http://www.xda-developers.com/android/linux-3-4-kernel-for-the-galaxy-s-plus-gt-i9001/
PLEASE! DO A SGS+ FORUM! WE DESERVE IT!!
p.s: For this i will get an big advertisment but it's ok :laugh:
AW: I guess for that we need an separate forum!
anyone should Start a Petition that we can sign and Hand over To the mods.
And op's please leave this thread in dev section althoug its not directly dev but its only about splus
We should have our own forum idd. Why? Because the i8150 even has his own forum. and we have more development then the i8150
Let's all post as much curse words as possible so we draw the attention of the mods so they will see this thread.
Okay I begin I guess....
No just kidding! You are right we need a seperate forum for our device we always argue with ppl posting **** in the wrong thread
Sent from my GT-I9001 using xda app-developers app
broodplank1337 said:
We should have our own forum idd. Why? Because the i8150 even has his own forum. and we have more development then the i8150
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is true that we have more development but I don't really see why that would be a comparison.
It would be great if we had a separate forum but in the mod's and admins eyes, we are only an extension/upgrade of the i9000. I can't fathom how many times I have seen this kind of discussion in these forums and how many times the mod's just simply said "No." Well, they have made many changes recently to make sure spam stays minimal so it might be possible if we approach with the fact that having no separate forum creates an unbelievable amount of spam, which is actually pretty damn true.
Xistance said:
This is true that we have more development but I don't really see why that would be a comparison.
It would be great if we had a separate forum but in the mod's and admins eyes, we are only an extension/upgrade of the i9000. I can't fathom how many times I have seen this kind of discussion in these forums and how many times the mod's just simply said "No." Well, they have made many changes recently to make sure spam stays minimal so it might be possible if we approach with the fact that having no separate forum creates an unbelievable amount of spam, which is actually pretty damn true.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well, I think you're actually right. but it's justa pity that we don't have other forums. although it doesn't slow down the development at all! it's only increasing and increasin
But I must admit that asking a Q in the i9000 Q&A forum is just terrible. since it's so i9000 orientated.
But idd the mods just won't change it ever. period
R: I guess for that we need an separate forum!
broodplank1337 said:
Well, I think you're actually right. but it's justa pity that we don't have other forums. although it doesn't slow down the development at all! it's only increasing and increasin
But I must admit that asking a Q in the i9000 Q&A forum is just terrible. since it's so i9000 orientated.
But idd the mods just won't change it ever. period
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If i9001 had a separate forum or had a dedicated section in the i8150 one we would eliminate lots of spam threads or "which ROM is better?" ones
Inviato dal mio frigo a pedali.
i don't think having a separated forum will have any use . we have 1 gb rom still active , 3 ics roms and maybe 3 or 4 jb roms . 4 kernels focused on jb , 1 on ics and 1 on jb . a separate forum for 14 topics ? the only use of a separate forum would be that modders and app devs like brood can get more organized , but brood implements everything he does into his rom forums and modders are getting fewer by the day . and our device is getting old .
probably , after the release of klp most people will move to another device and the forum will be dead . having in consideration that a phone's life is , by industry standard , 2 years ..well we're basically getting a separate forum for a few months afterwards we all would move onto a new device .
it has no use . i9001 has an amazing developing team for a niche device , but all this fuss is not worth it seeing that this is a close knitted , close to a thousand user community .
Sent from my GT-I9001 using xda app-developers app
Already asked several times to our moderators. Whiskey01 answerd back that they would take it in to a count and they would let us know if any thing changed.
Sure..This will be..ahm..
Never?
R: I guess for that we need an separate forum!
No, the day after never.
Inviato dal mio frigo a pedali.
the real problem is that i9001 is seen as an upgrade of i9000, but they are really different, i discovered only few weeks ago that our Q&A section is in the i9000 one.... and i think it is nonsense, why i have to go in i9000 Q&A to make a question for i9001? it is so confusing, people risk to brick their phones by misreading i9000-i9001 (some i9000 users answer i9001 questions thinking is the same thing.... but even button combination to get in recovery is different)
It could be better if we at least we have a new separate general section :fingers-crossed:
So that development section would be spared from unnecessary threads.
