Disclaimer: No, I don't work for QiMai or the seller on Amazon. I'm just a guy who has been struggling with screen protectors since the S8+, and finally found one I'm 100% satisfied with. So I figured I'd share.
I was using the Cubevit PET screen protector and loved it, but it was a fingerprint magnet, and like all PET screen protectors got pretty scratched up.*Otherwise it's a FANTASTIC screen protector and only $8 for a 3-pack.
I had put a QiMai TPU screen protector on my wife's S9+, and you could barely tell it was there. I have to occasionally pick up her phone and look really close to make sure it's still on there. But since it was TPU I worried about it having that rubbery feel, and the SPen leaving marks.*
Since the QiMai was only $10 for a 2-pack, I decided to give it a try on my Note 9 anyway, and seriously, it's the best screen protector out there. It may not offer the drop protection of a Whitestone Dome, but as far as clarity and feel, there's no equal.*
It is crystal clear. Matter of fact it covers the FF camera and all the sensors, but it causes no distortion or interference. And it's almost as slick as the factory glass. It has no rubbery drag at all. And fingerprints wipe away very easy. And no indents from the SPen, unless you really dig in. Even then they disappear quickly.*
Ringke makes a similar screen protector, as does a few other companies, but I haven't tried them. Here is the link to the QiMai if you all want to try it.*
Galaxy Note 9 Screen Protector, 2-Pack QiMai Case Friendly Easy Install Screen Cover(Not Glass)[New Version]*https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07H2ZW9PG..._q.BfCbVBPDM3J
So far no interference with my cases. I use a Ringke Air, a Speck Grip, and a couple minimal generic TPU cases. So nothing that really comes far over the edge of the screen. I'll be ordering some Goosperry cases soon, but I don't see where they would interfere either.
Installation is easy, but it's also easy to get lint under it. It took me four tries. The first one was 95% perfect except for a bubble from lint in the top right corner. The second one got a bubble for an unknown reason that wouldnt go away. Small bubbles disappear after 24 hours. But this one wouldn't. Otherwise it was almost perfect.
I reached out to the seller and he sent me a free replacement 2-pack. I screwed up the first one, but finally the last one went on perfectly.
I do think I'll try the Ringke version of this screen protector next time, simply because it was a built in lint remover that picks up all lint and dust as you install automatically. But I've got no experience with the Ringke to know if it's as smooth as this one.
If you want a tempered glass screen protector, then go for the Whitestone Dome. But if you like thin, minimal screen protectors that you can't tell is there, then I highly recommend this one.
UPDATE: I accidentally tore my QiMai screen protector, so I used the opportunity to try the Ringke Dual. It's the same exact material and fit as the QiMai. It just as clear, but is slightly easier to install. It seems to be more oleophobic, yet not quote as slick as the QiMai. They are both super smooth to the touch, but the Ringke seems to have just slightly more drag to it.
But I can say I like both screen protectors and you can't go wrong with either one.
Mr. Orange 645 said:
Disclaimer: No, I don't work for QiMai or the seller on Amazon. I'm just a guy who has been struggling with screen protectors since the S8+, and finally found one I'm 100% satisfied with. So I figured I'd share.
I was using the Cubevit PET screen protector and loved it, but it was a fingerprint magnet, and like all PET screen protectors got pretty scratched up.*Otherwise it's a FANTASTIC screen protector and only $8 for a 3-pack.
I had put a QiMai TPU screen protector on my wife's S9+, and you could barely tell it was there. I have to occasionally pick up her phone and look really close to make sure it's still on there. But since it was TPU I worried about it having that rubbery feel, and the SPen leaving marks.*
Since the QiMai was only $10 for a 2-pack, I decided to give it a try on my Note 9 anyway, and seriously, it's the best screen protector out there. It may not offer the drop protection of a Whitestone Dome, but as far as clarity and feel, there's no equal.*
It is crystal clear. Matter of fact it covers the FF camera and all the sensors, but it causes no distortion or interference. And it's almost as slick as the factory glass. It has no rubbery drag at all. And fingerprints wipe away very easy. And no indents from the SPen, unless you really dig in. Even then they disappear quickly.*
Ringke makes a similar screen protector, as does a few other companies, but I haven't tried them. Here is the link to the QiMai if you all want to try it.*
Galaxy Note 9 Screen Protector, 2-Pack QiMai Case Friendly Easy Install Screen Cover(Not Glass)[New Version]*https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07H2ZW9PG..._q.BfCbVBPDM3J
So far no interference with my cases. I use a Ringke Air, a Speck Grip, and a couple minimal generic TPU cases. So nothing that really comes far over the edge of the screen. I'll be ordering some Goosperry cases soon, but I don't see where they would interfere either.
Installation is easy, but it's also easy to get lint under it. It took me four tries. The first one was 95% perfect except for a bubble from lint in the top right corner. The second one got a bubble for an unknown reason that wouldnt go away. Small bubbles disappear after 24 hours. But this one wouldn't. Otherwise it was almost perfect.
I reached out to the seller and he sent me a free replacement 2-pack. I screwed up the first one, but finally the last one went on perfectly.
I do think I'll try the Ringke version of this screen protector next time, simply because it was a built in lint remover that picks up all lint and dust as you install automatically. But I've got no experience with the Ringke to know if it's as smooth as this one.
If you want a tempered glass screen protector, then go for the Whitestone Dome. But if you like thin, minimal screen protectors that you can't tell is there, then I highly recommend this one.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nice, is it just a film protector?
felloffthetruck said:
Nice, is it just a film protector?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yup. Dry install TPU film.
The link is borked, though Was easy to find with search, but still..
does the S-PEN leaves marks on the film after using it for a while ?
