/Vendor won't unmount in recovery - HTC U12+ Questions & Answers

/Vendor won't unmount in recovery - HTC U12+ Questions & Answers

Hi guys,
Just looking for some information, or maybe we could get a successful discussion on this matter to help others who might come across this issue.
I was getting a bootloop after flashing the latest Dolby Atmos build via Magisk Manager. I'm on Magisk 17.1
I could successfully reach recovery and I could successfully restore /system, /data and /boot from an earlier back up. But I couldn't restore /vendor, because TWRP could not unmount it.
I know that this is fixable via RUU (which is what I did in the end), though i'd like to understand what is happening and how to fix it without RUU (if it is even possible at all).
As mentioned in other posts, uninstalling Magisk is impossible without /Vendor being unmounted.
Any help and information is appreciated. I'll continue investigating to see if there's any further info for me to find.

Kyuubi10 said:
As mentioned in other posts, uninstalling Magisk is impossible without /Vendor being unmounted.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's simply wrong. You should have installed Magisk using the Magisk Manager and a stock boot image in your internal SD card, by using the patch boot image method in Magisk Manager and flash it afterwards. Thus uninstalling Magisk would simply be to flash an unpatched stock boot image.
Sent from my HTC U12+ using XDA Labs

5m4r7ph0n36uru said:
That's simply wrong. You should have installed Magisk using the Magisk Manager and a stock boot image in your internal SD card, by using the patch boot image method in Magisk Manager and flash it afterwards. Thus uninstalling Magisk would simply be to flash an unpatched stock boot image.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, that isn't an "uninstall"... What you described is an overwrite.
Flashing RUU does the exact same thing.
I'm talking about flashing the magisk uninstaller zip. - that is a true uninstall.
Maybe were getting semantics wrong, should we start defining the meaning of "uninstall" from now on?

Kyuubi10 said:
No, that isn't an "uninstall"... What you described is an overwrite.
Flashing RUU does the exact same thing.
I'm talking about flashing the magisk uninstaller zip. - that is a true uninstall.
Maybe were getting semantics wrong, should we start defining the meaning of "uninstall" from now on?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Man I'm not stupid and know exactly that it's "just" an overwrite.
But if you used the patch boot image method in Magisk Manager, and flashed the patched boot to "install" Magisk, you could uninstall all modules in Magisk Mananger and afterwards flash the stock boot and you'll be done uninstalling Magisk anyway. In this very case the uninstaller isn't needed at all.
Learn about the different ways on how to install and uninstall Magisk and you'll see that I'm right, as I clearly defined the installation method as well. Maybe you still didn't understand the different ways of how to install and uninstall Magisk.
If you flashed Magisk through TWRP yeah you're done and may have to flash a RUU. But anyone who read up on
this very topic and knew all basics of how Magisk and rooting on Treble A/B devices currently works would have known that one prior to rooting as well. It's stated in a lot of threads and happens on other devices as well, that Magisk isn't allowed to mount and alter vendor.
Sent from my HTC U12+ using XDA Labs

5m4r7ph0n36uru said:
Man I'm not stupid and know exactly that it's "just" an overwrite.
But if you used the patch boot image method in Magisk Manager, and flashed the patched boot to "install" Magisk, you could uninstall all modules in Magisk Mananger and afterwards flash the stock boot and you'll be done uninstalling Magisk anyway. In this very case the uninstaller isn't needed at all.
Learn about the different ways on how to install and uninstall Magisk and you'll see that I'm right, as I clearly defined the installation method as well. Maybe you still didn't understand the different ways of how to install and uninstall Magisk.
If you flashed Magisk through TWRP yeah you're done and may have to flash a RUU. But anyone who read up on
this very topic and knew all basics of how Magisk and rooting on Treble A/B devices currently works would have known that one prior to rooting as well. It's stated in a lot of threads and happens on other devices as well, that Magisk isn't allowed to mount and alter vendor.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Brilliant! You should have started with this.
I'm looking for knowledge and information.
To be given a solution which I'm already aware of is useless to me. This thread was my way of asking for information... And telling me "i'm simply wrong" and then using wrong semantics for your explanation is a sure fire way of getting someone to call you stupid (though I never said it, and you simply implied it. Very good victim complex there).
In my daily job semantics are VERY important... So I absolutely WILL point out words used in the wrong context when I come across them.
It's just what I'm used to.
So next time choose your words very carefully not to confuse myself or others who come across this post.
Uninstall is a script designed to "uninstall" something... If I overwrite the entire partition manually, then it's not an uninstall.
Now that we have that out of the way, lets move on to building information that the community can make use of.
1. Magisk no longer can mess with a vendor partition. (Is this truly across the board? On all A/B devices? Can you post threads with more information please?)
2. You advise that the best way to install Magisk on A/B devices is via flashing patched boot... This is very interesting.
3. From your signature I noticed you've got different set ups in your A/B partitions.
I like that, do you have a guide where I can learn more?

5m4r7ph0n36uru said:
Man I'm not stupid and know exactly that it's "just" an overwrite.
But if you used the patch boot image method in Magisk Manager, and flashed the patched boot to "install" Magisk, you could uninstall all modules in Magisk Mananger and afterwards flash the stock boot and you'll be done uninstalling Magisk anyway. In this very case the uninstaller isn't needed at all.
Learn about the different ways on how to install and uninstall Magisk and you'll see that I'm right, as I clearly defined the installation method as well. Maybe you still didn't understand the different ways of how to install and uninstall Magisk.
If you flashed Magisk through TWRP yeah you're done and may have to flash a RUU. But anyone who read up on
this very topic and knew all basics of how Magisk and rooting on Treble A/B devices currently works would have known that one prior to rooting as well. It's stated in a lot of threads and happens on other devices as well, that Magisk isn't allowed to mount and alter vendor.
Sent from my HTC U12+ using XDA Labs
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Also additionally, why can't TWRP mount/unmount Vendor?
Is that something that's already been discussed prior as well?
because that's the bigger problem I had.

Hi,
It would be nice to find how to format the partition 'vendor' and reinstall via TWRP? it's a problem for a complete custom rom that includes the 'vendor' part!
PS: With Super-R kitchen 'vendor' does not flash !!

Alan-B said:
Hi,
It would be nice to find how to format the partition 'vendor' and reinstall via TWRP? it's a problem for a complete custom rom that includes the 'vendor' part!
PS: With Super-R kitchen 'vendor' does not flash !!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
As far as I've experienced after a fresh RUU i can flash vendor.
But not after the first boot.

