Feel free to discuss your location in the comments as well, as that can have an effect.
taylor.fowler said:
I've got a map set up in the flashable radios thread to help track this sort of thing by region:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1694012
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
correct me if i'm wrong
but I'm pretty sure the Stock Rogers radio is the same as the 1.73 ATT one.
(stock rogers ROM is 1.73 base, so It should be 1.73 Radio as well.)
loneBoat said:
Move this to General if that's a better place for it. Feel free to discuss your location in the comments as well, as that can have an effect.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've got a map set up in the flashable radios thread to help track this sort of thing by region:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1694012
It might be a little more effective than a poll, since this is a largely location based issue. (Some radios perform better than others depending on region)
no sure if serious but you put poll ....
Just going to leave this right here...
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1673114
taylor.fowler said:
I've got a map set up in the flashable radios thread to help track this sort of thing by region:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1694012
It might be a little more effective than a poll, since this is a largely location based issue. (Some radios perform better than others depending on region)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yup, "best" radio is usually geographic more than anything. So doing a poll like this, that doesn't take location into account is pretty much meaningless.
And this doesn't belong in Development.
designgears said:
Just going to leave this right here...
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1673114
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Was your point that it's a redundant thread or that it doesn't belong in DEV? I considered both points, but went ahead and posted since (1) it's a little different from taylor's thread since it's a poll instead of a map and (2) I think it's dev related since radios can be a big issue with some ROMs.
Anyway, some mods want to chime in? If it's inappropriate, go ahead and move it. I'm not trying to clutter up the forum. Just thought it might be useful even though it's not broken down by region. (and the poll's already had several responses, so at least SOME other people seem to agree)
EDIT: dg I tried to thank you to show I'm not just trying to be argumentative - but I already used all my thanks for the day!!
me either, but pointing out the rules of the section. If it has nothing to with development, it should be in general. Think Tanks are fine, people are working on different ideas that eventual lead to root/bl unlock/s-off...
This is just a voting thread about modems, and modem will differ vastly depending on your location, so a popularity contests for modems is useless, you just have to try them and find one that suits your situation.
just my 2 cents.
loneBoat said:
I think it's dev related since radios can be a big issue with some ROMs.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is really just a discussion about radios, so it belongs in General. It only belongs in here if its a tool, ROM, radio. Particularly one that you developed. If you are not a developer, you should probably not create new threads here.
designgears said:
me either, but pointing out the rules of the section. If it has nothing to with development, it should be in general. Think Tanks are fine, people are working on different ideas that eventual lead to root/bl unlock/s-off...
This is just a voting thread about modems, and modem will differ vastly depending on your location, so a popularity contests for modems is useless, you just have to try them and find one that suits your situation.
just my 2 cents.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
...And then drop a marker on my shared map with your info so the community can benefit
Since this is a generalized thread (with poll) about radios, it does belong in the General section. Dont get me wrong though, this is a good idea so that people can quickly glance and see what others are using and then look at the map for their area.
Alright - I'm cool with it moving. Can I move it myself? Or does a MOD have to do it?
EDIT - Well I feel dumb. It had already been moved when I posted that.
loneBoat said:
Alright - I'm cool with it moving. Can I move it myself? Or does a MOD have to do it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Already moved. Red5 is a MOD. Do you wanna pop a link in the OP to my map, too? It would be good to get as much data as possible in there.
With our powers combined, we can actually get some useful info, i think.
taylor.fowler said:
Already moved. Red5 is a MOD. Do you wanna pop a link in the OP to my map, too? It would be good to get as much data as possible in there.
With our powers combined, we can actually get some useful info, i think.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Done, but I get 60% of the profits.
The best radio is the one which works best for your device in your area
Sent from my HTC One X
taylor.fowler said:
Already moved. Red5 is a MOD. Do you wanna pop a link in the OP to my map, too? It would be good to get as much data as possible in there.
With our powers combined, we can actually get some useful info, i think.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Captain Planet is gonna be pissed you stole his trademark catch phrase.
