Magisk not working on DP2 - Google Pixel 2 Questions & Answers

Has anyone gotten Magisk to work on DP2? Whenever I flash it through TWRP the phone just ends up in a bootloop with the "G" logo. I know the problem is with Magisk (I've tried Magisk 16.1-16.4) and not with TWRP because when I installed TWRP by itself the phone booted fine. However, once I flashed Magisk I ended up getting stuck in a bootloop again. Any help would be greatly appreciated!

akablasian said:
Has anyone gotten Magisk to work on DP2? Whenever I flash it through TWRP the phone just ends up in a bootloop with the "G" logo. I know the problem is with Magisk (I've tried Magisk 16.1-16.4) and not with TWRP because when I installed TWRP by itself the phone booted fine. However, once I flashed Magisk I ended up getting stuck in a bootloop again. Any help would be greatly appreciated!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Working here.. on magisk version 16.4. Have not changed from stock kernel and had only added my google account at that point.. not sure what else to tell you. Try booting it a few times, magisk seems to cause it to get stuck sometimes for me on 8.1, probably same problems on 9.

Magisk and its SU are working fine -- Systemless Ad Block however does not seem to be.

sulpher said:
Working here.. on magisk version 16.4. Have not changed from stock kernel and had only added my google account at that point.. not sure what else to tell you. Try booting it a few times, magisk seems to cause it to get stuck sometimes for me on 8.1, probably same problems on 9.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for trying to help. I tried rebooting it several times but had no luck. However, I just decided to try wiping data during the DP2 installation and now it seems to have worked.

Related

Updated to 9.5.9 and now it reboots into TWRP over and over.

