My phone does something weird. When the data mode, shown beside the battery icon, is shown as 3G, no data transfer can be made until it is changed to 'H'. This gets very annoying.
The problem is that it stays at 3G until I want to do some data transfer, then it changes to 'H' which takes some time.
Anybody gets this as well? Is there anyway to prevent this?
Sent from my HTC Desire S using XDA App
H means hsdpa,which is High Speed Downlink Packet Access. It is 3.5G. And it is faster than 3G.
Sent from my HTC Desire S using XDA App
I think, its metwork config...
I had this very same issue in UK (Virgin pay as you go)
Sent from my HTC Desire S using Tapatalk
Same issue with o2 Pay Monthly, although it generally switches to H quite quickly when data access is required.
CatcherInRye said:
H means hsdpa,which is High Speed Downlink Packet Access. It is 3.5G. And it is faster than 3G.
Sent from my HTC Desire S using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Correct me if I'm wrong. H means HSPA, which is 3.5G, and 3G is 3G in itself, and G is 2G? I thought 2G didn't allow data transmission? So isn't 'G', 3G?
I understand HSPA is supposed to be faster than 3G, but the problem is that 3G doesn't allow any data transmission.
ffforce said:
Correct me if I'm wrong. H means HSPA, which is 3.5G, and 3G is 3G in itself, and G is 2G? I thought 2G didn't allow data transmission? So isn't 'G', 3G?
I understand HSPA is supposed to be faster than 3G, but the problem is that 3G doesn't allow any data transmission.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
"WCDMA"
H = HSPA = 3.5G
3G = 3G
"GSM"
E = EDGE = 2.5G
G = GPRS = 2G
All of them allow data access, or should do anyway.
ffforce said:
Correct me if I'm wrong. H means HSPA, which is 3.5G, and 3G is 3G in itself, and G is 2G? I thought 2G didn't allow data transmission? So isn't 'G', 3G?
I understand HSPA is supposed to be faster than 3G, but the problem is that 3G doesn't allow any data transmission.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
WCDMA
H = HSPA = 3.5G
3G = 3G
GSM
E = EDGE = 2.5G
G = GPRS = 2G
Both 2G and 3G allow data access.
No, "G" is not "3G". "G" means GPRS (General Packet Radio Service) and is an old standart to transfer data via GSM. It is, in fact, the slowest ond one of the oldest.
There are two networks, "2G" which is "G" or "E" (EDGE which is is a litlle bit faster than "GPRS" - and "3G" (now even "4G" ) which is a high spead network. "H" should mean "HSDPA" or "HSPA"
Oooops, to slow.
In addition: Via 3G you can do data connection and phone calls at the same time, this you can not do in 2G
ffforce said:
My phone does something weird. When the data mode, shown beside the battery icon, is shown as 3G, no data transfer can be made until it is changed to 'H'. This gets very annoying.
The problem is that it stays at 3G until I want to do some data transfer, then it changes to 'H' which takes some time.
Anybody gets this as well? Is there anyway to prevent this?
Sent from my HTC Desire S using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Your phone will check to see what the best connection available is before downloading. The wait is down to your network provider's service and availability. And possibly your radio. It's not that it wont download on 3G. It will. It's just that 99 times out of 100 if 3G is available, so is HSDPA so it'll go for that one over 3G every time. Unless you are on my network provider. Then you'd get better consistent data transfer over a piece of wet string.
You could go into your phone setting and choose 'WCDMA only' if you generally have good coverage and want to cut the wait out?
Dial *#*#4636#*#*, from the resulting menu select 'Phone Information' then scroll to the bottom and change the drop-down menu to 'WCDMA only'.
Does that help?
Tip:
You can also do this without dialing a code:
Got to settings/wireless & network/Mobile network/Network mode
So you don't have to remember the code if you want to change settings
wnp_79 said:
Your phone will check to see what the best connection available is before downloading. The wait is down to your network provider's service and availability. And possibly your radio. It's not that it wont download on 3G. It will. It's just that 99 times out of 100 if 3G is available, so is HSDPA so it'll go for that one over 3G every time. Unless you are on my network provider. Then you'd get better consistent data transfer over a piece of wet string.
You could go into your phone setting and choose 'WCDMA only' if you generally have good coverage and want to cut the wait out?
Dial *#*#4636#*#*, from the resulting menu select 'Phone Information' then scroll to the bottom and change the drop-down menu to 'WCDMA only'.
