Wasn't sure where this would go, please move if inappropriate.
I bought the Sennheiser Momentum In-Ear (Android Version) back in October. They worked great with my Nexus 5 and the Note 4 I owned briefly. The buttons worked to control music playback and volume with no issue. On my Moto X 2014, the controls do not work at all. Play/pause, volume, skip track, etc... are all completely non-functional.
I thought that there were only two standards, iPhone and Android, and that all Android phones should work with the controls designed for any Android phone. Obviously I was wrong. Does anyone have IEMs/headphones that have in-line controls that actually work with the Moto X 2014? Note I am speaking only about wired headsets, not bluetooth.
My LG HBS-800s work perfectly with my Pure edition running Lollipop. I have only tested it with Play Music though.
Thank you for the recommendation. I am really looking for wired options though.
I have the Bose IE2 and the newer version and they both work.
I have noticed that my Samsung headphones dont work with the X either. Volume pause etc. Not sure why but I think it is on motos end why it doesn't work.
Sent from my XT1095 using XDA Free mobile app
raptir said:
Wasn't sure where this would go, please move if inappropriate.
I bought the Sennheiser Momentum In-Ear (Android Version) back in October. They worked great with my Nexus 5 and the Note 4 I owned briefly. The buttons worked to control music playback and volume with no issue. On my Moto X 2014, the controls do not work at all. Play/pause, volume, skip track, etc... are all completely non-functional.
I thought that there were only two standards, iPhone and Android, and that all Android phones should work with the controls designed for any Android phone. Obviously I was wrong. Does anyone have IEMs/headphones that have in-line controls that actually work with the Moto X 2014? Note I am speaking only about wired headsets, not bluetooth.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
We had this conversation over on the Motorola site. Android does not bake in headphone control (except pause/pick-up/hang-up). Some manufacturers have, such as Samsung and I guess LG, and those work with all of the controls. Motorola does not add in the functionality. There are some headphones that work with a software driver (app) that looks for button press, but I've never tried those. I have gone to bluetooth for my phone.
My skullcandy Ink'd work. Play, pause, skip, previous.
Not my preferred pair but when I need the controls...
Note10.1Dude said:
We had this conversation over on the Motorola site. Android does not bake in headphone control (except pause/pick-up/hang-up). Some manufacturers have, such as Samsung and I guess LG, and those work with all of the controls. Motorola does not add in the functionality. There are some headphones that work with a software driver (app) that looks for button press, but I've never tried those. I have gone to bluetooth for my phone.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hm, that's... odd since the headphones work on Nexus devices. And I would assume anything built in to a Nexus device is baked into Android...
jphilippon said:
My skullcandy Ink'd work. Play, pause, skip, previous.
Not my preferred pair but when I need the controls...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My skullcandy 50|50 did not work very well, the link control didn't work and i always heard electrical noise at the beginning of music or movie
Sent from my XT1097 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
I have the Amazon Premium Headphones; they work very well. (the controls work too)
Note10.1Dude said:
We had this conversation over on the Motorola site. Android does not bake in headphone control (except pause/pick-up/hang-up). Some manufacturers have, such as Samsung and I guess LG, and those work with all of the controls. Motorola does not add in the functionality. There are some headphones that work with a software driver (app) that looks for button press, but I've never tried those. I have gone to bluetooth for my phone.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Android (software) does have it baked in most nexus(hardware) have it
Nexus 5(lg) nexus6 (Motorola)
Android supports but hardware needs support it too
Like HTC LG Samsung Nokia Sony
I've been using the Plantronics BackBeat GO Wireless Headphones.
Controls:
Accept or Bypass Calls
Volume Up & Volume Down
Up & Down Skip Tracks
Pause & Play Music
Related
The idea is to control music player with screen off to save battery. Control with volume buttons and maybe trackball.....
If you have a headset in then you already can. The headset it comes with allows this. I have a bluetooth stereo headset and can change tracks with it just fine.
toooitwo said:
If you have a headset in then you already can. The headset it comes with allows this. I have a bluetooth stereo headset and can change tracks with it just fine.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i am not using stock headset because sound quality is horrible.
Would be interested in this as well.
Agreed stock headphones are trash.
kolyan said:
i am not using stock headset because sound quality is horrible.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Buy anything supporting the iPhone, the Nexus One seems to support the same standard. I bought some Sennheiser in ears w/ inline remote for the iPhone and they work for play/pause/next.
Casao said:
Buy anything supporting the iPhone, the Nexus One seems to support the same standard. I bought some Sennheiser in ears w/ inline remote for the iPhone and they work for play/pause/next.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the advice.
ps. Trackball has been modded to skip songs with stock player. kinda what i was looking for.