I followed the previously rooted guide to update to 9.5.9 and now when the phone reboots, it gets to the unlock screen and immediately tells me its shutting down and reboots back into twrp again. How do i fix this? Please help and thank you.
what method did you use (there are a million rooted guides)? did u get the correct OS OTA for you model phone? provide us more info please.
Looks like i forgot to turn off the magisk modules. I had to go into twrp and delete them all and re download the modules. silly me
I'm having a similar issue. I can't figure out what to do, but I i went and deleted all the zip files for magisk but after reinstalling magisk thru twrp, I get stuck booting to recovery everytime. I can someone help point me in the right direction?
jakemaxfield said:
I'm having a similar issue. I can't figure out what to do, but I i went and deleted all the zip files for magisk but after reinstalling magisk thru twrp, I get stuck booting to recovery everytime. I can someone help point me in the right direction?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I stuck at the same situation. Can you flashboot flash boot.img and then it can boot normally?
Same problem here.
Situation before flash: stock 9.5.8, Magisk, a number of Magisk modules
What I did:
* downloaded 9.5.9 with Oxygen Updater
* disabled Magisk modules
* rebooted
* installed 9.5.9 from the builtin System Update
* went to Magisk, installed it with After OTA
* rebooted to recovery
* installed TWRP and Magisk
* cleared Dalvik
* rebooted to system
The phone seems to start normally, but when it reaches the unlock screen it immediately goes to Power Off, then it reboots to TWRP (not power off). From TWRP I can decrypt data ok etc.
I tried reinstalling the boot loader, OTA image, TWRP, Magisk - same result. Rebooting to system from TWRP just goes back to Power Off then TWRP.
equlizer said:
I followed the previously rooted guide to update to 9.5.9 and now when the phone reboots, it gets to the unlock screen and immediately tells me its shutting down and reboots back into twrp again. How do i fix this? Please help and thank you.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If this is any help in the future, whilst I don't have twrp, I install the updates via local update in settings > system > updates and then before reboot I go to magisk manager, and install magisk to second slot and reboot. Never had a problem and I'm on 9.5.9 now. The only modules I disable, update, or remove are the magisk ROMs available here such as no limits, as they are usually version specific.
manor7777 said:
If this is any help in the future, whilst I don't have twrp, I install the updates via local update in settings > system > updates and then before reboot I go to magisk manager, and install magisk to second slot and reboot. Never had a problem and I'm on 9.5.9 now. The only modules I disable, update, or remove are the magisk ROMs available here such as no limits, as they are usually version specific.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's exactly what I did. It landed me to the bootloop.
All you guys had to do is,
Install the full uddate zip in twrp,
Install the latest twrp zip,
Reboot recovery,
Install latest magisk,
Reboot system,
Hope this helps, cheers
Update: I can break out of the loop from TWRP > Advanced > Fix Recovery Bootloop. That lets me boot normally, but loses root. As soon as I reinstall Magisk I get back to the bootloop.
lcd047 said:
Update: I can break out of the loop from TWRP > Advanced > Fix Recovery Bootloop. That lets me boot normally, but loses root. As soon as I reinstall Magisk I get back to the bootloop.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm in the same boat.
My twrp doesn't offer to decrypt partition_b so I cannot manually install Magisk on the new partition.
This seems to be a common problem when updating rooted Oneplus 7 pro and I haven't found a update guide which actually works every time. Last update to 9.5.8 I had the same issue where I couldn't get into oxygen os because it turned itself off and when twrp opened I couldn't decrypt the data. I couldn't find a solution last time and I had to full wipe and start from scratch. Now I don't want the same to happen so I hope someone can post a guide how to do the update successfully.
sapalot said:
This seems to be a common problem when updating rooted Oneplus 7 pro and I haven't found a update guide which actually works every time. Last update to 9.5.8 I had the same issue where I couldn't get into oxygen os because it turned itself off and when twrp opened I couldn't decrypt the data. I couldn't find a solution last time and I had to full wipe and start from scratch. Now I don't want the same to happen so I hope someone can post a guide how to do the update successfully.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
