I currently have an otterbox Commuter case and I think it's on the bulky side. Would getting something like the UAG case be better and offer the same protection from drops? I'd assume that the thicker the case is the more protected?
The UAG case -
http://www.amazon.com/dp/B00CJY8ZSO/ref=cm_sw_r_an_am_ap_am_us?ie=UTF8
Sent from my SCH-I545 using xda premium
after reading about fake UAG cases I'm reluctant to buy one from Amazon unless it is ship and sold by Amazon. last year I unknowingly bought a fake Speck Candyshell case for my wife's S3 that was only fulfilled by Amazon. Their current prices seem too good to be true for a case that was released 2 months ago.
HKSpeed said:
after reading about fake UAG cases I'm reluctant to buy one from Amazon unless it is ship and sold by Amazon. last year I unknowingly bought a fake Speck Candyshell case for my wife's S3 that was only fulfilled by Amazon. Their current prices seem too good to be true for a case that was released 2 months ago.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I always buy directly from Amazon for this reason. It's worth the few extra dollars. What is your opinion on the cases I mentioned?
Sent from my SCH-I545 using xda premium
I don't like the UAG, which I think is overrated. I had one on a previous phone and I didn't like it all. The plastic feels cheap. The top and bottom edges of the case are not hard plastic, only the sides are. Adds bulk.
I always like Speck Candyshells, which I had on previous devices. I immediately got a Candyshell for my S4.
Pros:
-hard plastic on all 4 edges
-slim
Cons:
-scratches show easily on dark color models
-slippery, but there's a grip model
Protection is good. I had it on my Galaxy Note 2 (which is 41% heavier than the S4) and dropped it a few times without any resulting damage.
The Otterbox is too bulky. I would only get that if I worked in construction or similar.
Read this thread. I have both but overall I feel the uag is the better case. I know rock the element eclipse case.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2334795
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using xda app-developers app
For as boring as Otterbox cases are they are in my opinion still the most well built cases out there. I have a commuter case right now and one of the samsung cases as well, I havent seen another case that will protect as well as the commuter that is as well built. On a side note the commuter case with the Spigen Glas.t nano is amazing.
I had the commuter with my GS2 and I have the UAG case on my GS4, but I have seen the commuter for the GS4 in person.
From what I read, the biggest risk to the phone is the screen breaking, and apparently, the greatest chance of this happening is when the phone is dropped and it lands on a corner. The UAG case has extra protection on the corners more so than for the commuter.
Personally I like the UAG case because it is lighter and not as bulky and offers just as good if not better corner impact protection. The lip around the screen is not at high as the commuter, but it is enough that if you put the phone screen side down, it is elevated off a flat surface.
Otter box is bad lol. Ruins the phone. Worsens signal to. Took mine back and got the neo hybrid
Sent from my SCH-I545 using xda premium
Thanks you guys. Very helpful. I ordered the UAG case.
Sent from my SCH-I545 using xda premium
Rofl what, does not affect the signal at all. The commuter is rubber in the corners and hard plastic everywhere else. No different than the UAG. The UAG is one piece vs commuter two piece, so count that as a pro or con with your preference. I believe the screen is better protected on the front ie a larger lip on the front face. Just dont go saying silly things like it affects the signal.
Related
I bought my S4 with a Ballistic Aspire case, and it's done a fantastic job for the last two months protecting my phone. But after my phone took a disgusting fall on my garage floor, I'm starting to think a hard plastic case might not be a bad idea.
My question is: Is the OtterBox Commuter a worthy upgrade from my current case or am I better off saving the money?
Product pages for each case are below:
http://www.goballisticcase.com/products/samsung-galaxy-s-4-ballistic-aspira-series-case'
http://www.otterbox.com/Galaxy-S4-Commuter-Series-Case/sam4-galaxy-s4,default,pd.html
Wouldnt the hard plastic just transfer all the force to the phone?
The hard plastic has a tough silicone membrane in between it and the phone which absorbs the impact. I have the commuter and the uag case. I think the uag will protect better bc it's got reinforced corners which when you drop a phone it hits the most but I do like the color choices of the otter box. I'm a case hoard and just bought the element eclipse case so I will be selling my black uag and green/black commuter combo. Pm me if interested.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using xda app-developers app
Otterbox has a case replacement guantee that i like.
If u trying to keep ur phone slim then keep the one u got. The commuter case is huge but it adds alot more protection then the ballistic case
Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk 4 Beta
I have a pink/grey commuter case from otterbox. I have loved otterbox since my first case years ago. I may be off here but it seems to me they're getting a little shotty quality wise. My rubber seems to turn brown and attract every piece of dirt within a mile of it and now, I have just found, the pink has bled into the white on my phone and stained it. Is this the phone or the case being substandard here? I do love otterbox but I'm thinking its time to move on. What case can I look to for the same protection and reliability? What's the best/worst phone case in your opinion?
Sent from my SPH-L720 using Tapatalk 2
I'm a big fan of the Spigen Slim Armor and Spigen Neo Hybrid cases for this phone. High quality, fits like a GLOVE, not bulky at all, look great, and don't have the big lips like the otterbox that make dragging down the notification panel a hassle. Check out their site but buy from amazon, I think you can get the slim armor on amazon for less than 15 bucks at the moment.
I use an otterbox commuter for my s4 and it doesnt interfere with notifications panel at all.(that happens in the s2 commuter case)
Dunno about other colors but my black is holding up pretty good to daily abuse.
Sent from my GT-I9500 using Tapatalk 2
Using Spiegen Slim Armor and View.
He gives better design but I'm thinking the Otterbox have better protection if you drop it unfortunately.
Well it's dépend if you take care about your phone or not.
Sent from my GT-I9505 using Tapatalk 2
Siwandroid said:
Using Spiegen Slim Armor and View.
He gives better design but I'm thinking the Otterbox have better protection if you drop it unfortunately.
Well it's dépend if you take care about your phone or not.
Sent from my GT-I9505 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I baby my s4 but accidents can happen thats why I use my commuter for most of the time(daily use) and my blue spigen slim armor when I go to parties etc. Lol
Sent from my GT-I9500 using Tapatalk 2
sohail99 said:
I baby my s4 but accidents can happen thats why I use my commuter for most of the time(daily use) and my blue spigen slim armor when I go to parties etc. Lol
Sent from my GT-I9500 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well it's not bad. It's a good idea though
Sent from my GT-I9505 using Tapatalk 2
These cases are built for war to thick for me. I tried it for a week and ordered me a smaller case. These cases are perfect for people who drop there phone alot there well built but I rather have an extended battery and a case if I'm gonna make my phone this bulky.
Sent from my SPH-L720 using xda app-developers app
Otterbox makes my phone feel like a brick so I went with spigen neo hybrid. Complete coverage and a little lip.
Sent from my Beastly powered S4 using Tapatalk 4
Just got a gift from a friend, Otterbox Commuter for S4, everything looks fine but the cutout for charging below the case seems not so accurate.
After the disaster which is the S3 Otterbox Defender, I have refused to recommend any Otterbox product to anyone. (the silicon would just keep stretching out of shape)
My GF's S3 Commuter fared slightly better with none of the silicone issues but the plastic shell cracked the first time she dropped the phone...
Fast forward to today... we're both using S4s and couldn't be happier with our Ballistic SG Maxxes. Truly a marvelous case which takes impacts and drops like a champ! The design of the S4 version is a little skimpy up top though but so far so [email protected]
I work in construction so I have a Defender on my s4. Holding up great so far. Thinking about picking up another smaller case for weekends.
Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk 4
Spigen Slim Armor
I have been using the Otterbox Commuter cases over the last year and have been really happy with them. However I recently got the Blue Spigen Slim Armor and it is really impressive how it fits, quality of construction, buttons are easy to push, fits perfect and looks are better than anything I have seen thus far. Plus it matches my Grabber Blue Mustang GT. hahaha Really impressed with it.:good: So far it is the best case I have had on any phone in the last 10 years.
I really like my green commuter. It fits well and looks pretty cool. The construction of the case seems very tight; on some past otterboxes, it's seemed a bit "stretchy" and not as formfitting right out of the box, but this one is very nicely done. My only gripe was the charger cutout was too small, but a kitchen knife and some diligence solved that problem rather quickly.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using xda app-developers app
I had a similar problem with the charging port on my marine/dark blue commuter case. I didn't want to carve up the case, so I just ground the plug down a little with my dremel tool. I figured if I screwed it up I could always get another OEM charger. So far it works fine. I ground down to metal, but a quick check with Galaxy Charging Current shows that my charge values are unaffected. Is this a common problem with the Otterbox Commuter?
My first thought was that I got a fake one, but the box had the hologram sticker on top, website on back, sku sticker on bottom. The silicone lining seems firm and tight with no sagging. Most of the fake vs real videos on youtube stressed the cheap and floppy silicone lining in the fake Otterboxes. Mine seems fairly stiff and fits well.
