Database Info

Best camera / video recording app?

What are the best apps available for picture and video recording for 2.2? I don't know why but I've been having a hard time finding good ones. I've been using Vignette which does it's job for taking pictures but doesn't have video recording support.
Hopefully there is an app availble that supports the 8MP pictures and 720P video recording of the X10.
I'd love to be able to use the stock camera from stock firmware but that doesn't seem to work on 2.2

Why not use this ROM? http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=945264
It has a working 8MP cam and 720p video recording(Though the sound capture might be inaudible not sure why, i bet the devs are working on it and colour reproduction for me was kinda bluish effect.)

That is the rom I'm using. I'm just looking for an APP to take pics / shoot vids with. the stock android one kinda sucks

well...for photos with perfect light (outside, daylight) camera360 is perfect. it has very nice effects and the photos look like they are made by a pro. (one bad thing is, that it doesnt recognize the flashlight of the x10i - i dunno why and its not for free)

Eugene1991 said:
Why not use this ROM? http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=945264
It has a working 8MP cam and 720p video recording(Though the sound capture might be inaudible not sure why, i bet the devs are working on it and colour reproduction for me was kinda bluish effect.)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
so far the best rom for me...

other than stock SE camera miui cam is nice

i confirm that

I love Camera360 Ultimate, it takes pictures faster than Vignette and in my experience better quality features.
Vignette has more effects but it takes FOREVER to process a photo, and I have frequent freezing, so I don't like it that much.

[MOD] 720p recording ported from Hancocks ROM

BEFORE YOU READ ANY FURTHER, THIS MOD/PORT (WHATEVER) WILL PROPABLY ONLY WORK ON RED LENSED DEFYS! SORRY BUT IT SEEMS TO BE A HARDWARE THING! AND THERE ALSO MIGHT BE THE SLIGHT POSSIBILITY THAT IT IS LIMITED TO 3.4.2_145-003 VERSION ONLY! (AT LEAST THIS IS THE VERSION HANCOCKS ROM IS BASED ON AND THE SAME I TESTED IT WITH)
to make it short, i (kind of) ported the 720p recording capability of hankocks rom 1.11 to pays rom 3.3 (based on 3.4.2_145-003).
first of all, I AM NO DEVELOPER! so all props go to hankock! what i did was the following:
i took all the libs from hancocks rom which had something to do with camera & encoding (as you can see, not a very devlike procedure) and put them into my system/libs. then i took media_profiles.xml from hancocks rom and put it to my system/etc (of course i changed back permissions afterwards). first i used hancocks patched stock camera app and merged my and his build.prop so that the whole thing would run on my rom. and it worked perfectly. but this solution has 2 drawbacks:
1. hancock used 3gpp container, which is imho inferior to mp4
2. the audio encoding is very bad (amr_nb, 8kbps)
then i found out, that if i used lgcamera instead i would't need to change build.prop anymore and it still worked fine. besides of that, lgcamera is much more customizable settingwise. and by not modifying build.prop, i hope to enhance compatibility of this mod to other froyo versions.
and that is what my package contains:
-all libs with "enc", "cam", "camera" in therr names from hancocks rom (i know, i'm an amateur )
-media_profiles.xml from hancocks rom
-lgcamera 5.25 (free) btw. it works with the latest pro version from the market too
please use tenfars clockwork mod or other custom recovery to flash this update.zip. the built in original recovery won't work (doesn't accept signature). BEFORE YOU START, DON'T FORGET TO MAKE A NADROID BACKUP!!!
here you find an untouched video sample: http://forum.kut-btu.de/video/VIDEO00017.mp4
([email protected],8fps, mp4-container, video: [email protected]~10000kbit/s, audio: [email protected]/s, 44khz)
i know, seems very choppy but this is because i was walking constantly. framerate is quite good. my defy runs at 1,2ghz but i tested 720p rec @ 800mhz too and it worked the same. it might be necessary to apply sdcard read_ahead_kb patch (mine runs at 2560 kb instead of 128) to avoid slow framerate effect which could be observed on hancocks rom.
sadly, recording with .h264 codec is still not possible (and i doubt it ever will). hence the resulting video is no match for the 720p recordings of e.g. the samsung wave but imho it is still a lot better than stock and looks almost great
now i leave it to the real devs to optimize this, whatever it is.
DISCLAIMER:
I WILL NOT BE HELD RESPONSIBLE FOR ANY DAMAGES RESULTING FROM THIS MODIFICATION!
/edit:
mod works fine on the following froyo versions:
-3.4.2-117
-3.4.2-145 (as the mod comes from this version)
-3.4.2-155
mod doesn't work on:
-3.4.3-11
strange behavior detected:
after recording in 720p dmesg shows:
Timed out waiting for DSP suspend 3
pm_op()latform_pm_suspend+0x0/0x54 returns -1
PMevice C6410 failed to suspend:error -1
PM:Some devices failed to suspend
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
don't know, which impact this has on battery drain. after fresh reboot and w/o recording in 720p this problem doesn't show up.

