Hi all.
I'm about to get my first N4, and I read and hear everywhere that it's like the most fragile phone ever. I did my research and I can't find a decent review about any of the cases in the market.
A case purpose is to protect the phone from a drop. And given that there's no drop test of a n4 with a case I wanted to ask for your feedback.
How many times?
Which case?
How nasty was the drop?
What side did it land?
Of course if you have a bad experience to tell you're more than welcome to share.
This is my first thread and English is not my first language. If I made some mistake please tell me.
Thanks in advance
Once, maybe. It's hard to know how much damage the fall would've done. Might've just scratched the sides, might've shattered part of the glass. Might also have done pretty much nothing. It fell flat on its front, as far as I remember, and it was on bathroom tiles from.. about 1.5 meters. There've been a couple of minor falls as well, which, I think, would've have done anything more than maybe minor scratching without a case. Drop tests won't really help, unless someone would do larger studies. With a single fall, there are so many variables..
The case: diztronic TPU, but as of today, I maybe would look for one where the buttons are easier to press.
In general, the phone isn't as fragile as I first feared. Even with tight pants and quite a bit of pressure (accidentally sat down on it once on my bed), nothing has really happened so far.
Has anyone here decided to forego a case entirely after deciding the phone didn't need a case?
Usually I drop mine at 0.7metres, both my LG Bumper and a ****ty tpu case have saved my ass numerous times. But without my back and from screenprotectors the glass would have been broken. I have dropped it maybe 10 times, half of it on hard wood or cement
Sent from my Nexus 4 using Tapatalk 4
Phone was sitting on top of a blanket on my car, my friend pulls the blanket without realizing my phone was there. The phone flew several feet and landed hard on the pavment screen side down. I ran over to my phone and was amazed when there was no crack or anything. My 12$ case saved my butt!
Using diztronic tpu case. Dropped 3 times from chest height on marble/concrete ground.
Not a single scratch. Not a single crack.
Sent from my Nexus 4 using xda premium
I had a variety of cases on the phone and never dropped it. Tried it "naked" and was hooked with the slim feel and the quality look.
Then a few weeks I dropped it getting out of my car onto the concrete from about 3 feet (hand to ground)
Landed on the corner. Front and back glass both completely shattered.
Had to replace the screen and am living with the shattered back.
and extra $150 and hours of my time down the drain.
Don't risk it. It isn't worth it. I will never go without a case again. Just not worth the risk or cost.
Since then I dropped it from the same height with my TPU case on. Not a scratch or any sign of damage.
DEFINITELY worth it. Only takes one drop to destroy this beautiful phone.
My rubberized matte Dizitronic saved my phone every time I've dropped it, except for the one time when I didn't have it on. Now I have several small cracks and dings on the face. Perfect.
Never. I'm really careful.
Original bumper - 6 drops - all corner strikes on variety of surfaces including concrete from heights up to 4 1/2 feet.
Total score: 0 scratches, 0 cracks. Bumper had some slightly scuffed chrome.
I've switched to the Poetic now but not had any drops so far. The thinner Poetic bumper makes the phone easier to grip (for me) but I doubt it would provide as much protection.
My case has saved my phone more than once, I constantly drop my phone from waist height (not on purpose of course) I've had 3 different cases I've dropped my phone most with my first and 3rd case. First case was the Diztronic TPU case, third (and current) case is the Rengke hybrid TPU/hard back.
My cases do a good job of protecting my phone I'm not worried. When I drop it it's usually on concrete or tile flooring. Up till now I get lazy with babying my phone when I'm sitting on a chair and I placed the phone on my lap, if it falls it falls, my case is good for it.
My all in one wallet case has well protected my N4 on a few occasions.
Never dripped it since I got it on release; p
Sent from my Nexus 4 using Tapatalk 4
Dropped mine quite a few times, once in particular where it sort of backflipped a couple times from chest height.
Not a single scratch nor scuff anywhere thanks to a cheap Remax TPU case.
Dropped my N4 from all sorts of heights and angles and it came out unscathed each time. Ringke case is definitely a great buy.
Its constantly saving it. The back and the sides would've been scratched as hell if I didn't have a case on
Sent from my Nexus 4 using xda app-developers app
my TPU case has protected it alot, im careful over the device in public but since i had the case from day one i know how much it can handle,i dropped it around the house fell off tables often, tossed it on the table like you do to a wallet.
ive tried those thin cases with the top and bottom exposed and that is the point of impact for me so i cant use them
This phone definitely needs a case with as much glass as it's sporting on both sides. Both the Ringke Fusion and now the Ionic case that I prefer have saved it from a few falls. The one time that I dropped it when it didn't have the case on it, it shattered the tempered glass protector but the screen itself was scratch free.
bobtheamazing said:
I had a variety of cases on the phone and never dropped it. Tried it "naked" and was hooked with the slim feel and the quality look.