Has anyone tried MEElectronics SP51P Sound Preference In-Ear Headphone with Sound Tuning w/Microphone to check compatability with the G2x?
Or does anyone have a set of inear headphones with inline mic and play/pause button that they can verify works with the normal music player on the G2x?
No interested in opinion just facts
I'd also like to know of a set of inline headphones with music controls for the G2X. I sold my SGS4G to get the G2X and decided to keep the headphones after learning the G2X doesn't come with headphones. The only issue I have is that the PowerAmp headphone control(s) that worked on my SGS4G do not work on my G2X. I could pause play and skip songs on the S4G, but I can't even pause/play with the G2X. I'm using the same headphones and music player so I'm at a complete loss. I'm willing to buy headphones with built-in music controls if they'll resolve the issue but I'd love to have proof.
I have a set of nuforce ne-8. The buttons could pause/play/skip but now that i try to do it, it won't do it. I gotta play around with it some more. These headphones are wonderful for the price.
I bought Jlab j3m headphones with mic and button from amazon for $20 for the G2x.
All functionality is there (answer/hang up, play/pause) except for voice dialer. In fact, a long button press will bring up the voice dialer, but it gets stuck on starting up.
Hopefully there will be a fix for this...
MEElectronics M9P: The headset sounds GREAT but mic/button functionality is a bust. When using the headset to answer a call, the mic randomly works and the phone drops the call. Could be a bad set???
Plantronics Backbeat 216 All controls work except volume but SOUNDS LIKE CRAP
I'll be returning The 216's and exchanging the M9P's. All I really want is great sound and ability to take phone calls for <$60. Any suggestions?? Thinking about Jbuds J3M or J4M; Klipsch Image S2m; or Monster iBeats (refurbs)
Any experience with these?
*I'm using G2X with PowerAMP music app
My klipsch image s2 button does not work for controlling playback on my g2x....bummer.
Bose MIE2: it is tricky to control music. You have to have the correct timing to make it work.
Sennheiser MM60: play/next works
Griffin iphone remote ( http://www.jr.com/griffin-technology/pe/GRF_GC17061/ ) : play/next works (recommended)
Audio Technica iphone remote ( http://www.jr.com/audio-technica/pe/AT_ATMP100/ ) :it also works
Anybody tried any skullcandy buds on this phone yet? What's better jbuds j3, or scull candy titan mic'd?
I bought the Jlab J3Ms, have been using them extensively, and enjoy them very much except for one flaw.
All functionality is there (answer/hang up, play/pause) except for voice dialer. A long button press will bring up the voice dialer, but it gets stuck on starting up.
Has anyone successfully used voice dialer with Wired headphones with an inline mic?
I can live without the voice dial, but my klipsch s2m's that worked great on my n1 are a nightmare on the g2x. Button does not work, phone randomly pauses playback, voice dialer actually opens on it's own sometimes. It seems like it is getting false button presses. Really annoying to have to pull out my phone when doing something active to have to answer call/resume playback/skip track.
Here's a question? Does anybody know if the Optimus 2X headphones work on the G2X, if so it may or may not be worth just picking up a pair of those. Which will probably be much easier to get a hold of. Just a thought. I might do that. (USA version got shafted on accessories)
Spoke with jbuds rep and they confirmed that the g2x jack is setup differently than most phones. I don't know what to do about this. Here is the link they sent me. Jbuds are setup for Mic, ground, l, r
http://pinouts.ru/HeadsetsHeadphones/lg_tu550_headset_pinout.shtml
Sent from my LG-P999 using XDA App
bamabruin said:
I bought the Jlab J3Ms, have been using them extensively, and enjoy them very much except for one flaw.
All functionality is there (answer/hang up, play/pause) except for voice dialer. A long button press will bring up the voice dialer, but it gets stuck on starting up.
Has anyone successfully used voice dialer with Wired headphones with an inline mic?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
They don't have a skip button?
Yeah they do, you just double click the button.
Sent from my LG-P999 using XDA App
jsauce75 said:
Yeah they do, you just double click the button.
Sent from my LG-P999 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Awesome, these might be IT for me then.
Please let me know how they work if you get them. I spoke with a jlabs rep and they confirmed the jack on the g2x is laid out differently than what the jbuds are designed for, but if they work, they work. Everyone designs their headphones to work with apple products, so outside of lg directly I think finding headphones designed to work with this jack layout isn't going to happen.
