Gear S2 3G competition - Samsung Gear S2

Hey everyone. Not sure if this thread will get booted or not but figured I would try.
I have been eagerly awaiting the 3G version of this watch to come out. Until now, there has been no other watch that offers 3G support on a smart watch (that I know of. Please don't kill me if there is something else out there). I came across the LG watch Urbane 2. I looks very promising to me. It is slightly bigger but has a bigger battery. It will also be sporting LTE. I have seen reports that LG is working with the US carriers to be able to keep the same phone number for both the phone and the watch. Which for me is a huge plus. I hated the thought of having two different phone numbers. I also like the fact it is android wear because I have heard it had more apps. I have never had a smart watch. I would love to hear from people that have had a smart watch with android wear and now have tizen. Do you think it is better? Any thoughts on the Urbane 2? Why would one be better than the other?
I would miss the rotating bezel but from early reports it does not seem to be a significant feature.
Looking forward to hearing everyone thoughts on this. Thanks!!
Sent from my SM-N910V using XDA Free mobile app

Related

[Q] Do you think the Gear 2 will work on Lollipop (Nexus 6)

I am considering purchasing a Nexus 6 when it becomes available on T-mobile but would really hate not being able to pair it with my Gear 2. I really have become addicted to it. I had been originally holding out for the Note Edge to replace my Note 3 but then was able to get one of the Nexus 9 tablets and I think that I am becoming a convert to "pure android"! Any thoughts or speculations would be appreciated. Hard facts would be even better.
still looking?
firstflyer said:
I am considering purchasing a Nexus 6 when it becomes available on T-mobile but would really hate not being able to pair it with my Gear 2. I really have become addicted to it. I had been originally holding out for the Note Edge to replace my Note 3 but then was able to get one of the Nexus 9 tablets and I think that I am becoming a convert to "pure android"! Any thoughts or speculations would be appreciated. Hard facts would be even better.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have both devices but have only paired my android wear watches so far with the N6. that being said if you are still looking for an answer let me know and we could do some testing.
Probably not... I don't even think you could get the gear to pair on non tw roms? It took awhile for them to port it to the n2 but that didn't have full compatability. The way I understood it is there more concerned with running it on the Samsung devices so it is left up to the devs and I don't think samsung has quite hit the mark on the smart watch market yet.
firstflyer said:
I am considering purchasing a Nexus 6 when it becomes available on T-mobile but would really hate not being able to pair it with my Gear 2. I really have become addicted to it. I had been originally holding out for the Note Edge to replace my Note 3 but then was able to get one of the Nexus 9 tablets and I think that I am becoming a convert to "pure android"! Any thoughts or speculations would be appreciated. Hard facts would be even better.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have done some looking and I'm sure you can get it working at least 90% of all functionality
kimdoocheol said:
Probably not... I don't even think you could get the gear to pair on non tw roms? It took awhile for them to port it to the n2 but that didn't have full compatability. The way I understood it is there more concerned with running it on the Samsung devices so it is left up to the devs and I don't think samsung has quite hit the mark on the smart watch market yet.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sent from my SM-N915T using XDA Free mobile app
bda714 said:
I have done some looking and I'm sure you can get it working at least 90% of all functionality
Sent from my SM-N915T using XDA Free mobile app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
From what? Everything I've seen requires a tw base. I'm interested in this a bit, too since i got a good deal on one but I don't use it
kimdoocheol said:
From what? Everything I've seen requires a tw base. I'm interested in this a bit, too since i got a good deal on one but I don't use it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have been using my gear 2 and my gear S for a while now. The nexus 6 is no different. There are a couple ways to go about it without using touch wiz. The gear 2 is actually much better considering that there is already a rooted custom rom out for it, and like i said, with that you will get about 95% functionality. I believe the weather app isnt 100% working and one more thing whixh i cant think of, but all the good stuff works perfect and even a few added features. Making/ recieving calls, ir blaster, watch faces, bluetooth, notifica.... all thats 100%. If you need any help or wan't to try it just pm me. I think this op may have found his answer already though.
bda714 said:
I have been using my gear 2 and my gear S for a while now. The nexus 6 is no different. There are a couple ways to go about it without using touch wiz. The gear 2 is actually much better considering that there is already a rooted custom rom out for it, and like i said, with that you will get about 95% functionality. I believe the weather app isnt 100% working and one more thing whixh i cant think of, but all the good stuff works perfect and even a few added features. Making/ recieving calls, ir blaster, watch faces, bluetooth, notifica.... all thats 100%. If you need any help or wan't to try it just pm me. I think this op may have found his answer already though.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi there. I sent you a PM about a similar request. Can you please check and let me know?
Did you guys actually figure out if it works with nexus 6?
Hi, someone managed to connect the gear 2 with nexus 6? I'm trying but, but I do not get results. If someone have a solution can post a guide?
Would appreciate it too
Please help!!
I have gone through all the methods in trying to connect my gear 2 to my nexus 6 and nothing will work!! Has anyone actually found a way?? I don't mind if some thing don't work, I just like the text and call features anyway.. Please respond to me, I love my watch and don't want to go over to a different one
any updates on this? will the samsung gear 1 OR the gear 2 watch work with the nexus 6 2014 version? thx
I tried following an XDA tread to connect Gear 2 Neo to Moto X 3 XT1575, with watch still on Tizen. No joy.
This method worked easily, but it will be an Android Wear watch: http://forum.xda-developers.com/gear-2/development/please-help-kernel-compiling-android-t2992953

