Database Info

Most up to date rooting method for HTC A9?

Hi, I rooted my a9 back in May right around when 6.0.1 came out. Long story short, my device just gave up the ghost after a nasty interaction between the screen and concrete, so now I have a new device being shipped tomorrow. I figured the first thing I'll do is let it run any updates / OTAs it might have to get it up to date then attempt to root again.
I've been looking around for the past several hours trying to determine what the correct rooting method might be now given Nougat's rollout, but I haven't come across anything truly definitive yet. If anyone could enlighten me on what I'll need to do now to root this new version I'd be very appreciative.
Thanks in advance guys!

Just got the phone today and updated to 7.0 (software version 2.18.651.2) Still searching around and not seeing a definitive answer on whether or not the old method for rooting works for this or not. I'm hesitant to attempt it without knowing, so any advice would be greatly appreciated.
Last time I rooted, I used Windroid toolkid to unlock the bootloader, flash TWRP and apply SU. I'm wondering, would the same program work if I replaced the recovery.img file in the Data folder with the TWRP 3.0.3 unofficial recovery I saw floating around in here for nougat?

txag2011 said:
Just got the phone today and updated to 7.0 (software version 2.18.651.2) Still searching around and not seeing a definitive answer on whether or not the old method for rooting works for this or not. I'm hesitant to attempt it without knowing, so any advice would be greatly appreciated.
Last time I rooted, I used Windroid toolkid to unlock the bootloader, flash TWRP and apply SU. I'm wondering, would the same program work if I replaced the recovery.img file in the Data folder with the TWRP 3.0.3 unofficial recovery I saw floating around in here for nougat?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can unlock it on the HTCDEV website, although if you've already got it unlocked I doubt you need to do it again. To root I just ADB fastboot flashed TWRP 3.0.3-4, then used that to flash Magisk, mounting system read only. I'm fairly sure some people are using Su on Nougat, so it'll probably work.
Never used the Windroid toolkit so I can't comment on that, but I've also never minded typing commands to the prompt. I'd imagine if you gave it the right TWRP it'd flash it OK..

JohnRogers23 said:
You can unlock it on the HTCDEV website, although if you've already got it unlocked I doubt you need to do it again. To root I just ADB fastboot flashed TWRP 3.0.3-4, then used that to flash Magisk, mounting system read only. I'm fairly sure some people are using Su on Nougat, so it'll probably work.
Never used the Windroid toolkit so I can't comment on that, but I've also never minded typing commands to the prompt. I'd imagine if you gave it the right TWRP it'd flash it OK..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That actually doesn't sound too bad; From that it seems like the process is still more or less the same. Why is the system mounted as read only though? After looking through most of the older step by step guides it doesn't mention anything about doing that. From what I see, after i run the command "fastboot flash recovery recovery.img" i boot into TWRP and then proceed to do a factory reset and wipe the cache, presumably to remove the encryption iirc, then install the supersu.zip is that still the correct procedure, or does this require mounting the system as read only now?
If you don't mind me asking, what steps exactly did you take to root yours? from what I've found all I need to do is get the bootloader unlocked with the steps from HTCDev, drop into download more, fastboot flash recovery recovery.img to get TWRP, boot into TWRP, run a format to get rid of the encryption, then install supersu.zip and that should be it. IS this correct or am I missing something?

I'm about to start the process trying to root using the above methods.. I'll post again when I have results.

