[Q] Moto X, HTC One, Galaxy S4 or Galaxy Note 2? - General Questions and Answers

Hey xda community I need help deciding on which phone I should get next since I have an upgrade with Sprint. I've done some research and I'm stuck between the Moto X, HTC One, Galaxy S4 and the Galaxy Note 2. I will most likely install a ROM but I only like complete ROMs with no down sides to them as in Camera, video bugs ect.
I was really going for the Moto x because of the talk feature so I can change music in my car but the 16gb internal and no expansion SD card is a disappointment. I like uniqueness but what I really like about Android is the ability to remove your battery and have added memory so the Moto X doesn't seem like a good choice for me. Same with the HTC One but they do have a 32gb internal memory but I can't remove the battery. I just don't want to install a ROM and freeze and have no control to be able to pop out the battery and reboot to recovery ect. I love the Note 2 features and battery life. I'm only concerned about the size with a case on it because I always get an otter box. I've been out of the scene for a while so I wanted to get some suggestions from you guys. I'm coming from The Photon 4G running CNA Android 4.1.1. I loved that phone especially with the CNA ROM but it's time to upgrade and I want to make the right choice.
I like to stand out from the crowd and be unique. I want 4G LTE. I really want to be able to add a 32gb mini SD card and be able to remove the battery. I basically like to have the most control of my phone. I will eventually install a ROM on my new phone whatever it being, if it's worth it. I want a smooth running phone. The Photon has given me trouble here and they're kind of frustrating but it was from the ROM but I wouldn't complain because it was much better than running stock Android 2.1.1.
I just want to get some suggestions and maybe some experience from you guys. Any reply helps. I appreciate it. Thanks.
Edit: I'm leaning towards the HTC One but will not being able to remove the battery cause problems with installing ROMs? I might not even instal a ROM since 4.4 KitKat is coming to HTC One

Note 2's pen is great

You can't choice nexus 5 or lg g2 ?
Else, i think note 2 is better

maskah said:
You can't choice nexus 5 or lg g2 ?
Else, i think note 2 is better
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I looked a little at those but I think I'm going to go with the S4. The Note doesn't have gorilla glass and will be too big in my pocket with a case

Galaxy S4!
You already answered yourself. Galaxy S4 is the way to go....like you said the note 2 is going to be too big with protection case ect. I have the Galaxy S4 and the size is just right, removable battery and good rom support.

i7vSa7vi7y said:
I looked a little at those but I think I'm going to go with the S4. The Note doesn't have gorilla glass and will be too big in my pocket with a case
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok, so you should buy the S4 :good:

Ok thanks guys. I just needed to make up my mind I guess. What ROM would you guys reccomend installing? I think I'm going to install Sac's ROM but is there any bugs or problems? I like complete ROMs.

Related

choice a new phone?

