I recently just got rid of my Mytouch 4g, which had HORRIBLE reception with wifi calling. I had the phone replaced 3 times from T-mobile before finally giving up. Does anyone use wifi calling with the G2X on a regular basis? I know with my wife's sidekick 4g, the wifi calling is flawless and is just as clear as talking with a full signal. I am looking at picking up a G2X soon, but am really hesitant since I have NO signal at my house, and am not sure the quality of wifi calling with this phone. Thanks for any input.
I also have horrible reception at my house, so I use wifi calling all the time. I haven't had any issues with it on my G2X, and haven't heard any complaints from people on the other end.
You still have to have a connection to Tmo. If your phone says "no service," the wifi app will not connect. I'm assuming though, that if your wife's phone connects, the G2X should as well. I put off getting an Android phone, until they got wifi calling. I cannot live w/o it lol. Losing the wifi calling is one of my "Top 5 fears of an AT&T takeover."
My first G2X had major issues, and the wifi and wifi calling wouldn't work at all (it said it was connected, but it wasn't). So, if you DO have issues, try getting a replacement.
Good Luck.
Thanks much. That's what I needed to hear.
my wifi calling works fine. Can barely tell the difference between the two. The blue icon turns green when you are using it.
Most important thing is that make sure free wifi calling is included in your plan. Otherwise, 1 hour of wifi calling will subtract 60 mins from your plan. If you have unlimited talk you shouldn't worry.
I just picked it up today, and wifi calling is perfect. Thanks for the input folks.
Related
Ok. I have the G2X from the GS4G.
Does anyone notice really bad wifi calling quality?
When I was on my GS4G, the call quality was awesome. I mean, no problems, fast connection, no jitter.
With the G2X, the jitter is almost unusable.
Should I wait for the 2.3 update to see if that fixes the issue or should I just return the G2X for my old GS4g. The only thing I would miss would be the flash.. I know.. crazy, but I really just use my phone for business and rarely need that much CPU power.
Thoughts?
I use wifi calling in my office since the reception is horrible. I haven't had any issues with call quality, more or less smooth and crystal clear. Not sure what could be causing the jitters with yours.
ALuton said:
I use wifi calling in my office since the reception is horrible. I haven't had any issues with call quality, more or less smooth and crystal clear. Not sure what could be causing the jitters with yours.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm using wifi calling in my office and at home and haven't had any issues with call quality.
ikaden said:
I'm using wifi calling in my office and at home and haven't had any issues with call quality.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
if you are not having problems, what the network type you are using.
A/B/G/N
Are you using a bluetooth,etc,?
Thanks!
I can attest to my wifi calling being poor. The call starts out with good quality then slowly diminishes and either drops me or says my wifi lost connection. It definitely isnt my router and I shouldnt have lost connection... Not sure what the deal is.
Home and offfice are both N, not using a BT headset.
I use Wi-Fi Calling a lot. On the G2, the call quality was good even with a moderate signal. Sitting five feet away from my Netgear N600 n-speed router with 0 dbm the G2X flakes out on Wi-Fi calls. It'll start out great then voices start to drag and muddle and then goes back to great. I don't think it's the Wi-Fi Calling app, I think it's LG's F-d up implementation of Wi-Fi which is causing the signal to fluctuate. The router's bullet proof and the G2 performed flawlessly (as do other telephony devices hanging off the router) so I know it's the phone.
I've had issues with wifi calling as well. static not clear. Turned off the wifi calling and it worked perfect. I'm not high on wifi calling right now
Sent from my LG-P999 using Tapatalk
My experiences with wifi calling have been mixed. Sometimes I get absolutely perfect calling, and other times its completely unusable due to stutters. Based on this and what the rest of you are saying, I'd agree that its LG's wireless drivers that are the problem. The hardware itself seems to be capable, and its not the router, so the software is the only thing left. And if people have been able to use t-mobile's wifi calling app on other phones, that leaves this phone's particular software, ie the stuff LG provided us with, since the wifi calling app is the same throughout the different phones. Hopefully gingerbread or even better cm 7 will fix this.
wifi calling on my g2x is awesome! Way better than what it was on my old blackberry 8900.