Related
Seeing as the admins here are stubbornly refusing to create a dedicated sub forum for the x7510, I've set up a free forum which may be found here: http://htcathena.freeforums.org
Please note: I don't WANT to be running a seperate board and I'd prefer to have a sub forum here. However, for as long as the admins ignore our requests I'll keep that forum running.
Should a dedicated x7510 sub forum be created here I will close that forum down. Closing down may be deleting it, or if there were many useful posts simply preventing new posts, so that it dies a slower death over time.
This is NOT an attempt at blackmail, but rather me trying to avoid more devices being bricked.
PS: Please excuse the ads on that site - I've gone with the completely free option, so I'm saddled with the ads!
What's the big deal?
NanoRuler said:
Seeing as the admins here are stubbornly refusing to create a dedicated sub forum for the x7510, I've set up a free forum which may be found here: http://htcathena.freeforums.org
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What reason could the xda admins possibly have for not creating a sub-forum for the 7510? Or even an entirely new forum? Look at the Elf and the Vogue.
Anyone know the admins' reasoning on this?
Isn't in my mod powers to create a sub section... I am asking to the admins, again. I hope we will have some answers soon
sergiopi said:
Isn't in my mod powers to create a sub section... I am asking to the admins, again. I hope we will have some answers soon
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you, although I have to say at this stage I'm quite annoyed with the admins, especially seeing as they cannot even be bothered to respond to any request!
elf and vogue are totally different devices which happen to look the same
one is cdma and one is gsm and they work in totally different ways. the vogue has 400mhz prcessor and the elf 201mhz
also to be perfectly honest, how can people not tell the difference between x7510 and x7500/x7501
you bought a device that cost £700 (according to expansys) so surely you know its model name. and because of the cost, if you see x7500/x7501 unlocker you will be wary of using it, even if you think its a typing error
and on the subject of the elf, the elf has 2 variants elf (64 ram and 128 rom) and elfin (128 ram and 256 rom)
both are different and only the elf has hard spl
flashing one rom for one onto the other will brick it
so the same probs as here
but they deal with it and have stickies saying how to distinguish between them and where to go for hat, and seperate guides for flashing roms onto the elf and elfin etc etc
so maybe thats whats neded here
i think the admins are probably fed up of people requesting fora only to have them empty:gene, pharos, juno, sedna are all pretty empty forums that were massively requested and yet not much comes out of them
and now i just counted the votes in the "we want an x7510 section" thread nd there are 33 in 3 months
yes 33
not exactly a huge number is it
But you may all think im just raining on your parade, but im not, I completely understand why you want a new section, but im just trying to highlight why the admins probably dont want it, there are so many new devices which have massive appeal, compared to a £700 device which is essentially an 18 month old device in new casing.
And so in conclusion, I think a sticky explaining he differences between x7510 and stuff is whats needed. Plus, cmones seemed keen to make (or try and make) you guys a hard spl, so why doesnt someone whose a senior (or old) member contact HER and see what she can come up with. she will probably need rom dumps and stuff, but I'm sure she can do it. after all she and others got custom roms on the shift.
night guys, and I hope it works out for you all, and nobody else bricks their devices...
rorydaredkign said:
And so in conclusion, I think a sticky explaining he differences between x7510 and stuff is whats needed. Plus, cmones seemed keen to make (or try and make) you guys a hard spl, so why doesnt someone whose a senior (or old) member contact HER and see what she can come up with. she will probably need rom dumps and stuff, but I'm sure she can do it. after all she and others got custom roms on the shift.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Now THAT was helpful! Why didn't anybody else think about it!
But seriously, CMONEX confirmed she is working on a hard SPL/unlocker and happens to agree with the need for a seperate sub-forum, for a number of valid reasons.
The thing is that a sub-forum will not affect anybody else on XDA-Devs - it won't require more resources, nor more bandwidth. It takes a minute to set up and it may well save several devices.
So please tell me in great detail why there SHOULDN'T be a seperate sub-forum? Why SHOULDN'T things be better organised than the current "pile-everything-into-one-pot" mess? And how exactly will YOU be any worse off should a sub-forum be created?
