually when I've doing something with the phone (today was flicking through my GPM library). I'll power it back on and it will boot cleanly and then (more often than not) power down again. Other times it will bootloop, but that's rare. It seems to me that if I let it boot up and then don't touch it for a while, it will stay up but I'm not sure that's consistent.
Anyone else seen or heard of the power button causing a powerdown instead of bootloop?
techinv said:
So I'm suspecting that I have the wonky power button too but.....
I haven't been able to get it to go to recovery when pressing power down and I've defintely had a few restarts very recently.
More importantly, and something that I haven't seen anyone else post about; more often than not my N5 just shuts down. It's usually when I've doing something with the phone (today was flicking through my GPM library). I'll power it back on and it will boot cleanly and then (more often than not) power down again. Other times it will bootloop, but that's rare. It seems to me that if I let it boot up and then don't touch it for a while, it will stay up but I'm not sure that's consistent.
Anyone else seen or heard of the power button causing a powerdown instead of bootloop?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You will need to troubleshoot this the old-fashioned way. Have you installed any updates, apps, mods or anything recently?
Best case scenario would be that you flash a stock image without restoring apps, kernel or any mods. Run the phone for some time, couple of days or so, and be on the lookout for power downs or reboots. After that, you can try adding a few apps at a time and keep checking. If the phone reboots even with a clean factory image, then I'd have to say the hardware is faulty. Could be the power button, could be something else.
Try it out and let us know
Hello,
I have a Nexus 5 with Android 4.4.4 and CyanogenMod 11. Like always, it had been working really find untill today, when it started to reboot and entered in a loop. I found out that it was because the power button was broken and with the lightest touch, it would activate.
Searching through the Internet I found out that many people happen to have this problem. I tried to disable the power button editing a file that is found under /system/usr/keylayout/qpnp_pon.kl, where I had to simply comment the line where the power button was.
Now, if I click the power button it doesn't happen anything, like I was expecting, but after 30 seconds of clicking it, it shuts down and it reboots like if it was an internal error or someting similar that caused that reboot.
Is it possible that disabling it the way I did could cause any type of problem that made it reboot after touching it?
I know it's an internal problem or something like this because when I touch it, it doesn't lock the screen or show the power menu, so the button itself is kind of "disabled", but it keeps causing this problem.
Is it good what I did? How can I solve it?
Thanks!
Pyttar said:
Hello,
I have a Nexus 5 with Android 4.4.4 and CyanogenMod 11. Like always, it had been working really find untill today, when it started to reboot and entered in a loop. I found out that it was because the power button was broken and with the lightest touch, it would activate.
Searching through the Internet I found out that many people happen to have this problem. I tried to disable the power button editing a file that is found under /system/usr/keylayout/qpnp_pon.kl, where I had to simply comment the line where the power button was.
Now, if I click the power button it doesn't happen anything, like I was expecting, but after 30 seconds of clicking it, it shuts down and it reboots like if it was an internal error or someting similar that caused that reboot.
Is it possible that disabling it the way I did could cause any type of problem that made it reboot after touching it?
I know it's an internal problem or something like this because when I touch it, it doesn't lock the screen or show the power menu, so the button itself is kind of "disabled", but it keeps causing this problem.
Is it good what I did? How can I solve it?
Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I had the same issue unfortunately. My N5 is still at LG for repair and it's taking much longer than they told me. Which is good of course. Like most smartphones now though, a 10 second power button hold will forcefully reboot the phone. It's hardcoded in the phone and no matter how much you try to disable it through the OS it won't make a difference until the rogue button is physically taken off the motherboard. If you're in Europe though and your phone is still in it's 2 year warranty I would strongly suggest flashing a factory image, relocking and calling LG (or Google, if the device came from Google).
Hope this helps.
humzaahmed155 said:
I had the same issue unfortunately. My N5 is still at LG for repair and it's taking much longer than they told me. Which is good of course. Like most smartphones now though, a 10 second power button hold will forcefully reboot the phone. It's hardcoded in the phone and no matter how much you try to disable it through the OS it won't make a difference until the rogue button is physically taken off the motherboard. If you're in Europe though and your phone is still in it's 2 year warranty I would strongly suggest flashing a factory image, relocking and calling LG (or Google, if the device came from Google).
Hope this helps.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well... It's been like three years since I bought it, so I guess the warranty is over...
And if I want to disable it, I will have to do it manually and disconnecting it of the motherboard, am I wrong? I guess I'll either have to live with this problem or buy a new phone... Today it's not my lucky day! Hahahaha
Anyway, thanks for your reply!!
Many owners have the power button issue. A competent cell repair shop should be able to replace it.
audit13 said:
Many owners have the power button issue. A competent cell repair shop should be able to replace it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, that's true, I've found a lot of people over the Internet with the same problem.
By the way, I could finally solve my problem; after searching for a while, I found a YouTube video that showed a peculiar way of solving it... And it actually worked!
Well, it looks like I cannot put the link because I'm under 10 posts :cyclops:
Well, here's the video code if anyone is interested: _QpSSCifxAw
The Internet is amazing! Hahahahahahah
Thanks for your replies!
Are you referring to banging the power button? It wouldn't work for my friend's power button. He had to have it replaced because it failed a multimeter test, apparently.
audit13 said:
Are you referring to banging the power button? It wouldn't work for my friend's power button. He had to have it replaced because it failed a multimeter test, apparently.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yep, exactly!
Like the video said, I bumped my phone a little bit because the power button was kinda stuck inside the phone, and that really worked...
I was amazed! And I'm so happy it worked! No need of having it replaced. [emoji16]
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
How did you do that?
spacecaptain said:
How did you do that?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just hit the phone into your hand so the power button gets unstuck.
You can see the video I mentioned above for a clarifying idea on how to do it.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk