Lineage OS available? - Huawei P20 Questions & Answers

Hello!
Is there Lineage OS already available for the P20?

Any actual roms?
0xsly0x said:
Hello!
Is there Lineage OS already available for the P20?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Are there even any roms out for the P20, not liking the stock and don't really want to get a launcher

No, not yet and i doubt that there will be scene because huawei is locking the possibility to unlock bootloader

P20 can still be unlocked
g_oral said:
No, not yet and i doubt that there will be scene because huawei is locking the possibility to unlock bootloader
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You'd think that some people would want a custom ROM though

There are a lot of Treble roms available for P20 (Pixel Experience, RR, LOS).. just take a look on the internet !

ROMS
Androlark said:
There are a lot of Treble roms available for P20 (Pixel Experience, RR, LOS).. just take a look on the internet !
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry to be annoying but do you know if any flashes of twrp and magisk for p20 cuz my current twrp keeps encrypting and I can't find a magisk that works, all the in error 1

Androlark said:
There are a lot of Treble roms available for P20 (Pixel Experience, RR, LOS).. just take a look on the internet !
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
And have you tried any of those? Could you tell us what's not working on treble ROMs?

0xsly0x said:
Hello!
Is there Lineage OS already available for the P20?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Actually it is. ?
https://forum.xda-developers.com/honor-view-10/development/rom-lineageos-15-1-t3753000
And there is also GSI Lineage
https://forum.xda-developers.com/pr...evice-development/lineage-phh-treble-t3767690

0xsly0x said:
Hello!
Is there Lineage OS already available for the P20?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
rawdealer said:
Actually it is.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/honor-view-10/development/rom-lineageos-15-1-t3753000
And there is also GSI Lineage
https://forum.xda-developers.com/pr...evice-development/lineage-phh-treble-t3767690
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have the GSI Lineage running on my P20, with the caveat that i have to run V3. V4 gets stuck on the lineage logo. Haven't tried the honor view version yet.

rawdealer said:
Actually it is.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/honor-view-10/development/rom-lineageos-15-1-t3753000
And there is also GSI Lineage
https://forum.xda-developers.com/pr...evice-development/lineage-phh-treble-t3767690
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Marnux said:
I have the GSI Lineage running on my P20, with the caveat that i have to run V3. V4 gets stuck on the lineage logo. Haven't tried the honor view version yet.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Androlark said:
There are a lot of Treble roms available for P20 (Pixel Experience, RR, LOS).. just take a look on the internet !
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Would you recommend switching to LineageOS/AOSP? Why (not)?
Anything you miss in particular? Is the camera quality bearable?

There's a quite buggy port made by phhusson, but ported from Mate 9 so pretty useless..
The camera quality is actually bad. It is the main reason I'm not switching to LOS.
The notch is not supported at all, some texts and icons are hiding behind it.
No FP sensor too.
I've got no issues for booting Treble roms with EMUI 8.1, but some are getting issues with 8.0
I opened this on phhusson's github, you can take a quick look.

I like clean and uncluttered. So i buy my phones with unlocking and custom romming in mind, as i have a choice of software at that time. It's a personal preference.
That said, i find something that is closer to AOSP, always recommended. I'm sure there are people that don't agree. Tastes differ and i like to have freedom and own my device. I paid for it, so i can do with it what i want.
I don't miss anything, i don't have high quality standards for camera and such on a phone. There is specific equipment for specialized tasks.
It is good enough to send the odd photo or video on my messaging app.

Androlark said:
There's a quite buggy port made by phhusson, but ported from Mate 9 so pretty useless..
The camera quality is actually bad. It is the main reason I'm not switching to LOS.
The notch is not supported at all, some texts and icons are hiding behind it.
No FP sensor too.
I've got no issues for booting Treble roms with EMUI 8.1, but some are getting issues with 8.0
I opened this on phhusson's github, you can take a quick look.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks Androlark.
Did you try the phhusson's GSI LineageOS version or LuK1337's Unofficial LineageOS? Is there any difference between them?
Are the bugs you mentioned fixed?
https://github.com/phhusson/treble_experimentations/issues/39
If I had a spare phone, I would have tried these treble roms on my device, but P20 is my main daily driver. But, I (and we all) would love to have a fully working LineageOS for P20. I am watching this space closely.

Related

Lineage OS for Huawei Mate 9?

EMUI is MIUI, just "copy my homework and change it a lil bit". I love MIUI but clean/stock Android, like on my OnePlus 3T is the best.
Whats about Lineage OS and Huawei/Kirin device, like on the Mate 9? The same problem like on Exynos devices?
Regards
Didnt know emui was miui
Klanac89 said:
Whats about Lineage OS and Huawei/Kirin device, like on the Mate 9? The same problem like on Exynos devices?
Regards
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
We couldn't​ do anything, cause lack of kernel sources.
Klanac89 said:
EMUI is MIUI, just "copy my homework and change it a lil bit". I love MIUI but clean/stock Android, like on my OnePlus 3T is the best.
Whats about Lineage OS and Huawei/Kirin device, like on the Mate 9? The same problem like on Exynos devices?
Regards
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Guess the main problem is the unpublished kernel and missing device trees.
it took months to unofficially​ port lineage for the p9 lite. Meticulous did it by reverse engineering because he earned a sponsored device for his awards. Maybe he would do it here too but the mate 9 is very expensive compared to the p9 lite.
But just the fact our mate is running a Kirin doesn't shoot it out. P9 series are running on Kirin too
intruda119 said:
Didnt know emui was miui
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I use MIUI before Huawei even build devices. It's just the old MIUI, what you get on EMUI.
5[Strogino] said:
We couldn't​ do anything, cause lack of kernel sources.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I saw a lot phones without kernel source but with almost perfect port. Is there more than kernel source?
WieserZ1C said:
Guess the main problem is the unpublished kernel and missing device trees.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What do you mean by 'device trees' ?
There is a buggy LineageOS 14.1 image for Honor 8 and they also don't have 4.x kernel sources.
Has somebody tried to boot the HiKey960 4.4 kernel to test the core CPU support ?
It is useless for the phone operation, but will be a good starting point for kernel development.
Closed-source firmware blobs at https://github.com/96boards-hikey/tools-images-hikey960 with very high probability were taken from the Mate 9 codebase.
So it is possible but it's really hard to port it?

Project Treble and the benefits for custom ROM development

Hey guys, I wanted to know something, when the Oreo update comes to our device will it bring project treble with it or not ? And if it will bring it will there be any benefits to the users, say the ability to use the dual cameras or more stability, or will it just make it easier for developers to make Oreo, (or P ?) ROMs ?
This article explains everything https://www.xda-developers.com/how-project-treble-revolutionizes-custom-roms-android-oreo
RedSkull23 said:
This article explains everything https://www.xda-developers.com/how-project-treble-revolutionizes-custom-roms-android-oreo
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What about dual cameras on our phone ?
With treble, stock huawei camera works.
Coolyou said:
With treble, stock huawei camera works.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yay

RR rom is possible?

