Some people think It's illegal, while others, like myself, believe It's not.....a lot of people seem to confuse flashing a phone with actually stealing something...certainly talking about it isn't illegal...and I'll say it again (XDA), TALKING ABOUT IT ISN'T ILLEGAL..if flashing a phone is illegal, then so isn't rooting a phone, and installing a custom ROM..and if that's the case, then most of the subjects on this forum are talking about doing illegal things...if someone out there has any proof cloning a phone is illegal, then let's see it
Sent from my MikG'd Boost Mobile HTC EVO 4G using XDA
Yes! It's illegal to change the exaust system on your car with another either
I don't know how is it in the USA but i didn't heard anything here in the old republic
chaki- said:
Yes! It's illegal to change the exaust system on your car with another either
I don't know how is it in the USA but i didn't heard anything here in the old republic
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think ur spell check might of changed a few words on u and to me some of what u said made no sense ...sorry
Sent from my MikG'd Boost Mobile HTC EVO 4G using XDA
Cloning is obviously illegal... Unless you're cloning your own phone... Which wouldn't make much sense... Just saying if you clone somone else's phone and incur charges, YOU ARE STEALING, that been illegal since the mid to late 90's (at least in Illinois)
I bought my EVO outright from sprint when I had sprint...I bought my incognito outright from Boost...I pay boost mobile monthly for service, and even though I flashed my EVO myself, I still only get what i pay for, regardless of which phone I use....It's the same for any phone on any carrier...It's not a cable tv descrambler, in which u get more than what ur supposed to get, which is stealing, but a cell phone provider will only give u what u pay for, regardless of phone.....how is that stealing
Sent from my MikG'd Boost Mobile HTC EVO 4G using XDA
Clearly he said "UNLESS YOU ARE CLONING YOUR OWN PHONE." It is illegal when you clone another person's device in order to use their minutes or data as though it were your own.
MissionImprobable said:
Clearly he said "UNLESS YOU ARE CLONING YOUR OWN PHONE." It is illegal when you clone another person's device in order to use their minutes or data as though it were your own.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not clearly cause that's not how he worded it....he said "incur charges", meaning of I cloned someone's phone and they incur charges because of something I did then that's illegal....he did not say if i cloned someone's phone to use there service as my own is illegal
Sent from my MikG'd Boost Mobile HTC EVO 4G using XDA
Ewe knew what he meant. Now play along or be turned into a newt.
mkelsho said:
Some people think It's illegal, while others, like myself, believe It's not.....a lot of people seem to confuse flashing a phone with actually stealing something...certainly talking about it isn't illegal...and I'll say it again (XDA), TALKING ABOUT IT ISN'T ILLEGAL..if flashing a phone is illegal, then so isn't rooting a phone, and installing a custom ROM..and if that's the case, then most of the subjects on this forum are talking about doing illegal things...if someone out there has any proof cloning a phone is illegal, then let's see it
Sent from my MikG'd Boost Mobile HTC EVO 4G using XDA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
http://www.fcc.gov/guides/cell-phone-fraud
Wireless Telephone Protection Act of 1998
And no, talking about it is not illegal. Neither is talking about how to rape someone. But that rightly is not allowed here either.
Oh God, this thread again...
inb4 "if you have nothing to add, don't post", you should seriously use the search button before duplicating a thread on the same topic.
Rooting isn't illegal for the record OP.
As shown cloning phones is illegal and talks about doing it are not allowed on xDA. Only warning. Thread closed
Related
http://www.xda-developers.com/android/it-is-illegal-for-verizon-to-lock-some-bootloaders/
Found this on front page.
STAND UP FOR YOUR RIGHTS!
wimmy wham wham wazzle!
completed.
I hope this does something.
Yeah, I think I will just drop this off here and LOL for a while. XDA should do its homework.
http://www.androidpolice.com/2011/1...-does-not-violate-fcc-block-c-spectrum-rules/
Read all this article before you file anything.....
Edit: post above beat me good show chap.
If I helped you in any way please use the thank you button
voxigenboy said:
wimmy wham wham wazzle!
completed.
I hope this does something.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If it does, I might actually switch to big red. Give me unlimited data!
Filing a petition right nao. My rights will not be infringed upon!!1!