Sent from my LG-P999 using XDA App
I have iphone head phones with mic and htc head phones with mic the only features that function are the play and pause Iam trying to find a way to get all the features of the htc head phones to work (skip/back)
I spoke at length with people at lg and jbuds. Basically they won't work unless the board in the mic assembly is compatible with the phone. So an adapter won't fix it. There are reports that jbuds work, the rep couldn't verify because they don't have the phone there, but he has heard they work too. I'm going to give them a try when I have a little extra cash. The other options are lg wired headphones or stereo bluetooth.
Sent from my LG-P999 using XDA App
These work great
I've been using the Nuforce-NE-700M. They work great! I'm using them with the paid PowerAMP app on stock G2x. The only thing is no response to long press for voice dialer. Since I haven't heard anyone else using long press successfully, I'm guessing it may be a software issue. The mic,play/pause, skip, back and ans/hu functions all work flawlessly. The voice dialer does work but only if you initiate it from the phone. Setting up a short cut/gesture should be an easy work around. (I here gestures may be apart of the CM7 release for G2X..??)
They're a little pricey for some at $75. However the sound quality is equivalent to headsets that sell for double.
I produce and engineer in my home studio and have compared them to my over-the-ear SONY MDR-7506 which are a professional standard. IMHO the NE-700M's actually perform better. Bass is full, tight and punchy and doesn't distort mid-range. Highs are crisp and mids are well defined. Isolation is supreme. As with most high-end speakers, they will need a few hours "burn in" time out of the box, but seem to sound better each time I use them.
BTW for those that don't know-press mic button twice to skip track and 3 times for previous track. Here is a pic of my settings in PowerAMP (I believe they are the same for the stock player)
jsauce75 said:
I spoke at length with people at lg and jbuds. Basically they won't work unless the board in the mic assembly is compatible with the phone. So an adapter won't fix it. There are reports that jbuds work, the rep couldn't verify because they don't have the phone there, but he has heard they work too. I'm going to give them a try when I have a little extra cash. The other options are lg wired headphones or stereo bluetooth.
Sent from my LG-P999 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
A guy previously in the thread said they work just fine with his G2x?
edit: just ordered them from Amazon. Will report back and confirm.
It seems that people are having compatibility issues with headphones working on the g2x. I thought it would be nice if there was a thread where people can list what headphones work and those that don't. I can verify that the buttons do not work on the klipsch image s2 and the headphones that came with the nexus s.
Sent from my LG-P999 using XDA App
jsauce75 said:
It seems that people are having compatibility issues with headphones working on the g2x. I thought it would be nice if there was a thread where people can list what headphones work and those that don't. I can verify that the buttons do not work on the klipsch image s2 and the headphones that came with the nexus s.
Sent from my LG-P999 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just got my Zagg SmartBuds, and they all functions work perfectly, from volume control to answering/ending calls. PLUS they not only sound great, but w/all the sliders I can keep the cord from going rogue on me. They also came w/4 additional [5 total] ear bud adapters to fit different ear sizes.
I was worried, but I figured [since I bought them during the 50% off sale] worst case scenario I got a gift for my girls iPhone. Was a win-win, depending on how you look at it, more of a win for me.
Are they water/sweat proof?
fatal27 said:
Are they water/sweat proof?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
and this is their fatal flaw... well, of sorts. No, they aren't. Zagg does have some that are, but you lost the phone/audio controls.
Here are the links...
SmartBuds
AquaBuds
I do work outside here in Oklahoma and seeing how we've already had our first 100+ degree day, I see much sweating in my near future. I'll keep you updated.
jsauce75 said:
It seems that people are having compatibility issues with headphones working on the g2x. I thought it would be nice if there was a thread where people can list what headphones work and those that don't. I can verify that the buttons do not work on the klipsch image s2 and the headphones that came with the nexus s.
Sent from my LG-P999 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah, I have the Klipsch Image S5i headset and the play button works to start/stop music and answer/hang-up calls but the + & -- buttons don't do anything.
The Image S5i's are designed for Apple products, I have compared the 3.5mm tip connections and they are the same configuration layout that I need for my G2x, but there is obviously something different in the command structure to activate functions.
I love the quality of sound from the S5i's and they are more rugged than the Image S4's I have. I am crossing my fingers that someone will come out with an app that will allow all the functions to work. I found one on the Android market that looked promising -- but it only works with Gingerbread, and I am running Froyo (rooted), so we may just have to wait a little longer for the compatability/upgrade to be introduced in order to get the headsets fully operational (hope it is very soon).
I use my iPod earphones.. the mic works great and so does the play/pause/skip control, the only thing that doesn't work is the volume up/down
G2x
Delete
10char
i bought the Jaybirdgear sportsband. they are more useful for people who excercise but they work great. all buttons work as well as mic
If you have Mortplayer Music, give it a try.