Let's ask the moderator about this :thumbup:
Sent from my GT-I9001 using Tapatalk 2
I9070 has a few ROMs / kernels but it has a separated forum !!!!! I'm agree with new forum
I also agree the idea, normal S is completely different phone than our plus.
Yep we need a separate forum.
+1
s and s plus are totally diferent... only have the same appearence
There are a lot of phones out there which have way less development than our great device and have their own forum anyway. I mean come on, our great dev community managed to port kernel 3.4 - and it's as good as bugless! We have a close to beta version of CM10.1, and there are coming up new devs all the time.
Furthermore, the thing with the Q&A thread in i9000 Q&A forum is confusing as hell. Our device has f*ing nothing to do with i9000! And this is also a reason why the dev section is being spammed all the time (I gotta admit that I also once spammed because I was so confused)
So I agree, PLEASE GIVE US OUR OWN FORUM!
I know I just said a lot of things that were mentioned earlier in this thread, but I just wanted to sum it all up.
AW: I guess for that we need an separate forum!
They think that our device is just an other version of the i9000 but the i9070 is just an other version of the i9100, too and the i9070 has his own forum.
And withe an own forum we won't have so many Q/A in development died or how its called
Sent from my GT-I9001 using xda premium
Related
Hello everyone.
That's my issue may not be the right place, but this is where I find the most relevant, since for this section.
I think for some time the number of threads are increasing enormously for new ROM, which is fine because it shows that the community is very active) but many of the Roma are found to be the same base or from ports of other devices, and there are so many with names that look alike or have nothing to do with the content (I will not name to avoid any controversy and stay in a general term) that we end by not knowing what exactly that is.
So I think it should be revamped a little with all that can be sub-sections by Dev ports or Roma, ways to try to eclaicir section and avoid ending up finally with questions about a thread that has nothing to do with this thread Rom.
That's what I feel for a very short time and I think it would be good for both dev and users of éclaicir things.
When do you think??
Arma, a user begins to consider warning from the time I practice android flash device.
This makes little to no sense, so can't really reply. Think youre essentially saying that maybe devs combine their different ROM releases into single threads?
rorydaredkign said:
This makes little to no sense, so can't really reply. Think youre essentially saying that maybe devs combine their different ROM releases into single threads?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Or subforums? So the DHD Dev subforum has a couple more subforums within it (one for ported ROMs, one for ROMS built on a native base)? That's how I read it anyway.
Sorry for my bad english (google translation), but yes I think it would be although it is organized by several sub-forums, for example, the ports of other phones, stock rom, rom MluI, or do that every dev its own sub-forums, and finally they are ideas, see what might appeal without being overly burdensome for devs who already have enough to do.
If someone else with ideas on how to build the threads?
The discussion is now open.
I think people would over see things and it would be a mess then a dev gets a new device and his sub forum is left behind and annoy like sticky threads
Sent from my Desire HD using xda premium
sub forms like : Sense Development, MIUI Development and Ported roms development would be super cool and better than just one single development section.
It takes me a roughly 15-20 mins just to find a thread here lol
fearkillerr said:
sub forms like : Sense Development, MIUI Development and Ported roms development would be super cool and better than just one single development section.
It takes me a roughly 15-20 mins just to find a thread here lol
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I totally agree to that!!
Agreed. Either that, or we need someone to keep an updated sticky again. But a "Utilities" section, for radios, RILs, and recoveries would be a good idea also.
fearkillerr said:
sub forms like : Sense Development, MIUI Development and Ported roms development would be super cool and better than just one single development section.
It takes me a roughly 15-20 mins just to find a thread here lol
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
And not to forget kernel, RIL and RADIO
Hi guys is there any chance this would happen? I know that the Galaxy S 4G has everything to support this. So anyone willing to develop a port. The S2 has already a working one so why not galaxy s 4g?
Thanks
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1407967
Wrong section :'(
No. back to general with !! ! Oh wait this is the 30th thread?