Does that help?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I tried this. For now it seems that it is stuck at HSPA now! Thanks! Am I right to assume that under WCDMA only mode, I either get HSPA data or no data at all? The phone will not go to 3G or 2G right? (there's no 2.5G here)
Thanks to the others who clarified the 2G,3G,3.5G terms. I understand it more clearly now!
ffforce said:
Am I right to assume that under WCDMA only mode, I either get HSPA data or no data at all? The phone will not go to 3G or 2G right? (there's no 2.5G here)
Thanks to the others who clarified the 2G,3G,3.5G terms. I understand it more clearly now!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
WCDMA only means you will only have HSPA and 3G connections. You will not have, as you wrote, 2G. 2.5G means EDGE which is still a 2G connection but a little bit faster than GPRS, and right, you will not have that.
Sent from my HTC Desire S using XDA App
HSPA includes HSDPA and HSUPA. I really don't know the difference between them.
Sent from my HTC Desire S using XDA App
HSPA is faster than HSDPA, and HSUPA is the standart for uploads. You should visit Wikipedia for detailed information.
Sent from my HTC Desire S using XDA App
My fastest tests I took with Infuse were on UMTS network, ranging between 6000 and 6500 kbps. I beleive it's a 3G, right?
Immediately following it from 1000 kbps to 6000 kbps were HSDPA tests (I assume those are "4g"?)
I took about 30+ test in different times, different networks. But top 9 speeds by download were on UMTS network following by HSDPA network.
What gives? If this is a current state of affairs, then I'd rather just lock to 3G and save battery.
artisticcheese said:
My fastest tests I took with Infuse were on UMTS network, ranging between 6000 and 6500 kbps. I beleive it's a 3G, right?
Immediately following it from 1000 kbps to 6000 kbps were HSDPA tests (I assume those are "4g"?)
I took about 30+ test in different times, different networks. But top 9 speeds by download were on UMTS network following by HSDPA network.
What gives? If this is a current state of affairs, then I'd rather just lock to 3G and save battery.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Lo should have been forced to hpsa+ when you enter data no matter what. All the tests were on 3g just some happened to be faster. By the way our 4g is not 4g only lte is. Its a gimmick lol. And one thing suprising is regular 3g and this Plus stuff is the same stuff just having more bandwith for it to go faster.Uses no more battery.
Ryanscool said:
Lo should have been forced to hpsa+ when you enter data no matter what. All the tests were on 3g just some happened to be faster. By the way our 4g is not 4g only lte is. Its a gimmick lol. And one thing suprising is regular 3g and this Plus stuff is the same stuff just having more bandwith for it to go faster.Uses no more battery.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, this is consistent. There are way too many tests to consider this an accident. See results below. Umts is faster then HSDPA on 30+ tests I run so far. As you see in locations they are all different, also different parts of the day as well. Sample is too big to consider this an accendal observation.
"2011-08-13 07:00","Umts","33.00701","-96.89448",6412,1119,133,"Dallas, TX","10.183.179.99","32.150.131.141"
"2011-12-07 06:00","Umts","33.00760","-96.89575",6344,715,160,"Dallas, TX","10.41.103.105","166.205.9.197"
"2011-08-21 08:21","Umts","33.01306","-96.88703",6254,1035,140,"Dallas, TX","10.79.102.172","166.205.9.42"
"2011-08-12 13:49","Umts","33.00822","-96.89473",6239,1099,144,"Dallas, TX","10.150.100.141, 10.68.90.161","166.205.10.75"
"2011-08-12 13:52","Umts","33.00822","-96.89473",6164,1113,156,"Dallas, TX","10.93.66.121","166.205.10.75"
"2011-11-20 11:52","Hsdpa","32.99510","-96.88730",6077,730,68,"Fort Worth, TX","10.137.181.9","32.170.23.132"
"2011-11-19 11:18","Umts","33.00369","-96.88326",6028,1096,121,"Dallas, TX","10.131.241.205","32.168.238.98"
"2011-08-25 21:58","Umts","32.80980","-96.79930",5927,718,131,"Dallas, TX","10.131.153.86","166.205.8.68"