i have make a search for a new best phone for me i cant choice wich one is the best
i was thinking about SAMSUNG I9100 GALAXY S II vs SAMSUNG GALAXY NOTE vs i phone 4 vs HTC Sensation vs Samsung Galaxy Nexus...which one you will suggest to me for the top use ?
My personal opinion I like the new Motorola Razr (Or Droid Razr in the US). 1GB RAM, Dual core 1.2cpu and seperate gpu. 16Gb internal with SD ext support. 8Mp Camera rather than 5.
The new Nexus is comparable but has 5mp camera and no external sd card support, which I just don't understand.
If you like the Galaxy, version 3 should be out 1st 1/4 of next year. That looks a beast.
you have to decide wither to go with Android or iOS.
if you want more apps, much much less customization go with iOS and buy iPhone 4/4s
------
if you want good amount of apps, customizable OS go with Android
then ask your self do I want a phone or a small tablet if you want a phone remove the note from your list
other phones in the market share the same specs: 1.2 dual core around 1GB ram
5-8 mb camera
I will go with HTC rezound (in US) or the Galaxy nexus or If you like the design of
Motorola Razr its good phone (my friend told me its camera is not that good)
my final personal choice will be the new Galaxy Nexus
You can't go wrong with Galaxy S II. It packs all the things we love in Android - big screen (but not too big), open bootloader, great power etc.
I just love the idea of "Pure Google" phones. I have a Nexus S that I love. I'd go for that if I were you, or even better, if you have the budget to afford it, for a Galaxy Nexus.
Pure Google phones = best support (quick system update deployment), no bloatware (I'm not a fan of TouchWiz, Sense and others).
Of course it is a bit irrelevant once you install CM on them, but there's something that makes me feel good to have the brand Google on the back of my phone.
giorgosfl said:
i have make a search for a new best phone for me i cant choice wich one is the best
i was thinking about SAMSUNG I9100 GALAXY S II vs SAMSUNG GALAXY NOTE vs i phone 4 vs HTC Sensation vs Samsung Galaxy Nexus...which one you will suggest to me for the top use ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
and remember, tinkering with Apple stuff is a futile effort! unless you work for them. which i suppose is like a gang initiation in / out. basically apple-ites live on their own little planet.
I heard that the sound quality on the s2 is not as good as the first version.
i was thinking to buy the htc flyer but with the samsung note maybe i change my mind because i saw the specs for that device and i think is better to have 2 things in one devices and more more cheaper
In my opinion the Galaxy Nexus is the best you could get because you can be sure that Google will support this phone a long time and the hardware is really nice.
The second phone I would choose is the S2, brilliant screen and epic phone.
Hi, I had the Captivate, then upgraded to the SGSII. Now my wife has the Cappy. I just put a rom in the I777. Working great. I love the SGSII.
Just my 2 cents.
i decide that i wont buy an iPhone and i will stay with the awesome android OS.
but i want to learn more about the Samsung phones ...like how to root each of them and if i can root them.
what phone have the best screen from the others and the camera.
also about the best custom things like roms and hacks.
battery life and also the best and more important part what are the problems they have .
And if their is a compare video or site with all the samsung phone i am interesting
What about SG note? Weird that nobody recommends it
Sent from my X10a using xda premium
That is very simple, HTC Sensation.
It has design, beauty and class over others.
Get iphone because remember if u have an iphone, u don't have an iphone.
brunomirjanic said:
That is very simple, HTC Sensation.
It has design, beauty and class over others.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The HTC Sensation is very nice. I love mine. Even after buying the HTC Amaze I STILL use my Sensation. It feels very nice in the hand...and you can buy white battery covers which when combined with a new ROM, make you feel like you have a new phone.
Pipsqueak approved this message
I recently got a HD7 with windows phone, and i gotta say, its really nice.
its buttery smooth, fastest growing apps market, etc. the phone is also really nice, fast, good size, good weight, nice screen, not too bad of a camera (cant beat a real camera ofc, but still).
just my opinion.
S2
-------------------------------
Sent from my HTC Desire S
why anyone suggest samsung galaxy note????
i have seen the specs of the phone and its also awsome but noone want it ....why ???
does it have problem???
I think the Galaxy Not is a little bit too big for the most. But i would take it
As long as it fits in the pocket, its not too big(and has nice specs too)
Sent from my X10a using xda premium

[Q] galaxy nexus or galaxy s2 or htc one?

