Variants - LG G7 One Questions & Answers

Can anyone list the model number(s) of the G7 One? Is there only one variant released with the N.A. LTE bands (Canada network)?
I was debating on whether to go looking for one of these to use in the US.
thanks.

Ok, so I see conflicting information out there. One site lists LTE bands 1(2100), 3(1800), 5(850), 7(2600), 8(900), 20(800).
Yet another lists B1 (2100), B12 (700), B13 (700), B17 (700), B2 (1900), B20 (800), B28 (700), B3 (1800), B38 (TDD 2600), B4 (1700/2100 AWS 1), B5 (850), B7 (2600), B8 (900).
Anyone can confirm if there is just one global variant (LMQ910UM) with the 8 US LTE bands in my third sentence?

nate0 said:
Ok, so I see conflicting information out there. One site lists LTE bands 1(2100), 3(1800), 5(850), 7(2600), 8(900), 20(800).
Yet another lists B1 (2100), B12 (700), B13 (700), B17 (700), B2 (1900), B20 (800), B28 (700), B3 (1800), B38 (TDD 2600), B4 (1700/2100 AWS 1), B5 (850), B7 (2600), B8 (900).
Anyone can confirm if there is just one global variant (LMQ910UM) with the 8 US LTE bands in my third sentence?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
When released in 2018 it was released only for the Canadian market and for select carriers as far as I understand now. Seems the (globally) tagged label for this was for North America but marketed only in Canada. Though not specifically sold in the US I am basing knowledge from sources, reviews, and info found on the web and will assume now that it has the necessary LTE bands for my country.
One of the sources in case anyone needs...
I mainly needed to know that this phone would support T-mobile in the US well. From what I know it will, and so I am good on my original question.

nate0 said:
Ok, so I see conflicting information out there. One site lists LTE bands 1(2100), 3(1800), 5(850), 7(2600), 8(900), 20(800).
Yet another lists B1 (2100), B12 (700), B13 (700), B17 (700), B2 (1900), B20 (800), B28 (700), B3 (1800), B38 (TDD 2600), B4 (1700/2100 AWS 1), B5 (850), B7 (2600), B8 (900).
Anyone can confirm if there is just one global variant (LMQ910UM) with the 8 US LTE bands in my third sentence?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
As far as I know, there is only one variant available in North America, that's the LMQ910UM for the US & Canada. And 2 variants for the Asian market specifically in Japan (as the LG X5/X5AO) & South Korea (as the LG Q9 One/LMQ927L). Both asian variants are packed with a 64gb of storage compared with the 32gb of the NA Variant.
Anyways, here are the network bands for the following:
LG G7 One LMQ910UM:
4G LTE: B1 (2100), B2 (1900), B3 (1800), B4 (1700/2100 AWS 1), B5 (850), B7 (2600), B8 (900), B12 (700), B13 (700), B17 (700), B20 (800), B28 (700), B38 (TDD 2600)
3G UMTS: B1 (2100), B2 (1900), B4 (1700/2100 AWS A-F), B5 (850), B8 (900)
2G GSM: B2 (1900), B3 (1800), B5 (850), B8 (900)
LG Q9 One LMQ927L:
4G LTE: B1 (2100), B3 (1800), B5 (850), B7 (2600), B8 (900), B40 (TDD 2300)
3G UMTS: B1 (2100), B2 (1900), B5 (850), B8 (900)
2G GSM: B2 (1900), B3 (1800), B5 (850), B8 (900)
LG X5 X5AO/X5LG10a:
4G LTE: B1 (2100), B2 (1900), B3 (1800), B4 (1700/2100), B5 (850), B7 (2600), B8 (900), B12 (700), B13 (700), B17 (700), B20 (800), B28 (700), B38 (TDD 2600)
3G UMTS: B5 (850), B8 (900), B4 (1700/2100), B2 (1900), B1 (2100)
2G GSM: B2 (1900), B3 (1800), B5 (850), B8 (900)

edwaine said:
As far as I know, there are only one variant available in North America, that's the LMQ910UM for the US & Canada. And 2 variants for the Asian market specifically in Japan (as the LG X5/X5AO) & South Korea (as the LG Q9 One/LMQ927L). Both asian variants are packed with a 64gb of storage compared with the 32gb of the NA Variant.
Anyways, here are the network bands for the following:
LG G7 One LMQ910UM:
4G LTE: B1 (2100), B2 (1900), B3 (1800), B4 (1700/2100 AWS 1), B5 (850), B7 (2600), B8 (900), B12 (700), B13 (700), B17 (700), B20 (800), B28 (700), B38 (TDD 2600)
3G UMTS: B1 (2100), B2 (1900), B4 (1700/2100 AWS A-F), B5 (850), B8 (900)
2G GSM: B2 (1900), B3 (1800), B5 (850), B8 (900)
LG Q9 One LMQ927L:
4G LTE: B1 (2100), B3 (1800), B5 (850), B7 (2600), B8 (900), B40 (TDD 2300)
3G UMTS: B1 (2100), B2 (1900), B5 (850), B8 (900)
2G GSM: B2 (1900), B3 (1800), B5 (850), B8 (900)
LG X5 X5AO:
4G LTE: B1 (2100), B2 (1900), B3 (1800), B4 (1700/2100), B5 (850), B7 (2600), B8 (900), B13 (700), B17 (700), B20 (800), B38 (TDD 2600), B12 (700), B28 (700)
3G UMTS: B5 (850), B8 (900), B4 (1700/2100), B2 (1900), B1 (2100)
2G GSM: B2 (1900), B3 (1800), B5 (850), B8 (900)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Cool thanks brother for also confirming and naming the othe two. I look forward to using one soon.