So anyone know when we are going to get the NFC function working on our watches

I bought this watch with the understanding the NFC function was working in the USA. Well was I misinformed and blown away considering the Iwatch is possible of making ipay payments. You would think their prime demographic would be this function. The hardwares there what are they waiting on to activate this in the US.
The watch is great. I love the SOS function as Im a fishing guide. Love how its a stand alone phone when not bluetoothed. But was really excited to just swipe my watch and pay for things. The Galazy s7 edge is great at this and thats what I have it paired with. Just killing me every thing is there for them to make this work but what Software???
When the Galaxy S9 is released the NFC will function totally just another two years of waiting.
Sent from my SM-N910F using XDA-Developers mobile app

Want to get the S3 have some questions

I want to get the Gear S3 Frontier. I have a Honor 8 phone. I use Google Messenger and Google Allo. Do both of these apps work with the Gear S3, can I send and receive text messages etc. I don't want to use the stock Samsung app.
falcon26 said:
I want to get the Gear S3 Frontier. I have a Honor 8 phone. I use Google Messenger and Google Allo. Do both of these apps work with the Gear S3, can I send and receive text messages etc. I don't want to use the stock Samsung app.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You get notifications(with the content like you have in the Android status bar) , but you can not reply from the watch
falcon26 said:
I want to get the Gear S3 Frontier. I have a Honor 8 phone. I use Google Messenger and Google Allo. Do both of these apps work with the Gear S3, can I send and receive text messages etc. I don't want to use the stock Samsung app.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
jpph said:
You get notifications(with the content like you have in the Android status bar) , but you can not reply from the watch
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Replying works too but requires installing android wear and pairing it with an emulator.
10urshin said:
Replying works too but requires installing android wear and pairing it with an emulator.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How to pair with emulator? Mine just says trying to connect....
Sent from my SM-N920C using Tapatalk
aapanju said:
How to pair with emulator? Mine just says trying to connect....
Sent from my SM-N920C using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
http://www.tomsguide.com/faq/id-2452471/install-android-wear-emulator.html
Perfect... will this enable more features on my Gear S3? As Iv read that it doesn't but some say it does... whats your take..?
Sent from my SM-N920C using Tapatalk
aapanju said:
Perfect... will this enable more features on my Gear S3? As Iv read that it doesn't but some say it does... whats your take..?
Sent from my SM-N920C using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It is for android wear watches so doesn't do much for gear, it only enables replying to the messages even if you are not using samsung's message app. You can just use SMSGear instead of doing this actually. https://forum.xda-developers.com/gear-s3/themes/opensource-sms-application-gear-s3-t3557263
Ahh only sms... I thought whatsapp etc also...
Sent from my SM-N920C using Tapatalk
I will probably skip the Samsung watch and grab a wear watch instead like the Lg Style. After some reading Samsung watches are great if you have a Samsung phone, but if you do not then it's hit or miss with most apps and some don't work at all. And of course the apps I use are the ones that apparently don't work at all with Samsung. Shame really because I think the Samsung watch looks almost like the $1000 Tag Heuer smart watch. If they would have only used wear software instead of there own.
falcon26 said:
I will probably skip the Samsung watch and grab a wear watch instead like the Lg Style. After some reading Samsung watches are great if you have a Samsung phone, but if you do not then it's hit or miss with most apps and some don't work at all. And of course the apps I use are the ones that apparently don't work at all with Samsung. Shame really because I think the Samsung watch looks almost like the $1000 Tag Heuer smart watch. If they would have only used wear software instead of there own.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