You will be worse off, won't you? Why else would you be against it?
NanoRuler said:
Why SHOULDN'T things be better organised than the current "pile-everything-into-one-pot" mess?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree with you on that, NanoRuler. E.g. without the latest Athena ROM link by sergiopi (thanks for it), I wasn't even able to compare all existing ROMs for the x7500 at a glance, there are too many threads spread over the entire forum.
Regarding the x7510, a new sub forum would possibly give a better overview. It hasn't been of major importance until now, but it will become necessary very fast, once the x7510 can be unlocked...we should get prepared for that moment. ;-)
rorydaredkign said:
also to be perfectly honest, how can people not tell the difference between x7510 and x7500/x7501
you bought a device that cost £700 (according to expansys) so surely you know its model name. and because of the cost, if you see x7500/x7501 unlocker you will be wary of using it, even if you think its a typing error
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, except there was no indication NOT to run various tools against the x7510.
rorydaredkign said:
but they deal with it and have stickies saying how to distinguish between them and where to go for hat, and seperate guides for flashing roms onto the elf and elfin etc etc
so maybe thats whats neded here
i
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My, what an excellent example of good organisation....NOT. Maybe what's required is a rethink in how the forums are structured, eh? And maybe having distinct sub forums for the different models of Athena will help a great deal.
rorydaredkign said:
and now i just counted the votes in the "we want an x7510 section" thread nd there are 33 in 3 months
yes 33
not exactly a huge number is it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I suggest you go and count again, bearing in mind there are actually requests in different places (perhaps another fringe benefit of piss-poor organisation?)
rorydaredkign said:
I completely understand why you want a new section
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sure, buddy. You have me COMPLETELY convinced that you have our best interests at heart.
rorydaredkign said:
And so in conclusion, I think a sticky explaining he differences between x7510 and stuff is whats needed.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
And that will sort out the mess how exactly?
rorydaredkign said:
night guys, and I hope it works out for you all, and nobody else bricks their devices...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Let me re-phrase your sentiment: I don't want you guys to benefit from a seperate section (even though I'm not directly affected!) and I certainly don't want things to become more organised and anyway there's so few of you that your opinion doesn't matter, but hey, here's to no more bricked devices!
I'll be polite here and let you choose the 1st word, but the second word of my reply is certainly "OFF!"
will_990 said:
I agree with you on that, NanoRuler. E.g. without the latest Athena ROM link by sergiopi (thanks for it), I wasn't even able to compare all existing ROMs for the x7500 at a glance, there are too many threads spread over the entire forum.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
you think thee are lots of roms here, go look at damond rom development and then tell us there are loads of roms here...
I really dont mind or care if theres a seperate section, but I can see why you want one, and also why the admins havent made it
I think a seperate section would actually help dev for us, as we could use your roms and port between the two and stuff.. it would lead to a better dev community here
nano, don't take your anger out on rory. He's not a mod and undeserving of your "**** off".
How about you have a few drinks and relax?
techntrek said:
nano, don't take your anger out on rory. He's not a mod and undeserving of your "**** off".
How about you have a few drinks and relax?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, he's not a mod, but he also did not need to try and build a case against the wishes of quite a few members here using poorly thought out strategies.
He was dismissive without having any reason to be and essentially stated that our opinion doesn't matter (although he didn't quite put it in those words).
Finally, I specifically did NOT tell him to **** off, but gave him some choice in the phrase.
Either somebody's part of the solution...
fair play
hope it works out for you guys
Forum created. This thread closed.
Further discussion here:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=438035
Mike
I'm need all of you guys opinions about this. I live in South Carolina and I need some suggestions.
Let me help you before the flaming begins.
Just try a few. Radios are pretty area specific.
Did you even READ the sticky?