Technically the name is "LG Android One X5". All A1 phones in Japan follow the "<maker> Android One <model>" naming convention.
And it is 32GB, not 64.

Related

[Q] China/US Compatibility and Usage for Galaxy S6

I'm looking to purchase a Galaxy S6 but I need it to have international compatibility. I will be in China for much of the next two years (Shenzhen and Hong Kong area to be specific) and have done some research into model compatibility. I have found a few models that I like. Here are the models I have found (all the normal S6, not the edge if it matters):
SM-G9200 (Dual Sim, I believe this is the Hong Kong model, but on Amazon it is labeled as International)
Bands:
2G GSM
GSM850, GSM900, DCS1800, PCS1900
2G CDMA
CDMA 800
3G UMTS
B1 (2100), B2 (1900), B5 (850), B8 (900)
3G CDMA
BC0 (800)
3G TD-SCDMA
B34 (2010), B39 (1880)
4G FDD LTE
B1 (2100), B3 (1800), B4 (AWS), B7 (2600), B8 (900), B28 (700)
4G TDD LTE
B38 (2600), B39 (1900), B40 (2300), B41 (2500)
in which B39 is only in domestic support
SM-G920I (Australian and/or Singapore model (not quite sure), lacks all TD-LTE bands except band 40, but much cheaper than the SM-G9200, similar compatibility otherwise)
Bands:
2G GSM
GSM850, GSM900, DCS1800, PCS1900
3G UMTS
B1(2100), B2(1900), B4(AWS), B5(850), B8(900)
4G FDD LTE
B1 (2100MHz), B2 (1900MHz), B3 (1800MHz), B4 (AWS), B5 (850MHz), B7 (2600MHz), B8 (900MHz), B12 (700MHz), B17 (700MHz), B18 (800MHz), B19 (800MHz), B26 (800MHz), B28 (700MHz)
4G TDD LTE
B40 (2300MHz)
SM-G920F (US International model, lacks all TD-LTE bands, but also much cheaper than the SM-G9200, the reason I mention this one is because I've heard LTE isn't that good in China, but I'm not sure, more on that below)
Bands:
2G GSM
GSM850, GSM900, DCS1800, PCS1900
3G UMTS
B1(2100), B2(1900), B5(850), B8(900)
4G FDD LTE
B1(2100), B2(1900), B3(1800), B4(AWS), B5(850), B7(2600), B8(900), B12(700), B17(700), B18(800), B19(800), B20(800), B26(800)
Which phone will work well in China? I know that the SM-G9200 will work great (from what I understand), but will the SM-G920I work well there too? DO I need band 38, 39, and 41? How does the TD-LTE stuff work with China and which bands are used by who? If anyone could provide some clarity on how it works and which providers over in China use what that would be great. Also if I can get some clarity on the 3G and 2G networks that would also be nice.
Overall, I just want the phone to work as it would in America when I get there. If anyone has any experience with the cell tech in China (specifically Hong Kong/ Shenzhen area), please let me know how it works. I have heard it is not that great in some places and good in others but that LTE is expensive. If anyone uses or has used the service over there I would love some help. What carrier do you go to? How is the coverage and what is the best provider? Thanks in advance!

TDD-LTE Band 33 (1900mhz)

So I just recently discovered that TDD-LTE Band 33 is 1900mhz, Same as FDD-LTE Band 2. Do anyone have a device that has TDD-LTE Band 33 in the USA? And if you can switch it over to TDD and see if it will pickup a 4G Signal? Thanks.

Help me add band B28 (700) S6 SM-920FD

Happy New Year to all.
Is possible to open the B28 (700) band in the Galaxy S6 SM-920FD. These are the bands that have default:
*
4G LTE FDD
B1 (2100), B2 (1900), B3 (1800), B4 (AWS), B5 (850), B7 (2600), B8 (900), B12 (700), B17 (700), B18 (800), B19 (800), B20 (800), B26 (800)
I would greatly appreciate your help.

Understanding Cell Service Bands - Does anyone, really?