Adrynalyne you don't even understand.... Obviously the XDA post is 100% accurate or they never would've posted it on such a respectable site.
adrynalyne said:
Yeah, I think I will just drop this off here and LOL for a while. XDA should do its homework.
http://www.androidpolice.com/2011/1...-does-not-violate-fcc-block-c-spectrum-rules/
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
jolly good show chap!... ;(
this bloody verizon mumbo jumbo really brasses me off! its a load of bullocks if you ask me.
the kid escobar said:
Filing a petition right nao. My rights will not be infringed upon!!1!
Adrynalyne you don't even understand.... Obviously the XDA post is 100% accurate or they never would've posted it on such a respectable site.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Guess you don't read fine print, Verizon sued FCC then withdrew for unknown reasons,then a clause was found that stated a carrier can do what ever it wishes.
If I helped you in any way please use the thank you button
Grnlantern79 said:
Guess you don't read fine print, Verizon sued FCC then withdrew for unknown reasons,then a clause was found that stated a carrier can do what ever it wishes.
If I helped you in any way please use the thank you button
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
To the link to the android police website that is supposedly contradicting the article I posted,
It does NOT contradict for two reasons:
1)The arguments made in favor of what is "reasonable" for Verizon do not include the actions themselves, only the standards they use. The actions they take according to those standards,(e.g. locking bootloaders)are notr easonable by the same definition. That is, 4 out of 4 carriers use the same standards as Verizon. But not all four carriers lock bootloaders.
2)The issue of Verizon's double-standard concerning bootloaders is entirely ignored. Verizon says they lock bootloaders because it's a threat to network securityand management. However, they do not require the bootloaders locked on all their devices. Samsung's bootloaders are unlocked, including on phones like the Galaxy Nexus. (Remember? The Galaxy Nexus on Verizon was the whole reason we asked about the Droid RAZR's bootloaders in the first place.) So why the double-standard for HTC, Motorola, LG, etc.?
Until THOSE questions are satisfied, there is no error.
Good luck with your complaint then. I'm sure it will go as far as the circular filing cabinet.
But
But we do have a security breach on a locked bootloader. They can duplicate the phone. And still no solutions just denial from Verizon
all I know is, with all the red tape, Verizon is going to continue and get away with their double-standard until they are taken to court and lose.
Wish I would have found this thread before I filed my complaint lol. Oh well here's hoping it leads to something.
im just confused why its only thunderbolt and not other LTE phones?
and please someone dont tell me to read the articles i did, it just talks about the laws/rules/ supposed violations
Pithism said:
im just confused why its only thunderbolt and not other LTE phones?
and please someone dont tell me to read the articles i did, it just talks about the laws/rules/ supposed violations
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't think there's a definite answer as to why the Thunderbolt was the only one locked. but I could guess.
Considering that the Thunderbolt was Verizon's flagship LTE phone, they assumed it would sell well and probably had the same mentality they do now with the RAZR.
well, i think its the only phone that can be on the phone and surf the web on 3g.... any phone with a 4g connection can do that. also, without more people taking this seriously, this wont go far. for those thinking this is a joke, there are always 2 sides of the story. pros and cons can make a difference in the balance. obviously, the rules state they can do what they want within the boundaries...double standards for phones can create an issue with a defense for phone security...also, for those thinking we can have unlimited data....it doesnt state that, if u read the second article that was linked in the first article, they can charge what they want for any amount of data....they just arent suppose to throttle u, deny or limit. u can go over ur data usage, but u just get charged for it...so theres no limit there.... thats my understanding of it though....feel free to correct me
voxigenboy said:
I don't think there's a definite answer as to why the Thunderbolt was the only one locked. but I could guess.
Considering that the Thunderbolt was Verizon's flagship LTE phone, they assumed it would sell well and probably had the same mentality they do now with the RAZR.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So you don't the see the Bionic as locked?
Interesting.
Verizon is smart lock the boot loaders on the most popular phones load some bloatware on them which they sell space as a nice cost which keep 98% of users from deleted since they won't root. As long as the developer of the phone like HTC leaves a backdoor open we the 2% should always been quite happy. Moto just goes that extra step to completely lock it down.
If I helped you in any way please use the thank you button
well gents, I finally got a call from the executive offices of verizon wireless tonight in regards to my complaint with the fcc. all they specified was that they were looking in to the "matter" and for me to call back if I have any questions.
voxigenboy said:
well gents, I finally got a call from the executive offices of verizon wireless tonight in regards to my complaint with the fcc. all they specified was that they were looking in to the "matter" and for me to call back if I have any questions.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Me too just now something about 14 days
Sent from my ADR6400L using xda premium
It has recently come to my attention that a few people are upset at the actions I took to get the threads closed which told you how to change your IMEI number.
