[Q] HTC Desire S VS Samsung Galaxy W - General Questions and Answers

I'm looking for a good compact, pocketable droid and I've narrowed my search down to these two
Galaxy W Pros:
Faster CPU
More internal storage
Lighter
BlueTooth 3.0
Slightly better battery (on paper)
Desire S Pros:
More RAM
Existing CyanogenMod support - ensuring ICS upgrade
Autofocus
Veteran, proven model
Slightly cheaper
Your insight would be appreciated

Bump........

Personally, I would by a Desire S because I love the build quality and style. It fits in my hands beautifully and is what I was going to buy myself but instead got the Nexus because it was cheaper.
I have never personally played with the Galaxy W but it does have some pretty good specs. Have you played around with the phones in a shop? I think that is very important part of deciding which device is for you.

-CMX said:
Personally, I would by a Desire S because I love the build quality and style. It fits in my hands beautifully and is what I was going to buy myself but instead got the Nexus because it was cheaper.
I have never personally played with the Galaxy W but it does have some pretty good specs. Have you played around with the phones in a shop? I think that is very important part of deciding which device is for you.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Seeing as both phones have virtually the same measurements, both would probably fit the same in one's hand. The Galaxy is lighter, though, but I don't know about the build quality.
Unfortunately I can't play with the phone since it hasn't arrived in my country yet

Get the Galaxy W. Both are great phones but the Samsung wins hands down IMO.
Sent from my GT-S5830 using Tapatalk

jimbo.levy said:
Get the Galaxy W. Both are great phones but the Samsung wins hands down IMO.
Sent from my GT-S5830 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks, I'm also liking it better as of now
Could you possibly elaborate on why you think it's better ?

Sure can. I like HTC for their UI (Sense) but feel that 3.0+ is crap and somewhat overdone. 2.1 hit the mark for me.
Whilst they both boast very similar specs, the Galaxy W takes things a little further forward.
Samsung are well known for their speedy and reliable hardware whereas HTC are notorious for badly coding their CPUs, ultimately resulting in slower performance.
Build quality is great on both devices and dimensions and weight are very similar.
It's a variety of little things that make me favour the Galaxy W above the Desire S.
Things like the faster processor, better and simpler UI etc.
I'm also a Samsung fan boy at heart =D
I hope that helped =)
Sent from my GT-S5830 using Tapatalk

jimbo.levy said:
Sure can. I like HTC for their UI (Sense) but feel that 3.0+ is crap and somewhat overdone. 2.1 hit the mark for me.
Whilst they both boast very similar specs, the Galaxy W takes things a little further forward.
Samsung are well known for their speedy and reliable hardware whereas HTC are notorious for badly coding their CPUs, ultimately resulting in slower performance.
Build quality is great on both devices and dimensions and weight are very similar.
It's a variety of little things that make me favour the Galaxy W above the Desire S.
Things like the faster processor, better and simpler UI etc.
I'm also a Samsung fan boy at heart =D
I hope that helped =)
Sent from my GT-S5830 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks, I'm also a bit of a Samsung fanboy
Too bad it's not guaranteed to get ICS...

t0x1n said:
Thanks, I'm also a bit of a Samsung fanboy
Too bad it's not guaranteed to get ICS...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It all depends on the market, if many people will opt to buy it they will certainly be many developers who will want to develop for it.
Only time will tell, lets just hope the bootloader doesn't come locked or that someone will find a fast way to unlock it.

In my country,the price of desire s is 1.5x of galaxy w.desire s has the 'premium' feeling

tcchuin said:
In my country,the price of desire s is 1.5x of galaxy w.desire s has the 'premium' feeling
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The question is how justified that feeling is, in terms of real world usage

Update
A couple of new reviews for the phone:
http://www.trustedreviews.com/samsung-galaxy-w-i8150_Mobile-Phone_review
http://www.hardwarezone.com.ph/review-samsung-galaxy-w-i8150-winner-different-way
I wonder what's keeping GSMArena...

Has anyone seen the white one in person? How is it?

i prefer desire s, in my opinion is better.