Then a few weeks I dropped it getting out of my car onto the concrete from about 3 feet (hand to ground)
Landed on the corner. Front and back glass both completely shattered.
Had to replace the screen and am living with the shattered back.
and extra $150 and hours of my time down the drain.
Don't risk it. It isn't worth it. I will never go without a case again. Just not worth the risk or cost.
Since then I dropped it from the same height with my TPU case on. Not a scratch or any sign of damage.
DEFINITELY worth it. Only takes one drop to destroy this beautiful phone.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I completely agree. When i first bought my phone brand new, i put a slim hard case on it, it went to the edged but didn't cover the front the top of bottom edges. dropped it onto the concrete when i was getting out of the car, maybe 2-3 feet. I crack on the screen and the whole digitizer broke. Cost me $150 to replace and since then I've kept it in a diztronic tpu case. I've dropped it multiple times now from different heights and its been in perfect condition because that case covers all the edges. I highly recommend a case.
bobtheamazing said:
I had a variety of cases on the phone and never dropped it. Tried it "naked" and was hooked with the slim feel and the quality look.
Then a few weeks I dropped it getting out of my car onto the concrete from about 3 feet (hand to ground)
Landed on the corner. Front and back glass both completely shattered.
Had to replace the screen and am living with the shattered back.
and extra $150 and hours of my time down the drain.
Don't risk it. It isn't worth it. I will never go without a case again. Just not worth the risk or cost.
Since then I dropped it from the same height with my TPU case on. Not a scratch or any sign of damage.
DEFINITELY worth it. Only takes one drop to destroy this beautiful phone.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That happened to me with my Galaxy S2. Dropped it getting out of the car. Didn't bother replacing the screen, just bout the N4 lol
Now I have the N4 with the iLoome tempered glass protector and the Ionic case and it's been great.
Related
A lot of people use screen protectors and some don't....
I bought two but both got dust underneath them while installing them....and then they started peeling because of my case......
I do baby my phone to some extent and use it sensibly..
To people who use the phone naked how scratch resistant is the screen? Is it as good as an iPhone 4/4S (just a reference because my mom's has no screen guard from almost a year and there are no scratches at all....)?
Sent from my Nexus 4 using xda premium
Its pretty good tbh, I've never had any scratch or any sort of screen protection on any of my phones, to be fair Ive dropped quite a few times and it has one minor scratch at bottom of screen, but its very minimal, other than that its pretty solid I've had in pocket with coins keys, dropped it and feel out pocket a couple of times. I'd say it matches the iPhone 4s screen resistance my gf got that and she is just as clumsy as me.
Nexus 4 PACman + Franco
tiru.adi13 said:
A lot of people use screen protectors and some don't....
I bought two but both got dust underneath them while installing them....and then they started peeling because of my case......
I do baby my phone to some extent and use it sensibly..
To people who use the phone naked how scratch resistant is the screen? Is it as good as an iPhone 4/4S (just a reference because my mom's has no screen guard from almost a year and there are no scratches at all....)?
Sent from my Nexus 4 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Keep in mind that EVERY phone is susceptible to micro scratches. Scratches happen when an object that is harder than the screen comes in contact with it. Since our screens are gorilla glass, it is harder than keys, coins, knives, etc. These objects won't scratch the screen.
But dust and sand have particles in them that are as hard as diamond so any phone (including iphones) will get micro scratches after a while. If you hold your mom's phone up to the light you'll see them.
I put a very small (almost invisible) scratch in mine shortly after getting it. I think it came from dropping it in the local golf course pro shop (commercial carpet on concrete slab), where I am guessing some embedded sand was the culprit. Sand has no problem scratching glass - even Gorilla Glass. Since then, no other scratches have surfaced on either the front or back. I make sure my pockets are free from sand and dirt.
I do not like screen protectors. IMHO, the ruin the look and feel of a nice phone.
Mine was dropped from my pant's pocket and I have one visible scratch in the front glass near top.
Tough I have also tested nailing the front with T5 Torx screw driver without a single scratch but this fall from pocket was not that major fall but the scratch is there. :crying:
I have a rev_11 Nexus manufactured in May 2013. Its Indian version.
---------- Post added at 05:51 AM ---------- Previous post was at 05:50 AM ----------
I have never put any scratch guard or covers on any of my phones but this time it seems I will have to get some slim cover for the back atleast.
I didn't use screen protectors for a long time until I noticed the micro scratches all over in certain lighting. the good ones are very scratch resistant and hardly feel any different from the glass. Ive tried more than a few between my iphone and nexus, and the SGP ultra crystal are my favorite by far. I like them even better than the expensive tempered glass screen protectors.
you can get a dust free installation pretty easily with the dry install protectors. The secret is using tape to remove any dust that gets trapped under it. I've only ever had one dust free install that didn't require the use of tape. The steamy shower trick makes it even easier. Then, on the oleophobic surfaces you can even actually very slowly massage the protector around the glass after installation, which means it's very easy to get perfect placement.