Related

Most up to date rooting method for HTC A9?

Hi, I rooted my a9 back in May right around when 6.0.1 came out. Long story short, my device just gave up the ghost after a nasty interaction between the screen and concrete, so now I have a new device being shipped tomorrow. I figured the first thing I'll do is let it run any updates / OTAs it might have to get it up to date then attempt to root again.
I've been looking around for the past several hours trying to determine what the correct rooting method might be now given Nougat's rollout, but I haven't come across anything truly definitive yet. If anyone could enlighten me on what I'll need to do now to root this new version I'd be very appreciative.
Thanks in advance guys!

Just got the phone today and updated to 7.0 (software version 2.18.651.2) Still searching around and not seeing a definitive answer on whether or not the old method for rooting works for this or not. I'm hesitant to attempt it without knowing, so any advice would be greatly appreciated.
Last time I rooted, I used Windroid toolkid to unlock the bootloader, flash TWRP and apply SU. I'm wondering, would the same program work if I replaced the recovery.img file in the Data folder with the TWRP 3.0.3 unofficial recovery I saw floating around in here for nougat?

txag2011 said:
Just got the phone today and updated to 7.0 (software version 2.18.651.2) Still searching around and not seeing a definitive answer on whether or not the old method for rooting works for this or not. I'm hesitant to attempt it without knowing, so any advice would be greatly appreciated.
Last time I rooted, I used Windroid toolkid to unlock the bootloader, flash TWRP and apply SU. I'm wondering, would the same program work if I replaced the recovery.img file in the Data folder with the TWRP 3.0.3 unofficial recovery I saw floating around in here for nougat?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can unlock it on the HTCDEV website, although if you've already got it unlocked I doubt you need to do it again. To root I just ADB fastboot flashed TWRP 3.0.3-4, then used that to flash Magisk, mounting system read only. I'm fairly sure some people are using Su on Nougat, so it'll probably work.
Never used the Windroid toolkit so I can't comment on that, but I've also never minded typing commands to the prompt. I'd imagine if you gave it the right TWRP it'd flash it OK..

JohnRogers23 said:
You can unlock it on the HTCDEV website, although if you've already got it unlocked I doubt you need to do it again. To root I just ADB fastboot flashed TWRP 3.0.3-4, then used that to flash Magisk, mounting system read only. I'm fairly sure some people are using Su on Nougat, so it'll probably work.
Never used the Windroid toolkit so I can't comment on that, but I've also never minded typing commands to the prompt. I'd imagine if you gave it the right TWRP it'd flash it OK..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That actually doesn't sound too bad; From that it seems like the process is still more or less the same. Why is the system mounted as read only though? After looking through most of the older step by step guides it doesn't mention anything about doing that. From what I see, after i run the command "fastboot flash recovery recovery.img" i boot into TWRP and then proceed to do a factory reset and wipe the cache, presumably to remove the encryption iirc, then install the supersu.zip is that still the correct procedure, or does this require mounting the system as read only now?
If you don't mind me asking, what steps exactly did you take to root yours? from what I've found all I need to do is get the bootloader unlocked with the steps from HTCDev, drop into download more, fastboot flash recovery recovery.img to get TWRP, boot into TWRP, run a format to get rid of the encryption, then install supersu.zip and that should be it. IS this correct or am I missing something?

I'm about to start the process trying to root using the above methods.. I'll post again when I have results.

txag2011 said:
That actually doesn't sound too bad; From that it seems like the process is still more or less the same. Why is the system mounted as read only though? After looking through most of the older step by step guides it doesn't mention anything about doing that. From what I see, after i run the command "fastboot flash recovery recovery.img" i boot into TWRP and then proceed to do a factory reset and wipe the cache, presumably to remove the encryption iirc, then install the supersu.zip is that still the correct procedure, or does this require mounting the system as read only now?
If you don't mind me asking, what steps exactly did you take to root yours? from what I've found all I need to do is get the bootloader unlocked with the steps from HTCDev, drop into download more, fastboot flash recovery recovery.img to get TWRP, boot into TWRP, run a format to get rid of the encryption, then install supersu.zip and that should be it. IS this correct or am I missing something?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It wasn't bad at all. The reason I mounted R/O is because I'm using Magisk and not disabling dm-verity. I'm not sure if it works the same on 7, but SuperSu should disable dm-verity, so if you're using it you might not need to mount R/O, I haven't been keeping up on that at all. Benefits of Magisk include Android Pay and being able to take an OTA.
That all sounds like exactly what you need to do, except I believe it's fastboot mode (the one with the black screen?) to flash TWRP. I also didn't have to format anything, but I believe you do if you're using Su and disabling forced encryption. You may want to take a system image backup before you change anything, so you can go back to stock and get an OTA, or in case something goes wrong, but other than that it sounds correct to me.

JohnRogers23 said:
It wasn't bad at all. The reason I mounted R/O is because I'm using Magisk and not disabling dm-verity. I'm not sure if it works the same on 7, but SuperSu should disable dm-verity, so if you're using it you might not need to mount R/O, I haven't been keeping up on that at all. Benefits of Magisk include Android Pay and being able to take an OTA.
That all sounds like exactly what you need to do, except I believe it's fastboot mode (the one with the black screen?) to flash TWRP. I also didn't have to format anything, but I believe you do if you're using Su and disabling forced encryption. You may want to take a system image backup before you change anything, so you can go back to stock and get an OTA, or in case something goes wrong, but other than that it sounds correct to me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
huh... Magisk can utilize android pay and OTA's? I'm a little bit intrigued.. I just might have to give that a quick look now. Was it difficult to get up and running, and is there a fairly decent guide for doing it?

txag2011 said:
huh... Magisk can utilize android pay and OTA's? I'm a little bit intrigued.. I just might have to give that a quick look now. Was it difficult to get up and running, and is there a fairly decent guide for doing it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Magisk is a framework for systemlessly modifying /system, so safety net works and you can take an OTA (with stock recovery), and also includes root. It's brilliant, but not quite as powerful as Xposed. Not difficult at all to get running, all it needs is to flash the magisk installer zip in TWRP (system mounted R/O of course) and then install the Magisk Manager app from the play store.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/official-magisk-v7-universal-systemless-t3473445

JohnRogers23 said:
Magisk is a framework for systemlessly modifying /system, so safety net works and you can take an OTA (with stock recovery), and also includes root. It's brilliant, but not quite as powerful as Xposed. Not difficult at all to get running, all it needs is to flash the magisk installer zip in TWRP (system mounted R/O of course) and then install the Magisk Manager app from the play store.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/official-magisk-v7-universal-systemless-t3473445
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I might give this a shot then, thank you for that. I'm about to try flashing TWRP 3.0.3-0. From the looks of it this is the most current one available. I'll update when it's done

txag2011 said:
I might give this a shot then, thank you for that. I'm about to try flashing TWRP 3.0.3-0. From the looks of it this is the most current one available. I'll update when it's done
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Go to the TWRP thread, hit the download tab, pick one of the newer ones there. I went with 3.0.3.-4.