txag2011 said:
That actually doesn't sound too bad; From that it seems like the process is still more or less the same. Why is the system mounted as read only though? After looking through most of the older step by step guides it doesn't mention anything about doing that. From what I see, after i run the command "fastboot flash recovery recovery.img" i boot into TWRP and then proceed to do a factory reset and wipe the cache, presumably to remove the encryption iirc, then install the supersu.zip is that still the correct procedure, or does this require mounting the system as read only now?
If you don't mind me asking, what steps exactly did you take to root yours? from what I've found all I need to do is get the bootloader unlocked with the steps from HTCDev, drop into download more, fastboot flash recovery recovery.img to get TWRP, boot into TWRP, run a format to get rid of the encryption, then install supersu.zip and that should be it. IS this correct or am I missing something?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It wasn't bad at all. The reason I mounted R/O is because I'm using Magisk and not disabling dm-verity. I'm not sure if it works the same on 7, but SuperSu should disable dm-verity, so if you're using it you might not need to mount R/O, I haven't been keeping up on that at all. Benefits of Magisk include Android Pay and being able to take an OTA.
That all sounds like exactly what you need to do, except I believe it's fastboot mode (the one with the black screen?) to flash TWRP. I also didn't have to format anything, but I believe you do if you're using Su and disabling forced encryption. You may want to take a system image backup before you change anything, so you can go back to stock and get an OTA, or in case something goes wrong, but other than that it sounds correct to me.

JohnRogers23 said:
It wasn't bad at all. The reason I mounted R/O is because I'm using Magisk and not disabling dm-verity. I'm not sure if it works the same on 7, but SuperSu should disable dm-verity, so if you're using it you might not need to mount R/O, I haven't been keeping up on that at all. Benefits of Magisk include Android Pay and being able to take an OTA.
That all sounds like exactly what you need to do, except I believe it's fastboot mode (the one with the black screen?) to flash TWRP. I also didn't have to format anything, but I believe you do if you're using Su and disabling forced encryption. You may want to take a system image backup before you change anything, so you can go back to stock and get an OTA, or in case something goes wrong, but other than that it sounds correct to me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
huh... Magisk can utilize android pay and OTA's? I'm a little bit intrigued.. I just might have to give that a quick look now. Was it difficult to get up and running, and is there a fairly decent guide for doing it?

txag2011 said:
huh... Magisk can utilize android pay and OTA's? I'm a little bit intrigued.. I just might have to give that a quick look now. Was it difficult to get up and running, and is there a fairly decent guide for doing it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Magisk is a framework for systemlessly modifying /system, so safety net works and you can take an OTA (with stock recovery), and also includes root. It's brilliant, but not quite as powerful as Xposed. Not difficult at all to get running, all it needs is to flash the magisk installer zip in TWRP (system mounted R/O of course) and then install the Magisk Manager app from the play store.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/official-magisk-v7-universal-systemless-t3473445

JohnRogers23 said:
Magisk is a framework for systemlessly modifying /system, so safety net works and you can take an OTA (with stock recovery), and also includes root. It's brilliant, but not quite as powerful as Xposed. Not difficult at all to get running, all it needs is to flash the magisk installer zip in TWRP (system mounted R/O of course) and then install the Magisk Manager app from the play store.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/official-magisk-v7-universal-systemless-t3473445
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I might give this a shot then, thank you for that. I'm about to try flashing TWRP 3.0.3-0. From the looks of it this is the most current one available. I'll update when it's done

txag2011 said:
I might give this a shot then, thank you for that. I'm about to try flashing TWRP 3.0.3-0. From the looks of it this is the most current one available. I'll update when it's done
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Go to the TWRP thread, hit the download tab, pick one of the newer ones there. I went with 3.0.3.-4.

JohnRogers23 said:
Go to the TWRP thread, hit the download tab, pick one of the newer ones there. I went with 3.0.3.-4.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did just that. Got TWRP installed successfully. I PM'ed you a second ago but I might as well ask this here for everyone else to see in case someone else is wondering this too.... So if I'm understanding Magisk correctly, all I do now is hit install and choose Magisk v11.1?
Edit: I did just that, but it doesnt seem to have done anything.. I dont see and magisk apps, and root checker says i'm not rooted.. Did I miss something?
edit 2: scratch that... I just installed the magisk manager app from the playstore.. according to it, the latest version of magisk is in fact, installed, and it's rooted with magisksu (despite not showing so in rootchecker).. Little confused now. Is that everything that needs to be done?
edit 3: I went back in after seeing something mentioning installing phh's superuser via TWRP and installing the app after installing magisk. Did both, but noticed safety net wasn't passing. found an option in settings to hide magisk, which seems to fix that. I also ran root checker again and it shows I have root.
unless I missed anything you can think of I think that about finishes things. If thats it thank you for all the help @JohnRogers23

