http://www.informationweek.com/news...html?articleID=225900042&cid=RSSfeed_IWK_News
So I read that and it sounds a lot like an Apple iPhone lover trying to find fault in this phone. Anybody who owns the Captivate, can you possibly check this and update us on this ?
I'd read the comments for that article.
and
http://androidforums.com/samsung-ca...vate-death-grip-issue-similar-iphone-4-a.html
The issue can be replicated on almost any phone in certain conditions. Its really not an issue to be concerned about.
I've noticed that my Captivate is hovering around 2-3 bars constantly. It rarely hits 4 or 5 bars unless I'm right near a tower.
I have the body glove case on the phone as well and this is still occurring.
Mine shows 4 bars on the table, in hand it drops to 3 bars. If I press it into the palm of my hand and put an actual "death grip" on it, it goes to 2 bars. Nothing to be concerned about as far as I'm concerned.
Looks like it is an issue, possibly worse than the iphone 4. There's a new test on youtube about it. I can't post links until my account is verified. Search "samsung captivate." Many phones are tested (captivate is around the 5:20 mark):
It dropped from 3 bars to zero. Yikes! Still though, this was a very tight grip test, which no one uses. I would like to see just a casual grip test. According to at least one video I saw, on the iphone, if you put just one finger on that spot on the left side, it will drop.
pjs2004 said:
Looks like it is an issue, possibly worse than the iphone 4. There's a new test on youtube about it. I can't post links until my account is verified. Search "samsung captivate." Many phones are tested (captivate is around the 5:20 mark):
It dropped from 3 bars to zero. Yikes! Still though, this was a very tight grip test, which no one uses. I would like to see just a casual grip test. According to at least one video I saw, on the iphone, if you put just one finger on that spot on the left side, it will drop.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is it this video? Don't be too concerned with the bars. Bars are just a vague estimate of signal strength (it's probably gamed by the manufacturer). I'm interested in real-world performance. There's another video on here (or maybe androidforums) where a user shows the bar drop during the "death grip" and then runs speedtest.net to show that the downstream performance is almost identical. If the data performance suffers or I drop calls when I hold the phone, it's a problem. If all that happens is the signal meter drops a little, I don't care.
I'd be interested to see if the issue Techno Buffalo had can be replicated on the other Galaxy S devices. IIRC, the Captivate is the only one with a metal back cover.
Yeah, that's the one. Good point about the bars...
Like the iPhone 4 it's not really a big deal. Most people will never replicate the circumstances needed for this to happen in daily usage and the ones that do probably will do it on purpose to make a stupid video......
dsjr2006 said:
Like the iPhone 4 it's not really a big deal. Most people will never replicate the circumstances needed for this to happen in daily usage and the ones that do probably will do it on purpose to make a stupid video......
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Seriously. Who holds phones like that? I love how he was dragging all the widgets around on the Evo with his palm. Hulk no get reception on Hulk's iPhone 4. Hulk smash!
I've tried holding my phone in 20 different ways and cannot make the signal go away. The problem with the iphone is NOT the same as just putting the captivate under something so it doesn't receive the towers as well. Captivate is fine.
All phones lose signal in a phone specific "death grip". The difference between a well designed phone and the iphone 4 is how awkwardly you have to hold the phone to lose reception. On the iphone 4 you lose reception holding the phone in a way that is normal for many people. Well designed phones don't lose reception while being held in any natural position.
I held mine the way you naturally would in the left and right hands and saw maybe a 1 bar drop out of 10 tries.
If you completely cover the back with your hand you can make it drop a couple bars (but no **** why wouldn't it you are covering the entire back lol). And by 'a couple' I mean exactly 2. Thats the most I could get it to drop any way I held it.
Also if you grip the bottom nice and tight, and make sure that your palm is making 100% contact with the back you can get it to drop 1-2 bars.
I made 10 test calls with the captivate and the most I can make it drop is 2 bars, and even when I dropped from 2 to zero bars it wouldn't drop the call.
As long as it doesn't drop the call I don't care how many bars it shows. Also I think that they are calculating signal strength based on data (upload and download) and voice. From what I saw I think the bar drop is from data upload speeds decreasing.
I'd like to hear if anyone can actually drop a call from this. I can't but service is okay where I am lowest I hit was 2 bars without the grip.
i get 4 - 5 bars normaly. When i apply the death grip i drop 1 bar... btw the death grip you give an iphone 4 and a regphone is totally diff. The deathgrip for the iphone 4 is casually holding it in your left hand. For normal hands one is required to strangle the phone. With the extreme death grip i got it to drop one bar. I have huge hands too...
I don't think the problem with the iPhone 4 is the normal attenuation problem you have when you put something like your hand over an antenna to attenuate the signal. With the iPhone 4 you are actually physically touching the phone antenna and shorting it with the other antenna using your skin as a bridge. The "death grip" for the iPhone 4 can be as simple as putting your index finger across the black gap between the antennas on the lower left corner. That's why Apple's $30 rubber band works.
I've been in high-signal areas all day so I haven't really had a chance to see how much of a problem the signal drop is when you have your hand over the bottom slider plate. I lose 1-2 bars, but I'm not getting any statistically significant difference using speedtest.net.
hey sensationers... I am thinkin of buyin a htc sensation over a s2...
the phone is truly amazing... and i loved it..
so tobe sure i was doing some research before buyin it...
came across a deathgrip issue..
and it really sucks in that case..
i wanted to know that is it a very serious problem?
i use my phones in landscape mostly...
besides does that death grip thing affect cellular network
does network signal drops when we cover the phone from top?
i know that wifi drops but same way does signal drops?
please honestly let me know..
No I never experience signal drop when I cover the top so don't worry about call drop in the middle of the conversation, but the WiFi does drop but it doesn't kill it off cause it usually drop until the one bar or so. In my personal opinion, I don't think it matters as it won't affect anything beside WiFi but for some other people they might it is.
i never experienced the death grip since upgraded to ICS and with the custom rom i use..
I just picked up my Galaxy S6 Edge, Rogers and i have noticed a bump on the screen, right hand top corner. This bump is only visible in highly lit area, please check for it as Rogers will replace the phone immidietly or when they have stock
I've noticed that my S6 consistently shows fewer bars in my neighborhood compared to my S5, even often going down to 2G in the center of Amsterdam. This never happened on my S5. GPS positioning is also awful. Standing still my position keeps on moving around while with the S5 it was spot on.
I think the new aluminum border blocks the different antennas. #antennagate
I'm having the exact opposite. My phone hasn't dropped into H since I've had it, my Nexus 5 would all the time.
with the hype of the s7 ramping up, i just wanted to know the thoughts of everyone with the s6 edge. i love my s6 edge, but i never use the extra stuff the edge screen offers about 99% of the time. i like the night clock, but thats about it. its only a matter of time before the s7 is released, and just wanted to see who would get the edge again or if they would switch back to the standard screen.
TookRDerbs said:
with the hype of the s7 ramping up, i just wanted to know the thoughts of everyone with the s6 edge. i love my s6 edge, but i never use the extra stuff the edge screen offers about 99% of the time. i like the night clock, but thats about it. its only a matter of time before the s7 is released, and just wanted to see who would get the edge again or if they would switch back to the standard screen.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I will be getting the S7E once it cones out.
Sent from my SM-G925P using Tapatalk