Currently on 2.3.2 can I get to 2.3.5? - Samsung Galaxy S (4G Model)

Hey Guys. I have the Samsung Galaxy S 4G from T-Mobile and it came with Froyo. I then upgraded to Gingerbread 2.3.2 and I am wondering if I can update to the most recent release for Gingerbread which is 2.3.5? Sorry if this has been asked before but I haven't really been able to find a solution. Anyway at all? Thank you.

How did you get 2.3.2? OTA?
There's no 2.3.5 atm. However, there are 2.3.4 ROMs already out in the Development section. If you want to flash them, be sure to do plenty of reading first.

I checked 2.3.5 and even on Vibrant, the only ones seem to be CM7 builds and Vibrants have dozens of roms available. So CM7 would have to be ported to the 4G first and that hasn't happened yet even for 2.3.4.
On the bright side, KH2 stock seems to be faster than anything I ran on my Vibrant before I broke it.

nazcalito said:
I checked 2.3.5 and even on Vibrant, the only ones seem to be CM7 builds and Vibrants have dozens of roms available. So CM7 would have to be ported to the 4G first and that hasn't happened yet even for 2.3.4.
On the bright side, KH2 stock seems to be faster than anything I ran on my Vibrant before I broke it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just a correction before people start thinking that CM7 for the SGS4G is ported. Krylon360 and Team Whiskey are working very hard to build CM7 from scratch. They're not porting it.

Related

Where do I start?

I have a vibrant and I've loaded mine up with a custom rom, but someone asked me to look at their captivate for them. They have whatever 2.1 OTA AT&T is pushing, its basically unmolested.
How can I upgrade this to a stable 2.2? Is there a stock leak thats out there? What would I need to do?
jbeez said:
I have a vibrant and I've loaded mine up with a custom rom, but someone asked me to look at their captivate for them. They have whatever 2.1 OTA AT&T is pushing, its basically unmolested.
How can I upgrade this to a stable 2.2? Is there a stock leak thats out there? What would I need to do?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Read the stickies, read the FAQs, read, read, read.
Do a search comes to mind.
Stock JI6 and JJ4, plus slightly fixed JJ4
There's one custom ROM based on the two Cap Froyos above (Cognition), two based on Vibrant Froyos (Axura and Eugene's Ginger Clone), and a whole bunch (everything else) based on i9000 Froyos using either xcaliburinhand's reorient kernel (adapts i9000 to Cap) or SetiroN's reorient + OCUV.
thanks, I already read a ton, there was way too much information which is why I was asking for a little help. I just want a stable 2.2 leak if it was available, I can't find it
s44 said:
Stock JI6 and JJ4, plus slightly fixed JJ4
There's one custom ROM based on the two Cap Froyos above (Cognition), two based on Vibrant Froyos (Axura and Eugene's Ginger Clone), and a whole bunch (everything else) based on i9000 Froyos using either xcaliburinhand's reorient kernel (adapts i9000 to Cap) or SetiroN's reorient + OCUV.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thanks, this is exactly what I needed