Hello All,
I have recently been shopping for 3rd party phones to use with T-Mobile, and have been successful with two Xiaomi phones, a Redmi 5 Plus and a Mi Max 2. I also have a T-mobile supplied Samsung Galaxy S7.
The 4G LTE download speeds on the Redmi 5 Plus are consistently much faster than on the Galaxy S7, which I did not expect, and based on what T-Mobile says about the bands they use, what Xiaomi says about the bands available on their devices, and what I found for the Galaxy S7. I have never seen information that is as confusing as this, and becomes more so as I dig in to it more.
The T-Mobile support page for their bands in use is: https://support.t-mobile.com/docs/DOC-4988
The bands for the Xiaomi devices, which I've tried to "map" against the above:
Mi Max 2
GSM 850 / 900 / 1800 / 1900,
UMTS2100 (B1), UMTS1900 (B2), UMTS850 (B5), UMTS900 (B8),
CDMA800 (BC0),
TD-SCDMA2000, TD-SCDMA1900,
LTE2100 (B1), LTE1800 (B3), LTE850 (B5), LTE2600 (B7), LTE900 (B8),
TD-LTE2600 (B38), TD-LTE1900 (B39), TD-LTE2300 (B40), TD-LTE2500 (B41)
Redmi 5 Plus
GSM 850 / 900 / 1800 / 1900
HSDPA 850 / 900 / 1900 / 2100
LTE band 1(2100), 3(1800), 5(850), 40(2300), 41(2500)
Galaxy S7
2G GSM: GSM850, GSM900, dcs1800, pcs1900
3G UMTS: B1 (2100), B2 (1900), B4 (AWS), B5 (850) 3 G TDSCDMA: B34 (2010), B39 (1880)
4G FDD LTE: B1, B3 (1800, 2100), B2 (1900)), B4 (AWS), B5 (850 B18), B7 (2600),
B8 (900), B12 (700), (800), B19 (800), B20, B30 (2300) (800), B29 (700)
4G LTE TDD: B38 (2600), B39 (1900), B40 (2300), B41 (2500)
According to Xiaomi's specs, I am not supposed to have LTE Band 4 on the devices regardless of whether it's FDD or TDD, yet when using the Redmi 5 Plus with the Network Cell Info Lite app, it shows me as being on LTE band 4. The Galaxy consistently shows up on band 12. All checks are being done in the same physical location, my home, so as not to make this any more messy than it already is.
Then add to that the T-Mobile page regarding bands notes band 66, which is described as, "Extension of band 4 on 1700/2100 MHz," which could account for the Redmi being considered on band 4, but Xiaomi does not designate band 4 as falling into these ranges, and use band 1 instead.
I am just curious if there is any site that really pulls this all together in a comprehensible way. Most that I've reviewed are not up to date or contain obvious errors just based on the fact that my Redmi 5 Plus does, indeed, get 4G LTE and a number of sites say it should not, but you can't argue with field testing that shows that it does.
Any insights would be much appreciated.