1st sugestion: do some search;
2nd sugestion: do some search again;
3rd sugestion: read a lot throught the forum;
4th and last sugestion: http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=393182
Skip-Breezy said:
I'm need all of you guys opinions about this. I live in South Carolina and I need some suggestions.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What the fuss is about is that people ask the same question day in and day out and people answer questions, only to have them asked again and again...the link given is the best place to look...look at other members signatures and see where they are and what radio they are using...secondly try some of them...it doesnt take but a minute to flash from radio to radio...Also, the quality of the radio is different due to numerous factors, programs you use, area you are in, rom you use etc...so it is too hard to determine what is the best...I personally have tested 5 different radios and always come back to the one in my signature..
I am looking at the radio thread but I want your opinions too.
Our opinions are: you must test several radios to check what is the best for you.
Skip-Breezy said:
I am looking at the radio thread but I want your opinions too.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Check my signature for the radio thread and what my opinion is of a good radio......PM some people or look in their signature and you can tell which radio they like and are using...I am currently testing 4 different radios, but always come back to the one in my signature...
And Dont Be Starting New Threads
As posted in countless other places, all "best radio" threads will be closed.
Ok, so I have literally spent hours reading up on and printing out information on upgrading my Tilt and I think I am ready to take the next step. I am currently using an unlocked AT&T Tilt on Rogers here in Canada and my objectives are to upgrade the OS to WM6.1 and get rid of all of the AT&T "bloatware" that slows me down and takes up precious memory.
My question is...are there any ROM/Radio combinations that work better than others on Rogers? Or, is this even a logical question?
In other words, I know ROM choices are pretty much a personal thing but is there anything I should be aware of when selecting a combination for a specific carrier.
Or perhaps a better way to put it is, is there any I should stay away from?
I am hoping that there are others on the forums that are also on Rogers and have had the opportunity to "test" different ROM/Radio combinations.
if you've spent literal hours looking up all this info, you would have seen that threads like this are totally forbidden. In before lock.
Please enlighten me. It is not mentioned in the RULES or FAQ's and it did not come up in several searches I did. What did I miss?
I thought the purpose of a forum was to share information. Or is this forum only for those who already know all the answers?
And what do you mean by "in before lock"?
Rick76 said:
Please enlighten me. It is not mentioned in the RULES or FAQ's and it did not come up in several searches I did. What did I miss?
I thought the purpose of a forum was to share information. Or is this forum only for those who already know all the answers?
And what do you mean by "in before lock"?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
In Before Lock: I know pretty much for certain that the mods will lock this one down when they see it.
I don't know what you were searching for but let me give you some examples:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=492664
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=486947
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=486467
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=483319
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=485200
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=485121
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=484618
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=483738
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=483426
Travito said:
In Before Lock: I know pretty much for certain that the mods will lock this one down when they see it.
I don't know what you were searching for but let me give you some examples:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=492664
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=486947
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=486467
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=483319
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=485200
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=485121
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=484618
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=483738
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=483426
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
you are so right brother. oh no cat attack
Travito said:
In Before Lock: I know pretty much for certain that the mods will lock this one down when they see it.
I don't know what you were searching for but let me give you some examples:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=492664
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=486947
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=486467
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=483319
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=485200
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=485121
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=484618
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=483738
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=483426
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Now This is too funny
K, thanks. It's easier just to put my SIM back in my iPhone.
There is an Ultimate Radio thread that will help you with finding a radio for your requirements (check the stickies).
Thread closed as per forum guidelines.
Thanks
Dave
sorry if this has been said before, but it would be easier if there were 2 forums for the 2 different Sapphire types.
edit: added a 10-day poll, enough time for everyone to put their opinion forward
+1 I agree with you.
I agree too!
+1 This would be great. Even if the posts could be tagged 32A or 32B
Agreed!
Save some confusion.
quite agree with you!!
not sure why this is necessary if ROM creators tag their threads with the correct version.
Well they need to tag it at the start, rather than the enb of the title eg.
[32A][ROM][PORT] xxxxxxxx v 4.2.3.1
rather than
[ROM][PORT] xxxxxxxx 32a v4.2.3.1
It makes it much easier to read rather than having it hidden somewhere in the title
Won't be long now and we might get some truly universal roms going.
I know Cyanogen's working towards it.