I was originally eyeing off the commuter cases but after reading the whole screen cracking thread, I went with the defender. This is possibly the best case I've ever had on a smartphone. The plastic inside shell is fairly sturdy which I love because I carry my phone in my pocket all the time and I was worried about having torsion dmg.
P.S: I'm also looking at getting the neon blue spigen slim armor but I'm still not convinced on the sturdiness yet. I so do not want to have to go through samsung warranty for anything. ~_~
I need a very slim case. One that doesn't add much bulk, I already have tempered glass installed on it. Not too worried about protection. Slimmer/thinner than the spigen, Diztronic. Thank you in advance..
Sent from my SM-G900T using XDA Free mobile app
I just ordered a few cases so I will let you know when they come in. I am/was looking for the same.
JC
I ordered 2 of those 0.3mm Chineese cases at 1 dollar. If you do not want those look at Incipio/Spigen/Ringke Slim or Case Mate barely there
Bump
Sent from my SM-G900T using XDA Free mobile app
Here is what I use. I don't think you can get any slimmer than this.
[]Rinkge Slim Case S5
I also got the Rinkge slim case linked above. So far, so good. It adds very little bulk. I almost bought the Diztronic slim TPU case similar to what I used for 2 years on my S3, but decided against it because of how it looked. The Diztronic protected my old phone from many a fall and withstood the wear and tear of daily use. Heck, I'm selling my S3 with the Diztronic as an added feature. Before making my final decision I was torn between the Rinkge and the Spigen Slim Utra Fit case. I never tested the Spigen, but a friend had the Rinkge case and I liked what I saw. Nothing to say about protection and durability yet as I only have the case for two weeks. Would like to hear from folks that bought the Spigen Slim Ultra Fit case to compare notes.
I just got in a slim armor and a neo hybrid.
Both are great cases, neither overly bulky.
I honestly prefer the slim armor. The neo is just a thin plastic frame, outside edge coverage only, around a thin tpu skin direct to the phone.
The slim armor is marginally more bulky, yet it seems much more durable and protective.
The bonus of both cases is they are a super perfect fit and EASY to get in and out of the pocket of even tightish jeans. The buttons and charging port are easy access (better on the slim armor) and the case wont try to come off when you take it out of your pocket.
These things are a laser tight fit. I was going to go trident for my case as I did with my epic 4g touch....... but I don't think I need to yet.
Sent from my SM-G900P using XDA Free mobile app
I have the Ringke, it's ok but it has 0 sex appeal(our phone needs it, because ew). I can't deal with the Spigen, I can't believe they put 'Auto Focus' below the lense. It bothers me greatly. It's not a lauded feature so I don't need some cheese wording below my camera.
This case on Amazon has fair reviews, about to order it myself.
http://www.amazon.com/Samsung-Galaxy-Case-GreatShield-Packaging/dp/B00KFQAZRW#customerReviews
Anybody have the ringke slim dot view case that can speak on if it retains the blue dye from Blue jeans? Thinking about getting the white one but worried about it turning another color.
If anyone has pics that would be great.
I bought the Spigen Ultra Fit Black and I using tempered glass the phone looks great. I am happy with it. See the photos :thumbup:
Sent from my SM-G900F using XDA Free mobile app
My Pixel XL should be here any day. (back ordered from verizon for 2 months).
On my past few phones I've used Otterbox commuter and had good success. I don't mind the bulk of the commuter as I feel like it's a good trade-off for the protection.
That being said, I need to get a case for my pixel xl asap and would like something that provides similar protection to the commuter....suggestions? I ordered the spigen tough armor.
Any other suggestions for one that provides otter box commuter (no built in screen protector) like protection without the otter box price (and more color choices)?
https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B01MQTN2RS/ref=yo_ii_img?ie=UTF8&psc=1
https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B01M...1483496486&sr=1&pi=AC_SX236_SY340_FMwebp_QL65
I use this with a tempered glass screen protector.
Sent from my Pixel XL using Tapatalk
Thanks guys,
The trident case says unavailable. But, do you think it is as protective as the otterbox commuter?
Regarding the iblassen, also do you feel like it is as protective as the commuter?