hey guys,
im looking to buy a phone in the upper mid-range category and im really confused between the s2, nexus and the htc one s. the s2 was my original choice but apart from the sd card and the normal sim slot it is inferior to the htc one s. on the other hand, the nexus may not have the fastest processor of the lot but it does have the advantage of being a google phone and thus has a extremely large developer base. I am keen on getting the one s now but i've managed to confuse myself once again. there have been reports that the one s is unable to maintain its black color when scratched and that the phones have had white marks on them because of the ceramic finish . and the lack of an sd card slot is a huge turnoff plus it only takes micro-sims that make the device even more inflexible...
i am utterly clueless here, i would be really grateful if someone could help...
and btw i am very keen on loading different kernels and custom roms on my device and i will definitely be overclocking, and im looking for a phone that is future proof atleast for 2-3 years...
P.S: this will be my first android device and i want my journey with android to be a pleasant one, so guys, please help me.
and one more thing,
I am not asking which is the best phone of the lot, i am asking which phone will be the best FOR ME! so no fanboy rants and petty quarrels please...!!
I personally prefer the Galaxy Nexus due it being a google phone and yes it does have a HUGE developer base both here and inside google. One of the main advantages is that it offers a pure google android experience, so no carrier bloatware apps or overlays.
While the HTC One S is a more powerful device, it does come with the Sense UI overlay on top of Android 4.0. Some people prefer it, while others don't like it. It all depends on the person. Also, on a side note, there is no real way of completely removing the Sense UI with a new ROM without causing some problems.
The Galaxy S2 is still a good device, but will have the Samsung Touchwiz overlay. Though Touchwiz can be removed without a problem.
Both the S2 and HTC One S will have slower Android upgrades than the Galaxy Nexus, which receives almost immediately when it is available.
Overall, both the HTC One S and the Galaxy Nexus will be future-proof as they are capable of running the future Android OS like Jelly Bean. However, the only difference is that the Nexus will receive the update much earlier than the One S. This is not to say the S2 won't get the update, but it will take some time as well.
Aesthetics wise, all phones are beautifully designed and thin, so no problems there.
Have fun choosing as they are all amazing phones!
thanks for the reply. i really dont mind if the updates come slowly. but if the s2 will get them eventually, i'm gonna go for it. the nexus is extremely dificult to come around in my locality and from how much i am aware of, the only assets that the nexus has, over the s2 is a better screen and a larger developer support since its a google phone. apart form that the s2 is better in all regard. i dont really care about touch wiz or sense. I prefer the stock android UI anyway. since that can be obtained in the s2, im gonna go for it. plus by overclocking im sure one can get scores of 4000+ in quadrant on the s2. so exynos is almost as fast as the snapdragon s2 if not faster...
cool. glad I helped Good luck with the new phone!
GNex
Desire S • Fallout V2.0.0 • xda premium
if the Gnexus is not available i would definately take the SII any day. While the One S has the S4 processor it doesnt have a micro SD so limited to 16GB and no removable battery. SII any day.
Go buy the Nexus. You'll have more fun with it to flash etc ...!
Galaxy Nexus for sure. I went from iPhone to HTC sensation then Evo3D but both played up. Got the Nexus and its the best mobile ive had.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda premium

[Q] galaxy s3 or galaxy nexus?

Hi, I'm an absolute juggernoob on here so i apologize if this has already been asked a million times but here i go..
I recently got the s3 which is amazing but dayum I need that jellybean. Now I can trade the s3 for a mint condition nexus but I'm torn between them and would like some insight from actual nexus owners as to whether it would really be a 'downgrade or if that tasty jellybean would make all doubt disappear.
Again I apologize if I've posted this wrong
Im not an nexus owner but I can tell you yes it is a downgrade to go back to the nexus... specially if you're doing it for jelly bean calm down and wait for the devs at the s3 forums do their magic sooner or later it will show up for your phone I'm pretty sure it's just a matter of time..
Sent From My Sexy Sensation.
The S3 will get JB. Not as soon as the GN, but it won't be too long. The much better specs of the S3 make it worth keeping.
Thanks guys, I guess I am being a little too impatient: ( I've got my own project butter setup now lol. Basically foxhound Ali version with Nova launcher and that screw animations make it super fast , it's actually pretty damn zippy Haha.
Do you guys know of any other good performance roms I'm new to all this Modding after getting rid of a 4s and lumia 800 (the Droid truly is the master)
A thanks to you both from me and my s3 XD
SIII is better, but not much, if money is no problem: go for sIII, otherwise go for Gnex, who is a bit cheaper
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda premium
Thanks. Does anybody know if the omega rom is any better than foxhound I've flashed a few so far but had abit of a scare doing my last flash Haha.
it depends on what is ur need and priorities
s3 has got external sd slot which is missing in nexus
camera of s3 is 1000X better than nexus pic quality of nexus is worst
both hav amoled screen nearly equal
rite now nexus has got jelly beam which makes it super smooth
but in few days s3 will b getting its jelly beam
even processor of s3 is better than nexus
i would suggest u shld stick to S3:cyclops:
visheshtungare0879 said:
s3 has got external sd slot which is missing in nexus
camera of s3 is 1000X better than nexus pic quality of nexus is worst
both hav amoled screen nearly equal
rite now nexus has got jelly beam which makes it super smooth
but in few days s3 will b getting its jelly beam
even processor of s3 is better than nexus
i would suggest u shld stick to S3:cyclops:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Definitely I just tried the ota port that somebody uploaded and although it's obviously not a daily driver yet it's still pretty promising lol thanks