6thtry said:
The link is borked, though Was easy to find with search, but still..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry about that! Try this link:
Galaxy Note 9 Screen Protector, 2-Pack QiMai Case Friendly Easy Install Screen Cover(Not Glass)[New Version] https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07H2ZW9PG/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_43agCbXE0S0MW
emudojo said:
does the S-PEN leaves marks on the film after using it for a while ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I actually covered that in my original post:
Mr. Orange 645 said:
And no indents from the SPen, unless you really dig in. Even then they disappear quickly.*
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Was just looking at the Ringke and it has no install guide.
I've always hated film protectors but might give this one a try.
Does it peel off easy and clean?
So my first package of tg was a failure. Neither stuck to the screen. Returning to Amazon. My whitestone (which I'm not sure now if I'll end up using now) is still a few days away, so I ordered this to have coverage. It will be here tomorrow.
felloffthetruck said:
Was just looking at the Ringke and it has no install guide.
I've always hated film protectors but might give this one a try.
Does it peel off easy and clean?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes it peels off easy and clean. No adhesive residue.
I actually JUST switched to the Ringke screen protector. LOL. I put my Note 9 in a sleeve to carry it without a case, and the corner of the screen protector peeled up and tore. So I ordered the Ringke to try it out. I like it just as well as the QiMai. There's some subtle differences. The Ringke is actually easier to install. And even though the QiMai feels just slightly slicker than the Ringke, I think the Ringke is more oleophobic. You honestly can go wrong with either one.
PuffinNugz said:
So my first package of tg was a failure. Neither stuck to the screen. Returning to Amazon. My whitestone (which I'm not sure now if I'll end up using now) is still a few days away, so I ordered this to have coverage. It will be here tomorrow.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What did you think of it?
Mr. Orange 645 said:
Yes it peels off easy and clean. No adhesive residue.
I actually JUST switched to the Ringke screen protector. LOL. I put my Note 9 in a sleeve to carry it without a case, and the corner of the screen protector peeled up and tore. So I ordered the Ringke to try it out. I like it just as well as the QiMai. There's some subtle differences. The Ringke is actually easier to install. And even though the QiMai feels just slightly slicker than the Ringke, I think the Ringke is more oleophobic. You honestly can go wrong with either one.
What did you think of it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How well does the dust removal deal work on the Ringke?
felloffthetruck said:
How well does the dust removal deal work on the Ringke?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not that great, actually. I think they could have used a little stronger adhesive, but it's okay. I wound up with one speck of dust on the very edge, but I also used a dust absorber from another screen protector kit to remove any heavy lint and dust.
It turned out about 99.9% perfect, which is the best I can expect from any screen protector. I always end up with some speck of dust or bubble somewhere. It's just so hard without an actual clean room.
I will say the screen protector is absolutely invisible. You have to look very hard to see it. And the more I use it, the slicker it feels.
Just make sure it's straight and aligned before you peel off the backing (tab 2 and 3). I had to readjust mine a few times to get it straight and centered left to right. That is one advantage to this installation method. You can readjust it as much as you want before you actually secure it permanently to the screen.
Mr. Orange 645 said:
Not that great, actually. I think they could have used a little stronger adhesive, but it's okay. I wound up with one speck of dust on the very edge, but I also used a dust absorber from another screen protector kit to remove any heavy lint and dust.
It turned out about 99.9% perfect, which is the best I can expect from any screen protector. I always end up with some speck of dust or bubble somewhere. It's just so hard without an actual clean room.
I will say the screen protector is absolutely invisible. You have to look very hard to see it. And the more I use it, the slicker it feels.
Just make sure it's straight and aligned before you peel off the backing (tab 2 and 3). I had to readjust mine a few times to get it straight and centered left to right. That is one advantage to this installation method. You can readjust it as much as you want before you actually secure it permanently to the screen.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you post a couple pictures showing this protector on the phone?
felloffthetruck said:
Can you post a couple pictures showing this protector on the phone?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sure. If not today, I'll snag some pics tomorrow.
felloffthetruck said:
Can you post a couple pictures showing this protector on the phone?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is the Ringke screen protector. I didn't get any pics of the QiMai protector.
Those specs are dust ON the screen protector, not under it.
Mr. Orange 645 said:
This is the Ringke screen protector. I didn't get any pics of the QiMai protector.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
WOW, that looks nice. I'll have to give them a try.
Did you get that result on the first try?
felloffthetruck said:
WOW, that looks nice. I'll have to give them a try.
Did you get that result on the first try?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes I did. But I cheated a little. I also bought the same screen protector for my Note 8 and installed it first. So I at least had some practice.
Just use as close to a dust free environment as you can. Then clean your screen really well, remove all dust with a dust remover if you have it, then take your time lining up the screen protector. Remember, you can lift it and readjust as many times as you want before you pull tab 2 and secure it permanently.
Related
I got my screen protector in the mail today and put it on my phone. I figured I should share my thoughts along with some pictures for those who are looking at screen protectors.
The pack came with two screen protectors, a squeegee, some dust removal stickers, and a small micro fiber cloth. The protector was not too bad to put on, pretty similar to other dry application ones and the Realook which I have used on my Samsung Vibrant. It was kind of tough to align because the screen protector is literally exactly the width of your screen, so if you're off alignment, it looks horrible.
The screen protector is definitely super clear. It also is a fingerprint magnet, and it feels slightly tacky. I'm hoping that tackiness will go away as it gets more use, because I like being able to glide over my screen smoothly.