Wifi calling was horrible on my SGS 4G, while it's great on my G2x.
Sent from my LG-P999 using XDA App
I'm definitely getting better call quality on my g2x than I did on my mytouch 4g. However, I do occasionally have a problem with the app failing to register on T-Mobile's network. However, a quick restart of wifi and the wifi calling app always seems to rectify the problem.
Sent from my LG-P999 using XDA App
I had the MyTouch 4G, MT4G with CM7, GS4G, and G2X
Here is my experience.
At first I did everything, Linksys, Netgear, Apple Router, N/G/A/ 2.4/5(for the 4g that had that), QOS, WMM, Blah blah blah..
It was never my network.
My phone calls are not short, they can be 1-2 hours long with tech support/customers
MT4G - Jitter.
MT4G(CM7-RC) - Better But Occasional Jitter
GS4G - Almost Perfect, some jitter but we are talking 1 time a day, not 20 times during a call.
G2X - Jitter, similar to the MT4G
Well.. sigh..
Because I used Wifi Calling exclusively when I am in my home office (all carrier have a problem because of the houses around me and a basement Office - (Sprint/VZW/ATT/TMO)), I exchanged my G2X back to my old Galaxy S4g. I loved the G2X but the wifi calling was critical for me. I agree with someone who posted Cm7 might help, but my gut is telling me it is a wonky wifi chip/card, not the wifi application.
I know software will update, but by then I might be getting the HTC sensation and Android will fully support the dual core procs and more improvement time for the wifi calling.
Why I had to return it:
Wifi Calling Bad for me, Had to do a battery pull a couple times, reboots didn't bother me every once in a while, I notice with wifi calling it would many times not release the router, in other works, I would leave my house and even though I was on 4G full bars - I could not complete any calls - Bug in Wifi Calling software?, Battery wasn't by far the worst (i think the thunderbolt has that honor ), but with the galaxy I could go through my 5am-11pm day. Bluetooth not connecting automatically, (I noticed this with an LG Optimus S - Buggy?) I like the touchwiz (shoot me).
I notice that Wifi calling goes south when the screen goes off. Cyanogen includes a program called GANOptimizer which, for Gingerbread, uses a new API to disable wifi power saving.
The built in gingerbread SIP stack also disables wifi power saving on its own, BTW.
My wifi calling is flaky. Sometimes it's great, sometimes it's very poor. I just went ahead and disabled the wifi calling using Titanium Backup Pro.
So I have a perfectly good 4G LTE signal going, data speeds are great and all, but every once in a while it will just stop receiving data. The 4G LTE icon is still there, occasionally I see the upstream arrow flash, but the downstream arrow remains blank. A difference that I see from other people's connectivity issues is that I never once see it switch to 3G/1X when this happens.
One thing to note is that this behavior is not readily apparent until you're doing something real-time network dependent, like streaming audio/video for a considerable duration of time until it cuts you off suddenly.
Between 10 seconds to several minutes after data stops transmitting, it starts working again. Sometimes I get impatient and just toggle between CDMA only/LTE automatic to get 4G LTE working again without having to wait.
Is this a common issue among Charge owners? I noticed the reviewer at Anandtech had a near identical experience (though not always fixable without a reboot for him):
"My only complaint is that every once in a while, the LTE data session sometimes stalls briefly – sometimes for a a few seconds, other times for a few minutes. When that happens, you’ll see the uplink green arrow blink, but no orange downlink arrow. Rebooting the device fixes things."
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
After conversing a bit with him (he also reviewed the Thunderbolt/Revolution), this apparently only happens with the Charge, but he also has faith that Samsung would fix this through software (RIL) or hardware (firmware). Given Samsung's track record with smartphone updates, I'm not so sure they will.
PeterDLai said:
Given Samsung's track record with smartphone updates, I'm not so sure they will.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Considering a month after the phone's launch we already have a Gingerbread leak I think this device will most definitely see support from Samsung. It is a DROID branded phone after all, and Verizon is statistically the best carrier for updates, they do take special care of the "DROID" phones over every other Android handset.