txag2011 said:
Did just that. Got TWRP installed successfully. I PM'ed you a second ago but I might as well ask this here for everyone else to see in case someone else is wondering this too.... So if I'm understanding Magisk correctly, all I do now is hit install and choose Magisk v11.1?
Edit: I did just that, but it doesnt seem to have done anything.. I dont see and magisk apps, and root checker says i'm not rooted.. Did I miss something?
edit 2: scratch that... I just installed the magisk manager app from the playstore.. according to it, the latest version of magisk is in fact, installed, and it's rooted with magisksu (despite not showing so in rootchecker).. Little confused now. Is that everything that needs to be done?
edit 3: I went back in after seeing something mentioning installing phh's superuser via TWRP and installing the app after installing magisk. Did both, but noticed safety net wasn't passing. found an option in settings to hide magisk, which seems to fix that. I also ran root checker again and it shows I have root.
unless I missed anything you can think of I think that about finishes things. If thats it thank you for all the help @JohnRogers23
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm glad you got it working. Strange you had to flash phh's Su separately though. Anyway, glad I could help.

Well Working !
1.Backup your all imp data from internal memory
2.Flash TWRP 3.0.3-4.. Do not reboot into system and enter into Recovery TWRP..
3.Do a factory Reset via TWRP.. Do not reboot into system
4.Now flash SuperSU 2.79 SR3 via TWRP.. Finally Reboot into system..
*2 bootloops are common, do not give up for at least 3 bootloops..
*It will take a long time to boot as you have done a factory reset.. So be patient and wait for at least half hour..

Dr.Anshuman said:
1.Backup your all imp data from internal memory
2.Flash TWRP 3.0.3-4.. Do not reboot into system and enter into Recovery TWRP..
3.Do a factory Reset via TWRP.. Do not reboot into system
4.Now flash SuperSU 2.79 SR3 via TWRP.. Finally Reboot into system..
*2 bootloops are common, do not give up for at least 3 bootloops..
*It will take a long time to boot as you have done a factory reset.. So be patient and wait for at least half hour..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks! I got it more or less and went with magisk. Couldn't pass up a chance to have root and still get OTAs and use android pay. I'm still monkeying around trying to figure out how to use it to get liveboot back up and running.

How To Root Oxygen 5.1.7

Oneplus updated the OnePlus 6's Bootloader and you may ask yourself 'Can i still root?'
The answer is yes. It is easy.
1. At first, your bootloader has to be unlocked
2. Just download the Twrp.img and the Twrp installer from twrp.me, then the latest magisk installer
3. Put the magisk.zip and twrp installer zip into the root of your device and boot into bootloader
4. Now you have to open a new shell or cmd window in your adb folder, then type "Fastboot devices" there
5. If your phone is recognized, then do this command: " fastboot boot .\twrp-3.2.1-0-enchilada.img"
6. The op6 should boot into the TWRP, there type in your pincode, pattern, or what so ever you have. If you get a message because of system modification, click 'Keep read only'
7. Go to 'Install', then flash the TWRP installer zip, then magisk right after it
8. Just reboot and enjoy
The procedure is the same as always. I can confirm it's working because i rooted a few minutes ago

Just keep in mind the kernels and custom roms haven't been updated to 5.1.7 base yet and may not work until they are.

iElvis said:
Just keep in mind the kernels and custom roms haven't been updated to 5.1.7 base yet and may not work until they are.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Forgot the mention that, thanks!