Sent from my Nexus 4 using Tapatalk 2
I have a very light scratch on my screen. I wanted to play with it before covering it. Of course, with my luck, I got one within 24 hours. I think it was when my little maltese walked over it. Unless it was just my dry fingers cutting it up.
Off the bat I used my N4 without a screen protector for the front (one for the back though) and I had not a single scratch on the front for ~4 months.
I have screen protectors on the front now and it doesn't really matter to me, but I did drop it in the washroom where it dented the screen. Besides that, no micro scratches or anything, so I say the Nexus 4 is solid.
how does the screen get dented? you mean the chrome around the screen right?!
Ive had the phone for a few months and never used a case however there are some micro scratches which are barely visible, more on the back than the front. I got a diztronik slim case to use when i will be working in a dirty environment which helps, but 90% of the time NO CASE NAKED IS THE WAY TO GO. (I have dropped it twice luckily only a small mark on the edge/border ring)
I would highly recommend a case or a screen protector. When I first got the phone I decided not to use a case and within a few days had several scratches on the back and one on the front side without ever dropping it.
I got a case that lasted me a few months then fell apart and got ugly so i took it off and now I got 2 NEW scratch on the top right by the camera
Now I'm trying to find whats the best screen protector then might add the bumper.
funky_snowman said:
I didn't use screen protectors for a long time until I noticed the micro scratches all over in certain lighting. the good ones are very scratch resistant and hardly feel any different from the glass. Ive tried more than a few between my iphone and nexus, and the SGP ultra crystal are my favorite by far. I like them even better than the expensive tempered glass screen protectors.
you can get a dust free installation pretty easily with the dry install protectors. The secret is using tape to remove any dust that gets trapped under it. I've only ever had one dust free install that didn't require the use of tape. The steamy shower trick makes it even easier. Then, on the oleophobic surfaces you can even actually very slowly massage the protector around the glass after installation, which means it's very easy to get perfect placement.
Sent from my Nexus 4 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Another tip is to take a hot shower and do the application immediately afterward so that the dust settles and no more falls on the screen during application. Worked perfectly for me
Sent from my Nexus 4 using Tapatalk 4 Beta
My first Nexus 4 got a lot of small scratches at the corners on the screen, I took great care of it but I guess my pockets scratched it? I got a replacement and it is a lot better. I have about a 1mm scratch in the center only from having my keys in the same pocket. I have a bumper and I only have one screen protector on the back now because I heard it's not gorilla glass and it's more pron to scratches.
I use a tempered glass screen protector regardless of durability. I hate having scratches at all and my last nexus 4 before I rma'd had scratches visible and annoying in sunlight.
Sent from my Nexus 4 using xda app-developers app
I got 2 scratches on the back
I got a front screen guard but no back screen guard
I never kept my phone on its back (rarely do)
I guess I scratched it using my own fingernails which I am too lazy to cut
These 2 scratches make me feel so bad that I just ordered a ballistic case
How good is sigen glass screen protector?
http://www.spigen.com/brands/samsung/galaxy/galaxy-s5.html
They seem to very hard to be scratch proof. Do they prevent damage of screens from falling? If not, I probably will choose a cheaper one because I never put keys or coins along with my phones. Is there any other paricular good points of glass screen protectors?
thotwielder said:
how good is sigen glass screen protector?
http://www.spigen.com/brands/samsung/galaxy/galaxy-s5.html
they seem to very hard to be scratch proof. Do they prevent damage of screens from falling? If not, i probably will choose a cheaper one because i never put keys or coins along with my phones. Is there any other paricular good points of glass screen protectors?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i just ordered mine yesterday i will let you know..hopefully it works amazing
If it's at least equal to the one of the s4 I can say it's the best glass screen protector I came across. And yes it protects even on the little falls. Because it protect mine when I left fall down from my hand it wasn't a big fall but when I lift the phone up the screen protector had a crack and the original phone screen had absolutely nothing
Great to hear that. Will order one.
I currently have the Zagg one on mine, it works very nicely. Throw it in my motorcycle jacket pocket all the time without worrying about scratching the actual screen, especially since it has a lifetime warranty and I can just get a replacement if it scratches up too badly.
I'm sure the Spigen ones are similar.
Great to hear that, will get one.
I am currently using the Luvvitt and I have nothing but stellar remarks for it. It's cheap, and it works flawlessly. My first one had a microscopic nick in the top right edge that was preventing the screen protector from adhering on that edge. I let them know last Friday and SUNDAY the mailman hand delivered me a new one.. Not even sure how all of that happened but yeah, great customer service to boot.
tech armor
i got the tech armor ultraclear ballistic glass and have to say this is a pretty nice investment. It's $20 from amazon:
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00IGISUTG/ref=oh_details_o02_s00_i00?ie=UTF8&psc=1
and its crystal clear, easy to put on, and so far seems to be pretty rock solid. i havent thrown it down a gravel road or anything, but i am pretty impressed by how clear it is, how smooth it feels, and the time it took to install, which was about 5 minutes, followed by smoothing out one 'line' across the middle that looked like a crease or something, but went away by pushing it with my finger.