Phone for US and Colombia

1. I will be living in the US and Colombia in an orphanage. I am currently in the US and my latest phone is a Note 3 and Verizon (CDMA). Colombia doesn't have CDMA. My Verizon Note 3 will work there, but not well. The closest spectrum match from a US carrier AT&T and I like anything in the Note series. I would like the Note 4 because it has a replaceable battery, a back that comes off so I can add a dual SIM adapter, the price, and if it comes up missing, it won't cost much to replace. However, Claro and Movistar are the two most popular networks in the country, and it appears that I see that the Note 4 and Note 5 do not support Movistar's UMTS B4, so it appears that the Note 8 is the only option if I want to support both. I've never been a band expert, so I organized the information below for your comment. The red in the Note 5 and Note 8 show the differences between them and the Note 4.
Colombian Mobile Service Providers
Claro (48%), Movistar(24%), Tigo(18%), remaining 10% are MVNOs of these.
Colombian Bands
GSM (2G) 850, 1900 (PCS) - Claro, Movistar, Tigo
UMTS B2 (1900 PCS) - Claro, Tigo
UMTS B4 (1700/2100 AWS 1) - Movistar
LTE (4G): Band 2/1900 - Movistar
LTE (4G): B4 (1700/2100 AWS 1) - Movistar, Tigo
LTE (4G): B7 (2600) - Claro, Tigo
LTE (4G): Band 38/2600 - DirectTV data
LTE (4G): Future - Colombia will "real soon" (when pigs fly) be auctioning in the 700 range 2x 15MHz blocks (Block A/B12), 2x 10MHz blocks (Block B/B12) and two 2x 5MHz blocks (Blocks C/B12&orB13, and D/B14). A supplementary 2x 2.5MHz block of 1900MHz spectrum will also be auctioned, comprising frequencies in the 1865MHz-1867.5MHz/1945MHz-1947.5MHz bands (Block E/B25).
AT&T Bands (as near as I can find)
https://www.frequencycheck.com/carriers/at-t-united-states
GSM Supported Protocols: GPRS, EDGE
GSM (2G) 850, 1900 (PCS)
UMTS Supported Protocols: UMTS, HSDPA, HSUPA, HSPA+
UMTS (3G) B2 (1900 PCS), B5 (850)
LTE Supported Protocols: LTE, LTE-A
LTE (4G) B2 (1900 PCS), B4 (1700/2100 AWS 1), B5 (850 CLR), B12 (700 ac), B14 (700 public safety), B17 (700 bc), B30 (2300 WCS), B40 (TDD 2300 implementing), B66 (1700 AWS)
Note 4 N910A (AT&T)
https://www.frequencycheck.com/models/GLDb7/samsung-sm-n910a-galaxy-note-4-lte-a-samsung-muscat
GSM Supported Protocols GPRS, EDGE
GSM (2G) 850, 900 (E-GSM), 1800 (DCS), 1900 (PCS)
UMTS (3G) B1 (2100), B2 (1900 PCS), B5 (850), B8 (900 GSM)
UMTS Supported Protocols UMTS, HSDPA, HSUPA, HSPA+
LTE (4G) B2 (1900 PCS), B4 (1700/2100 AWS 1), B5 (850), B7 (2600), B12 (700 bc), B17 (700 bc)
Supported LTE Protocols LTE, LTE-A
Note 5 N920A (AT&T)
https://www.frequencycheck.com/models/A1aaA/samsung-galaxy-note-5-sm-n920a
GSM Supported Protocols GPRS, EDGE
GSM (2G) 850, 900 (E-GSM), 1800 (DCS), 1900 (PCS)
UMTS Supported Protocols UMTS, HSDPA, HSUPA, HSPA+
UMTS (3G) B1 (2100), B2 (1900 PCS), B5 (850), B8 (900 GSM)
LTE Supported Protocols LTE, LTE-A
LTE (4G) B1 (2100), B2 (1900 PCS), B3 (1800 +), B4 (1700/2100 AWS 1), B5 (850), B7 (2600), B7 (2600), B12 (700 ac), B17 (700 bc), B20 (800 DD), B29 (700 de)
Note 8 N950U (AT&T)
https://www.frequencycheck.com/mode...axy-note-8-td-lte-us-sm-n950u1-samsung-baikal
https://www.techwalls.com/samsung-galaxy-note-8-sm-n950-model-number-differences/
GSM Supported Protocols GPRS, EDGE
GSM (2G) 850, 900 (E-GSM), 1800 (DCS), 1900 (PCS)
UMTS Supported Protocols UMTS, HSDPA, HSUPA, HSPA+
UMTS (3G) B1 (2100), B2 (1900 PCS), B4 (1700/2100 AWS 1), B5 (850), B8 (900 GSM)
LTE Supported Protocols LTE, LTE-A
LTE (4G) B1 (2100), B2 (1900 PCS), B3 (1800 +), B4 (1700/2100 AWS 1), B5 (850), B7 (2600), B8 (900), B12 (700 ac), B13 (700 c), B17 (700 bc), B18 (800 Lower), B20 (800 DD), B25 (1900 +), B26 (850 +), B28 (700 APT), B29 (700 de), B30 (2300 WCS), B38 (TD 2600), B39 (TD 1900 +), B40 (TD 2300), B41 (TD 2500)
2. Another entirely different subject is how good the AT&T network is these days? (Southwest Michigan mostly with some rural.) On Verizon pre-paid I'm always connected and get 13.9 down and 9.23 up in the worst part of the day on 3 bars. How well does it do inside buildings as I'm often buried in basements and wire closets with my IT work. Any advice appreciated.
Thanks TONS!!!
IT_Architect said:
1. I will be living in the US and Colombia in an orphanage. I am currently in the US and my latest phone is a Note 3 and Verizon (CDMA). Colombia doesn't have CDMA. My Verizon Note 3 will work there, but not well. The closest spectrum match from a US carrier AT&T and I like anything in the Note series. I would like the Note 4 because it has a replaceable battery, a back that comes off so I can add a dual SIM adapter, the price, and if it comes up missing, it won't cost much to replace. However, Claro and Movistar are the two most popular networks in the country, and it appears that I see that the Note 4 and Note 5 do not support Movistar's UMTS B4, so it appears that the Note 8 is the only option if I want to support both. I've never been a band expert, so I organized the information below for your comment. The red in the Note 5 and Note 8 show the differences between them and the Note 4.
Colombian Mobile Service Providers
Claro (48%), Movistar(24%), Tigo(18%), remaining 10% are MVNOs of these.
Colombian Bands
GSM (2G) 850, 1900 (PCS) - Claro, Movistar, Tigo
UMTS B2 (1900 PCS) - Claro, Tigo
UMTS B4 (1700/2100 AWS 1) - Movistar
LTE (4G): Band 2/1900 - Movistar
LTE (4G): B4 (1700/2100 AWS 1) - Movistar, Tigo
LTE (4G): B7 (2600) - Claro, Tigo