Edit: Screenshots

Flash kernel works. Btw please don't create threads on how to root if the method hasn't changed lol

joemossjr said:
Flash kernel works. Btw please don't create threads on how to root if the method hasn't changed lol
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry, I thought that would be helpful for people who are worried about root because of updated bootloader.
A Moderator can remove this thread then

joemossjr said:
Flash kernel works. Btw please don't create threads on how to root if the method hasn't changed lol
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Based on how things have been going so far, people are going to be asking. Just saying.

i understand butttttttttttttttttttttt this forum is flooded with how to flash twrp, how to root with 5.1.6, how to install 5.1.5 with twrp ect ect ect lol just trying to reduce clutter and make things a tad bit simpler. No offense guys lol

So if I already have twrp and Magisk installed is the method still the same?
Will this update lock the bootloader back?
Pretty sure I swiped to allow system modifications on my first twrp installation so will that matter?

joemossjr said:
i understand butttttttttttttttttttttt this forum is flooded with how to flash twrp, how to root with 5.1.6, how to install 5.1.5 with twrp ect ect ect lol just trying to reduce clutter and make things a tad bit simpler. No offense guys lol
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes I know. I mean, you're right. Thought something like "new bootloader, new confusions". I justed wanted to help people if they're worried of a brick

dgunn said:
So if I already have twrp and Magisk installed is the method still the same?
Pretty sure I swiped to allow system modifications on my first twrp installation so will that matter?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Don't worry. You can use TWRP and your phone itself as always

Sconny said:
Don't worry. You can use TWRP and your phone itself as always
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So do I flash the update in twrp?
Must the bootloader be unlocked again?

dgunn said:
So do I flash the update in twrp?
Must the bootloader be unlocked again?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No you flash in system via local upgrade

joemossjr said:
No you flash in system via local upgrade
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Flash with local upgrade, reboot to fastboot, run twrp.img, install twrp, flash Magisk and reboot? No unlocking bootloader again?
If not correct please tell me

Yup that's it

joemossjr said:
No you flash in system via local upgrade
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Flash in system.. you mean through the system updates in settings? And then I have to reinstall TWRP?

BossNexusS said:
Flash in system.. you mean through the system updates in settings? And then I have to reinstall TWRP?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes

joemossjr said:
Yes
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What were the steps you followed if you don't mind?

Maybe someone will upload the full rom?

anyone tried hiding system updates inside magisk hide ?
it now shows only 224 update (canadian vpn), hence don't know what it will do when you take that route, anyone ?

[noob] OTA Update procedure with TWRP and Magisk

Hello, I'm still a noob trying to learn, so far with help of this forum I've learned to unlock and root my first android phone, now I'm trying to learn how to properly keep my device updated!
Can someone please give a little rundown to what are the correct steps to update OTA on a rooted twrp device?
I've been browsing the forums a lot but I seem to find a lot of different approaches, or too vague instructions.
It would be greatly appreciated if someone could help me out, step by step, and explain the steps with the commands I need to put in, if there are any.
Thank you

download the ota from here
place it on your phone
go to update on you phone then hit the cog and hit local update
let it up date
reboot to boot loader
fastboot twrp img again
then flash the installer
reboot recovery
then it will boot back in to recovery again
flash root
job done

Hello,
To save you having to fastboot boot TWRP, do the following:
Save the following files to your SDCard:
OTA.zip
Magisk.zip
TWRP.zip
Boot into TWRP
Flash OTA.zip first, then TWRP.zip straight after, then Magisk.zip straight after that, reboot.