5 stars for this product.
ngravatt said:
i got the tech armor ultraclear ballistic glass and have to say this is a pretty nice investment. It's $20 from amazon:
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00IGISUTG/ref=oh_details_o02_s00_i00?ie=UTF8&psc=1
and its crystal clear, easy to put on, and so far seems to be pretty rock solid. i havent thrown it down a gravel road or anything, but i am pretty impressed by how clear it is, how smooth it feels, and the time it took to install, which was about 5 minutes, followed by smoothing out one 'line' across the middle that looked like a crease or something, but went away by pushing it with my finger.
5 stars for this product.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
:good: Gotta back you up on that one. Bought one and it's fantastic.
So I bought the GLAS.tr Nano the day it came out and was really excited about it. Unfortunately I was the first negative review on Amazon for the product. I got in contact with the company and it seems as though there was a batch that had issues with the tack used to stick it to the screen. Mine had several areas where it would just never stick along the edges and a huge area near the bottom that had no stick to it. I informed them and they promptly sent me a replacement. The replacement is perfect in every way and I couldn't be happier.
That said, I ordered the top rated glass protector with rounded edges on Amazon that was something like $12 for my girlfriend while I was having the issues with Spigen. Honestly the quality is almost identical for 1/3 the cost. If I had it to do over I would not have gone with the Spigen protector and gotten two of the cheaper options.
I did change my review to four stars but did not go with a full five due to it being over priced compared to the competition.
SS70Chevelle said:
So I bought the GLAS.tr Nano the day it came out and was really excited about it. Unfortunately I was the first negative review on Amazon for the product. I got in contact with the company and it seems as though there was a batch that had issues with the tack used to stick it to the screen. Mine had several areas where it would just never stick along the edges and a huge area near the bottom that had no stick to it. I informed them and they promptly sent me a replacement. The replacement is perfect in every way and I couldn't be happier.
That said, I ordered the top rated glass protector with rounded edges on Amazon that was something like $12 for my girlfriend while I was having the issues with Spigen. Honestly the quality is almost identical for 1/3 the cost. If I had it to do over I would not have gone with the Spigen protector and gotten two of the cheaper options.
I did change my review to four stars but did not go with a full five due to it being over priced compared to the competition.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What brand is the $12 one that you feel is almost as good?
enfurno said:
I am currently using the Luvvitt and I have nothing but stellar remarks for it. It's cheap, and it works flawlessly. My first one had a microscopic nick in the top right edge that was preventing the screen protector from adhering on that edge. I let them know last Friday and SUNDAY the mailman hand delivered me a new one.. Not even sure how all of that happened but yeah, great customer service to boot.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i have the same....works great....fit well...and super cheap to boot compared to the spigen:good:
I had the Spigen GlastR Nano on the S5 but had a speck of stuff under the screen. Pulled it off and installed the Zagg Glass and damn if I did not get another tiny speck under the Zagg also.
The Spigen is a nice glass but I like the Zagg a little better. Thinner, softer edges, easy tags for the install and it just feels plain nice.
MIME Feather Glass is what I ended up getting. Part of my decision was that I planned on getting my T-Mobile SGS5 from Delaware to avoid sales tax and I needed to have the screen protector (wanted to try glass for the first time too) by the time I had it too. I live in NJ and MIME is made in New York, so the quick shipping (free anyway but quick since we're neighbors) made it a good decision for me...
And I couldn't be ANY HAPPIER with my decision. It's so thin that I can barely feel it's there. I know if I went any thicker, I wouldn't like the feeling of going over the home button. The fit is beyond perfect and I don't have any scratches on it AT ALL yet. Keep in mind I go to the gym a lot and my pockets have zippers and I'm sure I'm constantly rubbing up against them when I take it out and put it in (that's what she said). No scratches at all. Responsiveness is completely unhindered.
I would highly recommend it...
---------------------------
Also, a little tip (regardless of brand I suppose, but the "purple film", basically a screen sized film with a very very light adhesive for "anti-dust preinstallation film" MIME gave actually came in VERY HANDY for me...) for the install!
credits to BillTheCat: http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1015394
okay, the only advice I really took here was to go into the bathroom at home (low dust environment!) and run the hot water in the shower for a bit (steam it up, even less dust).
at that point, I wiped my screen of course, then I just took the protector, handled it from the sides to make sure I got no oil on the adhesive side, and lined it up just right (worked for me, maybe you might want to try the tape method, but it may be difficult with glass protectors) and laid it down (bottom first to line up the home button perfectly). i ended up with 2 pieces of dust towards the top. damn it.