(I'm not sure where you're at but) Check Best Buy. The Samsung Rep told me you can return the S3 within a 15-day period after buying. I asked the rep at a Best Buy (at a location with a Samsung gallery -- not all locations have) to take the S3 out of Store Demo Mode so I can pair it with my old Galaxy Note 2 but he said he can't. He mentioned I can buy and return it within 15 days if I'm not happy with it. If you're going to do this, see if you can involve a manager. Sometimes reps just say whatever they want to make a sale. But who knows. He could be telling the truth.
RexEscape said:
(I'm not sure where you're at but) Check Best Buy. The Samsung Rep told me you can return the S3 within a 15-day period after buying. I asked the rep at a Best Buy (at a location with a Samsung gallery -- not all locations have) to take the S3 out of Store Demo Mode so I can pair it with my old Galaxy Note 2 but he said he can't. He mentioned I can buy and return it within 15 days if I'm not happy with it. If you're going to do this, see if you can involve a manager. Sometimes reps just say whatever they want to make a sale. But who knows. He could be telling the truth.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Best buy's return policy is 15 days unless otherwise stated. The only reason I know that is they will price match anything you buy within the return period as well. I had bought a TV and on the 15th day it dropped by about $500. Called them up and they refunded that amount. The info on price matching and return policy can be found easily on their website.
So I checked out the S3 at T-Mobile store. Never mind its way to big and heavy. Also it didn't work with half the stuff I wanted to do on my Pixel. I think this watch is great if you have a Samsung phone, but if it's a non Samsung phone then expect half the stuff not to work right. I think I will pick up the new LG Sport watch instead...
falcon26 said:
So I checked out the S3 at T-Mobile store. Never mind its way to big and heavy. Also it didn't work with half the stuff I wanted to do on my Pixel. I think this watch is great if you have a Samsung phone, but if it's a non Samsung phone then expect half the stuff not to work right. I think I will pick up the new LG Sport watch instead...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you're concerned about sizes, I think the LG Sport Watch is bigger but along with its size, you get more screen and a higher resolution. Unfortunately, there wasn't enough room to improve on battery life for the LG even for its bigger size. I'm on the morning of Day 3 and I still have 62% battery power (granted I turn it off after 9pm and turn it back on at 6am). Lots of trade-offs. But I agree. You get a better experience with the Gear S3 if you have a Galaxy phone. Have you seen this article? http://www.androidcentral.com/lg-watch-sport-vs-samsung-gear-s3
EDIT: One of the best things I love about the S3 is Samsung Pay (way better than Android Pay). Never again do I pull my wallet out (except when I occasionally buy wine -- I still get carded LOL!)
falcon26 said:
So I checked out the S3 at T-Mobile store. Never mind its way to big and heavy. Also it didn't work with half the stuff I wanted to do on my Pixel. I think this watch is great if you have a Samsung phone, but if it's a non Samsung phone then expect half the stuff not to work right. I think I will pick up the new LG Sport watch instead...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That hasn't been my experience at all. I have a Moto G4 and my wife has a Huawei phone and the S3 works very well with either. I've paired it separately with both plus an older Moto E I and everything works without a hitch. I know there have been some hitches with the IPhone but I wouldn't touch one of those if my life depended on it so I can't comment there.
There isn't a huge difference in the S3 user experience with a Samsung phone versus other branded Android phones. Regardless, if integration with the Google ecosystem is paramount, an AW watch will fulfill those duties better than the S3. But the LG Sport has a few serious shortcomings compared to the S3: inferior battery life, fixed wristband (a comfort and customization issue), and lack of MST. The LG Sport is the best AW 2.0 watch on the market only because it's the only one on the market right now. I too am waiting, I just chose to do it while using the S3 in the interim.

[Q] Is anyone using the S3 with a non Samsung phone? How is it?