Thnaks for this - i'll have a play with it later today

It works with Barebones 1.4... when im recording it seems little bit choppy, but playing it in MoboPlayer is good (smooth, maybe not 30 fps but its good!).
Thank you!

Antszej said:
It works with Barebones 1.4... when im recording it seems little bit choppy, but playing it in MoboPlayer is good (smooth, maybe not 30 fps but its good!).
Thank you!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
great! since Barebones 1.4 is based on CEE 3.4.2-155-002 Deblur, we can add it to the compatibility list.
yes, the recording view seems choppy on my system too, but the resulting video is quite smooth (~23-24fps).

http://www.multiupload.com/APEW3UPMI0
Here is the sample.

juuu
I want this for green lens...

insestito said:
juuu
I want this for green lens...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
sorry. i believe that 720p recording isn't impossible for green lense models. but i do believe that this patch based on hancocks mod will do the trick only for red lens defys. because it isn't just the color of the lens but a totally different sensor. perhaps someone figures out a mod for green lenses too.

But official Froyo is near, just wait, it should have 720p recording for EVERYONE.

I compare it to xd1 ROM files, and find the different files are,
720p_mp4venc_sn.dll64P
libOMX.TI.720P.Encoder.so
libOMX.TI.JPEG.Encoder.so
libOMX.TI.mp4.splt.Encoder.so
libOMX.TI.Video.encoder.so
Hope it can reduce the update size.

Antszej said:
But official Froyo is near, just wait, it should have 720p recording for EVERYONE.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
what leads you to this assumption?

sunoldman said:
I compare it to xd1 ROM files, and find the different files are,
720p_mp4venc_sn.dll64P
libOMX.TI.720P.Encoder.so
libOMX.TI.JPEG.Encoder.so
libOMX.TI.mp4.splt.Encoder.so
libOMX.TI.Video.encoder.so
Hope it can reduce the update size.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
feel free to modify the package everyone... my work is done

Worked like a charm for me, thanks!

ToTTenTranz said:
Worked like a charm for me, thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
u r welcome

Yep it works here too but i cant see much difference between WVGA and this 720p..its almost the same. Is there any app on market that has continuous autofocus while recording video(like barcode scanner) ?

I'll create this patch for the green lens?

insestito said:
I'll create this patch for the green lens?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
is this a statement or a question?

derbestimmer said:
is this a statement or a question?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Question for you or any Dev, sorry...
Google translator is very bad...

insestito said:
Question for you or any Dev, sorry...
Google translator is very bad...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i don't think i will be any helpfull, cause i'm no dev. i just took the work of a dev and ported it to another rom. sorry. perhaps someone else is able to do it.

My problem with Hancocks ROM is that lgcamera records very light sound, no matter what encoding I chose (AMR_NB, AMR_WB or AAC). I am not even sure the software records sound on defy with encoding as AMR_WB and AAC.
Video works ok with MPEG4 encoding though with twp slight issues. One is video file bitrate is not the same as configured in lgcamera settings. The other one is framerate is always below 25 - not sure if SD card speed is the bottleneck.

shural said:
My problem with Hancocks ROM is that lgcamera records very light sound, no matter what encoding I chose (AMR_NB, AMR_WB or AAC). I am not even sure the software records sound on defy with encoding as AMR_WB and AAC.
Video works ok with MPEG4 encoding though with twp slight issues. One is video file bitrate is not the same as configured in lgcamera settings. The other one is framerate is always below 25 - not sure if SD card speed is the bottleneck.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
with light sound, do you mean quiet or bad quality? strange when i set lgcamera from amr_nb to aac, it does use this codec at least the resulting video shows this in codecinfo. and i think the sound quality is slightly better too compared to amr. concerning the other two issues, i have the same experience. the framerate never goes over 23,9fps and when i force it to 25 or even 30, lgcamera won't start recording. youre right the bitrates of the resulting video are mostly lower then the bitrates chosen in lgcamera. 13 prduces ~10, 10 produces ~8 and 8 produces ~6 mbps. but imho there is a difference visible between 13 and 8mbps respectively 10 and 6 in the resulting video. at least on the computer you can see the difference.
Sent from my MB525 using Tapatalk