The Desire S has much better dev support and better build quality. There is already a stable ICS ROM for it and a plethora of different ROM's . I develop for it and have to say there are loads of great ROM's for it

In UK 3 will sell a Galaxy w for £180 a HTC Desire S costs £280. and I still pre fare the Galaxy W.

Related

[Q] Which one would you have?

Very powerful phones these two are:
HTC Sensation for £429.99 on o2
Samsung Galaxy S2 for £439.99 on o2 also.
Well the features are brilliant on both of them, but I'm stuck deciding which one I want to buy.
Well guys can I get opinions on both of them?
Thanks.
I might be biased but I would love the sgs2
Sent from my GT-I9000 using XDA App
Well for £10 less I can get a better resolution, a nicer UI and a better camera! Hmm!
Yeh but its heavy.. Worse battery and not as fast?
Well weight isn't a contributing factor for me and the ROMs are fast enough ain't they?
SGS2 Is the fastest phone available (source - Antutu Benchmark Rankings). Add to that the beautiful Super AMOLED screen and you've got a winner.
I'd definitely suggest the Samsung Galaxy S2. I got my hands on it for a few days and its worth the money
Droid117 said:
Very powerful phones these two are:
HTC Sensation for £429.99 on o2
Samsung Galaxy S2 for £439.99 on o2 also.
Well the features are brilliant on both of them, but I'm stuck deciding which one I want to buy.
Well guys can I get opinions on both of them?
Thanks.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think you are one of them who never can decide because it will "soon" come something even better. Reading all the specs and knows its pros & cons so you can talk against the seller when you are in the phonestore etc .
So my bet is that you will stick to your X8 util Xmas
....But you know what, I´ll do the same ;-)
The Samsung Galaxy S II has the better screen, and from what I've seen it makes better pictures. Also the battery for the SGSII is better: Li-Ion 1650 mAh vs. the Li-Ion 1520 mAh from the HTC Sensation. But the differences are not that great, and the HTC Sense from the Sensation is a great UI, and if you use a custom ROM from LeeDrOiD you can get a greater experience from the Sensation.

What do you think is the Best Android phone?