One huge disadvantage with this screen protector is that because of the curved screen, the protector only covers the flat part. It is definitely noticeable when you see it closer. I tried taking pictures to depict this. I also with they would have just had the protector cover the FFC. I'm not sure how it would actually affect the optics (if at all), but I really hate that cut out! Overall, I'm decently content with my purchase, but I would love to see pics and reviews for BSE when those arrive since I'm considering that for the back, and even replace the front if I end up not liking the Spigen.
Thanks so much for these. I used the SGP on my Gnex and loved it. There's something special about these Crystal series ones but I don't remember what it is.
Sent from my Nexus 4 using Tapatalk 2
I got the Ultra Clear for my N4. It hasn't arrived yet, so for now I'm using my spare One X Oleophobic. The Oleophobic is great, really good for repelling fingerprints, I would have got it but when I bought my N4 UltraClear they weren't selling the Oleo. Thanks for the pictures, it seems to fit a lot better than the One X SGP protectors did on the One X. Doesn't look too bad at all.
I got the crystal clear and I have the same issue with the protector being too small. I know that this has been the case with some their other protectors, but I'm going to have to try some other brands. I can't stand it being cut off like this.
Sent from my Nexus 4 using xda app-developers app
Where did you get it from ?
juventuss said:
Where did you get it from ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The Spigen website.
I wonder if using the Google Bumper will hide the fact that it doesn't quite reach the edges.
I got the oleophobic one in today from SGP, it doesnt cover the whole screen either. Better than nothing i guess for now.
I'm starting to have a huge distaste for the curved screens. Feels nice with the hardware buttons on my S3, but looks like utter garbage with a screen protector.
jackierobinson said:
The Spigen website.
I wonder if using the Google Bumper will hide the fact that it doesn't quite reach the edges.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The bumper does not cover it.
Also big warning for people looking to buy SGP: The light sensor is covered by this screen protector (not cut out like most) and it interfered with the functionality of the phone. In the past I've had screen protectors that went over the sensor without issue, but with this particular protector and phone, it did not work.
For example if i went to make a phone call, the screen would stay dark even if i took the screen away from my face. Also auto brightness didn't work either. I had to cut the film to expose the sensors. Everything is working normally now. Anyone else have this issue?
Also received mine today, dont have the phone yet though. Not feeling too happy about it already seeing as it doesnt cover the curved screen too well... Money down the drain then :s
Mine will arrive today and I plan to put it in a case so its not a big deal. The SGP on my Note 2 didn't go all the way to the edge either. A tpu case fixed that and everything was covered.
Sent from my Nexus 4 using Tapatalk 2
Good thing I waited. I am planning on using this phone with screen protectors only and I can't pay for a high quality one that looks pretty bad IMO.
Looks great. SGP never usually covers the entire front. It is always just a tad bit smaller.
You guys do know it has to be cut smaller because the curved edges will make the protector peel right?
ceejay83 said:
You guys do know it has to be cut smaller because the curved edges will make the protector peel right?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, I'm just hoping someone finds out a way to make t stick over the curved glass. I guess I am going to have to go with a wet screen protector.
ceejay83 said:
You guys do know it has to be cut smaller because the curved edges will make the protector peel right?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, but it stops way short of the curve. It literally just covers the display (width wise). They could have extended it a bit further. This is going to leave a gap, even with a TPU case on it.
How is the smoothness of these screen protectors? I really like the way zagg HD screen protectors feel and I'm looking for something similar.
Just received mine today. Installation was straightforward and the dust removal stickers easily snatched up the remaining few bits of dust at the end. The surface slickness is shockingly poor at first but improves drastically after just a few minutes.
The film doesn't run all the way to the edge due to the curvature of the screen, but there may be a solution. Steinheil makes a dry application edge to edge film called Curved Crystal for the SGS3 which also has a curved edge screen. If there is enough interest, I'm sure they will make one for the N4.
NYConex said:
How is the smoothness of these screen protectors? I really like the way zagg HD screen protectors feel and I'm looking for something similar.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm not sure how smooth the zagg HDs are, but right after you put the screen protector on, it is really tacky. But it gets much more smoother as you use it. I think that as you use it more, you're depositing more skin oils onto to screen protector and it kind of "seasons" the screen protector.
This sounds weird, but I just put a bunch of fingerprints on it, then I distributed it using a dry kimwipe (i'm sure a microfiber would work too) and after using it for about 24 hours, it's pretty much as slick as you would expect from the bare glass. Also, of course there is no orange peel feeling since this is a dry application screen protector.
ewuzh said:
Just received mine today. Installation was straightforward and the dust removal stickers easily snatched up the remaining few bits of dust at the end. The surface slickness is shockingly poor at first but improves drastically after just a few minutes.
The film doesn't run all the way to the edge due to the curvature of the screen, but there may be a solution. Steinheil makes a dry application edge to edge film called Curved Crystal for the SGS3 which also has a curved edge screen. If there is enough interest, I'm sure they will make one for the N4.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
they already emailed me back saying they don't have plans to make any.
http://www.iloome.com/Screen-Protector-ScreenMate-Premium-Tempered/dp/B00D8M1QUU/
For $27.99 shipped free (in the US anyway), seemed an ok price. Now I am coming from the Maru Tempered glass and that was a total waste of time and money. But that's another story.
I got my package a day ahead of schedule, kudos for speedy delivery of USPS here. When I got the package, the screen protector came in a nice thick box. My guess is to protect the iloome while in transit. When opening the box, you see instructions on how to install the protector. First and foremost, they say to look at the youtube videos and check out the installation vids posted by them. I viewed the GS4 video and that was really cool looking! I wonder why they didn't create a protector that is completely clear like the GS4 video shows. But whatever...I digress....