Sent from my SGH-T959V using XDA App
I sometimes think that this is done on purpose. :/
-Sent From My Amazing SGS4G-
If this isn't a dev posting a working and bootable ICS for SGS4G then does this topic belong here? This been posted about a billion times in the right section of the SGS4G forum mind you. Use search function, post in old decrepit post about ICS, but please don't hog up the development section with this garbage. Important stuff belongs here like the roms that the devs here work so hard on only to be under appreciated by a bunch of sniveling children who didn't get their beloved CM7. Yes ICS got unwittingly dropped by the ever so greedy and scrooge like Samsung, who against Google's Open Handset Alliance, which promises a device would be supported for 18 months, has decided they are going to drop all galaxy devices period rather than provide official ICS. If you'd really like ICS then you'd best start donating. Money is tight for me right now but I know when my cash flow picks up my green backs are going to start moving in this direction.
You know what I've come to understand? A new user won't know how the regular users will want the forum to run. I made the same mistake myself and had a few threads moved out of the dev section. It's a dev question, so it could properly fit in the dev board.
You're just bumping the thread needlessly. Next time do what I did and just post a link to where the topic was discussed instead of ranting about how it's in the wrong section. Just report the thread and have one of the mods move it. It's much easier than having to take time out of your day to type up a long post talking about how pissed off you are about it.
Merry xmas everyone!
Questions or Problems Should Not Be Posted in the Development Forum
Please Post in the Correct Forums and Read THIS
Moving to Q&A
As FBis said, links are the way to go!
Sent from my SGH-T959V using XDA App
My understanding is that basically everyone in this forum is migrating and upgrading to the Note. Are there any reasons for even considering anything else or staying with the obsoleted Infuse? The Note just seems like such an awesome phone so it would be great seeing all great users in this forum going there.
Sent from my Infuse 4G using Tapatalk
Yes for me
Let the flamers begin:
Just my 2¢
short answer...., who cares?
long answer.... do we really need to clog up the forum with this dribble? ???
there is a comparison thread for discussion of other devices, oh and a whole forum for the device you wish to discuss.
you make it sound like your next device has to be a group decision. the note is basically a bigger skyrocket with a stylus. what's the big deal?
edit... are you freaking kidding me?????
the mod already closed one thread of yours on this topic so you create another one???
are the forum rules this hard to comprehend???
Dani897 said:
short answer...., who cares?
long answer.... do we really need to clog up the forum with this dribble? ???
there is a comparison thread for discussion of other devices, oh and a whole forum for the device you wish to discuss.
you make it sound like your next device has to be a group decision. the note is basically a bigger skyrocket with a stylus. what's the big deal?
edit... are you freaking kidding me?????
the mod already closed one thread of yours on this topic so you create another one???
are the forum rules this hard to comprehend???
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What dani said is exactly right. Who cares? Don't be a follower! You are the one paying for the phone so get what you want. Who cares what everyone else is getting. I just used my upgrade for what i wanted and got a Atrix 2. I use it and my Infuse. Why buy two samsung phones that are similar when you can have two totally different devices? Do what you want, dont worry about everyone else.
Sent from my MB865 using xda premium
This is the infuse forum, so you are offtopic.
Any such questions you can posts in the General, General forum.
Thread closed
Remember I am not a moderator. I am only here to help!
Hi all,
As you all know we have a very nice collection of ROMS here in this section of XDA. And I must say, I love it and I will continue testing ROMS and kernels.
It is amazing how this section has grown. And more ROMS and developers are comming here to share their work.
However, every single thread I see people asking:
ETA's
Battery life
Will this work, will that work
Can you please add.....
When will you update this ROM with this base etc..
These things are not on the right place here.
As you all know we also don't have an own Q&A and General subforum like the Samsung Galaxy S / S Advance. I do understand why you put these questions here. It's the I9001 subforum.. But these questions are not on the right place here.
So we made these threads ourselfs:
[Q&As][REQs][etc]Q&A, REQ, PLEASE POST HERE!
Samsung Galaxy S Plus I9001 General
Samsung Galaxy S Plus I9001 Q&A
Yes I know these threads are somewhat chaotic. But, these threads are for us and our beloved phone.
I think we need some basicrules in here. Remember one important thing THIS IS THE DEVELOPMENT SECTION OF THE SAMSUNG GALAXY S PLUS AKA ARIESVE AKA I9001.