"2011-12-06 18:23","Hsdpa","33.00626","-96.88055",5906,1116,72,"Fort Worth, TX","10.58.242.16","32.145.53.131"
"2011-08-12 13:53","Umts","33.00822","-96.89473",5904,1074,154,"Dallas, TX","10.93.66.121","32.169.236.85"
"2011-08-12 15:03","Umts","33.00822","-96.89473",5886,1114,187,"Dallas, TX","10.93.3.118","166.189.112.8"
"2011-12-07 05:59","Hsdpa","33.00760","-96.89575",5864,724,137,"Dallas, TX","10.41.103.105","166.205.9.197"
"2011-12-06 18:16","Umts","33.00626","-96.88055",5643,732,124,"Dallas, TX","10.139.124.118","166.132.114.251"
"2011-08-12 13:44","Umts","33.00822","-96.89473",5530,1108,180,"Dallas, TX","10.68.90.161","166.205.10.75"
"2011-11-09 18:48","Umts","33.02570","-96.84037",5518,1065,172,"Dallas, TX","10.148.88.227","32.168.172.122"
"2011-10-02 08:52","Hsdpa","38.00000","-97.00000",5499,1131,71,"Oklahoma City, OK","10.77.146.107","32.170.196.78"
"2011-10-09 08:08","Umts","33.00628","-96.88251",5410,750,79,"Dallas, TX","10.137.89.60","166.132.199.183"
"2011-11-19 11:17","Hsdpa","33.01678","-96.88595",5408,903,68,"Fort Worth, TX","10.131.241.205","32.168.238.98"
"2011-09-03 15:58","Umts","33.06708","-96.89039",5398,740,86,"Dallas, TX","10.187.175.76","32.147.197.82"
"2011-12-06 18:19","Umts","33.00626","-96.88055",5388,1113,96,"Dallas, TX","10.58.242.16","32.145.53.131"
"2011-12-06 18:24","Umts","33.00626","-96.88055",5338,1108,70,"Dallas, TX","10.58.242.16","32.145.53.131"
"2011-08-23 18:25","Hsdpa","33.00810","-96.89472",5324,734,170,"Dallas, TX","10.17.250.78","166.205.9.55"
"2011-11-19 07:17","Hsdpa","33.00730","-96.89504",5242,732,127,"Dallas, TX","10.136.91.31","32.170.144.102"
"2011-09-05 09:04","Umts","38.00000","-97.00000",5232,1035,96,"Dallas, TX","10.102.94.83","32.150.105.130"
"2011-11-16 15:38","Umts","33.08185","-96.80335",5075,525,72,"Dallas, TX","10.149.253.134","166.188.180.124"
"2011-08-12 13:44","Umts","33.00822","-96.89473",5011,1088,161,"Dallas, TX","10.68.90.161","166.205.10.75"
"2011-08-20 16:02","Hsdpa","33.06562","-96.88689",4995,1102,169,"Dallas, TX","10.180.189.199","32.149.4.51"
"2011-08-13 06:59","Umts","33.00701","-96.89448",4985,739,148,"Dallas, TX","10.183.179.99","32.150.131.141"
"2011-11-16 16:03","Hsdpa","33.01648","-96.88608",4970,734,112,"Dallas, TX","10.55.212.71","32.151.10.169"
"2011-12-06 18:33","Umts","33.00626","-96.88055",4762,744,132,"Temple, TX","10.58.242.16","32.145.53.131"
"2011-12-06 18:15","Umts","33.00626","-96.88055",4679,739,137,"Fort Worth, TX","10.139.124.118","166.132.114.251"
"2011-09-06 08:59","Umts","37.38759","-121.97641",4533,685,136,"San Jose, CA","10.81.14.82","32.152.209.250"
"2011-10-21 14:52","Hsdpa","33.05276","-96.83213",4527,1047,88,"Temple, TX","10.138.35.120","166.132.31.49"
"2011-09-09 11:58","Hsdpa","37.39436","-121.97611",4508,987,112,"San Jose, CA","10.13.71.200","166.135.240.102"
"2011-08-31 17:18","Hsdpa","33.01180","-96.85744",4396,1089,155,"Dallas, TX","10.77.6.244","166.188.171.5"
"2011-11-20 08:04","Hsdpa","33.02268","-96.91396",4279,851,52,"Dallas, TX","10.137.181.9","32.170.23.132"
"2011-11-11 07:55","Hsdpa","38.00000","-97.00000",4229,294,72,"Fort Worth, TX","10.91.220.96","166.133.227.92"
"2011-11-11 08:02","Umts","33.08182","-96.80333",4225,745,65,"Fort Worth, TX","10.91.220.96","166.133.227.92"
"2011-09-08 01:17","Hsdpa","37.39514","-121.98374",4166,1099,142,"San Jose, CA","10.3.58.10","166.190.179.60"
"2011-08-19 15:18","Hsdpa","33.01901","-96.88339",4023,333,383,"Dallas, TX","10.184.183.207","32.149.250.36"
"2011-08-26 12:44","Hsdpa","33.02371","-96.88564",3974,1018,157,"Dallas, TX","10.79.97.170","32.145.218.19"
"2011-09-08 01:43","Hsdpa","37.39514","-121.98374",3945,1095,118,"San Jose, CA","10.3.58.10","166.190.179.60"
"2011-08-28 15:43","Hsdpa","33.01301","-96.88740",3791,644,196,"Dallas, TX","10.139.66.108","166.132.130.18"
"2011-11-16 15:46","Hsdpa","33.02505","-96.87194",3629,1055,157,"Dallas, TX","10.182.131.213","32.149.162.218"
"2011-10-04 07:08","Hsdpa","32.99733","-96.92118",3580,54,120,"Overland Park, KS","10.77.168.169","32.170.130.238"
artisticcheese said:
My fastest tests I took with Infuse were on UMTS network, ranging between 6000 and 6500 kbps. I beleive it's a 3G, right?