After checking the vid, I read the instruction card in the box a few times to make sure I didn't miss any steps. I practiced my placement of the protector a few times to align the camera and LED. Now saying that and looking at my phone, the front camera is a tad off. But I am OK with that because I don't take selfies lol. Or vid phone. Well anyways, I just turned it on to see if any of the protector was blocking the front cam and I am glad to report back no. All is clear.
After I put it on, tested PIE UI on it and increasing the trigger area, it works like it should. Is there any loss of responsiveness? A slight, but no where in the realms of the other protector I had, the Maru (boo!). Also I do see a oily spot smack in the middle of the phone. I cannot see it with the screen on, only when off
Anyways here's pics of it installed without and with the OEM White bumper. I am liking this protector so far!
Any questions please feel free to post them!
Thanks once I get back my money from maru I will pick this up. I just wish they cut out the camera
Sent from my Nexus 4 using xda premium
is it a fingerprint magnet?
what is the performance on the resistance of the fingerprint?
thanks
ping42 said:
is it a fingerprint magnet?
what is the performance on the resistance of the fingerprint?
thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It does attract fingerprints more than a simple screen protector. So yea it's a bit of a fingerprint magnet.
And after a half day of usage. I have to report it's not responsive as a screen protector, but it still works pretty good. I love the slickness of the glass. It's buttery smooth.
I have gotten over the oily or rainbow spot in the middle thus far. As long as it works as well as it does, I can deal with it and enjoy the smoothness.:good:
One of the things I love about the Nexus 4 are the curved edges. Does the iloome greatly diminish that? Thanks.
Sent from my Nexus 4
FallN said:
One of the things I love about the Nexus 4 are the curved edges. Does the iloome greatly diminish that? Thanks.
Sent from my Nexus 4
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes it does. I currently use a bumper and if I don't I use a case like the Ringke Fusion (when traveling). And when using those, the edges are pretty much gone, which I am used to since getting cases.
New day with the iloome...heading into the office this AM, and popping my phone on my orb charger, I noticed the screen get really dusty. I have to admit, my truck is dirty as all heaven lol, so I know where all the dust and debris came from. Just a dusting with a lint free cloth and good to go from there. Still loving it!
Thanks for the info. I appreciate it! I'm seriously considering getting one... Just want to make sure it doesn't have all the problems like the Maru...
1. When holding the phone naked (no case or bumper) does it add noticeable or considerable thickness in your hand?
(95% of the time I use my phone naked. The slim form factor of the Nexus 4 feels so good... Don't want to completely ruin that...)
2. Has the rainbow splotch in the middle of your screen gone away? If not, can you take a picture of it?
Thank you.
Sent from my Nexus 4
FallN said:
Thanks for the info. I appreciate it! I'm seriously considering getting one... Just want to make sure it doesn't have all the problems like the Maru...
1. When holding the phone naked (no case or bumper) does it add noticeable or considerable thickness in your hand?
(95% of the time I use my phone naked. The slim form factor of the Nexus 4 feels so good... Don't want to completely ruin that...)
2. Has the rainbow splotch in the middle of your screen gone away? If not, can you take a picture of it?
Thank you.
Sent from my Nexus 4
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I totally forgot about the blotch. I mean it was there yesterday and then when I just looked at it, it's gone! Lovely! And looking at the phone without the bumper, with the just the iloome looks a bit odd IMO. I wouldn't use it without a case or bumper, but that's me. I think it's because I know the edges are there and naked I KNOW what it's supposed to look like lol. I mean it doesn't look bad. To me it kinda looks like a thick screen protector on it. Would I leave it on naked? Personally no, because when you drop the phone naked, it's most likely going to crack somewhere. But if your goal is to protect the face, I wouldn't bank on it entirely. Well...without a case of some sort anyways.
EDIT: just took the bumper off and took a good look at it...
To me, it looks like a Nexus One! LOL A bit bigger, but has the "look" when the black painted sides are visible. I mean if it was clear, I may have a different opinion? I dunno lol.
Also, I noticed a hairline scratch under the protector which can only be seen with the screen off and at an angle. I emailed iloome last night, took a picture this morning and an hour later, they issued a refund and I get to keep the protector. Great customer service!
Sounds awesome. Does the protector have beveled edges?
bkoon1218 said:
Sounds awesome. Does the protector have beveled edges?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nope. Look at the third pic.
Does death gripping the phone with the bumper make the protector lift? If you have a Ringke Fusion, I would really appreciate it if you could test with that!
Thanks!
bkoon1218 said:
Does death gripping the phone with the bumper make the protector lift? If you have a Ringke Fusion, I would really appreciate it if you could test with that!
Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My Fusion case is at work so I'll report back to you sometime on Monday when I get back in my office. Feel free to remind me!
are there any tempered glass screen protectors that have curved edges? i like to use my phone without a case
Dimatchka said:
are there any tempered glass screen protectors that have curved edges? i like to use my phone without a case
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not that I am aware of, sorry.
Dimatchka said:
are there any tempered glass screen protectors that have curved edges? i like to use my phone without a case
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah I'm the same way. I love the slim dimensions and buttery smoothness of my N4 naked but still want a little protection for the front and back glass... And I hate the rubbery feeling of normal screen protectors so they aren't an option.
I'm willing to pay top dollar but the few glass screen protectors they have are either garbage (i.e. Maru) or don't offer a really thin profile with rounded edges...
Sent from my Nexus 4
bkoon1218 said:
Does death gripping the phone with the bumper make the protector lift? If you have a Ringke Fusion, I would really appreciate it if you could test with that!
Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Pics of the iloome tempered glass screen protector with Ringke Fusion case. Looks good! LOL I can say it JUST fits with the Fusion on. Any higher or wider and the screen protector will come off.