LTE (4G): Band 38/2600 - DirectTV data
LTE (4G): Future - Colombia will "real soon" (when pigs fly) be auctioning in the 700 range 2x 15MHz blocks (Block A/B12), 2x 10MHz blocks (Block B/B12) and two 2x 5MHz blocks (Blocks C/B12&orB13, and D/B14). A supplementary 2x 2.5MHz block of 1900MHz spectrum will also be auctioned, comprising frequencies in the 1865MHz-1867.5MHz/1945MHz-1947.5MHz bands (Block E/B25).
AT&T Bands (as near as I can find)
https://www.frequencycheck.com/carriers/at-t-united-states
GSM Supported Protocols: GPRS, EDGE
GSM (2G) 850, 1900 (PCS)
UMTS Supported Protocols: UMTS, HSDPA, HSUPA, HSPA+
UMTS (3G) B2 (1900 PCS), B5 (850)
LTE Supported Protocols: LTE, LTE-A
LTE (4G) B2 (1900 PCS), B4 (1700/2100 AWS 1), B5 (850 CLR), B12 (700 ac), B14 (700 public safety), B17 (700 bc), B30 (2300 WCS), B40 (TDD 2300 implementing), B66 (1700 AWS)
Note 4 N910A (AT&T)
https://www.frequencycheck.com/models/GLDb7/samsung-sm-n910a-galaxy-note-4-lte-a-samsung-muscat
GSM Supported Protocols GPRS, EDGE
GSM (2G) 850, 900 (E-GSM), 1800 (DCS), 1900 (PCS)
UMTS (3G) B1 (2100), B2 (1900 PCS), B5 (850), B8 (900 GSM)
UMTS Supported Protocols UMTS, HSDPA, HSUPA, HSPA+
LTE (4G) B2 (1900 PCS), B4 (1700/2100 AWS 1), B5 (850), B7 (2600), B12 (700 bc), B17 (700 bc)
Supported LTE Protocols LTE, LTE-A
Note 5 N920A (AT&T)
https://www.frequencycheck.com/models/A1aaA/samsung-galaxy-note-5-sm-n920a
GSM Supported Protocols GPRS, EDGE
GSM (2G) 850, 900 (E-GSM), 1800 (DCS), 1900 (PCS)
UMTS Supported Protocols UMTS, HSDPA, HSUPA, HSPA+
UMTS (3G) B1 (2100), B2 (1900 PCS), B5 (850), B8 (900 GSM)
LTE Supported Protocols LTE, LTE-A
LTE (4G) B1 (2100), B2 (1900 PCS), B3 (1800 +), B4 (1700/2100 AWS 1), B5 (850), B7 (2600), B7 (2600), B12 (700 ac), B17 (700 bc), B20 (800 DD), B29 (700 de)
Note 8 N950U (AT&T)
https://www.frequencycheck.com/mode...axy-note-8-td-lte-us-sm-n950u1-samsung-baikal
https://www.techwalls.com/samsung-galaxy-note-8-sm-n950-model-number-differences/
GSM Supported Protocols GPRS, EDGE
GSM (2G) 850, 900 (E-GSM), 1800 (DCS), 1900 (PCS)
UMTS Supported Protocols UMTS, HSDPA, HSUPA, HSPA+
UMTS (3G) B1 (2100), B2 (1900 PCS), B4 (1700/2100 AWS 1), B5 (850), B8 (900 GSM)
LTE Supported Protocols LTE, LTE-A
LTE (4G) B1 (2100), B2 (1900 PCS), B3 (1800 +), B4 (1700/2100 AWS 1), B5 (850), B7 (2600), B8 (900), B12 (700 ac), B13 (700 c), B17 (700 bc), B18 (800 Lower), B20 (800 DD), B25 (1900 +), B26 (850 +), B28 (700 APT), B29 (700 de), B30 (2300 WCS), B38 (TD 2600), B39 (TD 1900 +), B40 (TD 2300), B41 (TD 2500)
2. Another entirely different subject is how good the AT&T network is these days? (Southwest Michigan mostly with some rural.) On Verizon pre-paid I'm always connected and get 13.9 down and 9.23 up in the worst part of the day on 3 bars. How well does it do inside buildings as I'm often buried in basements and wire closets with my IT work. Any advice appreciated.
Thanks TONS!!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Get an unlocked international model(GSM), then you can use it anywhere, it just requires changing SIM and maybe flashing the firmware from whatever region/carrier you use the device in.
Sent from my LGL84VL using Tapatalk
Droidriven said:
Get an unlocked international model(GSM), then you can use it anywhere, it just requires changing SIM and maybe flashing the firmware from whatever region/carrier you use the device in.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I run across story after story like this https://forums.att.com/t5/Samsung-D...ote4-LTE-on-the-AT-amp-T-network/td-p/4731477 while hawking online forums of the issues people run into attempting just that. In the case of the AT&T phones all use the 32-bit Snapdragon processor and chipset. The international versions that also have the required bands, use the 64-bit Exynos processor and chipset, which would be incompatible with AT&T's firmware. (Qualcomm chip's modem/radio is compatible with many frequencies but only 6 can be enabled at any one time.) Additionally, in approximately 50% of the instances where users buy even seemingly identical phones from Samsung, or from another US GSM carrier that is not an MVNO of the same network, they fail to get the firmware of the new carrier to flash to their phone, and end up swapping phones to one from the new carrier. It seems at very minimum they run into unresolvable VoLTE issues, and often even basic 4G connection issues. These problems seem to be a common only when a US carrier is in the mix. Thus, my thought is the only realistic option is to get a phone from a US GSM carrier like AT&T, that has the bands I need, and use SIMs in it from Colombia. The Note 8 is the earliest of the Note series from AT&T that has all of the bands necessary to cover all three wireless networks in Colombia.
The problem with the Note 4 is it has B4 for LTE, but not UMTS, which is the only UMTS band used by the 2nd largest wireless network in Colombia, Movistar, and reportedly the network business people prefer. I checked coverage maps hoping Movistar had LTE and VoLTE almost everywhere and wouldn't need UMTS. That turned out to be not true. They have a lot of 3G-only areas and 2G-only in a few. I checked coverage maps hoping to see that I could just use Claro. That didn't look too promising either. In fact, it looks like one would not want to cut themselves out of any of the the three. So it's either a used Note 8, or an inexpensive new AT&T phone that can cover all of the bands. If I bought a new AT&T phone with the required bands, it wouldn't be near the phone of a used Note 8, and cost more. So it is looking more and more like an AT&T Note 8, which is too bad, because from every other perspective, I'd far rather have the Note 4, even if it was the same price.