4G is flakey, on both devices that offer it. I have both the Thunderbolt and Charge with me most of the time, and I see all kinds of flakiness on both. It's the network.
It is definitely the network. I had a Thunderbolt before the Charge and it was FAR worse with network connectivity falling off the face of the planet despite having full 3g/4g.
Sent from my SCH-I510 using Tapatalk
I have had the same problem. I usually wait and it comes back in about 30-45 seconds, but it is annoying. It was really bad for a couple of days but has been better the past couple.
I personally haven't had to much issue with 4g dropping out. However people need to keep in mind that LTE is new for both the mfgs & carrier. So it is going to take time to get all these bugs worked out. That said I have to give props to VZW and the mfgs tho because back when they were building out 3G originally you want to talk about issues my lord was it bad.
I have had this issue, with the 3G and the 4G, but I can't say that it's a deal breaker for me, compared to the lousy HSPA+ signal my Vibrant had. It's only ever happened to me at my house, which is right on the edge of LTE coverage, so it switches back and forth a lot. But I have to give the network the benefit of the doubt for right now, it's a brand new network and a brand new device. And the 97% of the time that things work properly, it's so far above and beyond the T-Mobile network I have no regrets about switching.
I called Verizon with the same issue last Friday. Their resolution after a couple of questions was to overnight me a new (certified like-new) Charge and SIM card - the replacement was received on Monday. I haven't had any issues since, but I also stopped seeing the issue after I made the complaint.
Regardless, replacement has been better and locks a GPS signal much quicker. Maybe it's the SIM card?
SAME CRAP HERE!!!!
Sent from my SCH-I510 using XDA App
I tested if I have this behavior using LTE only mode (dial **583 in Phone app) and indeed I do, so this furthers my belief that my issue is not due to something wrong in the hand-off between 4G/3G.
I found out the way to actually change the data modes and tested using EV-DO Rev. A instead of eHRPD (in conjunction with LTE) and also using just CDMA 1X (in conjunction with LTE, essentially disabling 3G), but my issue of dropping data exists. The 4G LTE icon is displayed the entire time when it happens, I just seem to lose connectivity (and all three of the tests in the Phone Info area fail) temporarily. For what it's worth, I'm not moving the phone around at all when this happens.
I think I would actually be more content if when the data connection stalled, my 4G LTE icon just disappeared or if it switched to 3G because then it would make more sense to me (that I may have lost connection to the 4G service and it's attempting to reconnect to either 3G or 4G), but as it stands, all I get is a constant 4G icon with intermittent dropouts. The switch to 3G/1X seems to be the more common issue among 4G smartphone owners, but my (and the reviewer at Anandtech's) issue seems to deal completely within the 4G network, and I've tried every leaked radio to no avail.
The regularity of the dropouts seems kind of random as well; I'm not sure how I can figure out the source of the issue. Does anyone know if there are some logs that I can look into to see if something is happening to my phone at the very instant that I'm having these stalls?
Of course, I'm not discounting the fact that it might completely be on the side of Verizon's network and/or my area in San Diego and has nothing to do with my phone, and I may in a minority of users that actually continuously uses the 4G enough to notice these dropouts, which on average happen once every half hour to hour or so. Sometimes I'm able to stream something for several hours without the stalls, and other times it'll happen frequently within a short time span.
I just got off the phone with tech support for the intermittent data drop problem. After confirming that I was on EE4, and that I had tried doing a factory reset, he is fedexing me a new sim card.
Really hope it works, I love the phone but losing data for 1-2 minutes at a time randomly is pretty lame. Especially since I switched to Verizon for their reputation as the better network.
Racer447 said:
I just got off the phone with tech support for the intermittent data drop problem. After confirming that I was on EE4, and that I had tried doing a factory reset, he is fedexing me a new sim card.
Really hope it works, I love the phone but losing data for 1-2 minutes at a time randomly is pretty lame. Especially since I switched to Verizon for their reputation as the better network.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is your problem the same as mine (data drops all while 4G icon is displayed) or is yours the more common 4G to 3G/1X transition or losing the 4G network icon data drop?
