Compare gingerbread or touchwiz 3.0 - Samsung Galaxy S (4G Model)

Sooo which one its better... Gingerbread out touchwiz 3.0
Sent from my SGH-T959V using XDA App

Nextz said:
Sooo which one its better... Gingerbread out touchwiz 3.0
Sent from my SGH-T959V using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Gingerbread is Google OS (2.3 specifically), TouchWiz is an overlay to the OS that Samsung makes.
Can't compare them at all..

I personally like the Gingerbread....both from a design and a UI point of view.

arzan said:
I personally like the Gingerbread....both from a design and a UI point of view.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just so we're clear.. Gingerbread is the OS, TouchWiz is just a skin on top of the OS..

I rather have the pure Gingerbread OS without the Touchwiz overlay

Related

[Launcher] Stock Gingerbread

I didn't see this posted anywhere so figured I would share. Modaco, has released the stock Gingerbread launcher modified for Android 2.2 in the market. Search Modaco and you should see it.
While it lacks the features of ADW and LPP, it's buttery smooth and very fast. The green actually looks pretty good as well IMO. Give it a shot, I think you'll be happily surprised.
Thanks Modaco for the app and Deliberation for the tip!
Works great, thanks for sharing.
I personally have found myself using Enom's custom launcher a lot more lately. Sometimes less is more and this thing is smooth as butter like you said! Thanks for the find and I think I will use this for a while and I was waiting for something like this to use on CM6.1 but couldn't port Enom's over.
It would be nicer if it had the 3d scroll like the stock nexus launcher
Sent from my Nexus One using XDA App
jdmoore81 said:
It would be nicer if it had the 3d scroll like the stock nexus launcher
Sent from my Nexus One using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree however this was just a quick and dirty port. I'm sure within no time there will be custom launchers based on this that will incorporate many other features like 3d scroll.
Has anyone tried pushing the sdk launcher to see what would happen
Sent from my Nexus One using XDA App
The Gingerbread Launcher only has 5 screens by default. Any way to add 2 more screens for a total of 7?

GB 2.3 on a SGS4G?

This person on a Phoenix (Arizona) area Craigslist is claiming he's got a SGS4G on 2.3 Gingerbread.
http://phoenix.craigslist.org/evl/mob/2364273095.html
Is this just a BS screen hack?
Well, the dockbar looks like it has GB icons but the notification bar doesn't. Id say it is themed 2.2.
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA Premium App
he's full of it
BS!! Ask for a screen shot of the Model number, Firmware Version and Baseband Version
I dont think that's legit! I think he's running Shadow's ROM!
chadster214 said:
I dont think that's legit! I think he's running Shadow's ROM!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What rom would give him a 2.3 theme?
Beefvvl said:
BS!! Ask for a screen shot of the Model number, Firmware Version and Baseband Version
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Has anyone asked him yet??
There are convincing-looking (and free) Gingerbread launchers in the marketplace. My Galaxy S 4G has looked like the one in the post, but certainly isn't running 2.3, and I suspect that's what we're seeing. Whether it's deceptive or just a poor understanding of what Gingerbread is -- that's another question.
Hey, it's my first post! Woot woot.
I sent him an email via craigs list asking for pics.. see if he sends some back.
Aint real .. Get awd launcher and gb theme i got it and looks reall tho
Sent from my SGH-T959V using XDA App
Craigslist Poster Response:: said:
The base firmware is 2.2, as I stated it has been modified, I uninstalled the TouchWiz UI and replaced the Froyo launcher with the Gingerbread launcher. I can install a full version of Gingerbread, so the base reads 2.3.
I would be willing to put forth the work, in trading for a G2X.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
He can install the full version? i didn't think this was viable yet...
One problem, the app drawer is not 3D like GB. Isn't GB launcher 3D?
Sent From SGS4G using XDA App
Posting has been deleted by its author apparently
Sent from my SGH-T959V using XDA App
golmar88 said:
One problem, the app drawer is not 3D like GB. Isn't GB launcher 3D?
Sent From SGS4G using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Launcher pro has the 3d launcher. I am running 2.3 on my vibrant right now. With touch wiz 4 . And doesn't have 3d app drawer.
Sent from my GT-I9000 using XDA Premium App
Bl4ckpheniX said:
Launcher pro has the 3d launcher. I am running 2.3 on my vibrant right now. With touch wiz 4 . And doesn't have 3d app drawer.
Sent from my GT-I9000 using XDA Premium App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
True TW 4?? With the gestures and everything? Like where you hold two fingers and tilt to zoom in and out?
golmar88 said:
True TW 4?? With the gestures and everything? Like where you hold two fingers and tilt to zoom in and out?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, true TW 4 for some gestures requires the new hardware that supports multi-touch, and uses the gyrometer for tilt.
It's just TW4 without those features.
Theme
I am making a full GB theme, the problem is that I can't change the fon't colors at the menu because apktool never recompiles framework-res, so I had to keep the same old popup menu. Other than that, it is amazing