EDIT: Put back the Fusion and pressing the sides will case the lip of the Fusion case to slip under the glass and cause a popping noise. Even though I don't see any lifting of the glass, I can see that it may do so with constant gripping on the sides.
Thanks! You're awesome! I was worried the protector would lift when I grip the phone too hard with a case on. It happened with my Fantom 4.
bkoon1218 said:
Thanks! You're awesome! I was worried the protector would lift when I grip the phone too hard with a case on. It happened with my Fantom 4.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
WAIT! LOL
I just put it back on and based on the "tight grip". I hear a pop when pressed together and hear a pop on the sides of the phone...So it will lift IMO eventually sorry!
Oh nooooo! I guess I'll decide between running my phone naked or stick with my case, lol. The bumper is fine though?
bkoon1218 said:
Oh nooooo! I guess I'll decide between running my phone naked or stick with my case, lol. The bumper is fine though?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes the bumper is fine. When gripping it tightly, the bumper stays into place. I think the Ringke has some give and the lip slips under the glass a bit to create that popping sound.
I ordered the Clarivue tempered glass one as well and apparently is thinner and no black marking, making it completely clear,which I prefer, but will report back if it works on both bumper and Fusion. Stay tuned! I should get it by the end of this week or next Monday the latest.
However, if it doesn't work with PA PIE UI, then it's dead to me lol. So for moment the iloome wins out thus far.
I just ordered my new Moto X 2014, I'm actually getting it for free to replace my old Moto X.
What are some good case and screen protector combinations? I know in the past I've had some trouble with a case AND a screen protector, it's sometimes one or the other. I'd prefer a clear case, but I'll probably end up getting more than 1 anyways.
blueice5249 said:
I just ordered my new Moto X 2014, I'm actually getting it for free to replace my old Moto X.
What are some good case and screen protector combinations? I know in the past I've had some trouble with a case AND a screen protector, it's sometimes one or the other. I'd prefer a clear case, but I'll probably end up getting more than 1 anyways.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just got mine as well here is what I have found so far:
All tempered glass is a waste of money for this model none if it fits right at all due to the rounded edges
I would ASSUME the older plastic style ones MIGHT work better but read they also dont work that well
Most cases that say they are clear are actually frosted and that for me defeats the purpose of customizing the back
So I am going naked screen and hula case and will carry the phone in a belt pouch. Not the perfect solution but for me its acceptable. I would have preferred a strong clear tpu case (most turn yellow), I dont want a hard case, and would have love tempered glass on this but they simply dont adhere correctly.
There you have it the sad but true facts about cases and screen protectors from the research I have done. Hopefully some others in here can give you better news
adm1jtg said:
Just got mine as well here is what I have found so far:
All tempered glass is a waste of money for this model none if it fits right at all due to the rounded edges
I would ASSUME the older plastic style ones MIGHT work better but read they also dont work that well
Most cases that say they are clear are actually frosted and that for me defeats the purpose of customizing the back
So I am going naked screen and hula case and will carry the phone in a belt pouch. Not the perfect solution but for me its acceptable. I would have preferred a strong clear tpu case (most turn yellow), I dont want a hard case, and would have love tempered glass on this but they simply dont adhere correctly.
There you have it the sad but true facts about cases and screen protectors from the research I have done. Hopefully some others in here can give you better news
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't mind a hard case and not a fan of the glass screen protectors. I like the film ones. My last film protector made it a matte screen and took the glare away. It was fantastic! And it worked with the case. But it's the only smartphone that I've had where screen protector AND case can be used.
blueice5249 said:
I don't mind a hard case and not a fan of the glass screen protectors. I like the film ones. My last film protector made it a matte screen and took the glare away. It was fantastic! And it worked with the case. But it's the only smartphone that I've had where screen protector AND case can be used.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I guess no one else has found better solutions. The naked case is a decent hard clear case though expensive and also prone to yellowing
adm1jtg said:
I guess no one else has found better solutions. The naked case is a decent hard clear case though expensive and also prone to yellowing
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's either going to be the Gelli Black Frost case or the Hula Bumper case initially. I'm getting one of those for free if I buy a screen protector, which I was going to do anyways.
I just can't get anyone to tell me what one of those cases, if any, work with a screen protector. I've been trying to get someone to answer this question for 2-3 days now. Nobody on earth knows! lol
blueice5249 said:
It's either going to be the Gelli Black Frost case or the Hula Bumper case initially. I'm getting one of those for free if I buy a screen protector, which I was going to do anyways.
I just can't get anyone to tell me what one of those cases, if any, work with a screen protector. I've been trying to get someone to answer this question for 2-3 days now. Nobody on earth knows! lol
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have the hula bumper case and i can't see any reason it would interfere at all with a screen protector. When I tried my glass protector it was in combination with the hula. Honestly thought most screen protectors are so think that they can be used with almost any case.
adm1jtg said:
I have the hula bumper case and i can't see any reason it would interfere at all with a screen protector. When I tried my glass protector it was in combination with the hula. Honestly thought most screen protectors are so think that they can be used with almost any case.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The glass is usually cut thinner, the film isn't always cut thinner and I've had instances where the cases would peel up the edges of the film. How did you like you Hula?
blueice5249 said:
The glass is usually cut thinner, the film isn't always cut thinner and I've had instances where the cases would peel up the edges of the film. How did you like you Hula?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I love the look, not sure it would truly give a huge amount of protection but should protect the edges of the glass on the screen which i read is the most vulnerable part of the phone. It does have a little but of movement when you hold the phone (aka wiggles slightly) but it also adds more grip, i have a plastic backed phone.. Those damn beveled edges, nice concept, nightmare in reality. They are why no glass or other screen protector will truly fit right.
adm1jtg said:
I love the look, not sure it would truly give a huge amount of protection but should protect the edges of the glass on the screen which i read is the most vulnerable part of the phone. It does have a little but of movement when you hold the phone (aka wiggles slightly) but it also adds more grip, i have a plastic backed phone.. Those damn beveled edges, nice concept, nightmare in reality. They are why no glass or other screen protector will truly fit right.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How bad is the wiggling? I have a bit of OCD so sometimes things like that will really bug me.
blueice5249 said:
How bad is the wiggling? I have a bit of OCD so sometimes things like that will really bug me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
When holding or using the phone its fine. I am also extremely OCD and when it moves/wiggles is like when you just tap the side with your finger you can feel it move very slightly, very slight;y but for me noticeable, but not enough to get rid of the case just makes the phone look awesome.