Hello all, I'm starting this to get opinions of what people think is the best android phone and the reasons they think it's the best. I'm looking to get a new phone and would like other peoples input on what phone is best, since there are a lot of options available. I know everything is an opinion when it comes to a phone. Just say what you think the biggest pros are and the biggest cons are. Admin, If I started this thread in the wrong place apologize!
I've had 3 android phones, all with t mobile. The G1, nexus one and the samsung galaxy s(vibrant). I still have all of them!
Now in my opinion the nexus one has been the best for installing modified ROM'S, With the least amount of issues and ease of unlocking with all hardware working. The downside is the screen size and the flipping power button keeps breaking!
Now my second option is the samsung galaxy s. I like the dimensions of the phone and the screen size is awesome. But with modified kernels and a crappy GPS antenna you still have GPS issues.
So come one come all, leave your input let's see what phone you think is the best on the market today!
Sent from my SGH-T959 using xda premium
Galaxy S2 hands down.
Transmitted from a Galaxy far far away via XDA lightspeed telepathy.
+1
geko95gek said:
Galaxy S2 hands down.
Transmitted from a Galaxy far far away via XDA lightspeed telepathy.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
specially the SGS2 HD version
The Galaxy Nexus.
HTC Wildfire S
I was also thinking on the same lines... tho I think people should be careful as to what their suggesting... I don't think this thread is based on "what phone do you own, hence think is the best "... because I'm sure as **** the Wildfire S is by far not even close to the best android... maybe the best cheap android phone... but definately not the best...
If you think a phone is the best... then why do you think so... you need to have a valid reason...
As far as I'm concerned I want to change phones as well... at the moment the S2 seems to be at the top of the hill... I was sure I would get the galaxy nexus but after seeing the utterly disappointing specs... a crappy camera, no expandable memory, and a TI processor rather than a exenos is just a major letdown...
Tho in the upcoming phones seems the Droid Razr is supposed to be a beast and the S2 HD seems to be awesome... but iit looks like will need to wait a while for them... not to.mention the s2 HD will only be released in Korea...??? :s
Its actually quite strange phones are getting bigger and bigger... they just wont seem to fit in pockets soon... I thought a 4 inch screen is perfect... tho 4.2 is really pushing it... but 4.6... I'm not really into wearing clothes twice my size to be able to fit my damn phone in my pocket
What does anyone suggest based on facts... wait for the nexus... or the S2 HD... or just go for the S2...
Sent from my Motorola Atrix 4G
I've favored HTC phones. I've personally owned the Droid Inc, Inc2, and the moto Droid. I've had my hands on quite a few different ones. I think the Inc Is my favorite . Samsung has good phones, but I like the HTC's better.
XDA App. DInc 2 PoWeReD
Best android phone ever? As an early adopter I'd say the g1, that thing was supported for a looooong time given the average lifespan of android phones, the form factor, while thick, is still one of the coolest to date with android, and I believe you could get it all the way to gingerbread despite being a severely dated device. Next to the HD2 it is my favorite tinkering phone. The best right now, likely the gs2, I don't have much love for the current devices but the hardware on the razr is looking pretty sexy. I have a thing for thin phones. That's why my next device will be a Nokia 800 but that's a story for another thread.
Tl;dr? G1, GS2, razr droid.
For someone like you just get a Galaxy S ii and call it a day.
Sent from my HTC Sensation
I think Galaxy S II, yup! Me too, samsung has good phones, but I like the HTC's better.
AllGamer said:
specially the SGS2 HD version
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1 for sgs 2 hd lte
but i wonder when it release
announce so long adi ><
XeactorZ said:
+1 for sgs 2 hd lte
but i wonder when it release
announce so long adi ><
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think the OP was leaning more towards phones that are available now. Obviously, the way technology and competition works, the best phone will be the one not released yet...
Samsung Galaxy S II
Incredible 2
I know it is only single core phone and doesn't have 4G, but it is a great phone.
good size, verizon, international, supported by cm7
My one!
XeactorZ said:
+1 for sgs 2 hd lte
but i wonder when it release
announce so long adi ><
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+ 1
Tapatalked from my Samsung Galaxy S Plus
DirkGently said:
My one!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Oldskooling it
Galaxy Nexus easy.... duh.... haha
Please thank me if I helped.
well it depends upon what specs you want to have(and brag about).
IMO, there's no such thing as 'best Android phone' because having the 'best' phone is always subjective.
If you want the highest specs on a phone, you can look at the flagship phones.
If you want to be unique, choose a less well-known brand.
If you want to customise, there's plenty.
If you want to have a good-looking UI, SE arc or ray would do
mine.
lol

Samsung Galaxy R Vs HTC Desire S

These appear to be the value phones of today. Basically I'm wondering which one I should buy. I live in the U.K., so prices are more or less the same.
http://vschart.com/compare/samsung-galaxy-r/vs/htc-desire-s
Nice comparison chart for you there, personally I love the galaxy
Dude, what a question ? There's nothing to compare. IMO it's not the same class of smartphones. The only hardware-related advantage of Desire S is aluminum unibody which feels much more solid than our shell but otherwise Galaxy R is better pretty much in everything. U'll buy
Desire S now and after 6 months u'll start to think about something faster.
If the price difference is not that huge...I wouldn't hesitate. I came here from Incredible S which has almost the same specs like Desire S (the same processor, ram....) and difference even in regard to sound quality (during phone calls) is huge. I think that nowadays htc handsets are not that solid like before. My old HTC Legend was a great phone, my newer Incredible S was a plastic crap you could hardly call with.
But do you think Galaxy R will get a stock version of Ice Cream Sandwich like what is being developed for HTC Desire S?
Kazuha Vinland. I don't think, I know Samsung announced this officially two weeks ago. While HTC hasn't confirmed it for any of its single core devices yet
Yeah, I know it'll get ICS, but can you like uninstall that skin they use?
Kazuha Vinland said:
Yeah, I know it'll get ICS, but can you like uninstall that skin they use?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry. I have absolutely no idea. Never thought about it, and I've never taken it into consideration when I was making my decision about purchasing any android phone
if u think about ICS then Galaxy R for sure.
Exactly, I should have mentioned that
Oh well, I guess it's not as horrid as Sense anyway. Thanks guys, I'll opt for the Galaxy R then.
I had a desire before galaxy R. The Htc sense is amazing but the hardware it's faster on the galaxy R. The screen on galaxy is bigger. The only thing the htc is better than the galaxy is on the htc sense. I think your choice should be the galaxy R.
Sent from my GT-I9103 using XDA App
Kazuha Vinland said:
Yeah, I know it'll get ICS, but can you like uninstall that skin they use?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If by "skin" you mean Touchwiz, there are many options.
It can be replaced with "GO Launcher EX", the most popular option.
But Samsung Touchwiz has hardware acceleration, it was built for our device.
The others may be slower for this reason.