JohnRogers23 said:
Go to the TWRP thread, hit the download tab, pick one of the newer ones there. I went with 3.0.3.-4.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did just that. Got TWRP installed successfully. I PM'ed you a second ago but I might as well ask this here for everyone else to see in case someone else is wondering this too.... So if I'm understanding Magisk correctly, all I do now is hit install and choose Magisk v11.1?
Edit: I did just that, but it doesnt seem to have done anything.. I dont see and magisk apps, and root checker says i'm not rooted.. Did I miss something?
edit 2: scratch that... I just installed the magisk manager app from the playstore.. according to it, the latest version of magisk is in fact, installed, and it's rooted with magisksu (despite not showing so in rootchecker).. Little confused now. Is that everything that needs to be done?
edit 3: I went back in after seeing something mentioning installing phh's superuser via TWRP and installing the app after installing magisk. Did both, but noticed safety net wasn't passing. found an option in settings to hide magisk, which seems to fix that. I also ran root checker again and it shows I have root.
unless I missed anything you can think of I think that about finishes things. If thats it thank you for all the help @JohnRogers23

txag2011 said:
Did just that. Got TWRP installed successfully. I PM'ed you a second ago but I might as well ask this here for everyone else to see in case someone else is wondering this too.... So if I'm understanding Magisk correctly, all I do now is hit install and choose Magisk v11.1?
Edit: I did just that, but it doesnt seem to have done anything.. I dont see and magisk apps, and root checker says i'm not rooted.. Did I miss something?
edit 2: scratch that... I just installed the magisk manager app from the playstore.. according to it, the latest version of magisk is in fact, installed, and it's rooted with magisksu (despite not showing so in rootchecker).. Little confused now. Is that everything that needs to be done?
edit 3: I went back in after seeing something mentioning installing phh's superuser via TWRP and installing the app after installing magisk. Did both, but noticed safety net wasn't passing. found an option in settings to hide magisk, which seems to fix that. I also ran root checker again and it shows I have root.
unless I missed anything you can think of I think that about finishes things. If thats it thank you for all the help @JohnRogers23
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm glad you got it working. Strange you had to flash phh's Su separately though. Anyway, glad I could help.

Well Working !
1.Backup your all imp data from internal memory
2.Flash TWRP 3.0.3-4.. Do not reboot into system and enter into Recovery TWRP..
3.Do a factory Reset via TWRP.. Do not reboot into system
4.Now flash SuperSU 2.79 SR3 via TWRP.. Finally Reboot into system..
*2 bootloops are common, do not give up for at least 3 bootloops..
*It will take a long time to boot as you have done a factory reset.. So be patient and wait for at least half hour..

Dr.Anshuman said:
1.Backup your all imp data from internal memory
2.Flash TWRP 3.0.3-4.. Do not reboot into system and enter into Recovery TWRP..
3.Do a factory Reset via TWRP.. Do not reboot into system
4.Now flash SuperSU 2.79 SR3 via TWRP.. Finally Reboot into system..
*2 bootloops are common, do not give up for at least 3 bootloops..
*It will take a long time to boot as you have done a factory reset.. So be patient and wait for at least half hour..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks! I got it more or less and went with magisk. Couldn't pass up a chance to have root and still get OTAs and use android pay. I'm still monkeying around trying to figure out how to use it to get liveboot back up and running.

Self-install possible with latest Magisk?

Hello All,
For systemless root on the latest magisk, can I just install latest magisk manager and let it do its thing, or do I have to flash a custom boot image first?

if I'm not mistaken, magisk manager will need magisksu...
so you will flash the magisk zip, it will patch your kernel with magisk / su support... (I don't even know what u mean by 'custom boot image')...
then magisk manager will work.

-Be completely stock
-Install Magisk manager 5.4.0
-Let it patch boot image
-Flash patched boot image in fastboot
-Done and profit
Good luck.
Cheers
Edit: make sure you're bootloader is and stays unlocked offcourse.
Sent from my Google Pixel using XDA Labs

Just flash magisk zip through TWRP

Sgace said:
-Be completely stock
-Install Magisk manager 5.4.0
-Let it patch boot image
-Flash patched boot image in fastboot
-Done and profit
Good luck.
Sent from my Google Pixel using XDA Labs
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks! thought so with the latest version, so I don't need to flash TWRP, I can just unlock bootloader and let Magisk do the rest right? As you can see in this thread, people post conflicting stuff, mostly from before when magisksu was unable to deal with the A/B partitioning

Pinktank said:
Thanks! thought so with the latest version, so I don't need to flash TWRP, I can just unlock bootloader and let Magisk do the rest right? As you can see in this thread, people post conflicting stuff, mostly from before when magisksu was unable to deal with the A/B partitioning
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, unlock bootloader if you haven't already (this will factory reset your phone) and then follow my first post.
No need for twrp anymore.
Cheers
Sent from my Google Pixel using XDA Labs

Sgace said:
Yes, unlock bootloader if you haven't already (this will factory reset your phone) and then follow my first post.
No need for twrp anymore.
Cheers
Sent from my Google Pixel using XDA Labs
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks a million, somebody should sticky this as people are still going with the other methods. I'll straight flash the image before unlocking to iron out possible kinks from various updated.