PeterDLai said:
Is your problem the same as mine (data drops all while 4G icon is displayed) or is yours the more common 4G to 3G/1X transition or losing the 4G network icon data drop?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The data will stop. Then the 4g or 3g icon will disappear entirely for a minute. Then it will reconnect at either 4g,3g or 1x, I don't really see a clear pattern, it seems totally random to me.
Is there anyone who's reading this that regularly uses their 4G continuously (i.e. hours) for streaming web content (e.g. radio streams, live video streams, etc.)? If so, do you experience any occasional dropouts or is the 4G connection for you rock solid?
Racer447 said:
The data will stop. Then the 4g or 3g icon will disappear entirely for a minute. Then it will reconnect at either 4g,3g or 1x, I don't really see a clear pattern, it seems totally random to me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
hey, I have exactly the same problem!
same here,lose 4g icon when i use either the mobile hotspot or the tethering option.longest i have been connected was about 15 minutes.
fender22 said:
same here,lose 4g icon when i use either the mobile hotspot or the tethering option.longest i have been connected was about 15 minutes.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Tested on mine and same result.
Edit: Rebooted and it works fine been on it 20+ now, I'll be testing some more
A couple of days ago my SIM card crapped out.
Now that i have a new one my 4G signal has been more consistent and stronger than ever. I live in a fringe area and before the new SIM it would constantly switch between 4 and 3G. Now i go for hours on 4G and it even stays on 4G in places that it would always switch and stay on 3G.
Get a new SIM before getting a new phone.
Sent from my Samsung Droid Charge: Stock EE4
After reading this thread I'm considering switching to either the Thunderbolt or the Revolution, or something else when it comes out...
Anyway, I have experienced this same thing.
The only difference in my situation is that I'm trying to use my LTE internet as a dedicated connection. The setup I'm trying to do is plug my phone into my router and have the router distribute the verizon LTE internet through my apartment. My router currently has the latest version of tomato installed and I compiled my own RNDIS module (modified to work with the charge). Everything works for the first few minutes (15-20), then I notice the 4G icon "stall", then disappear, then reconnect. After the first disconnect and reconnect, the internet connection is very unstable and will disconnect every couple of minutes until I disable and re-enable the internet again... very frustrating.
In the interim, I've been using EasyTether and this works very well. I have streamed hours of 720P video and it works flawless; not one skip or reconnect.
This leads me to believe that it is either one of the following:
The kernel - I'm currently using the PBJT kernel found in the latest version of humble. I'm not sure if the stock rom will provide better stability.
The radio - I currently have the EE4 radio installed, but am very curious to know the stability of the GB radio updates (EP1f, etc.).
Any other ideas would be greatly appreciated!
Thanks!
I've noticed this only at night time when I'm at home. My phone will be on Edge instead of 4G. Data is fine because I'm on wifi but if I turn wifi off, I will have no data and it will not connect to 4G.
I live in an area without 4G LTE, but we do have HSPA+. I have a few iPhones in my house also and they are not, nor have they ever, switched to Edge in this area. So why does HOX keep doing it? Is there something I need to do like turn of LTE or something?
relic120 said:
I've noticed this only at night time when I'm at home. My phone will be on Edge instead of 4G. Data is fine because I'm on wifi but if I turn wifi off, I will have no data and it will not connect to 4G.
I live in an area without 4G LTE, but we do have HSPA+. I have a few iPhones in my house also and they are not, nor have they ever, switched to Edge in this area. So why does HOX keep doing it? Is there something I need to do like turn of LTE or something?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have yet to see mine display anything but 4G, even when my signal is very low
I have run into the same problem as you, and likewise my iphone 4S never went to edge nor had a signal issue where I live. I think i'm going to take my phone back to AT&T and either ask for another phone or a refund. I really like this phone but having no signal at home is unacceptable.
Some of my "android" co-workers have said it may have something to do with the battery profile? Since we don't have root we can't check it but. But something about the phone is thinking "I don't use 4g at night" so it shuts it down to save battery... anyone?
My first HOX would never switch to "E", but always showed "4G", except when it would lose all bars and show a small X. I finally swapped it out yesterday for another one and the new one hasn't lost the signal completely yet, so I'm guessing there are a few bad HOX's out there with buggy radio firmware.