I can do play/pause (one press), next (two rapid press), previous (three rapid press) with Audio Technica iphone headset adapter.
Anyone tried the nexus one headphones with the g2x? Pause/play works but next/previous track buttons don't with stock player, winamp, or poweramp.
Sent from my LG-P999 using XDA Premium App
Moto ROKR S9 HD
I can confirm my bluetooth Moto ROKR S9 HD's work just fine, I would def recomend those if you hate wires like me
Teidullie said:
I can confirm my bluetooth Moto ROKR S9 HD's work just fine, I would def recomend those if you hate wires like me
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
looks good. can you buy one for me?
Hey guys,
While I had my iPhone 4S, I bought a pair of SkullCandy 'Fix' earbuds, which according to the packaging, were designed to be compatible with the iPhone chipset. They are an earbud/mic combo with pause/play/volume controls.
Will the controls work properly with the HOX? I've tried them out and they don't seem to. While they start and stop music, they won't change the volume.
Any idea about an app or something that might make these fully functional.
Thanks for the input,
J
There is no set standard for in-line earphone controls for smartphones. Earphones designed for iPhone will almost always not work properly on Android (most buttons won't work).
The following app should be your solution. Its designed to make the buttons on iPhone-compatible headsets work on Android:
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=jp.co.chobirich.tools.mediabutton&feature=search_result#?t=W251bGwsMSwxLDEsImpwLmNvLmNob2JpcmljaC50b29scy5tZWRpYWJ1dHRvbiJd
Thanks !!!!!
Hello guys!
I'm interested in a pair of headphones/handsfree, but I've tried a few "universal" units and either the buttons or the mic doesn't work with the RAZR HD.
Is there any way we can identify which headphones/handsfree fit on our unit?
Thanks in advance.
Sent from my XT925 using Tapatalk 2
I will try out my wife's Klipsch Reference One's when I get home and next week I will have a pair of Miles Davis Trumpets to try out too so I will let you know.
memphis060 said:
Is there any way we can identify which headphones/handsfree fit on our unit?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There are two specifications for implementing headset-based remote controls. One way is the way Apple implements headset controls. The other way is how everyone else in the industry implements headset controls. (sounds very "Apple-like" doesn't it?)
You can use this general rule:
If the headset says it works with the Apple iPhone, then it probably won't work for the Droid RAZR.
Quick example of this:
Klipsch Image S4: Version of headphones without headset controls.
Klipsch Image S4i: Same headphones, has headset controls that work with Apple iPhones (but not Android)
Klipsch Image S4a: Same headphones, has headset controls that work with Android.
Thanks for the input, but I have tried samsung galaxy s hands free for example and they don't work.
Sent from my XT925 using Tapatalk 2
may be a lil late here, but i use the dre beats for my iphone on android phones all the time and the mic works...
nemesis000000 said:
may be a lil late here, but i use the dre beats for my iphone on android phones all the time and the mic works...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just to be clear... the headphones and mic for these kinds of heatsets will always work regardless of intended Apple / Android manufacturer. Handling audio is just pure analog electrical signals.
However, the push button controls will depend on how the smartphone manufacturer implemented the control specifications. So even though your Dr. Dre Beats for your iPhone works for your Android smartphone, I'll bet that the buttons (Fast Forward / Rewind / Skip Track / Mute / Volume Up / Volume Down) does not work for Android the way that it works for iPhone.
I have been using Skullcandy ink'd with mic for over 6 months. At TjMaxx and Marshall's for $9.99. I also have Klipsch Promedia with Microphone. They both work flawlessly, but you can't go wrong with Skullcandy for the price. They sound awesome, come with lifetime warranty, and cost so little.
anyone can tell me if this
http://www.ebay.com/itm/A075-SKULLC...128&pid=100015&prg=1006&rk=1&sd=221066028978&
is compatible with razr hd?
thks a lot!
I would assuming they are the mic one they will. I have a pair of skullcandy fmj's and they work just fine. Also have a pair of Skullcandy 50/50 just the track control buttons don't work but the middle button and the mic work
Sent from my DROID RAZR HD using Tapatalk 2
Blutooth headphones
I use de s10-hd blutooth headphones handsfree, its great, controls work and handsfree sounds great besides its rain resistant! at least a light one.
Im very happy with it
Anyone else can suggest another headphone please?
Thanks
I have Klipsch X7i both the mic and the Play/Pause button work fine. Only volume buttons don't work.
Same with my SOL Republic Tracks HD, mic & play/pause works but not volume
Sent from my XT925 using xda app-developers app
Someone tested:
- Philips SHE 8005
- Jays a-Jays One+
Thanks for your feedback