The way I understand it is that Changing your IMEI is illegal in most countries. So I asked a mod if this knid of thing was allowed on XDA developers. The moderation team closed the thread, not me. They decided it was not suitable.
So I'm curious to know what the general opinion on this matter is.
And rather than me receive PM's from people making personal attacks I thought it would be better to discuss in public.
Please let me know your thoughts
cjward23 said:
It has recently come to my attention that a few people are upset at the actions I took to get the threads closed which told you how to change your IMEI number.
The way I understand it is that Changing your IMEI is illegal in most countries. So I asked a mod if this knid of thing was allowed on XDA developers. The moderation team closed the thread, not me. They decided it was not suitable.
So I'm curious to know what the general opinion on this matter is.
And rather than me receive PM's from people making personal attacks I thought it would be better to discuss in public.
Please let me know your thoughts
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Share the trick dude!
Sent from my HTC Desire S
hamedunix said:
Share the trick dude!
Sent from my HTC Desire S
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You are asking Cjward to participate in an illegal activity.
IMEIs allows phones to be rendered useless if the phone is reported stolen. Sharing "the trick" of changing IMEIs not only promotes theft of Android phones, but it is illegal in some countries.It would allow the possibility of getting XDA in trouble if such information was posted here and we don't want that.
cjward23 said:
It has recently come to my attention that a few people are upset at the actions I took to get the threads closed which told you how to change your IMEI number.
The way I understand it is that Changing your IMEI is illegal in most countries. So I asked a mod if this knid of thing was allowed on XDA developers. The moderation team closed the thread, not me. They decided it was not suitable.
So I'm curious to know what the general opinion on this matter is.
And rather than me receive PM's from people making personal attacks I thought it would be better to discuss in public.
Please let me know your thoughts
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I guess one of those people would be me. It was not meant as a personal attack. I'll just repost what I said before on another thread so there are no confisions:
Some guy thread about imei unlocking got closed and locked in the general section. This has nothing to do with this rom, but i can't reply there. So here are my thoughts.
The action may be ilegal, but the information itself isn't. You are ultimately responsible for what you do with it.
There are lots of examples throughout History about information limiting for "the good of the people". Usually ends up with book burning.
Another example: I'm pretty sure that in my country it's illegal to record calls without the consent of the other party. The should I take out 2 way call recording from the kernel, and should xda delete all info on this site on how to do it?
What about the google apps we all include in our custom roms? There's a reason CM7 does not include them. It's illegal. Should xda remove all threads and roms that do not comply?
I'm sorry for the rambling, but i enjoy my freedom, and selfrighteous actions like these make my blood go hot.
Peace
Sent from my HTC Desire S using xda premium
After this there were more examples on illegal stuff we do around here. If anyone actually reads the HTC terms of service, pretty much everything we do with sense roms is illegal. The point is, information should not be limited. Here's a drastic example:
The best way to kill someone fast: shoot him on the head.
Am I condoning murder? Will that line be edited bi mods?
Ridiculous example of course, but the line of reasoning is the same.
Peace.
This is not meant to start a flame war, or pose as a personal attack on anyone.
@lowveld
It wasn't you, I received 2 PM's and one of them wasn't very nice.
I'm very intrested to see what the general consensus is on this matter.
Sent from my HTC Vision using Tapatalk
There are quite a few of examples there. Some that are irrelevant, some that you are right (HTC example), but since HTC has not acted on XDA, and most likely have used developer's fixes I assume they are fine with it because they are not making a profit and it is beneficial to them. As for the call recorder one...Well you could just use it legally...I mean I can't see how changing your IMEI is legal in any way.
Cimer said:
There are quite a few of examples there. Some that are irrelevant, some that you are right (HTC example), but since HTC has not acted on XDA, and most likely has used developer's fixes I assume they are fine with it. As for the call recorder one...Well you could just use it legally...I mean I can't see how changing your IMEI is legal in any way.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I would also like to know what effort someone could get from in it legal matters.
When I understand it the right way there is none except the possibility to mask a stolen phone.
Swyped from my Desire S
Don't You think that knowledge of how to do such a "trick" can encourage theft and sale/use of stolen goods? It's like sharing info about how to steal a car and what to do next to make it "legal" again for further sale.
You guys must be really thick to refuse to understand that:
1. It is illegal
2. Wast majority of our community is against it
3. This is xda developers, not xda thieves guild
Please provide links to laws cant find anything about it
Cimer said:
You are asking Cjward to participate in an illegal activity.