[REQ]Old app drawer for GB ROMS

Hello Everybody!
As the tittle says,i'm looking for a flashable zip(if it exists)of thew old app drawer,which is compatible for GB sense ROMs...Is there a flashable.zip,and if not can someone make it???
thank you very much in advance
Do you mean the stock gingerbread launcher? I only have a flashable zip that removes the ADW launcher in CM7 and replaces it by the stock launcher: http://www.mediafire.com/?ru552c3njx7fkf1
I guess the update-script has to be changed in order to remove the sense launcher.
No he means the endless scrolling app drawer on sense 2.0 (froyo) not the paginated one on 2.1 (gb) I don't think you can just have the drawer you'll need to rake the entire Rosie and port it. I seriously doubt a Devs going to do that though. Sorry mate
Sent from my HTC Desire HD using XDA Premium App
Gtj94 said:
No he means the endless scrolling app drawer on sense 2.0 (froyo) not the paginated one on 2.1 (gb) I don't think you can just have the drawer you'll need to rake the entire Rosie and port it. I seriously doubt a Devs going to do that though. Sorry mate
Sent from my HTC Desire HD using XDA Premium App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thank you my friend,at least for your answer!

[Q] Different UI for Nexus S ?

Hey Guyz
i would like to ask if there are other UI's for the Nexus S just like MIUI interface
Because the stock is pretty boring !
There are a lot of roms for NS, starting for CM7 based roms, MIUI, CM9 alpha, and well take a look on the developing section and test the one you want..
Wait a few weeks they're almost done with HTC Sense.
Yeah, and MIUI V4.
Sent from my Nexus S using xda premium
devgee said:
Hey Guyz
i would like to ask if there are other UI's for the Nexus S just like MIUI interface
Because the stock is pretty boring !
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You're saying "UI"... do you mean "Launcher"? Because you don't need a custom rom to change the way the phone looks. There are lots of them on the market, just to name a few I've tested:
-ADWLauncher EX: smoother than regular ADWLauncher, highly customizable, worth the purchase (for me at least, runs great)
-LauncherPro: also very smooth, pretty customizable
-Go Launcher EX: can't say I loved it too much, but also nice looking.
Take your pick. Hope this is what you were searching for, a replacement LAUNCHER, not a replacement ROM.
I don't mean the launchers.
I mean different transitions, icons,statusbar,notification and etc like the full framework has been changed as you see in MIUI Rom
Sent from my Nexus S using xda premium
The MIUI ROM is still based off of Gingerbread and hides it really well. Though most of it is recognizable once you see past the themes and skins.
If you want a list of different ROMs, some of which sport their own framework visit the Nexus S ROM thread
here.
Also as flodb113 pointed out, essentially you are looking for a different launcher. ADWLauncher is a good place to start off if you're not looking to flash a new ROM.
The ADWLauncher contains themes which can change the whole appearance of the UI including: transitions, icons, statusbar, notifications and etc.
But isnt a UI called RoUI available?
Sent from my Nexus S using xda premium
devgee said:
But isnt a UI called RoUI available?
Sent from my Nexus S using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you are referring to this then it only allows you to customize the lockscreen. Which is similar to changing a launcher; no flashing required.
devgee said:
Hey Guyz
i would like to ask if there are other UI's for the Nexus S just like MIUI interface
Because the stock is pretty boring !
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Miui is available for the NS and NS4G, just flash it.
Not sure why you chose the Nexus if you're looking for a flashy interface... The nexus was designed as a vehicle for the bare bones, no frills aosp android experience.

How many people couldn't stand the ics touchwiz?