Thanks!
IT_Architect said:
I run across story after story like this https://forums.att.com/t5/Samsung-D...ote4-LTE-on-the-AT-amp-T-network/td-p/4731477 while hawking online forums of the issues people run into attempting just that. In the case of the AT&T phones all use the 32-bit Snapdragon processor and chipset. The international versions that also have the required bands, use the 64-bit Exynos processor and chipset, which would be incompatible with AT&T's firmware. (Qualcomm chip's modem/radio is compatible with many frequencies but only 6 can be enabled at any one time.) Additionally, in approximately 50% of the instances where users buy even seemingly identical phones from Samsung, or from another US GSM carrier that is not an MVNO of the same network, they fail to get the firmware of the new carrier to flash to their phone, and end up swapping phones to one from the new carrier. It seems at very minimum they run into unresolvable VoLTE issues, and often even basic 4G connection issues. These problems seem to be a common only when a US carrier is in the mix. Thus, my thought is the only realistic option is to get a phone from a US GSM carrier like AT&T, that has the bands I need, and use SIMs in it from Colombia. The Note 8 is the earliest of the Note series from AT&T that has all of the bands necessary to cover all three wireless networks in Colombia.
The problem with the Note 4 is it has B4 for LTE, but not UMTS, which is the only UMTS band used by the 2nd largest wireless network in Colombia, Movistar, and reportedly the network business people prefer. I checked coverage maps hoping Movistar had LTE and VoLTE almost everywhere and wouldn't need UMTS. That turned out to be not true. They have a lot of 3G-only areas and 2G-only in a few. I checked coverage maps hoping to see that I could just use Claro. That didn't look too promising either. In fact, it looks like one would not want to cut themselves out of any of the the three. So it's either a used Note 8, or an inexpensive new AT&T phone that can cover all of the bands. If I bought a new AT&T phone with the required bands, it wouldn't be near the phone of a used Note 8, and cost more. So it is looking more and more like an AT&T Note 8, which is too bad, because from every other perspective, I'd far rather have the Note 4, even if it was the same price.
Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You might be able to get the AT&T device of your choice and then flash it with a different modem that has been extracted from a firmware from a different region, flashing just the modem can avoid any incompatibilities between the complete firmware packages, i.e. bootloader, kernel, system differences wouldn't be an issue because those aren't being modified.
Sent from my LGL84VL using Tapatalk
Droidriven said:
You might be able to get the AT&T device of your choice and then flash it with a different modem that has been extracted from a firmware from a different region, flashing just the modem can avoid any incompatibilities between the complete firmware packages, i.e. bootloader, kernel, system differences wouldn't be an issue because those aren't being modified. Sent from my LGL84VL using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I like the idea if I can find one that that uses the same processor and it can be done without tripping KNOX. My thought is I would be safer with Samsung Pay than a real credit card...when they get around to implementing it there. LOL!
Something I wish they would do is implement a method to reset KNOX and return it to an exact factory image.
IT_Architect said:
I like the idea if I can find one that that uses the same processor and it can be done without tripping KNOX. My thought is I would be safer with Samsung Pay than a real credit card...when they get around to implementing it there. LOL!
Something I wish they would do is implement a method to reset KNOX and return it to an exact factory image.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Flashing a stock modem from a firmware for a device that is the same model but from a different region, won't trip Knox, that I know of. Its a stock file so it should pass all security and signature checks by the bootloader/kernel.
Sent from my LGL84VL using Tapatalk
I believe in order to not trigger KNOX, I would have to flash the entire firmware because the modems and bootloaders require the ROM to be of the same firmware. If I do that, I will have a carrier problem. If I don't do that, I would have a KNOX problem.
IT_Architect said:
I believe in order to not trigger KNOX, I would have to flash the entire firmware because the modems and bootloaders require the ROM to be of the same firmware. If I do that, I will have a carrier problem. If I don't do that, I would have a KNOX problem.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, flashing a modem from a different region's firmware for THE SAME MODEL NUMBER device to use the device on a different carrier/region is a very common thing, bootloader and ROM differences aren't an issue, that I know of. If the model numbers on the devices are the same, you can mix and match the firmwares and their parts, certain things might not work as they should, though, but that's more carrier related than it is hardware/software related.