Pinktank said:
Thanks a million, somebody should sticky this as people are still going with the other methods. I'll straight flash the image before unlocking to iron out possible kinks from various updated.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ya, sorry for any confusion, I may have added. ***I was not aware of using this newer method, seems handy fir some people... however; ... it's still rather pointless to use for some of us and doesn't obsolete using twrp;
1. I'm a kernel Dev, so I'm frequently flashing builds.
2. using magisk manager to patch a custom kernel, just would add unnecessary steps to the process.
it's much faster to just fastboot into twrp. flash kernel and magisk in one go, reboot...done. ***this would also be true for anyone flashing zips, that aren't magisk related.
still though; easy great tip for people who only need magisk.

nine7nine said:
ya, sorry for any confusion, I may have added. ***I was not aware of using this newer method, seems handy fir some people... however; ... it's still rather pointless to use for some of us and doesn't obsolete using twrp;
1. I'm a kernel Dev, so I'm frequently flashing builds.
2. using magisk manager to patch a custom kernel, just would add unnecessary steps to the process.
it's much faster to just fastboot into twrp. flash kernel and magisk in one go, reboot...done. ***this would also be true for anyone flashing zips, that aren't magisk related.
still though; easy great tip for people who only need magisk.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
no problem. The nice thing about the magisk method is that it actually slips in the necessary changes during boot without static patching, keeping the system the same. Not sure how it would roll with custom kernel booting

Pinktank said:
no problem. The nice thing about the magisk method is that it actually slips in the necessary changes during boot without static patching, keeping the system the same. Not sure how it would roll with custom kernel booting
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah, I'm not too sure either. It would require probably changing my workflow, unpacking / repacking stock boot.img, adding in my init rc scripts, then using the magisk method ~ that sounds less automated, at first glance...
Right now, I build the kernel, then pop it into into a folder, zip it and flash it (all of the other parts are taken care of / setup).... I love magisk though; great root / systemless method. glad to see it opensource nad always improving

Pinktank said:
Thanks a million, somebody should sticky this as people are still going with the other methods. I'll straight flash the image before unlocking to iron out possible kinks from various updated.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You're welcome. Let us know how it worked out for you.
Cheers
Sent from my Google Pixel using XDA Labs

Get March OTA without having to re-install Magisk/TWRP

I read some stuff about doing an OTA update with Magisk (v18) on my Pixel 3 (Feb 2019), but I still have a few questions about doing it. I'd rather avoid re-installing TWRP and Magisk from recovery again, and I'd like to be able to do this all without my computer if possible (see planned process below).
1. From what I've read, I should be able to restore a stock boot image to the inactive boot partition (from within Magisk Manager) , then install the Update (both steps 1 and 2), then reinstall Magisk Manager to the inactive boot partition.. And then reboot, and I should have the update, and keep TWRP and Magisk, right? (just looking for confirmation of the process)
2. I never provided a stock image to Magisk when I installed it originally, and I don't have one right now. How do I extract the boot image from the stock image on the Android website?
3. And do I need to indicate to Magisk that I have a boot image, or will it ask me when I go in to restore non-root?
4. Are OTA updates cumulative, or do I need to update the stock boot image each update?
Thanks!

madhattr999 said:
I read some stuff about doing an OTA update with Magisk (v18) on my Pixel 3 (Feb 2019), but I still have a few questions about doing it. I'd rather avoid re-installing TWRP and Magisk from recovery again, and I'd like to be able to do this all without my computer if possible (see planned process below).
1. From what I've read, I should be able to restore a stock boot image to the inactive boot partition (from within Magisk Manager) , then install the Update (both steps 1 and 2), then reinstall Magisk Manager to the inactive boot partition.. And then reboot, and I should have the update, and keep TWRP and Magisk, right? (just looking for confirmation of the process)
2. I never provided a stock image to Magisk when I installed it originally, and I don't have one right now. How do I extract the boot image from the stock image on the Android website?
3. And do I need to indicate to Magisk that I have a boot image, or will it ask me when I go in to restore non-root?
4. Are OTA updates cumulative, or do I need to update the stock boot image each update?
Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Although what you described works for some devices it won't on the pixel. To update and have twrp and root you'll need a pc. If the ota would flash when you have twrp and root, it won't, it would overwrite twrp and the patched boot image. So you're back to needing a pc to get twrp and install magisk.
For your other questions, if you extract the factory image you'll find another zip file in there. That's were the image files are and you need to extract that zip. And, ota's are cumulative so you don't need install previous ones. But specifically to the boot image, a previous months boot image may or may not be the same as the current one, etc.

jd1639 said:
Although what you described works for some devices it won't on the pixel. To update and have twrp and root you'll need a pc. If the ota would flash when you have twrp and root, it won't, it would overwrite twrp and the patched boot image. So you're back to needing a pc to get twrp and install magisk.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm confused then. Isn't the method I described specifically for a phone with two boot partitions?
The instructions I am trying to reference:
Devices with A/B Partitions
Due to the fact that these devices have two separate partitions, it is possible to have the OTA installed to the inactive slot and have Magisk Manager to install Magisk onto the updated partition. The out-of-the-box OTA installation works seamlessly and Magisk can be preserved after the installation.
After restoring stock boot image, apply OTAs as you normally would (Settings → System → System Update).
Wait for the installation to be fully done (both step 1 and step 2 of the OTA), do not press the restart button!! Instead, go to (Magisk Manager → Install → Install to Inactive Slot) and install Magisk to the slot that the OTA engine just updated.
After installation is done, press the reboot button in Magisk Manager. Under-the-hood Magisk Manager forces your device to switch to the updated slot, bypassing any possible post-OTA verifications.
After the reboot, your device should be fully updated, and most importantly, Magisk is still installed to the updated system!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse

madhattr999 said:
I'm confused then. Isn't the method I described specifically for a phone with two boot partitions?
The instructions I am trying to reference:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It is, but it doesn't work on the pixel. Google's security, probably the M chip, but I may be wrong, prevents it from working. In theory, magisk should be able to patch a boot image on your device and you shouldn't need the magisk zip but that doesn't work either. You can certainly try what you're describing but backup at least your data partition with twrp and have it off your device before you try. Get the contents of your internal sdcard to if you have stuff there you don't want to lose.
Most likely restoring the stock boot image and trying to install the ota will just not work, but you never know.

jd1639 said:
It is, but it doesn't work on the pixel. Google's security, probably the M chip, but I may be wrong, prevents it from working. In theory, magisk should be able to patch a boot image on your device and you shouldn't need the magisk zip but that doesn't work either. You can certainly try what you're describing but backup at least your data partition with twrp and have it off your device before you try. Get the contents of your internal sdcard to if you have stuff there you don't want to lose.
Most likely restoring the stock boot image and trying to install the ota will just not work, but you never know.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks, I'll back up my files and try that.