Immediately following it from 1000 kbps to 6000 kbps were HSDPA tests (I assume those are "4g"?)
I took about 30+ test in different times, different networks. But top 9 speeds by download were on UMTS network following by HSDPA network.
What gives? If this is a current state of affairs, then I'd rather just lock to 3G and save battery.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Okay, some clarifications. I'm guessing you're just talking about how it was displayed in your app, but HSPA and HSPA+ are both UMTS based networks, so 3G and HSPA+ "4G" are both UMTS. The difference in this current implementation of 3G and "4G" is that 3G is HSPA which maxes out at 14 Mbps downstream, whereas "4G" HSPA+ maxes out at 84 Mbps downstream. It's the same technology, just basically a software update.
Now, most HSPA 3G phones don't support 14 Mbps downstream. I think most max out at 7.2 Mbps. Most HSPA+ 4G phones max out at 21 Mbps, or some even support 42 Mbps, however, being that AT&T's network is 16QAM, their network's max speed is 14 Mbps. So really, HSPA 3G is entirely capable of going as fast as HSPA+ 4G on AT&T's current network, assuming you have a phone with a fast enough chip in it.
As for the results you posted, I'm not really sure what to say. You said your UMTS tests gave you 6000-6500 Kbps, but then HSDPA tests gave you 1000-6000 Kbps. What's confusing is that whatever app you are using is posting random labels on the network which are all technically correct, but only confusing people. 6000 Kbps is very definitely HSDPA. In it's first release, HSDPA was sometimes called 3.5G, whereas UMTS without HSDPA would have been base 3G. The second release of HSDPA is where we go to HSPA+ and "4G", increasing speeds to 42 Mbps.
If all of this is very confusing, then I apologize, but I'm not really surprised. This is why they apply names like 3G and 4G to it when it's far more complex. If you really want to learn more about the network technology, check out the wiki page for HSPA: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-Speed_Packet_Access
And yes, as previously mentioned and as you may have gathered from what I posted, HSPA 3G and HSPA+ 4G are the exact same technology, just updated a little, so the battery effect is negligible. LTE 4G will bring an entirely new radio, on top of having an HSPA or HSPA+ radio in it as well, so that's where you get more battery drain. For now, HSPA+ 4G devices won't drain any more battery than HSPA 3G devices.
AJerman said:
Okay, some clarifications. I'm guessing you're just talking about how it was displayed in your app, but HSPA and HSPA+ are both UMTS based networks, so 3G and HSPA+ "4G" are both UMTS. The difference in this current implementation of 3G and "4G" is that 3G is HSPA which maxes out at 14 Mbps downstream, whereas "4G" HSPA+ maxes out at 84 Mbps downstream. It's the same technology, just basically a software update.
Now, most HSPA 3G phones don't support 14 Mbps downstream. I think most max out at 7.2 Mbps. Most HSPA+ 4G phones max out at 21 Mbps, or some even support 42 Mbps, however, being that AT&T's network is 16QAM, their network's max speed is 14 Mbps. So really, HSPA 3G is entirely capable of going as fast as HSPA+ 4G on AT&T's current network, assuming you have a phone with a fast enough chip in it.
As for the results you posted, I'm not really sure what to say. You said your UMTS tests gave you 6000-6500 Kbps, but then HSDPA tests gave you 1000-6000 Kbps. What's confusing is that whatever app you are using is posting random labels on the network which are all technically correct, but only confusing people. 6000 Kbps is very definitely HSDPA. In it's first release, HSDPA was sometimes called 3.5G, whereas UMTS without HSDPA would have been base 3G. The second release of HSDPA is where we go to HSPA+ and "4G", increasing speeds to 42 Mbps.
If all of this is very confusing, then I apologize, but I'm not really surprised. This is why they apply names like 3G and 4G to it when it's far more complex. If you really want to learn more about the network technology, check out the wiki page for HSPA: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-Speed_Packet_Access
And yes, as previously mentioned and as you may have gathered from what I posted, HSPA 3G and HSPA+ 4G are the exact same technology, just updated a little, so the battery effect is negligible. LTE 4G will bring an entirely new radio, on top of having an HSPA or HSPA+ radio in it as well, so that's where you get more battery drain. For now, HSPA+ 4G devices won't drain any more battery than HSPA 3G devices.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Boom! Better explanation than me lol. Sorry for my post not being long enough, i am at school. I was trying to get to what he said.