IMEIs allows phones to be rendered useless if the phone is reported stolen. Sharing "the trick" of changing IMEIs not only promotes theft of Android phones, but it is illegal in some countries.It would allow the possibility of getting XDA in trouble if such information was posted here and we don't want that.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
sent from my IPhone 8S using time wrap app professional
Cimer said:
There are quite a few of examples there. Some that are irrelevant, some that you are right (HTC example), but since HTC has not acted on XDA, and most likely have used developer's fixes I assume they are fine with it because they are not making a profit and it is beneficial to them. As for the call recorder one...Well you could just use it legally...I mean I can't see how changing your IMEI is legal in any way.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
A few years back I had a Asus P527, windows mobile device. Due to some flashing issues, me and a coupe of dozen other users ended up with the same (default) IMEI. At the time, a service provider from India threatened to cut out service to anyone in that situation. So I figured out how to change the IMEI in that situation, and all was well. But it was still illegal in strict definitions.
But the example is pointless, and the discussion is pointless if you're making points like "HTC has not acted" and "is most likely fine". That does not bear any impact whatsoever on the legality of the action.
And what you find "not relevant" was not meant as a actual real life example, but what in mathematics is referred as "reduction to absurdity". Apply the same set of rules to a different situation with the same premises, and you see the ridicule in the rules themselves.
Cheers
And I'm through with this. Peace.
Nothing more to say ..!!!
lowveld said:
A few years back I had a Asus P527, windows mobile device. Due to some flashing issues, me and a coupe of dozen other users ended up with the same (default) IMEI. At the time, a service provider from India threatened to cut out service to anyone in that situation. So I figured out how to change the IMEI in that situation, and all was well. But it was still illegal in strict definitions.
But the example is pointless, and the discussion is pointless if you're making points like "HTC has not acted" and "is most likely fine". That does not bear any impact whatsoever on the legality of the action.
And what you find "not relevant" was not meant as a actual real life example, but what in mathematics is referred as "reduction to absurdity". Apply the same set of rules to a different situation with the same premises, and you see the ridicule in the rules themselves.
Cheers
And I'm through with this. Peace.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
sent from my IPhone 8S using time wrap app professional
Just mind your own threads next time.
Destroyer
The trick is on my site PERMANENT
Sent from my HTC Desire S using XDA Premium App
hey, cjward did what he thought was correct. DON'T GO AGAINST HIM, JUST BECAUSE HE REPORTED SOMETHING HE FELT WAS WRONG. HE IS, IN ABSOLUTELY NO WAY, AT FAULT. Even though i feel that information should be shared without any problems, and brokenworm's thread shouldn't have been deleted, i feel sad that people are flaming cjward. I completely agree with lowveld.
Got to admit when I first saw this posted, I actually questioned to myself whether or not this would be useful or not.
Unfortunately the reasons I had come up with as to why this could be useful, were not in a lawful manner. I thought about this further, came up with the idea again except expanded but with more self-justification. I've given up on the idea in a whole.
Unfortunately I feel that the information should be there, but the associated information pertaining to the relevant law(s) and legal ramifications boldly displayed with what it obviously should and shouldn't be used for, should said distribution of information.
I have to disagree with the way brokenworm is going about this though, immature in the least.
Technically, good.
Sent from my HTC Desire S using xda premium
Dont flame the proud policeman?
shrome99 said:
hey, cjward did what he thought was correct. DON'T GO AGAINST HIM, JUST BECAUSE HE REPORTED SOMETHING HE FELT WAS WRONG. HE IS, IN ABSOLUTELY NO WAY, AT FAULT. Even though i feel that information should be shared without any problems, and brokenworm's thread shouldn't have been deleted, i feel sad that people are flaming cjward. I completely agree with lowveld.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
sent from my IPhone 8S using time wrap app professional
In my opinion I think it's bad ;( why? Becoz it's 1 of the unique information to identify who owns the phone by looking at the IMEI, so if a thief knows how to do this he can modify the IMEI so no one will know if the phone was stolen.
Just my little opinion peace!
Sent from my HTC Desire S using xda premium
i have a question, probably noobish one but would apreciate any response. what is the benefit of changing the imei? why would we want/need to do it? i guess it's like changing the mac adress of a nic but in this case i know what the benefits are but do not find them relevant in the case of the imei. sorry for the question if it's not apropriate..
xxmorph3u5xx said:
i have a question, probably noobish one but would apreciate any response. what is the benefit of changing the imei? why would we want/need to do it? i guess it's like changing the mac adress of a nic but in this case i know what the benefits are but do not find them relevant in the case of the imei. sorry for the question if it's not apropriate..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Unless you are a theif, drug dealer, pimp, fraudster, terrorist or politician you will probably never have a reason to change your phones IMEI number.