https://forum.xda-developers.com/oneplus-7-pro/how-to/successfully-upgraded-to-9-5-7-t3937414.
Works every time, the same way I have been doing for both 6T and 7 Pro.
Sometimes you might be on the wrong active slot, you can change this by using fastboot set_active a or fastboot set_active b. TWRP seems to like changing your slot but will tell you when it does. If you're getting stuck try changing slot and booting.
schmeggy929 said:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/oneplus-7-pro/how-to/successfully-upgraded-to-9-5-7-t3937414.
Works every time, the same way I have been doing for both 6T and 7 Pro.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It worked for me for 9.5.8, got the bootloop this time around. I guess this means I'm not the Chosen One.
---------- Post added at 03:37 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:34 PM ----------
djsubterrain said:
Sometimes you might be on the wrong active slot, you can change this by using fastboot set_active a or fastboot set_active b. TWRP seems to like changing your slot but will tell you when it does. If you're getting stuck try changing slot and booting.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I tried that too. When I switch to the other slot I get to a menu where I can only wipe data, reboot to boot loader, or reboot to recovery. Not particularly useful.
Hey guys!
I'm having the same problem. No matter how I try to update it will reboot to stock recovery.
I was wondering if any of you have /Data converted to f2fs? Maybe it could be culprit...
mkos86 said:
Hey guys!
I'm having the same problem. No matter how I try to update it will reboot to stock recovery.
I was wondering if any of you have /Data converted to f2fs? Maybe it could be culprit...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What I had to do here was go to fastboot mode and flash twrp img. Then in TWRP I flash the TWRP zip file and magisk and rebooted. All good
Alright so I fixed mine. I went and just removed all the modules while I was in twrp. To do that go to Advanced, then file manager or whatever it says, find the adb folder and from there look for a folder named Modules and just delete them all. From there just reinstall magisk through twrp and it should all work.
jakemaxfield said:
Alright so I fixed mine. I went and just removed all the modules while I was in twrp. To do that go to Advanced, then file manager or whatever it says, find the adb folder and from there look for a folder named Modules and just delete them all. From there just reinstall magisk through twrp and it should all work.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you sir, this fixed it for me, too. So the missing link was that Magisk modules have to be removed completely, not just disabled, before upgrading. Removing all directories except .core from /data/adb/modules allows the phone to boot normally, with Magisk enabled.
schmeggy929 said:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/oneplus-7-pro/how-to/successfully-upgraded-to-9-5-7-t3937414.
Works every time, the same way I have been doing for both 6T and 7 Pro.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thats the way i tried that time and got stuck in bootloop.

Magisk causes bootloop

Hi! I just updated to 9.5.11 and tried flashing magisk 19.3 however that just causes a bootloop. I was flashing it through TWRP and immidiately when the enter pin-screen shows it says powering off. I then get rebooted into TWRP, when I go in advanced settings and press fix recovery bootloop it starts working again (I can boot and use the phone normally) but still no magisk. Anyone have any idea what I might be doing wrong? Downloaded the magisk file from the app, and tried from the website. Also tried using the all in one tool. Same issue. Appreciate any help.
warrip said:
Hi! I just updated to 9.5.11 and tried flashing magisk 19.3 however that just causes a bootloop. I was flashing it through TWRP and immidiately when the enter pin-screen shows it says powering off. I then get rebooted into TWRP, when I go in advanced settings and press fix recovery bootloop it starts working again (I can boot and use the phone normally) but still no magisk. Anyone have any idea what I might be doing wrong? Downloaded the magisk file from the app, and tried from the website. Also tried using the all in one tool. Same issue. Appreciate any help.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Try to flash Magisk unninstaller first and only after attempt to reflash Magisk.
Most likely you left some module installed/active before the update that is causing the bootloops