Miui Nexus port

Ok, so it looks like the Miui ROM posted on the I9000/Vibrant forums that uses the Custom Bilboa1 CM7 Kernel works for the Captivate.
Here is the Link to Bilboa1's Kernel thread:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=979206
Link to I9000 Miui ROM Thread:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=992251
Follow the direction on the I9000 thread and substitute the CM7 captivate kernel in. Also it is noted that you have to flash the CM7 kernel right after flashing the beta 3.zip file (the zip file installs a I9000 kernel). Good luck hunting
Sent from my SGH-I897 using XDA App
there is already a miui port but from the fascinate. i would love to see a more functional; version though. just need someont to get the aosp kernel straitened out and reorient it. but that takes a lot of work.
Miui was being worked on and it was dropped. Have to ask master because he was the thread Creator for the captivate port as to why it was stopped. He is a vibrant dev.
This is my Captivate. There are many like it but this one is mine
flashman2002 said:
Miui was being worked on and it was dropped. Have to ask master because he was the thread Creator for the captivate port as to why it was stopped. He is a vibrant dev.
This is my Captivate. There are many like it but this one is mine
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
it could be something as simple as one idiot making a flaming post, and master getting pissed off and quiting, but as far as i knew darkyy and DG were in on it too, and both of those are experienced on cappy. however, darkyy has his own rom to focus on and im sad to say it but it kinda looks like DG has moved to focus on his atrix. Not that i blame him, but i know that i will miss his work
ballz0iron said:
it could be something as simple as one idiot making a flaming post, and master getting pissed off and quiting, but as far as i knew darkyy and DG were in on it too, and both of those are experienced on cappy. however, darkyy has his own rom to focus on and im sad to say it but it kinda looks like DG has moved to focus on his atrix. Not that i blame him, but i know that i will miss his work
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You mean like this http://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=12006864&postcount=2104
MIUI was picked up by the french developer jblanc, and then tinkered some by another dev in i9000 land. It's basically the NS port of gingerbread miui jammed together with CM7 and bilboa's kernal for CM7 one. So we do need a reoriented kernel, as the one they are using is not the CM7 since it wouldn't boot properly. Please don't spam the thread with requests for ETAs like what happened to the old Miui thread.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=992251
I have been following that thread. It looks to be much further along than the last port. This one reads like it will end up being usable, once ported here. I am running cm7 and bilboa has a captivate version of his kernel. May have to give it a run when I can afford dealing with a soft brick
CM7
Wasn't asking for ETAl, just didn't know if anyone saw. Its not the port Master put out there it was the nexus S port the uses that custom CM7 kernel. It has some of the same problems as CM7 but its miui. Seriously this is an awareness thread no flame. We have a Bilboa Kernel for Captivate, is why I'm saying why it might be possible
Sent from my SGH-I897 using XDA App
I would not pay mind to those who enter threads just to criticize without reading or knowing what they are talking about.
If this works on the captivate it would have all of the same "bugs" as cm7 as it is using all the set up including a custom kernel built from cm7 source.
Reading the thread it its farther along than the last port as wifi, data, and calls work. It is also gingerbread where as the last port was 2.2.1.
CM7
sold1erjjt said:
Wasn't asking for ETAl, just didn't know if anyone saw. Its not the port Master put out there it was the nexus S port the uses that custom CM7 kernel. It has some of the same problems as CM7 but its miui. Seriously this is an awareness thread no flame. We have a Bilboa Kernel for Captivate, is why I'm saying why it might be possible
Sent from my SGH-I897 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry, didnt mean you specifically. Just a word of the wise for all the lurkers who read these threads
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I897 using XDA App
Yeah, it would just be interested to see. I've never personally seen Miui so it could be cool.
Sent from my SGH-I897 using XDA App
hope that they can make it a stable rom then port it to captivate..
i used to use MIUI rom on my nexus one and now it's the only thing i miss... it'll be great if MIUI rom b able to run on captivate!!!
mcord11758 said:
I have been following that thread. It looks to be much further along than the last port. This one reads like it will end up being usable, once ported here. I am running cm7 and bilboa has a captivate version of his kernel. May have to give it a run when I can afford dealing with a soft brick
CM7
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Has anyone tried using it on the Captivate with Bilboa's kernel? I might have some time later today to try.
Ok I got it to boot following the instructions from the MIUI thread in the i9000 forums:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=992251
All I did was subsitute the captivate equivalent files from CM7. I also had to flash a captivate modem from the CM7 section too. going to test it out now.
Ok FYI after you do these steps and Flash MIUI Beta 3 it will install a i9000 kernel and modem. You will have to go after the initial steps and install a captivate CM7 Kernel and Modem.
So you used bilboas captivate kernel after you flashed the beta 3 zip?
CM7
doctahjeph said:
Ok I got it to boot following the instructions from the MIUI thread in the i9000 forums:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=992251
All I did was subsitute the captivate equivalent files from CM7. I also had to flash a captivate modem from the CM7 section too. going to test it out now.
Ok FYI after you do these steps and Flash MIUI Beta 3 it will install a i9000 kernel and modem. You will have to go after the initial steps and install a captivate CM7 Kernel and Modem.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hows it running? I know GPS doesnt work in addition to the stuff that doesn't work on CM7, just didn't know for the Captivate.
Sent from my SGH-I897 using XDA App
I hop i 'll come to our Captivate T_T
tmhung said:
I hop i 'll come to our Captivate T_T
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It already work, albeit it has bugs. Try it out

Who did not update to GB?