Sent from my HTC Vision using Tapatalk
cjward23 said:
Unless you are a theif, drug dealer, pimp, fraudster, terrorist or politician you will probably never have a reason to change your phones IMEI number.
Sent from my HTC Vision using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you CJ. You hit rock bottom there. I actually considered you an even minded guy, but generalizations like that kind of prove me wrong.
Fu**, I even told you that I had done it before, so in what way is this not a personal attack? Care to tell me what you think I am? Thief? Rapist?
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=579741
I know this is a touchy subject due to the potentially illegal uses of IMEI numbers. Let me be very clear, I want to restore MY original IMEI number. Here is my situation:
Through various ROM flashes I have changed my IMEI number. Kies says my device in unregistered because I have the wrong IMEI. I wanted to try going back to stock since GB is now available without using a custom ROM. I have my device's original IMEI number saved in a document (in case it was ever stolen). I do not have a backup of my original EFS folder, only the IMEI number itself saved in a text document.
Is there any way for me to manually input my devices IMEI number and save it back into my phone?
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=881162
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I897 using XDA App
Thanks for the suggestion. I had already seen this, but since it was talking about setting the values to a "generic" setting I was trying to avoid it. I tried it anyway and it didn't fix the problem. I unrooted the phone and took it to AT&T. The problem ended up being that the APN setting couldn't be accessed and they weren't configured. The rep was able to do a hard reset. Not sure what kind of reset it was though. Not factory. It didn't revert back to Froyo, but it did remove all the apps (to include all google apps) I had to reinstall the market and restart the phone before it would work. Anyway, everything seems to be working fine now. I just wish I could have seen what the rep was doing so I could describe the solution better, but he was on the other side of the counter and didn't seem to want me to see.
IMei Problems in turkey and registration rules
Hi there
I know this will probably yield me a "no its illegal" reply but please hear me out on this. Im a good person!
I moved to turkey 6 months ago to work here as an IT teacher in an international school. I brought with me my lovely HTC HD2 which i had hacked using XDA software to now run andoid (was very pleased with my phone). registered my phone here with my passport. The phone then broke and while trying to fix it I snapped some of the internal data cables...
I have my old HTC wildfire here but cant use it on the GSM network as im only allowed to register 1 phone to my passport every two years!
I know its not technically allowed but i was thinking of changing the imei on my wildfire to that of my broken (but registered) HTC HD2 and was figuring if i got caught for it that they would see that the imei number is in fact registered to me anyway.
I have searched high and low for solutions for this. I found the Iwizard but I think that this was released in 2007 and my phone was released in 2010 so i am presuming that this will not work. also had some problems and questions about using activesync on my windows 7 computer along with presuming that I cant connect an android phone to activesync.
As I said before. Im not tying to commit a crime here but just trying not to go out and spend lots of money (and phones do cost lots of money here) on buying a turkish phone.
if anyone can help then please let me know
my email is [email protected]
cheers..
Thats called cloning. Will not be discussed here as it is illegal in the states and many other places. Check Turkish law, they may not have any laws against it, however you would still be on your own as its not discussed here.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I897 using XDA App
just because something is illegal doesnt mean it is illegal to discuss it. it is called freedom of speech. this guy stated he wish he knew how to clone a phone. if you preface your response with the fact the information is not intended for illegal use, you are not aiding anyone. he is responsible for his own actions. a good example of this is when a group attempted to ban "the anarchists cookbook" , a judge ruled that even though the book detailed how to construct illegal devices it could not be baned. the judge cited the first amendment.
i would never advise anyone to break a law but i would not look down on anyone who seeks information. my point is this: it is illegal to make TNT in your basement but it is not illegal to speak or write about how TNT is made. the op should seek his information on the web elsewhere since xda is not for q and a for phone cloning. there are many web sites that explain cloning and it is not illegal to read or write about this matter.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I897 using XDA App
Uh ya, and in short, its not discussed on XDA. I never trounced on anyone's freedom of speech.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I897 using XDA App
georgiajad said:
just because something is illegal doesnt mean it is illegal to discuss it. it is called freedom of speech. this guy stated he wish he knew how to clone a phone. if you preface your response with the fact the information is not intended for illegal use, you are not aiding anyone. he is responsible for his own actions. a good example of this is when a group attempted to ban "the anarchists cookbook" , a judge ruled that even though the book detailed how to construct illegal devices it could not be baned. the judge cited the first amendment.