I guess it really hard to tell from the pics of cases on Amazon. The otterbox commuter has a really thick and somewhat stiff runner inside and a plastic shell that snaps on the back. Just looking for something with that same level of protection without paying $50 for a case and then need a few color options for my wife's pixel xl (otterbox only had a couple colors)
The iblasson, for me, is protective. The back is a plastic with the edges and interior being rubber/silicone something like that. The edges are pretty thick and the corners are even thicker with cut outs that allow for compression of the rubber/silicone if it lands on the corner to cushion the blow. I would feel confident if I dropped from the hip and pretty confident if I dropped from head level. It also has a pretty good lip to account for glass down drops. Hope this helps.
Sent from my Pixel XL using Tapatalk
Thanks, any other suggestions?
Ahent, some iblasson's have a built in screen protector, which I don't want. The one you linked to does not have the built in, correct?
Have you compared the iblasson you have to an otter box or spigen tough armor?
No built in screen protector on the one I linked to, I hate those. The only other case I have had on this phone is the caseology parallax, which I really liked, but wasn't very protective or maybe better phrasing would be not as protective as the Iblasson. I mainly ended up with Iblasson because it had a holster and I like holsters. Usually I use seido cases because of the holsters (typically the surface) but they didn't have one at the time I got my phone but I think they have one now.
Sent from my Pixel XL using Tapatalk
kboater said:
My Pixel XL should be here any day. (back ordered from verizon for 2 months).
On my past few phones I've used Otterbox commuter and had good success. I don't mind the bulk of the commuter as I feel like it's a good trade-off for the protection.
That being said, I need to get a case for my pixel xl asap and would like something that provides similar protection to the commuter....suggestions? I ordered the spigen tough armor.
Any other suggestions for one that provides otter box commuter (no built in screen protector) like protection without the otter box price (and more color choices)?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The Speck is pretty protective but will still at you back $30 on Amazon. It has a tendency to become a little loose early on but doesn't seem to get progressively worse. A lot of people don't seem to mind it, but I did. The tough armor is a decent solution. Probably as protective as the OtterBox for a fraction of the price. Be aware, cases like the Spigen with the small cutouts around the laser autofocus are prone to dust buildup which will interfere with the cameras autofocus. Make a point to keep it clean or buy a case like the Ottetbox with a much larger cutout.
Spigen has great products. I have used Otter before. You can not go wrong with Spigen.
Checkout VRS Design
https://vrsdesign.com/collections/pixel
I use the High Pro Shield and love jt
My favorite is Seidio. They've two levels of protection. The SURFACE line is most similar to the commuter, and i think better. I prefer the DILEX line for the corner bumpers though. https://www.seidioonline.com/shop/?device=pixel-xl&style=
Does anyone have input on the UAG cases? The Amazon ones are mixed and I don't want to burn $30.
i have the ash uag case for mine and my wife's pixel xl since the beginning of December.
was looking forward to this case. when i first got it i liked it alot, but then other people got theirs and made me start to look at mine again. the one issue is that the lip at the top and bottom seem to show a little bit too much metal. it's almost like as though they rushed the case. i thought the case from uag would have been similar to the uag case they did for the galaxy note 4, in how it wrapped the phone and you knew it was protected.
since getting my uag case i have ordered the presidio grip, didn't like it, not that much screen protection and that case felt lose on the phone.
ordered the seidio dilex, bigger case tab the uag in feel making the phone feel bulkier but the headphone jack cutout is too small, unless your headphones have a skinny plug. will be sending that one back.
received the vrs design high pro shield. same thing not that much lip on the screen and button feel was not that great.
was going to order the LifeProof fre but read people having flash issues at night with the case on. still thinking about giving the caseology case a try.
so after going through those cases determined the uag case will work and get the job done with a screen protector. just ordered the full screen glass protector from spigen through Amazon, presently using the yootech screen protector.
thought about going back to the diztronic but just a little too plain. and the uag has taken a few slips out the pocket already and has survived so will stick with this one for the time being.
Sent from my Pixel XL using Tapatalk
I have been using UAG cases for years. As soon as the version for the XL came out I had it. I used it for 2 days and hated it. It did not fit quite right and was very heavy compared to the Spigen Rugged Armor. I threw my UAG in a drawer and have no plans to use it again.
Mike02z said:
I have been using UAG cases for years. As soon as the version for the XL came out I had it. I used it for 2 days and hated it. It did not fit quite right and was very heavy compared to the Spigen Rugged Armor. I threw my UAG in a drawer and have no plans to use it again.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
LMAO. thought about giving the rugged armor another try, just concerned about the small cutout for the autofocus sensor.
Sent from my Pixel XL using Tapatalk