then the purple film came in damn handy. i very carefully (with my fingernails, but being careful not to actually touch under the glass and get marks on it) lifted up the glass and peeled it back just enough to get "purple film" underneath and "grab" the dust particles off of the screen. i was afraid it may leave marks or residue, but it didn't at all. not sure how painter's tape would work in this case, but I'm proud to say that I have a 100% dust free, mark free, PERFECT installation. =DDDD
then again, I have some patience and a fairly steady hand, so this may or may not work for you. I used to make money back in middle school changing out LED's on Nokia 5100's, 6100's, 8200's series... ah the old days haha. that required some steady hands. i still have my 8260 that i converted to the 8860 and soldered on the slide pin that made the sliding cover active. removing and rotating the polarized LCD films to invert the screens.. anyone remember all4cell? man i feel old now.
wow, now i'm thinking about the old TDMA networks and how much i hated GSM phones cause you couldn't change the carrier tags (on Nokias). i guess if it was still like back then, the T-Mobile Galaxy S5 threads would be the VoiceStream Galaxy S5 threads MIRITE??!
biggest advice though: go to the bathroom, steam it up (not too much)! that alone helps with the dusty environment, i thought that was very very good advice.
I got this with US$25 and working fine
http://shop.brando.com/Brando-Works...ition-Samsung-Galaxy-S5-_p10841c1547d011.html
epsilon022 said:
What brand is the $12 one that you feel is almost as good?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's the LUVVITT brand. Maybe it's a little thicker than the Spigen, but honestly it's barely noticeable. Especially when you factor in the little ridge along the screen of the S5.
SS70Chevelle said:
It's the LUVVITT brand. Maybe it's a little thicker than the Spigen, but honestly it's barely noticeable. Especially when you factor in the little ridge along the screen of the S5.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's good to know as I shop around for glass screen protector. Thanks!
I just got it in the mail today. Had to put it on right away. Extra smoothness! I've had the Spigen Glas series since the S4
I went cheap and got this http://www.ebay.com/itm/151282778240?ssPageName=STRK:MEWNX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1497.l2649
Works like a charm, and for $6 you can't really argue..why would I spend $20-$40 for a glass screen when this phone is already made with tough Gorilla glass? I also have this http://www.ebay.com/itm/351046202801?ssPageName=STRK:MEWNX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1497.l2649 case, so it's not I'll ever break my screen now when dropping my phone..
thotwielder said:
Is there any other paricular good points of glass screen protectors?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
In my experience the best part of the glass protectors is that they feel the best. For the longest time I bought the super cheap xtremeguardz protectors on slickdeals which were good for protection but felt too tacky and got really dirty. Same with the free protector that came with spigen case for my Nexus 5. The glass ones feel like you don't have a screen protector on, shed minor damage readily, and provides the best extreme impact protection (at the cost of its own life though).
The biggest drawback is that they can chip if you drop them on cement... depends on the person, I know people who go an entire year with no screen protector, and I know others who drop their phones on pavement regularly. I recently reviewed the Movaluate 7 protector (http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2744597) which has served me well so far.
It feels so nice in your hands... I really don't think there is any need for a case or a screen protector, unless you're really using your phone in extreme conditions. Just my 2 cents.
Polishzx said:
It feels so nice in your hands... I really don't think there is any need for a case or a screen protector, unless you're really using your phone in extreme conditions. Just my 2 cents.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Agreed - I haven't used a screen protector since the intro of Gorilla Glass... never had a problem.
These Note4 bezels on the other hand... they look prone to scratches and nicks
Polishzx said:
It feels so nice in your hands... I really don't think there is any need for a case or a screen protector
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
until you drop it
Kawaisa said:
until you drop it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
then it feels funny in your wallet
Kawaisa said:
until you drop it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There are so many drop tests on the youtube of the Note 4. The thing looks pretty indestructible. I mean sure you'll get a scratch, but I would still rather get scuffs and scratches and enjoy using it naked. Food for thought! Of course it hurts resale value, no doubt.
never been a case person although I always use tempered glass on the front. I would however be interested in a slickwrap for the note but I can't find em anywhere. I just love the carbon fibre feel.
I just put this on my iphone
Polishzx said:
It feels so nice in your hands... I really don't think there is any need for a case or a screen protector, unless you're really using your phone in extreme conditions. Just my 2 cents.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Totally agree! Screen protection seems like a waste to me with gorilla glass 3, maybe even down grading due to loss of clearness.
My Galaxy S3 doesn't have a scratch on it after 3 years and I never used a screen protector.
I use a leather pouch and run the phone in hand naked!
That said I'm super good with phones and many people need the protection, I get that.
I put my phone inside a cloth pouch with velco that my wife made. I read putting in on a case with get metal chaffing on the side after a while.
I am a careful person. When I take out my phone, I always check what floor (hard or soft) I am on, believe it or not.
My biggest concern would be putting the phone on the table as the camera is raised.