These are not my pics but its how my phone looks
https://onedrive.live.com/?cid=89BBC42D0064FA66&id=89bbc42d0064fa66!1491&authkey=!AAcLU2pED71lK04
Also if you can order the hula from case mate rather then moto as moto charges an extra $5 shipping. They are also at times very hard to find in stock anywhere depending on the color you want.
adm1jtg said:
When holding or using the phone its fine. I am also extremely OCD and when it moves/wiggles is like when you just tap the side with your finger you can feel it move very slightly, very slight;y but for me noticeable, but not enough to get rid of the case just makes the phone look awesome.
These are not my pics but its how my phone looks
https://onedrive.live.com/?cid=89BBC42D0064FA66&id=89bbc42d0064fa66!1491&authkey=!AAcLU2pED71lK04
Also if you can order the hula from case mate rather then moto as moto charges an extra $5 shipping. They are also at times very hard to find in stock anywhere depending on the color you want.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I really like the way that looks. My phone is Royal Blue, White Front, and Red Trim. So it's between a white or red hula case, or the gelli case. I'm leaning towards the Hula for more everyday use I think, and buying another case from amazon for when i need more protection. Or buying the hula and getting a good protecting case from moto's website
I have a coupon code from Moto for $25 off, so Im buying the screen protector and I basically get any case for free.
blueice5249 said:
I really like the way that looks. My phone is Royal Blue, White Front, and Red Trim. So it's between a white or red hula case, or the gelli case. I'm leaning towards the Hula for more everyday use I think, and buying another case from amazon for when i need more protection. Or buying the hula and getting a good protecting case from moto's website
I have a coupon code from Moto for $25 off, so Im buying the screen protector and I basically get any case for free.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I use the hulu and a cheap leather holster with belt clip to carry it in. Its extremely cheaply made but fits real well.
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B001H3ON0W/ref=oh_aui_detailpage_o07_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1
I have the Hulu and the Trident Aegis. The plastic on the Hulu cracked at the USB port area (from bending when removed or put on), but it doesn't effect the case
I've been using the Hula bumper and Power Support Brilliant Film screen protector. The edge of the case doesn't contact the screen protector so it doesn't peel.
nbell13 said:
I have the Hulu and the Trident Aegis. The plastic on the Hulu cracked at the USB port area (from bending when removed or put on), but it doesn't effect the case
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks! I heard one other person had a problem with cracking. Very good to know beforehand, I'll make sure to be a bit more careful.
braves10 said:
I've been using the Hula bumper and Power Support Brilliant Film screen protector. The edge of the case doesn't contact the screen protector so it doesn't peel.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you! This is exactly what I wanted to know! :highfive::good:
adm1jtg said:
When holding or using the phone its fine. I am also extremely OCD and when it moves/wiggles is like when you just tap the side with your finger you can feel it move very slightly, very slight;y but for me noticeable, but not enough to get rid of the case just makes the phone look awesome.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Weird question, but do you think there's enough give with the Hula case where it would fit around the Moto X in a thin TPU case? I like the TPU cases but worry about the protection or lack thereof. Just wondering if it'd be possible to use them and occasional put the Hula Case around them for extra protection. Of course the buttons probably wouldn't work then...
fldude said:
Weird question, but do you think there's enough give with the Hula case where it would fit around the Moto X in a thin TPU case? I like the TPU cases but worry about the protection or lack thereof. Just wondering if it'd be possible to use them and occasional put the Hula Case around them for extra protection. Of course the buttons probably wouldn't work then...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You wont be able to use the two together, to much of a lip on the back with the hula case. Even if you did somehow fit it on the tpu would never touch the back of the phone just the lip around the edge. TPU will likely give more protection then hula but hula will likely give more grip then a tpu case.
New to the X, is it worth while getting a screen protector? Case is on its way, but with Gorilla Glass 3, is it truly worth the extra to cover the screen? Probably will end up with one but wanted some other opinions!
xKroniK13x said:
New to the X, is it worth while getting a screen protector? Case is on its way, but with Gorilla Glass 3, is it truly worth the extra to cover the screen? Probably will end up with one but wanted some other opinions!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That is completely up to you but I can tell you this based on my research and personal experience:
There is not a tempered glass screen protector on the market for the 2014 that adheres properly. Not one of them works well and thus dont bother with those. The 2014 tapered edges on the glass are the issue. I have HEARD of similar issues with PET style screen protectors but never messed with those as they never felt right to me.
Lastly everything I have read says those tapered edges o the glas DO make it more prone to crack or brake on a drop so you need SOMETHING to protect the glass edges. Full case, hula bumper, something....
blueice5249 said:
Thanks! I heard one other person had a problem with cracking. Very good to know beforehand, I'll make sure to be a bit more careful.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
A lot of the cracking that people report is from dropping their phones, not taking the Hula on and off. The Hula is designed to absorb the shock of a drop and it breaks so that the phone does not. Better that your $20 bumper break than your $600 phone.