[Q] How can I fix the HD video recording on my XT720? I'm only getting 21FPS

I stumbled across this video created by khalpowers on the XT720:
http://vodpod.com/watch/5015769-hd-recording-30-fps-xt720
This tells me that it's possible to get 30FPS out of this phone. Mine is only recording at 21fps according to Windows.
Will using one of khalpowers' ROMs fix my camcorder app?
I've tried the lgcamera app and I still get only 21FPS.
If any of you have any insight into this I would really appreciate it.

So I installed khalpowers' camera update and things seem smoother now, but I don't get 30fps. In Fraps I'm getting between 21fps and 24fps. It's better than it was before, but still not quite as smooth as I would like. The shutter lag in the camera is also better after the update.
Is this phone even capable of 30fps at 720p? The specs seem to say it can only do 24fps.

It can only do 24 FPS.

try khals video settings in lgcamerapro app. it allows for recording in 30fps.

SickBeast said:
I stumbled across this video created by khalpowers on the XT720:
http://vodpod.com/watch/5015769-hd-recording-30-fps-xt720
This tells me that it's possible to get 30FPS out of this phone. Mine is only recording at 21fps according to Windows.
Will using one of khalpowers' ROMs fix my camcorder app?
I've tried the lgcamera app and I still get only 21FPS.
If any of you have any insight into this I would really appreciate it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It turns out that the FPS thing is really difficult to evaluate. This is because the phone records variable bit rate. The actual rate recorded seems to depend on how much light is hits the camera sensor (i.e. brighter scenes get higher framerates and darker scenes get lower framerates which makes sense to me).
To make things even more confusing the file contains a number as a "guesstimate" of the frame rate. This guesstimate is what most programs show. Unfortunately, the guesstimate seems to be incorrect most of the time. IIRC the only thing we found that seemed to show us the actual framerate was Windows Media Player in Windows 7.
There's a lot more about this in Dexter's stock221v13 development thread. Page 126 of that thread seems to be in the middle of it http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=939644&page=126 I think it started here: http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?p=11630078#post11630078 but it's really spread out.

Can someone post a link to kahl's camera update and khal's LGCamera settings. And should I apply the update if I'm running StealEpicBlue, or the ROM already has the update?
Thanks.

Even with lgcamera and khal's settings, the files are still not 30fps. Even watching his sample videos, they don't look any smoother than what I'm getting with his "fix" installed on the default camcorder app.
Anyhow, I can live with 24fps. I just wanted to know if 30fps was possible, and it seems as though it's not.
Thanks everyone for your input.
Perhaps khal can chime in and confirm that his files are indeed 30fps. IMO Fraps is a good way to verify it.

Higher rate on xt just 24fps.....that video from eclair..now can produce better than that with airplane mode ..

So............... does we have Camupdate on StealEpicBlue or not?
Thanks.

yes..complete patches included with cam update...

khalpowers said:
yes..complete patches included with cam update...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's why we all ♥ U!

On stock 2.1.1, I did that :http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1088297
but, I mean it's already done in khalpowers ROM

Can someone post the best settings for LG Camera, please?
Thanks in advance.

Force 720p recording on leaked Gingerbread ROM

Hi all,
When using the leaked Gingerbread ROM, the camera and video app revert to the default Android one and we lose the LG camera / video app.
I don't really mind this except for the fact that having the video on 'High' uses the psuedo 1080 and is not nearly as smooth as the 720p recording on the Froyo ROM.. I saw the same issue with "1080p" on the Froyo ROM.
What I'd like to do is force it so that "High" is 720p.
Is there a hack that will let me set this permanently, or an app that will let me select this on the fly?
I'd much rather have smooth video at 720p than psuedo 1080p that's a little jittery.
Thanks so much for any information.

I found my own solution.
Download LgCameraPro from the market.
It's a camera and video camera replacement that has TONS of features and even allows you to set your own custom recording resolution, bitrate, framerate, etc..
GREAT app so far (although I've only been playing with it about 20 minutes).