i would never advise anyone to break a law but i would not look down on anyone who seeks information. my point is this: it is illegal to make TNT in your basement but it is not illegal to speak or write about how TNT is made. the op should seek his information on the web elsewhere since xda is not for q and a for phone cloning. there are many web sites that explain cloning and it is not illegal to read or write about this matter.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I897 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's not about whether or not it is illegal for the topic to be discussed. If you allow potentially illegal information to be placed on the forum freely then you open the community up to unnecessary scrutiny. There are a lot of people out there that do not like developers helping people alter there mobile devices. Yes it's legal, but it also pisses a lot of companies off. So one way the community protects itself is through self-censorship.
that's right
reply
ConeyKiller said:
Thats called cloning. Will not be discussed here as it is illegal in the states and many other places. Check Turkish law, they may not have any laws against it, however you would still be on your own as its not discussed here.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I897 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
cheers for taking the time to at least explain this. I was under the impression that someone from XDA had previously posted software on here for the very purpose i am describing in my last post (re turkey). I saw a screen capture of the software (iwizard) and it has a picture of a turkish cup of tea on it. I was guessing that XDA had decided to help people in turkey with the the registration issues we have. But after about 1 week of free time spent searching the internet for solutions I am ready to give in and just go out and buy a turkish mobile phone (can sell me blocked one in england next time i go home) .
Cheers and thanks for all the great software I have previously had from the site for my HTC HD2
f
Don't know what happened... but my alert was put into Q&A even though it's not a question.
Sorry, for the cross-posting... but this issue is very important to all of us who care about rooting/modifying our devices. We may soon lose the legal exemption to do that.
UPDATE: I see that xda-dev has an article in its main portal page...
Bumping this until Feb. 10...
when no one will be able to affect the situation...
TRIED the website but it must be having some issues. Thanks Geek for the heads up. What a freakin joke. Utter and total BS. Imagine if the government tried to tell people that they couldn't modify there car? I'll try to find a better link to the petition.
Before everyone gets hyped:
It's a little bit complicated. First off, the Federal Government (namely a member of Congress) would have to care enough to push for a law to be passed. Another thing that could happen is that there could be an Agency regulation that specifically prohibits rooting. However for that to happen, they have to authority to be able to enforce it.
As long as you are not reverse engineering, you are not breaking any U.S. law. This exemption that is expiring only clarified a defense to a law that does not exist, meaning that we specifically stated that rooting was not a crime, while there was no law stating that modification was a crime. It is a very vague, legal gray area. It's a lot like gun laws- things are not settled until they are tried in court.
So hopefully it gets renewed.
finch8423 said:
Before everyone gets hyped:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Too late. Getting hyped is a prerequisite for being a member of xda-dev.
finch8423 said:
It's a little bit complicated. First off, the Federal Government (namely a member of Congress) would have to care enough to push for a law to be passed. Another thing that could happen is that there could be an Agency regulation that specifically prohibits rooting. However for that to happen, they have to authority to be able to enforce it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree that it is complicated. But, according to EFF: Some device manufacturers claim that jailbreaking violates Section 1201 of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA), which carries stiff penalties.there is already such a law. Granted, there has not been a court case, yet, testing that law. But it is on the books.
finch8423 said:
As long as you are not reverse engineering, you are not breaking any U.S. law. This exemption that is expiring only clarified a defense to a law that does not exist, meaning that we specifically stated that rooting was not a crime, while there was no law stating that modification was a crime. It is a very vague, legal gray area. It's a lot like gun laws- things are not settled until they are tried in court.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well, you may wish to read, specifically, about Section 1201 of the DMCA. It is false comfort to think that a law does not exist... it does exist. The wikipedia article on the DMCA has a good discussion. If you are more of a legal geek, then the government provides congressional report 105-796 and a summary on the internet. For information on how institutions of learning can be affected, EDUCAUSE addresses the issue on its site.
finch8423 said:
So hopefully it gets renewed.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The whole point of creating this thread. To help ensure that it is renewed.
A bull****, nothing more. It is my property and I do with it what I want. They can only affect my warrenty. They can only do something if its a carrier branded and you don't buy for full price . Then device is still a carrier property
Sent from my HTC Desire S using xda premium
This country is already broke (not only financially, but also morally -- but that's an entirely different discussion), how will they go about actually enforcing this law? I know that phone companies can gather a lot of information about your phone remotely, but can they tell whether your phone is rooted or not?