I take my Hula off and on all of the time and it has never cracked. I think people are dropping their phones and the Hula is doing exactly what it is supposed to do - absorbing the shock, which can result in it cracking instead of your phone.
After having seen all of the issues with the glass screen protectors for this phone, I decided that I needed to try something else in the meantime. While I have a Sakai glass one that I ordered from ebay that is due roughly a month from now, I'm not very hopeful for it working. As a result of all of this and the need for a screen protector ASAP, I went with the Spigen screen protectors that I have seen mentioned on here. Having used PET films in the past, I was expecting a huge hassle. Bubbles, cheap feeling etc. Turns out, these worked REALLY damn well, to my complete surprise.
Installation:
Installation was quite easy, much easier than the older thin film screen protectors that I remember. You simply clean the surface of the phone, following the instructions. Place the tabs on the screen protector to help you position it. Then carefully position it properly keeping an eye on the edges and the sensors. It adheres to the screen very much like a glass screen protector does. There are a few small bubbles here and there, but they squeegee right out. I ended up with two permanent bubbles (one by the light sensor and one near the edge). Neither were the fault of the screen protector, both were caused by me rushing and nicking the surface of the screen protector when squeegee-ing the bubbles out. I think I could easily get it on there next time with zero bubbles. Way less hassle than any other attempt I have had with a film screen protector. One complaint I have is that they only included one alcohol wipe (everything else is in multiples), I don't know if I just got unlucky or they aren't thinking. Anyways, I have access to many solvents at work. No big deal for me.
Result:
How does it feel? A bit more plasticy than the usual glass screen protector but otherwise surprisingly nice. It adheres to the curves perfectly with no major bubbles, clarity-wise it is crystal clear. I honestly can't tell it is there. It adheres nicely to the curves of the display without any gaps (other than my nicks at the edge). My Otterbox Commuter case fits right over the top of it with ZERO problems. I was expecting these to be a stop-gap measure until the better glass ones come out but honestly I don't see anything wrong with these as is and would be just fine using these alone. I am not sure about longevity as I just installed it but so far I am actually surprisingly happy with it, especially for the cost. If you are on the fence between glass and plastic. Go with these plastic screen protectors for now and let the manufacturers work out the difficulties of the glass ones. Then you can decide later if you really want the glass one for you phone.
Link:
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B01B1GQDGG/ref=oh_aui_detailpage_o00_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1
it will get scratched to **** within 2 weeks don't worry. Then you'll have to use another of the 3 that came with it.
Agreed with everything that OP posted, and agreed with the person above. Mine got scratched within a day but I got over it.
I installed one only because I tried three different Temper glass ones and none sealed correctly. I like it so far installed very good, covers the entire screen. So far so good.
I got a soft screen protector from AliExpress. It's a bit tricky to apply at first but once you get the idea it's not so bad.
The screen protector is really good! It's like silicon , doesn't get scratched easily.
Best part? it's 1.4$ each! What else can you ask for..?
Link:
http://www.aliexpress.com/item/For-LG-G5-Full-Coverage-Soft-Screen-Protector-Guard-Film-for-LG-G5/32618522429.html?spm=2114.13010608.0.54.iHJztH
Here:
Yup good screen protector but it does scuff, so is it perfect no, but one of the better non temper glass protector
I just tried and failed to apply all three. I can't be doing with bubbles or marks on the screen, and who in their right mind decided to put adhesive on a screen protector.
First one too many bubbles, second one, dust, bubbles and scratches, third one, same.
Add to the fact it feels like a ZAGG invisible shield, rubbery rather than glassy.. I will keep it naked from now on.
I have an Xtreme skin skin to install, wish me luck, i'll bloody well need it haha.
Jonathan-H said:
I just tried and failed to apply all three. I can't be doing with bubbles or marks on the screen, and who in their right mind decided to put adhesive on a screen protector.
First one too many bubbles, second one, dust, bubbles and scratches, third one, same.
Add to the fact it feels like a ZAGG invisible shield, rubbery rather than glassy.. I will keep it naked from now on.
I have an Xtreme skin skin to install, wish me luck, i'll bloody well need it haha.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I got the dark oak Xtremeskin!
I've put on a tempered glass before, it was kinda bad, lost saturation and brightness, and i got a clear case from spigen, but the case's lips protudes to the center so much that it started to push the screen protectir out!, I eventually removed the tempered glass... Not usre which screen protector to apply on with the spigen case :/
The Spigen Crystal Clear is too thin in my opinion - I killed it within a week. My old Spigen Steinheil Ultra on the S4 was way better. Purchased a CrocFol Premium instead.
Yup I have to change my opinion as well, used it for a bit, scuffed easily, stays clear without the rainbow effect. I had a few defects in my screen protectors, changed them out. Using the otterbox Defender case for now.
1$ tempered glass (rectangular) from AliExpress are perfect of you dont care leaving the top curved part unprotected. No bubbles, no rainbows, no effect on colors\contrast\clarity.
I just got my essential phone and I'm really honestly digging it. I think that it's a very nice phone that fits my needs well.
However, within a day and a half I have already scratched my screen. Its dead center on the screen and like an inch long Literally got the phone on Saturday and scratched it by Monday early AM. I didn't do anything with the phone besides take it in and out of my pocket. Didn't even make it to work with the phone yet. So I'm pretty upset about that.
I know it's gorilla glass 5, but I have never scratched a phone so quick before. Hell my old phone (Moto X pure) Only had one small scratch after running it for 2.5 years without any screen protection at all, including numerous drops and rough handling.
So I guess a screen protector is a must. I ordered a tudia case and a tempered glass screen protector off Amazon. The screen protector is garbage. I hate it. The edges of the screen protector do NOT stick down, even without the case. The edge all the way around the screen is lifted. It looks terrible.