Until then.. it's not like there's a lot of difference - only two files really.. boot.img and wlan.ko.
If all the rom developers clearly marked their roms as 32a/32b then it wouldn't matter so much.
Radix999 said:
Won't be long now and we might get some truly universal roms going.
I know Cyanogen's working towards it.
Until then.. it's not like there's a lot of difference - only two files really.. boot.img and wlan.ko.
If all the rom developers clearly marked their roms as 32a/32b then it wouldn't matter so much.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Exactly my thoughts. There is a big discussion on this and even if this doesn't happen I can't believe that people are so lazy that they don't read the first post of a thread to distinguish if the ROM is 32A or B!!!
Radix999 said:
Won't be long now and we might get some truly universal roms going.
I know Cyanogen's working towards it.
Until then.. it's not like there's a lot of difference - only two files really.. boot.img and wlan.ko.
If all the rom developers clearly marked their roms as 32a/32b then it wouldn't matter so much.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Exactly and in the meantime if the forums were separated there's the danger one or the other might miss out on something the other is doing. Much better everyone sees everything.
-1
I don't like this idea: many topic are shared among the two models (all is related to the applications!). Now it is already a mess that I'm loosing great topics on the Dream's forums.
In the next future (I hope) there will be many firmware that can works on both the models (even on the Dream): look at the Cyanogen.
The use of the tags is good enoght!
+1 agree
the rooms must be in separate threads, but maybe the apps must be in only one for all Android mobiles.
Is difficult to know now for what version of Magic is a post (no only roms, also related post answering about)
Now I think is too late.. we just have to organize each others better like suggested before...
Do you imagine the work will have a moderator of this forum moving all the threads?
-1
I don't like the idea because I have to post everything twice when I release something for both sapphire's.
I do like the idea of the tagging the threads.
+1 4 tagging
Better tagging will do the job.
Amon_RA said:
-1
I don't like the idea because I have to post everything twice when I release something for both sapphire's.
I do like the idea of the tagging the threads.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
-1
exactly...
i agree because there is no common thing
at314 said:
i agree because there is no common thing
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Almost everything is common.
Better tagging, or rather better reading of the tagging is the answer. Most threads are properly tagged, I think the problem is more to do with people not reading the tags/titles properly.
Paying a bit more attention is the answer.
+1 for the guy that says: WTF, just RTF Topiclines a bit better before whining.
If you can't read 32A or 32B, get your eyes examined
To that end, don't visit the forums while drunk, doped or very sleepy, it'll prevent topics like this ever getting started.
Peace out!
I personally think they should - too easy to pick a ROM from the wrong phone and brick your shiny toy!
At the very least a subforum within the Nexus umbrella
There's like 12 threads about this now.
Sent from my Nexus S using XDA App
I hate to participate and bump this to the top but - enough of these idiotic threads. A 4G subforum is unneeded
tailsthecat3 said:
I hate to participate and bump this to the top but - enough of these idiotic threads. A 4G subforum is unneeded
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's your opinion, which may not reflect that of others!
subthread needed!
I vote FOR a separate thread or subthread...would make it much easier as they are NOT the same phone and require different ROMs.
Is it REALLY REALLY that hard to just put [CDMA] or [NS4G] in front of the ROM that is for the 4G only? Are we really THAT lazy that we need a forum so we don't have to spend 5-10 seconds reading?
I realize that the dev's have been putting something in front, I'm just stating that it's easy and doesn't require a separate section if that standard is followed.
maybe always using tag in thread subject. just for sure..
If the touch pro 2 has separate sections, than the nexus s should and for the same reason which is obvious. Its a no brain-er..
Sent from my Nexus S 4G using XDA App
I'm all for a separate section. Trusting that all posts would contain [NS4G] or [CDMA] is wishfull thinking. Make a separate section and the problem is solved.
It is a different phone after all..
maconu said:
I'm all for a separate section. Trusting that all posts would contain [NS4G] or [CDMA] is wishfull thinking. Make a separate section and the problem is solved.