will RR come to this device?waiting it for so bad since it have alot of customization and being using on all my devices?any RR dev can make for this device?:laugh::laugh::laugh::laugh::laugh:
sadnessblues said:
will RR come to this device?waiting it for so bad since it have alot of customization and being using on all my devices?any RR dev can make for this device?:laugh::laugh::laugh::laugh::laugh:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yep, absolutely capable these, if later full source devices trees on repos LineageOS release and ready for it.
and good news is here : https://review.lineageos.org/#/q/status:merged+project:LineageOS/android_device_xiaomi_sdm845-common+branch:lineage-15.1+topicolaris-bringup
sadnessblues said:
will RR come to this device?waiting it for so bad since it have alot of customization and being using on all my devices?any RR dev can make for this device?:laugh::laugh::laugh::laugh::laugh:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You should try this version:
RR GSI for treble devices
eDooM85 said:
You should try this version:
RR GSI for treble devices
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It work on any device?can u guide me which one should i download,or link it here
sadnessblues said:
It work on any device?can u guide me which one should i download,or link it here
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
1) It works on any treble enabled device.
2) You should download this version:
Resurrection Remix ARM64 Aonly Devices:
Official: https://downloads.resurrectionremix.com/arm64aonly/
I can't test for myself since I'm on the 360hours period before unlocking my bootloader
7/23 GSI RR isn't really a daily driver. Camera is not good. I tried Open Camera and it just flashed color to b&w and back. Picture quality was still poor. Bluetooth headphones don't work--audio doesn't come through. No VoLTE (of course). Probably other issues I didn't notice or forgot.
thatguy222 said:
7/23 GSI RR isn't really a daily driver. Camera is not good. I tried Open Camera and it just flashed color to b&w and back. Picture quality was still poor. Bluetooth headphones don't work--audio doesn't come through. No VoLTE (of course). Probably other issues I didn't notice or forgot.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Any recomendation for a ROM based on AOSP
eDooM85 said:
Any recomendation for a ROM based on AOSP
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Xiaomi makes nice phones but they aren't considered development friendly. It might be a while before a few AOSP ROMs are available for the Mix 2S and there won't be as much development for this phone as for the cheaper Redmi models since those sell a lot more units.
The Mix 2 had global LTE bands out of the gate and because of that it was available on Amazon right away and was reviewed by tech sites that pointed out it was the first Xiaomi phone fully compatible with LTE in North America. There is official TWRP for the Mix 2, official Lineage and some other development although it is pretty limited.
For whatever reason Xiaomi did not do the same thing with the 2S. It initially came out with much more limited band support than the Mix 2 unless you purchased the 256G model which had global LTE support. There was also no announcement at launch that there would later be a global version so reviews in the west said the 2S was incompatible with North American LTE unless you purchased the most expensive variant and those reviews were never updated after the global model was released.
Because of this a lot fewer people (in North America at least) ended up purchasing the Mix 2S compared with the Mix 2.
The result is no official TWRP and no development so far even though the release of the Mix 3 is just around the corner.
Official LOS is apparently in development but there probably won't ever be a lot in the way of AOSP ROMs available for the 2S and the handful that are will be buggy because the devs will be auto-compiling those ROMs since they aren't likely to be using the 2S themselves.
The Mix 2S is probably never going to be a good phone to own if you don't want to run MIUI. Maybe Xiaomi's policies will change in the future but at the moment they seem to have no interest in encouraging third party development for their phones. They see themselves as competing directly with Apple rather than as an Android brand which is also the case with Samsung.
eDooM85 said:
Any recomendation for a ROM based on AOSP
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm using the unofficial phh Resurrection Remix rom .
I'm on version 5, A-only with the included Gapps. It works just fine for me, open camera and all.
russphil said:
I'm using the unofficial phh Resurrection Remix rom .
I'm on version 5, A-only with the included Gapps. It works just fine for me, open camera and all.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks I'm gonna try that, when the 360h period is over
Enviado desde mi Mi MIX 2S mediante Tapatalk
I used the official and the unofficial version found on XDA. Both worked fine for me, expect some minor flaws, some glitches as it's a work in progress.
I used it as a daily driver and for what I'm using it it's working just fine.
I'm on pixel experience now and it's really good too, will stay with it for now.
RR has lots of customizations that's where it shines. As I don't need all the features and prefer a clean AOSP near experience I switched to PE.
Where did you find PE ROM for mi mix 2s?
Antoxin said:
Where did you find PE ROM for mi mix 2s?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Maybe the treble rom.
hbbxmjbb said:
Maybe the treble rom.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, go to the Project Treble section of XDA. It's available there.
It works, but Bluetooth and some dedicated functions seem not working. And it is so stable, especially if you rely on Xposed and Magisk for daily use.
PriceKiller said:
It works, but Bluetooth and some dedicated functions seem not working. And it is so stable, especially if you rely on Xposed and Magisk for daily use.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Bluetooth is broken on all GSI Treble ROMs for this device. The Mokee ROM posted in this forum is actually stable enough for daily driver IMO. Just make sure to follow the instructions in the thread from Hyapatia.

Our devices is dead??? No more rom support?