Well, as far as I know twrp backups only work for data (with verity and all that). Always bootloop on a vendor or system restore. Back up your data a million times and go for it. Worse thing that happens is back to zero. Wait, you said no computer? Well, put it on a free cloud saving service, have your data backed up out there. Not advertizing for any service in particular, but backing up data is something everyone should be thinking about.
I am about to go for broke on this device for the 4th time. Non boot several times, flashing, flashing, building, flashing. I have the added benefit of figuring out if cell service works as the vendor.img always breaks it. Good times mate.

I might be missing something here, so please clarify if there is a way to "Get March OTA without having to re-install Magisk/TWRP", and how. Wondering about exactly that. Thank you.

madhattr999 said:
I'm confused then. Isn't the method I described specifically for a phone with two boot partitions?
The instructions I am trying to reference:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What you have quoted works fine for me. I did both February and March update with this method on my P3 and no problems.
The only thing i noticed is that it takes more than 20 minutes to do step 2 of the instalation (optimizing apps)
But to be on the safe side, please backup.
Another thing: i don't have TWRP recovery, just Magisk root

fronten said:
I might be missing something here, so please clarify if there is a way to "Get March OTA without having to re-install Magisk/TWRP", and how. Wondering about exactly that. Thank you.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There is no way to do so. Either side loading the OTA, or fastbooting the factory image, will still require you to install root and twrp. Which, really isn't a big deal at all :good:

Badger50 said:
There is no way to do so. Either side loading the OTA, or fastbooting the factory image, will still require you to install root and twrp. Which, really isn't a big deal at all :good:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
But the person above you said he was able to do it on both recent updates...

madhattr999 said:
But the person above you said he was able to do it on both recent updates...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
He doesn't have twrp and if you do have twrp the ota won't work for sure. So you're welcome to try if you're only rooted, no twrp. But patching the boot image and installing it from magisk hasn't worked, but maybe it does now. Let us know.

dracushor87 said:
What you have quoted works fine for me. I did both February and March update with this method on my P3 and no problems.
The only thing i noticed is that it takes more than 20 minutes to do step 2 of the instalation (optimizing apps)
But to be on the safe side, please backup.
Another thing: i don't have TWRP recovery, just Magisk root
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
@dracushor87, can you confirm that the process described by @madhattr999 worked correctly? I have a Pixel 3, rooted with Magisk, without TWRP. I would like to apply the monthly updates as easily as possible: without wiping data, uninstall/reinstall Magisk, etc.
Specifically:
madhattr999 said:
1. From what I've read, I should be able to restore a stock boot image to the inactive boot partition (from within Magisk Manager) , then install the Update (both steps 1 and 2), then reinstall Magisk Manager to the inactive boot partition.. And then reboot, and I should have the update, and keep TWRP and Magisk, right? (just looking for confirmation of the process)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I looked through Magisk Manager, and don't see a way to "restore a stock boot image to the inactive boot partition".
In the installed state, I don't see any functions for patching or installing boot images within Magisk Manager.

timg11 said:
@dracushor87, can you confirm that the process described by @madhattr999 worked correctly? I have a Pixel 3, rooted with Magisk, without TWRP. I would like to apply the monthly updates as easily as possible: without wiping data, uninstall/reinstall Magisk, etc.
Specifically:
I looked through Magisk Manager, and don't see a way to "restore a stock boot image to the inactive boot partition".
In the installed state, I don't see any functions for patching or installing boot images within Magisk Manager.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, i confirm. Before you start, please check if there is an update available. If there is, restore image, update, reinstall magisk and then reboot. If you reboot without reinstalling magisk, you will lose root. To install on the inactive slot, just click install in magisk manager and then you will be asked what method to use. If what i said is unclear, just requote me

dracushor87 said:
Yes, i confirm. Before you start, please check if there is an update available. If there is, restore image, update, reinstall magisk and then reboot. If you reboot without reinstalling magisk, you will lose root. To install on the inactive slot, just click install in magisk manager and then you will be asked what method to use. If what i said is unclear, just requote me
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Used this method after the May update finally arrived for me yesterday. Backed up everything just in case, but it worked flawlessly.

Installing OTA after TWRP + Magisk = fail to boot

I'm at my wit's end here. I know I'm probably missing some critical step, but I haven't been able to install any OTAs since installing TWRP and Magisk. Fortunately, I was able to update to the latest TWRP before trying (the one that has working decryption) and backup Boot, the two Systems, and Data. I cannot stress enough how important this is!.
The OTA installer detects the device is rooted (or unlocked, if magisk isn't installed) and downloads the OTA. It then asks to install (which is does while booted to system, presumably to the side (A or B) that isn't updated), and asks to reboot. After reboot, the system fails to boot, then goes to the original OnePlus recovery (with the Chinese characters).
I seem to remember reading somewhere that I needed to shut the phone down instead of rebooting, but that doesn't seem to help. I want to know the correct procedure for updating, but I also want to better understand what is actually going on. I'm guessing the boot image on the other side gets overwritten by the OTA, which then flips you to that side, but I don't understand why it doesn't boot. Non-patched boot.img, I suppose?

These steps worked for me:
1 install ota
2 flash TWRP_A_B_Retention_Script-Magisk.zip via magisk
3 install magisk on inactive slot
4 reboot

RocketGeeezer said:
These steps worked for me:
1 install ota
2 flash TWRP_A_B_Retention_Script-Magisk.zip via magisk
3 install magisk on inactive slot
4 reboot
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Awesome. I had not even heard of the retention script, but it sounds like exactly what I'm missing.
As for step 3, how do you install Magisk on the inactive slot?

Flapjack said:
Awesome. I had not even heard of the retention script, but it sounds like exactly what I'm missing.
As for step 3, how do you install Magisk on the inactive slot?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Open magisk, click the first install option and download that zip. Then a box with four options should appear. Click the last option to install on another slot.

whatthekj said:
Open magisk, click the first install option and download that zip. Then a box with four options should appear. Click the last option to install on another slot.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks! Trying now!

Flapjack said:
Thanks! Trying now!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No problem. Let me know if you have any issues.

Well, it's different (booting to TWRP instead of stock recovery), but it still didn't work. It booted through the "warning...unlocked bootloader" screen twice, then went to TWRP, though without encryption. I was able to switch the boot slot and get into system again (just as it was before the flash), but I don't know what I did wrong.
The only thing different I did was use the tools under EX Kernel Manager to flash the TWRP retention script, as I couldn't find where Magisk could do that.
**EDIT**
Now when I try to do the OTA, I get a "System update installation failed".