I to have that app you speak of and I like the video camera but I dont like any of the Camera apps in the market they all shoot crappy pics the closest one to even the stock android app is called camera advance so right now I use the stock app for camera and LGcamerapro for the video mostly sometimes I just use the stock for video but I heard that it only shoots in 720p and not 1080p. I updated with the LG update as soon as it came out I mean hours after the release Someone said that the LG update lost 1080p video capabilities but the OTA got them back. So Again I am confused does my stock app shoot 1080p or 720p.

Identify CM7 HD Recording issue and need help to modify libcameraservice.so

This post is better to be in xt720 Dev board. But it is a pity that I don't have the privilege to post in that board now. So anybody who kindly help forward to the dev board would be great appreicated.
For quite a long time, we sufferred to HD record issue in CM7. And I spent some days inveistigaing this issue and fortunatelly got some interesting findings to share.
1. 720p HD recording fail becasue of wrong width and height parameter pass to function createOverlay in libsurfaceflinger.so.
02-13 17:38:12.030: D/TIOverlay(1876): overlay_createOverlay:IN w=768 h=432 format=99
02-13 17:38:12.030: I/Overlay(1876): v4l2_overlay_init:: w=480 h=854
02-13 17:38:12.030: I/Overlay(1876): v4l2_overlay_init:: w=768 h=432
02-13 17:38:12.030: I/Overlay(1876): v4l2_overlay_init:: w=768 h=432
Here we see, the paramter passed to createOverly is (768,432). And in comparison with 2.2 stocked Rom, the right parameter should be (1280,720) for HD recording.
2. The wrong width/height parameter is set in libcameraservice.so. Perhaps CM7 forbids HD recording...
02-13 17:38:12.030: D/CameraService(1540): Changing overlay dimensions to 768X432 for 720p recording.
And double check by open libcameraservice.so, we found the matched words in the above at the address of 0x000ae00h. The very possible guess is CM7's libcameraservice.so check width/height parameter, whenever it detect the parameters are for HD record, it reset the paramter to (768,432)!!
Proposed solution:
If someone could kindly help modify the code to comment the piece of code and build a new libcameraservice.so, we may have chance to bring HD recording back.

I forwarded into developpement thread but I don't know if it is the only problem because librairies from 2.1 to 2.2 and 2.3.

Great thanks!
libcameraservice.so is the current blocking issue I have identified. Certainly, there are possible some issues come out after we solved this one.
BTW, I've enabled 720p hardware video decoding in CM7. The phone could now play 720p video smoothly. This should be a good basie to fix HD recording issue.

Interesting. I don't have much to say about this at the moment, but for now I can point you into the source (Line 767):
https://github.com/CyanogenModXT720...ces/camera/libcameraservice/CameraService.cpp
These commits seem relevant (from the "blame" view):
https://github.com/CyanogenModXT720...mmit/a930c3c872cf6eaa57bfdddc923132cf0d48564b
https://github.com/CyanogenModXT720...mmit/cf997d0147228ece729ceb95745d20905664426d
Edit: So, it looks like to set the overlay size to whatever we want, we just change line 74 of CameraService.cpp to put the desired resolution. The other part of the puzzle is to adjust media_profiles.xml to add the HD profile. I had done that in the past by copying settings from decompiled MotoCamera, but the screen would go black and get weird or cause a reboot when the camcorder was switched to HD. I think your finding about the overlay resolution might explain why.
FYI: *Temporarily*, I don't have access to an XT720 (due to a laundry incident that took out both my second XT720 and my wife's Nexus S--so she's using my primary XT720 and I'm luddite mode until we sort out what to do about her phone--surprisingly they both may have survived--they power on, the XT720 boots all the way but no touch (when the screen is on you can see some streaking under the screen so I think possibly some residual moisture is interfering with capacitance so I'm going to let it dry some more--I tore a different XT720 into tiny pieces recently and there's a whole stack of paper-like pieces under the screen and I think they're still somewhat wet) and the NS turns on but get's stuck at the Google logo even when trying to enter recovery so I think it needs to be reloaded, I've only made it as far as fastboot mode on that one due to only having a power-only usb cable handy at the time).

what you mean by 720p playback?
i have tested with youtube videos (searched for 1080p hd
what other test can be made?
btw, hope you will be able soon to post in the devel section

Hi peshovec, I also read your reply in dev board.
As you got the same finding and have already fixed the code, could you please share the new built libcameraservice.so? I don't have CM7 source code at hand, and it will take me several days to sync. Last month, I spent near two weeks to sync CM9 code ...
And one important thing, we might need to keep libcameraswervice.so compatible with old 2.2 driver libcamera.so. libcameraservice.so from other 2.3 Rom contains a new function "_HAL_Camerainfo" ( sorry, did not remember clearly) that does not implemented in old libcamera.so. The trick I saw in the code is to "#define BOARD_USE_FROYO_LIBCAMERA".
I am quite interested to follow-up on this HD record issue with all of you help!