I'm not trying to be pompous, so I apologize if I came off like that. I completely agree with you.
They can claim all they want. It's important for everyone to know that if it comes to that, there is no specific law addressing this, only claims under the DMCA.
In my legal opinion, root privileges can hardly be misconstrued as copyright infringement. It's mainly Macintosh that is pushing this though- they claim that jailbreaking is illegal because of the close-source nature of their products (It's also ironic to note that many of the working conditions of their factories would be considered illegal in every country that they sell their products in).
Well macintosh and... recently, ASUS, right? and one other... last summer, but I can't recall who right now.
Let's just say... for sake of argument that carriers sign agreements with manufacturerers (when, in fact, they're different companies)... that require them to deny service to "rooted" devices based on the law... or maybe not the law... but their collective interpretation of the law...
Honestly...
Ndaa, sopa, pipa... Now this???
Dammit my m4 is getting put to use soon isn't it??
Sent from my SGH-T959V using XDA App
^ add ACTA to that list.
Sent from my SGS 4G.
You do realize that google gave us source, and samsung gave us source, and they both stated that "THIS CAN BE USED FOR "ENRICHMENT" OF YOUR PHONE" google android is 100% free. Even if it expired, it wouldn't effect us. Whoever the fool that initially stated that rooting will go away is false.
As ACTA is *****. My country accepted it, **** them
Sent from my HTC Desire S using xda premium
gefilus said:
As ACTA is *****. My country accepted it, **** them
Sent from my HTC Desire S using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Damn... is your town as beautiful in person as it looks in pictures? I had to look it up to see where the hell you lived
Watch profile and will see where I live
Sent from my HTC Desire S using xda premium
airfluip1 said:
You do realize that google gave us source, and samsung gave us source, and they both stated that "THIS CAN BE USED FOR "ENRICHMENT" OF YOUR PHONE" google android is 100% free. Even if it expired, it wouldn't effect us. Whoever the fool that initially stated that rooting will go away is false.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Are you suggesting that EFF doesn't know what the hell they are talking about?
Sent from my SGH-T959V using xda premium
Maybe. Just ask Google.
Sent from my SGH-T959V using xda premium
We might not be talking apples to apples...
I know apple has fought their phones being jail broken. But isn't it the carriers who really have the problem with it? They want to make you buy their network specific phone from them?
They can only put this law if there is one only on devices which are carrier branded. On unlocked or unbramded devices they can't do the ****. It is in my proparty and take you hand of from it, I can do with my device what I want
Sent from my HTC Desire S using xda premium
lumin30 said:
Damn... is your town as beautiful in person as it looks in pictures? I had to look it up to see where the hell you lived
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Mostly and almost the same like in pictures. And ye waterfall is or mark
Sent from my HTC Desire S using xda premium
I only noticed this when trying to use another sim card (even though i unlocked it), the imei is different to the one on the back and the box of the phone, is there anyway for me to restore or get my original imei number back. I suspect that a rom must have corrupted it.
Regards
ghostcaller said:
I only noticed this when trying to use another sim card (even though i unlocked it), the imei is different to the one on the back and the box of the phone, is there anyway for me to restore or get my original imei number back. I suspect that a rom must have corrupted it.
Regards
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did you ever send in your Sensation to HTC for repairs? If HTC replaced your motherboard then that explains why the IMEI is different.
android1234567 said:
Did you ever send in your Sensation to HTC for repairs? If HTC replaced your motherboard then that explains why the IMEI is different.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nope I have never sent it. I have done a check on the current dodgy imei and it says that it is a htc one x rather than a sensation. I would seriously pay someone for sorting this mess!
A ROM did not corrupt it. That just didn't happen.
There are ways to change an IMEI, but don't ask how to do it on XDA. And don't even discuss doing it on XDA.
Changing that number is illegal and XDA does not tolerate discussion of illegal activities. It is a bannable offense on XDA.
Furthermore your IMEI number did not get accidentally changed to a valid number of another device. The amount of coincidence involved there is unfathomable. It's like picking a star in the night sky at random and having it be the one that has abundant ineligent life.
Did you buy this phone from a store? Or did you buy it from a guy in an ally in a transaction that started with "Pssst...hey buddy...you wannt buy a *wink wink* new phone?"