@Swatto86 By twrp do you mean TWRP recovery or TWRP installer? I assume that you mean the installer

audinak2 said:
@Swatto86 By twrp do you mean TWRP recovery or TWRP installer? I assume that you mean the installer
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry yes, put the installer zip on the sdcard

Thank you everyone for the quick replies,
What exactly is it to 'flash' the installer? Is it something I can do from the TWRP screen, just tap on it? Or will I have to put in command prompts?
audinak2 said:
@Swatto86 By twrp do you mean TWRP recovery or TWRP installer? I assume that you mean the installer
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have followed this guide https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Es80k627kTc to unlock/twrp/root, I have a TWRP recovery as far as I know, I'm not sure about 'installer'.
Thanks!

i just download and install the OTA through system updates. Then boot to Trwp recovery and flash magisk . Profit

DampDeceiver said:
Thank you everyone for the quick replies,
What exactly is it to 'flash' the installer? Is it something I can do from the TWRP screen, just tap on it? Or will I have to put in command prompts?
I have followed this guide
to unlock/twrp/root, I have a TWRP recovery as far as I know, I'm not sure about 'installer'.
Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can flash the installer zip for TWRP through TWRP itself.
Doesn't installing OTA through system settings wipe TWRP? That's why I perform all my updates from TWRP directly.

DampDeceiver said:
Thank you everyone for the quick replies,
What exactly is it to 'flash' the installer? Is it something I can do from the TWRP screen, just tap on it? Or will I have to put in command prompts?
I have followed this guide https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Es80k627kTc to unlock/twrp/root, I have a TWRP recovery as far as I know, I'm not sure about 'installer'.
Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You have to do twrp/root again after updates. Unlock sticks, but twrp and root don't.

there must be something strange with me then , OTA update doesnt wipe my twrp , i just flash magisk after OTA

Ajaykumar21066 said:
there must be something strange with me then , OTA update doesnt wipe my twrp , i just flash magisk after OTA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It prob doesn't overwrite until u reboot so twrp may not have been overwritten on that partition yet, so would make sense, I need to try it out sometime

When you install OTA via system settings and reboot, the slot switches to the inactive one (where the OTA installed to) and boots. This means the previous slot (prior to reboot) still has TWRP installed.
You are probably going direct to recovery after the OTA install without doing a full reboot first.

Swatto is correct. The risk when using twrp is that you must reboot to recovery immediately after flashing the twrp installer zip, or you will boot to the old slot and things will be broken. Rebooting to recovery gets you onto the active, updated slot.
When you reboot to recovery and flash an OTA, you are flashing it to the other slot. The current slot is untouched, while the new active one is completely stock. The twrp installer zip flashes twrp to both slots.
This is the procedure to follow if you want to update via twrp. Personally, I prefer taking the OTA and reinstalling via fastboot just to make sure everything is clean.
lollyjay said:
I have personally tested the following with TWRP already installed and twrp-installer-enchilada-3.2.1-0.zip on your phone:
Download full (not incremental) OOS ROM to your phone and check MD5
Reboot to your installed TWRP
Install the OOS ROM
Do not reboot instead stay in TWRP
Install twrp-installer-enchilada-3.2.1-0.zip
Reboot Recovery
Wipe cache
Reboot System
Click to expand...
Click to collapse

Alright everyone, thanks for all the replies. I have to say even with all your help things were still really confusing for me. I went ahead and ditched TWRP (since I don't really need it anyway), updated OTA through the system, reinstalled magisk before reboot on 2nd slot (the OTA option), and rebooted. And so far all seems fine, I'm on the latest OOS version and I'm still rooted, everything seems to work. Can I do this again in the future and completely overwrite my TWRP installation on my A slot?
I kinda went with TWRP as it's supposed to be more safe for noobs but it ended up making things a lot more difficult to manage.
Thank you

DampDeceiver said:
Alright everyone, thanks for all the replies. I have to say even with all your help things were still really confusing for me. I went ahead and ditched TWRP (since I don't really need it anyway), updated OTA through the system, reinstalled magisk before reboot on 2nd slot (the OTA option), and rebooted. And so far all seems fine, I'm on the latest OOS version and I'm still rooted, everything seems to work. Can I do this again in the future and completely overwrite my TWRP installation on my A slot?
I kinda went with TWRP as it's supposed to be more safe for noobs but it ended up making things a lot more difficult to manage.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have not tried that method as I want twrp, but that is the recommended approach.
I know things have changed with twrp, but it's not that hard once you get used to it. You just have to remember that your phone will switch active slots every time it gets an update or you flash an ota (for example, to go back to stock), so twrp, etc, have to be installed on the other slot before you boot to it. Once you get comfortable with that idea, the rest of it is pretty easy.