I'm trying to decide between getting the Gear S3 and the Hauwei Watch 2, but I'm struggling to come to a decision.
I have an LG G6 phone, so I suppose that an Android Wear watch would be more suitable as far as software integration goes. The battery life is OK on the HW2, but it's not quite as good as the Gear S3 and the build quality on the S3 looks better.
I'm just wondering if I'd be making the right choice if I buy the S3 with me having a non Samsung phone. I'd love to get some feedback from any forum members that are using an S3 with a non-Samsung phone, how are you getting on with it?
I used mine with a Moto G4 and had no problems at all. I now have an Honor 8 and it works perfectly with it also. It actually improved the Moto because the Moto didn't have NFC so I couldn't use any pay apps. Once I synced the S3, the Moto could then get the Samsung Pay app. Of course I could still only pay with the watch. I also synced the S3 with an old Moro E and all functions worked. I never really used the E, I just wanted to see if the old backup phone worked if I needed it.
UKseagull said:
I'm trying to decide between getting the Gear S3 and the Hauwei Watch 2, but I'm struggling to come to a decision.
I have an LG G6 phone, so I suppose that an Android Wear watch would be more suitable as far as software integration goes. The battery life is OK on the HW2, but it's not quite as good as the Gear S3 and the build quality on the S3 looks better.
I'm just wondering if I'd be making the right choice if I buy the S3 with me having a non Samsung phone. I'd love to get some feedback from any forum members that are using an S3 with a non-Samsung phone, how are you getting on with it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have recently switched my Nokia 8 for the LG G6.
The Nokia 8 would not reconnect to bluetooth after moving out then back into range whereas the G6 has no such issue and works seamlessly with my S3.
Sent from my [device_name] using XDA-Developers Legacy app
UKseagull said:
I'm trying to decide between getting the Gear S3 and the Hauwei Watch 2, but I'm struggling to come to a decision.
I have an LG G6 phone, so I suppose that an Android Wear watch would be more suitable as far as software integration goes. The battery life is OK on the HW2, but it's not quite as good as the Gear S3 and the build quality on the S3 looks better.
I'm just wondering if I'd be making the right choice if I buy the S3 with me having a non Samsung phone. I'd love to get some feedback from any forum members that are using an S3 with a non-Samsung phone, how are you getting on with it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The only issues you will have is full access to emails and text messages. I switch to the LG Watch sport. Found a new one for $240.
Thanks all, I bit the bullet today and I have ordered the Gear S3. Roll on Christmas day!
nrage23 said:
The only issues you will have is full access to emails and text messages. I switch to the LG Watch sport. Found a new one for $240.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just curious, but what type of full access for text messages are you referring to?
Running my S3 with my LG G5. Works great
I'm using a oneplus 3 and I have full access to texts and emails just fine and Samsung pay works flawlessly.
Tel864 said:
Just curious, but what type of full access for text messages are you referring to?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You cannot start a text from the watch. You can view and reply to a new one but not see a conversation and start a new text. You can view a new email but not clear the notification on the phone or reply to it from the wsatch.
nrage23 said:
You cannot start a text from the watch. You can view and reply to a new one but not see a conversation and start a new text. You can view a new email but not clear the notification on the phone or reply to it from the wsatch.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can start a new text to anyone in your contacts.
Sent from my B3-A40 using Tapatalk

Thinking about buying a Gear S3 Classic, please help

Have the original Huawei watch.... Screens a bit burned in and looking for a replacement. Liked the HWatch, was ehhh with AW 2.0 so I'm fine with moving OS's. Looking around I don't see many options I really like outside of the S3 classic, however I have been reading nothing but horror stories about Tizen 3 update. Is it really that bad? If I'm going to be forced to run a nearly 18 month old watch on original firmware I might as well stick with what I got.
Any input to assist me here?
chrisokaly said:
Have the original Huawei watch.... Screens a bit burned in and looking for a replacement. Liked the HWatch, was ehhh with AW 2.0 so I'm fine with moving OS's. Looking around I don't see many options I really like outside of the S3 classic, however I have been reading nothing but horror stories about Tizen 3 update. Is it really that bad? If I'm going to be forced to run a nearly 18 month old watch on original firmware I might as well stick with what I got.
Any input to assist me here?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Have Gear S3 Classic LTE version Verizon, with 3.0 and no issues
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
I have the Gear S3 frontier on 3.0 and no issues. I get 2 - 3 days on a charge depending on the watch face.
Sent from my SM-N950U using Tapatalk
I also came from the Huawei Watch v1 and just got the Gear S3 Classic yesterday. The reason I switched was because I also do not like Android Wear 2.0. Overall, I do like the Gear S3 but I also miss the app selection and support of Android Wear. If all you're going to use the watch is for notifications with simple replies, then the Gear S3 will work for you. However, if you're planning on using the watch as somewhat of a phone replacement, then the Gear S3 is severely lacking in that category. The reason why I state this is due to the lack of app developers that support Tizen.
Forget about native Google Maps support on your watch, texting is really only done via replies, Fidme for loyalty cards, i.g. Starbucks, is hit or miss, etc. Overall though, as I stated above, if your main goal is just to have notifications on your wrist, have Samsung Pay, and don't mind using S Health for fitness, then the Gear S3 is an awesome device. If you need anything more, you're better off going with Android Wear for the full application and developer support on the platform.

Categories

Resources