I cleared the cache and tried it again, this time doing the retention zip from inside Magisk > Modules > Add (+ sign) option, which is what I'm assuming you did.
It did the exact same thing. After step four, I rebooted, and it went straight into recovery (without the option to decrypt).

I think you have to root your phone again If you have the chinese twrp you can do it via twrp. Otherwise put tj magisk installer on a USB stick

RocketGeeezer said:
I think you have to root your phone again If you have the chinese twrp you can do it via twrp. Otherwise put tj magisk installer on a USB stick
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I can install/uninstall Magisk all day long, now that I've put TWRP 3.3.1-30 on. Even after a failed update, where it fails to ask to decrypt, I can still sideload via USB and install it (even though I can't see the internal storage).

Flapjack said:
I can install/uninstall Magisk all day long, now that I've put TWRP 3.3.1-30 on. Even after a failed update, where it fails to ask to decrypt, I can still sideload via USB and install it (even though I can't see the internal storage).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you lflash the ota image again? And after that twrp and after that magisk again. After that reboot to system again. This worked on my pixel. Not shure if this works on the 7 pro...
Maybe do some research first. There is also a unbrick thread

RocketGeeezer said:
Can you lflash the ota image again? And after that twrp and after that magisk again. After that reboot to system again. This worked on my pixel. Not shure if this works on the 7 pro...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've tried that... several times. I wish it worked.
Maybe do some research first. There is also a unbrick thread
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've been doing a lot of research. There are some pretty in-depth threads on reddit how the A/B treble system works. Nothing I didn't already know. It's certainly different than pre-treble, but not rocket science... something is wrong with the phone. I would just like to know what I did wrong in the first place so I don't do it again.
Fortunately, I still have a bootable system with root on my B partition, so I was able to run TB and backup everything, along with all my pictures and such. I'll be restoring it to stock and just going from there. Looks like I don't have any other choice.

Flapjack said:
I've tried that... several times. I wish it worked.
I've been doing a lot of research. There are some pretty in-depth threads on reddit how the A/B treble system works. Nothing I didn't already know. It's certainly different than pre-treble, but not rocket science... something is wrong with the phone. I would just like to know what I did wrong in the first place so I don't do it again.
Fortunately, I still have a bootable system with root on my B partition, so I was able to run TB and backup everything, along with all my pictures and such. I'll be restoring it to stock and just going from there. Looks like I don't have any other choice.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Okay I updated just like we do with our pixels when we flash a custom ROM. TW RP flash your ota.zip,TWRP zip, reboot to recovery that will switch slots , because your update just flashed to the other slot, then flash magisk then reboot. That's how I did this last update. Oh and it's got to be the full ota from what I read anyways.

Best/most efficient root method OP7P

I am running 10.05, I can't decide whether to install twrp, dd root, or magdisk. Given that I have the most current version of oxygen os, what would be the best way to root my phone?
Don't misinterpret my ignorance for lazyness, a majority of guides I've seen aren't recent and don't go over pros & cons of the method.
Thank you, I'm willing to donate for help.

Edit: I'm stupid, I was in wrong forum. Please ignore this post and what I've said!

You only need a patched image if you don't want to install TWRP. If you install TWRP, I'd simply ADB sideload Magisk to get root.
That's what I've done and it works just fine.
This assumes that you're using a OnePlus 7 Pro, and not a 7T Pro. Not got a 7T, so can't comment on that.
Sent from my GM1913 using Tapatalk

Bagpuss said:
You only need a patched image if you don't want to install TWRP. If you install TWRP, I'd simply ADB sideload Magisk to get root.
That's what I've done and it works just fine.
This assumes that you're using a OnePlus 7 Pro, and not a 7T Pro. Not got a 7T, so can't comment on that.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Edit: I'm stupid, I was in wrong forum. Please ignore this post and what I've said!

Lossyx said:
TWRP doesn't work on devices launched with Android 10, which has been discussed many times.
My reply above stands true, a patched boot image is the only way as for right now.
(And we're on a 7T Pro forum)
Sent from my OnePlus7TPro using XDA Labs
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Are you positive? I see TWRP install guides everywhere. From what I've read TWRP with magdisk (not SuperSU, us it's not open source) is the best way to root with the most flexibility. What if I'm running 10.03.0GM21AA, and there is no patched image? Do I need to roll back?

Lossyx said:
There is only one way to root, and that is by using a patched image. Check the guides section, there's probably a patched image of your device, if not, you'll have to make your own.
And what's your version? AA or BA?
Sent from my OnePlus7TPro using XDA Labs
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
AA. So do I need to roll back? I bought the OP7P because I stupidly assumed it would be as easy/flexible to root as my past OP devices. It's ironic I switched from a Samsung devices to a OP for the ability for a stress-free rooting experience and I got the same problem lol. I might just return the phone for another, I'd prefer something with an SD card slot anyway.
What's the best phone with SD card feature that can run TWRP magdisk without issues like using banking apps and Netflix?
Forgive my ignorance, I am still in the learning process.

Lossyx said:
TWRP doesn't work on devices launched with Android 10, which has been discussed many times.
My reply above stands true, a patched boot image is the only way as for right now.
(And we're on a 7T Pro forum)
Sent from my OnePlus7TPro using XDA Labs
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No we're on a 7 Pro forum. And TWRP works fine on the 7 Pro, but you need a patched version of some sort last time I checked.
sixisixsix said:
I am running 10.05, I can't decide whether to install twrp, dd root, or magdisk. Given that I have the most current version of oxygen os, what would be the best way to root my phone?
Don't misinterpret my ignorance for lazyness, a majority of guides I've seen aren't recent and don't go over pros & cons of the method.
Thank you, I'm willing to donate for help.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
To root my phone, I didn't even use TWRP. I downloaded the lastest OOS version from OnePlus, extracted the boot image, copied that to my phone, Magisk patched that boot image file (you don't need root for that, you can use the Magisk manager). Then unlocked the phone, and installed the bootloader I just patched while the phone was in bootloader mode (fastboot flash boot boot.img or whatever).
Might not be the easiest, but I think it's clean, however back then I did not know about the option to properly use TWRP. Maybe I can find it, but I know it's possible to just unlock the 7 Pro, and then from the bootloader boot to TWRP once without flashing it, and install Magisk.