Can´t boot to recovery. Always landing in QUALCOMM CrashDump Mode

Like the title says, I can´t boot to recovery (Oneplus one). If I try to boot to recovery, I´m ending in the Qualcomm CrashDump Mode.
I have a Oneplus 7 Pro with Stable 10.0 BA FW.
Rooted with Magisk (Patched Boot.img) Is this causing the problem?
After pressing Vol+ and powerbutton, the devices boots normally.
Thanks in advance.
RealDanyo said:
Like the title says, I can´t boot to recovery (Oneplus one). If I try to boot to recovery, I´m ending in the Qualcomm CrashDump Mode.
I have a Oneplus 7 Pro with Stable 10.0 BA FW.
Rooted with Magisk (Patched Boot.img) Is this causing the problem?
After pressing Vol+ and powerbutton, the devices boot normally.
Thanks in advance.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I had the same issue this morning when trying to update to 10.0.1. Just boot to bootloader and boot twrp then install 10.
I think is the magisk update (magisk 20.0) that causes this, because it's happening to me in the beta 3 and before I updated magisk it was working fine with the beta 2
ItsTecnoDavid said:
I think is the magisk update (magisk 20.0) that causes this, because it's happening to me in the beta 3 and before I updated magisk it was working fine with the beta 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have no issues with magisk or twrp.
It might be the way you are installing ota or rom.
Might be model specific not sure as I don't know what model you are on. Mine is GM1915.
I'm talking about the official recovery
GM21AA, exactly the same situation (from 10 stable to 10.0.1 and magisk from 19.4 beta to 20) and the stock recovery bump into Qualcomm Crashdump problem here, system bootup normal as well as bootloader.
Troubleshooting:
1. Local update twice, install magisk at inactive slot OTA before reboot, for Android 10's A/B partitions machinasm , try let magisk patch both boot.img. Same...
2. Local update and reboot, lost root but stock recovery work, Fastboot boot twrp.img (latest, not flash, cause I don't need the permanent twrp)->twrp install magisk, reboot system, then, again, same problem.
Todo:
Magisk manager or twrp uninstall magisk, but if it's fail maybe ended up to bootloop, scary.
May try to install back old 19.4 magisk.zip via twrp, it's working in 10.0.0
Anyone with the same problem have any idea?
Thats the exact same error I ran into.
But as mentioned earlier, I never had TWRP on my OP7P. I flashed the patched boot.img via adb and I´m still on 10.0 BA Firmware.
I thought TWRP dosn´t work on Android Q (I´m coming from an Pixel3 and there it won´t work) So maybe I will give TWRP a try tomorrow. Are there different versions or is the official one the best?
RealDanyo said:
Thats the exact same error I ran into.
But as mentioned erlier, I never had TWRP on my OP7P. I flashed the patched boot.img via adb and I´m still on 10.0 BA Firmware.
I thought TWRP dosn´t work on Android Q (I´m coming from an Pixel3 and there it won´t work) So maybe I will give TWRP a try tomorrow. Are there different versions or is the official one the best?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The recovery here is the one to use.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/on...nt/recovery-unofficial-twrp-recovery-t3931322
Be sure to read through
So thanks erveryone who helped.
I now have TWRP running as recovery. So there is no need for official recovery. (and no Qualcomm CrashDump Mode)
Had this happen to me earlier this week. Just ended up using the MSM tool and restoring shipping firmware. You can look for the unbricking thread here for more info on that.
Yea, this just happened to me. Updated Magisk, Updated to 10.0.1 from 10.0. Booted fine.
Re-installed a few magisk modules (didn't just re check the modules, but reinstalled each)
Now OS won't boot, and recovery goes to Crash Dump. Would be ok if OS wouldn't bootloop and I could get to OS.
Oh, and my ADB now is an unauthorized device while its in bootloop mode
EDIT:
phew. Tried to hold volume up+dn rather than up or dn, got into bootloader. Able to fastboot boot TWRP and then delete problematic RIRU magisk modules. All is well in the world now...
I don't get it why it have to be so hard.
I'm constantly soft bricking/ bootlooping this phone when trying to do simple things such flashing magisk and twrp. I remember it being so much easier with my Poco F1, never got close to bricking it.
Now every little mistake ends with a bricked phone and 5 hours on the internet trying to understand why
WillyRy said:
Yea, this just happened to me. Updated Magisk, Updated to 10.0.1 from 10.0. Booted fine.
Re-installed a few magisk modules (didn't just re check the modules, but reinstalled each)
Now OS won't boot, and recovery goes to Crash Dump. Would be ok if OS wouldn't bootloop and I could get to OS.
Oh, and my ADB now is an unauthorized device while its in bootloop mode
EDIT:
phew. Tried to hold volume up+dn rather than up or dn, got into bootloader. Able to fastboot boot TWRP and then delete problematic RIRU magisk modules. All is well in the world now...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Same issue here and no TWRP installed.
I did ADB REBOOT FASTBOOT and was able to install the twrp image by FASTBOOT BOOT twrp-3.3.1-70-guacamole-unified-Q-mauronofrio.img
Going to try and remove Magisk and see if I can salvage my data and then re-install Magisk afterwards.
Ok...got back into the system by flashing the Magisk Uninstaller in TWRP that is here: https://magiskroot.net/md/Magisk_Manager_for_Recovery_Mode_(mm)-2019.4.4.zip
Went to advanced in TWRP, then to terminal, then typed mm.
Typed in C for Core only to load into system without Magisk. Deleted my Magisk modules that may have interfered with it (I had an older version of No Limit that I should have updated prior. After removing and rebooting back into system, all is fine now.
JLine05 said:
Same issue here and no TWRP installed.
I did ADB REBOOT FASTBOOT and was able to install the twrp image by FASTBOOT BOOT twrp-3.3.1-70-guacamole-unified-Q-mauronofrio.img
Going to try and remove Magisk and see if I can salvage my data and then re-install Magisk afterwards.
Ok...got back into the system by flashing the Magisk Uninstaller in TWRP that is here: https://magiskroot.net/md/Magisk_Manager_for_Recovery_Mode_(mm)-2019.4.4.zip
Went to advanced in TWRP, then to terminal, then typed mm.
Typed in C for Core only to load into system without Magisk. Deleted my Magisk modules that may have interfered with it (I had an older version of No Limit that I should have updated prior. After removing and rebooting back into system, all is fine now.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yea man, things are hinkey this update.
My big problem was i had twrp but it got wiped i guess (could no longer access) and couldn't access adb nor fastboot. But finally got into bootloader (cmd fastboot) so was able to fix.
Easier solution than installing Magisk uninstaller (presuming one has twrp installed, which would be the case if able to flash Magisk uninstaller) is go to TWRP>advanced>file manager and navigate data/adb/modules and delete from there
DO you guys know if there is an updated magisk being developed or what is the way to fix it? Uninstall magisk via TWRP (since I can temporarily install and get into TWRP using the all in one tool by the TWRP developer). Then install TWRP and then Install Magisk ?
I have same problem
How to fix it and bring back stock recovery?
wawanRedblack said:
I have same problem
How to fix it and bring back stock recovery?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you boot OS?
Can you get to bootloader?
WillyRy said:
Can you boot OS?
Can you get to bootloader?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes i can boot os and bootloader is ok