Don't know which phone to buy

hello, all
i need a good android smartphone (not to big) with nice camera. This will be my first smartphone, first i was thinking about HTC ONE S, but the mess with processors (s4 changed to s3) made me not to buy it event it was a perfect pretendend - very good camera, not big, powerful. Now i'm thinking about GALAXY S3 it has best specs so far, but I don't know if i will feel comfortable with the size of that phone, because my hands are not big.. As i read some forums about SG3 some people said that he is doesn't worth that money.. what do you think guys ? Is it worth to buy SG3 or better to wait for some new phones appear ?
I would say go for the HTC One X, was worried that the S3 would best it when it was released, I've used both for decent periods of time and i feel the X has a much better user experience
Not too big with nice camera? Maybe Xperia P?
Sent from my LT26i with Tapatalk 2
Samsung galaxy s3 intelligent android phone
Sent from my Samsung Galaxy S3 using xda app-developers app
I went from an HTC Aria to an HTC Inspire 4G, and I can honestly say that you would probably get used to it, whatever the size gap.
Sent from my HTC Sensation using xda premium
Nuf said
Galaxy s3 is very good.
If you're big with camera and specs and everything, there are nothing better phone than SG3. One X is decent too, but is more laggy than SG3 and has less software feature.
If you are OK with bad camera and OK with last year spec, highly recommend GNex. Best phone IMO, especially with Jelly Bean
kajukas said:
hello, all
i need a good android smartphone (not to big) with nice camera. This will be my first smartphone, first i was thinking about HTC ONE S, but the mess with processors (s4 changed to s3) made me not to buy it event it was a perfect pretendend - very good camera, not big, powerful. Now i'm thinking about GALAXY S3 it has best specs so far, but I don't know if i will feel comfortable with the size of that phone, because my hands are not big.. As i read some forums about SG3 some people said that he is doesn't worth that money.. what do you think guys ? Is it worth to buy SG3 or better to wait for some new phones appear ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Why do you want a high-end device for your first smartphone? Then there's no way to improve on it. I would recommend to buy something more moderate. Would also be less expensive in case you brick it. Quadcores don't really do anything for you, they don't really run android any faster in my experience.
I can tell you that it is not very enjoyable to have a larger screen than you prefer. It's a good idea to try a few sizes to narrow down what size fits your taste.
go for a xperia s.cool design and awsm camera.
Sgs3 hands down, so many more pros than cons compared to the HTC one series phones.
Sent from my LG-MS690 using xda premium
ehh
Galaxy S3 is an amazing phone, but if this is your first smart phone, why not go for something cheaper like the Galaxy nexus (another amazing phone) Yeah it doesn't look as nice on a spec sheet, but it comes stock with jellybean now and is overall a very nice phone.

Do you think Nexus 4 would be a good upgrade from the One S?