Time to upgrade, but can't decide on which one

Hey guys, I believe this is my first post.
I've had a Nexus S 4G since last March and Sprint is telling me that I'm eligible for an upgrade. My wife doesn't seem to want to get a new phone so I'm thinking about giving her my Nexus S and getting a new one for me.
I'm looking at the LG Optimus G and the Galaxy Nexus. The biggest thing drawing me to the GNex is it's fairly similar to the Nexus S, and I love that phone. Would just like the GNex for the faster processor and more space. The Optimus G looks interesting because it seems to be the CDMA version of the Nexus 4, but the glass casing and terrible LG updates are making me second guess.
I've also noticed the the development for the Optimus seems stale, maybe since it's so new. Where on the other side, I already know that the development for the GNex is huge.
Thoughts, opinions, flames, whatever you want to bring to the table, I'd really appreciate it.
Thanks!
be like everyone else and just get the s3
Gungrave223 said:
be like everyone else and just get the s3
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1 or note2
life!
note 2 is too big to handle, go for Galaxy Nexus, its a killer
davitslv said:
note 2 is too big to handle, go for Galaxy Nexus, its a killer
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Okay, after some research and finding out that the Optimus G does not have a removable battery, that one is definitely off the table.
I seriously may consider the GS3. I just love the Nexus devices so much though. The GNex seems to me like a Nexus S on steroids.
I'll see. Gonna go look at some tonight and see what kind of deals people have. I know the old lady wants a GS3 so I may surprise her with one.
only android?
or you are looking for something else?
you cant go wrong with a gs3..and if you wanna root and mod it,this is the place to be with your gs3
bear in mind also if u plan to use LTE support, different country, uses different band and make sure u get the right phones, i got an LG optimus, and my provided provide a different LTE band... suck...
go for Galaxy Nexus you won't regret it.
Well the galaxy nexus gsm version is the best phone I used so far. But I heard bad things about the CDMA version such as potentially poor signal, much slower official updates compared to the gsm version and less battery life. Don't forget the Galaxy Nexus will have the widest variety of third party os roms such as firefox and upcoming Ubuntu and Tizen.
The Galaxy S3 might be a better choice if you don't need as cutting edge roms and updates though. It has excellent camera, microsd slot, longer battery, slightly better screen and beret sound quality (either the us or international version). I'm disappointed with the built quality though and the Nexus built is definitely better even if not great. Also you should read the thread about many people getting sudden death issue with their 16gb S3 due to failed nand, but I guess you're okay if you have sprint warranty.
Sent from R800at
Gnex is a great choise. However it is 1.5
year old. Optimistic G is like a little monster!! But do u trust LG???. Don't forget that 4x won't update to jb!!! If u like aosp look don't forget LG Nexus 4!!
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda premium
If u have big hands try note2
But if u have small hands then s3 will be fine for u
If u are going to root it then there is no reason for buying nexus phone......
I am an Android Fanboy but Steve Jobs had Rightly said that if a phone cant be used by one hand it's not a phone......
IF ITS BETWEEN THOSE TWO;GET THE NEXUS MAN :thumbup:
Sent from my MiniPro using xda premium
Ayushsinghal said:
Steve Jobs had Rightly said that if a phone cant be used by one hand it's not a phone......
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I do not used a touch screen phone one handed, it's a very slow way of controlling when my index finger can move faster and is more flexible than my thumb.
Sent from R800at
wait for the galaxy s4..?
Sent from my SGH-I777 using xda premium
I'd go for the Galaxy Nexus
Dude get a Note 2 pls
go for Nexus 4
How about oppo find 5?
wait for another somedays & go for the Sony Xperia Z

Your opinions on this phone?