And for 720p playback, I mean to hardware decode some 720p video.
Xt720's CPU is able to support h264 baseline profile, but could not support H264 high profile. So I am afraid for 1080p video and H264 high profile 720p on youtube, our phone still could not play with hardware decode.
The trick to fix 720p hardware decode is to use old xt720 2.1's codec: lib\hw\*, and libOMX.TI.*. The existed libOMX.TI.720P.Decode.so in CM7 support other phones (e.g. Defy) well, but not support xt720.
I tested my phone after the fix of 720p HW decode with one 720p video, and found my phone could play the video smoothly with either Moboplayer or Moto Videoplayer. And before the fix, the playback could only use SW decode, and even overclock to 1GHz, the pictures was still lag behind of voice.

Hi Mioze7Ae, I also did investigations on media_profiles.xml and build.prop.
Acutually, stocked 2.2 xt720 Rom is not necessarily to rely on those settings in either media_profiles.xml or build.prop. As you observed, all resolution parameter was set in Camera.apk. I tested xt720 2.2 Rom without media_profiles.xml and none of related settings in build.prop, 720p HD video still work fine. And for xt711 phone, it even don't have media_profiles.xml in the official Rom.
Ah, 5 post now. Still need 5 other post ...

hhcat said:
Hi peshovec, I also read your reply in dev board.
As you got the same finding and have already fixed the code, could you please share the new built libcameraservice.so? I don't have CM7 source code at hand, and it will take me several days to sync. Last month, I spent near two weeks to sync CM9 code ...
And one important thing, we might need to keep libcameraswervice.so compatible with old 2.2 driver libcamera.so. libcameraservice.so from other 2.3 Rom contains a new function "_HAL_Camerainfo" ( sorry, did not remember clearly) that does not implemented in old libcamera.so. The trick I saw in the code is to "#define BOARD_USE_FROYO_LIBCAMERA".
I am quite interested to follow-up on this HD record issue with all of you help!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
here is it (attachment)
also here is the mediaprofile.xml (which i use), with high and wide working
https://github.com/CyanogenModXT720...la_sholest/blob/pesh-modif/media_profiles.xml
can you try to search in youtube for 1080p hd videos and try to play some of them? i am curious if they will play on your setup (`couse in my test build i am able to play them...)

Thanks for the attachment! I will have try and give update later.
I tried to play some H264 high profile video: voice only and no pictures.
xt720's CPU fail to HW decode thoese video.
The workaround solution is to download the video, then we could choose SW decode in mediaplayer ( I used moboplayer). But the video play is very terrible, the picture play frame by frame, even though I have overclock to 1GHz.

Haha, the quick update is HD 720p recording preview work fine! Verly clearly and smoothly view from preview window!!
On the way home now, will do some more tests later.
Mark: 9 post now

Yeah, 720p HD recording is perfectly fixed!
Now we could enjoy HD recording in CM7!
BTW, I didn't tested your media_profile.xml. Now I used the one in 2.2 stocked ROM.
10 post now, heihei...
I will packed my Rom and share in Dev board tomorrow.

Great job, it's awesome and sweet.
I‘m looking forward to it!

omg, lol, so can someone confirm that hd video really work on any cm7 ? =)
well, afaik good that you have fixed preview.
Problem now in hd encoder...
Well.. we don't have it.

my fast testing doesn't seems good...
preview ok, but can't focus well (after try-ing to focus, the focus is set to the minimum distance), recording seems to start, preview display freeze. some file is generated trough.....
but that should be just my setup (is motoroi with the moto froyo able to record 1280x720p ? , if yes we can find way*)
p.s. *remark. in my opinion 1280x720 recording is just marketing, also it is not job for the phone to record at this resolution, working wide 848x480 is more than enough...

My phone is able to HD recorde in 2.1 and and 2.2 Rom, but lose this ablity when upgrade to CM7 2.3 Rom.
Not sure whether our phone have some HW difference.

I am uploading my Rom to DEV board.
Have a try.