Using only a fit leather pouch for carrying around, phone itself is naked and without a screen protector. I dont really care about the resale value dropping if i get some tiny scratches since the value in 2 years will be less than 1/3 anyway. Its a phone not my house after all.
I've said this before elsewhere, but it's really easy to replace the frame of the phone if you get nicks around the side or scratches on the camera glass.
Just need to buy a replacement frame online and unscrew a few screws. Frames will probably be around $10-15, so if you don't think you'll drop your phone, there's no real need to get a case.
2 years have a cash long time to never drop a phone. You keep your phone with you almost all the time and frequently pull it out of your pocket. You use it when you're drunk and dead tired. You use it when you're woken up in the middle of the night. For at least one year (for most people). Probably 2 years. That's a very long time to just assume you won't drop it because your lifestyle isn't "extreme".
I've had my Galaxy s3 for over two years. I dropped it once. Onto concrete from six feet off the ground. I'm very careful with my phone, but I'm glad I had a case that night.
Just like driving... no matter how careful YOU are, it's not always you that causes the accident.
All it takes is a stray elbow or someone not paying attention to cause a major issue.
I applied a glass screen protector and put it in a slim case before I even turn it on for the first time. I switched from my trusty S4, which I've had in a case since day 1 and I only used it naked when I got the notification that my Note 4 has been dispatched. I just can't feel safe enough without body and screen protection!!
Well i drink to much and belive it or not ihave never droped my phone [emoji6]
Enviado desde mi iPhone 6 utilizando Tapatalk
I went ahead and got the S View Flip Cover, retail $50, got a deal for $15 at time of purchase in store and I am loving it.
That you remember...LOL
Polishzx said:
It feels so nice in your hands... I really don't think there is any need for a case or a screen protector, unless you're really using your phone in extreme conditions. Just my 2 cents.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
you can take back your 2 cents ... backs to slippery just about dropped mine
mliou said:
My biggest concern would be putting the phone on the table as the camera is raised.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am using everything naked except the camera lens. I cut out glossy screen protector plastic and put that over lens. I had lots of scratches in lens of S2. In Note 1, flip cover raised and didn't have to protect lens. I had used similar protection in N3 too.
Note 4
I just put on a skinomi full body protector. There is a small protection for the camera (similar to the film that was on it when you take it out of the box). So the back and sides are sticky. The top part will attract lint since I put that part in my pocket first. Just waiting for the xtremeguard glass protector to come in and I'm all set. Now just look for a good heavy duty case for the times I may need it.
So Ive been trying to decide on a new case for a while since I'm moving away from the otterbox defender that I usually buy for my phones. I came across this one. And it just came in this morning.
http://pages.ebay.com/link/?nav=item.view&id=171778123626&alt=web
I don't like really thin cases that aren't good for anything more than scratch proofing.
That being said this case isn't exactly thin, nor is it as bulky as an OB defender. I wanted a case that would protect my phone from falls, and decided this would be worth a try (especially since I got it for 9$+shipping). I wasn't disappointed, the very first thing I did was clean my phone, put it in the case, and drop tested it from 6 feet, into a faceplant and it survived without a scratch.it's got good protection on the corner, and the case looks very nice with the acrylic back that lets you see the phone through it.
I definitely trust this case to protect my M9 from normal, everyday usage and drops. That being said I would not be willing to test throwing my phone across a room like I would with an OBD, since this case has no shock proofing on the back due to the transparent acrylic.
The built in screen protector works great as well. I already had a Zagg scratch proof protector on (not the tempered glass, or the thick HD one and left it on) and I haven't lost any responsiveness to my screen. The built in protector does add a slightly annoying glare though.
Definitely a good case, and like all cases has its share of cons, but for the price, I 100% recommend it. Even if you only find it for the 20$ its usually advertised for.
Edit: I also forgot to mention that the cover for the charging port is somewhat hard to open, and hard to keep open. It will probably wear over time and become easier, but as of right now it is a slight hassle.
Edit2: After using the case for a few weeks, the charging port is no longer an issue. I've gotten rid of my Zagg screen protector, and removed the built in protector from the case. Instead using the Spartan tempered glass screen protector.
Sent from my HTC One M9 using XDA Free mobile app
Thank you for your review. It's nice to know that this case can withstand a drop from a few feet. I know that I get nervous with it falling-- I mean, these phones are not just expensive, but they are our "friends" that we take with us everywhere we go. That is pretty sad, huh?
If I could figure out how to get my phone out of this cinder block I'd have it out already. This is essentially an iPhone-shaped case for a not-iPhone. The curvature at the back of the phone is lost (though it does trap dirt between the clear platen and the back of the phone). The cover on the charging port, which is mostly pointless because there are lots of open ports on the case, makes it difficult to connect to my car holder. The plastic isn't a consistent colour between the front and the sides. It was a bastard to get the phone in, and now it's a bastard to get the phone out.