So my upgrade is in a couple of weeks. I have been deciding from The htc droid dna, Samsung Galaxy Note 2, or this phone. What are your opinions on this phone or problems you have noticed?
http://forum.xda-developers.com/forumdisplay.php?f=1716
Ooh nice choices. I've only used the s3 out of the 3 but it's really nice. I haven't had any problems with it and it has a good selection of roms / kernels.
All Q's go in Q&A
Since you were looking for a general opinion I edited your title
FNM
I absolutely love this phone. Running carbon rom with it. Lots of great development here and good hardware. Perfect size for me too.
My opinion
famous145 said:
So my upgrade is in a couple of weeks. I have been deciding from The htc droid dna, Samsung Galaxy Note 2, or this phone. What are your opinions on this phone or problems you have noticed?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Gnote 2 > GS3 >>>>>> Droid DNA (battery life is just putrid on the DNA)
I've owned my share of phones and the GS3 is the first phone that has cured my flashaholicism.. I am running cleanRom 4.5 and it just works. Battery life is all you can ask for and the phone has all the capabilities of any other phone. I have been 100% happy with this phone and have not had any desire to upgrade to anything else. With that being said, it is 8 months old and the S4 and HTC One are coming. At this stage, you may be best waiting for one of those two.
gs3 is good, the note 2 is great...I wont comment on the dna, waste of time and effort.
I prefer the S3. The Note 2 is nice, but it's definitely not a pocket phone. Wouldn't even consider the DNA.
The GS3 and Note 2 require cases due to their fragility. Performance wise they're both adequate. Expect occasional lags and Bluetooth routing issues when a headset is plugged in (SoundAbout paid app on the market fixes this) unless you use AOSP based ROMs which still have a litany of quirks and issues for both devices. Note 2 is a giant phone, but the added utility with the pen makes up for it.
Edit/addendum:
DNA shouldn't even be a consideration IMO. Android isn't quite ready for 1080p on the app side and the benefits of the faster hardware are lost due to the vastly increased pixel count. 16GB of non-expandable storage is a joke. Battery life is similar to the GS3 so I won't complain there. The device isn't officially supported by CM and probably won't be, unlike the GS3 and Note 2. Be prepared to love sense if you go this route.
Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
I would wait for the gs4
Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
Really after changing to android i got this S3 i cant remove my hands of it lol!
I really like my S3. I'm currently running Beans 11 and like it.
I'm happy with my s3. And if your into rooting and installing roms, it's a great one to play with. Odin makes this phone unbrickable.
The note is just too big, IMHO.
I'm a.d.d so I like to change to something new every few months, unfortunately I'm out of upgrades.. I ran stock touchwiz for the last month and installed an AOSP room last night so I'm happy again for the time being.
Sent from my SCH-I535 using xda app-developers app
Owning the S3 for a while now it really makes me wish Verizon will carry another Nexus device. I was addicted to the S3 at first but it kind of just wore off now. If the Verizon Galaxy Nexus did not have so many flaws in it I would have never left it.
There is no experience like a Nexus experience!
Between the phones you are asking about, if the size of the Note 2 does not bother you then I would go for that. If it is to big, which for me it is I would then go to the S3. Wouldn't even consider the DNA. Actually at this point in time I wouldn't really consider anything from HTC. They have really went to crap and it just seems like they are recycling their same phones over and over again.
Might as well hold out for the sg4
If you are looking to run a stock phone for awhile, I would wait for the S4, but if you want root and have pages and pages of ROMs to continually try, then the S3 is the way to go.
For the guys saying there getting great battery how many ours are you getting?
This phone is awesome! I haven't been able to put it down. I'm using liquidsmooth ROM and I love it. I just wish I could get more battery life but just like I said I haven't put it down since buying it.
The GS3 is great, I have the otterbox commuter and can still easily stick it in my pocket, the note 2 not so much however they are both great phones. If I could choose now, i;d wait and see what the specs on the Ubuntu Phone will be like and compare them to the GS4.
Love it. No real problems here.

Categories

Resources