Well, I am glad to read this post. Its always interesting how things can be slightly different in every phone manufacturer's setup.
After my lady Huawei device (Honor 6x), I did not want to have to deal with their style of... Control over their devices.
And things seem much easier here, while also being a little confusing right now. I don't fully get the slot a/b stuff yet but it sounds like it's a system to ensure stability on the phone in cases where the newest update could install incorrectly the alternative slot has a backup to ensure the device will function.
Sorta sounds like the dual bios setup on some motherboards. It's good!
Right, so to summarise to ensure I got it right:
1) Downloaded large (1gb+) ota zip from one of these threads, official twrp recovery installing zip, new version of magisk recovery installing zip
2) in recovery install all 3 of those zips in that listed order
3) reboot to recovery again to ensure twrp is still installed
4) profit
Which twrp thread should I take the zip from? There are a few different threads. I shouldn't care about the fastboot version when I already have twrp installed, right?
Either way, it can be much easier than what I had to do on Huawei phones. (currently the easiest phone I used for customisation like this was Nexus 4, but gladly OP6 is getting pretty close to that same level).
Sent from my OnePlus 6 using XDA Labs

You're best off downloading from the official twrp site. If you already have it installed, no need to use the fastboot boot method. You should to reboot to recovery in between flashing twrp and magisk to be sure magisk gets installed on the active slot.

Swatto86 said:
When you install OTA via system settings and reboot, the slot switches to the inactive one (where the OTA installed to) and boots. This means the previous slot (prior to reboot) still has TWRP installed.
You are probably going direct to recovery after the OTA install without doing a full reboot first.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Question, more of a scenario really. So if I'm on slot A and have TWRP and Magisk installed, would it be alright to just do a local update and reboot, giving me a perfectly clean install in slot B? Does it work that way? Thanks!
I'm actually using a 6t, but worst case scenario I just use the MSM Download tool, still I wanna get the hang of these confusing A/B devices.

Installing OTA after TWRP + Magisk = fail to boot

I'm at my wit's end here. I know I'm probably missing some critical step, but I haven't been able to install any OTAs since installing TWRP and Magisk. Fortunately, I was able to update to the latest TWRP before trying (the one that has working decryption) and backup Boot, the two Systems, and Data. I cannot stress enough how important this is!.
The OTA installer detects the device is rooted (or unlocked, if magisk isn't installed) and downloads the OTA. It then asks to install (which is does while booted to system, presumably to the side (A or B) that isn't updated), and asks to reboot. After reboot, the system fails to boot, then goes to the original OnePlus recovery (with the Chinese characters).
I seem to remember reading somewhere that I needed to shut the phone down instead of rebooting, but that doesn't seem to help. I want to know the correct procedure for updating, but I also want to better understand what is actually going on. I'm guessing the boot image on the other side gets overwritten by the OTA, which then flips you to that side, but I don't understand why it doesn't boot. Non-patched boot.img, I suppose?

These steps worked for me:
1 install ota
2 flash TWRP_A_B_Retention_Script-Magisk.zip via magisk
3 install magisk on inactive slot
4 reboot

RocketGeeezer said:
These steps worked for me:
1 install ota
2 flash TWRP_A_B_Retention_Script-Magisk.zip via magisk
3 install magisk on inactive slot
4 reboot
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Awesome. I had not even heard of the retention script, but it sounds like exactly what I'm missing.
As for step 3, how do you install Magisk on the inactive slot?