Oh I'm sorry Mr clever, sitting behind your of screen on the other side of the world I never knew you had unseen knowledge of my phone, and the fact that you try and say my phone is stolen a f***king joke and represents an accusing lying mind that you have, I have you know that I purchase my tech brand new, my imei did change keyboard warrior it was due to a dodgy firmware, alot of people have had the same problem I guess it's a f**ked up minded people like you who think everyone's phone is stolen. Ban me if u want I ain't taking **** from a 'law' abiding sheep who has no freedom!
ghostcaller said:
Oh I'm sorry Mr clever, sitting behind your of screen on the other side of the world I never knew you had unseen knowledge of my phone, and the fact that you try and say my phone is stolen a f***king joke and represents an accusing lying mind that you have, I have you know that I purchase my tech brand new, my imei did change keyboard warrior it was due to a dodgy firmware, alot of people have had the same problem I guess it's a f**ked up minded people like you who think everyone's phone is stolen. Ban me if u want I ain't taking **** from a 'law' abiding sheep who has no freedom!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So now you say you know the IMEI changed due to a dodgy firmware? And you know it's that because a lot of people have had the same problem...but earlier you thought it might have been due to a ROM install?
ghostcaller said:
I only noticed this when trying to use another sim card (even though i unlocked it), the imei is different to the one on the back and the box of the phone, is there anyway for me to restore or get my original imei number back. I suspect that a rom must have corrupted it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There appears to be some inconsistency in your story.
If it was so well documented that you knew it was dodgy firmware, how come 12 hours ago you thought it was ROM related? What firmware did you use? Where did you get it? Where is it well documented that this is a regular problem suffered by a lot of people? Can you share these resources?
The fact is that changing the IMEI is a crime. The fact that you seem to still want to do it after being made aware that it a crime doesn't exactly convince me that you're completely trustworthy and on the level here.
Again, discussing IMEI changes is not tolerated on XDA. I just gave you a friendly warning, assuming you didn't know. Buy hey...who am I to get in the way of your little temper tantum if that's what makes you happy?
Skipjacks said:
So now you say you know the IMEI changed due to a dodgy firmware? And you know it's that because a lot of people have had the same problem...but earlier you thought it might have been due to a ROM install?
There appears to be some inconsistency in your story.
If it was so well documented that you knew it was dodgy firmware, how come 12 hours ago you thought it was ROM related? What firmware did you use? Where did you get it? Where is it well documented that this is a regular problem suffered by a lot of people? Can you share these resources?
The fact is that changing the IMEI is a crime. The fact that you seem to still want to do it after being made aware that it a crime doesn't exactly convince me that you're completely trustworthy and on the level here.
Again, discussing IMEI changes is not tolerated on XDA. I just gave you a friendly warning, assuming you didn't know. Buy hey...who am I to get in the way of your little temper tantum if that's what makes you happy?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hey buddy check your PM
Sent from my HTC Sensation using xda premium
---------- Post added at 08:10 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:09 PM ----------
ghostcaller said:
Oh I'm sorry Mr clever, sitting behind your of screen on the other side of the world I never knew you had unseen knowledge of my phone, and the fact that you try and say my phone is stolen a f***king joke and represents an accusing lying mind that you have, I have you know that I purchase my tech brand new, my imei did change keyboard warrior it was due to a dodgy firmware, alot of people have had the same problem I guess it's a f**ked up minded people like you who think everyone's phone is stolen. Ban me if u want I ain't taking **** from a 'law' abiding sheep who has no freedom!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Control your composer :what:
Sent from my HTC Sensation using xda premium
ghostcaller said:
Oh I'm sorry Mr clever, sitting behind your of screen on the other side of the world I never knew you had unseen knowledge of my phone, and the fact that you try and say my phone is stolen a f***king joke and represents an accusing lying mind that you have, I have you know that I purchase my tech brand new, my imei did change keyboard warrior it was due to a dodgy firmware, alot of people have had the same problem I guess it's a f**ked up minded people like you who think everyone's phone is stolen. Ban me if u want I ain't taking **** from a 'law' abiding sheep who has no freedom!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
OK, time to relax. There is no need for this sort of out burst, if you feel action is required please report it, we will handle it.
The instructions you have been given are correct. The changing of IMEI numbers is not allowed on XDA as this information can be used by people who trade in stolen phones. Now i am not saying you are involved in this in any way, but unless you have a backup of your IMEI number, we will be unable to help you here on XDA. Sorry we cannot help you further, but we cannot aide in the breaking of the law.
Thread Closed