It is a different phone after all..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+++ 10chars
tailsthecat3 said:
I hate to participate and bump this to the top but - enough of these idiotic threads. A 4G subforum is unneeded
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1 the only section that is different is the Developer forums. Everything else is the same, if anything you'd be losing a large % of the Nexus community to your own forum.
Nexus S: Everybody else except Sprint.
Nexus S 4G: Sprint only.
You do the math. World vs. Sprint 4G
Jeez... its like the civil war all over where they want to have their own territory and break from the union.
It's also even possible that ROMs could have dual support for NS and NS4G. Relax. Just give it time.
We Nexus S users (non-4G) aren't complaining about NS4G ROMs going up on the Developer section. We're one big happy family, stop trying to be special and moving onto your own section where you're going to isolate the community in terms of NS General/NS Q&A/NS Apps&Themes and only have small number of users where you eventually just end up coming back here because your "NS4G" forum doesn't have as much people.
I agree with zephiK.
There should be at least a separate developer forum. Everything else is pretty much the same.
zephiK said:
It's also even possible that ROMs could have dual support for NS and NS4G. Relax. Just give it time.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It is also possible that the sun will rise in the west. So far, it hasn't.
Can you name any roms that work for both? I have yet to find one. Is this just due to radios or is this wimax related? If it's just radios, getting every dev to package them separately seems a logical choice, but unrealistic considering.
Sent from my Nexus S 4G "Lore"
oh for the love of god!!
thats just pure lazynes!!!
go read what the op/rom developer says in the description of the rom.
dont go the lazy rout and just push it on your nexus.
your the problem! not the forum.
your just to lazy to READ!
i really like allot of people here.
but these thing's and such stupid argument's/questions/opinions are what pisses me off.
stop being lazy!
dont like how XDA is? go make your own forum.
JWhipple said:
I personally think they should - too easy to pick a ROM from the wrong phone and brick your shiny toy!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
[KERNEL]Netarchy Nexus for NS + NS4G (15-May-2011) Stable: 1.3.0.12 Testing: 1.3.1
not a rom,but it is a kernel that supports both.
rougegoat said:
It is also possible that the sun will rise in the west. So far, it hasn't.
Can you name any roms that work for both? I have yet to find one. Is this just due to radios or is this wimax related? If it's just radios, getting every dev to package them separately seems a logical choice, but unrealistic considering.
Sent from my Nexus S 4G "Lore"
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
From my standpoint as a relatively newer user, I'd have to agree that separating this into sub-forums would be much easier to follow than the current layout especially on XDA Mobile.
I voted yes but...
I would say the TAG's would make it more searchable/sortable. If the goal of XDA staff is to keep all of us "NexSicans" under one happy roof this would be the fastest and easiest routes.
I have mod/admin experience on another unrelated forum and I can tell you these guys have a big job moderating already, so adding a sub section and finding harmony is not a fast and easy decision. So I can appreciate whatever decision you can all agree on to give your staff some relief.
From the Sprint users point of view, we would feel really welcomed to the family if the current Nexus S forum would also include the 4G title.
Or people could just read. Crazy I know. No subforum needed.
Sent from my Nexus S 4G using XDA Premium App
Yep no need IMO
rougegoat said:
It is also possible that the sun will rise in the west. So far, it hasn't.
Can you name any roms that work for both? I have yet to find one. Is this just due to radios or is this wimax related? If it's just radios, getting every dev to package them separately seems a logical choice, but unrealistic considering.
Sent from my Nexus S 4G "Lore"
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No body has even said the sun will rise in the west. Did I ever say any ROMs are both compatible at this given time? No. Is it possible? Maybe. It's too early to draw conclusions but koush is doing work on getting CM7 to work for the NS4G.
Sorry but regardless of whatever forum you're on for XDA. Flashing a ROM is to the user's responsibility, not the OP. There's no body to blame but yourselves.
I still stick by my point about NS4G and NS. I don't understand why you want to separate the community. The analogy for the "Civil War" about the Union & Confederacy fits perfectly. Don't know why you want to separate apart. It takes a few seconds to read if its a NS and NS4G ROM.