Stuck on an infinite boot animation that runs slow after installing Magisk 20.1

Ok, so I had to reinstall my OS through TWRP (2GB Full update)... and rebooting to the Bootloader to reinstall TWRP and rebooting again, I want to install Magisk again.
When I install Magisk through TWRP and reboot, the boot animation is stuck forever and animates very slowly. The only way to get out is to press VOL UP + POWER and inmediately VOL DOWN + POWER to enter TWRP. To fix the stuck boot animation I have to reinstall the full OxygenOS update and reinstall TWRP.
My problem is that I'm in this vicious cicle where if I install Magisk it doesn't work and I have to reinstall the OS and TWRP.
What am I missing? Why Magisk is making my device stuck on the boot screen?
Any help will be appreciated. Thanks!
I had that earlier today. For me I switched to the other partition from twrp and rebooted and it worked fine. Guess I'll flash ROM and magisk to both partitions next time
skymera said:
I had that earlier today. For me I switched to the other partition from twrp and rebooted and it worked fine. Guess I'll flash ROM and magisk to both partitions next time
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So let me make sure I understood you. I need to switch to Slot B and also install the OS and Magisk?
OK, an update. After trying to switch slots, install the OS in both of them and Magisk and all the possible permutations, I tried flashing 19.4 and it worked flawlessly first time.
Now I'm going to update it!
Update 2: I'm finally running the latest version! Updating Magisk through Magisk Manager worked fine.
Deses said:
OK, an update. After trying to switch slots, install the OS in both of them and Magisk and all the possible permutations, I tried flashing 19.4 and it worked flawlessly first time.
Now I'm going to update it!
Update 2: I'm finally running the latest version! Updating Magisk through Magisk Manager worked fine.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have the same issue with the slow boot animation and the endless loading. I tried to install the OTA again, TWRP again and magisk 20.1, 20.0, 19.4 ...
Sadly the animation stays that slow and my OP7Pro doesnt boot up. How exactly did you get rid of that problem? I feel like I tried every combination of flashing
dennisgrue said:
I have the same issue with the slow boot animation and the endless loading. I tried to install the OTA again, TWRP again and magisk 20.1, 20.0, 19.4 ...
Sadly the animation stays that slow and my OP7Pro doesnt boot up. How exactly did you get rid of that problem? I feel like I tried every combination of flashing
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I had this with PA. Not sure what caused it as my flashing process is the same every time.
In the end I gave up and formatted /data
skymera said:
I had this with PA. Not sure what caused it as my flashing process is the same every time.
In the end I gave up and formatted /data
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I decided to give up too... Was a bad mistake. I accidentely rebooted the phone after the update today. I will never do that mistake again
That dreadful moment when you have this problem again and googling points you to your own thread with no solutions.
UPDATE: Oh I think I got it! I had to uninstall Magisk Manager AND flash Magisk Uninstaller zip, reboot to OS, reboot to Recovery again and flash Magisk 20.3 again and it finally worked! No more stuck slow boot animation.
Probably the two reboots aren't needed, but I like doing things slow.

Flashing magisk 20.1 on OOS 10.3.0 causing bootloop

Last week I installed the 10.3.0 OTA without unsinstalling magisk and its modules because I completely forgot to, so the update got rid of root but the modules wheren't uninstalled correctly. Today I tried to flash magisk again several times through twrp and got bootloops every time, I eventually thought of removing the leftover modules and trying to flash again, since I still got a bootloop I completely unsinstalled magisk with the uninstaller.zip and tried to flash magisk again several times but they all also ended in a bootloop that was only fixed by flashing the uninstaller.zip again.
Does anybody know what could be causing these loops and how to fix them? I'm using twrp 3.3.1-16 for OP6 by mauronofrio.
Hello!
Try this last Blue Spark TWRP. That solved my problem (same as yours): blu_spark_r112-oos_op6-op6t_0dd5f9228.zip
HERE: https://github.com/engstk/op6/releases
SkyWo said:
Does anybody know what could be causing these loops and how to fix them? I'm using twrp 3.3.1-16 for OP6 by mauronofrio.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
mauronofrio wrote the following in his TWRP thread a while ago. You can try blu_spark TWRP that Ysar57 linked earlier -- I haven't tried it personally together with Magisk so I don't know if it will work or not.
So little update, after some tests i'm sure there is a compatibility problem between twrp and magisk, i was able to get only one of them, so actually i don't know how to proceed, i need to understand if it is a twrp problem or a magisk problem, TWRP is in stand-by for now.
There are not problems on Android Pie, if you need of the twrp on android Q just flash in boot partition the Q .img (fastboot flash boot twrp.img) and then reboot from fastboot in recovery. Before publishing the twrp I had not tested magisk and twrp together.
On Android 10 use only magisk 19.4
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ysar57 said:
Hello!
Try this last Blue Spark TWRP. That solved my problem (same as yours): blu_spark_r112-oos_op6-op6t_0dd5f9228.zip
HERE: https://github.com/engstk/op6/releases
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I tried following your exact guide from the TWRP post and now it doesn't even get to the bootloop. Maybe I'm missing something?
Don't need flash 3rd party kernel like Blue Spark.
When you got bootloop after first time install Magisk on OOS 10
All you need to do is unistall Magisk through ‘twrp 3.3.1-16 for OP6 by mauronofrio’. Then reboot into system
After that reboot to bootloader, and boot the recovery and install latest Magisk 20.4 again
---------- Post added at 08:13 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:13 PM ----------
Don't need flash 3rd party kernel like Blue Spark.
When you got bootloop after first time install Magisk on OOS 10
All you need to do is unistall Magisk through ‘twrp 3.3.1-16 for OP6 by mauronofrio’. Then reboot into system
After that reboot to bootloader, and boot the recovery and install latest Magisk 20.4 again

Categories

Resources