The screen cover is great, and there's every indication that the shock protection is good. The big square plastic buttons are easy to press.
Compared with either Otterbox (which is what I've had on my past HTC phones) this isn't as good.
Damosel said:
If I could figure out how to get my phone out of this cinder block I'd have it out already. This is essentially an iPhone-shaped case for a not-iPhone. The curvature at the back of the phone is lost (though it does trap dirt between the clear platen and the back of the phone). The cover on the charging port, which is mostly pointless because there are lots of open ports on the case, makes it difficult to connect to my car holder. The plastic isn't a consistent colour between the front and the sides. It was a bastard to get the phone in, and now it's a bastard to get the phone out.
The screen cover is great, and there's every indication that the shock protection is good. The big square plastic buttons are easy to press.
Compared with either Otterbox (which is what I've had on my past HTC phones) this isn't as good.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The case is easiest to take off if you peel the rubber back from the corner right above the buttons.
Based on the fact that its 1/5 the price of the otterbox, for roughly 3/4 of the protection level it offers, I would still recommend this case as a cheaper alternative.
Sent from my HTC One M9 using XDA Free mobile app
chaosrde said:
The case is easiest to take off if you peel the rubber back from the corner right above the buttons. Sent from my HTC One M9 using XDA Free mobile app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
chaosrde is right on the money. Using the spudger or guitar pick makes the job that much easier. I received a Glacier Touch case from Roocase for review purposes and ran into this. While the case is tough to take off, it does mean that phone is secure. It's a nice case that allows you to show off the nice metal casing of your phone. I dropped it a few times and neither the case nor phone showed any sign of damage, though due to it being clear and glossy the case does show scratches a lot easier. The case seems a bit bulky even with my large hands, but I think this is due to the box-iness of the case. It's more of a personal gripe than something wrong with the case. The built-in screen protector is nice, but does feel cheap (as most built-in screen protectors do) so if you pop it off and use a glass screen protector I don't blame you.
The only issue I had with it is what Damosel mentioned: Dust and dirt seem to get into the case a bit too easily and ends up collecting on the back side of the case. This is due to the case not being fitted to the back of the phone. This can lead to the metal back getting scratched which is something that bothers me. If there was an insert you could put inside the case that fit snugly behind the back I think it would be a nice improvement.
I agree with chaosrde that for the price point and the protection it offers, the Roocase Glacier Tough case is a nice alternative to the Otterbox Defender.
Hi all
got the edge plus with the clear view case now i have exactly the same issue with the smaller edge with little dots and a scratch on the screen.
contacted Samsung and they say their is nothing official for the Edge Plus so the chances are they will not replace the screen free of charge.
is anyone out their in the same boat as me, is their any official notification from Samsung covering the Edge Plus
Thanks
Same sh*t for me, my brother has the S6 edge and had this problem, and I bought the clear view cover for my edge+ thinking it was fixed, after 3 days, noticed few scratches when I was on sunlight, 2 weeks with the phone and already pissed out 'cause of stupid things like these...
Sent from my SM-G928F using XDA Free mobile app
I got this case but after reading about the issues with the S6 I only used it after installing a screen protector. I then noticed small pinpricks in the protector after using the case and I could even see the indentation of a circle where the magnet touches the screen. Fortunately most of the marks disappeared from the protector after a few days but it appears that they have not resolved this in the design. I also found that the back of the case itself scratches too easily - it is already showing several scratches even though I have been very careful in handling it. I am surprised they sell it as an official case given the known problems.
The clear view case is definitely one to stay away from. Although it added to the beauty of the phone, it just was not practical, offered no screen interaction when closed and over time I would imagine it would wear out quite quickly. Returned mine after 2 days (before any scratches set in) and opted for the official SView cover which gave me back the functionality that I was used to. Having had the original SView cover on my Note3, after 2 years of hard use it really protected my phone well. The case is in gold and looks better than I expected. Fingers crossed this new SView cover for my edge+ will hold up the same.
i have the clear view case for almost 2 weeks now and not a single scratch or dent visible; maybe you guys had some dust or smth in your pockets that went inbetween the case and the screen?
I had for few days the phone didn't scratch but the cover is completely scratched and it's just awful now ?
nulledapk.com said:
i have the clear view case for almost 2 weeks now and not a single scratch or dent visible; maybe you guys had some dust or smth in your pockets that went inbetween the case and the screen?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
***** crumbs in the pockets, no doubt.
ShyamSasi said:
I had for few days the phone didn't scratch but the cover is completely scratched and it's just awful now
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've had my gold clearview case for a week and it's looking a little bit scratchy but nothing too serious.
I just wonder where people's expectations lie in these cases. Of course we don't expect to see scratches on the screen when there's a protective case over it but the case couldn't have caused the scratches. Previous S-View and flap cases were quite soft and spongy, these ones are tough so grit could easily get pressed against the glass. If anything, Samsung should provide a screen cover with the case. I use a plastic screen cover anyway because I find the bare glass too slippery at times.