Hi, since Xiaomi decided to depreciate rom support for our mi4c, everyday i try to find a replacement firmware. But here is what i found: official lineage removed mi4c since april, last rom is 0209 because they no longer support 14.1 version. AICP lastest version is 2702, no longer update. There're many unofficial roms on 4pda, but all of them now have their support ended because the devs move to new devices. There's only Mokee that support nightly 9.0 and release 8.1 version everyday and monthly. I try to find something like "mi4c treble" but no hope, the repository is created but empty, not like mi4 that has unofficial treble support. Maybe i need to buy a new phone? But my phone is still in good condition with no problem so far... :crying::crying::crying:
Yeah, sad but true. I also gave up on new rom, so i still use the 15.1 LineageOS one (20180810). Good rom, no problems here, but wouldnt mind some security updates.
The phone works nicely though and apart from battery lasting a day, i dont see any problems. I guess we will have to move to new phone if we want to see some updates rom.
I resized device partition table in order to support android treble.
I will make custom recovery image which is support android treble.
Maybe our device is ready to support android treble by then
added
I made treble-enabled recovery image now and it works well.
I will release the solution soon.
dla5244 said:
I resized device partition table in order to support android treble.
I will make custom recovery image which is support android treble.
Maybe our device is ready to support android treble by then
added
I made treble-enabled recovery image now and it works well.
I will release the solution soon.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you, i'm waiting for your topic
AgiZ10 said:
Yeah, sad but true. I also gave up on new rom, so i still use the 15.1 LineageOS one (20180810). Good rom, no problems here, but wouldnt mind some security updates.
The phone works nicely though and apart from battery lasting a day, i dont see any problems. I guess we will have to move to new phone if we want to see some updates rom.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is that the one without vibration support?
https://gitlab.e.foundation/e/wiki/en/wikis/device/libra/install
it's a fork of LineageOS, still being updated
haven't tested it yet
This is update of lineage-16.0.
https://androidfilehost.com/?w=files&flid=289411
wRAR_ said:
Is that the one without vibration support?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, that is the one.
Tfgru said:
https://gitlab.e.foundation/e/wiki/en/wikis/device/libra/install
it's a fork of LineageOS, still being updated
haven't tested it yet
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Anyone tested it yet? It seems /e/ is sort of microg. how is it different?
Autines said:
This is update of lineage-16.0.
https://androidfilehost.com/?w=files&flid=289411
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Why is this not on this forum, and where is the development thread being discussed? Are there any problems with it? Anyone tested it?
dla5244 said:
I resized device partition table in order to support android treble.
I will make custom recovery image which is support android treble.
Maybe our device is ready to support android treble by then
added
I made treble-enabled recovery image now and it works well.
I will release the solution soon.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Great news, we're waiting for
AgiZ10 said:
Anyone tested it yet? It seems /e/ is sort of microg. how is it different?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
/e/ is a fork of lineage and based on lineage 14.1 for our phone, with microg pre installed. They use a different default launcher, bliss
It works well and is easy to tweak if we dont like the launcher or default apps.
Anyway since our phone is no longer maintained i've decided to build lineage 14.1 for myself.
I'll do it once or twice a month when there are updates.
If anyone need it check here :
androidfilehost.com/?w=files&flid=299596
corwinux said:
/e/ is a fork of lineage and based on lineage 14.1 for our phone, with microg pre installed. They use a different default launcher, bliss
It works well and is easy to tweak if we dont like the launcher or default apps.
Anyway since our phone is no longer maintained i've decided to build lineage 14.1 for myself.
I'll do it once or twice a month when there are updates.
If anyone need it check here :
androidfilehost.com/?w=files&flid=299596
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thanks
Mokee have a good android 9 ROM, been using it for months and no issues:
https://download.mokeedev.com/libra.html
Also WJXXBSH recently published new Lineage 16 and even 17! https://androidfilehost.com/?w=files&flid=299149
I have not tried it yet, but at least WJXXBSH is keeping our device live.
how about lineage 16 from havoic 3.1 (https://sourceforge.net/projects/havoc-os/files/libra/)
At least it work fine for me on mi4c

Android 10 ROMS for our beloved P2?--- A Discussion.