Flapjack said:
Awesome. I had not even heard of the retention script, but it sounds like exactly what I'm missing.
As for step 3, how do you install Magisk on the inactive slot?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Open magisk, click the first install option and download that zip. Then a box with four options should appear. Click the last option to install on another slot.

whatthekj said:
Open magisk, click the first install option and download that zip. Then a box with four options should appear. Click the last option to install on another slot.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks! Trying now!

Flapjack said:
Thanks! Trying now!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No problem. Let me know if you have any issues.

Well, it's different (booting to TWRP instead of stock recovery), but it still didn't work. It booted through the "warning...unlocked bootloader" screen twice, then went to TWRP, though without encryption. I was able to switch the boot slot and get into system again (just as it was before the flash), but I don't know what I did wrong.
The only thing different I did was use the tools under EX Kernel Manager to flash the TWRP retention script, as I couldn't find where Magisk could do that.
**EDIT**
Now when I try to do the OTA, I get a "System update installation failed".

I cleared the cache and tried it again, this time doing the retention zip from inside Magisk > Modules > Add (+ sign) option, which is what I'm assuming you did.
It did the exact same thing. After step four, I rebooted, and it went straight into recovery (without the option to decrypt).

I think you have to root your phone again If you have the chinese twrp you can do it via twrp. Otherwise put tj magisk installer on a USB stick

RocketGeeezer said:
I think you have to root your phone again If you have the chinese twrp you can do it via twrp. Otherwise put tj magisk installer on a USB stick
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I can install/uninstall Magisk all day long, now that I've put TWRP 3.3.1-30 on. Even after a failed update, where it fails to ask to decrypt, I can still sideload via USB and install it (even though I can't see the internal storage).

Flapjack said:
I can install/uninstall Magisk all day long, now that I've put TWRP 3.3.1-30 on. Even after a failed update, where it fails to ask to decrypt, I can still sideload via USB and install it (even though I can't see the internal storage).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you lflash the ota image again? And after that twrp and after that magisk again. After that reboot to system again. This worked on my pixel. Not shure if this works on the 7 pro...
Maybe do some research first. There is also a unbrick thread

RocketGeeezer said:
Can you lflash the ota image again? And after that twrp and after that magisk again. After that reboot to system again. This worked on my pixel. Not shure if this works on the 7 pro...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've tried that... several times. I wish it worked.
Maybe do some research first. There is also a unbrick thread
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've been doing a lot of research. There are some pretty in-depth threads on reddit how the A/B treble system works. Nothing I didn't already know. It's certainly different than pre-treble, but not rocket science... something is wrong with the phone. I would just like to know what I did wrong in the first place so I don't do it again.
Fortunately, I still have a bootable system with root on my B partition, so I was able to run TB and backup everything, along with all my pictures and such. I'll be restoring it to stock and just going from there. Looks like I don't have any other choice.

Flapjack said:
I've tried that... several times. I wish it worked.
I've been doing a lot of research. There are some pretty in-depth threads on reddit how the A/B treble system works. Nothing I didn't already know. It's certainly different than pre-treble, but not rocket science... something is wrong with the phone. I would just like to know what I did wrong in the first place so I don't do it again.
Fortunately, I still have a bootable system with root on my B partition, so I was able to run TB and backup everything, along with all my pictures and such. I'll be restoring it to stock and just going from there. Looks like I don't have any other choice.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Okay I updated just like we do with our pixels when we flash a custom ROM. TW RP flash your ota.zip,TWRP zip, reboot to recovery that will switch slots , because your update just flashed to the other slot, then flash magisk then reboot. That's how I did this last update. Oh and it's got to be the full ota from what I read anyways.