As for scratches on the case itself, well that's what it's for! It takes the hit so your phone doesn't, and with a mirror finish you'll see some wear and tear. If you wanted a case that maintains its original appearance then don't pick mirror finish, clear hard shell or light colours - grab a dark silicone thing to wrap around your phone and it will look the same in 2 years as it did the day you bought it. Next we'll be seeing case protector films to keep the case from degrading!
yesBilly said:
***** crumbs in the pockets, no doubt.
I've had my gold clearview case for a week and it's looking a little bit scratchy but nothing too serious.
I just wonder where people's expectations lie in these cases. Of course we don't expect to see scratches on the screen when there's a protective case over it but the case couldn't have caused the scratches. Previous S-View and flap cases were quite soft and spongy, these ones are tough so grit could easily get pressed against the glass. If anything, Samsung should provide a screen cover with the case. I use a plastic screen cover anyway because I find the bare glass too slippery at times.
As for scratches on the case itself, well that's what it's for! It takes the hit so your phone doesn't, and with a mirror finish you'll see some wear and tear. If you wanted a case that maintains its original appearance then don't pick mirror finish, clear hard shell or light colours - grab a dark silicone thing to wrap around your phone and it will look the same in 2 years as it did the day you bought it. Next we'll be seeing case protector films to keep the case from degrading!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Mate,
I am a very careful user 1.5 years with M8 without any case and it still looks brand new. But a "Official Samsung case" I expect it to be a bit more durable and not prone to so much scratches and this case ain't cheap either. Now Clear case by Spigen no no scratches on the case or phone. I'm happy with the performance. I chose Clear view case from Samsung so I can take advantage of it's features.
I've bought the clear view case for my black S6E+ and I can confirm that it does indeed scratch the screen.
The first scratches appeared after something like 3 days of usage, so I've placed spigen ultra crystal to protect screen from further damage and to mask the spots.
I thought that maybe the reason was that I've carried the phone in the case in my pocket one day. But to my rage I've noticed that the case have damged the screen protector within 2-4 hours after applying it and this time there was no pocket to blame, I was home with my little girl sick so I've only moved the phone from one room to another always carrying it in the hand.
I've contaced Samsung Poland by their facebook account and they advised to report the problem to authorised service center in order to assess the damage, but I've let it go - I dont think they have much experience with replacing the screen in this particular device and I was afraid that the final effect may be in fact even worse.
So I replaced the Spigen with another one (~20$ went straight to the bin) and I stay away from the clear view case. At the beginning I was using S-View Cover (highly recommended) but I settled now with Rock TPU (way slimmer and better than Nillkin Nature or Spigen Liquid).
I've compared clear view cases for S6 and S6E+ and it is obviuos that they tried to improve the design by adding a kind of "lip" along the internal edge of the flap so I doesnt rest at the whole screen all the time. This means that the scratches will now be placed (as it was in my case) along the edges of the screen thus giving additional meaning to "S6 Edge"
It does have oleophobic coating and yes it seems to be able to heal minor scratches so thats a plus, but it really doesnt matter as long as the case meant to PROTECT the screen actually DAMAGES it.
Thanks for that. Im glad i went for the S-view instead, i had it on my Note 4 previously without a single scratch.
In UK Samsung acknowledged that clear view case causes scratches on s6 edge and they are replacing screens (only once) plus adding screen protector, wondering if its the same for s6edge+. Worth asking samsung helpline
Mine did it after just a few days. I hate flip covers anyway. But I can't un-scratch the screen.
Ugh...
Chiffon Method to avoid scratches
Chiffon method to avoid scratches
Here is something that came to my mind using Chiffon fabric to put inside the cover to protect the screen, if the screen is still prone to scratches after this, means that the screen is pure crap.
If you don't want to use the Chiffon one, pay attention not to use one made from plastic.
Material:
- A cut of Chiffon fabric, in Mexico costs 1 dolar per meter.
- Transaparent glue, the one used in school that is water washable, in case of error, it can be safely removed
PROCEDURE: (Very complex)
- Glue the fabric into the inside of the cover as you will see in the picture
That's it, is possible to use any mostly transparent fabric in cotton or polyester that is like Chiffon or better, I found this one here.
NOTE: The pictures are very bad quality, looking at the phone is mostly the same using the fabric compared to not using it.
NOTE 2: Inside the cover is mostly the same in black, the bad lighting where I shoot it creates that gray halos, is pure black and if you are a purist you can do it much better than me.
NOTE 3: "CON" mean WITH and "SIN" means Whithout
No offence but it looks really terrible...
pokosik said:
No offence but it looks really terrible...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I didn't want to be the first to say it! ?
It seems the S view cover scratched the S6. Im expecting the same with the Plus
Sent from my SM-N9005 using Tapatalk