I kinda feel left out. It seems everyone has updated or at least tried to update to the Gingerbread release on LGs site.
But after reading how many people had complications or even bricked their phone, I decided not to try and update, hoping that an official "over the air" update will come from tmobile.
Am I the only one that decided it's to risky to try the update and is still on Froyo? Who else has concerns like mines?
I have not either. So far it seems more trouble than it's worth... Waiting on a good, stable release of GB from the devs!
Sent from my LG-P999 using XDA App
I didnt im waiting for cm7 to adapt new leak to their project
Sent from my GT-P1000 using Tapatalk
Also waiting for a CM7 without driver issues. EaglesBlood Froyo til then.
I did not update. I've waited this long.. might as well wait for the official T-Mobile version.
Sent from my LG-P999 using XDA App
Haven't updated either...I'm running xboarder's GB 2.3.4 and it's pretty stable...still get sod and have overheating issues but they don't happen often.
I want to try out the new update and baseband but don't want to brick my phone as so many have done, so ill just wait a littlebit longer...
Sent from my LG-P999 using XDA App
Me neither. I wait for a flashable version with new LG drivers and baseband.
I have not either I'm waiting for the Ota...I'm still trying to find out if the update everyone is using is really official or not.
Sent from my LG-P999 using XDA Premium App
I haven't updated either, mine is the LGP999DWP phone and it keeps saying that my software is up to date. when I read the forums and see how many people are having issues updating to it, i am somewhat glad i can't update right now...wiating for the OTA from T-Mobile I hope they deploy it soon.
i'm also waiting for CM7 to get the latest drivers. but cm7 is already running 2.3.4 so i don't see any reason to downgrade to 2.3.3. from what i have been reading, my cm7 is equal to being as stable as the "OTA". it works great for me.
What GB update?
Lol. Its a downgrade from CM7. While it is nice sometimes to "just work" but my G2x is pretty good on CM7. Occassionally does a nightly give me fits.
LG G2x - CM7.1 RC1 2.3.4
www.CincyAdmins.com
www.MiiWiiChat.com
player911 said:
What GB update?
Lol. Its a downgrade from CM7. While it is nice sometimes to "just work" but my G2x is pretty good on CM7. Occassionally does a nightly give me fits.
LG G2x - CM7.1 RC1 2.3.4
www.CincyAdmins.com
www.MiiWiiChat.com
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Pretty much this. After using CM7 for so long, then using the newest Gingerbread leak, it just felt so wierd.
Suprah said:
I didnt im waiting for cm7 to adapt new leak to their project
Sent from my GT-P1000 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Same here.
No update for me either I'm better off with cm7... besides they'll be all over it when the time is right
Faux123 for Dev *Join the revolution*
yea me neither plus the new miui rom for the g2x is sick
I have not. I tried but the LG updater freezes in Vista.
No update here. I am staying with froyo Dark &Sinister with Faux's kernel. I will only change after the Faux and the other developers incorporate this release inbto their work.
Why didn't LG update to 2.3.4 and skip 2.3.3?
Joe-retired said:
No update here. I am staying with froyo Dark &Sinister with Faux's kernel. I will only change after the Faux and the other developers incorporate this release inbto their work.
Why didn't LG update to 2.3.4 and skip 2.3.3?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Consensus seems to be that this is still just a development build. Also, given the amount of time it takes to test a ROM on a phone and the frequency that Google updates their OS, I wouldn't be entirely surprised if the final shipped version is still 2.3.3.

O2X to G2X Port Questions

I am thinking of porting some o2x roms.. perfect example is like MIUI. What files do we need to update to make it work on G2X. I do have some cooking exp from past.
To my Knowledge, Kernel is one, so i def, got to use new kernel.. System files are same? do i just extract and recook to g2x specs? possible swap ril file? some dev can help with my questions? thanks in advance.
No one??
Sent via MIUI-G2X
Im trying build miui rom too with mods.
Sent via MIUI-G2X
Maybe ask some people in the dev forum. BTW we have 3 miui roms but there is nothing wrong with more roms. Good luck.
Sent from my LG-P999 using xda premium
The kernel is the issue!
JBoxer and I have been working on some of these issues with a little progress, but we're not there yet.
MIUI can be ported from O2X to G2X because MIUI uses the CyanogenMod kernel, and there is a CyanogenMod kernel for the G2X, and thus it can just be swapped out. It is definitely possible to convert MIUI Roms to G2X this way.
However, O2X "official" builds require an equivalent kernel for the G2X. Currently we only have ONE 2.3.4 kernel that works on the G2X, and that's from the "leaked" LG-L95G build.
In theory, we can use THAT kernel on any of the O2X 2.3.4 versions to get them working on the G2X. However, it hasn't been done successfully yet. We're missing something, but the problem is being worked on.