Da rulez:
Read the XDA Rules: Link
Do not ask for ETA's (ETA stands for Estimated Time of Arrival)
Do not ask the developer to update the ROM with the newest base. If he/she has time it will be done. (it is not a must!!)
Do not ask the same thing in every thread (so if you ask something about a governor ask this in one kernel thread not in three)
Try before you ask. If you want to know something about a ROM read the thread, try and then ask.
Always read the instructions given bij the OP/Developer
Do not spam the thread. Trolling is funny I know but it has nothing to do with development. (WE NEED AN OFF TOPIC THREAD HERE :silly: )
If you have an important bug to report. Make a logcat.
Before posting anything, you must use the SEARCH button at the top of the webpage.
Respect each other. This is important. We all started as noobs as explaind here: Link
Use English when you are posting something here. If you are sending a private message to someone with the same language as you it's fine to use it. But post in English please.
If you are a new member here then please take a look here: Link
If you see something completly unfair/ against the rules / disrespectfull or whatever. Please use the report button it has an !
As a senior member of XDA I wish you good luck here. Happy flashing/modding/tweaking.
Cheers
Mrjraider
Reserved (if possible)
This behaviour cannot be changed now...it's too late...
If we should have sub-forum for our device, things would probably be different.
TwinHeadedEagle said:
This behaviour cannot be changed now...it's too late...
If we should have sub-forum for our device, things would probably be different.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
We just must ask admin's for forum to our phone. We have a really nice number of users and new roms, threads here. Why we don't try?
Harrocan said:
We just must ask admin's for forum to our phone. We have a really nice number of users and new roms, threads here. Why we don't try?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I did. A while ago. I sent a message to Whisky01 and he said it will be discussed.. But I havent heard from him ever since.
AW: [IMPORTANT][INFORMATION]Da Rulez
In my opinion opening a topic for general things, will lead into a complete mess, because everyone wants to post questions to a different Rom or topic. So I would support these subforums i9000 users have for our phone.
Sent from my GT-I9001 using xda app-developers app
Okay, before we get any discussion I want to explain why I made this thread.
As we all know this community is huge, our section is getting bigger and bigger. New ROMS, Kernels and developers.
We also get new users who wants to help and got questions. For me as a newbie 7 months ago it was hard to get answers and solutions for my problems. I was hoping I got my 10 postcount as soon as possible so that I could participate in the development section. Back then I was very noob and was helping and answering where ever I could and that lead to problems and random posts/discussions. To prevent suchs issues I create this topic to get the basic rules of XDA easy explaind in one simple topic. I refer to the original rules and topics made by moderators and admins. But still, this thread is easy to read (at least I hope )
Another reason for this thread is this:
I see comments like this:
+1
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
When will you update this ROM
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Any news????
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
When are you releasing a fix
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Etc etc.
These comments are annoying, and in particular the +1 comments.. I hate them, and they fill the topic for no reason.
I also want to prevent "problems". Problems like spamming and misunderstanding.
These rules are in no way against anything on XDA. If you as user got any problems with this topic or even me. Sent me a PM please.
TwinHeadedEagle said:
This behaviour cannot be changed now...it's too late...
If we should have sub-forum for our device, things would probably be different.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What do you mean??
I said that it's hard to learn an old dog something...
Samsung Galaxy Mini has it's own forum, and has 2 time less topics...
TwinHeadedEagle said:
I said that is hard to learn an old dog something...
Samsung Galaxy Mini has it's own forum, and has 2 times less topics...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Jup thats true.
I think I make a poll to show to the moderator/admins to get our own subforum
Wrong threat
AW: [IMPORTANT][INFORMATION]Da Rulez
This is no discussion thread! These are the XDA rules, if you want to stay here, follow them, if you dont follow them, leave. Theres nothing to discuss about.
Also, we asked for a i9001 forum multiple times, i dont get why they dont do **** about that. Its annoying as hell everything is mixed with i9000 things. I saw a guy who flashed a i9001 kernel on his 9000 because he thought the 9001 kernel are the "new ones".
For gods sake even the GS Advance has his own forum....whats the matter?
Sent from my GT-I9001 using xda app-developers app
Maybe it's a lot of work now for mods to move all threads, and because of that they don't wanna give us our own forum...