Are there any screen protectors for this phone that are actually decent? I would rather deal with the chance of more scratches than stare at this awful screen protector with unstuck edges.
Photo of the terrible edges.
I'm curious to know too
I haven't found a good tempered glass for this phone. They all seem to have issues. I've been using the IQ Shield wet install screen protector. Not tempered glass but looks and feels great (almost as smooth as glass), self healing and works with cases if you get the case friendly version.
Sent from my Essential PH-1 using Tapatalk
glass screen protectors are nicer, but they suck on this phone.
I went with wet install plastic in the end because it does the main reason for one, protect from scratches, I'm confident it will.
I just hate the wet install process.
but my experience with glass is it doesn't protect from breaking anyway. any significant hit that would break the screen will break the screen no matter what. I think a bumper case is most effective.
I'm using the this one.
https://smile.amazon.com/Orzero-Ess...8718314&sr=8-1&keywords=essential+ph-1+orzero
You need to clean your screen really, really, really good before you apply it.
Any oils will show up as a rainbow effect or something close.
I've been using it for weeks now with no lifting with a Tudia case.
Some people say they pop off. That has not been my experience. YMMV
tech_head said:
I'm using the this one.
https://smile.amazon.com/Orzero-Ess...8718314&sr=8-1&keywords=essential+ph-1+orzero
You need to clean your screen really, really, really good before you apply it.
Any oils will show up as a rainbow effect or something close.
I've been using it for weeks now with no lifting with a Tudia case.
Some people say they pop off. That has not been my experience. YMMV
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I also use this one. I have actually already gone through 5 of them... It seems like some of them are more sticky than others maybe. Initially I used them without out a case and they would come off all the time, but since I've had the Tudia case 1 fell off and the new one has been on there 3 weeks.
My opinion is they are hit or miss... just hope 1 of 3 is good.
ecstaticnoodle said:
I also use this one. I have actually already gone through 5 of them... It seems like some of them are more sticky than others maybe. Initially I used them without out a case and they would come off all the time, but since I've had the Tudia case 1 fell off and the new one has been on there 3 weeks.
My opinion is they are hit or miss... just hope 1 of 3 is good.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My guess is that these don't stick to the edges as well, but they are black, so you can't see it, therefor they peel off
idbl_fanatic said:
My guess is that these don't stick to the edges as well, but they are black, so you can't see it, therefor they peel off
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That is correct, but I have tried a couple of other brands as well and they are all like that. I only continue to buy these because there come as a 3 pack and are like $10.
ecstaticnoodle said:
That is correct, but I have tried a couple of other brands as well and they are all like that. I only continue to buy these because there come as a 3 pack and are like $10.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What I don't understand is why they are having such an issue with it, I had the LG V20 and it has curved edges, but they make them for it with no issues
idbl_fanatic said:
What I don't understand is why they are having such an issue with it, I had the LG V20 and it has curved edges, but they make them for it with no issues
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Manufacturers not that bright?
I use incipio, be careful, the installation instructions are very tricky, I messed up mine while installing, lost 40$
I'm waiting to see if they will send me a new one
So is the Incipio screen protector any good? I don't even care that it's $40, if it sticks down properly without the bubble around the edges I'll buy it.
I am also interested in finding a better screen protector. I have been using the IQ Shield LiQuidSkin, which worked great for a few weeks, but now a corner is peeling up, I assume from pulling it in and out of my pocket. I might go ahead and get another one if I can't find anything better. Would love a tempered glass protector if someone actually makes a decent one!
PaulieMyk said:
I am also interested in finding a better screen protector. I have been using the IQ Shield LiQuidSkin, which worked great for a few weeks, but now a corner is peeling up, I assume from pulling it in and out of my pocket. I might go ahead and get another one if I can't find anything better. Would love a tempered glass protector if someone actually makes a decent one!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Bought a 3 pack of the ozeros on Amazon. 1st on sucked. 2nd one I put on a few weeks later has been perfect. No rainbow of adhesion issues. Use a clear tpu case with it as well.
[2-Pack] Essential Phone [Upgraded with Full Adhesive] Tempered Glass Screen Protector, XKAUDIE 2.5D Arc Edges, 9 Hardness, HD, Anti-Scratch, For Essential Phone / Essential phone PH-1 https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0784N7KR9/ref=cm_sw_r_other_apa_KzVIAbKJ76G0M
Just seen this and ordered. I shall see.
..best way is to use loca glue with the glass screen protector.
Sent from my PH-1 using Tapatalk
rogconnect said:
[2-Pack] Essential Phone [Upgraded with Full Adhesive] Tempered Glass Screen Protector, XKAUDIE 2.5D Arc Edges, 9 Hardness, HD, Anti-Scratch, For Essential Phone / Essential phone PH-1 https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0784N7KR9/ref=cm_sw_r_other_apa_KzVIAbKJ76G0M
Just seen this and ordered. I shall see.
..best way is to use loca glue with the glass screen protector.
Sent from my PH-1 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
u may want to read the most recent reviews
yenkoPR said:
I use incipio, be careful, the installation instructions are very tricky, I messed up mine while installing, lost 40$
I'm waiting to see if they will send me a new one
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
$40 !!! Holy crap!
https://photos.app.goo.gl/HJi7Qb3AIpttVp142
Xtreme guard spartan glass screen protector.
sigma_wrx said:
https://photos.app.goo.gl/HJi7Qb3AIpttVp142
Xtreme guard spartan glass screen protector.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Where did you purchase? I'm not even seeing it for the Essential PH-1 on the official website....Nevermind, had to do a manual search for our model.