What you're saying would probably happen if you flashed a modem from A DIFFERENT MODEL NUMBER device.
But, I could be wrong, I'm almost sure that I'm not though. I've seen different modems used many times, even done it myself on a few devices.
Sent from my LGL84VL using Tapatalk
Droidriven said:
No, flashing a modem from a different region's firmware for THE SAME MODEL NUMBER device to use the devive on a different carrier/region is a very common thing, bootloader and ROM differences aren't an issue, that I know of. If the model numbers on the devices are the same, you can mix and match the firmwares and their parts, certain things might not work as they should, though, but that's more carrier related than it is hardware/software related. What you're saying would probably happen if you flashed a modem from A DIFFERENT MODEL NUMBER device.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Got it! I just went looking for what you suggested. Using FrequencyCheck.com, I learned there isn't a modem combination that works in the Note 4 line, nor Note 5. Grrr!
Claro (think Verizon) and Tigo(think Altel) are no problem with their 3G UMTS on B2. The stickler turns out to be Movistar(think AT&T), Colombia's second largest, and most advanced carrier, because their 3G UMTS is on B4. Movistar has VoLTE everywhere they have LTE, but there is plenty of 3G-only between cities. It isn't a good idea to cut yourself out of any of the three. It would be a stretch to give up Tigo, whose claim to fame is to service pockets the other two don't, and you might end up living. However, Movistar could very easily turn out to be the only one capable of usable data in your area.
I hate so say it, but it looks like there will be an AT&T Note 8 with its not-easily-replaceable-battery in my near future.
IT_Architect said:
Got it! I just went looking for what you suggested. Using FrequencyCheck.com, I learned there isn't a modem combination that works in the Note 4 line, nor Note 5. Grrr!
Claro (think Verizon) and Tigo(think Altel) are no problem with their 3G UMTS on B2. The stickler turns out to be Movistar(think AT&T), Colombia's second largest, and most advanced carrier, because their 3G UMTS is on B4. Movistar has VoLTE everywhere they have LTE, but there is plenty of 3G-only between cities. It isn't a good idea to cut yourself out of any of the three. It would be a stretch to give up Tigo, whose claim to fame is to service pockets the other two don't. Movistar could very easily turn out to be the only one capable of usable data in your area.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm not familiar with your region, the carriers in that region or which devices would have what support or not. I was just offering commonly used solutions for switching carrier/region.
Maybe someone else can provide more specific info for your particular scenario.
Sent from my LGL84VL using Tapatalk
You've done a FABULOUS job helping me. Because the stars didn't align isn't anything either of us could have predicted. Figuring out what won't work is part of figuring out what will. :laugh:
IT_Architect said:
Got it! I just went looking for what you suggested. Using FrequencyCheck.com, I learned there isn't a modem combination that works in the Note 4 line, nor Note 5. Grrr!
Claro (think Verizon) and Tigo(think Altel) are no problem with their 3G UMTS on B2. The stickler turns out to be Movistar(think AT&T), Colombia's second largest, and most advanced carrier, because their 3G UMTS is on B4. Movistar has VoLTE everywhere they have LTE, but there is plenty of 3G-only between cities. It isn't a good idea to cut yourself out of any of the three. It would be a stretch to give up Tigo, whose claim to fame is to service pockets the other two don't, and you might end up living. However, Movistar could very easily turn out to be the only one capable of usable data in your area.
I hate so say it, but it looks like there will be an AT&T Note 8 with its not-easily-replaceable-battery in my near future.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'd start digging a little deeper and look at other Samsung model numbers with the exact same hardware, i.e. same CPU and same radio. If you find other models with the same hardware, you might find one out of the bunch that has a modem that you can use. It will be tricky, but, if there are enough devices that match, the better the chances of one of them having a modem that is compatible with your hardware and region/carrier.
It would require some intense and in depth comparison of all the minutia of details at the software level, comparing bootloader and modems to find a firmware that has a modem that is compatible with your bootloader and hardware at the bootloader/kernel/coding level. In some cases, a modem can be made compatible by modifying the bootloader from your firmware thrn flashing the bootloader to allow the modem to flash or by modifying the modem to make it compatible with your stock bootloader(or the modified bootloader) before flashing.
It's tricky, but can be done. And it doesn't cause a Knox issue as long as the files are signed correctly. It's risky, modified bootloaders and modems can hardbrick devices, but if modified correctly, it usually works.