AT&T official gingerbread for Captivate discussion

I am opening this thread to discuss the new official release from AT&T and Samsung. Details can be found here.
I'm not sure why discussion rooting was a reason to close a thread, but I guess a overzealous mod is better than no mod.
I hate to burst your bubble but there's already an active thread about the official AT&T Gingerbread release.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1437947
I am not sure how much needs to be discussed. It is the same rom that was leaked back in 11/16/2011. Developers have done some amazing stuff with the Rom so far. All that is left for them to do really is add BLN and voodoo color to the kernel. I am not sure if having the source will do anything more for the Rom themselves.
FYI - Mod don't like ppl reopening closed threads.
yes I was active on that thread. It was locked by a mod because people started to discuss how to root the new release. zergRush does not work on it.
popfan said:
I am not sure how much needs to be discussed. It is the same rom that was leaked back in 11/16/2011. Developers have done some amazing stuff with the Rom so far. All that is left for them to do really is add BLN and voodoo color to the kernel. I am not sure if having the source will do anything more for the Rom themselves.
FYI - Mod don't like ppl reopening closed threads.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do we know yet that it is bit for bit the same?
Does anyone have an Odin or Heimdall compatible version of the ROM?
stoobie-doo said:
Do we know yet that it is bit for bit the same?
Does anyone have an Odin or Heimdall compatible version of the ROM?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Those are the two big questions I have too.
That last thread was sure cut short, but i have a question regarding kies mini. Im currently running the leaked UCKK4 Stock, rooted, and bloatfree; will i be able to upgrade with kies mini?
gbalwing said:
That last thread was sure cut short, but i have a question regarding kies mini. Im currently running the leaked UCKK4 Stock, rooted, and bloatfree; will i be able to upgrade with kies mini?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I had the exact type of rom running on my phone. Mini kies told me I was already running the latest rom. So, I did one click back to KB2 then used mini kies.
Ah, my apologies then.
I'll throw a bone out there, Fugu Root. Nuf said. Interesting enough tether manager likes to fc when you have debug enabled along with the usb connected.
c0ldburn3r said:
I'll throw a bone out there, Fugu Root. Nuf said. Interesting enough tether manager likes to fc when you have debug enabled along with the usb connected.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I also had Tethering manage FC on me, but only right after I flashed it on the first reboot. I have not seen it FC again. I am very familiar with the Fugu kernel swap and think it great method, but my issue that I don't have a source of the kies released KK4 kernel. Do you know how to gernerate or extract an ODIN flashable kernel from the running image?
I'm running Cyanogenmod kang build 7.2 right now but I gotta ask is it worth going to stock gingerbread? How stable is it? I'll be honest I miss some of the touchwiz apps, but IMO the stock froyo rom sucked. At the very least I'd probably root and remove the AT&T BS, but IMO The froyo rom ran slower and buggier than the stock eclair rom! I really just want everyone's general opinion of it. Its a tough call. I got my phone running pretty stable with Cyanogenmod right now and its out of warrenty anyway so it might not even be worth my time anyway.
nbarsotti said:
I also had Tethering manage FC on me, but only right after I flashed it on the first reboot. I have not seen it FC again. I am very familiar with the Fugu kernel swap and think it great method, but my issue that I don't have a source of the kies released KK4 kernel. Do you know how to gernerate or extract an ODIN flashable kernel from the running image?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Check the KK4 leak thread for the tar.
No one has confirmed that the KK4 leak is exactly the same of the offical KK4. That is my only hesitation. I would like to be sure that I am running the AT&T KK4 release
Cor-master said:
I'm running Cyanogenmod kang build 7.2 right now but I gotta ask is it worth going to stock gingerbread? How stable is it? I'll be honest I miss some of the touchwiz apps, but IMO the stock froyo rom sucked. At the very least I'd probably root and remove the AT&T BS, but IMO The froyo rom ran slower and buggier than the stock eclair rom! I really just want everyone's general opinion of it. Its a tough call. I got my phone running pretty stable with Cyanogenmod right now and its out of warrenty anyway so it might not even be worth my time anyway.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well the camera is a heck of a lot better the AOSP. It's worth it, even though it's still RFS, it's snappy and way better the KB1 ever was.
Yeah speaking of rfs I'd definitely be putting a lag fix on. I might look into it, and yes I agree about the camera, in fact honestly the hate against touchwiz is unwarranted. All the touchwiz apps are better, even the launcher is better than vanilla android one(not counting cyanogenmod that uses adw, which is one if the best). Only thing I did notice is without touchwiz the rom is faster, so obviously it adds bulk but the apps are so much better!
Sent from my SGH-I897 using XDA App
I never did get slacker radio and maps working at the same time on kk4. Even with tweaks I mentioned in another thread, slacker started dying after about a day of use. No problems like that with cm7. Thats why I am mostly interested if they actually made any changes from the leak. I doubt it though.
Ginger Bread is here
Im updating currently to official ginger bread
Didn't you notice that Samsung & at&t dropped lots of original Gingerbread features? like the CRT screen-off animation... I can't find it on the new official GB update one.
Is CarrierIQ still present in the official build? Curious. It was in the leak.
Sent from my SGH-I897 using xda premium

Categories

Resources