After using it for a day I just could not accept the tw launcher and had to install ics launcher.
Just wondering if anyone has found the touchwiz launcher useful and if so why?
If you ditched it which launcher did you go to?
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I727 using xda premium
TW ruined the ICS that's all I can say.
Sent from my SGH-T989 using xda premium
It's not a terrible launcher.... Just boring. Not very customize-able. I have and will always use an aftermarket launcher. AdW eX to be exact.
I am using Nova Launcher. I have had no issues with it so far.
Hawkeye9723 said:
I am using Nova Launcher. I have had no issues with it so far.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Even though I dont have ICS yet (****ty Rogers), I definitely agree with hawk
I was looking for a nexus experience but didnt want to get a galaxy nexus.
Thats why i would recommend Nova Launcher, Ive watched enough videos
I'm neutral, just looks like plain old touchwiz to me. Like the one we've always had, And I think we expected that. But with the added multitasking features And other added features its beem a pleasurable experience so far And I'm thourghly enjoying it.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I727 using xda premium
I'm having no issues thanks to cdshepherd. He be the man.
robin48 said:
I'm having no issues thanks to cdshepherd. He be the man.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I just grabbed some AOSP .apks and shoved them into an early alpha #-8 preview of NexusMod ICS...i'm working hard on making this look vanilla
M0D1441 said:
I just grabbed some AOSP .apks and shoved them into an early alpha #-8 preview of NexusMod ICS...i'm working hard on making this look vanilla
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I would definitely love you if you get it vanilla. I hate touchwiz, most useless software ever.
BTW you got any ETA as to when its coming out?
I ditched it for Apex. Much nicer.
I've always used launcher pro, so i'm super used to it. I just have it set up to have an ICS feel to it using this guide. I've had this for a while now, but now I actually have true ics
http://forums.androidcentral.com/wa...o-ice-cream-sandwich-how-updated-10-19-a.html
This is what it turns out to look like. Not too shabby, b/c I don't really like Nova or Apex that much.
M0D1441 said:
I just grabbed some AOSP .apks and shoved them into an early alpha #-8 preview of NexusMod ICS...i'm working hard on making this look vanilla
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeeeaaaaaahhhh buddy! Do your magic MOD!
Sent from SKYROCKET
NexusMod 4.0
Romracer 0.3
Yea, the touch whiz completely ruined ICS for me. I had ICS running on my Inspire 4G before I upgraded to the Skyrocket, which was aosp ICS. I could definitely see all the differences straight away, and was quite underwhelmed by the ICS leak. I think some of the best parts of aosp ICS are missing. I used apex launcher for a while to try to make it a bit better, but in the end, went back to my NexusMod 4 backup.
Looking forward to some vanilla ice cream goodness.
SwiftKeyed from my Skyrocket using XDA Premium
Besides the launcher (which I ditched and bought Nova instead), I don't know what else is TW. I have no experience with ICS till today's flash-fest, so it all seems good to me (minus the TW launcher).
Samsung Skyrocket i727 - ICS Leaked - XDA Premium
M0D1441 said:
I just grabbed some AOSP .apks and shoved them into an early alpha #-8 preview of NexusMod ICS...i'm working hard on making this look vanilla
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think its a race right now between a few of you guys to get an aosp style rom puahed out! I really appreciate your guys' hard work!
I've just recently started looking into rom development myself and if I thought I could help yet id offer but I'm not there yet. Keep us posted on how you're doing! I know I'm watching the dev section like a hawk!
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I727 using xda premium
Face Of Boe said:
Besides the launcher (which I ditched and bought Nova instead), I don't know what else is TW. I have no experience with ICS till today's flash-fest, so it all seems good to me (minus the TW launcher).
Samsung Skyrocket i727 - ICS Leaked - XDA Premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The launcher, app drawer, and settings menu are the biggest changes. Some other little things like icons are changed too though.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I727 using xda premium
+1 fpr apex. I use apex on my galacy nexus and now my skyrocket as well
The thing that annoys me most about TW on ICS is that they got rid of the settings button in the notification pull down. Like... WHAT THE **** SAMSUNG?
ojx said:
The thing that annoys me most about TW on ICS is that they got rid of the settings button in the notification pull down. Like... WHAT THE **** SAMSUNG?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
you actually used that? WTF DUDE
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I727 using Tapatalk
ojx said:
The thing that annoys me most about TW on ICS is that they got rid of the settings button in the notification pull down. Like... WHAT THE **** SAMSUNG?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
They also hobbled the lock screen. AOSP ICS allows for many music players to have controls on the lock screen. Samsung only supports it's own music player to have controls on it's TW lock screen. I just don't get it, why take away features?
On top of that to still not add a widget (since you are forced to use the stock TW music player to have lock screen controls) for the TW music player is just stupid. Makes you wonder how thought out TW is.

Categories

Resources