QUBiCA said:
No we're on a 7 Pro forum. And TWRP works fine on the 7 Pro, but you need a patched version of some sort last time I checked.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Oh damn, I'm actually stupid... How did I miss were on 7 Pro?!
@sixisixsix please ignore everything I've said! I will edit my posts.
Sorry once again
Sent from my OnePlus7TPro using XDA Labs

sixisixsix said:
AA. So do I need to roll back? I bought the OP7P because I stupidly assumed it would be as easy/flexible to root as my past OP devices. It's ironic I switched from a Samsung devices to a OP for the ability for a stress-free rooting experience and I got the same problem lol. I might just return the phone for another, I'd prefer something with an SD card slot anyway.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've found OP devices (having owned two now) to be easy to root, and very friendly to the mod/root community such as XDA. Samsung is the opposite, in my experience (although each Sammy device is different, some better than others in this regard).
The main complexity with the 7 Pro is not that it is an OP device per se; but that it has something called A/B partitions, which are used for "seamless" OTA updates (Pixel devices use this scheme also - as well as a number of other phones).
The thing with A/B partition devices, is that they do NOT have a discrete recovery partition that you can just flash TWRP to. Therefore, you need to patch the boot.img partition (which on A/B devices contains both kernel and recovery, along with ramdisk). It is a little trickier, and somewhat more of a learning curve. But once you've learned that basic difference, it is not too bad.
It seems that the list A/B partitions devices is growing. So while I'm not an expert in the industry or anything, it appears that this is where Android is going (A/B is certainly not going away anytime soon, in any case).
So while the SD card feature is a legitimate difference (and a discriminator for some), I would say you should not make the A/B partition difference scare you away from OP devices. Maybe "too much information", but you can read more about the A/B partition scheme here: https://www.xda-developers.com/how-...ess-updates-affect-custom-development-on-xda/
---------- Post added at 10:13 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:05 AM ----------
QUBiCA said:
To root my phone, I didn't even use TWRP. I downloaded the lastest OOS version from OnePlus, extracted the boot image, copied that to my phone, Magisk patched that boot image file (you don't need root for that, you can use the Magisk manager). Then unlocked the phone, and installed the bootloader I just patched while the phone was in bootloader mode (fastboot flash boot boot.img or whatever).
Might not be the easiest, but I think it's clean, however back then I did not know about the option to properly use TWRP. Maybe I can find it, but I know it's possible to just unlock the 7 Pro, and then from the bootloader boot to TWRP once without flashing it, and install Magisk.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Certainly a valid approach (fastboot flash a patched boot image). The "other" (TWRP) method works as well, and probably a little easier for most folks:
1) Unlock bootloader
2) fastboot boot twrp.img
Note that this is just remote booting a TWRP image, not installing it. It simply allows the next steps. You can't flash a TWRP image directly, for the reason I've noted above.
3) Once booted to TWRP, flash TWRP installer zip (OPTIONAL). This patched the boot.img so that TWRP is installed. You only need to do this if you want TWRP installed on the phone.
4) Also in "booted" TWRP, flash the Magisk zip.
The main fundamental difference, is that Magisk is patching the boot.img for you, instead of doing it yourself. Have the files (TWRP.zip and Magisk) on the phone before starting the process, and it is really pretty simple and fast.
The nice thing about the patched boot.img method, is that is worked even when TWRP method did not. This applied to when the phone was first released, and the command "fastboot boot" was broken (therefore not possible to fastboot boot TWRP). This happened again when the device was updated to Android 10. Although the developer got fastboot boot working fairly quickly in both circumstances.

Lossyx said:
Edit: I'm stupid, I was in wrong forum. Please ignore this post and what I've said!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
redpoint73 said:
I've found OP devices (having owned two now) to be easy to root, and very friendly to the mod/root community such as XDA. Samsung is the opposite, in my experience (although each Sammy device is different, some better than others in this regard).
The main complexity with the 7 Pro is not that it is an OP device per se; but that it has something called A/B partitions, which are used for "seamless" OTA updates (Pixel devices use this scheme also - as well as a number of other phones).
The thing with A/B partition devices, is that they do NOT have a discrete recovery partition that you can just flash TWRP to. Therefore, you need to patch the boot.img partition (which on A/B devices contains both kernel and recovery, along with ramdisk). It is a little trickier, and somewhat more of a learning curve. But once you've learned that basic difference, it is not too bad.
It seems that the list A/B partitions devices is growing. So while I'm not an expert in the industry or anything, it appears that this is where Android is going (A/B is certainly not going away anytime soon, in any case).
So while the SD card feature is a legitimate difference (and a discriminator for some), I would say you should not make the A/B partition difference scare you away from OP devices. Maybe "too much information", but you can read more about the A/B partition scheme here: https://www.xda-developers.com/how-...ess-updates-affect-custom-development-on-xda/
---------- Post added at 10:13 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:05 AM ----------
Certainly a valid approach (fastboot flash a patched boot image). The "other" (TWRP) method works as well, and probably a little easier for most folks:
1) Unlock bootloader
2) fastboot boot twrp.img
Note that this is just remote booting a TWRP image, not installing it. It simply allows the next steps. You can't flash a TWRP image directly, for the reason I've noted above.
3) Once booted to TWRP, flash TWRP installer zip (OPTIONAL). This patched the boot.img so that TWRP is installed. You only need to do this if you want TWRP installed on the phone.
4) Also in "booted" TWRP, flash the Magisk zip.
The main fundamental difference, is that Magisk is patching the boot.img for you, instead of doing it yourself. Have the files (TWRP.zip and Magisk) on the phone before starting the process, and it is really pretty simple and fast.
The nice thing about the patched boot.img method, is that is worked even when TWRP method did not. This applied to when the phone was first released, and the command "fastboot boot" was broken (therefore not possible to fastboot boot TWRP). This happened again when the device was updated to Android 10. Although the developer got fastboot boot working fairly quickly in both circumstances.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you for taking the time to respond to my post in such detail! Wouldn't installing TWRP give me more flexibility for future updates? If I go the flashed image route won't I need erase my data on my phone every time I update?

sixisixsix said:
Thank you for taking the time to respond to my post in such detail! Wouldn't installing TWRP give me more flexibility for future updates? If I go the flashed image route won't I need erase my data on my phone every time I update?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't think TWRP would give you more flexibility when it comes to updates, unless you are planning on switching ROMs often, but if this phone is your daily driver I would recommend against that.
If you unlock the phone your data will be wiped, but only once. After that it is completely up to you, if you switch ROMs and pick something that is completely different from stock, it is indeed recommended to wipe data to prevent weird issues. But for a regular system update (if you simply stick with the stock ROM and use Magisk for root, you can still receive normal updates from OnePlus), or an update of the same custom ROM, you do not need to wipe data. I wiped data only once, when I unlocked it, because I had to.
Flashing/installing TWRP generally is not necessary and like @redpoint73 explained, with the "new" A/B system, it is not advised to flash TWRP as it is combined with the boot image (which your phone needs to start up, and is updated after every update, so after every update you will lose TWRP again if I am correct). What @redpoint73 explained is that instead of installing (AKA flashing) TWRP, it is possible to just start it up (boot it) once without installing it. From there you can install Magisk on your stock OnePlus ROM and use the benefits of a rooted system.