I don't have the knowledge to make those kinds of modifications but others here have done things at that level. Members here use modified stock ROMs, stock kernels, bootloader and modems more than you'd think. In a lot of cases, this is the only kind of modifications that Samsung devices with locked bootloaders have the option to use.
Then again, it would probably be much less hassle to buy a device that you can confirm is viable for what you need.
Sent from my LGL84VL using Tapatalk
Droidriven said:
Then again, it would probably be much less hassle to buy a device that you can confirm is viable for what you need.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is what I've summarized based on what I've learned.
U.S. lay of the land:
- AT&T is the GSM network in the U.S. most likely to be able to service you satisfactorily.
- AT&T as a rule does not work with carrier unlocked U.S. or international phones from a practical standpoint. Even IF you manage to get it to work somewhat with their network, you will have at least these service issues:
1) AT&T will not do carrier aggregation therefore maximum download is around 17mbps and upload is around 6mbps while with an AT&T branded phone download is 82mbps and upload is 44mbps.
2) AT&T will not provision LTE advanced features such as VoLTE, Wi-Fi calling, or advanced messaging.
3) AT&T will not recognize the IMEI in order to push secondary LTE bands which in turn also throttles bandwidth.
- AT&T works grudgingly, with T-Mobile phones. Government edict forced them support B12 as well as their B17 (a subset of B12) to be interoperable with T-Mobile. If you go with the T-Mobile phone to pickup the new B71 600 band, you lose out on the AT&T B17 range of B12, which is well managed by AT&T.
- The U.S. Unlocked Note 9 SM-N960UZBAXAA (128GB) is the best of all worlds. It has the SnapDragon, all of the AT&T bands and T-Mobile bands for the current and foreseeable future, AND all of the Colombian band for the current and foreseeable future, AND all of the CDMA bands for Verizon and Sprint. It is in most cases less expensive than the carrier versions. The problem, as mentioned, is getting it to work well with AT&T. I would guess the same situation exists with other carriers as well, and that it would require legislation, like they did with cable companies, to change that.
Summary:
- I need to pick an AT&T branded phone, and get it unlocked in order to work in the U.S.
- The phone needs to be able to also do the Colombian bands.
Colombian Bands
GSM (2G) 850, 1900 (PCS) - Claro, Movistar, Tigo
UMTS (3G) B2 (1900 PCS) - Claro, Tigo
UMTS (3G) B4 (1700/2100 AWS 1) - Movistar
LTE (4G): Band 2/1900 - Movistar
LTE (4G): B4 (1700/2100 AWS 1) - Movistar, Tigo
LTE (4G): B7 (2600) - Claro, Tigo
LTE (4G): Band 38/2600 - DirectTV data
LTE (4G): Future - Colombia will "real soon" (when pigs fly) be auctioning in the 700 range 2x 15MHz blocks (Block A/B12), 2x 10MHz blocks (Block B/B12) and two 2x 5MHz blocks (Blocks C/B12&orB13, and D/B14). A supplementary 2x 2.5MHz block of 1900MHz spectrum will also be auctioned, comprising frequencies in the 1865MHz-1867.5MHz/1945MHz-1947.5MHz bands (Block E/B25).
AT&T Bands
https://www.frequencycheck.com/carriers/at-t-united-states
GSM Supported Protocols: GPRS, EDGE
GSM (2G) 850, 1900 (PCS)
UMTS Supported Protocols: UMTS, HSDPA, HSUPA, HSPA+
UMTS (3G) B2 (1900 PCS), B5 (850)
LTE Supported Protocols: LTE, LTE-A
LTE (4G) B2 (1900 PCS), B4 (1700/2100 AWS 1), B5 (850 CLR), B12 (700 abc), B14 (700 public safety), B17 (700 bc), B30 (2300 WCS), B40 (TDD 2300 implementing), B66 (1700 AWS)
Note 4 N910A (AT&T) - Note 4, by far my favorite, and Note 5 fail because they do not support Movistar's UMTS (3G) B4[/B]
https://www.frequencycheck.com/models/GLDb7/samsung-sm-n910a-galaxy-note-4-lte-a-samsung-muscat
GSM Supported Protocols GPRS, EDGE
GSM (2G) 850, 900 (E-GSM), 1800 (DCS), 1900 (PCS)
UMTS Supported Protocols UMTS, HSDPA, HSUPA, HSPA+
UMTS (3G) B1 (2100), B2 (1900 PCS), B5 (850), B8 (900 GSM)
LTE (4G) B2 (1900 PCS), B4 (1700/2100 AWS 1), B5 (850), B7 (2600), B12 (700 abc), B17 (700 bc), B29 (700 de),
Supported LTE Protocols LTE, LTE-A
Note 8 N950U (AT&T) - Note 8 & 9 support all bands for all three Colombian carriers current, and the proposed bands
*Differences between Note 8 and Note 4 are highlighted in red.
Note 9 adds B66/AWS-3 which is used by U.S. T-Mobile's 4G, but not T-Mobile's new B71 (600) that they are rapidly deploying. That is only available on the T-Mobile model.
*Differences between Note 9 and Note 4 and 8 are highlighted in blue.
https://www.frequencycheck.com/mode...axy-note-8-td-lte-us-sm-n950u1-samsung-baikal
https://www.techwalls.com/samsung-galaxy-note-8-sm-n950-model-number-differences/
GSM Supported Protocols GPRS, EDGE
GSM (2G) 850, 900 (E-GSM), 1800 (DCS), 1900 (PCS)
UMTS Supported Protocols UMTS, HSDPA, HSUPA, HSPA+
UMTS (3G) B1 (2100), B2 (1900 PCS), B4 (1700/2100 AWS 1), B5 (850), B8 (900 GSM)
TD-SCDMA (3G): B34(2010), B39(1880)
LTE Supported Protocols LTE, LTE-A
LTE (4G) B1 (2100), B2 (1900 PCS), B3 (1800 +), B4 (1700/2100 AWS 1), B5 (850), B7 (2600), B8 (900), B12 (700 ac), B13 (700 c), B17 (700 bc), B18 (800 Lower), B20 (800 DD), B25 (1900 +), B26 (850 +), B28 (700 APT), B29 (700 de), B30 (2300 WCS), B38 (TD 2600), B39 (TD 1900 +), B40 (TD 2300), B41 (TD 2500), B66/AWS-3
Summary
I can come up with other phones that will straddle the fence, and some are quite inexpensive. However, if I want a Note, I can't go less than the Note 8 to do it.
Thanks for all of your help!

Categories

Resources