Sent from my GT-I9001 using Tapatalk 2
TwinHeadedEagle said:
Maybe it's a lot of work now for mods to move all threads, and because of that they don't wanna give us our own forum...
Sent from my GT-I9001 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So they can give moderator to any developer on this forum, ex. broodplank, or someone else. I think we can move threads at us own. Only baricade is ... we don't have forum...
I have an idea. It's a little annoyng but we all can report this post to mod's with reason ex. "We want to have forum for our phone, please, read that topic". But OP must insert info about that in 1st post. What do you think about that?
we need to vote for a new forum and show them the votes (just to say that we are a lot and we want it)
Guys guys guys, this.topic.of.us getting a new forum has been discussed many times in the past, all with the negative ans frm mods.
The mods may not want to start this again.
Sent from my GT-I9001 using xda app-developers app
Aldokazer said:
Guys guys guys, this.topic.of.us getting a new forum has been discussed many times in the past, all with the negative ans frm mods.
The mods may not want to start this again.
Sent from my GT-I9001 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
In my eyes is this bulls**. Even the lowend devices placed under legacy and low activity have their own forum. There is absolutly no reason to give our phone not an own place...
Le edit:
Please stop this discussion, I doubt we get our own place so stop it...
Please go ontopic again..
mrjraider said:
In my eyes is this bulls**. Even the lowend devices placed under legacy and low activity have their own forum. There is absolutly no reason to give our phone not an own place...
Le edit:
Please stop this discussion, I doubt we get our own place so stop it...
Please go ontopic again..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
And you try to tell this to the moderators.
And yes, let's get back to the topic.
Sent from my GT-I9001 using xda app-developers app
XDA Forums generally have bad organization and very bad moderation. They are here only to punish you...
I am and was mod/supermod on many Tech Forums in my country, the biggest has 300.000 members, and it's organization is 100 times better then this. I had hundreds of posts, and know how good forum work. A lot sub-forums for better member orientation, gentle and kind mods who always have advice for you how to be better, and not warnings...
That's why simple members treat them with respect and not with arogance...
AW: [IMPORTANT][INFORMATION]Da Rulez
TwinHeadedEagle said:
XDA Forums generally have bad organization and very bad moderation. They are here only to punish you...
I am and was mod/supermod on many Tech Forums in my country, the biggest has 300.000 members, and it's organization is 100 times better then this. I had hundreds of posts, and know how good forum work. A lot sub-forums for better member orientation, gentle and kind mods who always have advice for you how to be better, and not warnings...
That's why simple members treat them with respect and not with arogance...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What? Punish? Do you even know how many people have an.account here? 300.000 is maybe the point on the i here at xda.
Sent from my GT-I9001 using xda app-developers app
To be honest, I dont see a moderator here very often. I believe (and this may be wrong) that they are only moderating the populair devices:
Samsung Galaxy SII/SIII HTC One X/X+ etc.. Our device is not so populair....
But please stop this discussion, this is not going to end..
So , here is the deal. In every frikin tread on this specific forum i see flame wars between i9500 and i9505( wich soc, audio,camera etc is better).
these are two almost completly different devices in term of development etc. as i see every specific carrier (version,t-mobile etc) i9505 has got its own forum so why do you put two different devices in same basket. its kinda confusing for new users and totaly unnecessary. So to put an end to constant trolling in every tread i suggest you make specefic forum for I9505 and other for I9500. Here i rest my case and iv put up pool to see what other people think about it. Oh and im sorry for bad spelling.
I think here is the point...
If thrre are seprate sections for verizon and atnt mob then ...obivously 9500 & 9505 should be seprate
They have almost different hardware & users
So septsrion would be great and good for futute
Otherwise the flame war will start every now n then...
+1
via Tapatalk
This thing really nagged me when I first came to this forum, I totally agree with you.
+1
Sent from my Octaaaa! GT-I9500
I real be easer. Cos threat and solution for 9500 is not same are 9505 and general forum really mixed and hard to find needed threat.
I agree
There is a thread for new forum requests in General Discussion > About XDA-Developers forum, you should post there.
Thread closed.