I'd keep swapping out units until you find one with stable cell reception. My new one finally switched to E today, but that's because I'm barricaded in a fortified complex with no cell penetration whatsoever. Seems to be working as expected.
mine does the same. I live in a low reception area and my 4s can hold on to the hspa signal while the one x goes between edge, no service, 4g. Love the phone but I need my phone to work at home.
Folks,
I am curious if anyone else is having some of the issues I've been experiencing. I am not happy with this phone overall. I am having lots of problems with it:
- HotSpot - I originally found a hotspot issue with this phone, that took them a few weeks to resolve. But even after they've resolved it, I have other issues. The biggest is that after some period of time, my laptop will not get data through the phone. I've tried different laptops. The laptop shows that it is still connected to the phone's wifi but no data. The fix is to disconnect the laptop from the hotspot and then reconnect. This is an issue for me as I use this for work to provide customer demos. In order to get to my lab, I need to make 2 VPN hops. (1 into work and then 1 into my lab) When I disconnect and reconnect my laptop the hotspot, I have to go through all of that again. This problem only affects the connected device. So when the laptop stops "working", the phone can send/receive data just fine. If I kick off a speedtest, it looks good.
- GPS issues - The GPS accuracy seems to drift. Lots of times when I am using Waze, it has me in completely different places going in different directions.
- Phone issues - I drop calls often. I believe (but not 100% sure) that this happens when it uses wi-fi calling. (I just turned off wifi calling, so I'll see how it goes)
- Phone issues pt. 2 - Sometimes I get an error message "Mobile network is unavailable" and I cannot make or receive calls. A reboot fixes this.
Been a huge LG phone fan since the G2 (even loved the G4 despite the bootlooping), but this phone makes me want to throw it against the wall
Hello! You may want to turn off the default 5 minutes timeout. I think this is the problem. Check attached screenshots.
Inerent said:
Hello! You may want to turn off the default 5 minutes timeout. I think this is the problem. Check attached screenshots.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's not turning off as I have the timeout set to Never Turns Off.
Thanks
I am having the same issue. People have told me that they tried to call me but phone never rang. It also rang on their end and then went to VM. So people assume that I got a missed call but I didn't.
I also at time show no reception. I would have to go into auto connection to network and then it starts working again.
This is really screwing up my business.
I have the same problem with missing calls (never rings) or I can't make a call. Also, sometimes I can hear the other person clearly but they can't hear me or I sound terrible on their end. However, I have an LG V30 (lurking here because I'm looking to buy a V50) so I don't think it has to do with the phone as much as it's Verizon's coverage. For the last 8+ months this issue has gotten worse in my area. I was thinking it was the phone, but I think it's Verizon.
Edit: Just in case it matters, I'm still on the original grandfathered UDP
I must clarify that this issue only pertains when I am home. For some reason, when I loose Verizon connection because the wifi is being used or a dead spot in my house. The mobile connection won't come back on until I manuallly have to reconnect.
I used to have Verizon fios at home and never had issues before but as soon as i switched to optimum this issue might be because of that.
Outside of my home, I don't have any issues with missed calls.
Sent from my LM-V450 using Tapatalk
No issues whatsoever on Korean models.
I have a Samsung Galaxy Note 8 and live in an area with very poor cellphone reception. I have wi-fi calling turned on but it is as if the phone is ignoring the wi-fi calling setting and keeps trying to connect with the crappy cellphone service.
I have no problems with wired VOIP calling so I thought maybe my wi-fi is the problem. So I went so far as to upgrade my wi-fi to Ubiquiti UniFi access points but that didn't help at all.
I also have the LTE calling option turned on (I'm on Sprint ). In the past I experimented with turning it off and it didn't really help. Besides, I want to leave that on so I can get voice+data when I'm not on wi-fi.
Is there something else I can do to improve my wi-fi call quality? And is there any way to confirm that my calls are actually being placed over wi-fi rather than the weak cell signal I have here? Any suggestions would be appreciated, I moved here a few months ago and I'm going bonkers with the crappy call quality. HELP!