Does anyone know any developer who would be willing to make android-10 ROMS for our P2 or is Pie the last update for this awesome phone?
Kinngk said:
Does anyone know any developer who would be willing to make android-10 ROMS for our P2 or is Pie the last update for this awesome phone?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hopefully not as the developers said that as long as they have this phone working they'll keep the development going. :fingers-crossed::fingers-crossed:
Well, I hope there will be future development for this phone too. I'm using one for more than 2 years, and battery still rocks, it sure lasts more than any flagship !
as far as i can tell, mike is working on lineage os 17.
so at least one android 10 rom might be coming soon
ryd3r89 said:
Well, I hope there will be future development for this phone too. I'm using one for more than 2 years, and battery still rocks, it sure lasts more than any flagship !
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yea bro same, more than 2.5 years and still i get SOT of 6-7 hours.
Whenever i think of buying a new phone, i look at my p2 and i stop. Its still so smooth cuz of the ROMS and charges under 1 hour and 15 minutes.
This phone is the best purchase i ever had. So i want development to keep going on, atleast for 1 more iteration of Android. Then i'll maybe buy Redmi K20 pro next year cuz it'll also have good development in future.
@Erazor84 that's good news brother. But I'll wait for AOSP xtended Android-10 (if it ever comes)
Bcuz i used their Oreo build and now using pie, and i found them the best among all of'em.
Erazor84 said:
as far as i can tell, mike is working on lineage os 17.
so at least one android 10 rom might be coming soon
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My guess would be at least 2 more ROMs :fingers-crossed: one from @VladSor and second from @Fullbustah as they are consistent with porting/ developing the ROMs such as Havoc, Syberia, Bootleggers and POSP for P2.
But of course, we need a reliable vendor upgrade first.
Xiaomi redmi note 4 which has the same Specs has just got lineage 17.
mido hamdy said:
Xiaomi redmi note 4 which has the same Specs has just got lineage 17.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
We're next, I guess :fingers-crossed:
Kinngk said:
Does anyone know any developer who would be willing to make android-10 ROMS for our P2 or is Pie the last update for this awesome phone?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yus coming 10
Astridxx said:
Yus coming 10
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You're the man buddy!:highfive:
Only sgsi are coming for our device No rom yet , and those gsi are also ****ty...
shivang_bagh said:
Only sgsi are coming for our device No rom yet , and those gsi are also ****ty...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you tell me please what is the meaning of gsi ? Or sgsi?
is there any chance for android 10 for havoc os?
As per my understanding:
HACKIMTOSH said:
Can you tell me please what is the meaning of gsi ? Or sgsi?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Generic System Image (GSI) is pure untouched Android released by Google for treble enabled phones with a designated vendor partition.
Semi GSI (SGSI) is a customized GSI with features and name of a custom ROM and it can also be installed on treble enabled phones with a designated vendor partition.
alirazaagha said:
Generic System Image (GSI) is pure untouched Android released by Google for treble enabled phones with a designated vendor partition.
Semi GSI (SGSI) is a customized GSI with features and name of a custom ROM and it can also be installed on treble enabled phones with a designated vendor partition.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Now i see , thank you bro
How is Android 10 on Lenovo P2? Is it stable? I am on stock Rom Android 7. How to get from stock to Android 10?
Thank you.
Astridxx said:
Yus coming 10
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The following url https://forum.xda-developers.com/lenovo-p2/development/rom-aosip-derpfest-t3981193 will give You access on this forum to the thread concerning AOSiP-10-DerpFest-Alpha-kuntao-20191009.zip which is the first alpha version of the first Android 10 custom rom dedicated to the Lenovo P2.
If You are interested in testing this Android 10 rom, just follow the installation instructions given on the first page of the thread.
If I well understood, I think that someone, maybe mikeioannina ?, should now be working on a Android 10 rom LineageOS 17. If this is the case, all we can do is to be patient.
You will note that from now on we must say Android 10 instead of Q as asked by Google. So, next year, the next version of Android will be Android 11 and not R.
Below is the lineageos github page for Kuntao (Lenovo P2a42), the branch is on 17.0, but it seems it hadn't been developed on in 4 months, but i don't know how these things go...
Github Kuntao: https://github.com/LineageOS/android_device_lenovo_kuntao
Roms for kuntao
slovantes said:
Below is the lineageos github page for Kuntao (Lenovo P2a42), the branch is on 17.0, but it seems it hadn't been developed on in 4 months, but i don't know how these things go...
Github Kuntao: https://github.com/LineageOS/android_device_lenovo_kuntao
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hello I've tried all of the versions on my KUNTAO, at the beggining very laggy now better, there are some ROMS which you can use w/out a problem if you can live w/out some of the features like the FP GESTURES OR AA CONNECTIVITY.
HAVOC 3.0 (NOT THE TREBLE VERSION) to me is the best option till this post furthermore I don't know.
CHHERS
So, We are half a year further from the last post in this thread, any news on the stability and performance of the android 10 rom's? Im right now on Crdroid Pie ROM and except fingerprint kicking the bucket everything is working flawlessly. Any stable and well performing 10 rom's out there, or should we wait a little longer?

Categories

Resources