Question Migisk boot.img or magisk.zip

Hello all
I've used the boot.img and found it to be inconvenient as id have to redo this with every ota update, instead I use adb magisk.zip and keep root after ota updates, is this incorrect as I've not seen the method I am currently using spoken about at all and everyone directs to use .IMG or at least all the root guides I've come across

mlolz93 said:
Hello all
I've used the boot.img and found it to be inconvenient as id have to redo this with every ota update, instead I use adb magisk.zip and keep root after ota updates, is this incorrect as I've not seen the method I am currently using spoken about at all and everyone directs to use .IMG or at least all the root guides I've come across
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What do you mean by "adb magisk.zip"?

V0latyle said:
What do you mean by "adb magisk.zip"?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Apologies, in recovery mode send the zip to install

mlolz93 said:
Apologies, in recovery mode send the zip to install
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
With the stock recovery? As far as I know this shouldn't work because the stock recovery will only accept official signed images.

V0latyle said:
With the stock recovery? As far as I know this shouldn't work because the stock recovery will only accept official signed images.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry no with lineage recovery
Definitly have root, can use several tools that show as much. So I just find it odd that with all tutorials that I have come across, the ones for custom ROMs will say to use boot.img and that doesn't make a lot of sense considering that it'll loose root after an update.
Anyway I'm left wondering why people default to boot.img which takes more steps and is overall more inconvenient.. Or is there a trade off that I am missing

mlolz93 said:
Sorry no with lineage recovery
Definitly have root, can use several tools that show as much. So I just find it odd that with all tutorials that I have come across, the ones for custom ROMs will say to use boot.img and that doesn't make a lot of sense considering that it'll loose root after an update.
Anyway I'm left wondering why people default to boot.img which takes more steps and is overall more inconvenient.. Or is there a trade off that I am missing
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Because that's how to root the Pixels - you have to patch the boot image. There are a number of ways to do this: you can manually patch it in Magisk; you can live boot a previously patched image and use temporary root to perform Direct Install in Magisk; you can live boot a custom recovery (if on the stock ROM) and install Magisk that way; or you can sideload Magisk in custom recovery.
The reason why updating breaks root is because the boot image gets overwritten with a "clean" unpatched image. This will happen regardless of the method you use to root, so you'll have to re-root every time you update.

V0latyle said:
Because that's how to root the Pixels - you have to patch the boot image. There are a number of ways to do this: you can manually patch it in Magisk; you can live boot a previously patched image and use temporary root to perform Direct Install in Magisk; you can live boot a custom recovery (if on the stock ROM) and install Magisk that way; or you can sideload Magisk in custom recovery.
The reason why updating breaks root is because the boot image gets overwritten with a "clean" unpatched image. This will happen regardless of the method you use to root, so you'll have to re-root every time you update.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Side loading the .zip is way easier and I've not lost root after updating so to me seems like the better method.
because I've not seen it used in guides I was concerned that they're was a trade off.
I will assume side loading the .zip is the better method.
Cheers @V0latyle

Same here, I used adb when rooting only with custom recovery, lineage update with no problem, flash it to inactive slot before rebooting to finished update, make sure you disable the magisk modules that you have to prevent bootlooping

mlolz93 said:
Side loading the .zip is way easier and I've not lost root after updating so to me seems like the better method.
because I've not seen it used in guides I was concerned that they're was a trade off.
I will assume side loading the .zip is the better method.
Cheers @V0latyle
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
For LOS, yeah it would be easier.
You actually do lose root after updating, but when you sideload Magisk, you're patching the new boot image

V0latyle said:
For LOS, yeah it would be easier.
You actually do lose root after updating, but when you sideload Magisk, you're patching the new boot image
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nope, mine is still rooted when I updated on 04/08.

imna357 said:
Nope, mine is still rooted when I updated on 04/08.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I disabled all my modules, start the updater and after ready to install I went to Magisk and install it to inactive slot, then reboot.

imna357 said:
Nope, mine is still rooted when I updated on 04/08.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'd retained root for 2 update but with the last one I had to reinstall to inactive slot