So with the new announcement of the Nexus 4 and how it will work on T-Mobile's network, I've been wondering if I should sell my One S to buy the Nexus 4? Is anyone else having similar thoughts? I am really interested in the bigger screen, higher resolution, as well as the S4 Pro processor and the 2 GB of ram. The One S has served me well but waiting on an official Jelly Bean release from HTC has been a big pain, though ParanoidAndroid has helped me deal with that. I can't imagine it being supported officially when 4.3 comes out.
Just wondering what everyone else thinks of the Nexus 4 in comparison to our One S.
Sorry, I didn't realize I was posting to the General section. This should belong to the Q&A section. I tried, but I don't know how to delete or move the thread.
I feel bad for messing up.
No worries a mod will move it. But on topic yeah its a great upgrade, it has the best specs on the market right now and it's only £279 I have already decided to upgrade and we can sell are one s on eBay and get the nexus 4 for like £30 on top.
Sent from my HTC One S using xda premium
I'm actually considering the same thing. Allthough the one S is a gorgeous device with good preformance and a wonderfulll build quality. But for this price its a real bargain, and as im on a 2 year contract i doubt the one s will keep up to speed. Plus I'm afraid alot of dev will jump ship aswell (some allready are).
Pro's for getting the Nexus 4 over the one S
- Better screen, this was a mayor lackbuster for the one S
- Newest chipset, allthough the oneS is doing a great job here, there is no denying the power of the s4 pro, and the nexus has a fresh aosp on top of that.
- Huge development community behind it
Con's
- Allthough the nexus has a great camera it doesnt has the same preformance and usability (burst, 0shutterlag, ect.)
- No sense. Yes its bloat, but we can't deny the solid preformance it has nowdays, and if we look at what 4.1 did for the one X i think i rather have a fun Sense ui over a vannila blend aosp nowdays (boring).
- I think i prefer the build quality on the one S, and it looks alot better aswell.
Still with this display, preformance, newest android builds is it hard not to consider it, especially with that price. And the development behind the nexus devices are really tempting too.
I'm buying the LG nexus 4 and selling HTC One S S3 because this phone was garbage. This was my last phone from HTC.
Goodbye HTC (crap), hello Nexus 4!
I like my HOS S4 but I cant resist the S4 Pro chip and the 2 GB of ram. The only con is the lack of an SD slot like the HOS.
Sent from my HTC One S using xda premium
icet69 said:
I like my HOS S4 but I cant resist the S4 Pro chip and the 2 GB of ram. The only con is the lack of an SD slot like the HOS.
Sent from my HTC One S using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I really like the my HOS S4 but I'll sell my One S for about the same price of the Nexus 4.
PS: I don't care about the SD
There is just one "small" problem. It looks like in Italy the phone it will cost probably 549€ or 599€ instead of 349€ like Spain\France\Germany(via play store)...so I won't sell my One S
Vauix said:
I'm actually considering the same thing. Allthough the one S is a gorgeous device with good preformance and a wonderfulll build quality. But for this price its a real bargain, and as im on a 2 year contract i doubt the one s will keep up to speed. Plus I'm afraid alot of dev will jump ship aswell (some allready are).
Pro's for getting the Nexus 4 over the one S
- Better screen, this was a mayor lackbuster for the one S
- Newest chipset, allthough the oneS is doing a great job here, there is no denying the power of the s4 pro, and the nexus has a fresh aosp on top of that.
- Huge development community behind it
Con's
- Allthough the nexus has a great camera it doesnt has the same preformance and usability (burst, 0shutterlag, ect.)
- No sense. Yes its bloat, but we can't deny the solid preformance it has nowdays, and if we look at what 4.1 did for the one X i think i rather have a fun Sense ui over a vannila blend aosp nowdays (boring).
- I think i prefer the build quality on the one S, and it looks alot better aswell.
Still with this display, preformance, newest android builds is it hard not to consider it, especially with that price. And the development behind the nexus devices are really tempting too.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This pretty much sums it up. I wont buy it, as my contact lasts one year
Will probably move to it as well, main reasons are
- nexus phone therefore we get updates as soon as they are released and will be guaranteed to get them
- bigger screen
I love the one s, prefer sense to stock android, will probably have a better camera and it has way more features, prefer Samoled, better design/build etc. but HTC as a company have really let it down with support and slow updates, can't see jb hitting my phone for another 4 weeks or so....
I just need to see reviews of it first and user opinions for the audio, camera and battery life, there are reviews for the optimus g, but lg's software seems to have been very poorly optimised (software/driver optimisation is very important in these areas), although these areas still look very good anyway except the camera.