QUBiCA said:
Flashing/installing TWRP generally is not necessary and like @redpoint73 explained, with the "new" A/B system, it is not advised to flash TWRP as it is combined with the boot image (which your phone needs to start up, and is updated after every update, so after every update you will lose TWRP again if I am correct).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It is correct that you lose the TWRP install when you update (as well as losing root). But it is just a simple matter of flashing the TWRP installer zip after the update (I do this the same time as re-flashing Magisk after OTA update), which takes about 10 seconds to accomplish. I wouldn't personally take that as a reason to "not" flash TWRP. But it is a personal preference whether to install TWRP or not. The reasons to have TWRP installed on the phone are much reduced from previous devices. In the past I would have said that being rooted without a custom recovery is asking for trouble. But now, with A/B partitions, along with the fastboot stock ROMs, the choice becomes much less clear. To the point that installing TWRP is purely optional.
I still personally believe that having TWRP installed gives you more recovery options. But again, it is a personal choice, and certainly not mandatory by any means.
---------- Post added at 09:11 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:01 AM ----------
sixisixsix said:
Wouldn't installing TWRP give me more flexibility for future updates?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Actually, no (as QUBiCA touched on above).
Reason being, OTA updates will still come through on this device (even rooted). And you can still flash (or put OTA files on the phone to flash) using the built-in update engine in the phone's settings menu. Which gives you the option to update to either A/B partition slot. Plus, you can just re-flash TWRP (if desired) and Magisk after the update, straight from the Magisk Manager.
The trick is to make sure you do NOT reboot immediately after an OTA update (when rooted). Then simply open Magisk Manager, flash TWRP as if it were a Magisk module (optional, if you want TWRP installed again). Then install Magisk again through the Magisk Manager as well.. Now you can reboot, and you will be updated with root.
sixisixsix said:
If I go the flashed image route won't I need erase my data on my phone every time I update?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No (again, just backing up the answer already provided). There is not a big difference between the two methods. In either case, you are patching the boot.img partition to be rooted (whether you flash a patched boot.img, or you have Magisk patch it for you). And in both cases, you don't need to wipe your data.

redpoint73 said:
It is correct that you lose the TWRP install when you update (as well as losing root). But it is just a simple matter of flashing the TWRP installer zip after the update (I do this the same time as re-flashing Magisk after OTA update), which takes about 10 seconds to accomplish. I wouldn't personally take that as a reason to "not" flash TWRP. But it is a personal preference whether to install TWRP or not. The reasons to have TWRP installed on the phone are much reduced from previous devices. In the past I would have said that being rooted without a custom recovery is asking for trouble. But now, with A/B partitions, along with the fastboot stock ROMs, the choice becomes much less clear. To the point that installing TWRP is purely optional.
I still personally believe that having TWRP installed gives you more recovery options. But again, it is a personal choice, and certainly not mandatory by any means.
---------- Post added at 09:11 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:01 AM ----------
Actually, no (as QUBiCA touched on above).
Reason being, OTA updates will still come through on this device (even rooted). And you can still flash (or put OTA files on the phone to flash) using the built-in update engine in the phone's settings menu. Which gives you the option to update to either A/B partition slot. Plus, you can just re-flash TWRP (if desired) and Magisk after the update, straight from the Magisk Manager.
The trick is to make sure you do NOT reboot immediately after an OTA update (when rooted). Then simply open Magisk Manager, flash TWRP as if it were a Magisk module (optional, if you want TWRP installed again). Then install Magisk again through the Magisk Manager as well.. Now you can reboot, and you will be updated with root.
No (again, just backing up the answer already provided). There is not a big difference between the two methods. In either case, you are patching the boot.img partition to be rooted (whether you flash a patched boot.img, or you have Magisk patch it for you). And in both cases, you don't need to wipe your data.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So if I used the patched version of 10.3.0 and another new version comes out I can just download it through settings and I will remained rooted?
Sent from my Redmi Note 8 Pro using Tapatalk

sixisixsix said:
So if I used the patched version of 10.3.0 and another new version comes out I can just download it through settings and I will remained rooted?
Sent from my Redmi Note 8 Pro using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
NO.
You need to go through the process and flash Magisk from inside Magisk Manager.

tech_head said:
NO.
You need to go through the process and flash Magisk from inside Magisk Manager.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Okay so I downloaded magdisk manager, I flashed the patched version of 10.03, then when I rebooted I hit install update on magdisk and when the phone rebooted it was no longer rooted.
Even the guides for flashing aren't in depth enough for me. Can you help me out real quick?

sixisixsix said:
So if I used the patched version of 10.3.0 and another new version comes out I can just download it through settings and I will remained rooted?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You should get the OTA update and be able to download it through settings. BUT, after you install the update, you still need to do as I already said in order to remain rooted:
redpoint73 said:
The trick is to make sure you do NOT reboot immediately after an OTA update (when rooted). Then simply open Magisk Manager, flash TWRP as if it were a Magisk module (optional, if you want TWRP installed again). Then install Magisk again through the Magisk Manager as well.. Now you can reboot, and you will be updated with root.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
---------- Post added at 09:28 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:00 AM ----------
sixisixsix said:
Okay so I downloaded magdisk manager, I flashed the patched version of 10.03, then when I rebooted I hit install update on magdisk and when the phone rebooted it was no longer rooted.
Even the guides for flashing aren't in depth enough for me. Can you help me out real quick?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You seem to be mixing the two processes: Install update in Magisk is for when you update in the future. You shouldn't have to do this rooting the existing ROM with the patched boot.img method.
For the patched boot.img method, you should just be able to flash the patched boot.img, flash the Magisk apk, and open Magisk, and it should say rooted.
My recommendation is follow this guide: https://forum.xda-developers.com/oneplus-7-pro/how-to/guide-bootloader-unlock-twrp-install-t3940368
I can't possibly see how it can be any more in depth.

Database Info

welcome