In theory the battery should be better than the s as the n4 has a next gen battery, more power efficient screen and s4 pro, the adreno 320 is more power efficient than the adreno 225
I'm tempted by it so much too just cause its a new phone lol ... But I really don't like the huge screen and I'd miss my camera too much cause the camera the HOS has is too good .. AND honestly the way it feels and the weight and all that makes me not wanna sell this ... On top of all that I think I actually like sense over stock lol ...and screw LG after the g2x I don't think I'm ever getting over that
Sent from my HTC VLE_U using xda app-developers app
icecicle said:
I'm tempted by it so much too just cause its a new phone lol ... But I really don't like the huge screen and I'd miss my camera too much cause the camera the HOS has is too good .. AND honestly the way it feels and the weight and all that makes me not wanna sell this ... On top of all that I think I actually like sense over stock lol ...and screw LG after the g2x I don't think I'm ever getting over that
Sent from my HTC VLE_U using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wow, are you me? I really do love the camera on the One S and the build quality just feels excellent; the two things that I would say it has over the Nexus 4. I like the cool metal case and just how professional and solid it feel. Like you, I also had the G2x before the One S and felt like they had screwed me over (Crappy drivers, crappy camera, crappy promise of ICS, etc.). I'll have to really see if I trust Google more than I distrust LG on making a good phone...
hippocritical16 said:
I'll have to really see if I trust Google more than I distrust LG on making a good phone...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Lol that right there is what i need to figure out too Lol couldn't have said it better
Sent from my HTC VLE_U using xda app-developers app
Though HTC is not so good at delivering updates, in my opinion it is the most reliable OEM out there. So i won't move to LG or Samsung. My reason is based mostly on build quality, which kida sucks on LG and Samsung when compared to HTC.
Also, i don't really see the point in having the latest gadget. The HOS S4 will still be breathing at least a year from now, the CPU and GPU are strong enough. Plus, i don't really see how a quad core will help me on a mobile phone.
The only Nexus i really miss is the original Nexus One, the HTC Desire's brother.
You do realise that lg have nothing to do with the software? All they have done is made the phone and everything regarding software is handled by Google since it's a nexus phone.
Google said they shipped the lg design team over to Google headquarters in order to work with them very closely on the design and ergonomics of the phone.
Lg make fantastic hardware and a lot of their phones are very good as usual they are let down by the poor support and awful software.
I am really thinking about selling my One S S3 and getting a Nexus 4. I seems to be a very good phone.
.TanTien said:
I am really thinking about selling my One S S3 and getting a Nexus 4. I seems to be a very good phone.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I would definitely agree if you have the One S S3. It would be a significant speed bump and there probably isn't a significant con to the Nexus 4 that the One S doesn't share (non-removable battery, no SD card, etc.). I think the S4 version would be a tougher decision as to whether or not to upgrade to the Nexus 4.
Im getting the Nexus 4 the second I have the funds.
hippocritical16 said:
I would definitely agree if you have the One S S3. It would be a significant speed bump and there probably isn't a significant con to the Nexus 4 that the One S doesn't share (non-removable battery, no SD card, etc.). I think the S4 version would be a tougher decision as to whether or not to upgrade to the Nexus 4.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
But I'm too lazy to find someone who wants to buy it. And I don't want to sell it for under 300€.
Ruwin said:
Though HTC is not so good at delivering updates, in my opinion it is the most reliable OEM out there. So i won't move to LG or Samsung. My reason is based mostly on build quality, which kida sucks on LG and Samsung when compared to HTC.
Also, i don't really see the point in having the latest gadget. The HOS S4 will still be breathing at least a year from now, the CPU and GPU are strong enough. Plus, i don't really see how a quad core will help me on a mobile phone.
The only Nexus i really miss is the original Nexus One, the HTC Desire's brother.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My thoughts exactly although I still have my N1, it will always be the one I never let go.
The speed and performance on this phone is outstanding and well asop has become very boring and old. Sense for me was a very big suprise as its come such a long way and just gets better. For me I'm sticking with my One S.
.TanTien said:
But I'm too lazy to find someone who wants to buy it. And I don't want to sell it for under 300€.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Lol, no way you will get 300 euros for a S3 one S, when you could get a S4 one S for that.
Especially if you have the black model, which has chipping issues.
Only way is if you can find someone around your area who don't have a clue about tech/android stuff.

Categories

Resources